HomeMy WebLinkAbout0230.095•
I •
FROM:
' ..
".,-.
. ' '",
City of Palo Alto
City Manager's Report
HONORABLE CITY COUNCIL
CITY MANAGER DEP ARTMEl'n: Planning and
Community EllviroDmellt
AGENDA DATE: M.y 1, 1995 CMR:l3O:"
SUBJECT: Ham.. R.rallo.... Commission and ~aiJIg Commission
Recommeadatic>lIs t.. Adopt ... F.deraUy-Req.ired
CollSOlidafecl PI .. CODwnmg tbe City of Palo Alto'. Housing
... d C.ommollity o.velopm."f N..... and Objectives for the
Period from luly I, 1995 to laDe 311, 2000
BEOUEST
The purpose oflhe May I. 1995 public ~g is for the City Coo.ncillo re\iew and
act "" the Coosoli<la!ed Plan for the period July .. ) 99S 10 June 30. 2000. Preparation
and adoption of the Consolidated Plan is • requirement of the [)q1artment of Housing
and lkban DeveloptneDI (MUD). in order for the City (and nonprofit organizations
within the City) I<> apply for BUD funding. The CoosoIidated Plan replaces the
pn:vioosIy required Comprehensive Housing AfIOrdability Strategy (CHAS); includes
the addition of priority "",,-housing commllIlity developmem needs; and serves as the
app!ication for Com'Dunity Development Block Gra!Il (CDBG) f\mds. It inclucks a
des.-ripOOn of PRIo Alto's offordab!e hoosing ..,d rommunity development needs, •
strategy 10 address those need;, ane! a priority ooe-year action plar>_
RECOMMENDATIONS
Staff reques<s 1hat the City Council authorize and direct the City Mar.ager, or her
designee, 10 execute and submit 10 BUD the Consolidated Plan fur the period My I,
1m 10 June 30, 2000.
POUCY JMPUCATIONS
The Conso!idaIed Plan for t. ... period 1995 -2000 does oot rcprescnI any changes 10
existing City pOOcies. The Plan replaces the previously required Comprehensive
Housing AfJOrdability Strategy (CHAS) adepted by Council 011 November IS, 1993. and
the non-hoosing rommunity development plan adopted by Council 00 December 13,
',,' ..,
c ". ;-i
."" .• .' .•.. ,"s-,-"\',_" ~
"-;" ,;::,..~,:-< . ~
.-'.
Pap''''J
•
. .
4
.--'
,. I
. ~
.. -~' -> ..
-~.-
199). The goals and policies de'.aJled in !be Consolidated Plan are in roofonnan« with
d!ooe in tM City's Comprehensiv~ PIm, particularly the Housing El=enl
EXECUTIVE stJMMABY
The overall goal of!be federal programs covered by !be CoosoIidated Plan is 10 develop
viable urban communities by providing tb:ent housing. a suitable living Ctlvironlmnl,
and expaBJing ecooomic <Jfl>OrtUfti1les, principally for persoos of low and very low
income. TIle Plan is a required clement in lb. appIkation for any of lOur formula
programs of!he Department ofHoosing and Ltrnan OCvelop!Dent (HUD). wbiclJ inclU<le:
HOME Investment Partncrs.'lip Program, Housing Opportu!lities for Peq:le witb AIDS
(HOPWA) Program, !be Emergency Sbelter Otant (ESG) Program, and tbe Commucity
Dcve~ Block Grant (CDBO) Program. Of Ibe four programs, !be City of Polo
Alto receives only CDBG funding as an eoti!lemenl direQly from HVD.
The required public review perkld for the Draft CoosoIidated Pi ... began OIl March 1,
I99S ... -,d ended OIl Marcb 31, 1995. The document ,.. .. reviewed and <f!SCIJ>SCd ot !be
Planning Commission meeting of March 8, 1995. The Planning Comnllssion
unanimous.'Y re<:<>mmended 1ba! !be Council approve !be C()(lS()lidated PlIIIL TIle
Human Relations C<Jmmissioo also dis.;ussed !be CoosoIidated Plan at !beir meetings
()II March 9, 1995 .. ,d April 13, 1995 and recommended approval of!be Plan. PuNic
commenls, • bomeiess strategy, and 11>e ooc-y~ llSC of CDBG fun<Is have been
iIlcoIponted into lb. final document, which must be submitted 10 HUD by May 15,
1995.
figALIMPACT
AdcpIioo of !be Coosoli<Iated Plan and !be application for !eden! CDSO funds will
provide $972,000 to !be City in fiscal year 1 '195-96 fur programs and projects which
benefit lower income persons.
F..NVIRONME.Vl AL ASSESSMENT
Adoption oftbe CoosoIldatcd Plan is exempt from !be CalilOmia EnviroomentaI Quality
Act (CEQA) under Sectioo 15262 as a planning study. It is oJ", exempt from
eoviromnen!al review as an adnllnistrative activity under federal envlrorunental review
reguWioos for !be CDSO program at 24 erx pari 58.34 (3).
ATTACHMENTS
Planning Commissioo su.ff Report for March @, 1995 Muting
Planning Commission Minutes of Marcb 8, 1995
CoosoIidated PI""
" . . . .
•
' .. -.
I I •
I
PREPARED 8Y: SuuODe Ricbards. CDOO CoordinalO<
DEPARTMENT HEAD REVIEW: ~~f.~ukka
KENNETH R. SCHREIBER :;>
Director of PIamling and
Community EnVl.''CflI!lelll
CITY MANAGER APPROVAL: ~~
C ~ ger
cc: Citizens Advisory Commillee
Planning Commlssjoo
Hwnan Re!alicns Commjssion
Palo Alto Housing Corporation
League of Women Voten
InDcr¥alive Housing. Inc.
Mid-Peninsula Housing Coalition
I'qe] oU
PLA..~NING COMMISSION
MEMORANDUM
TO:
FROM: DEP AJtTMENT: I'I2nning
AGENDA DAtE: M.arI:II 8, 1995
SUBJECT: ReoIew ADd .--oa dle CoI!!GIid&1ed I'Iaa
RECOMMENPATlON
SIaff lewuuaends that the I'Iam!ing Commimon COlJ1mCDt on the Ccnsolidated P1.m and
forwanI those <OllUDellI5 10 CooneR.
The ConroIidoted Plan is • ,.,.., requi:emenl1IIis year from the Viii"'" Su ... Dcpartmenl of
HousiDg and U!1>an DevelopDrtt (lruD). II tqlla<a the CHAS (C<!mpIebeu£>"'e HoosiIlg
A&nIability SttotesY) and the DOII-bousiDg Community DrNeJopmcD! Plan propamI by the
C-IIy ill Ibo post IS the pWIniq ~ for the receipt 0( federal bousing and
romDIImity 4evdopmoDt funds. ~ Planning CcmmissioD Ilas m-iewcd and cm>nWJIed on
the CHAS or iIs prode<;essor. the HousiIlg Assistw;e Plan (HAP), sil>ao 1974. ~ kxt and
<oo!eIIt 0( the CoasoIidabod P1.m is essentiao, the same as that COllIlIiroed in the CHAS
IlklpIecI in 1m.
POUCY IMPUCATlONS
~ Coasor>1ated Plan is • five·year SInIe8JI and • """'year oction plan whick implements
c<isting City policies COOllIiDod in the adopIed CompcMmrhlr PIgn. in particuiar the 1:I$2Jgl!Jg
1i1Lmm. and in the lXltI-lloasing Community Devctopmem Plan. The Cooso'.idau.d Plan does
DOt CO!lIain lIlY _ policies or programs DOt p:eviousIy audIorized by the Council,
, . . .-:;~-
pJSCUSSION
The CoatoIidaIOd Plan includes infonnatiou about affordable !loosing .,...;s, homeless ceeds,
II<>asinc markd CO!lditioo< r.ncIln invenlor)' of existilJi facilities. bous'..ng ml "'I"Vices. The
Plan ~ IIle City's priority Iloosing ml tooummi!y de.el<lpment tlO<ds r.ncI <1<_ •
five year strategy for addres<ing lOOse priority tlO<ds. The priorities ml iIrategies lIe based
011 an wessmtDI of public ml private financial n:soorces (federal, State mllocal}, which
=l<lrearos6ntlly be expect.cd '" be lvaiIllbIe. The fmal PIaD ... iIl also contain • cDC-year
ICtion plan fer 1995-96, including • propooed budge! fo< !lie City's CDllG _III graD!
of 5822,000.
PIlblk Pmi£ip!!!jnp
CiIlzelI participotion is • :equiRd and encounge/J elemeDl in 1I!e Como/idated Planning
. Process. A public meeting ..... c:oodIIct<:d by staff on October 21, i 994 to gIve citiz.ens an
oppJrtUnity Ie e>pmS !lleir ,.;"ws ~ !be City's needs ml tho selection of priorities.
The meeting ,. .. anended by • broad opa:tnmJ of !he public representing differeDl seiJD<IllS
of Ibo Iow-inc=e popuIatioo ml persons willi specW needs ml cr ... bilities. Consultations
have also been beld ,,<iIh ~es oC odl/er elXltIemeDl juris<flCtioos in Santa Clara
County, i!lcluding !be CiCes of SaD Sosc, Gilroy, Sunnynle, Sant.t Clara, Moulllain YIe,.,
ml IIle Urban County. Ie cfl5CU5S oceds ml _regies on • Coun!ywide basis. The Coosoli
_ PIaD m1lSt be avWi>le f<x public rev;.,. and cOllllllCnt f<x • ~ period. The
<:OClDlODI period begin OD MArt:lll, 1m aDd concludes "" M3!clI 31, 1m.
bLIERNAIIYES
RevisioosaDd commeDlS suuested by IIle Commission v;U be forwarded, togetber with
wuuneuI> from Ibo public, to the City Cowx~ f<x Iboir consideration.
FISCAL IMPACT
A BUD oW"'-Coosolidated Plan is • pret<qUisitc for the City (and ncmprofits operuing
witbiD !be City) 10 apply fer aDd =ive federal housing ="istanc< funds ml commllDily
developmelll funds under Ibe CDOO r.ncI HOME program r.ncI many odl/er fedeaI housing
programs.
El-'"VIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENI
AdopIion of !he Consolidated Plan is Cllemp! from 1lJe C.:ifurnia Euviromnental Quaflty Act
(CEQA) under Section 15262 ... planoiDg .wdy _ It is also ".lllpt from elWiromnontaJ
JeVicw .. , ID !ldtnlni.shtive activity under kdenl eoviroomeolaJ !eView regulations for !be
CPBG program at 24 CfR pa.'1 58.54 (3).
3-8-95
Page 2
STEPS R?I 'Q\VING APfROV AL
The CoosoIi4aIe<! Plan will be ,.,ie-...d by Ibc Human Relations Commission ml Ma.-ch 9.
1m. 1be Cily Coua:il will ,..;.,. aDd oct 0II1bc Plan aDd Ibc 1995-96 CDOO fundins
aIIoc:olioDs DO May 1. 1m. The Plan aDd CDOO bo<!r-t mUSl be !UbminI:d '" HUD by
Mal' IS. 1m.
AlTMl!MfNI$IEXH!BI: ComnT.,,,,,,,, P!.m For Ibc Period JulJ I. 1m 10 JUDO 30. lOOO
cotjRMX COPIES:
Cky Coua:il
MarieDe I'reDderpst. Palo Alto HooslI!g Corporation. 540 Cowper Sb<et. Sllitt G.
Palo Alto CA 94301
UrboD MmisIly. P.O. Box 213. Palo Alto CA 94302
L<Ske C<>1ema.n. Jnnovatjve Ho<mD&:. 457 Kingsley. Pal" Aho CA 94301
Leapc of Womeso Votors. 2719 Blyant. Palo Alto CA 94306
-11..1,..,.,..,. MidPenlnsuIa Citizens for Fair Housing, 457 1Gng~,
Palo Aho CA 94301
s.,.." llussen, MidPeninsuIa Housins Coalitioo, 658 Bair Island Road, Suitt 300,
R.e<lwood Cily CA 94063
Aff<lrdablc Housing ~od:. 25 E. HecIdins, San Jose CA 11:> 112
Prepoted by; Suzanne Ricbards. CDBG Coordinator
Calbcriue Siegel. Housing CoonIinaIor
Project P\amJer: Suzanne RicIwds. CDOO Coordinator
DivisioolDeparlme lkad Appro,-aJ: \-{b '-2qf 0~c J ~
NAN . MADDOX LYfLf.
Chief PIanniI>g Official
l-8-9S
Page 3
'W
, . . : -, -~.
~; ..
-" ,
EXCERPT o-f FlannlIl( Co.l!!kissicn minutes c.r 3/!195.
The ,1a.rul'D9 coa!tfu'Ofl !let h • regu"!'" HeUng on Vedntsdl1, Mire'h ,.
U9S It 7,]S p ••• fl t~e Council Cbambers .nt~ Chl ..... n OJ.thn pr .. ldlng.
ll:wa1:
6bDA1:
StIff mUnt:
ROtl CAlL
Ca.mlssfoner, ~Chil, Carrasco. Clssel. Cllzf2r a Ojatfan~
Sc~lnl Ind Sc~mldt
lion.
NlOCl lytle. Chief 'Iannlng Offlcl.l
Debra Cluble. ~~'Ist.nt Ctt, Attorne,
SUzlnne Ilc~.r6s. PToJect Planner
Cather!ne SIegel, ~o"sl.g Coord!nltor
OAAI. C!MtJIIl CATIONS
'~Jlnoa. 01Ikf,., Tho first ftee en our Igon4a Is Oral (..-unleatl ....
At tlf. tl .. , any..aber Gf the public .'1 Spelt to Iny Itee that Is not
on the agenda. Is ther. anyone who wish., t. speak thIs eyenlng? SeeIng
no Sptalttr.5. we vB1 lIO~t en t. the next agendl Uelll.
llarx Er[h()fl. 425 High strut. 1120. Palo Alt,: I have lfyed IrolJnrJ here
sInce J WI, • llttl. gIrl I. 1959, and I .. 4~ "o~, so 1 ~aye se.n I lot
Gf chngu. Orlgl.aliJ. to ~c_ acquainted .nt" the East '"10 Alt.
~ht.rfcil Ind AgriClltunl SOCiety, OD whic~ In u~lcl. was done last
, •• r f. the 'al. Alto W.olly. the polnt Wi •• ade thit the stIle .f lfvlng,
Whit' brings to Ea.t 'al. Alt. ~ho closo lf,fng a.6 cult"ral .n~
Isd"strl.1 wort folr11 ,10'. together, Whlth undercwts soma of the
trlnsport.tloo problea. rIght there. A lot of .ultlc.lturll focus woald
be • good aDd.l for the rest of the ,tate. The ViI the st.te go •• Is
eften I.fluenced ~1 Whit bJppen, on the p •• losoli. Indeed. tho rest of tho
eountry. J)fs •• lltIIDlng of • ,ertala aaount .f s"i-asTle.'tural and
Ir.clustrlal and residenlfll close togeth,r II,. is an In fdea I think that
shoul' be IOGte4 It for Whatever ,la"nf.~ fs done 10 the f.ture. It
$houl' be IOGled It f. genorll IS an 1401. It Is also .. re Wholesome IS
It exposes child ... Who are close t. the slt •• tlon t. responsible
fnteraetlon vith 'OIethlng t~.t Is .ot Just I toy to be thrown a~l.
Toofght, 1 .... ld '\199 .. t that one 01'9 to be r .... OIberod thl, gl,en tho
Ixfst!ng •• t"re ,f t~o nefghhor~ood th.t yo. ire looking It, 1.s •• f
prcpert, .1100 •• bo"ld not bo t~.t serlou, I probl .. camp. rod t. any
.atters t~.t the neIghbors .ould blve to werry .bout I. ono of the DOre
.xpensl.e .~tfons of town, ~c." .. it Is alr.adl partly Industrial •
•• !-II-My·S.,l-Ylrd for the economIc Imp.ct CD prGperty yalues shcold not
be I .ljar Frob 1... Thank you.
ruStIC HEARINGS
A6EIIDA ITElI I IHE ,OHSQUDAUP PVIi: R, vi e. a.d ,,,,,,,,,,n t on the
federa11, requIred Consolidated flan whick de.cribes the
Cit, of 'al. Alto's housi.g and community deyelopment
needs and Dbjectlve, for tho period fr~' Jul, I. 1995
t~rough June 30, 2000.
~3/0S!95
+
",
.'~ .
-.
'hltraa" Ohk1u: Ve IIISLlJlb tUrli h .. one~)'ear ,lan each ,ear, but e-wer,y
ffve )eaTI. we tura fl .. five-year plin~ Th!s ~$ tnown to us prE~iousl1
IS CHAS~ Tbe commission' •• etroa OD thfs tonfg~t will be to male anI
caa.ents DT suggesticns •• fter wbf~h we will ~ke I motfon tD piSS the~
along tt the city council.
I Wlnt t. polot out that Suzann. Ifchard. Is here toolgbt. Suzanne Is the
pers"" "". b.lped draft this report for us. Goes stoff ~ ... a ..... c ..... nto?
Ms. R!"lrdS! Th.nk ,... Tou are corre<t that this Is the first time you
ha.1 s~ t\is doc ... nt cliled the Consolidated Pl... It was a part of
tb. origl~l HUe rtfaventlon changing the w'l tb.y did business to try Ir.cl
I.corpor,t. bot. housing Ind ... -bouslog como.oltl de.elop ... t needs I.t.
ene doc .... t th,t would looi It I three· ta flve·y.ar ,l.n and would look
It c_nlt, .eeds .nd re.ources and put them together II one place. So
t.ls Is the prevlou, (HAS, as ~ll a, the clt,'s non-hou.lng eomnwnlt1
dev.l~.t pl... Row it Is Ils. the one·y.ar applleitfon for cOGmuolt1
doyelopoeat .locl srlnt progr .. fu,~'. Tho.e Ire the c.l, HUO fund, that
t~9 tltJ of ,,1. Alt. recel.es ••• n entltleQe.t communit,. So t~l. 'S a
dr.ft doc .... t t~.t Is out for public review and t~nt for a 30·d.,
period. It will be fln.lized. and the fln,l .er.lo. will al'o go the
on •• y.or opti •• ,1.n, which viII be the pl,n for ,peodl,; 1995·96
communlt, de,elopoe.t block grant funds.
1}ls ,lan vas put together prior to the changes. It .~s developed prior
t~ the NoY~r. J994 electtDG. Since then~ we live bee~ faventinQ MUD
'2, a~d there is another ~ole set of changes that very ~el1 mlgbt occur
tD ill of t~ese progra-s thll are mentioned fm thls document. ! can sa)
that ve Ire going to be looting .1 ~.jDr ,rogr •• e~ang., withl •• 11 of the
HUO progr .... Ind .. doubtedl] II .Ignlflcant hudget roduclio" II fundiDg.
Even t~, .;ssf~n If the fedar.l government IS it relates tc bousin9 's
being questlo,ed .t this pOiot. So the fut.,e i, deff>itell up '" t~e Ilr
for .11 af the,. progr ... ,. Eve. though I. thl, document, we say that the
1995·96 e.tltleae.t Is 5822.000 fl ccomonity deyelayment block grant
funds, there fs rig~t at t~ls OODOnt I reelo'on bill befo.e the Eou •• to
reduce that bl 8 percent. So we are hliny U I, Q"" dOl .t • t I.... Tour
COGRents are welc ... tonight. V. also pia. on having. public h •• rlng
t-.rrow 119M .t the ~ ..... n Reht!ons Conmlssion. Think yo ••
£hair!jn Qiakfa~: Are there I~Y qu!stfon fro~ commissioners?
Cpmmi$$igner (arTj$(e: "yen t~at HUe', re~ulitiQ"s are changfng, and t~e
Ittltude of the gOYonoooot. thE W., it .eemed t. &e, II listening to what
Cfsner •• fs t,lklog about and rEvanplng HUD and changing ,11 the olne
prD9r~ iata I .are st~aalfned process, ett~. woGldn't this ~ole
document change? Do we o •• ~ t. revfe¥ It now, and will we not hl.e t.
review It ooce 'gail?
pis, Ucblrds: Th,t Is a good que.tlon. Tbe whole Flan Wi' deyol.oped
prior to III of the.e other cbanges. It Is • requirement rIght now for
fundfng, so VE do noed to review It and turl It ID, .,king ,ure lhat it
.eets to. .111 ... requirement. ,. that we ar. able t. re,elYe the fundiGg
It whateyer leyel It will be. It s .... rather obVIOUS that there will be
.. joT change., and probabll t. tlis document also I. t~e f,ture. Ooes
that answer )'our Cl~est~on?
G3j08j9S
·3-
,
Ii
••
(p'pfssfpner 'arrli'D: Yes. it does. but it still seems lite I
.. a.IDgl.s. t.s1.
Cb"!'!'" Cl,\lIn: Bl "".t d.te clo .. Uls document hve to be cDmpleted
ancI tu .... ed to! .
"5. IkMnSS: Bll!l1 15t~. We bov. 45 days before the progrill y.ar ""Ic~
beVhs July I, Dill" fIscal year. II order to receive the S8U,~OO w. h',.
bee. tolcfwe 0111 rec.lv. II block ~rant 'unds.
Cbalrman Ol.tlan: Before we <In cleteno!n. ""ether thIs is a me.nlogf,l ~r
.. a.loglo •• ~er<Is., we probably will not know that by t~ls tIme
deadline. 1"\1$ doc_n! 0111 hive to be 10, Ind ._tl .. Ifter that
deAdlIne Is .. t. we will flocl out If there 's.anl Yalldlty to our actIons.
!to 11chards: Tbat i. correct.
ft., Siegel: For the upcoming fiscal year, t~ls I. stIll an Important
doc .... t. Most Gf the HUe houslog funding is 111.1J t. rosal. so .. ""at
I.tlet for 1995-96. It Is I. subsequent fiscal yo.rs that the progr.ms
are goIng tl be .. rged and consolidated, ond the. funding will probably be
cut s'gnlflcantlJ. J. terRS "ot o,lJ of CoeG funds but of the cily's
Ipply10g for possiblo 1;0'" funds for 1995 and noD-profits •• , .... nt t.
appl, for c.tegorlcol HUO grants. those are sltll .,allabl. for 1995. So
this document Is fmpcrta.t for tn. Upcooin9 ye.r.
eki! .. ,n OjakilO: 1 will now ope' the public helrlng.
PatrICia $aff1r. 27]' Bryant Strfrt. 'alp Alt.: I Ie speitfng t~is~t for
tbe leag"" Df Vomo. totor.. Th. league of ~oee. 'oters CommEnds tn. <i11
stoff 00 the preplrotion of the consolidated documomt. Ve hive been
following the CHAS for severa' years. and we co~tinue to aa-ire 10~ for
belog abl. to produce 0 document that Is reasonibl, r •• dabl. and <l •• r_
We hope 10a won't ~aYI te do it all eyer a91~B too soon.
lot unexpected1,. the flous~~S fteeds Assessment section shows that there
are umoet housing need. for .11 categorl •• of lower-fncome 'al. Altan,.
As st,tad .D '"ge 46 of the document. ',I. Alt. polltl I, t. rely
prlaorll, OD private groups to laltllto housIng development propos.l ••
for the long teMl, therefore, we feel the city .u.t be I. a po.itlon t.
lend support to new bocslng propo •• ls Vbl<~ --, s.rve I wi~ ••• rlety or
needs. The le.gue belle •• s that the boo.log s.ctloos of the 1955-2000
Graft plan do cooto!. s,fftcl.nt breadt_ .nd prlorltl •• and propo,ed
octhltles to pro.Me Ue requIred flulbl1lt,. lie urge that t~e
Con.olldated 'lan be odopt~ witho"t s'g.lflc .. t chanse. or ".1.1100 •.
Tbe league .1.0 supports t~e strong ernp~.sls gi ••• to housln9 I. the
1995-95 aetlon ,lon_ lobl. 3 followin9 'a9. 54 ll.ts sever,l projects
Whlc' the le.gue supperts and is hopef.l will proceed i. 1995·96,
Including the Alm. Street SRO housing and the rete.tlon of the Arastradero
'ark Apartment. is subsidized housing, ~. feel It is essentl.l th.t •
substantial part of the 1995-96 C06& funding be allocated for bouslng. V •
• 1so uTi" tODtl.u,tlon, through t~e Hu.an Services Divisloo of the City's
Department of Community Service,. of ,oppor! tl the non·profit 'genci ••
that provide $eTY~ce~ t. res!dents, suei IS cht1d Cire~ teeD counseling.
rape crisis. single pare~ting <lisses and nutrition progr~s. We
03/08/95
-C-
i'
••
partic .. 1.,.11 urge suciJI support 'fill • ."nu affecting cbildren and fl."II\Hes
~th ~~116rln. We would lite to see that tnese services Ire affere~ t,
bOleless f .. lllos with chlldre •• as well as perhaps the .ore .oroa",
CDVtred groups I. fa'. Alt.. lbank yo. yery .uch •
",[l,n' Pr.n4t:taut, 54D t!?llper Strut, hJI..Al.tR: I .. t"e £xecftlthte
Director of t~e fl'. Alte RousIng (orporltlo •. r, too, would lIlt to
eooaend the ,tiff for t~ls prod!glous lBOunt of work. All the tlse, 1 get
asked to .pelt lbout bouslng, and DOW, I ,in jDst ta~. t\ls w1tb De Ind
will not •••• t. be stwobllng around for detail. Ind facts. This fs
relll, coopl.to and I very good re.DUrtf for tbe clt1·
V. certalall support tbe preptrltl.n and III of the work that has gon.
iot. tbls, beel.'. It is I necfssary vehlcl. for federal fund~.g to the
txtent t~lt Cathy vas til king .bout for ""1 foderal fund log that will
r..al. 1& the 'uture. T,'s Is a doc .... t that get. vs there. so we
opprecfat. the City's efforts t. got t_ls done. Ve. then, Cin co .. lnd
.s. it t. get 'undlng.
Ve .lso certl'.l, agr •• t~.t .ffordable rent.l housing Is. Ind.ed. I
prlorit1 ,. this communitl. That Is, .f cour,. the bo.slng corporation's
priNry bus'l'IE'ss. and it h dU.Penh1,J needed h Palo ~l to., $0 'J'!' ire
,1111 to se. nil that continues to be In I.porta,t sut,,,,,.t fo H. Flan.
I bave read through this doc~"t. and [ bave • few ... 11 ".t,lls t.
<GORent upon wh\e~ r will give 10 writing to Suzanne Richards. They are
just ... 11 things. There is one ' ...... nt I vant to .ake tonight. On P,ge 4e .. there Is • refere:K:e tD tne arthit1u (If I'lor.-pnflts. Non-prcfits
Ilso contribute substanti.l staff tl .. and energy t •• ffordable housing
efforts, iIIIfld ilH.lod, Qf tllat tilM! is paid for frOll tf'leir own resources. Tiis
Is true, Ind this Is good, ind I am flad th.t that statement is ther ••
T~fs Is the buslness wt are il~ I~d ~f t~fnt we ire In \~p~tant re~rce
to the coaounltl.
II the chart just below tht, under Kon·P...,fit ·Develop.rs. I thi.k it
probabl, Is Dot an official 1. by ".fl,itloo, but we would lik. to briefly
CooaeDt that under P.ent.l Asslstonce, .lthough we do not give out
~t'on 8 certificates as I ~.·proflt, we do •• If·subsldize a lot of our
}ropertles. To the extent po.slble, we do Dot .al.e rents er we subsidIze
~lrtlc.lar unit. 0.\ of the property budget so that t~. rent I. lo .. r. We
do t~.t ~enever and wherever ~ Cin .fforl it~ It 'I rental Iss1sta~t,
.Ithough oot by efflcial defloltlon. Another comment Is under ~~le,.
PreventloD. V. are not I. the business .f bomeless se .. lces. but now wit.
the reopeRlng of the Barker Aot.l. we r •• ll, are f. that bUSiness, too.
Of the tenlnt. there. quit •• number of the one. we ha.e jest rented t.
Ire 'rOIl the botnele .. ,..."unit1. So we vanted to mate those ,tat..,..ts.
Vhfther or oot they become offfcl.l l's there '" the chart, I do not t,ov.
but these Ire So.! of our good leti.ltfe ••
Ct.l ..... ) Ola"".: Seelog no other speabrs. r will closo the public
portion .f the bearing and bring II back to the coonlss!o". Ar. there .n,
comeentJ from C~is5ioners?
(gmm'sl'oner tl$5el~ I have a question about what happens when the armory
IS cl.sed. I believe there are thre. aMOOrle. '" the count, that are open
I. the vioter and closed I. the summer. It is • commoD Idea that 250
e31os/9S
oS-
.. ~.
.. ,
(.../
""-.
. ;.-
u~1ts ~rt be~~9 put up il So~th San Jose te rep'." .some of tho5e~ but
t~.t the other lnoorl •• wIll be clo •• d. Wh •• wIll that bappeD, and what
I. iolng to occur the.?
. • !L.Jl1khiotl: It Is predIcted .ow that the lroorl •• wIll elc •• II 1997.
TOe [aergenc1 RousIng ConsortIum Is proposing th.t they have • reception
. c .. ter 10 South San Jose that will be open y .. r round to p,oylde beds, not
onl1 I, the wioter, but all lear, a. well IS othEr homeiess seryfce ••
rhlt Is supposed t. be ~50 bed., so it will not replace all .f them, but
it will be • njorlty.
(OM!'jllgner ('$S']: I ha~e I question about lead~based pa!lts. I. the
report. it Indleat •• that that I. ncre of a ~IJor probl.~ f' ,lngl.·, •• 11,
~UIe" beta"so tho.e are the home, t~al ~~re built I. that era. Do
slngie-fasll, hODO. h.ye .. ie. t<21 ••• 4 to compl, with wh •• th.y palot or
clean or rebab? Or are slngle·famll, h"~' Ignored i. t~ls proces.?
el. Richards: A5 far lS I L~OW, there ire DD regulllfDns, unless we need
te oddr ••• it If there Is feder.l funding l,volved. for pri.at.,
,lngle-flB111 resldentes. I d. not tnow of "'J regol.tlons •
. thai",'" Qj;th,,,: I l1avf II question. Ira Table 3 ttlat 'Wa:s Illuded' til
preti1DUsl, .. it Sly5 .. -n.e projects wMc" lIa! need funding_ .• • .1 all
eur1ou$ about bo~s'ng fer the deve'~pm!ntllll disabled and if there is any
stat"s Dn that. llein1cg at \that stage '!)-r level ire lie it i!I that becoming
• rulit,?
PI. Rfc~ards: Tb! orgl",zltion t~at is spansDring that project is t~e
Mid·Penlo.al. flouslng Coalition. Th.y ~a,e be •• loctlng fer the l.sl t.o
y •• rs for • sit. I. ,.10 Alt •• T"e, would lIte t. buIld about 24 unIts of
apartments, .04 It wocid be fer Independent liviog for people that are
developROnt.ll, d!s.~ied but Ire cap.bi. of 11.lng on their own. The, Ire
looting very serloo,iy now .t t~e county-owned property at fage Mill Road
and Asb Str •• t io tho (.llfor,l, Avonue .,e.. The county has Indieated
th.t the, Ire de.lrous of .el110g the propert,. Thoy ba1 it appral .. d
t.fs list fa11 and ~i~e beeR d~SC~S5\ns ~thll the countJ structure bow to
go about putting it o. t~ ••• riet and What legal requIrements appl, to
t~eo as I public agency. So the ~jd·P.,;.s.l. Rnasl.g Coali\lon is
watc~l.g o •• r that proce,s. Th.y Ire going to be reYiewi'g the approl,.l
a~~ decla1~g ~~t~er or not t~e1 can r.a~t an effET. We are wortIng
c10.el" Yith th... City people wi II .lso be re.iewing the Il>pral,.l and
lootIng at our boaslog budget t. ,e •• ~ much •• ney we can fund. It
probebl, will need t~ •• ajority of th. land cests to bo funded with some
type of bousing 8O.los. Ve do .ot know whit' ones yet.
ChaIrman Oiat1an: If th!re are no furt~er quest1ons~ does someone want to
ute I IICItion?
~! Commlss!ontr Ca c $ol! 1 mo~e t~at we fDrward this to tne Cit,
council for th.!r consideration. wlt_ .any th.nks t. the stoff for the
.ffort t.o' they h.,. put i.to It.
~, 8, (DOD!s,lo,er Sch$idt.
Coon;ss!on.r Stnmlqt: It looks lite 83 unit. bave been achIeved slnco the
CHAS was I.st put tog.ther, lookIng .t the projects on Pige 31. Tnere
nl/OBj95
-6-
.
-.
were three prajects that C~ on line ,. 1994. and t~at previous (HAS ~a$
dated ill It93~ ... t.fI~ other c'hart we .. ere referdng to. I bel itve there
were 254 units t •• t ~I~~t need '"ndl,g. I want t. comme,' thaI I am ~"PPY
to s .. SOle unit. eomln9 OD lin., Ind I will be 'ory ~'PPI to see DOre
~Its c~lng on 11... I will be dislppoloted to see HUG dlsapp.'r er
bee ... ..eh 1 •• 5 of In 155'stlnt '0 ~.i,log us pr.,lde t~es. ~ous'ng ~s. As we III toow. we ha ••• ddr.,sed I .,.letJ of bousfng projects en
~~Is c..-Ioslo. ave. t~. 1,st two years. Ind not a lot of them biV' gone
forward. We ~.ve tb. opportunltl to.lgbt to tlke en. further t. our .ext
agondl It ...
Cgeml<sloner C.ss.1: It Is .Ico to se •• 11 of t~ls ~aterl.l put
togethe.. I ~~ thlt n •• ~ y •• r. yo. will Dot b.ve to do .not~er Whoi.
docuoent and that YOD CI. just write I little summary. rD. bad to do
.1 ... , In •• tlre on. la.t y.ar, Ind • lot of t_ls •• terill bad te be
reiDventtd in InDtber foraat for t.is year. So there must ~a~e been an
extons!, • ..aU"t of .taff tl .. Involved. It',. good Ide. to put It .11
tosetber i. ene document. but I hope WE do .ot ~.y. to ~.ep on redDing
these f .... overy two or three years. It fs • oleo pfece of ~ork and It
will be us.f.' I. other tlsks thlt we tackie.
MOlIQH PASSES: Chairman Q!aklln: Ye \ave I ~otlgn by Conmissioner Cassel
and soconded by t_Iuloner ScMidt to fo .... rd Uh document on te the
city council w1th no c~rrections Ind with deep appre'latf~ of lne ~taff
efforts far putting 1t together. Is there any furtner dist~SS10D on t~is
DOtlon? All tho •• i. fa.or, S>1 Aye! All opposed! Th,t p.sses
unanimo~s11 OD I vote of ,~O. T~fs ite~ ~11 go to the C1t, counc1t on
Hay 1st.
AGENDA ITEK 2 725-753 ALNA STREET: Prell.lnar, ~.yie~ of .pplication t.
rez .. e the property It 725-ZS3Alm. Street fros CO-SI"
Downtown Conoerc,.ljServfce. Pedestrl.n Coabl.lng
Ol.trlct, t. PC {'lanned CommunIty) Oistrlct 10 order t.
de.alis~ 1ft existing s Ippr&x{mat.ly 3,000 ·square·foot
autD service bu.ld~ng and te construct i mixed gse project
consIsting af IG7 ""t •• f Sfng1.-Roo. Decupaney (SRO}
bouslng, appro.laatel, 1.7S? square feet of ground floor
3!lsed offfe! space and 74 ~lrtiDa sp~ces 11 I two~leyel
parking garage. A De.lgn f~hane~nt Exception (Of E) Is
required for portions of the parapet tn.t exceed the
SO·fvot beight lImit by f""" feet. An enyironment.i
impact .sse.5 ... t will be prepared prior ta the .econd
bearing before the ,lannlng commissIon_ file
No •• 94-ARB-Z37. 9S·Zt-2. 95-EI~-Z. 9S-OEE-I.
C~I'rm3n Qfak'in: Whit we are looting It tonfgnt, as we do for all
PJanne4 (oam~nit1 zones. is I prelf.fnarl or conceptual review Df t~is
item, •• t'ls Is oot t ••• y that we are 100kln9 it • final appro.,l of
t~Is praJe<t. It Is the first f •• three-step process that lo.olves
looting it what I. i. {root of •• concopt.allJ, wit_ thl. It •• go'D9 00 ta
tbe Irciite<turll review board_ and theft coming back t~ the ,lanning
commission ror • flnll bearing and. ffn,l approval process before going
OD to the cltJ council. TonIght we are II the first step of th.t process,
Ind that Is what we will be havIng the public be.r;,g on ,. a ~03ent. 're
there anI ,taff c ..... nts on this it ... l .
03/~gS
·1-
CITY OF PALO ALTO
Housing and Community De>elopment
CONSOUDATED PLAN
SnbnUned 10 HlJD: ___ _
Ptepared by Dcpanment of Planning &; <:omrounily Envil:oomel1
250 H.amiIIO!l A",,_
Palo Al'.o. Ca.lifornia 94301
X"" Sebreiber, 0;,-""",<
F<Jc lnfOl'lllatWn. Cootact: Sazanno Richanls
i'IamllD!l Di>i<kln, City '>f Palo AIrc (415) 32<}.1428
I.
Consolidated Plan
Table oj Con/ems
1995
A. PIaD Coorc!iDatioo -Mana&<ment •.•••.•••..•......•••...•..
I. Roles IDd ResponSiOilities •••••••••••.••••...•••••••••••••.
2. COIlSUItation and Coonlination with Other Agencies •....•.•.•..•••.
B. om... Participation ••••••..•••..••...•••.•.•....••..••••
I. Citizen Panicipaoon Proctss •••••••••..••••..•••..•••••••.•
2 O>=D!s/R~spoos.. . • . . • . . • • • • . • • . • . • . . . . . • • . . . . . . ••.••
Do HousiDa: and Community Developmea! Needs (l9%-2000) ••..•••...•.• : ••.
A. Olmmunity De:i<:ripOOa •••••.•.•••••••.•••.••..••••••••••.
B. Al'fonlable HOusinz Needs .•••..••••.••••.•.....•.••..•••..
Summary of Needs/Housing Needs by iloosebold C.~ory •.•••.......•
I. RenterlDd Hoolrowner Households •.•.•.•.•.•.•.••.••.•.•...
2. Large Families .......••.••..•••.•..•.••......•.•.••.•.
3. Elderly Households ••••.••••.••••••••...•.•.•..•.••••..•
&. Supportive Housing for 1he Elderly: Needs and ~ •.•••••
1>. Supportive Housing foe the Frail Elderly: Needs and Resoun:es •.•.
c. Summary of Elderly and Frail Elderly Need ••••••.•••.•••••
4.SiIlglePenoos ••••.••.•••••..••.•......•...•••••.••..•
S. Penoos wiih Disabilities ..••••••.•...•••••.•.••..•••..••..
•. Supportive Housing for Penoos with Severe Men!aI
Illness: Needs IDd Resources •••••••••••••••••••••••
b. Supportive Housing for Persons wiJh Developmental
Disabilities: Needs IDd Resources ••...•••••••••••.••.
c. Group Homes for Deve10pmenWly Disabled: Needs
IDd Resources ••••••••.••.•••••..•.••.••••..•••
d. Suj>pOCti>c Housing for Persons with
Ploysical Disabilities: Needs and Resour..es ••••...•••.••.
e. Supportive Housing for Penoos willi
AlcoboI or AcI<Iictloos: Needs and ReiOlllUS ••.••••••..••
i SupporJ ... Housing foe Pecsoos with AIDS: Needs
and R.esouI'"..es ••••••••••••••.••••••••••••••••••
6. SiIIgIe ParenI Households .•..•.•.....•.••.•..•.•••....••••
,. Households Overpaying for Housing ••..••....••.••..•.•.•.•.•
•
S. OIIercrowd<>! Housebolds • • • • • • • • . • . • . . .•.•••.•••••.••••..
9. Substandard Housing Units .••.••..••••••..•.•...•.•..•....
C. 1i000eJless Needs ...... ~ ....... __ .... _ ..... _ ....... -.... -.
I. Nee:ls or Sbelterod and Unsho_ Homeless •.........••....•..•
2. Toto! Number or Home1= Persoos •••.....••.••••.••••••••••.
l. Local ·Pow in Time" Coon< or Homeless ••.••••..••••..•.•
3. 0umII Numbers or Homeles. Pers..,.,. Served .••••••••..•••.••••
4. Unshollered Homelcs.s •.••........••..••.•..•••..•.••..•.
S. Ra<e and Ethnic Composition .••..•••.....••...••.•..•.•..•
6. ~ or !be Homeless ..•...•••..•.•..•••...••••..
7. N_ or Persons Threatened witlI Homeless.... • .•••.•..••.••••••
8. lovenrory or Ficmtits and Scrvkes 10 Assist
!he Homelcs.s and Persoos Threater.ed .. itil
Homelessuess • • . • • • . • • • . • • . • . . • • • . • . . • . . • . . • • • . . • • .
t. lovemmy or Faci\i:les .••..•••.....••.•••....••......
b. IaventOl)' or Servicu ..••.........••...••....••••..•
D. PIIbIic HousiDg Needs •••....••...•••••..•....•..•••.••..••
E. lacI-BII!ed PaiD! Needs ..•••...•.•••••...••••.•••....•••.•
F. M.vIut CoDditioIlS •.•.•..••••••..•••.•••••••••••••.••••••
I. CurnDl and An:icipaled Housebolds in Palo Alto
for the 1995-2000 P'~ng PeOOd by Income Level .•••....•••••..•
2. HoosiDg Trends ••.••.•......•...••.••..•••...••.•..•.•
3. Homeo~hip Affordability •••.•••••.•••••.••••..••••.•.•
4. Reotal Affordabilily ...••.•.•••••.•.••••••.••..••.•..•••.
S. Ocoupancy and Physical Clwa<teristks or the
HoosiDg Sto<:t ••••••..••••••••••..••••••••••..•••••
l. OwDen;bip Housing ••.•••••••••..•.••••••••..•••••.
1>. RtnIal Housing •••••.•••.•••••••.••••••••••.••••••
c .• 'Be or Reotal Sloel: .••.•.••.••••..••••.••••...•••.•
d. RtnIal Vac:arw.'Y Rate ...•••••.••..•••••....•....•...
e. Definition or "Substandard" Con<fruon .•....••..•••.....••
6. Ethnic and Racial Cbar>ctcristics or M>rke[ •••••.••.•..••••....•
t. Areas ct RaciallElIlllic MiDoriIy c""",ll!I'alion • • • • . • • • • . •
b. Areas or In ... ·lncome Concelllration .•••...•••....••••.••
1. Suilabilily or Housing Sloe" for Households
wid! Special Needs .•••.•••.••.•..••••..•••.••.••••..
l. Elderly Households ............................... .
1>. Persoos ,.itlI Physical Disabilities ••••.•••••.•••.••••.•.•
c. Families ",ilh Cbildrea •.••••.•.••••••••.••••••••.•••
s ....... isted Housing IllventOl)' •••..•••.•••••.••••.••••••.•••••
t. Section 8 RtnIal Assistance Program • • • • . • • • • • • . • • • .
b. 0Iber Assisted Hous1..'lg InveJllmy .•••.•..•...••.•...•..•
c. Below M>r1ret Program Housing Inventory •.••.•..•••..••••
G. Barriers '" AIT_ble HousiDg ••••.••••.••••..•.••.••••...•.
I. LocI< or Vacant« Available Land for Hrosing c"nsttuction .....••.•.
. --.,
" 0-_ :.-~' <.". -
-0...,-
." :'.
2. Pric>: 0( Land SUitable for Housing ...••..•••.••..••......••.•
~. Lad; 0( Mute! DomaDd and financing for MMke,
!We Housmg .•••... -••••••••••••••••.•••••.•••..••
H. Fair IIoIIsiDI . . . . • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . • . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . ..
L Table I ............................................. .
IlL HousIDg IDd Community DeveJopmenC Straf<Ik Plan
(1995-1000) ••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••.•••••••••
A. HoiIIIIDi IDd Community DeftIopmenI Objecthes .....
Proi-............................................. .
J. Priorio.oy AlfonIabIe Housing Ne<ds .••••....•.•.•••••..••.••••
I. PrioriIy: Rt1ttaI Housing ••..•••..•••.••..•.•.....••••
I. Activi!ieG: Acquisition. Rohabilitation
New Consttuc6on. SUpport Services •••••••••••••.•••
b. 1'ricriIy: Ownushij> Housing ••••••.•••..•...•.•.•••...
L Activities: Homebuyers Assistance.
Robabilitation. Acquisition •.•..•••••••..•••.•..•.
i1. Activities: lI<hlIbmuOOn 0( Existing
Single family Homes. SUpport Services .•.•••.••.•.••.
2. PrioriIy Homeless Ne<ds ..•••.•.••...•. _ •• _ ••• _ •• __ ••.. _ •.
I. Priority: Homeless and • At. !tis\:. for Becoming
Holnekss-.4. ______ ...... __ .• __ . __ •• 4 __ ~ _ .•• _
i. Activities: Acquisition. lI<habililallon.
RenIaI Assi..<tance. SUpport Services and
fliC11ities •• _ ••••••••••••••••• , .••••••••••• __
3_ OIlIer Special Noeds Populatioos ••.••.• _ .• _ •• _ ..•• _ ..•••••••
t. Priority: AI Special _ Groups ••.•••.•.•••••.•••••••
i Activities: New COilSIIUCtion,
Rohabilitatioo. SUpport facil1ties and
Services •.••••••••.••• _ • • _ • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • • •
4. PrioriIy N<>n-Housing Community Developmenl Needs ••..••••.••.. _
I. Public focilities and Improvemerus: C~ital
Project Noeds ••••.. _ ••••••••• _ •.•• _ .•••••••••.
1>. PubrlC Services wItic~ ser.e Lower Income Oients
Primarily _ ••..•••.•.••.••••.••.•...•••••••.••
S. Anli-Puverty Stntegy • • • • . . • • • • • • • . . • . . . • • . • • • • . . • • • • • • • •
6. PublidJouslng ••.•••••.••••..•••.•••••••.•..•..••.•.•.
,. Leod-Based Painl ....................................._
8. IDstituDooal Structure •.•••. _ .•.••••..•••.••..••... _ ••.••.
9. Jl<dIICtion 0( Barriers . . • • • • . . • • . . • • • . . . • • • • . . • • • . . . . • • • • •
B. CGonIInadoa •••••.• _ •••••••••••••••••••••••••••••.. _ ••
C. Table2 ......... _ ............................•.......
IV. Adioa Plan (l99S-1996) _ _ • • . • . . • . _ . • • . • . • • • . . • • . • • . . • . • • • • • . • • .
"-:,'-.
-~.,
A. FDC'lZl 424 •••••••••••••••••••••••••••••.•••••••••••••••
B. HooloID& and Community o.velopmeDl Resources ••••••••..••.•••••
1. FcdenI Programs •••••.••••••••••..•.•••..••..•••...•.•
2. Non-FcdenJ Public Progmns ••••••..•••••••••••••••••••.••
•. Slate ProgI8IIl5 •••••••••••.•.••••••.••••••••••••••
b. L:>cal Programs ••...••••••......••..•.••.••••.•.••
3. Private Re30urces ••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••••
c.. Description of Adivllies ••...••••••..•....•••..•..•••....••
I. l\ellIal Housins Acfr.fities ••.•.•••••••••••••..••..•••••••.•
2. AnD-Home-" ActiviticslStta",,-ies .•..•.••••.••...•••.•...
3. AIIti-Poverty ActivldeS,IStra~ ••••••.••..•••..•.•••.••....
D. Loc:aIioas of Ac1mIles ••••...•.•••..•....•••..•••..••••.•.
Eo MouiIoriug of Adi-ritios .••....•.......•....••.•....•....••
F. CoocdlDatioa ••••.•••••.....••••.•••..•••••••••..••••••
G. CDBG Scbm.issicm Rfquiranents ...••....••...••...•••...•..•
H. Tatlo 3 •••••••...•••••.....•.••••••.•.•.•.••.•....•••
V. Appendi'
A. GIossalyolTmns
B. CertIIbIions
C. CitheR ParddpalioD Plan
D. Pul>1k Notices
Eo Iaoome LimIts
F. T_ le (From 1994 mAS)
G. Sommary of CJIizeoa CommeoIf5
R ParriES! Surrey Statistics
-, ,". -:",
, ' ,c-,
L SaDImar)' of CoosoIIdated Plan Development Pr..,...
A. PIau eoor.r_ and Mmagement
On 'annat) S, 1m tile Oefartme!ll of Housing and Urban Developmem (HUD) issued • Final
Rule "" !be cooso!idation of applications ~ four major HUD !'annul. programs:
Community Developmolll Block Grant (CDBG}
HOME InvestmeDl Partnerships (HOME}
Hresing ~ fc< Perscns with Aids (HOPWA)
Emergency Sbelter Grants (ESG)
Of tile four formuJa programs. CDBG funds a"o the ooIy ones received by Palo Alto .. an
~ cfu«:dy from HUD. Funding from II!)' oftbe _ soun;es would ~Ire a SU<:<:eSSful
gr.mI application in • competitive process admInistered by eitber the State of California or HUD.
The CoosoIicIated Plan trings oogelber the principal hou<ing ",.arming document ~i.-.:d b)' HUn
(formerly knowllas die CHAS>. die Non-Housing Comrnunlty Devolopmem Plan, and the CDBG
Final statemelll (ODe ~ use oHunds).
11 is Inte~ 10 initiate a collaborate ~ss wboreby a community ..... Nisbes • unified vision
for community a<:tions. and strengthens partnc"bips among all leyels of govemmen! and tile
private =to<, including for·profit and DOn-profit organizations. The Plan is Intended to Iink
identified needs 10 the federal and 10cal resourt:eS available 10 meet !bose needs.
HUD's goals for Ille new Consolidated Plan are 10 teduce paperwork and duplication 0( effort
while increasing progJim etJ<ctiveness by enoooraging • conabontive process, I clearly defined
strategy, and • basis for .ssessing pc:rfonnan<:e. The nn' requiremeIJ!s stipuIa1e !hat jurisdIcIioos
truSt produco • single, tine 10 five ~ strategic plan 10 further achieve !he Chrce basic gOlls 0(
the formula gr.mI programs: tD provitk duerrlMusing, " n<ita1JU living enviro,uruI1lJ. turd tD
ap<m4 _Ink oJ1]lOTtlutitk. for fIU'O'lS 0/ Ww tur4.ery 10 .. income.
WIIhin !he City 0( Palo AM, the Departmelll of Plannir.g oDd Communi'y EnviromneIJ< is
respoosible for administering !he CDBG Program, and completing !he Consolidated Plan. The
4evelopmelll process for die preparation 0( the CoosoI:'<I.ated Plan was initiated wi!ll • public
I>eariDg 00 affordable housing and community development needs. priorities. obstacles and
strategies. The bearing was cooductecI by City-Planning staff, and was bold at 1:00 PM on
October 24, 1994 m the Ccmmuni!y Room at !he Locle Stern C<lIIlIlIucity Center, .an accessible
location, Persons .. to c.JUId not att<:nd the hearing were ellCOUl'lIged !O submit Information by
eitber calling or writing City-Planning staff.
1
-, i
--~~
. ".!.". ,', ',-',",
Notice of Ill< pub!>: hearing "", published as a cf.sptay ad in tlJe Palo Alto Weekly on Oc1Ober
12.1994 (see C<lp)' in Aj>pendix 0), and,.as mailed to an cxteosiv. Jist of individual CitiullS and
orpnizalioos ~ • broad spectrum of tlJe City p<>puIation:
• Memb= of CiIJ Commissions. Coonnittees. Task Forces
• N<q>ro6I boosins developers and providers
• Nonpro/iI ole ~ social servU ag=ies
• ~gbboring Cities and jurisdictions
• Privab: mil _ investors, clevelopen and BoanI of Realm"
• Low income tenants <I< IetW!I groJp5
• Affordable housing Idvocarn
• I.merested citizens
Cotn!uem from Ill< bcariIlg were recorded and ournmarized (see SummaJy of Citizen CommeDlS,
Appendix G). Ccples of tlJe 1991-94 CHAS were distributed at tlJe meeting as VIeD as writteD
materials describing the new process and requiremell!S and tlJe p<opos«! timefme 10< completion.
The draft ConsoIida!td Plan ...... vallaNe from Man:h 1. 1995 10 Marcil 31. 1995 10< ""bIle
to>leW, NOOce of tlJe availability of Ill< drafi document. and tlJe planned pubIle bearing dates
...... published IS I display II<! in Ill< Palo Aha Weekly 00 March I. 1995 (See copy in AppendIx
DJ, The DO!lce ..... also mailed 10 Ihc list above. The P1an was reviewed by tlJe Planning
C<><I\mis,ion on March 8, 1995, and by tlJe Hum>.n Relations Commission at tlJeir meeting' OIl
March 9, 1995 and April n. 1995, The CoosoIidated P1an will be CO<lSider<:d by Ille fun Council
at tlJeir meetios "" May I, 1995,
City Housing and CDIIG staff roasuItcd wi1h or n:celved data from local agencies .. -hiell p<ovide
housing and services to persons with specialllfcls. The agencies whic1l 'O'er: c:onsuIted are:
• ~ Mental Health (mentally ill)
• Innvvativ. Housing (single pareD! f2millc.)
• Urban ~misay (homeless)
• Emc-gency Housing Ccnsortium (homeless)
• SiD And. ..... Rcgiooal Center (developmemally disabled)
• CAIIIIllIlllity Association fa< Rehabilitation (cflSa1>1od)
• Senior Coordinating Ccwd (elderly. frail elderly)
• Mid-PIminsula Hcusing Ccalition (1ow income bouseholds)
• Palo Alto Housing Corporation (1ow income bouseOOlds)
Housing and COOO staff from wilhln Santa Clara Coun!y met five times bet ..... n Oc1Ober, 1994
and F~, 1995 to sIwe infOOlll!tion. cf15<. ..... data oeeds and availability, Pn:.<enI at these
meetings were the jwisdic1lons wiIhln s.nta Clara eoun.., ... hiell are also requir«l \0 prepare •
CoosoIidat.ed Plan: Sallt3 Clara Ccunty (rep=en!ing !he Ikban Crull!)'. Morgan Hill, CampbeD,
2
~"---:;::---7"--' -,--------
.' "
•
,,l.,-".~ __
'"'~: ~~-t~ ~;l .. ' .'
'.
Los (JalOS, Sanlros .. Milpilas, Los AlIos, Los Altos Hills, Monte Sereno and CAmpbcn). and tb: enti_ citieJ (PlIo Alto. Mountain VJeW, Sunnyvale. Santa Clara, San Jose and Gilroy).
Tho SIaIJ invoMd <OOnIlnaIod JequesIS for data from CooDIy ag.""ies and discussod melhodoIosY
for cstimaliJ!8 a.. JocaI .bare or Coomywide statistics. ODe or Ibcsc meetings also included I
consuItolioD with HtJD CommwUty P1anning and Developmem (CPV) staff from Ibc San
FroI!cisco office.
NWllOlOUS JDOeIings wm: a!s<l bcId with a.. County', Homciess C;)ord'matoc 10 provide specific
wcum .... tionand informa:ioo on a.. issue ofbomclessness CounIy'Ioide. Tho meetings included
' ......... Ih .. rrom all a.. cooo enIitlcmellt Cities in Santa CIanI CooDIy. IS ,..11 IS tb: Urban
County. New demogr>plUc informallon from • January. 1m homeless study has been
incotporaood inIo Ille final version or Ille Ccnsofldated Plan
B. Citiz£u Partic:ipalioD
A pcimar} ~ or Ille Housing and Communi.'Y Dev<lopmem Act or 19S7 is Ille provision or
IIdequatt oppoI1UDity for citizens 10 participaw in an advisoQ role in tb: planning, implemeWllon
and assessmcnr or Ille CommwUty DeV.Jop=llI Block Or:un program. To comply with Ille
requirements or tb: Act. Ille City or Palo Alto follows I detailed Citizen Partic:ipallon Plan
adopIod by a.. City Cowx:~ CD December n, 1993. The COnsoIldalfd Plan Final Rule will
_ilate cllanges 10 Ille c:urn:m Citiz£u Partic:lpatico Plan incorpolaling new Consolid.ted
PIamJing language and requimneDts. k is Ille inteoticD or Cily Planning 5llIff to amend Ille
cmen Partic:ipeticn Plan duriIlg Ille 1995196 fiscal year. The curren! Citiz£u Partic:ip.>ticu Plan
is iDclucIed in AppeD<ftlt C.
Citiun tomIIlODIS reaived during Ille consolidated planning process and tb: 30 day public: review
period 1m included in Appendix G.
3
n. Housilla"" CommuniIy DcvcJopmeIll Needs (1995-2000)
A. COMMUNITY DESCRIPTION
" .. -.'
.-:-':'. :,.-." ' .. -;.--;-~'---~
Palo Aho is. tuburbaD. c;ry wid> • 1994 resident popWaOoo 0( approximately 58,000 people
silwllI:<I 00 IIle IIOi1bem bonier 0( SaoIa C1an Coumy in !be heart 0( 'Silic<Jn Valle)' _ Palo Alto
is port 0( I!le M1dp<mins>ll. -= wbicIIlpODS !ID<Ib:I". SanIa Clara CoonIy (""luding the eities 0(
Santa Clara, Mountain V ..... and SwmyvaIe) and I!le soutbera portion 0( San Mateo Coonty
(mcluding !be cities d Men10 Part. Eost Palo AI!o and Red ... ood City}. The CiIy is too .... foe
.. association wiIb IIle WO<'.d-Comous educaIiooaI and reseaJCh instibltioo 0( Stanford UDlvorsity.
Palo AI!o ~IU 1.100 tbe birtbpl2cc 0( high ~ _-try in 1l>c Valley. Stanford Me<flCa!
Centa is • major = foe mr4icIl care and racarcIL The City is a1so • center of inrernational
c:uIlure, ~ &hopping and food.
Palo Ahn is. OYtI'&II, •• ory aftluem eommunity. The m •• flan family income (1990 =>SUS) is now
over $68,000, abooIlWice L"" national m..r,.,. iI=<ne. from 1980 10 1990, Palo Ah,,', median
_ income increased 124" c<>mpan:d '" • 106" ~ foe I!le County as I wboIe. The
IlIIDlI>er o(per5ODS below ibo poverty level decrlllOd from 5.9" 0( IIle populaOoo in 1980 '" 4.6"
in 1990. Palo Alto is • vel}' deliirable ~ lI> live due so its crunate, high quafuy scbools,
culture, access Ie jobs, eu:. The housing supp/} has 0()( kepi. pac< with housing demand. IuS!
1,701 housilla cnits were added Jrom 1980 10 1994.
Hoosing demand in Palo AI!o is Slfongly inlh>enced by Ibe number 0( jobs in IIle City and
surrounding area. There are about twice as many jobs ill the City as Iller< .... =KIem.s in !be
labor fora. About SOS of !be City's "orlt fora is made up 0( commuters from otber
""""",mj!jes.. Tho employment base grew &Iring tbe 1980', by approxitmtely 10,000 jobo. but
.vaiIJl>Je data indlcate !hat IIle IOIliI number 0( jobs has declmed sine< 1990_
Housing costs esca1.trd tr<:mendoosIy during lilt 1m', and 1980',. Tho median value 0( owner
occupi<d housing tmits iIIcrease4 by 201S from 1980 10 1990 IJld m..r.." rents incn:ased by
137$ during tbe same decade. However. due so economic wx:ertaillly, sine< 1990 home prices
bave declined by approxima<cly 15%, although n:1lU bave been stable.
AnoIher impocta..~ factor influencing Ibe demand foe l>o!JsiDI in Palo AJto is !be proxinlily 0(
SWJford University. The studem population in 1992 .... 14,.."97. o(wbicII obout '.100 ... re
housed <>II-CIIq)us. Thus, o •• r 5,000 students had so be _ ill Palo AI!o or other neorby
areas. Tbero are m lInits 0( housing foe Ibe Univ ... ity·. 1,642 Ca<ulty and II.lI4 staff
1'1I:mbers. The f>cuh.y and ""ff bouseholds who .... ooc provided Unlversily lJoming add so the
housilla <Iemand in Palo Alto and !he Midpenin5u/l area.
In sumruary. d>ere is • greater demand foe boosing \han can be onec. ..is is lIcause Pal<> Alto
is I desiroblt place Ie live, tbere .... many jobs and tbere is Iiale land .. .a.bk foe ..... housing
devolopmcnt. This Ieods 10 hlgh boosing costs. low VICallC} ra<cs and I ~e 0( affordable
4
--.. "
,'J -
;.--""
bcu&ina opportlJnities. Tho bouoinal ooeds in !be con:miltlity Ire descn"bed in more de .. il in til<:
~oec<ioos.
B. AFFORDABLE BOVSfNG NEEDS
&nnm ...,. of NeedsiHoasIIIa NeecII ., HcuseIK.Id Ca\eiory
The _ significom bowiDi ......s in Polo AIIo is 10 a!k>iate !be high cOS! 0( housing for !ower
income households, <SpeCiaIIJ teDIIO'S. DoIa from !be 1990 U.S. Census indkate thaI over 7;$
of all lower income bouod>oldo wbo 1<111 PlY more !haD 3Oj\ of Illeir income for bousing. For
!bose households with evca lI£R &nltcd iI>:ornes, <peeiflCaily bousebolds wbe« incomes are less
!haD SOS 0( IIQwide metf ... _, til<: problem 0( overpaying is eveD more severe. In Palo
AlIo, approximately ;5" olll>:x "V<:r)Ilow" income bouseOOIds pay more !haD half of !be;"
income for boDsing. N<.c"";1 "" 1bese V<:r)Ilow income bousebolds have reduce1 incomes 10
begin wi!h, but over baif 0( Ill< bowe!>oIds also ba',e "' pay more \han SOS of tIl<:ir limit.ed
income iu" for housing COlIS. k.!be par8grapM and dolll below indicate, Ille lower incorue
boo&ebolds who hav~ the most severe overpayment probkms include elderly renters and sing!c
pare'" renten.
Another crilical housing ......s m Polo AIIo is !he ......s 10 provide affordable boo.ing for L'>e
bornel:ss and pe...-will> special Deeds. 1'crnla""1II affoolable bousing for bomeless bousebolds
bas beea and contlnu<s to be aD importlim !ICed in Palo AIIo. Of imponance also is til<: need 10
provide bousing 'IIi!!! "'I'I""'ive ~ for p=ons 'IIi!!! s;><ciaI neoc!s, such as !be frail elderly,
deve\opmenlAlly disabled, pIIysically disabled and !bose penons wi.th severe mental ill=s.
Other housing Deeds idenIified in !be pangr.lpbs lhaI follow include !be oeed for reblIbilitatlon of
existing housing occupied by lower income households and providing borneownership
opportuniries for lower _ booseboIds.
The D<ed for ._Ie bowing .ali •• b)' bousebold income level and category. ~ in !he
paragraphs Ihal follow are !be bousing ooeds and hooscOOId clwacl<ri>tics 0( various categories
of _ds in Palo AlIo. Tho categories inc"'de:
I. Ri=JIIer and iIome;)wner Housebolds
2. Lar",Familios
3. Eldedy JlooseboJds
4. Single Po""",
S. ~ wi.th Disabilities
6. Sin8k ParenI Hoo>ebolds
1. Households Overpaying for Hoo.'ing ("COS! Burdeoed')
8. Overcrowded Hoo>ebolds
s
S. SUbstaDdard Housing Uclt3
The 1990 US. c.nsus indicate tIw 42% of all bouseoolds "'ore renter househoIJs and !he .emalnina ss" o\ll1!C\l\hcir Ilom:s ..
BrnI!:r" Nrffls· The bip cost of reulls 1M biggesl problem r.,.. Palo Alto reuters. 41" ol
iii ....mn (old _Ie>eloi) lire ... erpeylng r .... bousille. Amoog low and ve<y low income
retIIen. overpa)'inB is • mucll m<Y."C serious problem. It is ooIy amoog larg. f.uniIy rentm thai
_ !lousing problems sud! as overcrowding and substandard housing are ootlble. The .... 1lI
of boosiDg problems _ !be renter population mdic.ws • a:ed b-more affonIabJc mlIa! units
and m<n !Odal po.ymcm ... _ sucb os tl>e Section 8 program. especially ~ very low _
bwsciIoIds. Very 10111 income n:n!ers, woo pay ever SO% ollbeir income ~ housing, may be
sacrificing _ 1!OC:SSi!ies. including cbiId care. to stay in boosing. These oo..sebolds are
especisI1y vulnerobJc 10 bomelessll<S •.
RENTERS WITH MY HOUSING PROBLEM
By 'lO ol ModllUl Income
AI Reotss 0-30 ... 31-50'10 5141 ... 68-95'10
'1_ 41S 71 " 90S 73% 671Ji
Problems
" hying NfA sa sa 21S liS
> SOS
Own<n X""",'· 26S of.ill! owners bave. housing problem. Only IS';O «Ii! ownen bave very
low. low or mcderate incomes. Of 1M low and moderate income 0""""", 37% (958
1Iou!JeboIds) bave bousiDg problems, ~ overpaying. GeneraDy. ill is rammes who ....
o_j'lDc. Excepc foe exl!1:me1y low income .lderly bomevwners. elderly 01IIDef3 do DO( bave
amp iDcidcn;e of <M:Iplymg. There are oot lOY programs II> assist ~ low and mode",te
income.fllmill! .,..".... ",ith !hcir housing e:<penS<S.
3. LarJe Families
Large reIlICr families (5 0< more related per;oosJ suffer housing problems 10 • greater degree !han
all _ boosebold types. SS% (222 bouseho!ds) ol aD large renter ramilies :hav •• housing
probIom. The typical problems «large families are overpaying and ovmrowding. or Ihese.
31" (142 famiIle:s) ar. low IDoome. o-;erpaying is die most feequelll problem of low income
large families ""itiJ an incideDC< of Dp 10 IS S.
{;
. ,
...... ",.
;:-.
.' .:
-
Elderly Iloos4ol>oIds male up 25" of Palo Alto', b<xIsebol;ls. The elderly population incrused
from 19S0 '" 1m II!II! is upectcl !O continue 10 n.. ...... se, Ove!paying is the mosi =.
housing problem f<x very low Hr;:ome eldorly re!llen. Of cldcdy l'I:1Iler houseboldo with a.:om..
betWeeo. 31-50" of mocIian, 8611 1m overpaying. E,,,,,!he mooen". income cldeIly rente" are
~ lila calC of 76%. This 40m0nstrates. great need f<x more reatal as,isuncc II!II! new
c:oosttuctioG 0( subsidized rental hOOsing f<x die elderly_
I. SUgQortjye HppsiDl for the fJdsrly' Needs and RCSQUrc.;s:
f!drr17 HMJCQWDm' 5011 of very low income owners "'<rpay f<x hOOsing. The Sccior
Coordinating COUld', .bar<d hOOsing program is one way ;0 meet ibis n:ed, but !bey "'PO<' •
lack of pcISODS _ 1IIish '" ,bare or relll from lUI elderly "wocr.
EkWlY Remers: ApproxIma:ely 5611 0( ail .kltr!y nnt<rs have. housing problem, almost
exclusively overpaying. Of !he elderly remer bouseholds .. itb inoom<s between 3! -5()". 86% ... e
overpaying. Even the moderate income elderly renters. are cve.rpa..}'L"1g a.t .. rate -of 76 i£ .
FurtIler Dee<! for rental assistan;e for elderly households is dcmonst:-ated by !he 156 elderly lI!II!Ior
", .. b!cd bousehoIds that are on !be County Housing Autborily's Section 8 w.iting list. The
Section 8 wailing list is llO'" closed. Most 0( tbewaiting IisIs $oc sub<i<fJZed elderly housing
"","Iopmenu or-. also closed. Those tbat arc opea are ope. only Ie persons who quaflfy for •
fc:dt:ra1 piefe:teillCe me! eves: lben the wait foe I unit is five: to sevca years long. These situations _ me !'even: Dee<! for mon: rental assisuncc II!II! new constrUCtion 0( sub<i"ized rental
housing f<x ;be dderly_
R<sowces cuaen!iy av>ilat«: in 1".010 Alto f<lr elderly households .... identified below.
INDEPENDENT LIVING (1110 Meals or Other Senic:es)
1) Palo Alto Gardens 128 units Very Low Income 0!lIy
2) Sheridan Apartmenls 57 units Lo,,· Income
3)Terman~_ 24 u..Lits Very Low Income Only
4}WebsterWood " onits L",.1ncome
S) Arastta<lero Park 13 units Low Income
6) Colorado Part 8 units Lo",1ncome
7
~ "-. -..
"'.'.
-~ -it. . -.-. -' .• -"
" ,.-.
--->-..'.
~ « .. ~:Jf.:.>_-"'+ 0; +. ".'
Elds!ID& Sapportlwe BoosIq For the Elclerly:
INDEPENDENT LIVING (Wlih Some Meals Provided)
1) SIevenioIIliouse 128 I1IliI$ Lowe, Income Ool)r
2) Lyuon I ODd D
3)LyuonN Sll1llits Lower Income Only
Palo Alto bas. higher pe=nl>ge of <>Ider senk>rs IIlan !be nation IS • wbolo. 20% of the senior
P'1'''t.OOn is 80 or Ib<M: COIIIpOI<d 10 12 ~ natioowidc. Based on natiooal iocidon<e A~, _
2,000 of Palo Aha', elderly have. signilkanl limitation which affects !beir !>Oed for S'.!ppOItive
services ,.be~ they live IS follows:
• 1,000 EIcler!y _ • Assisled Daily living" (belp with balhing, feeding. OIC.)
• 950 Eld<rly need substantial help performhg several activities of dAily w,ing or _ 24
Hour an: or skilled IlUJ'S1ng care
Oider senk>rs . .,.. more like!} III Deed lSSisIed Jiving or llIlrSing C8n'. otdcr senk>rs ~ aIso more
likely to have lower incomes. 31% of Palo Alto's seniors 15 or older have extremely low
in<:omeo (bcIow $15,000 per year). Abool14" of senk>rs berweeD 65 and 74 bave inoomcs below
$15,000.
Evea _living in suboicliud bousing may have Ii>oir bousing DCCd5 cbacg. as they age. The
Lytton complex is 1he on!} development in Palo Alto wbicI! provides • fuD range of living optioos
fer low iDcoru< ",niors from independenIliving I<> assisled living 10 slullcd DllI"Sing care.
1'bcn: is • need 10 provide mon: affordabk renIaI hoosing fer frail seniors and to provide
suf!icioDI in-bome "",ices 10 1he frail elderfy woo "'ani 10 remain in !beir own homes ""
apartmeDIS.
B
~ -. ~'-, -"-
;:-'.. .
.',(~,:, :~
,
EsIsdDi HoasInr r .... Frall Elderly:
RESIDENTIAL CARE FACILfTIFS
Name T_ NOJ>-L<rtr In<omeI
Units Ambulatory Subsidized
NONPROFIT
1) CbaJmine House' 254 "SO NOlle
2) Webster House" 37 NODe None
3) 4'ttoo n SO ? SO
FOR-PROFIT
~J Paio Alto Commons ISO ('1) 110 2·'
6) Casa Olga ? 1 NODe
PRIVATE BOARD &. CARE HOllIES
7) Pleasanl Manor 6 Noo< ?
8) Ro5edaIe Manor 8 4 ?
9) Lucm!a Home 6 None ?
10} May Can: S None ,
11) Sweet Rome 6 None ~
• Life Can: Contract Homes
•• Paio IJto Commons UJca] Sub<id)r. Pursiwlt 10 1IIe CiIy'. 'Bclow Market Rolltall'rogr2m',
the deveJoper of Palo IJto Commons ..... required 10 establish. fond from ""bkll !l>e inttrest
...rnings wcuJd be usOO 10 suI>sidizcd 1IIe mJts 00 unllS 10 k'vels alIOrdable by boaseholds within
HUJD's1<>w iDoome limit. Since !be _ genorat<d is curm:tJy only en<JUgkJ subskf.u: tile
IeIII on two units II $SOO per IIIOIlIh. tile Palo Aho Housing Corporation bas recommended !hat
tile program be pbas<:d out as !l>e subsidized tenants lene !be compleL
Skilled NuniDI Fadlities roc the Elderly:
Lytton Ganle!ls ill: 128 unilS (aboulSO% of1lle beds ..... occupied by low income elderly lSSisted
Il!lder Med"1CaI or Med"1ClUe}.
9
·-., ~~""""";,;,:,;,;;",;,,;,,,-,,,·,",,'-c.L<·'.,-'O~;'--"_"'--L-f.c..c..2c.c •. :,z;;~i2
The chart beloW ideotifia; !be curm>I need !hat b2s bee" idclllificd foc !be elderly m:I fniI elderly
households in Palo Alto.
NEED FOR SUPPOltTIVE HOUSING FOR \'FRY WW INCOME
ELDERJ.Y" FRAIL ELDERLY HOUSEHOLDS
ToIa! Need 'lOVery Groot Existing Estimate of
LoY Need Uaits Uamet
lDa>me' Need
_ UviDa 1.000 31S )10 84' 226 ....
J.IS m 60' m ....
-31'; of all .lderiy bousebclds (owner and ~nter) are very 10 .... income
• -Assisted Iiying uniIs lOr very low L'lCOIDe "'ere estlmal<d to ilx:1ude Ihree units at Pol" Abo
Commoos; 31 beds in n:sideDtW ~ homes, and SO residential care units al LytIO!l n.
24-Hour C .... UIliI.' are about 60 beds at LyUOll Gardens llL
~ _liOD is not available .bou1 single (noo-elderiy) pen<l'" '0100 live aIooe and singles
wile; cboose 10 nve willi otber adults such as !lIlI1Ia1'ried couples. The "&II other bouseholds"
caIeg<X)' in Table lie (see Appendix) is SO~ of an renlCrS. IIl!miDl prnItIrrn< ('flain a1mosl
"""'b QYtQI'Yinr) m 'DOC' wjdr:sprr,ad in this &lunD than jn BUY QfM renter po,pplatloo
UDIFP .tIt" lmr 'nd ,m lmr 'DCflII)£: -qQyr" rent"' haye brepjop prohkmSe The
~ge willi problems is spread evenly betWeCI1 extremely low. very 10 .. and low iDc<>me
caltgOries.
Unless !hey are disabled or elderly, 1he Section 8 progr.u1l does not generally serve single persons.
Also, Polo Ah<>'. SIOCl of oub<idized housing mostly serves elderly and Wnilies. The 10,.
IDcome, siDaIe acfuIt popnIotjoo ........ 10 be aD llIHIersened group .. _ primary need is
aIIor<1ab\e small nma\ units. SlI3t<:gies which invclve 111: ... ccnstrUction, aequisition oc O<ber
IlSC of Ibe eiJSIing housing SIOClt are needed. ..\pproprlaJe housing c()U]d include SROs. shared
group nYing in single WniIy _. second units. malCbes wilh elderly home<)""""" and small
oportmems.
10
. '.'.
,'" ':
-'.
I
_:.
'.
Appro.-Jy 1.940 perscns ages 16-64 in Pale Alto have. lflS<1bility wIDell affects mcl>ili:y or
..,lf~ occonfmg.., the 1990 Census. Of these. t.700 hive I disability "hich m= thrir
abiliIy 10 wod:. lnformatiOD is net avallabl< 11KM the type ofboosebold they 6v. in. their income
1e.el 0< how their disability offeCu 1beir housing needs. GeD<ralIy. persons ",iilI atSabili'.ies ""v.
10wer iDcoIries espociaIIy it Ibcir disability limits their abilily '" woci:. For pen;ons with physical
disal>ililies. occessibk housing is aitical '" their ability '" liv. ~iIdenIly. For persons who
lire net oble '" drive (or canJ1C( affooI '" own • car). hoUsinB must not oo!y be accessible. but also
Iocaled cooveniently 10 shopping ODd public transporUlion.
Tho SoniJ. Clara Coonty Health Departm""f. Menial Health Senic.es ~ll Center reports :l\aI
434 UDduplicated persons ,it!! severe menl3l iIlD<ss were served at the North Cocmy Ment>I
Heallh Center (Iocaled in Palo Alto) during FY 92·9l. Of the 6.967 persons bospitalized for
mental illness '" Coonty raci!ities during the year, 55" (382 persoos) ",ere eitber bomeless prio<
to admissioo or,.ere Eving in. temporaI)' arnngemem. Fllf ano<her 10.3" (or 721 persons)
tbeir prt,ious housing situation was roported as unl<nown.
A 1988 Santa Clara County plan idcmitied • Cocn<yWide D<ed {or 2.700 pennallCnt, affordable
rmtal units for mmtaIly iI1 pet'SOI'1S ... ho-were either homeless or in overly restr'ictive «
iDIdcquatc board ODd care bomcs. This hoUsing should be affordabk by extremely low income
persons (O-30:c. of mediaD) since • mentally If""bled person on SSl receives an income of $1,680
per year or 19% 0( median income. Sapportive services are very critical'" the menta"y ill.
Differelli types of housinB is nocasary inciud'mg lr1lDSitional and permanen< housing. SRO's, ,
_ housing ODd apartments.
EsisIin& Supportive HousiDg for Persons with Se ..... !IIentallllDess: .
MiramoIIre MeDlBl Health Services. Inc. provides tteatmet>t, support and rehabilitatiOD services
f<lc persons who bave beeD affc:csed by serious psyChiatric disabilitie.. A!tbough tbeir programs
and _ off"" are based in Palo Alto, their service area covers oor<lle .. Santa Clara
0m1ty. They opetlIte • licensed voop bome in Palo Alto. Through 1beir 'Community ADianc<'
program. Mmunoute also provides _bk. permllnelll housing f<lc obout 75 individuals m
shared living .itwltions in 1~ prope!ties whiclt they OWll or lea .. elocated m Palo Alto. Mountain V_. Sunnyvale allCI SaD!ll Clara.
AdoIoscent C<omseling Servi;es, IDe. operau:s I residential program f<lc teenage youth .. it!! severe
mental or emo6ooaI problems.
II
; :"
UCENSED GROUP HOMES (With ClD-Site Care)
Name No. Served
J2
6
Adults
Youth
(12-17)
Mir>rDOOte
PALO AL TOo INDEPENDENT SHARED LIVING
Name No, Served Clients
Waverley _ 8 Adults
Fcrnaudo St. House 5 Adult Veterans
Morprita St. House 6 AdultV.rerans
M'lddIelield Road 6 Adults
!to SDavlivc HotWna for persons wil' DeycJoppx;ntaT
Qisalv'jtjq." Nm!s and Res.ourccs
Sponsor
Mirunonte
Rehabilitation
Housing Associlotes
RebabilitJItioo
Housing Associates
M'nmonte
N=l b: ~ Living with Services: The San AIwlreas Regional ~nter idemified I IOtJIl
of 815 of Ihoir cflelll5 who .... borderline 10 mIldly retarded ancI could benefit from an
independent fiv ing setting. Of the 1Otal, 68 would Deed I wheelchair lICCC!.Sible unit. A recently
C<JDStnJCted mID funded reOlal developmetJ! in BeImoCl received o,.r 80 applicatiocs very
quick/)I and the 24 units were easily rented. k is expc:c!ed that there would be or least that much
demaD<I for an Iffordabk: renul project in Polo AIID.
There are .cry Iimiled opportunities b: persons with developmental di.aMities to 6ve ;" Palo
Aho 0Iber than living with !beir OWll filIIlllies. ¥ooth ancI aduhs who caJUiOl live with !beir
fmillies and Deed the care ancI supervision of • group home must generaDy be ~ in other
parts of the County _ CIl)' CDOO funds have bee .. used in previous years 10 assist the "Moving
On" group home ancI the PeW. Ave. Apts in Mountain Vx:w (acquisition in 1986)_ Progr.uru;
~. .
wIliclo place ~1opm<l!f3!1y dIsabled adul", in indepe!>kDl living utiliu housing in other cities
due 10 !he blgJI 0051 0( rentili in Palo Alto.
LJCENSED GROUP HOMES FOR DEVELOPMENTALLY DISABLED
Name No,Sernd Clients Sponsor
'Moving On'. Palo Alto 5 Youth Peninsula Chi!drens'
(12-18) ~ruer
Strausser Home, 2 MWu Pri:V'l'te
Palo Alto
Pettis A ... Apu., 14(m Aault Women Private.
Mt. V",.". S aponmenIS) Nonprofit
~. <irQQp Home$. b Qsm:~menfany Pisi'h1q;I· Nr,eds and RewYrctS
A numerical estimate N this oetd is l\()( available, but according 10 !he San Andreas Regiooai
eem.s, persons wl>o oetd • group borne setting are usually placed in It", sou!hera part of Sanla
C..,. Coonry siD;:e there is my little available in Palo Alto. Elcellent servi<:es are I\'ailabl£ for
Illis poputatlcn in Palo Alto, bot Ihe housing is not. so Ihe. clients must ~ tnnspo<t<d oortI! '"
receive services. Community AssociatiM for RebabilItatlcn (CAR,) in 1994 reponed that Ihey
receive an average ol twa .contacts per month f.-om persons seeking group res:ider.tiaf serv'iccs or
boosing for • family member with developmentll! DISabilities.
There "'" no resideIllial deve1opm<nts will!in Paio Alto whkll provide independent Jiving
opponunities qetber with o",sUe supportIve servi<:es for adults with deveJopmellLal disabilities.
bo Sunnyvale, at 121S CorItz Drive, Greater OPPortunities for !he Developmentally Disabled
nperatcs an independelll t'Virlgllraining center in I six cnit IJl"'1ID"1Il builDmg for adults with
deve\oprncnla1lf",bilities. Palo Aho CDOO fun<ls were provided in 1988 IC help acquire and
rehabilitate !he facility.
d. Sqpportive Bousine for ptrr.on:s with Pby:;icaT
Diybj'litjes· NmJs and R'WIlTCeS
In November, 1994, !he Housing Autbority of Santa Clara County reported !bat there were 156
ekledyldisobled persons on !heir ,.aiting list for housing flam Palo Alto. It is llIlt knc1lOl 11010'
many bave physical disabilities. The 1990 Con=;, p",vldes !he fi:lIlowiDg !1UIIlbers of persons
Hi Palo Alto ",j!h 'mobility cr self~are Jimjlations' ",,110 are no< living in institutions:
13
" ..
PERSONS "11'8 MOBILl1Y OR SELF.cARE LIMITA TJONS
Age 16 -64 years
No Work
DisaI!ilItles
239
212 pmoos
WOWork
DIsability
1.101
t.86S
It is DO( possible 10 estimale bow many 0( Iheso poop" may need specialized housing ,.!tb services
0< occessible !loosing. but some portion 0( them would have inadequate housing at this time ()f
in 1be fUlme.
Sl'PPORTJ\'E B()l,'SING FOR PERSOIIo'S WITH PHYSICAL DISABlLITIES
1n4e (l'Io Services Provided}
Name 110'0. UDits
WcbottrWood 4 units I BR Lo", Income
1
Tberc ~ no bousing developments specificaDy dcsignod aod built 10 provide SUJ>PO<tive !loosing
lOr """"'" with pbysical disabililies. Some projects for seniors will accept cli&abled pmoos for
some ol their units, but it is unlikely Iha.t IIr units meet current _ ol accessibility
(Americans WlIh Disabililies Aa). Genorally 1besc units wauld merely be ground Iloo< (OIl<
bedroom or studio) aportmeI>t> "ithcut stairs. These projects include: Arastradero ParI<. Apts.,
eokl<lldo Part. Apls .• Lytton I '" n, Palo Alto Gardens. Sheridan Apls .• Terman .... pts.
14
,,',' .
Sl;l'PORTIYE HOUSING FOR PERSONS WITH ALCOHOL
OR OTHER DRUG ADDICTIONS
N ..... c.
Vernon T~, Paio Alto
: ~ .
K<nneth Drive, Palo Alto 3-12 persons
.A<cDrU1r4! 10 a report 011 trends in Santa aa.-a Counly l'ybrlShed by the Counly in December 0(
1994. i is genr:ra!ly _Ii:<! !hat between 4,00;) and IO,OOJ peos;1e Jo.a.< HlV bfection in Santa
Clara CounIy. Since 1983, wbeD AIDS = wore ftrSl re.::ordM. 2,059 pe<>ple have developed
AIDS, ...wting in I ,2;~ dc;oll-oS in Sana Oar> O:'llnly,
'fbc:R are currenily no existmg boosing projects spedf><aDy designed for persons "'ilh H!V
diseose or persons with AIDS in Palo Alto, The A.IUS Project, • provide, 0( OO\Lcffig and support
services for penoos with AIDS, iDdir..ated !hat Ihey malotain • waiting IisIlhal ave"'ges one year
or more. Additionally. 1I><y aiJUcipate ~ needs fo< affordable housing for longer periods
of tlme as individu>Is live longer with HIV and AIDS.
During 19%'9S 11>< State O(Dlifornia awarded $425,016 in Housing Opportunities ".,. P>moos
willi Aids (HOPW A) funds to • loCal AIDSIHIV Care C.oosortia. Agencies represented by 11><
Ioc&I coowrtium iDclucle CounIy Social Services, AIDS Legal Servkes, ESQ, AACI., VISiting
Nunes Associ.don, ARIS, Ernerg.,.,,. Housing Coosortfum, and oO!en. The funds wen:
p!'O\ided to age..,,,, providing CcunIy1Joide OOusing-fl:la<ed and supportive services to 11>< target
populatioo.
In 11>< 1995/96 year. 11>< City 0( San Jose bas been de,ignated by HUD IS an entitlement Cily 10
recer,oe $601,000 in HOPW A funds. In =epIlng the HOPW A cn!ltlernent, the Cily 0( San Jose
is ~"ed 10 .... !be fuD<!s in ways which address !he CoImIywide boosing and .... ppon service
.. -.15 0( Iow·income individuals with HIV or AIDS, and in consuha600 with othcr loCal
governmenlal entities in Ib:: County, The Cily 0( Paio Alto inreDds to wlTaborate with !he Cily
0( San Jose and 1be O'lla Coun!y jurisdictions in ~g • process for expendinm: 0( 1be
funds on • CQWJIyWicIe basis.
,. Single Parent Households
About Oilt qua.'1<:r 0( 1be families with children in Palo Alto an: beaded by single parents. There
arc 1,014 single poreD! flllDilies with children nnder 18 and 900 single parents!lving with !heir
15
i
': ,"
chiIdJu UI and over, Tho iDcomeo o(single pareD! families (especWly fcmzkbe<>ded families)
an muck Jeos th.m !be iD::omes 0( married couple families with thildrea.
MEAN INCOME OF DIFFERENT FAMILY 1YHS
WITH CHILDREN lJ'NDER 18 YEARS OF AGE
Mmie<lCoupleF $HII,537
Mal.: IkacI 0( HouoeI!old Family $49.193
Female Heaof ol Hoosebold Family $36.651
WJlbout affordable boosing mel supportive s=1ces. many single pamlI households an II high
risk 0( bocorr.inI homeless, Single parent families are Ille fastest growing scgmcnl 0( Ibe
homeless population. 1Iccording,,!be '1993 Santa Oara COOllIJI Children', Rcpon Card'. 52%
0( homeless families in Ille Ccunly we,. beaded by single p;rrel!ts,
7. HouseboIds O .... payiDa ror Housing ("CGst B .... deDecI·')
Overpaying is Ibe priIl:iple problem 0( an very low. low and moderate income housebolds. bo!h
teDIcn and owuen, For retlJtn. bowev .... the problem is more 1IC\o1e, Tho 1990 U.S. Qnsus
dala show !bat more !ban half 0( an re= in Pal<> AlIa pay more !ban 30')1 0( their _ for
housing (aIsotnowD IS ·rostbw<kned"). HowCV<:r. oncloserexaminatioo,!his same census data
show 1IIat Iowa income """'" _Ids an: even mon: severely impacted. Approtimalely 71"
ol an Iowa iDcome renter bow<:bolds are ro5l bunlencd in Palo Aho.
The DCX1 level ol analysis is Ie eumlne _ remer bouseholds who are • ... erely cost
I!urdeaed;' !bat is, they ~ paying mo<e !ban SO" 0(_ iJx<m,e for housing. 1990 Cemus data
for an Iowa income remer households iI><Ik:ote lila! 46" 0( thes<: booseholds are severely cost
burdened. However. in reviewing data for very low and eX!n:mely low income bousebclds
(booseho!ds with incomes nnder SO" of media!! income), the problem is evea more acute.
Appro>lma!cly 55" ol these very "",. and extn:mely low income bouscboIds pay more !ban SO"
ol their income for housing.
Data for low ml moderate income homeo""""" in.f1Cale !bat cost burdca is I problem for very
low and extn:mely low income Ilomeownen and 10 • lesser degree for low and mode ... te income
""""",,,,,,,,,,,, Approximately 35" 0( an very low. low and moderate _ hc>meownors are
cost burdoood, Rowcver. 57" 0( extremeJy low income and 32" o(.ery low income bouseboIds
pay more dian 30" 0( _ income for housing. Only 23% olan moderate income homeowners
are cost burdened.
16
. '--
.. ~-,
-.. ,
---.
ID suD:u:nary. there are more raolCr bouscbok1s than homeowner households "'-00 are CCSi.
burclenod. E$pOCially <O<t bunlellOlf are eltrfmely lew, very low and lower income renter
Ilouseholds.
Overcrowding .. not as serious • t<rusing problem in No Alto as iI .. in s.m. ctua County IS
... !>ole or IS it .. in neart>, em.. suc~ IS MOIIotain V"' ... or Redwood Co,. Ov.r<:rowdIng is
primarily • problem 0: vcry lew and 10"" income large family renters as s1lo ...... below. Only
4 .3~ 01 .n reaten .... oven:rowded In Palo Alto toolpare<l to 17.1 'Ii in the Coon!y as I
wboIe. MOUIlIain V_ has. 11.6" ovenoll rlile and San Jose is the higbest with an overall ~
cf 23.8".
INCIDENCE OF OVERCROWDING
ALL RENTER A LARGE fAMILY RENTERS BY INCOME GROllI'
PALO ALTO
ToCal t-30% 31,50% 51~7'lL AlI_. 0" •. 3% 7.9% 9.2%
Large Families 48.6S . 48.0% 66.1 " 78.2%
9. Sch<IanclJlrd Housing
Palo ."00', boosing stock is generally In very good coDCfttioo even Ihough the Ci!:y has • high
proponioo (18.S") of <>kJer {pre-1940l stoc1< ~ompared 10 other suburba. cities. This is due 10
the bigh n!lJe of the bousing for both sak and rent. Due 10 .. ....,., notal structures {i.e. lG
years ow more in age) need upgrading and majo< malnteu.rx:e ..-typically Wits SIO,OOO-
15,000 per tmIt, but o ...... ..u: the pbysicaI CODdiIioD or bollSing is _ • problem in Palo Alto,
Co HOMELESS NEEDS
Santa aar. County', homeless ~tio. rel\ects the diverse urban, suburban, and ,ural areas
cf the Coun!y. The llrban bom<less are the mc-...t visible of the homeless population. Eighty
perce'" of the urban homeless are si!lJ!lc males, and they arc the =jo< users of the eme'geDe)'
wiDb:r sbeber 5)'stm1 in the COW>!y. Unlike the u.<ban bomeless, the County's ",burb .. and ruJ1!l
p!>pUlmon< are IIlOI'e diffi..'llIt 10 <mUDen!A: and do flO( congregate in any large !UlIlIDe". They
.,:, the invisible bomeless. As many as 150 10 200 homeless individuals have been identified as
amping along the IlWIl<FOUS creeks Ill>! netwod: the County. ,'>dditionally. many more bomeless
11
. -.
," .
'. . .
---------'-~ -'----_. ----,---'-.-
,. -. -.--" . ".'
-. \. " -
individuals and furulies may be found camping in parb, living in I!leir CIU"S O£ rccrcatlonal
veWcles. moving from location 1<l location.
n.er. is DC> a=pIed med><xI for 'aIlocaIlns'!be estiJr.a"'" O{1be number O(!lo!ncless to individual
<:itios Whin !be County. Due ID 1110 nnsiOOl)' natwe 0( hM>des ....... it c.anool be descrol>ed will>
III)' moaning ro:epl 00 III kast I Countywi6e basis. From 1110 penpectiv~ 0( • cOt)' like Palo AIID,
whlclI. is _ aJcng !be _ betw= two ccun:ies, homeless"... really sbollld be studied
from I su1>-~ p"~. Wb2!c'"Cl!be exact number 0( homeless adults, youth and
funllies, it is clear that existing programs and facilities do not mee< !be oerviu, sbtller and
IIo;;Ising ooeds 0( 1110 !oc>I bomeles5 populatiorL
1. TotII NIlIDher 0( Homeless Persoos
TbcR is II(! reliable infO£I!l3tion reganling !he exact 1lUaIbc, 0( homeless persoos either in Palo
Al;o 0< ill SantI Clara County is I wbDlc. TIlt .""". 0( I>:Jmelessness = only be estimated by
,....;n.mg <latl. collected from "orious """""'. <>< compiled b) V>rious s"'·"Y5. The January,
1995 5Ul'Ie)' COIlIlucte4 by the _ Clara Coonty Hamelcos Coordinator', Offiu. and !lescril>ed
belo .... tep<""'" !be most curren! infonr .. !ion available for sbelrered and Dnsbellered homeless
in the CoonIy. 1,011 petSOn5 =pooded 10 !be suney representing 1,476 individuals (mclUding
respondents partners and chiJdren). Of the 1.476 surveyed, 928 ",ere in ,btlters, 327 in
!nlISitioo&l housing. and 221 were unsbtltered.
The ..",ple .."..,ey tOUnIed a largo percenlage, 001 001 all, 0( 1he homeless people estimated 1<l
bt living in the COUDty. Based on !be nwnI>er of slltlter and tr.nsiriooal beds • vallable in the
CounIy. tbe I2SS sbeltered 5UrVeJ resp<>o<kms represented 62 ~ o(!be IOta! slltltered homeless
popcls.tion II I givee point in lime. Based 00 slltl'.er bed availability. and !be nwnI>er 0( IUIU
'Ways at !be lime 0( !be AITV:Y. the 1llIID!Jer 0( !he unsbellere1 homeless ~a!ion wilbin the
County ..... eslimRt<d 10 be 1700. A. roo.ogIo esIImate o(!he toUI aumhes" of homo;ess penoas
II a po ... poiDl in time (tile ...... eyl aJUld be eJ<trapoIafed I>y adding the lola! ,beltered and
u.nsbeItered cs!imates (1700 plusllll4), or 3m.
Fw1!ler, by nsicg • !ormul. to caleulatc turnover caICS in sbelrers, iI is estimaIed lhal tbere are
approximately 7,500 peopk who e><pcrience I!l episode 0( lIomelessuess during • given y<.ar. By
oMJDg in approximalel)f 8,800 'Aid for Families 1lIi!h Dependenl ChiIdn:." (AFDCJ recipients
who requestcd homeless assistance in 1994, it is esrimaled that tber-e .... U,300 people who
experieoced ... episode of __ , durin2 • giv ... f""". "shoold be emp!!.asiud !bat 10
II>l!l< I IIlO!:e precise delenninarion of the nwnI>er 0( homeles5 people in the County, further
izIve5tigatioo is I<qUired. inclUding follow-up survey> and an analysis 0( <lata provided by shelter
operators.
~ tbe Palo AIIo samp1c represented 4.2 ~ o(!he IOtal sur.ey population (see below), it rou1d
lie <O!imaIed lhallhen .... approximately 156 p.~ Alto 110m ..... III aD, given poinlln time,
ancIlhat 685 persom from Palo Alto .m expel ieoa! "" epi,<Ode of lHxneIesSDess "" .... year's
lime.
-"'.
/ ..
~ " , .
''lo, -, •
/ • <-"' ••
. '
.. --, .-~
.~;;o. -:" ,,' .
. --. :-.-
:1 hmllt)' 1295 Sam Can Cnunty Hpmclcss Survey
]a lamary. tm 1110 Sam. C1ara Coonty Homeless eoonrmator', Office undcrtoot • ~.ic
survey 0{ Ibo slate 0( homekss.... in Santa Oara Cooni)'. The survey <OfISisted 0( •
qolCSOOm>o1re dlIII ...... odministmd 10 a W11'1e o{!he bomekss population in Sa!Itt 0., .. CoonIy.
UnIiU • ccasus wbic!I = !he entire populatioo in • group, • sample survey attempts 10 reael.
only I subset (sample) o{!he population. The surve;< in!ervi<:w process consisted 0( two parts:
• OIHilt ~. ",iIlI indivlduals I!OI currently in • sbelter, but 11 various publi<: meet
Iocatiolls throagboullhe Counly. Street sitts wen: sclec!ed from locations pro>ided by
1O''I:I1DIl<1lI agone;" end outreach organizatiooo.
• OIHitc in!eniews 'WillI iniividuols currently at .n 0( the emergeocy shelters. youth
outreacIl centers, lId transitiooal housing facilities.
The survey qrxstiotm'liro .... developed in collaboration with go".rome'" and bcmekss .belter
represectativ... IndividcaIs participated in 11-.. survey on a voluntary basis. and an information
COIlIainec! in !he survey ..... self-disclose<l.
The major findings 0( the survey are:
• The IeDgtIo of time in """'eles", ... appears'" be incrusing. Over 41 ~ of n:.pondents
reported being homeless iJ£ man: than one year, an increase of 40~ from an ''''lie< report.
• Tbe """""" of chIIdrea wbn ~ bomeless oomprisecl13-' of the lola! sample count. ()(
!he IOIaIIlIlDlber of bcmeless c:hiId. .. a, 64~ were under !be age 0( 12.
• Tbe IIUIIIber of working bu ...... , lias more _ cIoubIecl from 12% identlfied in !he 1989
repoi1lo lS'iI\ in 1995.
• Meatal iDDess lin" subslaooe .1. ... ore problem! thai cootinue In be I significan! facto<
b: !he Coumy's bomeless population.
• The Couoty's bomcless populatioo cootinues to be well-cduc:aled. 53 ~ graduated from
higIl school or had II 1easI some conege coorses; 7" WOR wlIege graduates, aDd 2" !>ad
"""' graduate training.
• 82" of !he Cowily" bomekss population sUIe that !heir iDcome is well below the Datioo.aI
~Jevel.
]a Palo Aho, !he survey in!er.iews were cooduc1ed at !he roIlIting churck shelter program
<lpCl3led by !he umm MinislI)l. as weD as the droirin ceoter. ()(!he 1.476 persoos represented
ill !be survey Countywide. 62 or 4.2~ .... ", from Palo .oJ!o. The Palo Alto sites surveye4
included !he lTri>an Ministry's rotating chlrn:ll shelter p.-ogram and !he drop-in center. 46
19
.--._. • ,0
'.',
.c:spot>!CllIS porticipatcd in !be 5UC\'C)' ~ 62 fC""'os (~lucfmg child=! and pannors).
The SOlIVe1 !WisrlcaI results for Ibe entire Coonly and for !be City 0( Palo Aho are in<:1uded in
appen<fiI H.
III 1uDo, I99J, !be Urban M"misiry perl"onned a ooe night count of h<:>meleso inlfuiduals and
Wnilics seddDg shcl1o:r and _ "",,icn. This survey ",-a:; de$crlbed in dle 1991-1996 CHAS,
but is IIWIlIIIIril<d bore since ills Ibe ooIy local survey mat 11 Iea5l somowba! meets HUD's
SIaD<!azds.
JUNE 1991 HOMELESS COL'NT IN PALO _Y. TO
Total
Families 20 10 Ie>
No. of persons 10 families so 2S 25
Single Adults 70
• Note: Number. arequored IS sboWll in 1991-!996 CHAS, original data wu OOIIVailabk:
for this repon.
3.. Current NiDD ...... of Homeless Persom Sund
EmergeDC)l HoosiJJg Consortium repor.s mat tboir 1,2.;0 bed sbeltct system boused more Iban
$,844 nndlWfqu;d bomeleso adults during FY 9>-94 in Santa Clan County. AMJIionaJly, 133
WldupIk:aJed hcmcless and runa,..., ycud! ender tbo age of 18 we,. assisted by the Youth
Outreacll Program al !be youlll drop in «mer in San ~. Of the adult populaticD. served, 63
reported Palo Alto as !heir last resider ... oc signif>=ll address. The number of. WIdup!ica!.e4
bomeIeso adults served by Emergency Housing Comortium decreased olmos! 2S percenl from !be
JlIIlDber sm<ed !be pre'Iious year. The Ieduc600 was due 10 • decrease in !be number of days the
roId w",,!bet shelter operated in 93-94, and tile change in use of !be San Martin Family Living
Cen!r:r from tompor:ary shcl1<r 10 lraDSitiooaI bousing. The Urban Ministry of. Palo Aho provided
sbeIter for 187l1l!dljp!ic1ted single, aduI! bomc:Iess penons in their 15 bed rotaling chun:h sbel1<r
program in Palo Aho during FY 93-94.
Urf:Qn M"1lIistry serves • large number of 'WlSbelteied' bomeleso persons '" Ibeir morning ~in
""Iller. They pro.,jded 4,262 lIII!llu>l~ individuals with some type of etIlI!rgency assistance
during FY 93-94. ApprorimaleJoj 22,000 bot meals were coordinated in locations IllrooghouI Palo
. Alto. and 2,755 llDduplicated clieDlS were provided with 1,000 sacks of emergency groceries
20
,-.' ~-. <-'.
through !be Food Closet. 0Iher servica prooMed ilr-lUded counseling. job labor rcfem.!.
transpcif1atioD (bas passes). lI'I'1icatioc prcparaOOo ... ~. and mail and te\epbooo servir..es.
Approximatdy 100 IDCIIIaIly or pby;icoD-J disabled ctienD receiv<:d inIe.lsi •• roorry manageme'"
IDII/or cose managemeOl servic<:s. On. dail) blsis. !be drop-in center is visited by 80 10 120
peI'llO<l>.
Silu Ibo lJrt>m Ministry', cIrop-iD ce= is ~ • sbort wall: from !be San Mateo Coumy line
and ac!i1CC!ll to. major imer-Counly lr2nsit t.erminal. iI is =sooable '" assume ibat some of Iboir
cr_ bow coonoctioos with ocber .....",y <:O!IIIDIlCiIie. Some of Iboir clienls ~ utilize
!be winter shell« at cid>eI Ibo Su""}"IaIe or San M.a~ armories and Ilrus may be coonted in Ibo
UI!!J8! S<rVk:o: coon:s by _ ageo:ies. Od>er ctienD with some Iimlted income are able '" live
in • re.ideDrial betel b part of IIIe momh and tileD retunI 10 tt.e streets "·heD (heir IDOII!tJy
income is d<p!el.ed. However. if is very IiUIy Ibai IlllIII)I of !he uroan M'misIry'. 4.162 clients
II< InIIy "umhehered" ,i=!be drop-in collier is Jocated clo<e '" areas ... here!he homeless are
tnowD 10 camp.
The Cow:.<y's 1m """oy reponed !he KltklWing statistics al.ou1 tbe Polo Alto and CoonIywide
homeless populations:
1995 _ San": Stalisdc:s
hlo AiIo Countywide
Gmder:
Mak B2~ 70~
Female 13~ 30%
EIbnic:ity:
Caucasian 26~ 36~
African-American 57~ 19%
~!SpIIllc 13~ 25";
American Indian 0 S%
Other 4% 11%
21
1'. "'. . ;:.' ,
The 1m C<lUn!y Homeless Survey provides "'""" data abouIlhe sub-popuIatio!l$ of Ihe homeless,
but may be somewhat skewed .moe III Ihe 5latistic. repre5enI information which ,.as self
disclosed. The sur;ey iDiIkates IIW II'"' of ibe lIomoless population has some IypC of severe
metlI3I i!Inoss, 34 S; have IIcOOoI or druj abuse problems, 8:l IT< have boIh severe mental i!Inoss
and drugllIcOOoI abuse probIeJn$. ISS; are victlms of domestic rlolenc<. aDd 1 S; have AIDS or
relolec1 diseases. See Table I.
The umm Ministl)' reports !hey lu.ve ..... &.II in:reaso in !be IIlllIlber ollocal homeless persons
~ith syrilptoms ol seveR mcntaI ilIn<ss as ,.ell os I!l Increase in dIems woo are disabled by
_ i1lDoss. but IlOl psycbotic.
7. Needs of Persons Tbieatened with Homel~!iSDeS5
Tbe.. .. is • very iar]!e iIlI:ideIl!% ol ovOtpiying among 10 ... income bouscoolds boIh in Palo Aho
aDd in S.,O Clara Coomy as. wbole. Low income pen..'DS '''00 already pay more LIJan;o$ or
SO,", of lheir income for bousing are Ol ris1l: ol """"'1esSllO:ss Ol all limes. MAny hoo.sebolds must
regularly rely on emergency food. hot meal p<ograms and clo!hi.ng programs 10 continue 10 pay
!heir relll. Emergency assistance P£Oviders cootinually e><hau..q !heir funds for rcnt3l 1!lO'O-in
tiSlstara aDd emergency rent funds. There is • need for • steady and expanded source of fmdlng
for these programs.
In IIghI of !he fact 1hat!he 1995 CoonIy Homeless Coordinator', survey identified 6.328 clnldreB
in !he AFDC families applying for homeless assistance in 1m. it is impo<tanIto DOll: !hal
_ clli1d c:aze scrvlces 1m also • crltlcal Deed. Affordable child care provides !he parent
'widJ Ihe time 10 pur.rue employment cppor1uDi1ie5 and P£Ovides • safe environment for Ihe clllid
cIurin!! tile rurmoil whick families suffer as • result of die. homelessness. Onld care subsIciIeS
1m esseuiall<> Ibese fmliIics silll:e die IIIOIlII1Iy fees for fun time child can: in Palo Aho can fI!lge
from approximall:1y 5290 for grades 1-5 to $950 for infanlTlodd1er care.
B, IBvemory of Facilities and Services to AsRsIIhe Homeless and Persoos Threat..,.., vitIo
Hom ~ smess
The Palo Aho Urt>an Ministty operall:S die "Hotel de ZInk" slx:lter out of rwel';. cburcbes. using
• _ cb=lo eoclllllOllll!. of die year_Counseling. food. clothes. mail aIld drop-in cen!I:r are
also _ II o1ber locatioos 10 _ resklenls and oIher home1eu penons by Url>an MInistry_
MicamooIl: Ment3l Hei!th Services. Inc .• wbGse offices are IocaIl:d Oll California A venue in Pilo
Aho. P£Ovide meot3l healtb services I<> adults and older adnIrs with serious and persisteD! ment3l
disabilities. Programs SJ>O!lSO'l"l by Ihe agency inclucle group bGDSing with and without services.
coonseling, ca.", management. edocatioo and vocationallraining.
22
a. loysntPO pC FJthjljljes.-
EMERGENCY SHELTERS (IN PALO ALTO)
NaIDt Opei"alor COJ>8dt1 C6emeIe Otber
f1 of beds} Serrices
.iJo<d do Zink" Urban Ministry IS AWl .. Meals
Servtd
.
EMERGENCY SHELTERS (IN NEARBY AREAS)
Name Operator Cap&dty Clientele Otber
fI of beds) Senic<s
Armory Emergency 100 AWl .. Me<fJCal
W lllIer Shelr.:r Hoosing
Slmnyvak C<losonium -
Tra.ositlooaI HDIIriog Sbelters (In Palo AlIo): None
TRANSITIONAL HOUSING SHELTERS (IN NEARBY AREAS)
Name Operator Capacity amide Otber
f1 01 beds) Sen>icos
Havca Family House, Sheller 60 Families Ves, _Pm
Network atstte
JWwood F",u'·y -... Shelter 40 Families Yes,
-Cily Network :it srt.e
_ CIanI Family ~ Emergency 200 Families Ves, c-.-, Housing at site . _Om C<losonium
IIlinciJ SL _. Inoovati,,"e 8 Single Yes
_PlIcA. ... Housing Parents
23
.-
..
,-,
'-,
,',
Pl>RMANENT SVPPORTIVE SHARED HOUSING (IN rALO ALTO)
Bowdoin Hoose Innovative Housing 2HouseOOlds
I'ino St, Hoose Inoo .. tlve Housing 3 Households
& Palo Alto Housing
Corp,
Edgewood Hoose Inoovalive Housing 4Housebolds
b. luvmfOQ' of Seryjcea fOr ltc Homeless in NQ Abo
families
wfchildren
famil its 'ill febildrea
-.
The Palo AIIo Urban Ministry operiItes I drop-in center for Il!c hornele>s from Monday through
friday during !be hOUri of 7:3C am 10 11:30 am ., Il!cir center behind !be kd Cross buikfmg,
They provide food, meals, bus passes. sbower pas"'. message lJId mail service,. clolhing.
«lWl$Cq iocIuding menI2! health coonsermg in conjunction wiL~ MlmIlOOt!: Mental H<alth, case
~ payee se.--ices, They served • IO!al of 4,262 undupIicatcd bomeless persoos during
FY 93-94 wl!h on< 0< more of their services, The Uman Ministry's programs and scrvi<= "'"
IiIPlUd by !be lack of I <lesignatcd buillflllg with adequate space and facilities,
D. PUBLIC HOUSING NEEDS
'The Cily of Palo AItn does not bave any pubflC housing unflS or developmelllS IocaIed wl!hin the
Cily Ilmits.
Eo LEAD BASED PAIN'Y NEED
Duo !JJ dle age of Palo AItn's housing stock. moot (0->'« 90%) bO'.lscOOlds are living in unflS which
"'" likely !O coaWn lead based palm (defined IS unfIS built before 1979). In renIaI housing. very
!ow and low inc'JmC bousebclds lIe not cflSproportiooal<:ly affected by lead pain< hazards, 34 ~
of Ihe pre-1979 rentalllni1l! are occupied by 10 ..... incoroe l:ousebc!ds. Gene!ally. rental housing
in Palo AIIo is .... n maintlinr<l1llhick may reduce lead pa.inI hazards for all \eDants, In owner
0C<:Upied housing (due I<> Ihe high market value 0( sue!! housing) vel}' few lower income
bouoebolds an: affe<:&ld by leadp:oinlbazards, 16~ oflhe pre-I 979 owner occupied housing units
are occupied by 10_ income booscbolds. Lead painl bazanIs in owner occupied boosing are
liIo:Iy '" be I problem of hi,gber incoroe bousebclds wOO bave the """"""'"' teSOUICeS 10 rm.oo..J
their bomes_ Consultation with the Coon!y Environmenul Healtb Department did no( reveal any
n:poru of IligIlIead levels in childrea residing ill Palo Alto, s.e!be fi>llawing !able. for more
information.
24
,
,', •
, .
,~ _ i 1
~; .. -
-. t
RENT.U. UNITS BY AGE OF UNIT &c INCOME OF OCCtJPANTS
\"EAR BUILT: J're.1940 1940·1~ 1960 ·1979
Oc=pied by
Very Low Inoome 312 654 1,294
<>=pied by O!ber
Low Income ISO 333 63<~
Oc=piedby
ITlgher lnc<lme 1,33S 2,743 2,569
TOTAL lJNITS I,m 3,730 4.499
OWNER liNITS BY AGE OF liNIT &: INCOME OF OCUJPAlIITS
YEAR BUILT: J're.194e 1940·1~
Occupied by Very 373 816
Lowlncome
O=Jpied by O!her ill 504
Lowlncome
Oc=pied by Higber 2.310 6,678
Income
TOTAL llNITS 1.908 7,998
s....n:.,: Table 12 (l(yl~i93) in CHAS o. .. booI:; Speci.al
1990 CeDsus Tabulatloo Provided by HUD
F. MAltKET CONDmONS
1960·1919
106
52
2,113
1.171
1, CurreuI and AmIclpaWI Households in Palo ... lto ro< 1be 1995-2000 I'Iam!iog PerIod by
HouseIIold Income Level
Based on the abo~ ma.-ket foctors, Palo Alto estimates tr.at approximately 600 housing uniu .. iII
be added IQ the City's housing SlOe" over tlle five year perlod covered by !his Plan. This
representS an average anDual housing produ..-tloo rate 0( 120 units per year which exceeds L'>e
gt'O\Wl rile in the housing stock " .. , the last five years (less II;an 100 units per year from 1990
through 1994), However, the Ci!y expects boo.,ing starts 10 increase mc<lestly in the last baIf 0(
. ~ ... "
;-; --~~)-.. -~~,:-:,;~,';:'--~j ci';>-,';,'<:JS2;
Ib: 6tcaclt provldod til!! 1llC local """"""'Y eontil\ue$ 10 impcove and that intemt roles st'ibi!izc,
C_isteol wiIb Il>e CiIy', ~ted flp!!sine f1mv:nt of 1he <:nmprMeosjye Plan, /be Cily's
objcc:Il~. pmuant 10 "'" tqkloal'fair ~. aJl=tioo. is 10 e!ICouta&e!lousing produCtkut in
"""",daJX;O F.th Il>e ~"".llg propo<tioDOfJty;
• Very LoIl-lDcome (0 -SO~ of mediat» 126111llts
• Low IDcome (SO -80% of median) S411mts
• Moderate l/Ic""", (S(} -12()% 0( "","JlII1}
252 units
Total 100%
l! suffici<ol housing "",,;aleS and appropriate site< are available, /be Cily will ... o<k .. illl !lowing
deVelopers '" im:reasc: (over:hat sbown above) Ill< ownbct of very low. low and modera", iDe""",
unn. produced.
'I'Ii= is greaIP.r <Ietn.laI fDt!lousing in Palo Mo lIlan caII be mot. ponic>llar\} affocdable bousing
for bousebolds wiIb very low and low incomes. S~ Palo Mo is • iksinbJe place '" live and
p<Ilvi<les more jdbs Il>u bousiDg units. there is _ <Ietn.laI b Ibo existing units available and
prlces are !httcfur1: bid upww. Furtbcr,!httc is scat1:C land available 10< new boosing
clevelopmenl. ThiO Cily bas "Wj littk ,-&Cant Of _eloped land for new COIJ.<trOCtioo; in
fac<. 1Ii Cey is "W"'i'!ly "bulIt 00Jt' _ [)e~lopers 0( &ff<lroable housing project> JWS11heTeforc
~ wiIb clevelopets of _ rate !lousing for \he linn1£<! !and run .~aiIa!>k:_
Dem.>t!d for " .. nenl>ip bousing bas dampened considerably su.:e 1990 due 10 \he CCOtlOInic
doWDIunI in Ihe llOli)Q aDd in Silicon VallO} in p>rti<:uJar. PriceS of single family bousbg bave
de<;1ined somewhat from !holt peak Iove15 .r'" units take kmger to sen.
CmJqmjnb;m$: A 1993 s:u.r-ey of sales 01 alsting CDndom1niums foun:1lhat peas av~clJ
$225,000 for. cypiCallloo squa", fool. two bedroom unit and it is assumed 1ba11he $22S,o:x!
a_ pri<:o is still ...... .lIa1e in 1995. Coodominium o .. "...bip bousing in Palo Mo is generally
affo<dable 10 Ihe moderate income bousebold (100% to 120% of median iDeome). Hooseoold>
with iIlc<lmes from 80S to 100% 0( mediaD still have difficulty .ftOOfmg cbe !ypicaI11l'O bedroom
cO!ldo WlI ... they have large downpa)l1ll<1llS, Low ioc",,,,, bousebol<ls bave ro possibility of
purcbas1Dg in Pal<:> A/Io'. m<rIi:et, cX<:CpIlhrousl> !he CiIy". Below Marlet Ownersbip ProgYOm.
26
•.. "
, .
SiDak flmjly Dc!acl!cd HQ!!!C!i' III contrast, the l)'pical1hr<e bedroom. two balh older single
fluDiIy ....... bed Ilouse in PlIo Alto rosts .boot $400,000 and r<quires an income of aboot
$106,000 or 183$ of the c:urrcm Counry mediaD income. lbc chari below illustratco the
bomeowoonihip affonIabiJity gap for hou...tJolds.
2;
. "
ESTIMA 11'.1) AFFORDABILfrv GM' FOil. HOMEOWNERSHIP •
ClTYOF PALO ALTO l~
V<:r)" Low HUDLow True 80<;\ lOOS 01
IDcome; Income: otMediaa Median
!O"ot 63""01
M<dlaD Median
lncomo Level $28.900 $36.200 $46,240 $57.800
AI!ordabIe 58,670 $10,860 513,872 517,340
AlIma]
Rowing
Cost'
Affonlable $90,000 $112,500 $143,600 5179.soo
Unit Price'
Mart.lPrice 5225,000 5225,000 $225.000 5225,000
$135,000 SII 2 ,500 581.400 S4S,500
1 As3umpIkms: two bedroom coodo units; 3 person households
'21" 01 io::ome foe home mortgage; 3% foe taxes, insurance, dues
• Assumes 10'lli dowa payment; 9:1 inIr:rest; 30 year loan
4. _ A!rordabIlI!y
Mod<rate
120" 01
Median
$80,920
$14.276
$251,32S
5225,000
None
The rene data 1hal is available indica!es thai <eDlS bav. bcea fairly stable since 1990, The IV<IlIge
two bedroom apartmeDl in PaIG "' .... rents foe about 5900 per month plus utJlioo. This is just
affordable 10 !he lop or HUD'. 1993 Iow« _ limit foe • household of 3 persons" There is
• subslaDlial affordability gap, however, belweeD ",hat velY low iocome bousehclds C&B pay foe
renI and !be _ ~ See tile clw! on !be ~llowlng ""ge foe calcuLttion or offordable rents
by 00useh0Id income categorif>;"
28
-..
RENTAL AFFORDMlILITY • 1993
Affordable Rent
E.xIJem<,Iy Low: ~ 30'1 of mo>.fian or ~ $16,000 $400
~V=~~Lo=w.~.~~~~'I~of~~~Ym~or~~~$=2~6'~~~ ____________ r-____ ~~~7 ____ ~
Low 1Dcome: ~ 60'1 el med"lJUl or ~ 532,000 5801
Santa Clara CrunIy: MeaWl Relll el2 Bedroom ApI as of7i93: $745
(souree: Bay Area C<>uncU', quarterly reot survey)
Il! 1990. !be 0"'_ occupancy "II" 1IIas 57$ in PaloAJo.o ThaI is. 3% increase since 1980.
Sevenly~;ght peICCt!I of !be O1IIlleTShip stock is i:J t!lree bedroom units. Most 0W1lCf oc<upied
units (88'1) on: single family <kUched 00mts. MOSI an: over 30 years old, !be medIan ,ear built
is 1954 and less tIw! 10'1 of !be owner oe<:upied l>ousing was buill ,;:lee 1980. EV<B tbougb !be
(Jwner t'CCUpied housing stock is older .. it tends SO be wen ff'.aintainr;d due 10 its .. high market
value. TIBls,!be CRy estimaIes (based 00 earlier surveys cIooe for !be 1988 -1991 HAP) that only
3$ of!be owner ""-'"1!J'ied stock is substandard.
b. Bema' Homige
Over two Ibirds of !be CiIy'. 10,471 renraI u ... its If. SIr.al!er units (studios, 0,,", and two
bedroom). On!) 9'1 of !be subsidize<! ",oral units arc ibree bedrooms or ..."..
RENTAL STOCK BY UNIT SIZE
'''IBR lBR 3+ BR To(aI
Total SUx:k 5,032 (43'1) 3,515 (34110) 1,920 (18%) 10,471
Subsidize<! ?6! (71110) 216 (2.)110) 97 (9110) I,OS2
Units
29
The C"Il)I'. reDIol bousing is somewhat .,. ...... Iban its' 0""""" occupie4 bousing with. median yeM
buill of 1960, About 8 ~ of ClIO lOla! = II!lits were built sUu 19S0.
d. BcnW Ynror JWe
Tho Census infonnatioo sbows an ovcnll nmtaI vacancy rote (opartmen!S and homes) of 3.96$.
The c.y Planning Division t<>IlI!uoIs its' 0"" serni->nn1.1>l c!etemUnatioo of the ~DllLl apartmcnl
'-.aDC)' nte pursuanI to the provisioos of the city'. coDClominium cODversion mfinaJlC<:. The
C""Y', lDIlysis is based QQ IICIUaI utility _ ~ and thus is more timely and acxurale than
the Census infonnation. ..... of November, 15194, !be City ~ 10.31 $ ~ apartmeDI
VI""",,, rate.
e. Dcfipjtjgn of ·SnOOry1W ConQrtjoo-and -Sybrtao4an1 Cmfrnn but Suitable For
JWwbiljtatjop •
Palo Aho coosiders • bousing unit sub<tandard if. doesn', meet tile federal 5e<tic. 8 Housing
Quality ~. Eo",ntWly all subslandanl hoUsing units are considered as suitable for
rehabmlalion.
Wbile die COy"s IOIal p<lP'Jlalioo bas inI:rea~ only mlnimalIy (by I $} over the IasI decade from
(1980 -1990). ClIO racial ~n bas changed. The biggest <~.anges are in the Asian &:
Pacific ls1anl5en group 'l'hicl> In=osed 10$ and Hispanics wllkb increased 34$_ Whites
declined 4~.}'Ul .... still the major poruIatioo group wrJi 8S $ of !be 10IAI population.
Pak> Alto defines "ncial!etImk minorlt) c:oocentration" as • CC9S11S tract with • non-white
population of over SO~_ There are DO areas .. ithin the City wllkll are considered areas of
COl>OC!lInIIlon by !his clefinj(joo. . However, !here are tbree census tracts wbcre !he !>Cia!
compositiou is sigDificanLly differena !han !he CiIJ as • whole. A difference is coosidered
significarf ~. mioori!)i poop', popuI.ation is five perceDl more than tIleir percemage s!lare
oflhe City wlde p<l{AlI.tion.
Ceosus TNds "" Greall!r Ihe.o A • ..-age Minority I'opuIatioDs
CiryvOOc NoAho OtiveIWest OatCccek:
Gardens McadowNeruura 5116.98
S093.2 5107
Wbite 84.9% 655% 1O.8S 74.0%
AsiaIlIJ'loc:If 10.41' IUS I2.8S 17.9'1
r.Iaader
iliad 2.9'1 I2.2S 7.SS S.IS
Amt.rIam o.n o.os 0.2% O.IS
IDdiaD
0!JIa" I.S:I> 4.2S S7% 2.9%
b. Areas 01 (pw-ITIX!f'DC Cgnq:ntpginn
· -\ -'--~'"~--,
<--;/
Pa.to Alto defines an area of low income Coo:entration as • C<llSUS IraCI wbere more tlwt SOS 0(
aD lilt OOnzbgkls bave incomes below Ihc low income limit for Ihc CDBG program (about 65%
<lfllle ~ __ wbicll in 1990 ..... $34,200). All "',,,sus IrlICtS w:ept Oll< bave
med'"1aD M'SChnkl incomes above the low income level.
The ODe census uacllhat does III)( is census InC! N(). 5093.02. This IraCI bas. poverty ....... <If
II.2S (Ihc loi~ in Ihc CiIy) and • me<ftan h<>usebold income of $12,891 (lbo lowest in !he
City). This IraCI bas • sm;lI I<lCaI population (403 penoos). over balf 0( ""hlcillive in Ihc Palo
AIIo Gan!ellS ApartmerD, I fcderajJy subsi<f!Zed, 10,. income developrnttI 0( 156 mlllS. The Palo
AIlo Oardens project bas 128 senior mlllS and 28 family mlllS; all occupied by very low income
households, IDOSl willi annual incomes below $10,000_
Ipw Irx:g!no Family Hg",.bolds· The median income of fami1y housebold, is coosisten!ly bigller
dian nool'amiIy (single per.iOIlS and penoDS t-vlng will> nonre1atives) bouseOOIds. The <:ensus!ract
with !he lowest fiImiIy mod""LIUI is Tract 5101 mcwn as "Otive-Wesr. MeadowNenru,.."
Dcighl>orbood. lIS me4ian fImiIy income was $50,068 in 1990.
31
-'. .:.')
Otbc:r In. Ipmmr; HQltzbnk!S: Six CC1l5US tracts bave median PQOfamily ~ below HUD's
low iDc<lme IimiI: of $34,200. They are:
Ceasus Tract Name Nooramn, Mod!aD
IDcome (1990)
S093.02 Palo A1t" Gardens S 1,897
S09oI.Ol Mooroe ParI< 26,094
5108.03 Fainne<tdow 26,595
5107.00 Olive/West 32,436
MeadowlVentura
5115.98 College Terrace; Evergreen 33,292
Park; Soutl!g ...
5109.00 Old South I'lIIo A.1to; 33,306
MidtOWD West; El Carmelo
AImoot 30'1 of P>Io Alto', population lives in noofamily bousebolds. The elderly, students and
-fivin8 aIooe 0< in sban:d Evl."lg situations .,. major parts or this population group. .-.mong
low income remers, n% of the Ilousebolds are eitber elderly (oae and two member bousebolds)
or other noorelated bousebolds (singles and nonrelated adults).
7, SuIIabiIity of HoasIn& SIock For Hoosebolds Wrth Special Needs
a. !McrJy H!l!!sc!Jglds' AImosI ODO·baIf of Palo Alto', renI2I 5Iock is srucflOS and oa: bed.'OOIDS
which OR of appropriate size for II!OSI elderly bousebolds. About 64" of the subsidized stock
is oa:upied by seni<Jr beaded bouseboIds. However, 1IIere is stil! I sbortage ola!fordable ""'''in;!
for vel}' low iDc<lme seniors and • lack ol accessible units for seniors with disabilities. There is
oIso • lack ol affordable housing for the low income frail elderly.
br Pm.nns Wu Pi;vsjgl Pisahj1;Qes· Tbere is no readily available informitioD on the extent
'" ",hiell Ibere is sufficienl accessible housing in Palo Alto for persons with disabilities.
However, ~ tile age ol P>Io Alto's bousin;! stock iI is likcly lhai ro .. units (and projecl»
..-""'-real _ for accessibility as mandated by the Americans With Disabilities Act
(ADA). There is aIsv I lack ol infonnaticn on the occessibiliry ol tile subsi<fued bousin;! stock.
Some subsidized proj<cts have " unit or units "'hiclt are reserved for tile disabled or for
",_hair users. However siDee II!OSI or tile units wen: boilt some time ag", theY probably do
no( meet Q1rrellI standards. In addition, r<>mmon areas ol tile developments may not be fully
accessible. .
,
J-.
•
.. "
, --"';~ ~ "
·c. fami'a With rum-The housing S1ocl: information indicates that there may ~ •
shortage at: suit>ble rental bocsing for families, especWly for families tMt need Ihr<:e or I00I".
be.Jtooms. 00Iy 9:1 at: dIC Slil>sidiud stock is in Ihr<:e bedroom units and only 1 S:I at:!be IoJtaI
remallIOCL It is fairly cmaiD \tal eX1rnncly row at: Illroo bedroom units (for sak or ren<) on !be
opeD mar","'" a1fordablc by 10 ... income households.
The lable belo'li !ihows Ihe DlIIIlber uf housing units under Sectlon 8 r.:ntal as.i.;Wx:e COIlII"aCU in
Palo Alto as at: November. 1994 based CD infonnation provided by the Santa Oan County
HwsiDg Authori!y, dIC governIl)e!ItlI hody which adminisIm !be Section 8 program witltiD Palo
Alto. EUCI numI>ecs are not available but most at: !be 58 units are in S'Jbsidiz.ed housiDg
developmenl5. Very ro ... private property 0 ..... " ,.in ren! to tenants with Section 8 assisunce
'"" wm seek out Section 8 sub<idies si= they = easily rem for more to maID:! cat< lenan<s. The
HousiDg Authori!y also reports Ib!t Ibere ... ere 164 households from Palo Alto on dIC ""aiting list
for Section 8 asslsWu. Of the 1M households, 156 ...... ldelly/disabled.
Sedi<JD 8 Program -lr.age !.o Pak> Alto
CIIarac:Ieristi of Tenants '" Units (November. 1994)
Tocar: 58 HouseboIds I 21i EId-..:lylDisabled I 32 Family Households
b. 0t7rr Assisterl Hgusing Inyentory
The lo!1cwiDg cIIart !isis Palo Alto's inveoW<:Y at: subsidized 10 ... and moderate _ reIHal
bouslng.
All at: !be developmcW !ist«! are f.dIy cenred, bave very low turnover "''''' and most bave closed
'Wi1lng !isis. Of.m.e projects wit!!. 09<" ",oiling fIStS, they will 001, take awlkatioos from
peTSOIlS who bave • federal p~ (dispIa=!. Ih. in .... bstandard housing, or pay over 50:1
at: income for rem).
c. Bck;w Markel Pto£Am Housing Invcnto[y
In odc!ition, in 1995 Palo Alto bad 144 below market """,,,,,,ship units and 30 belo'li marh:I reIlla!
units. They ... localed Ihroogbout !he City in pdvalely wnstrUCte<l residellliaJ developments.
The units """" provided bY !be private maI1I:eI under cbe Cit} 's inclusionat)' zoning policies in the
City'. Housh., FJrme'll whicll bave bee. in e!fecl since 1974. Generaily, tl1e below market
progcamserves persoos wit!!. ~above dlCCOOO limit to.boot 100'" oflbe~ median
income.
• ~-' t
, " • -J --.
ern cw PALO ,uTO r.u.m.! * SfNK)Ir.
StiJlSlDtl',l;b UJIa'.u. 1IO(TSN{: ~ -. ....
..... Td --T
s.:~ m.m:, 4SS E,OIulcaoa """ 120 120 "'""
c-.ao Put. 11(.1 ~ Ave ,m '" ., .~
PW ~ Cludaa, 618 Sal ....... ,.'. ". '''' --&$."",
A> 57~ ArIsnIJef'O .... ,." .. .. F.mi)y4~
~ GIrdczs l650 to. A~ "'. 21. m ......
Wetaf ~go(, 'N1 "ebact Stm::t: ,.,. .. 41 Fazr;i1y. Sni:c" a ..
t.,l'UOIl Gantrm .. 66 ~ A'Wit ,.,. "'0 "" Se1lioor~.50 ~
.sc~c .. ,.
Sb:ricIaa ~)OO ~ AIo'C: 1m 51 " ""'" ......... -"" """" = ... "-
am 1"IIZInti, 1l'Q ~1"SOfI SIF¢rI ..., 1t H as-
T ..... 65!,,~ "'" '" 72 Famay .. Smio!'"
..... -19 •• ,. 10 """" :t01·I3:t Feme A_
~ Soadl. :w6i EInct:_ "., • • ""*" c..n..._ ....
. Jl».301.0 Ca:natr A\It!lUI
, • funil).~
...... ''''''''''-,,., • , ."""'"
Cal:fcrnit hrl Apt. .... ., '" """" . """"""-
OU'MMm 1'~ OJ!4I11Dbki ,.., D " .....,
J"!IaII Tn::e ~ ~.E:aenta 1m ,. 10 Mmi1r
t ,..-. DO E"JICH ARJUe .... " " Scio<
Bwt.:ac.r. 4J9 ~ , ... .. " ......", "....,
Emeno:. NonIi... lOSl-3061 £-=f'QI 5L '''' • • Small:Fami'y • Send.
tor .. . .... . ....
.-.
~. ".,'
,-';. ,.
O. BARRIE1tS TO AFFORDABLE HOUSING
1. Lad; or VacaDt or Available Lanll ror Housing Coostructioo.
This is :be priamy condition that affects both nooprofiI aJJl b-proI'~ d..-ve~ trying 10 devekJp
housing. hlo ,'J!o is esselllially. built cuteily. Only L4~ or r.s' urban area is "acanI. The
"Sranfanl West' site is die only major, Va<:anI residen!ial porcellvailablc for &:vcloj>meD!. 'While
Ibm ~ munerous parcels thai bave p<>Ie!l!iaI b-housing &:velopmen!. !bat po!tD!ial =mot be
~ ocbieved due 10 lIl3IlY IiIcIors in:1uding: comaminatioa by "'<ins. numerous o"nersbips,
legal issues. ocigbbo<hood cpposilion, site DOl for sale or p~ above !be market, rezoning
noe<lcd, occupied b1 "8fIDdf>lbe,ed" 11OfH:O!lfonning _ use.. etc,
This _Ie is related 10 !he scareily 0( land. WIleD Jand is .va~able in P>lo AM. !be ~ is
100 hip for !he ~ 0( low 10 moderate income bousing "ithout costly subsidies.
Rtsidentially zoned property COl!. sen for $40 per square foot and up depen<fmg on its' location
and clevdopmon! poI<nliaL Commercially zoned land (ou!Side o(!he 00"1110"'" eem) is valued
lit about $36 '" $4S per square foot. Thus. I 00< acre site ,.ou\d Iypically be worth about SI.7
millioo. or evell more. Since developers of commerc:iaf projects will often pay mere for Jand .
.,"""" 0( sites thai ., .• suitabl;o b-either housing 'X =ia1 use> will OOId rot for 1bI: higher
~ CheI can obtain from I commercial buyer .
. 3. Lad; of Market Demand " YlIllIIl<inI: for Markel Rate HClOSing
The poor economic wildiIions oltho 1990'. ill< reflocled in I lower demand for new. marUt rate
bousiDg. That foetor. toge<her wiIh 1bI: grea!er difficulty rmancins "'''' housing in tho 1990.', (a
by-p«>cluct of tho savings and loan crisis) Las R:SUlted in • =ber of approved market rate
housing projeds ".....r being built. Since Palo AIm bas an inclusionory zOlling requirement, !his
mtanS tbaltho below market units in these projects ....... not buill either. CoIIcctioDS of in-lleli
housing mitigation fee. have also declined in Ille 1990'0.
The IDOSI imponaDt factors ",hid; affect tho City', prog'"'' in meetinr lower income housing
objectives are:
• Extremely hip price of sites for """ housing or iJleUslinf residelllial properties suitable for
",babilitafion
• Highly competitive and complox application process for tho limited amount ol federal aDd
Stile bousiDg funds
>-,'<:, .. ' ' , .
35
;,-:---------
..
-... -. ""' .----....
-, .-
• HUD ..mn-.:ntaI SlmcIards which m.alce iI difficult '" bund federally subsidize<! housing
ill areas wkh noise Ie .. " lila! (ajJ. 10 meeI HUD SW>dards (aJoog EI Camino Real and near
nnro..IllaCb)
• Problems ollllilWDc federal housing programs such as S<ctioo 202 in arw wkh biglt
COilSIJ uctioD and !and costs
• LimiIed IIIIOU1II 0( funds lila! tile City re.:eiv .. on an entitIerDeDl "asis !rom tile federal
~
.. l.Zni!>4 """"'" land suitable for boosin8 coostructioo
H. FAIR HOUSING
The City ~ .nth M1CI-PI:ninsuIa Citizens foe foil' Housing (MCfH) 10 eDCourage .. ..J
JlrOIIIOfI' oquaI opponmUry in boosiDg for all people. Servic<:. include infoonalioo and "'fenal.
<OIDllIWIiIy outreach and cducatio!l. discrimination complain! chc<;tm, and investigation, legii!
refernts and ass~ in resolving complaints. As pa!1 0( the FY 93-94 f"oir housing eo,ruact.
MCFH ..... 1iInd<d by me Cily 10 bold • fair housin8 wrtsbop foe landlords, property managers.
owDon and iion profits. 11>c Cily abo contracts ",Sth P A.IJRS for lenamllandlord information.
rdetraI and moc!iar;oo oenicos.
As pan ol ita 1.995-96 'tim progmn. !he City cI' Palo Aho .. ill <:OOIluct "" anaI)Isis of
iq>ed"uoon 10 fair housing c:lloke.
36
,~
'-" .•. ;: '
','
~' '''' .---,'
",
"I , ,
"
"
',"
~';'f, '!-.
.\,
"'-'.;
,
,I
I
-",,',-1
* ~
~ ..... o.te: f 04J281Q!5
Port II __ Popu_
P_II'" wtth (lftlld ...
'. Number 01 Homo .... fomilioo
.2. Number of PeNOnlln HQrnetau P'amllea
IndlYklu." not , ... 'ami ...
3. YOUlh(17ye ... oIog ... yOUngor)
4, Adulla (~B+ y .... or ago)
,TOTAL (11_ 2 ., •• )
",It~: 8ubpopulatJOfta
... ome .... ' ... on. Witlh e.rvtoe N'" Mol •• to:
" _,. ~nt.IIlIt1_. (SMI) Only
~, AlOQIIOI/Olhor Drug AblI .. Only
3, SMI ond AIoo/IOIIOIho' Dn'g Abu ..
•• Oomoolie VIotonoo
S, AIDSIRolo1od 01 ... -
u.s. Depal"lmll .. t or Mo .... lng • .,d Urb.n D.v.~p ...... nt
CPD CO_lldolocl '100 avo-Il0l0 TIme: 07:03;/10
MOh.'", IIopulatione .... d lubpopu1lltlona
'1'01011
IIOEl.1wa
(.· •• dl
3:13
1,284
86
1,320
2."Z
,,'" ToIol
11.0
301.0
8,0
1M
1.0
T_'" _I--TOTAL N ___ D I)V_
III~ ~"'1IOJf T,..,.lUaMl
V
(0)
eo_ _ ..-.
(ft) '01 (ill
'3 <411 ,<411 ,«2
~B 112 M3 BB3
18 35 20 110
leI 335 896 21M
Z37 41Z ',471 m
,.,U, ConU._ ,,01
Numbe, e, OIho, (s(lllOlty) T_
296 Nornpon .. 18.0 fln __ 0,;
VI~ Phy."""_1Ih 0,7
.."ntl' HHtth 0,5
2115 family probIo .... 0.3
Phyo:o._"_ 0.3
404 Poot engll.~ Iklill 0,2
27
0-oonoemo 0,5
r\~f_l,;\·~J:_~,~·(~: (~!, :,' ;:< : ! ~~', ~; '< '~,,:'~ ~,' "f. .' __ ',.) ,. " r~»".:'."-~:I'( \,,', -'-~'-': ,,;~' '_:,l: . ~'.~ ',f"',-',:}?t:":',~~,,::: '-'.', ,> --. ','., ,: • 1,-.
~"':':'i I '.: ", ... ', • :,;:1 {--, ',' ,"1
--\ ~ ...
DL HQUSING AND COMMllNlTY D£YEIQPMENT !IT!!ATF&IC M AN 092S.?OOQ1
A. H(){,'SING AND COMIIf1.JNITY DEVELOPME1'<' OBJECTIVES AND PROJECTS
ToI>Ie 2 at !be end o(chis ICCIioo idenIif ... !be City') prioriIy needs. Tb< estimated dollar> needed
10 addtcss !be problems ideBtified OK VOl)' rough estimates and represent the five year period
coven:cl by :be plan.
1. Priority AlTonIabIe Hoasin& Needs
a. Priority: Ilc1lIa1 HoasiJl:
L A<Urities: Acquisition, RclIabilitatioo. New Cor.sttuctioo. Reat.al.&.ssistance. Support Services
PerSOIIS To Be AssIsIed:
• Very low h>:ome :emcrs (1I>'OmeS kss than 30% 0( mtdi>n and Icss than SO,.; of meOWl;
smaI1 & large famiJy bousebolds. &: OIher bouseholds)
• O!ber low _ renters (small &: large family bowebolds. &: othcr bouseholds)
• Persoas with speoi.ai needs (esp«:ial1y the meDtally ill)
Procrams. Resources: Tb< foIIowq programs and resources will be !VaiJabl< Cl£ applied for
dizecIly by Ibe City:
• rooo FY 9S!96 funds of 5972,000
• HOME FY 9S funds (W!Imown, lntcod 10 apply)
• Lcca! City funds: Commercial and resideotia1 boosiJl: """"'. fund
• Cx, Owned Lan4 NO! Neede4 Foc Other Pu.qooses
fcdml Rcsr.m;q. Tb< City Wl be using CDllG funds for acquisirloo of existing properties and
forassisWlce _~veIopmelllCOSlS ofJow income housing. Over $350,000 OC 43% of the
CDBG entiIJemerI aI1ocatioD for 1995-96 is proposed 10 be aI!ocated 10. "Housing Developmenl
Fund' for mol housing a..""jUisition, rebabililation and development The City intends 10 apply
10 !be S-for FY 9S HOME funds during caJeooar year 1995 provide<! planning approvals are
37
c -.
.,
received lOr the SRO (Sir'll!. Room Occupancy) new conslnl\;tlon project. TIl< dev~1oper c( tl-.e
DC'Ii SRO project will prol;ably apply lOr Low Income Housing Tax Credits in FY Y5.
C~y Rgoorcrn' Local JlI!blic funds .,hiclo will be avaUable for DeW rental housing units arc the
housing mitigation funds in the CiI)'·s commercial reserv.. These funds can be used lOr land
acquisition and lOr CODStru<:1ion costs. TIl<re is cum:ruly about $2 million avail,ole from Illis
SOU!eC. These funds will be wed ror the local match required by tbe HOME program.
Private !t'tl'Jr....es. The City will wlXk with OOl'lprof"ll housing devt10pen to obUln the ireatest
IIIDIlU!II 0( private financing lOr reO!al developm<DIS, coosiitelll wilh other objectives. TIl< City
will assist project sponsors in obWning financi.'Ig from tbe Fodera! Home Loan Bank', Affordable
Housing Program (AHP) for eumple. TIl< City ",ill also ",ock wit!> local lenders 10 pro,'ide coustr_ financing and bridge financing for ._1. boosing projects.
Matcbinr Funds' 1'heCWy'llocal ~ing ~e Fund" which comes fronl_boUsing in--IieY
fees on new commercial projects "ill be used for tbe required malCb for future HOME gr.IJ:ts.
v.."bero eligible, CDBG :u .. lds wbic~ are OOllg.ted fur housing activities and suppOO services w'JI
aJso be used IS a ponion 0( the ma!cbing requirements.
Specjtjc Projects· TIl< foDowing 5pCC\fJc projects meet tbe rental housing priorily:
New CoostrUCtion:
I. New Single Room Occupancy (SRO) Apanme!l!S
2. Ne", Qmstructioo: Family ~ Apartmen!5
). Ne ... CoosIIuctioo: [)e"clopmeDtaDy Disabled
4. New Construction; Shared Living
Acquisition andfor rehabilitatioo 0( existing housing:
I. Arastradero hrt Apanments (66 <>=pled units}
2. Mitigatioo Project foe 651 F.amilton
). Emerson Noo1.b. ~ Rebabi!itation (6 units)
Persons To Be T~: F"1nt time home buy." of units in tbe CiI:y', Below Market Rate,
"BMR" Program: below median inccme, "Otller low" inc""", (51 ',I; • 80%) and • 1<", "very low'
_ (31-SO',l;) ofme<fWl.
Programs, Resouc<:es: COBG Program Income, City's Residenlial and Commercial &>using
Reserve Funds, Mortgage Credit Certlfica!es and tbe City', SIoek c( new and resales "BMR·
units.
, '-'
..
The CiIy', Belo", Marie! Ita", (BMIQ bousing program Iw been providing horne o....".rship
'W"'1U1'ities maiDly 10 moderate illcomc hou>ebolds (80% k> 100% of 1IlC(f12D inccm<) siB.oe Illc
prtl8Rm" iI>I:epboo in 1m. Developers of ""w ownership and rcnraI projects of 3 or more units
an: required to provide 101' of tre units II Iov:er prices. Typical prices for • ""wly built, two
bedroom condo in 1994,..ouId range from $90,700 k> $153,600. Small projects of less than 10
...... , cr projects 'Il'bero an oo-slte BMR unit would be infeasible, may be aJiowcd to pay an in
Iku fee or pro>ide off~lte BMR unilS. P.esalc prices an: limircd _ on incre .... i!t Illc
000.",.. Price _, 50 1hat BMR lIDns beromc re1aUvely more tlfooIable ever lime. The Cily
COilIIICb with Illc Palo AM Housing' Corporation 10 _ Illc sale. and resales oC BMR
units.
Currendy, many of Ibo 'BMR' units are available at prices "'hicll are aff.ordable Jo CDoo
cligible, loW incomo: buyers. However, 10", income buyers oI<es do DO( have sufficient down
paymoDU or have more difficulty qualifying foe I borne mongagc !han JUsber income buyers.
'fbus, Illc 10_ priced 'BMR' units an: o&a sold '" moderate income buyers. Al'I evaluation
oClbo f<asibilily of I down payment sssisWlce program (or some OilIer form of assislancc) to b<lp
low income buyet5 purclw< D>O!e oC tho available units will be considered.
The Cirj will ""'wnuc to work cJosely willl Santa Clara Couruy 10 ccntinue Illc av",lability of
Ibo Mortgage Clcdil Certi/icate (MCC) income tax crcdl! ... ~ for moderate income and 10 .. '
incomo: fl<'St time home buyers "" Palo Alto. lD September 1993, Palo AM WIS awarded. 51
millioa allocation of MCC IUIbority IS part of I Coo!llyWidc appbcation. As oC January 1995,
18 borne buy.,. in Palo Alto had recei.cd MCC assisWlce from Illc 1993 allocation. A
subsWJtial portion of tile allocation is SCI aside for 10111 income buyers and lower priced unilS.
Penoas Te Be AssisIcd: AH CDoo eligible, owner occupiod bouscboIds, ho .... ver chc target
group is tile ><:I)' low incomo: (0 -30% and 31 % -50S).
The Cily will continue to f.md tile rehabilitation of owner occupied, single famiJy hccsing lllbel.
1I>erc is an urgenI need or _ heallll. and Sl&fety problems. This activlly is ~g,d to very low
iDcomc I!omoownen. ~nerally, it is Illc elderly or cr ... blcd ho"""".,,,,, who qualifies for
... istana:. I'Imc!iD,!: is from loan n:payments 00 previous ... habml8tion loans. The program is
hmiIcd III <aRCtion ofllTgClll hcaIth and Sl&fety problems. Most of tile Cily" owner =upicd.
Jingle familJ hoos1ll1! stoct is in stmla,d cooditioo and occupied by bouscbolds wi<h inc<Jm... .. of
moderate or ahove moderate levels. Generally. tile hccsing problem f-..ced by low income
borneo...,.".. is Ibo cost of tile lIousing, DOt the condition ol tile unit.
39
, . , "
a. Procrams. Resoum=s: federal: CDOO, HOME. Shelter PillS Care, Supporuve Housing,
Moclerate Rehab SRO; Local: C~ Housing Re<erve Fund, Gene!3l Fund Human Sonic<
a/k>c3Jioos; Private: federalliome Loan B .... k', Affordabk: Housing Program (AHP).
i Activities: Acquisition, R<:!Jl!bilitation, Rental AssisaDce, Support Facilities and Seovices
1>, Homeless Strategy For l!l9S-lOOO Plan Period:
The Ciry'.lxJmele:sS .. si.stancc strategy. ic ... housing activities which the C;':y Sj!<)nsors <f=Ily,
is 10 empbasize the creation of pert"..an<!1l housing ..,hiek is ~.ordable 10 the homele$s and 10
iDdividuaJs ,.ho are moving out of sl>elten or transitioMl boIlSing programs. The str:Itegy
include! creaJiDg housing opponunities foe single aduJts and f&milies ,.illl childrea This is •
""ntinuation of tlle homeless strategy ruled in !be 1991 -1996 CHAS. The CiIJ'. strategy .Iso
includes conaibuting funds fo< the cperation costs of cxistL">g shelter and trulSiliooaJ housing
pr"viders who serve the PaJo AIID and n.orthcra Santa Oora <:<mOly area and cooperating in
eoonay,.ide approaches 10 the problem.
The Santa a.r. Coonty O>1!.aborati vc on Ho:><ing and Hnmeless Issues. "'hiek was creatcllWo
years ago, representS homeless sheller and service providers. boIlSing and lxJmeless advocates,
noo-protil boIlSing developers, 2nd local governmental jurisdictions. includin:! the Ciry of Palo
AIID. Over 12{} agencies have fo<med the C.olI_borativo '" dra,. more funding for bomeless
sbelten. services, and III c=te more affordable housing. The Collaborative win be preparing its
member agencies III respond 10 the reque>I foe proposals in hcpes of assessing more funding foe
iml<wative programs in Ibis "'gien. The region will be preparing for the e=tioo of. CoDlirnrum
of care Planning Process whicll, like the eoo.oJidated Planning Process. win .esuh in • lxJmeless
Con!imrum of Care plan 1hat ideIllifies the region's hameless service and affordable housing gaps
and outfmes priorlIies III address them.. The primary goal is 10 preveot lxJme!essness and sl>one.
the time people are home!ess throagb the provision of bousing ,.ith supportive services and
employmenl opportunities.
Santa a.ra Coomy Homele$s Con.borative bas adopted • Continuum of Care appro_cll 10 help
alleviak the problems of homeless".... The strategy includes: I) Prevention ~, 2)
Emergency shelter with ootreacll and .. sessmclll ~, 3) Transition housing with support
service" and 4) Permanent boIlSing. The<e service. eJUst in Santa Clara County. but no( in
sufficient!lllIllbers to address the need. The Coonty of Santa Clara in coilaboootioo with the cities
believe strengil>ening the CoGtlnuum of Care on I "'giooal basis will effectively address !be needs
cf 'homeless people in our community. I void duplication of services, soo increase cost
effectiveness.
40
The ~ shwld continue '" b<lild .dditiooal transitiooal UId pennanc'~ homing with semce
cowpoocnto, sucII as .. 50 management, .lcohoI UId llrug, an<! mental heaItll senices. The
chalIeDjje is 10 insure Ihese how;ing umts are disbursed Ihroogbout tbe Cow>ry, in suburban and
rural ..... IS ... n. This may be easier 10 aceompIlsb because ;orne 0( tbo services are adopting
• poIic} 0( COIIII1lUIli1)I based senice delivery, serving the cflelll in the community UId DOl
llOCeSS&riIy in I clinic enviromnenL This is true 0( tbo delive!)' 0( menW bealth .. nices.
EmpIoy:oeDt UId ttainiDg services ~ • panicular need in Santa Clara County.
Employmclll and traindlg 1~llci.s need 10 be closely linkfd 10 rransitiooal and subsi<flUd
pcrmaDOIII bousing for homeless people. During the next cycle 0( federal funding for bomeless
programs, tbe Cowxy', empbasis ... iII be in developing proposals that Iinl< bousing with
mIpIoym<D! and ttaining, and support servic<os.
Pro!!!!ljon' I'r.ovcDtioo services for !be "at-ris!t" for homelessness popula!ion is !be most 4ifficuI1
10 fu,.t The CooIIIJ is IbrIumIe 10 bave • Ccuo!y-"idc EmorgetlC} Assistar;ce Network (EAN)
0( eigbl agencies that provide ISSisl.m;e 10 this population by providing roD!allmong.gc
... _. utilities assistance, food and clo<hing. M<>ce support is needed 10 assist !be fAN.
Placing empllasis OIl these senices is cost effective 10 !be entire community beC2use iI maintJlins
~ and famiIies in <beif bou,ing.
Em 'I"'" Sbcl!cr: The Cowxy has approxim3tely 682 etne:gency year-roond beds. Whoa the
_ IIlIlOries are opcood 1winB the winter months, emergency beds inoease 10 appro.Umitt<:1y
1,212 beds Cowxy-... idc. The Slate 0( California will be ellminating the .... 0( IIlIlOries for
emecg<IlC)' shellers, lhetefore, :be County is currentIy worting on "'Placing 250 0( <be 590 beds
whicl will be .runinatal with !be closing o(!be armories in 1997.
For _1Dd rura1 areas o(!be Coun<y,!be community" emphasis will focus 00 outreacIllDd
II ,-.1, extending services, suek as day services for bomeless mea. women UId !beir cbiJdrea.
Day centers need 10 be estabrlSbed in the northeno and sootberB part 0( the CnunIy 10 inoease
oc=o 10 information and referral services, voice maa, and hygiene services, sucIIas 51>0,"",,, and
I pI..:e 10 do laundry. The day c:en:en ..... e in geoeraIlS • resoun:e ocn:er for ooe-srop sbopping
for services. Smveys 0( people in tbo suburban and run! areas attest 10 !he need for tbe dAy
ceIlIen. Many """,.= inrervkwed in !be 1995 !lcmeless survey Slated that tboy did 00(10010'
wbere to go for basic services or information. Many did not 10010' how '" access Wlter
infonnaDoo or """" unaware 0( tbo slJelter hodinc phone DIllDber _ Day centers will address this
problem IS well .. increase aa:ess \0 services DOl currently accessible 10 !be suburban and rur.J
homeless populations.
Irwirjmal m1 pmnawnt Affordable HoosjIll"' The Continuum or Care win pay particular
aueotioo to 1I>c IlCI:ds of families and lUIIIl ... oy homeless youth. Transitional aDd permaneIlI
affordable bousing with supportive services for Ibis population are greatly !acki"8. In part.~,
outreaclIlo homeless youth is still under fwrded and needs \0 be ~xpanded 10 other parts 0( the
CouIlIy-
41
""
.'
Acrjcim TQ A4dmu; FroggCDC)' Shelter .104 Tranc:itj.onal Hm!siDg Neesk
Tho C"1!)i provides IIUlIJ8! CDoo funding 10 1he Urb.an Ministry of Palo Alto b their c;<JUDSefing.
food. cl<!<hiDg and wiler service< 10 !he homeless. TIlt Urban Ministry op<r.Ites I yeo, round.
is person emerge"', wrt.r b homeless individuals, Iocau:<l in Palo AJ'to churcl!es. Tho)
sheltered 1I0I&l of 187 WldupJicIl1ed persons during FY 93-94. TIlt Urban M'Ulistry •• <Imp-in
servi<z =-servo! 11<J!al a( 4.w IIIlIIUplioated bomcle .. per>O". during FY 93-94. $54,000
in CDBG funds 1IIUC provided in FY 94-95.
The City aOO provided $10.500 a( CDBG funding for FY 94-95 to Emergeocy Housing
Consortium, a Coulllywide oper1il« of emerge ... ), and tnnsitiooaJ sbelrers for iD<lividuals and
fltmilles. Of 1he 5.844 undupJicated homeless persons th8Idlo) served last y ..... 63 perscm were
nom 1he Palo Alto area.
$50,000 in CDBG funds were aI1ccaIed in FY 94-95 fer • DCW omergeocy sbelter projed IIlrough
Emergency Hous'.ng Coosortiwn, I!IC. Tho project is to acquire ,,'" rehabili .. t.! an existing
commercial building located in South San Jose Ie serve as 1 250 bed yur-round .. '>:lIer. The
facility wiI! replace • portion a(!he beds avoilablc in thtee wlrner armories whicb are schedukd
for ~Iosure.
The Cily aJso provides CDoo funds 10 Innovaliv~ Housing (512.500 for FY 94-95). Tho)
provide sbared and lrIIISitiooaI hollsiJl!l with coordinated servi:es for low income. bDmeIess single
pore!ltS and individuals and 0Ibers "'ilh special ncc:ds.
Willi City gODOnl funds. administrative support in 1he amouDI at $21,909 for FY *95 "'as
aJIo<aled 10 Mid·l'eninslll> Support Nerworli: for cmergeocy sbeber and SIlpportiVC services 10
boIIcre<I "01lI00 and !beil childrea
The cpenOOos of c.sa SaY •• sbel~ for rona",., >r.d bcmelcss yoolh were supponed with •
c:ootri!Jutioo a( $5.511 in C"lI)' generaJ f.mds for FY 94-95. Additionally, at 1O!aI a( 520.000 in
CDBG IImds """~ ailocat<d during FY 93-94 and 94-95 b rebabilitatioo a(!he yoolh sbelter in
MOWlIain VIeW.
~ To frevcn« Yw J nw Jnr;pmc; BOil s.eboJd5 From Decaro in, Homeless'
II is .nricipated th8I • I!C1II remaJ assistano:elblmeless pr1:VeI!!ioo progrnm !IdminL'lered by IIle Polo
AIIo Red Cross will be initialed in IIle 1995-96 fiscal year with tile help a( a City general fund
snnt in !he aDlOIlJII of $11.soo.
Prognms .. bk:lI Palo Alto fundi WhiclI iDdire<:Ily prevent bomelcssness are:
• Child UR subsidies for low income famJUes, Palo Alto Community OM Care, Annual
contract ",iIll CiIy general fI:nds;
42
• l.andlor4/TeIl&!lI Mediation. P A.-\IRS, AruruaJ contra.."t ... irh City ,e""raJ funds
• Single Puett Counseilllg & Suppon Services, American kd Cro<s. Annual coctracl willl
Cily geDOTal funds;
• BroWlI BaS Program. Second Harvest Food Bank, AlUIIlOI contro.."t with City general funds;
• Senior Day Heald> Prognm, Secio< HoosiDg C<>unse1iDg. Senior Coordinating CowIciI;
Ammal COIlItlICI willi Cily gentral funds;
• Senior NlItJitioo Program, LaCoraida. AruruaJ comr.ct wid> Cily general funds;
• ScDioc Home Rtpair Prognm, Senior Coord"lIWing Cowlcn; AnnuaJ contract with CDBG
funds;
• HiXlSing Infonnaoo" & ~ferral. Palo Aha Hou>ing Corporation, Annual contract with
CDfIG funds;
• lkal1l!. c.n Services. Mayfield C:l<nn>mity Clinic, Annual w<>1IKt ~i1h Cily general
funds;
• ReJllal and Mongage Assi<wx:e Program for HomeJess and Near·Homeless: The City 0(
PJJo Aho also .. .lj>I>OI1e<I !be creation 0( • revolving fund for • CounIywide Rental and
Mortgage ~ Program 10 prcvcnI bomclessness. City support was in !be fonn 0( •
'Memorandum 0( UDIlmraDlling' with SonIa Clara CooIIIy 10 "'O<}; in cooperation 10
imp_ !be program. Tho program bas beeR developed by !be Coullly H""'<ing &nd
Advisoly Comm;u"" (ol .. lricIl Palo Aho is • member) and funIIed with COIIIributioos ol
$200,000 from Ibe Housing &lid Trust Fun/J, AdditionaJ funding is still being sought from
BUD and odlor ",,",,"", III November. 1m. !be f.mls "en: dlsttibured I>y!be Emetge!XJ
A&sistaDl:e Network (FAN) fornmI& (based 00 popuIation and persons in poverty) 10 local
.gency memben ollbe EAN. For Palo AhG.!be American ~ Cross, PaIo}-.ItD Chapter
is !be Ic<:al agency, This program will >Upplemolll existing ~ whicb belp prevent
bomelesSDOSs 5UClI is FEMA and Unirod Way funds,
"cOOps To ASSN Hturtek;s,. Petsqns (1oc"Mfinr Tbog: we Spaiai NmJe) Mate Tbc TgnsWop
To PwnanenJ Boos;»r and ~ J~
The C'1ly supports !be provisioo of menta! beahh oounseIing services 10 !be homeless provided by
Mlnmoote Mental Healih at !be Urban Ministry', sbeltet program w,th an allocation ol City
£CDOral funds. Wilh!be re~ng 0( !be Barker HoteL 26 units of SRO housing with O1>-site
supportive ~ are DOW l.wable with priorily for oc<upancy 10 persons who are homeless
and/or Mve • disability,
43
, '"
~ "-~ ',.' .
~.. ..
"" .;~j
3. Other Sped'" Needs PopulatioD
I. E:tior:iI;x. AN Wial Nrmc C~
L AcItrities: New C<msIrudioo, Rehabili!atloD. Support Facilities and Senicos
........,. To Be .Assi"ed· IndividuaJs and smaH bowehoIds who bay. beeR ideoti . .'ied is having
speciiJ bousirJi needs. M05I persons are expecred 10 have very low incomes below 30% 0( the
I!IediaD family income, 0Ibers will be very low income (from n 10 50 % Qf median), • few may
below_.
Procrmos. ltesource!;, Fodera!: CDBG. Section 811, SetOOn 202, Low Income Hoosing Tu
CrediIs, Scpponiv. Hoosing Program; Local: Cily Hoosing Re.erve; Private: AHP
I. _ Hoosing fOr lndepcndo:nIliving lOr :be Devclopmen/Jllly Disabled; aboot 24 units; oew
COIlSInICtion.
In addition, 10 meet the housing needs 0( pe"""" wit!> specw needs suck as the .rosobled, L'le
mentally m. almsed women and children a,1d other groups !hat need housing with supportive
service<. the Cily oller. assisIanoe through the CDBG program with the acq.ilsiOOn costs 0( group
homes and with rehabililaOOn expenses 0( e<isting residcDli>l r ... "ilities.
Non-housiJJt! CO!I!mIiIlity developmen! needs include improvements 10 pubrlC fac~ities and public
...... ices, and <CO!lOfIlic developmeDt opponunltie5 fOr low income p..'lSOIlS, and program
adJninisttation. Tbe existing needs in Palo Alto in these areas are described below_
1. Tbere is • need 10 expand, mOOernizt:, rebabili!ate, make seismic and other safety retared
improvcmenlS and accessibility improvemeuts 10 existing facilities wb..u se",e speo:w need
popuWioos ()imltecI c_1e IS defined by HUD regnlatio:>s).
2. Tbere is • need 10 complele accessibilily improVCDlCIllS in pubrlC facilities, parks, streets, and
sidewalks tIJro<Igbout Palo AIIo 10 ensure rompllance with the Americans with Disabilities Act
(ADA).
l. Tbere are needs (within the Soulh Bay and Mld-Peninsula area) fOr more emergency shelter
beds fOr the homeless (bodt single persons and families) and for rebabilitation 0( existing
emergency shelter facilities.
" -~.
, .. ,
" -;
C. There are .-:. (witbin tho South Bay and Mid-hniI..w. amt) fur DeW facilities and capital
improvement and n:h2bilitation of existing fiK;ilit.;"s occupied by service programs whlcl! serve
tho \OW ioocmc and &pe<;w =<Is popuIalions.
5. There .... needs (witbin tho South Bay and Mid·Peninsula area) fur improved facilities for !be
provioioa ofhomeless services. incbfmg sbow=.laundry. fuod distribution. drop-in counseling.
eIC.
b. Public S(:ryicg Wbic;b Serve Lower IOCcmc CUcrwc Primarily
I. There "'" needs for supporting tho operoting expenses of ~ which provide human
serviceo to low _. vulnerable popul.ltioos. _It os,
• AffonIal>Je housing information and n:rem.!
• Information and coonseling on landIord!IenanI is.. .....
Slw-.d bousing <OUJlSCrmg and placement
• C..ounselillg. shelter services m! general assistance 10 the very" low income or bome1ess
• Scrvi<es whick addIess tho needs of Ibc elderly oc persoos wilh disabiliti<s
• Services ",1licl address !be needs of 10 ... income cbildrea and Ibcir families
• Transportation servlces for 10 ... income elderly and IflSabled pe""'"
• fair HoosiDg SeMces
2. There are needs for programs whlcl create and increase empl<>Y="l opporrunities for
_. low _ persons, homeless perscns. and persons ",ith disabilities
3. There is a nee<! to support tho COOO Program administration for reponing and compliance
with _ regullitions. '" provide technical .s<isJaoce 10 oooprofi« agencies. to implement Ibc
CiIizms Panicipation Plan. and 10 moni!i:K Ibc Prognm'. progre$S.
Since !be City of Palo AIIo bas .10 ... pJVerty ",Ie (4.7% of III persons}.1bc City's anti-poverty
strategy is 10 wad; cooperatively wiIh o<llor Io<:aI jurisdiclioos to talc. _ whlcl will
stnonglhen tho ecooomic be2l1h aDd compeilii_enes, of die Silicon V.no, as I wbole. The Cily
~ in "'" seveR ciIy CODS<Xtlum which spooson "'" Nor.h Valley PrivalelndustIy Council
(NOVA PIC) job 1raining and placemenl progrun.
" PuI!Iic: HIXISinc
45
Tho City COIIG and Housies SIaff ",ill "",1< with tile CowlIy of San!a ClllIlI COOO division,
COUll)' EnvbomheDlal HeoIth !Ild otber COBG entit!emeOl d,'" 10 dtvekJp and securo rufficient
filmiDg b". C<lw>!yriid< puNk infO!'lllation program to edI.'C8I< Ilome o",.,rs, landlords, local
buiIdins deportmenIs, -.. =actors and archit<cts aboollea<l hazards, ~, "'ll'uucUon
IOC!miques and proper abalmleDi methods. k is hoped that !undies fer Ibis program will be
obIa1ned from tile Strdc"undes !he Childhood Lead Poisoning Prevent.'on Act.
The City ~ 1<Sting and b&zard IedUc""tion in housing rebabilillUon efforts funded with
fed<ral and CiIy housing fuMs.
8. ~ S!ruc:tun!S
During tile 1995-2000 plan period. City stiff will comiwe 10 Slrenglben its' capability ~, carry
OIl! tile housing and "",,"housing COOlIIIllni!y development str.:egies described in Ibis Consc-!idate4
Plan in an efficioDi and timel, 1ll2lIDCl". The City will cnntinue 10 build • spi.-it of cooperatioo
I!DOfl8'l City stiff. nooprolil o<ganizatioos. an;! tile privale sec\<J< 10 leverage reso.m;.,.. The Cily
will COfIIlnuc it! ellOrts 10 wad cooperatively with <JIher local jurisdictioos in klentifying and
a.ldressing regional issues.
t, RecIudion of Barriers
The uearest b8rriers 10 provision of alfOfdabk housing are tile lack of lVai1lIbl. sites L-poD ",hlcb
10 build new housing or acquire existing housing and lack of soff",ieDi funding 10 adequmly
SUbsid"1ZC prc:iects so !hoy will be a&rdabk 10 tile low-and very -low inc""", households. OIIler
Mrricrs OR _ coOOitioos affecting housing consttucticn, local poIiOcal cooditions and
nelgbbori>oocl ~ alkcting !he accep(ability 0( either !fie type or density 0( project. The
specific straIqies 10 be m;ployed 10 remove or alleviate .. .x:" t·arriers OR listed belew:
Lack 0( Land or Siteo
LandCOGIs
STRATEGY
CootiDllC 10 rezooe appropriate commercial sites to. housing
I'UIP<J'CS per adopted pollcies in !he City's Housing Elemer.t.
Moo.ltor effectiveness of poIides b" providing bousing b" very-low
and low-income indlvlduals and families.
P>ovide Publlc Land at Belvw Market Costs when feasible; pursue
fund"mg 10 purc~.ase marie! "Ie property; pursue higber densily
projects whicll provide an appred.able proportiun 0( ><I)'-Iow and
1o",-incOIne housing. 10 reduc.: consttuctioo costs per unit.
Lack ol Sufficient Funamg
and Mequale Housing
Sub5idies
B. COORDINATION
!.
"-. <-"-,.,' -
-.-~ :?: "-" -.
Pursue higher densit)< projects foe very-low and low-income
housing 10 rodu<e construction costs per un'L
Punue focleraJ and state funding and taX credits 10 ~ costs ol
projects; pursue low interest loans from fedcnI. stale and private
S<JW'CeS; pursue mortgage credit ccrtifi<:31eS 10 reduce moruhly
IDOI'1g3ge paymeots.
Use ol Planned Community zooing projects to allow foe
modIfication ol;>roject densities and parking requimnents.
Pur.... available federal and state fund"mg and support an increase
in allocatiOn of such liuxIing. .
Tbrougli public ouL"<1OCh. iocrea.se public .wa.. ... ""'" ol cri6c.tI need
for affordaNe bousing and fact lhat such bousing bas had no
adverse impacts on property value>; developers pursuing new
bousing projects ., work closely with neighborbood ocganizatioGs.
As part ollbo developme1II pr<l<XS5 ollbo Coosolldated Plan. Ibo staffs oflbo COBG entitlement
cities ol Palo AIIo, Sunnyvale, Mountain V,. .... Santa Clara. San Jose. Gilroy and Ibo Urban
CoullIy ol SantI Clara met three times 10 <Iiscu5s data n:soun:es and 10 ooorclinate requestS foe
information 10 bod! pui>1ic and private Countywide agellCies. Tlx:se meetings have belped Ille
dties· bousins staffJ beuer II!lderstl!nd Ille Couruy and DOIlJ'rotit social .. me.: structure.
0Ya1bo last aeveral years, !bose c!lies have cooperated in Ibo joint funding ol. mmlber of CDBG
and bousing projects of CoontywMIe significance. Neighboriog ckies frequently cooperate in
joimly fundins bouslng for special Deeds popuJaUons. These efforts are e>pocted 10 continue.
:Mota Clara fmnty CoUalxprjyc gO Hqnsing and HomenJlC$s IsSDe;lj: City staff is also
participafi", in !be Countyw'.de effort. iDitialIy funded by • gran! from Ille NorIlleno California
~ 10 bring lOgetber ckies, homeless ... -vice and shelter pro~. CoonIy agencies,
bomeleos penoos and advocates and affordable housing developen Ie dev-elop coordlnat<d
opproaches 10 obuining greater federal fund"mg foc affoo!able housing and homeless projects and
programs and 10 Bx:rease ~ and oo""lInation lIDO"l! !be participants in developing more
effeoIive programs 10 address !he prOOlem ofbomele<sooss aod Jack of affordable housing in Santa
Clara Coumy.
47
...
T_2
Priorly Needs Summary Table
(lUS -ZOllOI
....... -...... ESTAIA""
FRIORITY HOUSING NEEDS HigI\. YIdi\m'I" Low. ftc Sud! NMd ""'" Ii; , '" I 31~'1 51~ 0:30%
CoII~>1C'S B r B I E
i . lIev
...... 1 Col' I!IwdrI > 50'S II E ~ B 101 sao -Sit I&rO' I I (3 Other
I! B I B
00.,= Jld I
E 1 E I I! 116
eo.lwd«I > lOS E 1 I! I I! ! ,.....
CoIt~>1CS f I IS -~ I! H ! E
"..".. • I ~
&+m dald • E f H E 18
0-. .... dill " i B : !l ,
Colt Bur$oIn ,. ~ I i K ~ K l(
~ Bur6en )0 5O"J, M j K i M
,..... -'iO ............ K
,
M 1 M
<>--@ i 128
M K M
CosI: Burditr1 >-.3O"l' " ~ M I K Rehab
eo.s~"'~ . I 5 K . K M
"""" , I ~ If i l'. M
ORIo , -i ' . .
v . .~
PRIORITY HOMELESS NEEDS
J'rWfily Need Level
• HigI1, UesWm, Low, No ouc:h neetl ---.............. --
B B B
~---"--'s-'~
B H B
T~~ ---"---.---
M M M
hrmanenI &oppork ~ ...... -'--_s.--_
M it K
P.m'l..nl Hr;.using ...... -........ .. 5.-.1_
K II M
_no
DOUAIISTO
AllDRUS
$1.500,000
4 ,7.30,000
15,040,000
2,100 ... 000
2,5020,000
5 .. 120 .. 00
16,384,OOC
lZS,OO
ostIIU.m>
O<><.WIO Tc>
""DRESS
--
--
--
--
--
1 _ Ass~ed to include units needed for non-elderly individuals
li ~ ~
.
PfUOfUTY 00UUIJNflY DEVELOPI.tEN'!" PrIorIIy Need r..v.r ESmIAm>
NEEDS ""If'\. ~~. Me ~ N.ed OOlUJ!S>o . ADOM>O
......, fACIUlY"""" . _c;..-.
H y--a
~FIdItia H
CMd __
!!
hfb~""""''''' B -,-H --H
ce-.............
~-
Ioid W .. DiIrpoMI ~ K
F1ooc' 0rIin ., 'lW1CJII~mCID I( .
W .. l' .... o ........ ,1lt K
bee!: In:pVtlIlllIIllI. >1
~"'OI'.mvD H
s-kIlp=_, •• I( --B
QI:rw~np::....,.....~
IUBUC SVI!IIC'E M£EI)S
.
s-i« s.omc. B
,. .. f if !s.m;.. B
VO«lIh &.Mea B
Tr.&pQi lidia, SeMces B
~~~ B
~TI'Ii"inQ H
Criino ........... M
Fa, ~ eoun...i"S' H
, ............... """"'"'"'" H
Otidcar.~ Ii
--.iI
OINt ............. .
. ..., ...... a
___ "i...rnIL twnlfIIC ~ ~ H -E rT'W. !oD1'OAIC' PRESIP:'i'A'noH NUDa K
ec:a-:~""'" .
c oiiI .......... ~ K
Cw ... ~'''_'''''' K
c::.... Cccaeu*~""'1aI .'+0 •• '" 1&$ M
MaN III __
a
00-_ "
TedriI::III ~ H
oea. e--Nr; 0 I II , ... NNda H
OTHER ~1Y DEVELOPIIIENT HEEDS
EnIr'gy EIIiciwqo truPCWIII1IMiI!J a
lead B...cI,c .. icaldii a
C.:MSe 1E! ___ c
H
1UoHI1II'Q. B
'JOTAL El'TllMTEl:I DOlUJIS NE!DID:
~----.. ...."
",-"-
$F_
APPUCA noN FOR FEDERAL ASSISTANC£
1. TYP£ OF SUBIIIISSoON:
A, ~T= ='R: p~:
J. CATE 8UBIa1TEI): 0lV15195
ApjIGcanl-'-'
3. DATE R.l!CElVED BV STATE: /1
S'bIte .........
... DATE RECEIVED BV FEDERAL AGEHCY: II
hdonoIl>io ........
5. APPI.ICAIIT 1NfORIIIA.1lON:
LogoIN_:
<>0 .. _ oa1 UnIt:
A_
Co<JnIy:
~-TI •• pbof .. lIUrnb4w:
S. EMPLOYEllIl M*BER:
7. TYP£ OF API'\JCAJiT:
I. TYP£ OF APPUCATION: --
CITY ~ PJ><.O J><. TO
PI.ANN1HG AND COMM\JNITY ENVII!ONMENT
fIFTH FLOOR
25Cl HMI11. TON AVENUE
PALO ALTO
$lINT" CLARA
SUZANNE RICHAAOS
(415)329-2418
9HOOO3li9
C
N
I. HAIlE OF FEDERAL AGENCY: U.S. Dept of _"ng & U<l>an DeWopmenl
10. CATALOG Of DOIo1ESTlC FEDeRAl. ASSISTANCE _BElt: 1421B
T1h: COMMUNITY OEVEl.~ENT BlOCK GRMT
U. ilESCRPTlIIE TTrU OF APPUCANTS PROJECT:
OOMMUNITY DEVElOPMENT BlOCK GRANT PROGAAM
1 J. AREAs AFFECTal BY PROJECT:
CITY OF PJ><.O AI. TO. (X)(J!o!;rY OF $llNTA ClARA. STATE OF CAUFORNlA
13.1'ftOPOSED PROJECT _ CdI: 07;01195
943Ql
14.. ~ DISTRJCTS: AppIicIInt: 12TH OOI'IGRESSIOf'W. o;STRlCT
pooject: 12TH CONGRESSIONAL o;STRlCT
B22000
e
o
o
o
150000
972000
11.18 APPLICATION SUB.lECT TO REVIEW BY STATE EXECIJT1VE ORDER Inn
~?C II
-Rap wi&ibdfww.
TIll:
T' Ji'.DneNwr ...... ~
Ddtllignecl:
APPUCAllON fOR FEDEAA.L ASSISTANCE
N
Xl'. ACTION PLAN (1995-1996)
B. HOOSlNG AND COMM1JlooTfY DE\'EWPMElII"T RESotjltCES
Palo AIlo is <"OOlm..'tt£d 10 purstili>g alI .,1Iilabl. federal. stato. local and privalE "'~ as
opprct>riaIo. H<rin:ver, 1bere is 1imiIe4 saff available and !ben:ron: Palo Abo encourages and
. "'f'IIO'IS ~ bousin& develo!:<n, 00meIess _ provider> and County agencies 10 apply
be fe<IcraI bousiDg plogIanJS be housing activities wilIili> Pal" Aho ",benever !bey an: eligible
app!iconIs nlbet \ban tile C~ itself 'l'P1~ing.
I Federal Pro&rams
F.IIIibIe Acdnnes Federal Housing Resources
hquisitio!> CDBG, HOME (via Ifle StalE). Scctioos 202
wIll
hquisltioD of Az-JOsk Federally l1HPRHA, COOO
Subsidized Hoosing .
Rebabilit&tioo CDBG. HOME, Sees. 202 and 811
New~"IioD CDBG (be land &. pre-developmenl ooIy).
HOME, UHTC, Sec. 202. Sec. 811
Home 8u)'el' AssisIJmce ... local n:sour<:<:s (MOC program}
ReDlOll Assistance Se<:Iion 8, Hope be Elderly In<!epeodence
(Co. Housing A.."'1boriI:y)
Homeless PrevenIion Supportive Housing Program. Sbelter Plus
Care, S<ctioo 8 Moderate Rehabilitation
SRO, Safe lhvens fur !be Homeless,
E~ Sbelter GAnts
Homeless Assistance FEMA, Em<rgency Sbelter Gran!
•. StalE Progyams: Cnrrelllly tile StalE bousing programs .,bicl, would be most applicable 10
Palo Abo', housing straIeJ!Y an: out 0( fun<Is. They are !be RcoIal Hoosing Construction Program
(RHO') and u.. CaJifOlI!ia Hoosing Rehabilitation Program -Rental Compooelll (CHiU'-R).
cr'
~. -""
,-'
-. • ,r"
".-~ -
Tbtsc programs are funded by ",Ier initi>tive approved bond issues, Another bond is.<u< ",ill
DOed 10 be passed before lIly fu!l<fmg ~ be Ivaililble.
Nonprofit bousin.!: deveklpers have utilized Ihe California Housin.!: Financ<o Agency's (CHFA)
MuIli-FImiIy _ Program f<x permanent mortgage financing for rental property. The SU",',
I..ciw Income Housin.!: fn Credit program has also beeR utilizd. These programs may be used
in the I\nure.
b. LccalI'ropJms: The primary 1oca1 bousin.!: """""'" available in Ihe C~ 0{ Palo "..ho is !he
City', "Housing Reserve Fund". The Fund bas two components· Co<I'.mercial and Residential.
The Fund can be used for acquisition. ",habilitation, ".... coosIrUCtioo and pralcvelopmcnt of low
income housing. The Commercw Fund is directed Sowards proMmg add'otional affordable
bousinS units f<x P-.Jo A!Io', wcd 1Onoe. The Residential Fund can be used for any I)'pe of Jaw
income_in.!:.
The "Conun<i<:w Housing kserve" is funded wIth bousing mitigation fees required from
developers 0{ =w and iMuslrial sp""". The fund currently bas about S20 million
available for "'iI projects.
The "Residential HoIHing R<scrve" is funded with in-nO'. fees under Ihe Cily Below Market
Housing prcsr.m from residential <levelopers. This fund presently bas • very ;maJ] balance.
c. l.cyerariDi aod Matcbine Requirements: The Cay of Palo Alto will1evcrage federal and
privall: Ilcusing funds 10 the greau:st extent feosible =istem with the goals identified, The C~
will CDCOUnIge bousin.!: project sponsors 10 seek private financing and private grantS. The Cily
will also utilize n' 1oca1 bousing reserve fuOOs as appropriate 10 leverag. federal and private
boosiog fuDds.
If Ihe Cily applies f<x and receives FY 95 HOME funds Ihrouglllhe Slate of CaJjfornia, Ihe Cily
will utiIiu its ~ housing reser;e funds IS Ihe required matcIL Where eligible, COOO funds,
whick are obligated f<x housing activities and support servi<=, will also be used as • portion of
Ihe matching requiremeIlI fvc ftderal !lousing prograa>s (f<x eumrk:, Sbe!ter Plus ('.are),
d. Palo Afro r"J!"d')CjIJi Fund -~ of Comrrnmitv ScQ'ircs: Tbe HWIlan Senice Division
in the CiIy'. Department 0{ COOlIllUIli!y Services cootracts with """Profit agencies 10 provide
prl)jl ams foe' residents .. 'ith.11uman SU\'U needs. 'Tbe c.ontracts are aW1cled 00 an Ilmual basis
IhrougIlIhe Hwnan SeMce Rerourre ADocatioo Process (HSRAP) whlcb is guided by tile City's
Human k!arloos Commission. In tile 199419S fuca! year, Ihe Cily Coonc~ approved grantS
t<lIaIing olmosI $964,000 10 Jocal agencies In support of prognoms .. .lel! IS senia< ~, child
care, "'"" counseling. information and referral, rape crisis, slngk parenting, IlUtrition. Jow~
beaIth care. renraI ossistmce and homeless prevention. and rebabilitati,e services for !bose with
physical. .,.. memal disabilities.
51
" .
•
."_ II-... --
. --'
' .. . . , .....•
." .--,-<-
-.-. ".,1"'.
, .~.
L For-Pro!X: The primary privare resou= for hooslng in Palo Aho is mltigati<.-n paymcDlS from
eommerclal dcvelopeB described 01>0"". Units provide4 b) private w;idential develop.. ... unIler
!he (;Ky", Below Mar'I;.ct R=DtAI and Ownership program is another iroporUnt privale JeSOUn;e.
Private _ lise contribute 10 affordable hcusing chrougb advantageous finar.<:ing I!llder !he
FJnlI's Affordable H\lusing Program (AHP).
b. NQQl1Illfi!' N~ housing developers op<!lIting in Palo Al"to contribute !heir 0..." equity
funds 10 10", iDoome housing projects boIh of !heir cwn and OIller nooprO\'ilS. Nonprofits also
contribute substantial smH lime and energy to affordable bouWJg effc<ts mucb of !hat lime is pa;d
for from _ '"'" resourus. The '0_' boaJd memben of local nooprolits lise contribute
many hours of unpaid time to 1111= efforts.
LOCAL PIJBUC AND PJtIV ATE !lESOlJRCES FOR AFFORDABLE BO\.1SlNG
"'" --...... B_ ......... ..,...., -• t C II .. &wi .-. -----LOCAL. P\J"BLX:
c-.IIq X X
~
-as,. x x x .........
CIoY ...... _ -X
MCCr.-.. J[ --x x x x
t_fm<
c-.Dqa<l X x
SociI!l~
ranATI!:~
_1aaI& o-rr-,;;,. x x
p,;,.~ x x I
AlII' ,...,.,.... X X X X X --X X
-&
~
52
.. "
. ,' \ .
" .. '
,'., .
C. DESCIUPTJON OF ACTMTIES
n.. following Table ..., die accompan)ing narrative de",ribe !he activities 10 be undert.1kta
cfwiDg die 1995-96 you. Tbeso actlvities .,.,. developcd afta taking into coosideratioo tlle needs
IS idemified in Section D, tIM: priorities described in Section m, and tlle re>O\lI'CeS cle<cribec! in
Ibis Section (Soction IV). Along ...-ilh tIM: description of eacb iDdivldualacuvily is inchule<l tlle
location of die activity ..., die lead agency fer die activily.
I ltcrgl Hpnrinr Actiyitjq·
Ao identified in -., m of Ibis I".an. die provision of affordable rernaI WliIS is 011< of tlle IIlO5I
signifi<:am _ in Palo Mo. Listtd below is a descrij>tion of !he activities planned ~ 199>96
10 lI<ldn:ss dlaIll!'ed.
moo F1m<l$1I'ilI be used Ie ossis! in tlle develoj>l!>cnt of. variety of bousing projects whie1l1l'ill
provide affordable !lousing 10 low and very low income families, cflSabled and single persons.
Funds ""'Y be used for predevetopm<DI expenses, acquisition 0( land 0< existing btJildings,
nbabilitalion costs c< otbe, CDBG eligible expenses.
Funds are expecIed 10 be ooeded for several oogoing projects 'lillie! were identified in !he CiIy's
FY 1994 Compr-..Ileosive Housing AffonIability Stra,egy (CIlAS) approved by MUD on
February 11. 1994. They are in various SIageS of site se=ll, predevelopmeDl and construction.
lD odditioD. tllere are new bousing projecls "'hiek are expected 10 proceed during FY 95-96.
Funds may also be ~ for oilier boosiDg projeclS !lOI presen!ly lcoown wbien moe! !be housing
aecds ~ in this c.qnso!jdate4 Plan.
• Objeclives of tlle Housing Development Fund
The City of1'a1o AIIo CollSOli4a'ed Plan and Hoosing EJqn;:nts bo<h emphasize !he great r>oc:d for
affo<&oblc bousing for low and very low incro>e households in Palo Ah", While an IypeS of
bousing are needed in die City. die QmSQIjdated Plan objectives IiJcus on die creation and
preservaIion of aJIrypes of reD!>I housing with an emphasis 00 bousinj; for singles and very small
bouseI>oIds wbe ore bomeless, at risk of bomelessness 0< of very low and low income, bousing
for persons 'IIilh special needs and boo'ing for families ,.id cllilllrell.
• Housing Development Fund -Purpose ..., Operations
The J"I'P05< of die Housing Development Fund is Ie have • pool of funds available on an ongoing
hasis 111 utilize wbea necessary '" facilitate die development, rehabili .. tion and preservation of low
B:ome. multifamily boosing. Housing development opportunilies come up throughout !he year
and due 111 !be nature of die reo) estate ma."ket, I quick response is frequently De<:eSSary. The
54
, ",--
,.. ..
•
Hoasin2 DeveIopmenI Fun:! includes boosiDg funds from several sources primaril! CDllG, City
HoIlsiq: Reserve ml HOME funds. Eacll funding soorce is acCounted fur separately. The City
...orb closei)' "ilIl1ocaIly active oooprotil!lousing deveJope ... and supportive hou5ing providers
011 projed proposals.
The IICIllaI process foe initiating • project will vary depending on the particular circumstances.
UtlWly, die ~ hrusing opons;:>r will apply 10 die Departmem ol Planning ...: Communily
Em ilOO1£tJl l>r bousin/: subsidy funds wbea die! are in negoti.>tion for • particular sire. AJ. O!her
limos, die City ID8)I is.= • R<:quesI For l'ropo5als, The City may provide funding from • variety
of """""'" """"'-';og on die !lIIlIn oldie project. Sources of funds in addit>JO 10 COOO inclu<le
II» CiIy', Io<:aI Housin: Itesen'e and federa) HOME funds. The P!anoing Depar1meDl will
presem recommondaIioDS foe eacb project lOgelller VIitlJ • proposed fimding pocuS. 10 !he Ci:y
CvunciI foe approval
In most .n cases, fw:ds will be provided as • loan. The Icon will be s.cu .. e.! by Ill£ property.
The repaymenr tmns and _ rate bav< 10 be tI~ 10 the parti<uIar project oinc~ low
income bousiDg !ypicaIly is ~ from multiple sources ..m. specific: reqWremelllS. Wllerever
possible, Ihe City will aaempllO obtain a repaymelll 0{ its funds II some poin! in the furuze. This
will enable the Housing Deve10pment Fund 10 colllinue I<> be used 10 create new bousing
opportucities even if federal subsi<f,.. decline in !he furure .
• u.e or COOO 1'1",<10
COOO funds are a vila! part olthe financing pocuge foe low income !lousing developmeDl
projecU. They ~ ." important soorce ol funlfllll foc \be .... lier pIwes or • housing project.
CDoo funds lIe I fairl, flexible S<lIlI'Ce foe predcvelopment and iIC<,."Ulsition """'. Nonprolil
hoosing developer; typi<:ally need COOO funds 10 e<>mplete prellminary arcbiteauraJ and
enviroDmcuraI studios to docermine \be feasibilily of a propooaI. This 11'",,:1: must be done in ooIer
to obtain _ ml state financing "" privat<' _loans. f<Jr some 1l'J>eS 0{ housing subs;me.,
lbe COOO funds CCW!I as • local matcll or equity. CDoo funds can also be osed 10 acquire
e.ili!ing rental .~ and to repa .... and reDOV"~ rental bousing. However, aU<Ctl, paying
for new CODSIIUCIion ol housing is 00[ an eligible activity wxler COOO regulations,
• Use of HOME Funds
HOME funds ~ l'rimariIy 10 be used 10 subsid'1U boo'ing construction costs and acquisitiOll
OOIIS. Units =Mog HOME funds lIlIl5I serve loll/ and very low income housebolds. The City
,....,ived an awore! ol $1 millioo or fisca! year 1992 HOME funds from the State on MarclI29.
i993. The City', C!lIire FY 92 HOME gran! was allocated ID the Bark.r Hotel project by the City
Coonc~ 00 December n, 1993. The Cily did nc< apply foe HOME funds in either tile 1993 O£
1994 rounds of f\Jnding since there were no eligible projects which we,. ready eDOUgh to put
!oget!ler I oompetitivc application.
5S
. 'f..:
>--.-.
• , .".
'. :.
Tho 1995 rourd 0( HOME funding is .~ to be ann<JUI>Otd in Ma~, 1m. Tho Cj[y intends
10 opp!-j for !be maximum $1 millioc probably for !he purp<><e 0( su!>sid" \Zing !he construction
cost. of 1be I'fOI'O'<d SRO project 00 AlmA Str:et.
I'.meTgency Shelter and Services: Paio AIIo plans 10 continue to provide annual CDBG funDIng
to our Ioc~ provider of shelter and homeless services -!he Urllan Mlnistty 0( Palo Alto a!ld to
regiooaI providers 0( sbcl1a" and se<Vi= sucII as Emergency Housing Consortium. PaJo AIIo also
iIUndo to e<mIiD:Je workIDg willi !be Sanla Clara CounIy Collaborative 00 Housing and Homeless
ls..<ues, and o<hes-Iood juriscf_ to in:reasc the number 0( sbelt<r beds, especiaJly year round
beds and to increase services ann.ble for homeless indi-.iduals and families.
Homeless PreveDlion: PaJo AIIo plans 10 continue 10 support Countywide efforts 10 obtain grea!er
!tmdlni for !be en>ergeDC) lWlta! I!ld Moogage Assistance Program oper-a<ed by the Emergency
Assistance NetwOlt 0( local ogene les {Ihe American R<d Cross operates !he program in !be Palo
Alto area} whi<:h pro\'~ loaDs and grants 10 prevent boos<holds from losing !heir boIlSh'1g 0<
defllulting on lhei< home mort.gage.
Transilioo From Homelessness To Pe!tnanent Hoosing: WlIh the completion 0( the rehabilit.1tlon
o(!be Ba...ur HoIeI in February. 1995, Palo Alto oow has available 26 units «permanent SRO
housing .. rents affordable 10 persons witIl incomes between 30% I!ld 50% «the meQWl income.
FIVe o(!he _'s units are fUlly accessible by wheelchair users. PtiociIy for occupancy is for
peno::lS ",110 are bomeless (either umhehered or sbeltercd); persoos with disabilities and persons
0( extremely low iDcoGles. Tho Cily intends to cootioue 10 support the provision 0( oo-,;te
"""""'ling services at !he Ban;er and screening 0( prospective tenants by !he lirl>m Ministry.
AIIl:ough !be Cily 0( PaIG AIIo bas aiow overall poverty rate (4.1" 0( an penoru;). reductio. in
the DIJlD!Jer 0( households living in poverty is still important. Efforts 10 i"crease !he incomes 0(
extremely low and very 10 .... income households is also • prioriIy. PaJo Alto works cooperatively
with CIber ~ jurisdictions 10 take acUons whiell will strengtbe1> the ~ ~ and
compeUtlvenes. 0( !he Sillcon Valley os • wbole. lbe Cj[y p.vIicipalei in !he seveD oily
c;onsortium wbicl! spo!lSO<S !be North Valley Private Industry Counc~ (NOVA PIC) job training
and p!acc:mem program. PaJo AIIo will also be assisting in ~ sm>ll business deve!opmem
efforts including considering !be provisions 0( CDBG funds for loans for sma!l eO!repreneur
programs including an ongoing program for "'omeB sponsored by tbe local YWCA and ellOru
by the Urtan Ministry 10 .. sis! bomcle<s persons in • developing business ell!l:rpnse..
56
, '.'~
•
" -,
-~-. ...",':.
,..."'-" -'; .
.'.
D. LOCATIONOFACTMTIES
f<O!"PNc Dj5fribctjgn.
Housing 1w:IMties: The CiIy will cooslcler the prevision of an types of boosing assistance on I
C~ basis consisreul -with the pc!icics of the CiIy" Comprebensiv< PIa!!.. The Cily does DOC
bave specific largot ImIS for bousing activities but auemp<s to clistributt iilt-sidiz.ed housing
Ihroughout dle CiI:y.
Coo:munitj Develcpmenl Activities: For dle 1995196 fis<:al year, !be City Ccunc~ has IIcIoptecI
Wnilieo. youth and <:OIJIJIlWlity IS I priori:y. Specific efforts are being coonfmalecl in the
Community Servka aDd Police DepartmonlS to focus on acti,itics and ~ in the VenIUra
POighborhood. A number of City sponsored prognms L'ld activities serving low and very low
income peISOIIS ba .. either beeI! andertaken oe .,.. proposecI. The Ventura Neigbborlloocl (Census
lI'act SlO1. Block Group 2) bas • large proportion of modest rental housing, • nl.ative!y big!!
proportion ofmiDorily 0Dd_ groups and 48.46 S of the bousobolds are below the COllG
iD<ome eligibillty limits.
E. I)RGENT NEED
!a the even! of. local, Slat< or federal cflSaSler decleration foe areas within the bourxlaries of the
City of PaJo Alto, the CilY resen-es the rigll< 10 use CDlIG 0< other available federal funds to
abot< jrnmrm.re and """"sa!)' bazards. Such fuDds may be usee! for staff efforts, loaDs, or
~ grants 10 ilJecI<cI parties, as approved by Cily Council and aIklwabie lIDler the pertinent
Federal O.ikWjrcs.
F. MONITORING OF ACTMTIES
The Cily will COIlIinue 10 mooiIor cJooeIy dle activities carried out to fo->nher the goals of the
CoDSoIidarfd Plan. Foe an CDBG ODd HOME fo.mcled activities, an annual pcrfonua...,., report
will be comple'.ed in. occonlance with f.:deral requirements cIetailing the doIIaB e:<pcndcd, the
bencficiari<s servee!, ODd the program goals ""hieved. Additiooally, City staff willlIiOIlltoc each
funding subrecipienl 10 insure compr..~ with all regulations governing their aclministr.lIive,
financial, and programmatic opcntioos; ancI 10 make sure the su~ipieDts ~v. dleir
performance objectives ... iIhi!I scI>eduIe and budS"'-
G, COORDINATION
As part of the 6evc1opmenl process of the Coosoliclalecl Plan. the !>Iaffs of the CDoo eotitlemeDl
cities ofPaJoAho, Sunnyvale, MOIlIlWn YIe,.., Santa Clara, Gilroy, San kse, and the Url>an
Cowq of Santa CWa mo:t to disr.uss obta resources, and 10 coo.-dinat< requests for information
10 both public and private CounIywide agencies. These II!<'ctlngs bave belped the cities' staffs
bener 1IDIlerstan:I the Coonty and nonprofit social service stru..."tUIe.
51
. . '-
. '--.' .-
-
I
I
)-'~' ~. '~~'~~~~~ ... ",:
.--~
--~--"
Over !be IasI sevaal years, IIl<se cities have cooperated in Ibe joint fundinB of I IJIllnller ot CDBG
one! housil>8 projcds ot Countywide .ignificllDOO. Neighboring cities frequently COOPCnlte in
joiDtly fundi.n& housing for spc<:i.al needs popul.1tioos_ These efforts are e:q>ectcd 10 continue.
To _ • cooo:dioatOO opproacll 10 tI>e CiIy'. Ilwnan service funding efforts, t!>e CDBG
CoordiDator aoo the AdministratOf' of Human Sen-ices meet often W I'CviclJf J.Jld discuss
applicatioos m:eivod Ihroogh boll, !he COBG and HSRAP p,ocesses. Additionally,. member
ot!be Human Relations Commission serves on the COBG CiIize!!S "" ... ls..'ry Cootmi""" 10 Ivoid
duplkatlon oteffon ODd 10 ISSUl'C collaboratioo within Palo Aho.
The CDBG and bousing staff 1150 attend and participa!c in the semi-anJTUO! Human Services
Provider Network mmings coordinate<! by the Human Se!vkes Division 10 promote
undemanding aDd collaboration amocg the local public ser".'ice ageocie._
During the 1995196 year, Cily staff will COllIimJe 10 stn:ng1ilon its capability 10 carry oot !be
bousing and comim",;:), developmonI strategies dcscril:>Cd ;" Ihls OmsoTidated Plan in an efficie",
ancl timely manner. The City will cootinue 10 build • spirit of cooperation between Cily .... if.
DOnprofits and !be private seclOl'.
H. CI>BG SUBMISSION REQVIREMENTS
During the 1995t96 fiscal year,!be City wiD aIlOCIIe sm.ooo in COOllIllmity Developrne'" Block
Gralll funds. The City will rea; .. $822,000 from MUD as tile annual eotilkment portion. and
$}$O,OOO will be available from program income. It is esriImtcd th3I $100.000 in program
mco...., will be generated duriaI tile 1995196 program year primarily from tile repaymelll ot
principal and imcrcst from eaisting loans from the HoosIng Improvemelll Progrant_ $$0,000 in
program inoome ...... r=l\<d in provious fiscal yean in excess otthe IIDOWII anlicipated. It is
difficuk 10 predid tile exact IIIDOWIt of program income ,.hklt will be roccived as many low
inrerest or ~ferred loans are paid in tun ""'"" prope!1)' is sold oc refinanced.
,-"-------. ~
Nam!Ive b' Table! -Table and Narratioe "m be inserted UPOD completion <>f CDBG funding
1IIOeoDoe· m>oiWDe"'!aOOcs.
Namtivc for Table 1
Project
5ItO .. Alma
~1'Irl~
, Bctmna b-DUabJcd
33lJ Emenco _
M"rtiprloa I'rujea b-651 Hamilimo
Io6ddIefieId "Well Sit<' LOI5 fm
Sharod Liv..,. IIouoes
EIo=oa N<K1h ""'-........
Feasibili!). !WIc Acquis'ition b'
Family
~ E>pemes R.r.r.d " SiIoand __ ,
E.mc:rgmc:y JCt!I.b>T"'a6na Loaa b'
Sm.k F..iwy .".....
. ...... : : .. .
AdirllJ
New_
Acq'ilirioa a.."ld
rebbili1alic."G
Ne1r cousuuctiO:a
Sew CODStr..ctioa
.A.:qu1sition and:
rebabiliLatioD
Nev cons-.ructioo
ltdW>iIito!ioo
NC..-~
NJA
Itchabilir.atioD:
..
Number of UDiIs
Ahola 107 .....
66 "'""
Ahau!: l4 ra:ruts
4 >mils
1 or rr.ore unit!
1 bou>n;
IlIo;;sebolds 6_
Emmote4
3O~ tmia.
Sf A
As """"" _
MisceDlUlO<>IS C<>SIS Related To Site and Project Feasibilily: CDBG Housing Development Funds
are also u.<ed to pay for """" associated with !he investig.tlon cl !he fe.<siMily cl sites and
properties for ocquisition by !he Cily or DOnprofllS for affordable, 10 ... income housing. These
COOlS usuaIly oeed 10 be paid prio£ 10 • project being officil.lIy created in !he budget. Typica!!y
Ibese rosts ore for appralsaIs. enviroomeOl.ill nlllics and soil 1CSting, tiLIe reportS "'xl desigD
skelches. Usually DO more !han $25,000 per fiscal year ",,11 be needed foc !hese <x;>enses and
oI\ea much less.
EmergeIE)' Loans For Single family Rehabilituion; AItlloagh tl!e Cily does DOl bave an active
siDgle famiIJ _ Ioo.n programs, it is possible thai seiioos emergen<y _ DIllY occur.
In sucl siruatioos. income quaf!lied bomeowners cooId apply for " reh'ibilitation Ioo.n in order Ie
I<pIir !heir home. The intent is only to pro"o'ide fi.-.m:lal assistance 10 homeowners who's bomes
"".,. serioos building co<Ie deficiencies and ,,00 bave no O!her reSOllI<es 10 _ repairs.
60
.. ; .
•
IV. AFI'F.NDIX
A. Glossary !If TmDS
B.~
C. ~ I'arlSdpelioD Plan
D. PubIk NoDreI
Eo Jacome Umils
F. Tablo Ie
G. Summary of CIti2aI Ct.>mmeDts
H. Homeless SIlrrey Statisti<s
61
.. -,.' ' .. .'
APPENOIX A
em;r"..tjoo A wriItt:a .....-bued on oupportiDg evidence !bat muSl be I:<pI lvailable for
iIlIpedioIl by liLTO, by 1110 Illspeaor Geacral of HUD and by 1110 public. Tht usenioo shall
be c!eem<d II> be o<aJrIIe ""'"-" HUD _ 0IIlctwiIc a&r inspecting 1110 tvidena: and
providina clue DOIioc and opporIW!itJ for ~.
CmmMem" gJau (or ·Uc ~ Tbr: cJcxvrnent tbal is submiae4 10 HUD chat &oern!S _ u Ib:
pIarmiDs cIoc>_ (~ lIcusiD& at'fonJabiliIy IttIIegy and COOUI!IJDiIy develapmenl
plan) oflbe jurisdlc:DoA and In oppIicIIioD f<lr I'wldins _ II!)' ofl!lc CommuniIy Planning
and DcveInpnwd formula snm "'''I'IWI (COlIG, ESQ, HOME or HOPW Al. whD is
p"'paued ill ~ WI>. 1110 process pm!<:ribed in Ibis parL
Cqrpnnhgp All orpnlz>tioII of ~ con!iguous units of cenem loco! gOveIIl!Mlll!bat _ ..m.a ... llingle UDit of geocnIlocaI SO""WDtIll f<lr JIUIIlOS"S of I!lc HOME program (see
24 CFR. port 92).
Q>s.l!!mlca The extm Ie 'IIIbicb gross IIoosintI C06IS, ur1"djnS utiIiIy costs, excool 30 pon:enI
of II""" income, based on data a .. ilabJe from Ibe U.S. Census Bureau.
Elderly person A penoo who is .. leas! 62 y ..... of age.
fmrwocy 1il¥:1!!:r-,..ny faciliIJi WI>. OV<:r1Iight sJeepin!: occommodatlons. !be primaJ)' I'WP"'"
of .. flicJI is '" proride IImlpOr.tl}' wI...-loe :be homeless in geoerol oe f<lr specific populations
ollbe homeless,
fl<trcrpM Im!t-jrmmc fwpi'Y. Family '11 __ is betweea 0 and 30 pen:em of!be _
iDcoaJe lor: Ibe ...... IS dot!:nniDod by HOD _ OIfjllSCmenlS f<lc <maIler and Jarger families,
"""'IJl!bat HUD II1II)' _fish iDcome cellini> bigber or lower IlIaD 30 pe=nI ofl!lc median
f<lr dIo __ en IlIo basis of HUD', fiDdinp !hOI sucIt variations m necessary becaul;e ol
prevaiIiDg levels of CODSaUCb<>G <OSIS or fair _ rems, or lIlIlSUally blgh or k>w bmiIy
iDcomes. ;
Hgmc!ess family -cliMI!!!, A family composed ofdlo roOowing !ypeS <lfbomeless per.ooos:
.. IeasI ODe paRU or guanlian and ooe child tmder IlIo ase of 18: a pn:g!lallI """'"'" or l
pmon iJldIo process of &eClIriDg kgal cwto4y of a penon tmder IlIo age of 18.
H"'P"h' pengo A yOUlh (11 years oc YOIIJl&Of) DOt ~ bY an adult 08 yoars or
older) or III adult 1IIitbouI: childreJI, who is homeless (not imprison<d or C<berwise dctai:lcd
pur1UIDI to In Ai:! of Cocgn:so or a State 10",,). iDcluding 1110 I'oIlowq:
(I) All iDlfIVidual who Iao:b • fixed, "'gular and IIIequate nighttime raidell<e: and
('2) All indlviduaIwoo bas • primaJ)' nigJudme residence !hat is:
(i) A Sl>pCt\i.s«I publicly or priYAlcly op<:I2red _,Q designod 10 pro'ide t<:mporaIy living
aa:ommodaIioos (mcJnding 'II01fare _Is, eongregate shelren and In!lSitional housing for Ibe
lbelllally ill):
(a) All iDstiMion Ibat prov1des • t.e:npo<aIy residence for individuals intended 10 be
~;or
'; -..
; ,.
(w) iI of ""'" • ~ IIIIt tho abilily could be improved by m<n ouitable housing cobditioos: ..
(2) hi,," I 4evc1opmoD!al <liAbility as defined in secti<>n 102(7) of tho Developmental
DisabiliDeo __ and Bill ofRljllls .\cI (42 U.S.C. 6001-6007): a
(3) be tho survivUJc ~« m<mbers of IDY fOmi!y !hal had beoIIliving g, an __ unit
wlIb tho cIe<:eued momber of tho family who bad • disabili!y II tho lime of his or bot death.
Pomrv kW family. FamiI)r MtII ... _ below tho poverty _ as cIerined by tho Offi<:e
of M.na...-m and BwlJeI and revised amrJal1y.
Scvm C!lIt bpn\eB. The exJm 10 'lIIhicIl_ hous"'s COOlS. ird"dina IIIiJiry e<'sIs. =eed 50
JICIt:CIIt of __ • baled "" elm available li'oin tho V.S. em.... B=au.
~. Art Slate of tho thlited SIaJea and tho COIDIIlODWCallh of Pueno lOco.
InwjrjppaIhogsjDI. • .. project dill is clesigDed 10 provide bousing and oppropriaIe supportivc
-. 10 homelcss persons 10 flII:i1i1ate 100_ 10 ~ livins ... iIhln 24 moo!hs. or
• Ion ... period applO''Cd by HUD. FOI" pwposes cf tho HOME program. Ih= is DO fIUD.
oppro .. ed lime period for I!lO"ing 10 iodcpencIent 1iviDB.
Unit of I!'ePCiTJ1 Jrgl tpyelJllPC!¥ A cily. H)":D. township. aNJlfY. parish. village or other
ICDOrII pu<pooc pof!ti<:a! subdivision of Slate; and urban ~; and I coosortlum of suck
poOOcaI aubcIivisiona ~ by HUD in aa:ordaDce MtII the HOME program (14 CFR part
92 or tho CDOO program (24 CFR pan 510).
tJrba; C!!lJyY, Sec definition in 14 CFR 570.3.
. ... ': .' ,
.-.',-
.. ,-.
~ ','< ~iii~~:J::li!~.,:· :~~<~El~i '~:~~:j ~:;, ~ '-;;;'.",".;;';'~;"";'~""::-":"2-':'~::;:ZC~"!!',
Ja ~ witk t,b.I:. applicable StatuteS IlId the replatiom ~ 1hc. consoIi4ltctl SUatel)' IDe! plan
JOFlMIoas,Ilio JudI-~ wt;
CIII-. hrC·"._ J>I.u -It l> folloMlll • -ddza pnidpz>iotI flu ~ .
lJ'ro9Id<Ilor no! """"""I" -panidpa-' -,.,-... plIasis "" J>OTIiclPa-by j>OIiollS of law DIJ _to _ 'lIII<> .,. _IS of chaD ODd bnptod.,.., _ or orea:; ill wbI<ll fw>c!s are
,p!OJICSOII1I> ... ....." lOll! ~!Dr pL~ or_a ia ..... __ to _
"""._ .. _by IX loa! jmisdlaioo;
~ ~ _ reasooabIe aDCI tfmcIy ac=s 10 local ""'"""'" ~ D4 _ rdocm, to
u.. .......... J>"'I"""I ..., or -. IS req_ by Ih< rquIatiODs ol w Se<:n:wy. IIlII rdatlu, '" Ill<
_ II&< or _ 1IlI4<r tbe Aa;
~ lor _ Osmtmae '" 1""]1$ repr<SeDta1lve of _ 01 "'" W _'" "'come thaI
requoot "'" _ iII_pIq ~ wit!> w loocI and 'l'P" of ........ ", 10 b<_toy
1IIe _'"'"
<I.l'nMdcs "" pabli< _IS '" obuill _ ...... oA4 '" ""J'OOd ., prop=ls and q'ostioas at all
...,.. of d>c ",,,,,,"wty ~t program. iDdodln: '" Ieoa ... ~.t of >=15, tile ... ,.., at
propou4 KIM"",-""" .-.. ofpro:ram ~ ...m<l bcuilll' W!! be hdel ,nor adeq=e
ltOdc:2., at rime::l Dd kx::ations ~em 10 potentia! or actual bcDeticiarics. ane! 'With .ac.co.OmOO·PQD for
1ho-..,pccI;
5.h0Yi42s Ioc .. timely ~ttom answer 10 .. 'tft"'.a: oompw:cs aod' ,rie~:a~ ... ichi.a is wod:icg 4i.ys na-c ,,-10;_
6._1ilies b~ Ill< DtC4s 0{ ODtl·EoJllsb .pukitlJ _" ...;u be met in ... QSe vr poblic ~
,.".,.. • "".5.,.", D"",ba of IK> ... EoJfi5l .peaiOng _"',", .,." be =.n.ly apc<!<4 ID pmsap.~
Citiaoa hrlH;>a--hi<>< IC .. ~ of i1S _. WI ",mmlDlily _pm .. ' flu IC RUl), tile
~-=
LMct Ill< """'" ponitipatiOa nqWmDOD15 of t9l.DX
l.Ptqwe41!s 1>ousinI-commmuty _pm"" plaa om<! ... uaI use of [aoc!s ia _= ";<11
19l.DX aaIIlDi4c ;., lIousinJ aDd _1DIiIy _pmc1I' ;lalI .. _. _Ie TO th. pob['<-
~ FDtlIxo-F. E~ -!he juri5<!ktiotl...;]l >/liImaa..Jy _ !air 110""..,. P'"I'= aD
analysis of impoc5moa1S ad __ ~ Ie arryin& out !his ct!tificaliDn. Azrd._ -!he _" ..m be <=cIutU<! aod·'--ill """I'....,.,litl>. truc VI 0[ the
C!wiI Rip1S ..... of 1%4 (42 U.5.c. 2!lOO!I). the Fait HotmDg All (42 usc. 3&)1-3620). 1M Ai,<
~_ Aa or 197$. ~ Or<l<n I1Il63. 1HZ, 12138, 12m lUll! 12892, Scaio. S04 0[ the
R<b_ Aa or 1973 (29 u.s.c. 194). the Ameri<3 .. with Dis:abitiu.. AJ:t (truclI) ."d
iRiplemeo'io& ,.,.-.
Anti.4Jispla= 11 mt aDd PelD Ijotl Pl2II -:It wm CCIllPIy wit:I: the ~ an1 relocatio:!. requl:rt::nenG
of the tJ:illorm Rclo<aIioD A<sistance and Real Properrt Acq_ Polidos AI;< al19'lO. os ...... w. as
r<.quired ...... 191= aDd Fc:d<nl imp_tiDl ~ti<>"". an<! t!w it bas iI1 c!fea and Is Ibn""", •
I<SidetItiala,,,idisp_ ItI4 reioca_ asmw>'" pLul ~ WIder scale> lO4(d) 0{ the -I
and CclmmuzUt.y t:>evckipmcDt AD. of 1974. :&:i ~cSecl,. end the reJocation :equI:rema.15 of 19I.::ctI
. . :
c ~ ;,~." ~ .. ,
.' ..
.','
.0-.
-'-. ' ..
I .. DRAFT :
Il"-' op-.I _tic .......... "".s.r seafO. 10S{aXll) "O(!h. Ilu...w,."d Cammtmfty
o..eIol""""' M 0( 1974, OJ -.,; "
Dnac F ... W~ -"Wi!! '" ..m" ,,"ltIn .. 10 prtWi4< • druJ_ ~-b):
lh!>llIIIflI& • .-III>!f!1IJII <l1li''''>-c.a, !!Ie IIlIl>WM ,..,,1IIiaun; -Iioa. 4lspeosms. P'"' • • or _ 0(. ____ IS J'",blblted m w p.o.""" _I:pWz _ ip':<iIyiII& the
__ will b< tUa oplIIst ... p~ b violation of 5d p",hlbloo!!;
2.Es!ablidllq .. ~J dn<t.fla _ P"'l"'"' 10 inrcrm employee> &!oouI-
(.}~ ~ ofdruj _III die _!<place;
(I»'Ib< "..roc~ poIlq of IIWD-. , dru,-fro. _"kpla<e;
«)AJ!y .-..lIable cIru, couaseIiDs. ~ .04 emplOJ'O< "'~"l"" P"'","", and
(d)The poaaIties _ may b< illlposo<! .poo .mpro-jOeS f<)r Cr.g .bust ..,,,tiO,,, O<OItriJ:tl iD !he
..oo:placo; "
!.M.ating k a ~uirement WI ~ ~ployee 10 be efigaged i.D th~ pcrlon::anct ot the pun be p\"ell. I
copy o! tlIe :StalcmeDt rcqldrcd by pangrlph 1;
. 4..NctilYin, tbe e:2lpToy« in the .sQtenl~I:U requi:re:Q by pm:zrapb 1 tut, IS J con.:!icoc of cmpl'o:UletU
ude.r the gaz!:t. the Ulployee ...;n •
{a) AJ)idt: by the 1emt5 or die stJ[£mcnt;, Illd
. {It)Notify die ~ i!l9o'ritiD& c! his or:bc:r COJr\'icL.iOll ix a "ViobitiGin of.l c:!"ilnIaI 4ru, SUtutc
oc:cuma.l iD 1M ....cdpbce DO 12= wa tiW: calendar 4.a~ .!tct sudl COIn'ictio.a;
S.NotifyIDg me '&'DC)' ill. -!o _ "'" ~ days a/lC1 ,_'villI DO<i<z _or SUbfalagraph ~(l»
.Dcm u em¢o!'ec or otberwise .R:CCMz1& latW' .Dotic:e or sud. c:cnMaioa.. E.mptoycn of ~
=ployee> ""'" prtWi4< II<>ti«, ~ po<it:on titIc, to .,..". .,.,.. om"" or other 4esiga<c CII .. iIo5,e cram K%MIy the c:c~ c=ploree ~ wotldn" :nJcss'-w Fcde...f ageD~' 1la:s i!esignatC:il' c:eattal
pofm fOr Et£ ~ alsuc:!!: 1lOtit:5. NOtice shaJI iDdud~ the jd",e:r..tifiatioa PWDbe:r(SJ at. eaQ aO'~
a=t;
6. TaJciJIg ODe oC!!Ie IoD""';"! _. willlin 30 caI...w cIa). or ,=i\iJ1g .oCia ,"",or subplr>ppll. ((1>).
wi<Il =I"'" "'. any =pJoyoc _ is 10 ",..;:aed -
(a)TU!aJ ,~ .. penoDOCl o«io~ 'sain'< sud! .. empIOJ'OC, up 10 ud illciwfu:I tmIIiDaIioo,
COt!Simot wrJl the rcq,~1S aI the RebabWtaOoa A/:I. 0( 1973. a ~ or
(I>~ sndo <mplD)'« IC panl<Ip ... ~ay ill , ""'I ,busc assimD", at :.babillUlioo
program 'pproved i>r suea plUJ'O'C' by • Federal. Slate, or JoQI h<al1lI. law enf"",,=>l, Of ._
'PP"'pm" apt)'
1.Ma1:ing. JOOd t&itll etfon 10 continue 10 maintaLn I cfrug·free ~'!<la l1uOtJp impkment3.tiol! or
panl:I"pbs 1-~ 3, ... S aM ~
",
"::~ 1 ~:~~:.
.. tile ,..,.,.. IDI)'1Ds<:n In III< spaoe prool<Ic4 b<low !be ,ite,.) ilr th< ~ ol wrl< _. m
_ Witilk op<dti< If"'"
l'la« 01 ~ (Stro<:t """'-dry, """''Y. ""«' zip c>c!<)
CIIcdt_ ree:. _'Wtdplolzl oalik 1bIa:< "'" ~ kn;TIIe =-..;a ~ to W
~ wtdp_ JOq1Ii:e4 loy :zA CD pan l4, oubpon F. .
Ad-~ _ To die 1><:1< 01 die JmiWoctioII:I ~ aDd ~
l.No _ appropdat<d 1=10 __ paid co: -.ill be po;4. by or '"' l><bIIlf 01 jr, '" &II)' _ kK
~ or attemptinJ ., ID/IUeDco III _ o< ... ~ or aty '1"II'l'.' Member at~ ......
_ D< OIlp!".)'eO 01 CoD_ 0< .,. empklju 01. Mcmbc: c:f CollJ=> ill ~ ";t!J t!><
~ of III] _ ""''''''-the o:iliDJ of.",. F<4cnl"...t, Ihe """"'" of uy I'cII.r>l bm. the
.... tcri:q """ of All)' <OOj>CtIu.oe._ an4 W <:Xtensioo, ""'tiI:ua<!oli., _ .".",-.. or
IDOdiacatiOD ol8llJ Fc4erat contn-O.,. :rat.. Jo.aQ,. or cooperative J~
ur III] _ otlI., !!Ian Fe4tnI appropriate4 ___ ~ or..;n be ~ 10 IIll' pe!S01l for
~ or aaempt!n& '" mtl_ .. ell!= or "'"PkIy:< ofuy _'Y, • M ... .., of CoD" .......
_ 0< 0!IIpI".)'e0 of Congrcu, 0< .. "'"P~ of a Mem1>er 01 Con""" ill ~ ";1lI 1hi> Fe40nI
-traa, JrUt,1cao, or coope:a!l>e Iz=mcot, it will Q)1OJI1= IOd submit StaDdald !'onn.lll.,
"D~.Form to Report I.o~' ill aamdaucc..mh its ~_
3.l< will ~ Qat rh< Ia.."..,. 0{ paragnrpI! (al ol <IIis <ml"1iatio. be f1IcIuaec! in Ihe __ on"
1ar all .. -"'<15 at Ill! ..... [Ulcll1<!inl .. bcoa_ s"db""' ... ..., """""" """'" ....... loaoo, ,lid
<t><>pemi>o _ .. ) oM rIIat&/l ~ic:Us sIWl =<iI\'aDd _ ~ne~ is
ia COIIIi'-__ au lobf>T-JII ~ by 24 Q'R port 17, "'F'kr "'th -forms, If
~ by ilia< pm. .
lopI A.JdbariIy -Jl possesses leplll>tbodzy _ s<iie wloc:al Itt '" ..u. put submlssioDS Illc! ., ........ _."miiy ~~l u4 _. j>fOJf>mS iOIId tk Jqris<I!a!on __ the Iopl..n.on-"
10 ""'l' OD! tk prcpmslOF _ it is -E hm4iD" ilr .=:l!.iDce ..;a "i'Plical>1o h"UD ..,watie=
ArlEn ye LIws _ ne jmisdiaio.a will c:ompq wiii d»e otbe:r p.tOrisio§ of * ADs tI:IYC2'fq prop:ms
_ II)" the coasoIl4alC4 pIJ.O ao4 Wid ether "pj:licablo _
Sipatme
TllI<
..
·,
.",
. DRAFT :
no Eatilkmcl1t CoImDIIIIiIy _ <bt:
> .. '
1"_ "
.. .'~..,;;,,,
(
v .. al ,_ _ I! las ~ f1s CDOSOIi=tecI pl&.a OIl< 'pr proj=d lIS< 0( t ... .:s 50 IS to &Nt
lDUfmu kasible prioIiZy ID ~ whic:Jt ~ .,.., and :IDOCfcr3le iDaJme famiI!.ts; or il4 ill the
pmeatiDll or c!jmi"._ 0(_ or bIiF~ (tile i""J<"U4 .... or lwIds ..., _ iPa~ aamtics _
IIlo """,.. =-are dafJl!l4 ., ..... ot!O<r cx""'tllmlty _pm"'" • ...,. tmll,a pani<:aIu ~
becl ... _, =-.. pose a ....... cd _to .,.,.., 10 !I!e bal<ll or ... !We or !he COIIImIllli!)4
aod ochet ~ ~ oro_ ...aablc); '"'"P' tlIal die ~P'" ... 0( WlIG funds_
-... -., 106 of Ik Ho..r., ad CI>Jmmmity Deo<lopIaeot Aa of 1.974, .. 1lII~ .M it
applicabk, -.. __ 108 or die ..... M, Itar!q 1""1=' yar(5) 199_ • {a p<OO<I
IpcdIicd by ""' """ ... <DDS!slli>, 0( -. -. DC ~ ~ ,,,_culM pro""" y<an}. shall
priJKipaDy .bend!( pet"CDS of aa. and mo4cab:: fDc::mIe ill a CW1."Oef t!w emnres thai .I1ot :k:ss tba:a: 70
p<=al of __ are .sed /Dr aaMtiO tl>a. bett<fit sud! p=o .. dun., suc!I p<ri04;
~ ~ l'Iaa -11 .... ""~ • """",w" II<velopme.t plan, /Dr tl>e p<tio4 .pedlIed
m the paragraph above,. lbat i6c1tilia c:ommuni!y develop.aJe%lr n.t housiDg 1loeed5 ud sped1:ie:s both shen
IItd "''''''-<=11 oommcnl1)' ~ ObjectiYos WI .... bco. de>cIop<d in oc:cW'...:>oaO .,th the,
p1fmary objective aIl4 requirem.e.ots of. dae IiousioJ and Comllurnlt)' De .... dopmetlt Aa. of 197(. as
&a:le.n~
S,pedaI ~ts -h win !KIC *ttea:pc: 10 ret;:Ollel any apit!1 cos.tS or pl,lbIk improvemeDG assisted' iD.
Wbole or fa part wilb: fura4s prtMdcd n4e:t s.eaioft 106 o(!he Hc~, &.Dd' Communi!J tlreveJoplPe1it Aa
of 197(. 15 IIIZlCt1c1ed. or _11ll amounts re:s'iZllin, frc!D • ~t= un4e.r sec'"Jo~ 108 of me same Aa. bY
;WeSS:ID1 any amoUl1l 2piDst prope1'lies ~ IDd occupied ~ pct50ns of low and mo4cr.tte income. ~
iDdudblg Illy fee <hrpd or as:st:SmlCJlt made :IS I cmufitioa of obtaini%)g ~ 10 su.:l ptiblic
impraYatGl5. uless:
J. F""", '-""dcl_ 106 o(thc ~ U<I c<>",."",Uy DeYoroPm<XIt A<>. of 1974, as
am~ an: \tSed ID pay (he proportioa at SDCi.lce or asses:uneal WI relates 10 1be c:apitlI CXl5t:$ or sud!.
pub& imptove:mer;!5 wr arc ~ bolD ~e SOa:rt:ei omc: than DA6er rule I 0( WI Act;; or
~ ;mrpases or ~ any atzlOUlit .apms. prQ,pet'O . .;s ov..lIe4 Ind OCC1Ip~ b5 pusoas or mOOuate
_ tile "..", .. <=iii" to the Sea=uy WI. JacI:s JUl!iQent tom'" rcc:oMcI Rild<r oealo. 106 of the
Housiq .. d C<>mmuni<y Ocvelopm<m kt 0( 1974, as atIieD4a!, '" comply with lIle ~=:s of
subpora""pb (1) ~c;
l,.ea.II-Based PamE -J::!. B~catiO" ins~ tc:niD: aud: .a"bate:mc:O[ Fr~ures CODCCIlIia& ka4·based
palo! will complJl_ 1570.608;
~ 1 .... -t: Joas ""'P"'" lOAd iJ ~
lA poIicJ prohll>lliDI II>< "'" or ~ force II!' law _, ...,..x...nhl1I II> jUris4iQi"" &pilIsl
a1t] __ ....".p ill aon""leDt dvi! JiC)US ~ ODd
l.A ~ 01 CIIIbrdq oppIicoI>Ie SIal< an41oca1 ..... lpiOsO ~ -. ........ ., or all from I fIdI!:7 or ___ • w nbjcc' 0101l<Il __ c:MI rfPis ~ withlIIl!s
JnritRmtW :
..
The pmee !IeteIly =tI!Ios !lilt IlK projea<4 ... otfunds iDdI:dts .,.. or IDOre opecitl<:aII}' idenIiW
aaMCes 1I'IIX!lare ~ IX> ..-omcr c:om!I1U11i\)' <IeIoeIopm<D1 uods 1Iav!D, • pankolar _
tu:w:se a:fstlD&. a;mdhioltS pose • ser:iolIs an4 :izI:med1atr ~ 10 dI.~ bealth Illd ~l!an: 0: Be
c::omIIIlmfty a:KI other buciII .resourcc:s are BOt available Ii) .lleet sa DUds.
Al'PENDlX TO <EImFlCATIO:.'S
~ocno:.'S OOl'lCER.'!ING LOBBYING AND DROO-EREE WORlO'LACE REQUIREMENTS,
Ttti_1i I _ ~ offt<t"p"" _ r __ ~_1hls
UI r.ill. wa made-er c:mezoed fDlO. ~. of thfJ czrtitiouioa .is • j4£leqcds1tc for ~
01 -ma """ &Is _lIIIpa5«I by .-l3S2, Ii!Ie 31. U.s. Codo. kly poDOll who
!!IIis '" ale !lie ~ _ IIIaII bo Rbi"" Ie I civil pcoaIl}" of _ .... IIwI $!0,000 .!J>4
_ III<1l< Iba Jloo,ooo Ix '*' Ado 1'lW=
L By ~ _lDbllllaiq tIC> app6atioD 0< """ ......... ~ 1he.,.,.UC ;, ~
III< cenilk:aIICIIleI ... fa porzsr>pb (0).
2. tbc ~ ICt ous iD ~pb (0) is a ma~ R,prc:senQtioD 0( faa ape • ..mdI
~ k plac:e4 wkI. Ilk lzeuq awarc!s the p.D.1-If j( is btu c!etennine.4 that the JnZ1tot
tBDwin&l1 reD4erec! I fa!5e c:enific:atioD,. or otherwise 'Violates the fcquiremezns Clf Ibc: Dn!g
Free Workplace .~ BUD, III additiou 10 &%!y otbcr rcmc.ties 3,,;Ub:bJ.c. Ie tbe Fe4er.aI
~l,. mzy Dl:.I! ICrioG authorized: 'C116er the Drug-Fret Workplace A.."'t.
3. Far p:mes ork:r than ~ A1tc:ma~c I applies.. (Ilm is the infonD.lOoD to 9o'hk!:
cntitlcmcnl ".._ ~
C. For crac1eC:i wbo are ~ Ahc:r:ate' n IppliG. {No< appIica~le to CDBG &--.,.. ..... }
S. W~ _ .,.." Ios.,.._ otiIeI IIwI "'~. _ DOl bo ~ti1i<4 OD
die cOn!li_ if -. Iky ...,. bo i<IeI1ti5e4 in 111< put applicatiOD. IC lb. l'U'ce
cJoes..,. idelIliJ! til< ~ 1l1he tim. of IPPIialioD, 0< "POD ~;r IlI= is ""
oppIir>r"" III< .,..,.. ..... bop IlK iolcrllhy o! tho ..,aplace(s) CD !De in II> o!lice ",,4
_ die iDformalioa .-we for _ ~ Failun: 10 idcmify all _
~ -... • ..,_ 0(111. "",lee"' ~·IE .. _lploce n:quU<!lICI15.
6. Wori<plaa _"'" .11'" iDcJu4,e the lCloaI lMress of buiJdilIgs (0< pan> or
bu!Idinp) <F """" lila """" ...n -... tho """ tam p-. c.~ 4tsafp1ioos
may bo .sea te. ... all ..-0( I .,... truISillaUtoti1;y or State ~ depan=ot
.. 1>lIe .. opentiol. _ <mpIo:!= in codo local """"'Ploy=t oIIicc, porfutm<n in
am=< balls or --J.
7. Ir!be _lplaa id<miIloo! '" !be oJCDC)' clJaJtgcs during tllo pedorma ... of!!l. I'U!' Il!e
_ sIIa!I mrom. die ._ 0( tho c:Iw1,.(.~ if;' previomly i<lcr.1llie4 !!Ie .. ",lplaa:o
in qucstio. (_ parapapll I!>e).
':;.' -", .. . " ~ , I
&. Drdf.IjtioQS of Iena5 iD the NoDprOCUem.ez1l SmpezmoD U4 De~ CDmmO!l rule
&od Dot-Free Woaplaoo oommoD ~ apply II:> m;, _00-. GraD"'" ."""_ ..
coDal, III ,.,-, '" IIIe ~ __ III<:se tlIlc£
"CoAtrOlkd ~ .. mam: a CD'DC"CDaI' ~bsw:u ill Schedules J thrmlp V of Ibe
Conln>_ SubsuD<es AD. (21 U.5.012} LCd .. rw-JIc _ I>J r<Jl'la_ (21 CFR
~11lrOoP .008.15);
"CcuoIcIoo' _ • ~ 01 JlIiIt (iI>cIodins • pica oC aola "'D~) or impositioR
oC ~ ... boI1, by IUIJ' jII4ic:aI bocIy ~ "';!h Il1o r~iIiV Ie clel<nOiDe __ oC <he _ or SWe crimiDal cIru, sm-.u:o;
~ draa m~· m:ems a Fe:4:nl OE" aoa-Fe4enl' afm.i:nIl5U.tuU ~ the
DWlmcmre. distrihutio:l.. dkpeDSing. QU" Of ~ or IJl)' OToltro~ nbstance;
"£=ployeo'" ....,., die emF",," of. "... .... di:eaJy .. pp! in th. pctfoImazIa or ""'rk
...... "...~ _" (i) All "cI!m:t $arJc" cmployeoo; [~j all "indi=! char",'
employees UDles! tbc:ir ~ or fDvotvcme..G., is ic.sipmam to 1lIe pe:foImaDce cf the
Jta!!t bII (ih) _po<2llI p::som>cI _ a>DSalwIl5 """ Or< o!i1ea1y "'PIC'! m the
pcrfomwI<E a{ MId< 1II1C!et Ill< IIU' &114 00lio Or< DOl CD th. p"tce\ I"'l""IL This
4efiD:jd"OIl. cJoea, Dot iDdudc ~ DO( oa the ~TOn of Ibc FUlee (e. .... volwucas.,.
c:vea 1'1ISe4 Ie mu: • D:LIlChiD, requ!:re:aJQ:r; contaIuDts or iDckpcllde.nt CODtnaOfS aoc
CD Ibc: ,Cr.a.Dtcc ..... pilTOn:. or rmployees-of nbredpitllti or suba).cD"""~OlS iII a;r..<ere41
""rtpla<:<s).
APP£tm:x c
ern' OF PAlO ALTO
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT (CDBO)
cruZEN P.un1CIPU1ON PLAll!
A.primaiy ISpOCI d!be Housi:>g and Ccmmimity Deveklpmc!ll Aa 0( 1987 is !be provisioD
at 1<Ie-.(WIIlo oppoltiIDily for citizeas '" panicipatell> au adviso<} role iD !be phuming.
imr". ..n ODd ~ of !be C<>mmuniIy Deve10pmeU Blotl Gram (CDoo)
prov-on. II! onIct '" eI!CCUI'Ige public enmjna • .,., ODd oppni5ll of Ibe pro<:esl. as wen as
10 0II!mJc0 J>t08nlD 1CCCUIIIabiIiIy • ...-.... rcqui:td to cenif)' llIol they ITt following •
<IoIaiIod cirizoa participatioD p!aIl. ~ rcqui:td IIDIler 24 en 510.303. 104 (1)(3). and 106.
!be ckizea panicipatioD plaJl must:
I. PnMc!c for ODd e:lCOUIllg< ckizea participatioIl in !be devdopmaJa. implemcJllarion
and totes "", •• of Ibe CDoo pr<lIJ'IIIl with pani<uIar ""'P""';' "" pa."ticIpation by
pcr1OI!S d low and II>OCIe:a2 income;
2. Provido citi=ls with _ and IimeIy ICCaS 10 loW mee:mcs, infDrlllOlion. and
r=mk Rioting 10 !be sn-'. prapoood aM ICIIW esc: of tImds;
"
3. Provide for 1C<>bmr..! assistaJa to I""'P" repre5eI!Wivc of pcnocs of lew and
moc!mu: income Iha! IOqIIOSI IIl<II assisIalu ill cIevdop'.Di fImdiIlg ~;
t. PtoYide for publlc JJoazmp 10 obWu ciIi2ea ........ WIG ,..,.., 10 proposals and
~ ti a11l1t1ces of !be romtD!rntty developmora propm willi rcasombIe ~,
• ""'III" dariot. for ~ "'ilh diAbiIities, ODd II limos and klcariom toDveniaII
.0 poceIlI:iaI or ICIIIal berIcIiciarios;
5. PtoYide for timely ,.,.;a"" ~ 10 wrine1l COOIpIailllJ and grieYlIIJaS wiIhDll5
W<JdI:iDg claY' wberc ptaericable; and
I
-.:-.
~ -' --', --~, .
·.' .. . '
6. IdcnIify how 1210 Deeds of noo--Engllsh speililJg reMems will be met in 1M case of
plbllc boirins' "'betc • sipiflCUl! number of IIOn-EnJIish speaking .... idents t.I.ll be
.... ~ expe<W 10 participalz.
ObIedIm of !lu: nan
k is 11:0: imaIl of 1210 Cily of Palo Alto 10 pro\ide for and ~ meanir.gful citizen
iDYolvcmeu in 1210 COBG Program by forming a cki2eD participation ~ whic!I
lacIudes !be following objectives:
I. To __ II> mI comply 1i'iIh 1210 provisiocs of 1210 CommuniIy DeYclopme:ll A.. .... N
1981. IS II!IleIIded mI aD other fedeI>I replotioI:s.
2. To mx:oor>ge 1210 participaOOn of citizens in 1210 plamJing, impIementarion and
........ J£D! of !be COSO progrzm. ospociaIly dJose N low mI very low iDc<lme.
membcn of minority groups. residents of areas ",11m fUnds ",ill be cxpcIlClod. !be
elderly. iDdivlduals willi clisabili!ies. and other "';ghbQrbood <K eM: groups.
3. To make iDfOlTllllio!! about 1210 COBG Program ODd process available 10 1210 public
!lIiwrIl =sonable am IImeIy access II> iDfor.nadon inclwf"'8 pubrx:ariom In local
~. pubIk l><arings. publlc meetings. and !he provisioo of I<ctmical
as.sisIaDce .
ComP29SD'li of the "an
I. COBG AItrisarJ CommIttee (CAq -Tbe _bli""""", of a COBG Advisor)'
Commim>e (CAe) proyjdcs • vehicle: far aclive cidzea Invoh>emelll in aD phases of
1210 Cnmnnmity Developmcm Bloc:t OnDIlJIOC'OS1.
A. fImctjog: Tbe COBG Advisory Commim:e is advisory Ie stoff on !be
.~ of CDBG lImOs mI!be COBG process. Tbe CAC will assist ill
she Li=nrifr,Qon 0( commu.nity ~lopment Deeds &ad the ps&",SSJrle:!'!! 0(
projco:ts praemm for fuDdiDg CO!ISidmIion. Tbe CAe will bay. an' odvlso<y
role in 1210 imr!rmcntarion of 1210 prognm '" actinc IS • COlIduiIII> fIinbor
cIdi<Jo cidzea!lOOds and ,eo ",,,,,....r,,,, project criteria. n.: CAC will usas
projects IIIlIIICtivlties II> deImnine il12lo objeaives of Ibo Cotmmmity
Developmcnl PIalI am !be ~ve BousiDs AIfordabilily Struqy
(CHAS) are beiI!a met.
AI reo 1I",.,...MatioDs. tommeDL5, ISSessn"mU. and proposals from dIIe CAe
will be forwar.le<l intact 10 1210 CiI:< Cowx:iI for !heir review. The CAC will
aid ill 1210 c!i""""jl!alion of informatioo .bout !be Comrounit)l Developmeut
2
'--,
;;'.:
B. Mm!benhjp: Commia= """"ben will be: appointed by me Mayor 10 serve •
l'IIO yar 10m!. Mm>bc:rS may DO( serve maR !hall two coaseoutive tuII Ieml>.
tbe C<'IIIIIlimc will lllve Dislo vodDi members, _ of wbom is • member of
!be CiIy'. Human RoI5lioos C""""iWon. tbe 0Iber eiJh! mombc" will tic
<OOIjIIisecI OCpenoas .... ho live or wort in Palo A/Io.1DII wI><; lIe. Of advocate
for. perIODS of ..... IDII modetalc _. or 0Ib0r pwps orielll<d IOvnnI the
pols of u CDBG Plan. for eumple, memben of miDoriIy PWPS. the
elderly. perIOCIS rill cIisIIri!iIies. eIC. In order 10 .v<;jd • pcrcei~ ooof1i<:I of
idmst. m pcnoD who is • member of the board of di:ocI<xs of. or is
empIojod by, III qers:y ilia! applies fa< or roceives CDBG fImdiDs, will be:
cfiiibIe 10 serve oa the C .... ",_ dmin& Ill)' year in wbicII suclI agency
,..,..".. or applies for CDBG fIDxIiDs·
2. CIIy CGmJdI
A. tbe CiIy Coua:ilIelS policy. priorities. IDII appro ... Ibc overan Community
Devd<lpmoJII Block Gram Program.
B. tbe CiIy Coua:il will hold. minimum of two pubrlC bc:ariDgs per year for !be
purpose of l>btainina citizens' views IDII f<JnnulJtina ()f InpOD<fmg 10
proposals IDII quesIioas. tbe public: beariIIp "ill be: bcld .. 4iffm::lll SI3geS
or u JXOI"'III )'CU so ilia! together theY a4cIress e.."IIIIDl1IIi1y developmenl and
bDIIsiJI& DOods, IIcveIopmcIII of pi opos<d IIC!iviIies IDII JXOI"'III performau<:<.
C. AaioDS of U City Coua:il will direct the implOlllOllWion of CDBG funded
projetIs.
3. GeDerIII I'IIbIIc
A. tbe ,..,..-ar public ;, ~ 10 p.,,;cipau: in !be vaIioIIs stages of !be
CD8G pr1lItZll by .!!cndjng the nocicod public bc:ariDg. or the CAe me<!lDgs.
'Iboy lIe ~ 10 exp=s their _~iews IDII commeats cIlrectIy 10 the
CDBG CoanfinaIDr ic the i'!aIml:lI Division <>< receive prosnm illformalioD
from the l'IIImiD& DivisKm Staff on the 5111 floor of City Hall, 250 H.amiItoD
AWDUe. Palo AIIo, CA 94301. kill)' lim< citizens may submit views
co .. ti IIi ... Palo A/Io'. performm:< in the CDBG program 10 the BUD /uQ
Office • 450 GoIdea Gall: A=. San Frmcisto. CA 94102·3448.
4. CIP. Stoft
A. tbe DcparImezlI of PIazming aM ('ommllnUy Enviromncnl bas !be primary
rcspcnslbili£y for the acImiDisttaIioD IDII coordiDation or the COBG Pmgmn.
{~'" -. -;
t~ .} ,-.
' .. ' .",
" .
. . , ..
f
I ,
-.
.. -;
B. AI. die begiDning of die pI.anniDg process for !be CDIlG ~ year. sQff
will pnlvide die CAC aDCI die Jenera! public with die foDowin& information:
2)
3)
The IIIDIlIiDl of JI3IlI fuDds and progmn i!Icome C>jl<CIed 10 be IIIIIk
.vail>ble 4uriDI!be oexI fiscalIprogram year for ptopooed community
6ovcIopneDI and bousillg actlvbles;
Tbe rqe of actlWia dill may be IUIdcrtakcu. jp;;indiog die estjm.,,,,
IDIOIIm poposoCllO be lise<! for ICIiviries Ibot wi:I benofit peno!lS of
low and ~ iDoome;
Tbe ptoposoCl CDBG ICIi>iIia whicl! ,ill IiUly r=I! in retooanon.
ODd dIc City's iDl=l1O minjrnj:r !be ~ for rd<xatioo of 1'0'""""
OJ I RSUIt of assio!od IOIiviDcs;
Tbe !)'peS and Jevels of I5IIjsw;c# Ibo City wlli ItlBb lvail>ble (or
RqI1ire otbm \IJ maR lvail>bIeJ 10 peno!lS WlIo .", eligible for
JdoCatioa assistata os I resuh of CDBG wisled ICIlvilles.
c. P1aming sQff will mainIain !be Citi=s· htticipation Plan, dIc f'lOposed and
Fmal sn_. !be Community HousiDg Affo<dabiljty SIrategy (CSAS). !be
CDBG PIon, dIc GnDI<:e Perfonnance ~ and an 0Iber program.~.
c!on,"=". illformation and "'I""'S ~ by federal '"I'J!.ati;)ns. Theoe
c!on_ an: available roc public .me ... in !be I'1.aDniD& DivWon, ,Stb floor.
Civic Cemer. 2SO Hamiltoa A ....... Palo Alto. CA 94301 during t>OCmII
wod:ins IIoun (weeIaIay1. 8:00 l.m.-12:OO; 1:00 p.m.-S:OO p.m.).
D. 'fechDical IS.;."' ..... 011 dIc CDBG regulatioIJs ItId die COBG progtam procc:s$
wiD be pn>Vidcd by die sralr of die I'Iam>in&: Divisioa 10 """iJ[DIit ago:tJCies
sorviI>ii low iDcome penOIIS. c:itizea groups ODd groups of \ow ItId mocknIe
iDcome and DCighborhood groups ~ IUClI .ssista,....,.. AWstara may
be in dIc form or Jenera! itICormolioo;. ~ <kmograpbic or socio-ecooomic
daIa. iuletptctatio<i :!! ~JD J\!les and regulotiotIs. explamOOn of City policies
ODd proadurcs alI'ectirIg t!J< CDIlG Pmgram, or adv!a: Rpnfmg allema.!ive
fimIIiDs sou=-for ptojecu wbich II< ine1iglb1e UDder tile CDIlG Progrun.
E. PIIImiDg sQff will arratJ8C for iDformatioa 10 be ~ In , biliogual
WlIioa at public boarings VIbeDover I oipIificam IIWI1ber of DOtI-EngIisb
speaking residcob QIII be reasooabIy ClIj>CC1ed 10 participate. or .... bea • request
is made for JUClI service.
F. Penoos wid! disabilitics ",ho RqUire IUXlIialy aids or ..mces In Dsiog City
h<:iIitics. services or ptOglatnS. or ......, wtJOId likc informatioa on !be City·,
eompIiance wid! !be AmericaJIs with DisObilWes AJ:t (ADA) of 1990. may
o.
H.
.-DitNh NetJ, ADA Dirc<Sor, CiI:)' of Palo Aho, 250 Hami!roo A_,
PlIo A!tI>, CA 94301; (.15) 329-1$13 (Yoke) Of (.15) 329-1199 (1'., IiI!!iiI j oMo Dcvioe 1« Ibo Deaf -TOO ma:hlDo). Public HeariI!gs
will be IIoI/! ill Ibo COUIICiI Cbunben or ocIIor IIO<:I:ISibIe Jocotic>m. Sip
lazI&uqo iDletjR_' will be provid<d "POll ~ Qh 7l boIIIs I<lvaDce
1IOIiao.
PIIImiI>I IIIIf will pIQ'ide a wrIaaI RSpOIIO: II> III 'J1iaeIt C<lIDp/alllIs ..., p._ ropnIiDJ Ibo CD8G """""" wiIIWl IS ~ day. of r=ipI cl
IUdl complaiIa or ,nova..:e.
PIIImiD& IIIIf will IdIr:dIIJc II1II _ III rtqIIir<d public hwiDgs .. well ..
Ibo pubIio ID"dinp 0( Ibo CAe. NoDcc of Ibo <lire, timo. p'-..., ...,..sa ot
Ibo pubIio boriIp will be I4>eniIed II ieIII lOa (10) days prior to 1be bcariIJa
ill Ibo PlIo Aho weot!y or IDOIIIer IIOWSpOjlCr of Jocal c:ir<:ulI!iaG.
A. Arnenrln"'"" 10 die CDOO progrtID WbicJII require BUD DOti:lication 01'
IIWfOVII will be lUbmiUed 10 !be CAC fDr J'IMn; II1II,0<"''' .n'..;.., prior
10 I:IIlImlIIoI of Ibo _ opp1ication 10 !be CiI:)' CouD::iI 1« opptOVaI.
Public JariIlp !Ielbft !be ell)' Cou:nciI will be hol4 CD .... " ....... wIIkII OM
ad·Demel in II&DU'C. at 1lIbea required by SliD. Sabqmtjel '''M ''btntS are
cIotlaocI .. :
I) !be la!p!erenration cllD acIiviIy DOl. JR>ioIIIIy jdq.j"'" ill Diffie i<U
deW! '" provide Ill'caaI ciIilzos ID lIPPOlluaily 10 IUlImil .. 0".
Of
2) a cIIaDF ill lID 1Ctivily'. J*'OI'1IDI bIo!pI wIIicII ...,...,. _ pen:ea ot
!be City's IIIesI IIIIIII&l rntjt_ ....
s
. ~,
APPENDIX I>
(I" ---A,8UC........-o ON COMIIIUI8TY DEVlUJPII£NT N!EDS
-• --. .. " ~~ ':" ..... -i 40 'lIN fVILO AlJ'O TO PflOVIDI!: INPUT .
: " .-:". ,·····,,';·_nE_aF11Ia • ::'. • . -:. ~ --~.:.; :~: ?C:ITri ~ftAA OONIOII'JA'!'EC PI.M
_ _ ...-: -.~~-::~ ::=-_·-:·'.~:,",: .. :~~'oC'ORR!7 .. -1'" -..... -:: ';---... -. ':~_,.' ." .... ::'~ .. ,.:oo-I*FlM..
~_. # ... ~",,!.~~~~_ .L"'~':IIGI.~ADII4."'Me
lhoCll)-~_"*'_tMo/OO,,",~""p __ 'd._'~2OODCo __ ~ _-_.-..:I""" ...... .s. Oopo'''''''' _ .... UO!>on 0tMII ... ,.,. f«.q. .
Ikb:riaii::ItI d. COre::tidBd Poan is.,..... Udng!I8QI.ftrJWI b' q d .. HU) 1:m'lJa~.s::
C<rrmdy Dao *" ,ue _ Clowt (I::OIq HOME ___ p-lOMfI, Erno!"gMcy &do.-_ .... ord_ ~ ... """","..an1\lOO fiOPW.'I
It'aCo: -; r.d.~ ... cIesc:ttJe~1'tOuSi'lgand~(:OI'I'!TU"iIynaedl, ~ nf
~ p-tlrrIja,lS WlIIIS h.ntegy rd pI;w'I kI meet E:'.e ~ needL b COIlSl:M.:lalid PIIIn IUm[ssion
... _ ... __ 00' .... "" .... _'" M __ PiASJ m:!""""""'"
...... o1pri:1tly r~ 00fTI'1'I.riIV Ci8' 4. i .c rte9dS.
n.......,1-"V""~2.",. ...... "'~b' .......... """""P'CII_~
""'"'"' "" ___ -..-............. ..,..,,"'_-.....,., .. 00,._"",,",
hJusilg. p..CIc S8"\'i;e.. C'ld ott.-~ CCl"I"WtVitt CIf1'w:p ••• needs.. ~ ItcU 1t1epriorty
I'IM6I ollOWllccmt ~ IBJriies YtIth c;tiIctwl, ~ toT ... pe.~ ..... eiideI'tJ. ... mer'UI)'''
pir:ION ...... ~ gr~eIopnetUI ~ pe!"'SOOS" ~ M)S, n1 ctiIdnir'llllfadsd bylBf poiscri"Ig.
hd. .. not wal ~ a ~ ~ SOI.I"OeS suc:t\ _ th! 1990 Qnr:us.," ~ lOl.9t b¥ 0., --f ......... ~"' ............... obn"Btioo,_ .... __ OiiI&JzJmo_C08G
0:0:" ....... 321242Iorc.a.ma SiIeveI.. HouWIg ~. ::.29-2lO& CcpieS d h ~ prerr.bus-OW! ... _ .... """*'II ~ Qultor, 50n '-. cov_ 250 __
f'In:onr.th cis:abifas 'Wh:I raq,.,jr9 adIry Ikts or Ba'\IIc:e! i'I LD1:I cay IiIcIfties, eeMces, or ~. O'..tlc.
~ .. llb ....... ,cn ... OlYIOOii ....... ..."h~."., ~1<J~~19901I"I8r --CirIf>_. _OttdNoJ>J1o, l!5O_...,~ _"""C\943O"I "~2313~-oot
,,1.5/32'9-! 1 913 TOO
,-
'". -
NonCE OF PUBLIC REVIEW PERIOD AA'D PUBLIC
flEARlNGS ON PALO ALTO'S CONSOLIDAn:D. PLAN
FOR THE PERIOD J1JLY 1, 199$ TO niNE 3lI,lOOO.
Tbe Cily 0( Palo """ ... ~ • _It c..-"" ..... whi'" """" ..... die ciIy', olf""""''' ~ml ..., ~.........u.;,. doffiopm'" .-. raow:u "'" ~rioriti .. lor "" period JoI} I. 1995 to Jan. 31,
__ p, __ ooCi SIdopiao or It.< Cos1s<>6_ P"" is "'IUir<d by II>< !ido.JI J_ ~ o!
Ii ...... lad lkI>o:s ~ (HUt>i. ill ...... r.r oil. Cily (and ,.""..lis "'P'-"'imm "" CiIy) ..
If'IiIl' r.r _ ........ 0D4 """"""'" ~ lDrmula P"'I'*'I' ....... II>c c...musury ~
Sloct GnoI fCDBG) to<! HOME _
no Coosolidoa>ol_ .. ill ",,_!b< ~ mjUin4 c~. ibis"" Alfonlobnily S,,*&>,
(CIlASJ ao4 will iIscIu6e !b< _~ or priori<y .....-"" _iIy ckvo!_ .c<ds. The Pim
__ pis fir III< JIf"Vbioo of -. .. a ,.,v ............. istas>cz '" low ISId vory low _ pcr5OSU.
~ k ~ It abo b':ludics II!. Ac:ticA PIIm ~ ~'bcs • one )011' scratqy for Ibe \lse of
-.or ...........
Pl1IIUC REVIEW PERJ()D, Tho DnfI c""",w-! Plan .. ill be ".,1abto r.r public miow, r.r • 3ll d.tr
perioof.. bqhmln, OIl Mard t~ 1995 and ~k;,o:ftO., O!I. Mard. 31,. 19t5. Writt..ca. ooawaltl cay be submitted
dunn, Ibe 1(I day reviN pc:iocf ao4 sboo.Ild be self to Ib: Palo Alto Department of Ptanninj!: Cl4 CommLlJ'llty
Ellvironmmt. Atta'lCCHI Suzanne R.Jcbn!s. 2SO HmtiJtOll A\le:!uc. Paro A1to,. C, .. 943(11.
PUBL!cH~.i
~ Ciry J'laaaiq Comll'lis1;ioll:l wlll lIold' • pvbric lll:aring OIl !he Drafi Consoridated Pl.ir! on Wed'aes4zy.
Mvt:1I .. 1995 at r.lO PM, ex-.a ~ lIS j:"OSin,1e d\ctafier, ic ~ COLInCiJ Cham"ber3 tlf Cay Ran, 250
Hami1t'Xl ~.~ No Alto. Com.mtmt ca. I!\C Draft C'ltISOfidlted Pl.at:. ~ be Jft$tti.lrc:l: 10 '!be Cic:Y PlllMm,
Commission It the public lIear1n,.
1M Ciry HalDl. ~116alt5 COlSllbiSJioa WI'll bo1d' _public bearing on the DrafI Consorida:ed Plan 011:
n.rscIaJ. Mardt t,. 1995 • 1:00 pM, or lIS SOQr\ IS P'KS-ibte ~. ill tM Couocil CorofCf'C1lCt .Roea, ~
Hmni1'r:oa AVClUCo hlo Aho. CommeiltS OIl the Draft Cornoricfntd P/.m may be pre$CD~ ro !he Human
Ae:TItioo5 C~OII'" Ibe J'\Ibtk Ilarin&-.
The f'Iu.a« Coar.:aittet...,.,..l1 held • public kirin& Qtl·1be t99S-96" COB(i Nrurm& aJkaU~ oz. THS4ay ..
AJRiI c,. J9J$ III 7:00 PM,. at as J:)OfJ as possibte~ ..... the Council Confermc:c ilDom. 250 Hamiltoa
AvalUe. Palo Aho. C0mmcnt5 on IIfI,c proposed f\a:ndina: alIocations may be ~ted"!O If\e F~ Ccrruufbe
• tb" pcA:.fi.c 1I~g.
Tbt: CRy Coaadl ,..ilI bold. Pu:b::tc :fic:ar.l\j: CII tJw: Con.soTIdm:~ PIaD ~ the 1995-1996 CDOO fcmding
atIoca::iClf"d 011 MODdlly. Ma, •. 1m. 1:00 PM. at IS SOO!I as pouibr" Ebculi:er. iD ~ Counc:iI Coru~
~00Dl. 2SD ti&"nmaa Av:nuc. p~ Aha. Commaus 0%1 1ht CoruoTIda:led .Plan 01 die proposed" fuh!fltl8
&Jloca:tioes. may be. presented to 1he City Council • ~ pubnc ~
TO OBTAIN A COFY Of THE DRAIT CONSOLIDATED PLAN: Copfes an ava.illb:t: I:! 1l'-< PLmnin!
Diy1sjOf! ;ounr.e:r City Hall SdI floor 2SO Hami1lOZl A\o'erwe., berwtcl ~ boun 0: 1:00 AM .. 12:00 DQOO and
t-:GO PM teo 5:00 PM. or by ~lt:phonms l~2«L Copt~ IR also a'llti"bbIt .. elf) Iibraric:s.. for Dlt},."'t
inromw:kIa. eoobld ScaDIM' Ridanfs, CDBG C&ORfia:nor,.t ("I~ 3l~UlI.
~ wD lDsatmmcs who ~ -,p;:ifwy .ods or .Ja'¥~" 1lIn:; Cily &cifltie$.. Jfflkcs or ~ tit '11110 w,,~d ~ irIo5:ltftlolcian
Of! 1M can: ~ aiItI !he ~ .i;fI ~i1itia Aa lAD"1 Qf 1990 m.I! tanl.Kt
~ )Cr!', ADA Pin!=t«, CII)' lid Plio AlltI
:2SO FWniton A~, -".arD A.I~ C,t, ~){.II
"'I~:UIJ lVoiu}. "l~ll"" (TDO)
r
>
E
;
,
• • •
cdba
Cltyd __
NOTICE OF PUBLIC HEARINO (D
1he Pafo NtoCl't ~ wi t'dc1ap.Hc. hEIrI!rha CI'l MIy 1, 1995 ..... It'.-'99S-2OJDo.:r~ P'tiI'I
~ PabAlo'o:~1\cusihg ftf ~ ~ raD,., ~ Ie adI:hss It'os& rI8edl..-.;I1 en)
yt/Ia' a1iMJilnh!: Ih:MI fik»"" Oty ... spn:f b ~~ ~ BJc:dr; Chr1I ~ 'lrOs t raroeMII v .... p.IpOEB. "....,1::Ic hiIImQ wi be lWd' .';OOp.-n,. ~ a:::!IOCI'I1I'S ~ 1tienIrafter. i; h CI\)' Cc!n::f
~250.~Iowut.NlAll:o.-
h.PLbi: r.ra"be 1wi:11D ...... h1d:P hC~ PIaro.o tD ~ h ~ c=-iniI tr ....
199:S-96 roBG ~ P\.CJIc ~ on h Co!wddI!lad Plan. ar(I C. COBG ~ hCi.di"G Ih3lIoIcMilg potjecJ
ed UStl aI tn:II, mila' be '#MI at 118 ~ The Cit;-~ 1:0 I'f:ICIIiI.<e $B221XXJ i'I meG t.nct; tc:m ~ lTba::I Sta'oeI:
~1 rJHcushg trtJ ~ 0 IF; i .. d f"d.l\ a'ld'wlI be aIIoaIfbg" ~ $.!50,000 r.un ~ PI'b
W*t\ hX:ImL jIf, rI .... ~ C/CtiYf'.ic .. c:tln6i;;trf. 'WttI f. CDaG. ~\ ~ ~d gHi"; JltiC:rtr'klo
~ 1IIich ber.at low rd ...ry .,. h::ome.Pllf"kll"& Tho:! 'lID .... De U!i'9d 11:1 tal h ~ reeds in !he CooscidaIed
"'"" 19t5-1i1 CDeG JIAOPOSeD ACTMnES
1.. Calt1ck Cna1i&Is d SrIIa On ~ $13;,200. ConJ)Iarl ~.anc:I ~ SIi!I'W::es b' aId!w1y ~
r: 1'U'1J'9<1' ~ c::n tac:iIIitIs. ~
l ~~ Ccnsatiun. $10.1'00. ~ Shell. iRf ~.-.ices tI' horr8ess pet"SOlS. ~
3 h'o.'2fMr~ $1~.300, 5nar9:fana ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ SIeI'\Ib:!s b low h.xma PIlfSO'lS ... --... PaloAlo~~ 131.100. WomIIItion;n:!~~b~~~..c~
~ iIIIc1ncI!IassiCanoe. ~.
So. UobiIn ~ $6O,coa.. &nxrt w.ices b~pe-sr,:7'<S~ & ~ n:l ak:dd~ pro;rarn.. ~
'-~ In! E5o;)rt, r.c.oo:L ~ ~ Ir;;r eiIJl1a bwrri1c:t1ra Ii5aIJIed' ~ Oty.Mde
1_ Md-PrilslIa c:::amn; b' Fair K::Ju5i"Q. 11G,27S, ~ III ~ a"l ~ rltatlnMlg iR::i..d"'og ~
~OOI~ard~~
8. Oi cJ Palo Ala, t1 n,.7'25. 0I9af 00Bt'l War1I ~ ao'\d'~ ~ costs. ~
a Silir"DM:miI Repair ~ Sri:lf ~ C:u1c:l t· 1 ,000.. $tbIidzecl' Irr.a~ ~ 10' lowe" no:v-t'1e
atI:I%~1I!fS. CIIywCIe.
10. ~M ~ C3.."tO. ~ 'IcxJtt:;aIi;t .. b' W bJ:..-c;!' ~ ee8 ParO"8 StmBo ... Pale Iril.c
11. PatlAlo Cotm.dY CHj Czre. S~83,coo.. AI!!" :-.... ri"O" a:idlions an:l' ~~to ~
~_,a990_Co>A __
12. Ccmn.nIy~ b All 4 5 ~ 136, t(Il. ~ Irduert iTp~ fO ttle eettr WTVt s.wn
~~dpIM~~IIItI~.-dadl'..s.~~ S2SE.~~ PalcAm
'3. Md-Pri'tsI.JIYWCA, ftnwl~ t.oen ~ $3O.ocn. ~i:)a)\rdlo ~ ec:o"V'tIii';; ~
PnIrI! efb1s cJbII n::cme 1iII'Om8't CIIrWde.
14.. cq,afPab.Qo. Hcu;i"g ~ F\,nj, I35t.2Cn F\I'dI"Jg b' ~..nct; ...aid'pt'eSeI"_-e a-~q; ~
A..I1t:lIr d ~ II'it$ irI hi O!¥ ~ '0.,.-&0"$ d bw...,...." ~ i1comes. CitywIde.
ecr-wr..ts QJ'I h~ Pa'l O'!he ct.eG ~ Q'" ~ b ~ ~stoJd beCh:ted to
Suzame Act8'dI&. Ott r1 hIIoAllQ, PIirri1g ~~ 250 1iIrr«or't~ 5tl Fbr, PaC .Alo, CA 9a)1; 41Sf329..2¢28,.
it1 ~ WIh h AmlJkarls ~ C*alIiIies Ac! d 1P!Kl., b'et"'ina as:sisIi\fII!' dIMca> n: ~ ir1 IN Co:ud
~.nI Co:.n:i ~ Room. SV"l1llrgu2lgi& ~ .... be prOIo1cJed I4lOO r'OQ..8SI wit?I 1:2 I1c.Joo$ ~
""""'-
•
'. \'c .•
','
..
,<,
-
-",,-,
,'. '-~ -"j., , "
APPENDIX B
COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT BLOCK GRANT (rooo)
U!15 INCOME ELfGIBIUJ'Y LIMITS
re-....... 1lIoome Vsy ....... r-..e
laa. I!lid (Moo'"'''''' ADlluaI) (M._am A:uluaI)
I 28,150 22,450
2 32.150 2S,700
3 ~,200 28,900
~
4 40,200 32,100
S 43,4()() 34,650
6 46,650 31,2S0
7 49,850 --39,800
8 53,050 42,350 -
199$ Sa lou PMS.f _ -. fOr. ftJtni11 uf """ & 164.200: /995 U,S. """"'" __ fOr.
familJ '" jiNu iJ S40.1OO,
,~.
TABLE Ie (FROM 1994 CHAS)
SANTA a.ARA COVNT\': C\JRRENT INCOME
LIMITS FOR. BOVSING PROGKAMS BY HOUSEHOLD SIZE
1995
I 1 3 of 5
Em-,lGw_ Sll • .w 515.401 5!1,l34 519,2& Dl.*Xl
Ill· JOS)
Very .......... $22.430 525.'Il10 $21,900 $31.1~ S34.630
(31·30S)
r.-JiOIIIor r.-1Lowor 528.130 $31,ISO $36,200 14O,JOO 503.400
_(5!-63$) ---$44.~ 551,360 m.m J6oI.JOO 559.336
~I<lOS) 101 __
SSl.J2ll 561.632 $69.336 $77.040 S83.2OJ
(1Q1-I20S)
SarIta aara eo..nty BUD AnIl MtdiDn Income: S64.200 ftw If /mnj/y <?f four
E,/Jeaive; lfJ/Wl1lJ 1. 1995
-..
,
$22.341
$1'.2'0
S46.i50
$74.472
SI9,l66
.. . . ~,::-~ ~<~-<i!; ~:..' c'.'
To:
Fr=:
Dale:
Subject:
APPENOIX G
-------------------------
Distribution
s_ RX:hards. COW Coo<diDator
November 4, 1994
Summal:J or C_ Commeuls frum
October 14, 1994 Public Hearinc CD
Communit7 D .. eIopmem Needs
• TB~RTKDQN
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
Low income peopie can', afford 10 ride -there is no sub<idJ
Lack of same day selVic<
Housing sites (Alma, Ev ... tt. Emerson) doo',l!ave good bus access
Oull"ea::\ c""" ($3.00 pu rOOM trIP) is roo mud! for man)'
Paratraosi< pric<s incr .... "mg II> S4:~O per muDd Irip in luIy (roo expensive)
Same day pMlItransil servke -very importAnt -up to 530 III get 10 Kaiser
Need 10 get 10 mcd"ocaJ appointments
Need spec;'] l!"allSpOI1aoon for mobility impaired which is DO! rIr.ked 10
fJXOd rout< nosil .
fix«! rout< areas get paratransil servic<s: if. bus rOIl!< is cut. !ben the
paratramit servk.'t is CUl
Stat< of pubUc IranSpO<I3tion is poo<fIength 0( 1J'ips;'lacTc 0( bus servic<
• lllU
• Sob>i>elf-empioylutlll·f« low iri<:o<n<orarooss II> mknrloan< (01' II> $ 10K) 10
Jtart ""'" ~"'~
• RQilfij1NG
• Camis>U1lIII ~ bou$in& lJi'<S '" meet all t>O«!s
• BiB iu<:n:ase ill .iD,l1e parent familo,s shoul<I be I 'l""'ia! ~ groop --.f
shared bousing
• SlwU! bousing
• Nee<! IDea! bcmeles< prevention tiuld&
• Hcu$ing with servlceo {supportive bousing}
• NeWs in CHAS are JtiIl important
• Bet1~ litr.l~ for acguisition of ..:'_J::isting bouslng -pusb HUD 10 \VOC'k out
stratego,s 10 """"" fed.,.) money
• EI!couraie JIOIl-"ror ... 10 wOO.: I<>gethe, 10 jolod, provide bO<lSlng with
~ {collaborative}
• S400 per JIlOIlth for ,ent is 100 mucll for those tw!Io bav. in<:ome of ollly
$600 per roonth
• -. CHAS «>n!eIU -SIa, as Is
• ["""""'" llOe4 for bousing for developmenQIly e!Sible<!
-Ioog 'lfllitin& liots
-81$ peopl. in San Andreas Reg. Ctr. c!ieOl3
-people must move ou! of P.A-10 tincl MILling
• Re-examine City Housing ~e Funds 10 provide more momy
""'" fj""""W resources, esped,,,1y for residemla/ fund
2
• ..!" •
WDSider finklns fuods wi:!! othe,. in W"N)!
• Tempor-.ry boIlsiDg for fommes of patie.ots at Y A, Stanfo;d (I 10 8 months)
expand volanttel' program where peopl. offer rooms in private homes
• Assi:swx:e wilh maye-ill CtlOIS
• !IOM'fl rss
• Housing for those will> 110 jDCO~
• S1I)JllO<1 for Regior.aJ Homeless ReCeption ~nter
• Sorvkes for I>om<less
• Coowl'Je City suppoct of CooN)! Homer... Collaborative
• Transporta,6on youcbus assistance for pcopie in sile:lter$
• FacD ity for cloUtes close,
• Pennanelll facility for all bomeless services
• Services for homeless cMdrca, Le, .chDd care
• PIJce 10 _/laundry, place 10 ,tore belongings -cenlrallzed faciii<"i
• enrre .. pro<'~ for homeless are inadequate
• Sb<Iter {year-round} facility in NortbICenlral Coonlf
• NO! enough foodfmeals for .belters
• Assistance with IDOvc-in, costs as homeless prevent>on service
• PUlUC SERVICES
• Fosler care for Latino ~nil ..
3
•
• Moro services for lee": ie., homework a!llerS; drop-ln conler>; expand
efforts at ocboo!s
• "'SONS WJTB DJSARUJTJ&S
•
•
~lnk p<iD< media (for blind, persons with e"vironmental disabilities -
tapes arc besQ
(See paratransit also)
4
1 :.:.
'-... , .~"',_.c •
.' <,
.~ r"
lHElEAGUE
OF WOMEN VOTERS
OF PALO ALTO
rL:'J.-" _.
!"~ ..... C,
'-'
--'-.~ ; 3/", '" -. ..,;)
451 M\lGSL£'I' ,l,VENUE • P"-LO ,I.llQ, C.qJfQRNJ4 94301 .4.15/327·914S
Karch I, 15195
TQ: Chair and Kembers of the Pla.?U'lIinq CODUllission
city or Palo Alto
%he League of Women voters of Palo Alto commends the City
Planning Staff for preparation of the cIty of palo Alto Dr~ft
COnaol14ated Plan for JUly 1, 1995 throgqb ~une 3G~ 2000. We
understAnd adoption of such a consolidated Plan is required by
the federal 90vernment in connection vith application for federal
housing and community development funds, as in the CO!IDlIunity
Development Block Crant program.
The Housing Needs Assessmer.t shows that there are unmet housing
needs for all cate~rles of lower income Palo Altans. As stated
on page 46, Palo Alto policy Is to rely primarily on p~ivate
groups to initiate housing development proposals~ For the long
term, the city must be in II position to lend support to new
bousinq proposals serving a wide variety of needs~
The League believes the bous,ing sections of this 1995-20{)<0 Draft
Plan contain sufficient breadth in prlcrities and proposed
actlvitEes ~o provide the required flexibility. We urq~ that the
Consolidated Plan be adQPte~ vithout siqnlficant change O~
deletle<>.
The Leaque also s.upports the strong emphasis qiven to housing in
the 1995-96 A~tio~ Plan. Table 3 tolloving page 54 lists several
projects which the Leaq\le supports and is bopeful ,,111 proce"d in
1995-96. including the Alua Street SRO housinq and retention of
the Arastradero Park Apartments as subsidized b~sinq. We feel
it is essential that a substantial part of the 1935-96 COBG
fWlding be allocated for housinq.
The League also urges CODtlnuation thrOQqh the Human. Service
Division in the City's Depa:&:b!ent of Community Services of
support to nonprofit aqencies providing services to residents,
such as cbila care, teen counseling. rape crisis~ single
parenting classes, and nutrition programs. We particularly urqe
such support in areas affecting children and families with
children. We yould like to see these services offered to
homeless famIlies with children.
!'bani< you.
Sally Pr~st, President
Pat Saffir. Heusing Chair
Falo Alto Housing Corporation
Ma't~ ~. 1994
Suzanne Ri<lwdl
CDBG CoonfL'laIor
City of Palo Alt<>
P. O. lIo. I02SG
Palo AltG, CA 94303
lle: Ccnsolidoted Plan
Dear SUZIImIe:
~-.~-
CO,yr.:;.. ........ " _
Vanou. o! 00< P ABC r .. d ..... l1od small tedU1ico! comments 10 lh. ConsoMated Plan. ... hlc~ I
mentioned I would get 10 you in ",nting They are as renows'
I. Page C}~ Re Palo A.'to Commoos.. There is currently on1y enougb mODey in 'tM in~
lieu accounl SO subsiaae the rent on twO', rather than three uruts.. at $500 per month_ FARe
has alS(') recommended that the Pfograro. b.e phased "t;t as CU11'ent subsidized tenants leave tne
complex.
). Fag. 14; Suppor-.we Housing Chart. Lou Goldsmith confi,med th .. ,nere is no unlt
at C<>lorado Park Apartments 111 .. is • disabililJl uri" of aoy s<>fL
. . J. Pagt 46; Fede.ral Program. Correct -spelling" is UHPRHA It ".nds for the Low
1nc.omt ~smg Pres.ervt.fiotr and Resident &meowtu:rs.'1.ip Act.
4. Fage 48; As I menti<llled at the healing. "ABC berr ...... tbat O<Jr self·subsidies of
vttriotI5 tenants in out properties should get credit as Rental Assistance. and' tlu!t our--=..peratfon.
c( the Bmet HoIeI is p,eventing numbers of peopl. from !Jecorning bomc1e" an.! .!muld be
registered as Homefess Prevention.
Thanks for your good w<><1<.
~...........,
~ H P",odergast
F.xecutlvt Director
j !"
". ". # #
~ • !!: !
, #!, ##"'#'" ; ###,### ~ 1Ii!5! Co ~ =ri ~ .... 0 r--!!l=~;;J,IIr.I.,"
h ~ ~ r # IIClo :::: ::
;! ~ "!
A-; or-::;~'l.O'" Ii = ... t;;;fO'>O~ ~
if " # ~ ~=,
~ j ~
~ -. ~ < 1 to ~ • c-Z ....
~ "-! Ii'###### § #,.##### ! .. § Qf4~ooc~ 4=~OQo=
~ . • c _ ~ e 000-• .. _ ~ eo 00 0= _ ..
H " , ~ ~111:~
,~ 1
;t • ~ ;' ..... ;; < -r 2 l ~ It z
, ~ ! # it ~ #. ii' #-~ ! #,##,,#, ,
c:!:a~t--Q'" ~=~~.o ... !
~. ~ o--==~"'1-o"", I: ... 'C'!~,.o,.. ;;
,. "., ".
1 ~ • :! !
~ i.,~ ::t.~ ;
! !h
,. ~ ! ###,,#,# I ~ #. ~ ~ ~ '#. #-".
~-c:!~; .... 'O :!=~.:at"o.., !
" . ;:; Co OW) :5: '!: _ Co of'! ::: "'~:2~"'o", ;
,. r' ! ! •
11
IIH .. . . •
'l ". i' # .. # ". # ! " # # 1# , .. " ! § 00! o==:r;:oo c==~~oo
.. .. .. ~ _ ... ... IN. • Co • 00 __ .-:1",00 ..
11 I •
I Ii J
!
~I
~ 1 J iPP i J ! juuiJ ! 1-)\ ~l
., • 0:
:z ~ III l-
I 1! • I ~
[ .. ~ • 1 1$ " 1\ ~ I ..
~~~~ : ....
I/l"~" ;;:;r: 1, ~""t. ....
~I
f!
I
;',l[ ..
:to 2 .... ; t~l ~
.l':"
t'" II ~'"'!:;~ •
.,~
'b ..., ... e .. "
-.,
,. 't6 " .. ..
~"" ~ .... 11 ...... .. .. ~'J~tt
""": ti "I :!~G: .. " I !!J~:t
<II" .. " ....
I J
.... ~Ifl 1.11
! "'t;_ ......
" .. I S
"";0-1:';: ., ..
-*.. .. c ..,
.c 0 4'ot_ -"
11 """ " ~VJI:t*~#
trtl t
..,. • t-... 00,..
f
" fIt,!
i 1 .
i
~"':" " ..
-}.1[
.,., ..
~!
~ ... !! ...... ~.c~ ;-
........ ~ <:: e ""
I ~ ,.. ~ 0'1',,;
.... O.Oor; ...
J G q ~ ttl
!t .. I/1 .... "" .... ~Qol
1 111
" .. 1
ttl
teo
~t .. tlll " .. " §
1/ ZI"C~,.,o
:'i
"' ..... e= ....
~""t •• "
..... O'~f'\ ...
; .... " .. : ..
-----It .. ~.:: .. 2
1111::
;1 :~1
-
lttfk~"( .... '"
JII ~ CI '" ...... ~
;::l "0" <>" 1/1IJi.l
~oo.co d '" i • J"': ! !lllll
~"iifl ~-" f ~~l I ..
ill " '" }
Ji~~~~
I I / I I J " J
t
h
\'
1
.,
IJ
.,
!
I
--
""" ~ " , " " " " ! )t""""" ~ " " " ! ~~t. ~t;;~c .. w "II ~ == .. :i It'-w::!~
i " I
0 ! J ... lit"" , = ~ 'C 00 00 f'i t ...... " ::: ~ VI "'~~ , ., -. .I .. t .c ~ ~
• ",," ; " " " " " " " ] f"""""" "",, " • oo! ~I:tooo ! 'I 5:oo~oo C§:O ! 11 " l
~ I h ...... ... -~ -.... .. ... NO=~CC .. ... .. ... .s1 ~ § . l... _ .. • t~ """ " " " " " " " " ! ::.,tt~.,.#~ ". I' ! '!i~ ! ~t=C;OIr. !! '5 :: ~ !::: ... ; .c-~ m
• .l! " i I. ~ ~ . -. ~ !lilt" '" ~ IIr) ~ Co'" '" ", ....... !:.-::..., 3-., I E = .z. .. ~
~ t """ " """''''''' ! ~ "" " " " " ! 'i ,,",,::!,,~ .. ;till· =~=oo • ..." _ 00 .... _
10 =': .-! ~
J ~ " ! ~ .
:J!:~ ~~.oo,.. J ., J E~ ::! ::! _.e::_ .. 00 .. :=: ::! ! .1_ ~ ..
I
"''''' ! " '" " ~ ~ ~ " iI""",,,,,,,, ~ " '" " " :=0 fCi ::t :: ! .. ""~~,;:c ! ~ l! : !
J~ " i ..
! ~ ': .. ~ e_ .. ~ . " ... '=' Co 0 ~ .. 1"'1 ... _ ... 0 I "~ .. ~ Hh !
,! ~ I J c -= .. I: 't t ~ r -I j t I 'lill! ~ j 'pP ;; i 1 ,~ I .!..!" ~ <1$« t,~ d=H QIi i. j i! Iliff ! " = ~
1 ., ., .. I I • • :E ., ., • ~ I ~ 1 'I J •
11 .. .! i • 'i
i i .. !
c.':l: ~ :E J .. .. •
ll' # f '" ~! .. .. Ii ~::I
~
0 ! I ~ .... .. co _ .If)
iU
'" ~ '" '" '" ! ~ II' ~ '" II' ",I" .. =-~ :: :J =.O<NO~!:
_NfO)P:;~ :!i " No .... _ c .. t
r ~ # II' # #
H
_ 00 CO 11>
.d f ~ .. 0 CO 0: C ~ PSi I .. _
P ~ '" '" '" ~ or;;."_
I i.
~ 1 ""
< I f co .. .. _ ...
i-• /Ii",
II' ",II' '" "'; # II' " '" '" '" ! co co 0 ~ WI ~o.co~ IQ f'4.1_
d ... ~eccc-~
'" '" '" ~ '" r '" II' "'II' ~ "'If 1£ !:" It -:.: ~ ! Jw.,: .... C!:. ~
_",_N<: ~ ~"l"_OC !;l
.
i .,.t.~'## 0"'0:""". '" '" '" # '" ::?: co 00 e ~ ~ ",,,,,,,,,,,,,#
:;tC~ ..... o;s. !
J b Hq !&,-0=0"0_..., _ 0. 10 0 ,... ~ = A .... _ C S ~
~ £ ~ ~ ~ ~#-#'*'If.
Co ;:::: = ~ ~ ~ ~ '" .... '" .. _ .0 -= 0 C CO ~
I!
flU .000 0 ~
~<<>-, ~Oil!
I
J
I ..
:I
1
l. ...
! •
~~"#"~"1'!! ,-.. =~I.= ,., !
11
l't-... "" Ie ~ V' 0 N ._ 1
!d
if
""#,,II#IIf, ! "2:Q~~ ••
~Ih "N._o._.~# ..
~. '" ;.. -
i t I "#""#",,,,, i l ~ w>,...t.:t!: • ..,"
lJl ....... £ ... :.; .. 0«-1:
-.,,,,,,,,,,,"t i t ~"~2·'=1C' • .i ~ . . ~ i !H "'''''''-$;1''':100«_ ~
~ i H
if
H , t
2!,-~
5' "" .. iJl:~ -'! .s;
.! J5 J5
111 HI e ( e ; , s .. t" i i
"""""""'# ! .:: ::= :: ~ = 0 .• .,
If
iiH ... 0 ......... 0.0 ..
UJ
,~ ~
~! ~ Hz
!H!IJP J
l~~J I" J
J
j j
.!.f..e
If! ~ !
!
Ii
J e