Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout0207.093lUI " - ~ o , , . < ••. . ',- March IS, 1993 THE HONORABLE CITY COUNCil Palo Alto, California THE ~ JJECT OF THIS REPORT ISA COUNCil PRIORITY 13 R&coQJmendation to Con!inue participati",," ti]!LB.EQ.Jeam and tQ~ceed ponce Deoortment's Altt.~orized Staffing Level Report in 6rief The Regional Enforcemarn Detail (RED T3am) has been actiVely assisting tne East Palo A~o Police Department [EPAPD) for almost one ~ea;, having commenced operation on Apnl1. 1992. Thls report summarizes the RED Team success to date, briefly describes the current crimina! environment in EPA and proposes 15 months of cootinued participation in tne RED Team through June 30, 1994. To date, overtime expenditures have been used to backfi'l for RED Team activity. Pending Council approval of oontir.ued assiStance, staff requests 8P\Yoval to exceed authorized staffing levels 10 backfill for those officers assigned in East Palo Alto. Total cost !or the 15 montn continuation equals $668, I 55. S1aff proposes 10 take tn;s from t,e Budget Stabilization Reserve since funding is not sufficient to oover the add~ional expenditures from on-going revenue sources. From iis incep1icn, RED Team effor".s have been to target crime in East Palo Alto via a proactive, highly visible enlorcement operation ~ was clear frem the start that the RED Team alone was not a "fix' to the crime prOblem; in East Palo AM. The concept behind tne Team's creation and uncertying ~ deployment for the last year has been 10 augment the severe~f understaffed East Palo Alto Police Department Team accompfishmenlS 100 .. "rd tha! e'ld have been remarkable, especially in light of tn. adverse conditions under which the Team has had to operate. Some of these include high recognition by criminals and their resentiment at It1e curtailment of their activities, routine violent oonfrontations and tne need 10 main'.ain constant Ie>els of vignance th!oughout the entire workday. Despije these impediments, operational success can be measu red on many levels. During !he eleven months ol BED Team operalion through february' w;J, tne Team has made 491 arrests for crimina: viofations rangfr'lg from theft 10 murder. During these arrests, 39 rifles and shotguns were seized, in addrtion to 49 handguns and a daggers. Narootics, with a street value of $60,000, were reoovened. These included crack cocaine, heroin, marijuana and otner illegal substances. Operations elso netted tne reoovery of 31 slOlen vehicles. The dollar value o! property reoovered during RED Team operations totaled approximately $216,000. CMR:207:93 3-18·93 ·,. • - o Statistical COUnts, however, do not tell the whole sla-y. in addition to the removal of criminals, cIr..gs and weapons team the street, the RED Team has amassed considerable Pllbflc support !rom the broader citiZenry. Residents in P ala Me have expfessed support for R ED Team activities as a mechanism to assis! a beleagwered neighbor. Those people Jlving in areas proximate to the boundary wi'J1 East Palo Alto feel tne RED Team has provided some reiief trom the continual nightly gunfire r.eard in those neighborhoods and the tailing bullets that heve been reported in the past. Menlo Park residents, particularly those in the Willows erea, feel s;mila~y. RED Tea'll members report hearty appl8use for their efforts trom East Palo Alto citizens, and EPAPD officens feel their burden is made consklerably lighter and safer when the RED Tllam is wor\<if'.<;j. Some opposition to the RED T sam conc9pt and the funds necessary to support it have come from membens of the pubr", who feel that East Palo Alto's crime problem is better Ia1\ to San Mateo County and its political sulxfrvisions. These opponents do not give credence 10 tne conr..ept of crime as a regional problem. OverBII, however, pubflc support appears \0 hea<11y outweigh the opposition. This is based on comments to the police agencias inVOlved, IYess reports and public oomments at COUncit maelings. Cwell! Criminal Climate in East Palo &'\0 Last year, East Palo Mo acquired the unique status of oecoming America's deadliest city, when 42 homicides and approximately 200 other shootings occurred "'ithi~. the City limits. The title of murder cap~oi, however, ~as forI'~nat91y nol carried over into the new year. In fact, so far this year, rot one murder has occurred in East Palo Mo. The rsasons for this sudden downturn ere not claar, a.lthough some speculation can be of!8red. Since the major arrest operation this past summer, coorcflnated will, FBI assista'1C8, a number of those arrested have since been sentenced and are off the street. The same holds true for many of those arrested by the RED Team. Several known ·shooters· have been arrested and are, al least foc the Ume being, out 01 circulation. ~ would be unwise to presume \hat crime is trending downward despite me reduction in homicides. Many nonfatal shootings have occurred, and a disturbing new trend is emerging. Recently, there has beer. a dramatic illcfease in the number of ir.cidents wherein the police have been the targets of gunfire. In 1992, five incidents occurred where officens were fired upon; during the first two mO<lths of 1993, !C.ere already have been five additional SUCh incidents. There have been severa' other s~uati<>ns involving shootings where the poIioe were not certain whether indeed they were the intended tafgelE. The len irlcidents dted, however, were ronfirrned situatioos whe'ein the ponce were involVed in actual exchange of fire or were shot at directly. Several police cars have sustained hits fram gunfire. Fortunately, none of the officers have been injured. CMR:207:93 ,. • - East Paio.~s Long-Term Pian in March 1992, wilen Council or'.ginally authorized funding for the RED Team, continued assistance to East Palo Alto was prea,cated on that City's development of a long-term p .. .'b/ic saf9ty pia". The staffing portion of t'18 plan has bee n deve!ooad and is atlached as A;Jp9nd1x A for Counc~ review. The Police Chiefs' Associations of both S8nta Clara and San Matl>O countieS have reviewed and endorsed the plan. Because significant attention has focused on East pajp Alto, the next year holds rome promise that adcf~iona' outside assistance may be available. A number of influential officials at both state and federal !$vels have been made aware oi the s~uatior, by local offic1als including Mayors MoCo-Nn, Slocum and Wilson representing the. cities of Palo Alto, Menlo Park, end East Palo Alto. East Palo Alto Pofioe Chief Matthews has also approached several grant funding entities and reports some promise exists in this area The California Highway Patrol Cornmissior.er has r",,--ently a~ed a contingent or highway patrol officers to work exclusively in East Palo Alto for a minimum or 60 days, beginning Apr, 1. Fourteen officers will work traffic-related matters, but will also respond to emergencies and serve as back-up. ~ appears the San Mateo County Sherfff's Depa,iment may take a new direction ~ respsd to East Palo Alto. Leadng candidates for the office or shan!! have publiCly expressed a willingness to help with the situation; and ~ is staffs understanding that the actitlg sheriff has agreea to provide 18 cleputies, begiMing ,t.,priI 1, lor an undetermined period. Alter the June 8 special election, action by the newly-elected sheriff and Board or SuperviSOrS will be needOO for continued participation or sher:ffs aeputies. In short, hope exists now where preYlOUsiy very liltJe did. AssiSlan(:e to East Palo Alto lor the next year will 1101 only help with e regional crime problem, but may enhance the East Palo Alto PolICe Depa,'tment's viability untJl substantial financial assistance is rendered. it is important to note that the funding portion or East Palo Alto·s plan is still being developed. The assistance providecl by San Mateo County, the Cai~omi3 Highway Patrol, Menlo Park and Palo Alto on an interim basis will only bridge t">e gap until the funding for the East Palo Alto plan is obtained. Red Team Contin~atioo Staff recommends providing COi1~nued assistance to EPA by extending RED Team participation. The RED Team, in ~ present form and deploymer1t, provides East Palo Aho with a proactive enforcement group that can be ~exibly appiied to address eri me problems which the normal patrol staff carmeL The RED Team also reduces the frequency for Palo Alto patrol officers to respond to East Palo Alto for aSSistance. Palo CMR;207:93 3-18-S3 .3- - ------------------------------.------------ Alto units we<.;ld respond eVGn =e lrequenl!1 than they do now ~ 00 RED Tea.." or similar component ",'ere operative. WI".~e ~ is unclear what the future will hold ;or crime rates in East Palo Alto, it is dear that \he financial, emotional and physical a:>sts 10 f.ghl crime have been significant. Assignment of four Palo AltD officers to the RED Team has required overtime fil~in to maimain Palo Mo Poflce Department's COnIractual minhnuf'1 staffing levels. During the RED Team's ten month operation, lotal actual costs associated with Palo Alto's partioipa!ion equal appro>lmately $339,600 (rer.r to Appendix B for breakdown.) This includes the salaries/benefits and equipment of the four Police Department employees on \he RED Team. Council authorized overtime expenditures of $100,000. Actual minimum staffing overtime expense, ptus RED Team overtime, has totaled $69,765 for the RED Team operatiollal period Of Ap<il 1992 to FebnJary 1993. To reduce overtime demands on officers, stall did not attempt 10 raise patrol staffing levels to these that normaJf>, would have existed Mad RED Team officers not been assigned. Some difficulty has beer> experienced in filling the minimum staffing vacancieS. To have attemptsd to go beyond thai level would have likely required mandatory overtime assignment Of officers. Staff is concemed that Palo Alto officers r.ave bacome fatigued by working overtime !lSSignmerns. Contir.uai ovarJm. assignments at this past year's level would likely resutt in a general service decline. The overti",e use assoc:ated with RED Team participation has been compouoded by the fact that during the same time period, the department has e"ll8rieooed an inordinately high injury rate requiring even more overtimt>. Staff beU6\'9$ thai continual use of officerll working overtime for the same period Of time er_ an undesirable situation. Pending Councol approval for continued partidpation Of the RED Team and in ordel' to mitigate o\'artime demands 00 Officers and to hetp maintain staffing levels, staff befleves that addnional sworn personnel are needed to backfill for officers assigned to the RED Team, These additional officers wi!! reduce the need 10<' mandatory O\Iertima. Therefore, staff requests approval to exceed current authorized staffing ievels by one sergeant ar.d two officers for the dufatioo of the City's ccmm~ment to East Palo Alto. ~ Couool conceptually approve> this request, staff anticipates that n wil take a minimum of three rr<>nths to recrun and hire these personnel. Funds to cover these costs would be included in the 1993-94 tnterim Budget Because n wiN take at ie8s\ an additional lour months to train th~ new officers, overtime funds would be needed to maintain minimum S'.affing levels during that seven morth period. COst Estimates Staff feels n is importarrt to provide Council with total ac1ual costs associated with continued RED Team participation. These expe°.ditures include both costs for RED Team CMR:207:93 c:':~-,,-_;;_" • ...J._______ ---... -.. - members (already included ir, the Fofice Department's bu<lget) and new costs. rt should be noted that costs include salary and benelITs. Council autho<izec:i o'o'E>rtime expendrtu,,", of $60,000 associated witl1 RED Team participation this fiscal ye"" n is projected, ~d on cu"""t usage, that tIlese t.mds will be expended by the mklclle of May. Staff anlic\pates that approximately $lD,COO in addlfional overtime costs will be needed from May 15, 1993 ur-til June 30, 1993. Staff /:>ef>eves sufficient funds exist '" the PoflCEl Department's current budget to cover these e><penditures, but n not, staff wiil request a transfer from Ire city Manager's Contingency Acrount. Costs Already lncIuded in ponce Depart.ment 1992-94 Budge1 RED Team Members 1 Sergeant 1 Agent 2 Officers 1 Sergeant 1 AgeU1t 2 Officers Apn11, 1993 -June 30, i993 SUBTOTAL RED Team Members July " 1993 -JuUle 30, 1994 SUBTOTAL $ 20,474 $ 1S,001 $~ $ 65,683 $ 81,914 $ 76,003 $14;) 649 $296,566 Additional Costs Not Jr.cuded in Pofice Departm"r.'. 1992-$4 Budget Overtime bacl<fill (May 15, 1900 -June, 30 1993j $ 10,000 Estimated Costs -for exceeding authorized staffing level (Ju~/1, 1993 to June 30,1994) 1 Sergeant 2 Officers ·Overtime SUBTOTAL $ 81,914 $140,649 $ 52,693 $275,256 • For RED Team members and backfill untii new officers hired, Equipment (Append'", C) TOTAL COST CMR:207:93 $..16&iQ 5688,155 3-18-93 -5- ;;] .1 -----------------------------------~~ The RED T earn has c!ra'llatically acted during tho past year to mitigate crime in East Palo Alto and ., !he surrounding communities. The ccmbined efforts 01 a regional approach hIM! been a worthy display of cooperative law enfo(cernent under very difficu~ circumstances. Wrth additional assistancE; apparently coming from the San Mateo County Sheriffs Office and the Calffomia Highway Patrol, staff bafieves continued RED Team sctMty will further decrease crime and provide tirne for East Palo Alto to implement the long-term pubflC safety plan. BAppmmenciations Staff recommends that Council 1) Authorize continued assistance to the City 01 East Palo Alto in their ef!ons to reduoe crime by extend"mg the RED Teem to June 30, 1994 and 2) Authorize the porrce Department to exceed !IS budgeted staffing level by one sergeant and two officer positions. ~11y S~bmitted, / rY/t1 /t(.(/~,- Attachment: Appendix A Appendix B Append"oc C CMR:207:93 3-1SS3 -6- • Dat~: To; From; ') APP[ND1X A " EAST PALO ALTO POLICE DEPARTMENr'c~' NlEMORANtJlJM Fetruary .c:., 19$3 M~!:1bersJ San Ma":.;;CJ ccunty Felice C'.'jief's .!.,ssoc:',:ticrl Bu~nha~ E. Matthews Chief c'f PelicE' Subject: EPA Task force Report Due to the. t:re!l\.enaous cr irne pr-:.blems being cCl"'.rr'::>n't.ed by tr.e E~st Palo Alto Police Department, i~ is relt in orde~ to gain c~ntrol of the streets, a superior force of uniforced police presence be made. Tbis show of fcrce c-==n~ot be of d limit:c c~rat.ion. Thcreiorel at the request of the SMCPCA EP.],. Task Force t the attached proposal of anticipat~C: police depart!",ent needs has be~n drafted. The plan calls for a definitive increase in the ~umber of officers lTon the street': at anyone tiI:".e, or a ;r,inimu:,:,. of eig'l::t plus a supervisor. Additionally, t.he plan also calls for an "overlap" shift between the hours of 1600 to 0200 ho~rs. In this manner the maxim'..ltn number of uniformed persoT".nel ""ill be availa,ble to handle not only calls for service, but i-:1itiate a pro-active 'Work mode as well. Historically, the ability t.o be pre-actiVE! i!l attacking the cr ir.e prot lE-!7ls has !'"Ict been ~'cs sible, Furthermc=e, due to the type af aqg~e5sive cc:icc 2ctivity w~ich .is ar.ticipate'':', it is impera~i'/~ the St::reY'Ii,sory a-:ld ::nid:l.le management of the department be stre:.gther.ed. The nurrber of investigators has also been increased to support !:h8 ... 'ork o~ the uniformed o!~icers. This proposal has beer. revie_w'ed by the 1251< force and adjustJ:1e:r:ts made. It i5 my. as ""tell 2S the IdS}: For..::e's opir,iorl that the primary factot" ir. this proposal is to increase d::-astice.lly t.?"-.e specific scheduling can be alte~ed t~ ~eet the never e~ji~g changes irl cr-irne patt.erns. The plan alsc a:~ticipates th3t after a fi",'e year inte~sified enfor-ce"::,,ent p!:,og~arr., the need [':,r the hi'?h !i~t!1i:'.Er cf off ieers :8,'-1' be dimi:"!ished. Trj h s f.a':-t. is i;"ldicated ir. the change of years six thr-Ollgh ten, reflecting a decrease ir-, ,-.r-.e rleed of p-=rsonnel. • ;c, l o This would be only possible if the I!roct causes" 0: the cril":1e, i.e., pcverty. employnent, education, ca~ be add~e~sed thro~g~ an intense social services program by city, cClln~y, state as well as federal agencies. The police dcpart~ent alan!;':: cannot !"lake any Zl.ppreciable it:lpact on crime .... 'ithout the .:.forementior,ea support of the social ~ervices networ-k. Additionally, end most i~port~~tly is the need for intensive economic develop~ent in the city >:0 support badly needed city services. Without ade.quate develor-rnerlt of a tax base~ !:he SI..l.stain-ed police preser.,::e in the city .... i11 not be possible. I-c is requested that upc'n review of the plan, :r'j nus i:tinor changes to the deployment of t.he personnel, th€ San Hat~o co ..... .,ty Pol ice Chizf's A5s0ciation approve of the proposal in the concept. Along W'ith the Associaticn's approval, the plan ... .rO'...l.ld be propos€d to the East Palo Alto City council to advise the~ of what the county's police chief's feel the real need is to ~ttack the ov~rt street cri!Il.e problem. • ~~_::-O600 0600-0700 0700-0800 0800-0900 r 0;00-1;00 ~aOQ-ll(lQ - ~~1260 1200-1300 1300-;'400 ~:~P_~-15C'O 1500-1600 ;600-111210 , !.700-180''J r--, _C~"_ -.J. -\ 0 \ 0 , 0 -, i --r }_~_~_~g_:::-_2 0_0 SJ I c ! s c ---I 2 ~ \ I 2000-2100 I 16 I If.. 16 1E I T I 2100-2200 IE I IE 16 16 I I I ---- 1 i t.-~200-2300 , 15 16 lG 16 _1 - \ I -- \ 2JOO-2;toOC 16 16 16 i 1(- --L_ i 16 :;'F -! 16 l6 I -i ASQVE NUMBERS EXCUJDE SC?ERVISOF:S "'-" ~ ;-"'"' o c I ....... . -.......::~ .~.-. ..:: •. ......::.::'~ -~" -~ .. "_..:.::.:_::.:..~~.:.:}·!:;:=t~'::!rlN::l.i..<· ~~~..,...,.,' *,... ;;~\4 ~st ~A-~~_UQ~~ ~LQ.-..Y.ili!!'_fuJQ9.J~-.t...r.r.Qj!£ct iOI1~. Years 1 - 5 -- EMPLOYEE SERVICEs Year 1 Year 2: Year J Year , -j Year 5 J ------~ ~-~---~--- 4,7'0,'77-'~2'O'8 _~~LARI ES I 4-,~~, ., l~_ 4,429,065-... ,606,22" I r FRING~ DENEFITs 1,320,202 1, ."173,010 ~_!.!2 7 ~!_3...£.. __ 1,485,048 1,Si.,449 ~---------------r--~------~-c---~----~---- OVERTIME 375,000 375,000 "!.!.-'5, 000 __ 375,000 :1'/5, 000 ! r--------------~ -----~----- ! SU8ToTAI. 5,953,918 6,171,075 6,409,151 6_~ 65~52".i __ 1-'< ' 9 0 1 ,~ ,_,--r-------~- f-------_._-f---~ --~---- SERVICES/SUPPL1ES ,-~ c-----t-----~-----~---------~---------"-------- OFFICE EXPENSE 7~,OOO 76,000 81,120! fl~_~~ ___ ~9 I r-=-'--c------------,-,~------~ ------- CONTRACT SERVICES I 239,000 144,560 _L_ :::: ::: r ::~~:·t :::: ::B '---------------.-~ ~~~~'-NT~':'~."-C~----'-'-"-'~ ° 0 46B,ooo __ i ~L _~ _______ '!!:~~/~?~_ __ 6~O,560 ___ . 718,88:'. ~_7_~91iJ __ 7?6,_7~. ! rUDT()~' i CAPITAL_ EXPENSES ___ L_--'-1~~.?"""____L_------3,056 r-__ 4_~1770__ -4_6,569 ___ ~--~,.~~1 ~~UBTOTA_L . I_--'-~~OO 43,056 44,779 4',569 _____ '!_~~ tGOT~-;:--------_---i~:;-~!.~~ .,910,691 ~2'817 7,"4,004 7,"'6,761 II The above figures inolude a. cost of living inOJ:e.ase of 4% per year for each coateqory. No cost of livinq increase added to overtim@ amounl$ ftS it is anlicipato~ that theso amount~ could be reduced each year. ., • I l I , ~ ~ ( ", ,.I ( " 'f EaB~,'!1.!? Alto Proposal ).~'(f>_ar B!!Qg~_~X~iol~\_ Years 6 -10 r~~~~9YEE BEHVICES -, ~Har 6 __ . Year 7 _~ Y'ear 8 - ~~~9 _____ ~ar 1~_ S'LARIEa =!= 4,995,222 4,991,739 4,990,061 __ 4,899,971 4 , 19 4 ,"-"-'--i ~~~NGE ·-;;N~.F.!TS --_=r __ ~~~54~'r-;~'; ~ _~!..:0 . .?1139_G~4~,9~ --~L~_18t()9J. 1,486,J64 ~ 375,000-1 OVERTIME 375,000 375,000 315#000 ~-----,---,~ ----, --------__ 375,000 __ ~ 6 5 ~-;;;;-~I I 50I3TOT~!~ _________ ~~ 'Jla, ~"..!_~r-~6, 914, 178 6,911,980 6 r 793,962 I' SERVICES/SUPPLIES --f---------i --11 I ---.. ---------~------+-~~---- --106 / 74.0-! , OFFICE EXPENSE: 'il,249! ')1,999 99,694 102,642 f-C------------------~---------,..----------------r---------'------- CONTRACT SERVICES 169,114 17~,879 182,914 190,2]1 197,04Q f-------------------------------~~ ------~ f---------~~-i VEHICLE MAIN'l'F..t-ll\NcE J 530,460 516,2S~ __ 505,326 473,5)4 t 472,5<9 t----------~-----,---------f------------------ SUDTOTAl, 790,823 787 /028 706 p 934 766,407 777,137' I~===-=----." ..... ---------.~. ~-~----- ------------I~""" '''~''-'--i --",,'" i--~~! 384 -- 54,479 ~_3~.!.659 __ 5~~ I t!--?_~!OTAL____ _ ___ ~D,369 ____ ~!2~ 54,479 ~ __ 56,65_~_ ____ ~6'925_il i ~---.--------.---------~------~------il LTOTAL 7 /"159,9]3 7,753 /590 7,75J,39] 7,61",028 7, 4..!21 118jj -. . -.===~- The above figures include a, 1% cost of living increase in each oategory and n"flect the redUctions in manpower and vehiclea for years 6-).0. " .~,/ • o ( ------"----~----. -____ n __ ':~_.-_-':~:C··"-' :~ ... ~~9_tJ?Al9_b_l tQ._J;~!:..9.~q_~_1'!! J,Jl~'i~!!:~lruIt . ..Erll~..t.J..9B~ Years 1 - 5 EMpLOYEE SERVICES -l!eac 1 Year 2 Year J Year ol I Yel'lr S nS-A-I-.A-R~-B-S ----~~-.-t"-' 2-;~;~~-~4n,n2n5n~n,n7n1n.~--"n.-2-~;n, n7-1-;: 4 , 2 SO T 716 4 , 2 ~-,-7-1-6-11 r!i;N~~:_~~~~_~l'1';-__ l:J~;-~-~_~~_._ l,34!O,202 . __ ~,3~;;;;--_~!-~~O~}_?~ -l~;~1 L.9VERT-.!.~~~n ___ " __ ~ ____ . ___ !~~~ __ ~_5,OOO J75,~__ 375,000 ~_~,oo_~ k""='" > •• n. n. • ... ',.n.__ ~95J,~~_ 5,953,918 __ 5, 953~ 919 I ------------------4--_____ __ ._~n _____ _ , SERVICES/SUPPLIES I I] ~~r~~E ~-~-E-N-;'E--~-_-_-~_=--_;~~~_non_n_n:!-__ ~~n7-S, 000 --7-5:;;0-On-+=_-" 5 , 000 T=-n-;~-;-o-".o_ CONTRAC'l' SERVICES -~--------------t----~-:-?-' .. ~~~ y!.:~!_~.LE~J.!"INTE~~.~~"~._~_~?_~._~~_~ _ _ ::~DTOT~~~ __ ~-+_~~_~~ .. ~~~_O __ , ~~~ 000_ 1-39, o.?~_+-~~~ .. , ouo _, l~!~~~~i ~.L00_._i 664,000 664,OO? ____ ~4,OOO , 4501000 __ 1 __ ~~~~ __ _l-_"_50,OO~~-~~'OOO~I, -i--~-~+--~-~--. ---------1 _, CAPITJl.L EXPENSES ! 414,000 'U,4UO 41,400 41,4QO 41,-4.00_ 1 1' r;;-D-~~;-AL-'-'--~~-r · ~<n,no-o-;-~~n.-;~:;;o--· ----;1-,-.-0-0--------n.nln,n4nO-O-~·~· ~--~~4-Q-O-~ ;~~~~-~n~~~n-~-.-~-,n1-J~-_,-9n~ ~~~-~-1-8-·~n.n,-.-S-9~~~ ~.659,~B~-'-'-6-'6:~3:1 The above ligures represent 199) dollars and cost of living increases are not tactored into lheBe charts. I'~.: ,-'If '~T""".:' ~ ,.: ," "'f-"--- c, i; '; " . .. i ,j ,_,:"","'Yl\,!~ ·r~,,*~,""II!, .... " " .~~I"';~'r'!b··'-I".!""fQ' :'':''''''~~T''"''?~~''T''m u ( ~~_L'pa 1~_..n.l.t~~~'.S~o9a 1, J,.o---'fR_qr~~.tJ'LQ'j cct_i_QD_~ Yeat'S 6 -10 IT-~ 'f '"''''', "" "~ fea. r fj Year 7 Year 8 Yaar '9 Year 10 I ------r____ ----------- SALARn.;S . ~-.!2~5~.16 3,?45,060 3,792_,Q60 3 6 580,404 3,368,748 FRINGE DENEFITG I 1,272,772 1,222,969! 1,175,521} 1,109,925, 1,u44,312 -------~----------------~ --------------+---~---------_._-! t OVERTIME ~ 375'000 1 375,000! 375,OO(j 375,OQO I J75,000 LEUB;~'rA!, =~--~~_~!)_;r~B8 ~ 5-,-54~'J~~2~ 5/343_~ 599 ~~~5, 329 ~ _,_,70-., ~~o 1'1 I~-~----------------'--"-q=;' -----. =11 ~ERVICES/8UPPLIF.S I I -.----- -----...... ----,--.-.----------.. -..-.--.-.-~--- OFFICE EXl'ElJSE ! '/S,OOO 75,000 75,000 75,000 75,O{lO J ~~;'l'RACll' f;E;;ICES --'!--J.J~.O~~--~;~tOOO 1]9,O~-~ l;-;~OOO ---I~ 119,000-rl __ ~_._.~ _______ ~ ________ ~_i_~. ______ ._.___ ~-~-------------."'--""----t------------------1 VEHICLE MhINTENANCE I .,6,000 408,00 0 . J84,000 I 346,000 3)2'0001! --~-----.-----,--.. ------,.. ---' ,---,-~-.~ -I-' I S~~!.?.!~ ___ ~ __ ._~-='-~~ooo ~_~_!,~~ __ --' ____ !)98~__ 5~~~OO ! __ 5~,OOO_ ---.~-------~-.--i I i CAPITAL liXP£NSES 41.,400 41,-400 -41,-400 -411-4014l.'400. t----~-.-.------.--.------. -------. . ---------------------------------< 'i_,,-unTO'TAL _. ___ ~ ____ ~ ____ ~~-__ ~_~~~-~~_ __ . ..!!~~~ _____ . ___ ~.~~~ _. ~_ 41, 40"-i,.1 I-----·~----····-------=-~.-;;~--+-~ -'~----.---~----, l}'Of~l\I, 6,444 .. 888 ~!~, 429 ~981~_999 ---'-=----~66,-729 !o,!'J5! 460Jr These tigureg represent 1993 dollara and cost of living increases are hot factored into thsac charts. -~........-....,,," .• , .. -.... 'f· l~ '.- / • ,' .. 'j '~' . ------------- ""' ---YEARS 1-5 ,... 1 Chief 1 Captain , 4 !..ieutenants ~,' 10 Sergeants ~-55 Off i,:; __ e r __ ~ 71 S'«or-n (, YEAR • 1 cnief 1 Captain 4 Lieutenants 10 Sergeants 2l. Officers 68 s· ... orn YBMi ___ I 1 Cr.ief 1 Captain 4 Lieutenants 9 Sergeants SO . Officers 65 sworn YEAR 8 1 Chief 1 Captain 4 Lieutenants 9 Sergeants II Of:t:i.cers 62 s .. 'orn YE~~ 1 Ch:e: 1 C3.p~aiT'J 4 Lieutenants 8 Sergeants li Off i c-"~_:r...§. 58 s ..... orn YEAR 10 1 Chi ef 1 Captail'. 4 Lieute,;ants 7 Sergeants ~:;" Officers 54 s:.o'orn 1 1 7 J 1 II 1 7 ) 1 13 1 , J 1 13 1 1 ... lJ 1 1 7 J 1 13 1 1 7 3 1 1J Eecay'ds Sllperv isor Secre~a.ry Reco.::-ds C ls.rks eso's \~~l:',_;' __ t::_J e_ ?-: e ~ b.:! n i c r.on-s',,;c::-r. Recorcis Supervisor Secretary Reco::-ds Clerk.s CS::' I s VC~~':1ech-a;('.i~ non-$:..,;orn Hecords Supervisor Se-::re:.ary P.ecc'ros Clerks CSO's ~t, __ i.~Je i1echar,ic;; J"lQrl-s'",'ot"n F:ecl~:-cs 5 -..:pe:-",,' i 50r Secretary R'2-cords Clerks esc's Vetl i ole Me.ch.;:l.ni.,£ nOr!-s;":orr: Ee;::o:::!s Supervisor Sec:-etar-y P.e:cor-ds Clerks esc's "y"§..,h.icle Mechanic r,on-s',,'orn Rec·::;·r-ds Supervisor Secret2ry Records Cler}"s eso's Vel"":icle MeC.D .. 9.n ic ;.or,-s;..;orn ' . .. ~" ~i " ,. • .... The salary costs include ~aximum certificate a~~ education pa~ and a.re haser! on establ ishinq a base salary at otticer level and increa.'si:cq the salary at each supervision level using a standard 15% increase. Tho!' twc levlO'ls of middle management ,Captain and Lieutenant) are separated by 10%). Officer > sergeant = 15% sergeant > Lieutenant = 10% I.ieutenant > captain = 10% captain > Chief = 15% The following initial pay scbe~ule was established: Chief So,ani/mo Lie"Utenan..t $5,377/mo Sergeant $1,8S8/mo Officer $4,2S0/mc Records Supervisor $Ji~OO/mo secretary $3,lol/mo Records clerk $2,793/mo eso $2,i93/mc vehicle Mechanic $3,409/mo Benefits vere set at 31% of salary lCO Background investigations, incl~ding polygraph, psych and medical at $1,000 per background $100,000 1,000 Bookings at cou~ty jail at 5114 ea. $114/000 Radio maintena~ce to serv~ce radi~s $10,000 CNTF contribution $lS,(l(lO $239,000 YEARS 2-10 1,000 Bookings at county jail at $114 ea. $114,000 Radio maintenance to service radios CNTF contributions $15 1 000 'tOTAL: $139.000 The vehicle maintenance account covers the ope~d;:ins --=,osts of the vehicles and a v8hicle replace~ent ~ccQ~nt. The a~a~nts used are; $14,OOG Marked Patrol Unit $10,OaO Unmar;':;ed Car The amount for e~ch year is deter~ined by the ~~~ber cf vehicles in serviCe for that yea=. YEJ...R 1-5 25 Marked Patrol Ca~s 10 Unmarked cars 24 Marked Patrol Cars 10 Un~arked Cars 22 !.farked Pa tro 1 ca rs ~o Unmarked Cars 21 Marked Patrol Ca~s 9 Unmarked Cars 19 .Marked Patrcl C2:::'S 8 t:~ma=ked Ccrs Year........!..Q 18 Marked Patrol Cd~S 8 Unmarked cars .' ,.~ C1t.PIT)1.L EXPENO!T~RE:~ --Y~AR 1 - 11 mar~:::ed patrol ' .. Hlits ;.lith lig1".': bars, radiQS and C.3.g02S at S2:;,.cOD ea. $264,000 5 unmarked c~rs wit~ radios a~d lights at $12,DOO ea. $6D,000 20 Portable radios ...... ith battery chargers at '$1,5'20 '='2. S30,OGO Ne1N office.r-safety equipment, v-ests, guns, belts, rain gear, flashlights. $60,000 YEARS 2-1Q Equipmer.t replacerneDt account to fund future replace!!1ents fo= ... orn out equipment other ttlan vehicles (set at 10% of original capi_ta! expenditure) . $41.400 cur:r:.ent Level 14 marked units 11 :-na.rked \.:.ni ts 25 marked u:tits 5 unmarked cars Ie unlt".arked cars 15 portab~e radios 2J portable radios 35 poct-able radios (1) CO ~ ~ u -. Q C) ~.~ 0 2:5 1-. N Ii c en ~, '0 ,-' <5 ~ < cu c (] 0 r- eG c CL ,.'-, ,:.:: w. ~ ,8 CO L' (iJ , LJ I. !----; ,:. ; I ~ I -~ ~; .1 '-. ___ ._~_J '.""":'! _i_' i ,;: I ; I --.' ~f ': I I. I~ !'·-I-;~~ i-- I '. " : I' . iii l : .~ .. l L_ I .... .--l :: , i I ii' :. 'I :~ H I-II ,-.~ . ; : . I ~i ~! - ", j i U I • L , , . ! -' , , --'-' '-~--T-)I 0 0 < o OJ Ii "-"- co C0 __ I ;:-7J '--- L~ Q o 'C1 L , L ~~ r--,;:: , , , . "~ . I ~ L~ ;---- I, ," I " -I; , . --, ! ---;, • .2 • u · , .3 • u , • o · • • o L~ o 0 25 (3 --'-....:..c-~-"- i~ : .. ,. --I "'. <> I,! ::.- LI -..!:'--_L C i , -1; l: • ~ .5 • " • ~ • " c ~_..c _____ ~; I L. , · • · . .. ;; ~ • Lo.:t. , • • C---"-: CI ~ ~ u ~ ----1.. 0 I _0--,-, _0--,-_"--,- • • ; " " · • • • " • " ;:; • " • o • ~ <> • <' o __ O'j' __ O.J ; • • " • o • ~ , ~ <3 Q OOOO'J .. -< = -: -l~ ~U ~ _" _~ _____ : _-----L.. ____ , . • E • u " ______ L __ " __ .L...J ; ii 111 • o ~ <> ~ o 000: _~ __ ,_ • .J (:0 (JJ """ ~) ,~-"'\ '_, -'-' o C) c o C C::1 OJ o Ql > co co n _ c ,~ U) co W \ I , \ I I ~I ! ~ -:-' , I I -I 1 G r..;. 0 o '';J ~' -c ,;;s:.."':::' ::;, u ::;(3 ~--' o > Q C o o ',-') , • ) .. -, ~4.:, ' • --, C0 (;...., .' j ,--0 0 Q 0 ,U '-J l-n c '-'-((I ':;j; 0 0 ~ « 05 ~ ,-- '-- 0 tIt ,- eo c CL '--- cj Q --' ,-, '" ~~ CJ ',j..,' co : I lJ -~ I 1_ I i Ii h _. __ .. J I, ! I ,-- ;-j~ii;~:: I I ,; 1;;1 °j;'I·, i ,---, I ,-, II :=:----" ~ '. i I r; :: i . i i~j if) ijMi l i l, i '------' c_"" I I~ '-i ,E;§;i; I : 'I ;, .:. ;i i: i , ~; " ~ • ~ 0 ~ • o;i 0 ~ • ~..!:.' • • "c ; ~ .. oi -'"~ i g .!:>. ~ ~ >,u:::; ~!~; .. _ ..... c- o .. " c:..:: ;~~0!i ~ otCDC:':O> · . · · -~~""'-- ~ • ;; . • '0 ~ t -= ~ ... ~ ... Qlu :! ~; ;= ~~:::i~O · . '" ...-'Q'c N 0), ,0 C) 10 I' " ~ CD co c ~ 0 ',-, " ClJ '-'-~.J 0, '----C (1 '-..L ~~ ~ ,,,", () '-' ~o ,~ " <: L 0 C '-\) ~ :JJ CD Q 0.-r' ~) ~ -' CO "';'.' m L'- W ;; ---I ~ ~ ~ ~ , · · · · , • u " u " , ., " ----0-' --, ~ < ~ ~ I I • <3 0 " <; (; <; 0 · , \ < o ' , " , ~-: '--, ! E, H , : ~ I , r--=-, ... ~ I I < • ~ · ~ • ~ ;~~J ' ! · 0 • • 0 ? " · ~ " • <; ::, 0 (; 0 0 ~-. , , , ~ -------- < : · • • , . J, 00 u " " • ~ " (; ;:; . 0 0 " , -'---..J 1"-1 ' < 0 l~l I ~ I i I • 0 ~ • ; • ; ; ; • " • ' . ! • ~ , • I !' " :: ., " ,. • • [--...,...---, ~ ! , 0 <; ;; :; <; <; · ~ · 0 0 1 : r--r-1 I o I I _ C ,I I 0 ~ __ ' __ L_L ' , I ~ I , - • ~~ , -; L~ o < 0 • · -• 0 ~ 0 ~ o -~ '---I , . _.J : I ~ , • " · · · ~ · ~--- · , , .. ~ .. , . , " • · • • • ~ u " · 0 <; <3 0; , , '" !II ;; C '-' ~ <> ~ " o 0 0 :5 _, ____ -----L-J a 41 I: • ~ <> ~ <> o <5 D :5 -"----,-------'----'-----'--" . --. ".--=-................. '---~ .... -------~ · ; , "" :; 0 --'~,--,' • " o 0. • " '--'-'-- · • • ., <C 0) cJ UJ c 0j Co! L o GJ > r---~ cc " c I ~ ----I " " I I ~ I ! i I o .~' ?; c '-' > -:_1 ;~ c .;:: a=_ , ,,~ o~ ~_U '-.:' c _ c U..c :: v g~ ---'-~-.-' -~ --~ -.--~ I I I 3 :; ~ ~ I " "=, .:: Gl '" -1 :0 > (5 0; c u '" 0 C. L '" '" , ~ x >-c: " 5 ;-:, :t ~ " " ~ " Q --; ",] ~ (5 o. 0 c 0 D c() c CJ Q '"' ------ " ~ 0 c ~ " '" ~ a.':':::: " , D~ C5 c =>:E -" <.':,0 <C C" ',-I,') ~~J - , i , 1 __ . __ J '------' , , 'I h ! I ,. H [ ! j ,---,----- --~.-- ~-­ , , . . I .. "," "," ",~ --~--.....! ~ ! I ' -' ,--, ! i !:. I ~--1:; I I '': ~ JII'_ J 1 ' ;------. . . 'L-i_ ! , j!: ! --, ... : ;~ ,'-,- , . : .,~ . ~ , . , · : : · · . · : . i __ -------,-_' __ '_1 -' ----; ~ • • i I' J ~ :; U I '; ;:: I ~ ~ I <-----..J r----. I; • i i: .. : J -; I ~ : '::' : I : :', I _--.J I --' ! : , ---' ~ ,jI , LJ: .: ' : I ~ :~ ~ 1= ':! I 1--.' _' _.J " ---0 0 • 1 " I ! -' . -· . . 0 • , , I -· · -; ; ; , , :i ,; ~ ____ ,_: I --' -!--~ , ' ; .--'--": . . , , . ;- I" ,. .-. " .. " .. -.-. -. -.... ~~! =~ IJ Q...J =,0 ,." . d -..... :;:: .~ 'v C ,~ ,""1 ~---' " ,.-, -' ,~ _ 0 o ~;. I:::=L 8 ,-. ; . ..,: '0 -. II!: ~ : ·0 i • ~ '" I -=--~ ~---'~ CL G> ~ " 0 ,--' ~~ CD « C 0 0 cD ~ CO 0 Q ;--., 0 -'- -~ D 0) iJ) ':'0 '- , I ' ~-1 o -" .- ~i ~ ~i ; __ ' __ ' __ ~ • j I----;----j · . · · · . · · -~. I !~ 0; C C ;; , . , lJ!' , · . · --- o c -'--'--'-'---'---' : . · · · · -Q C - -L ~~~_~_,_o, Q. , · · · -;; 0 ;; <; , --'-' · · · · 0 0 ---L_J . . . . . . - 0 ;; " <; ~---'--'-' -' '" ''''; -~' () .,-\ :,-\ ~ -., o '" -'-' co ('0 W C) , i I'" A, '--~------.--~, . .,.....--- , . , 1 ; I '-I~i 0 5 > . ~ J :2 - 0 ~ 5 ? ,. -z.; .:;: ,,-,I Y j' -2 ~ " 0 c :3 ,=' ~ Q ;::j .-:! CO v , I I I , I I I I I I I CD CiJ 0 D r, ~J ~, t· ... " LL ,-, '0 -'-' « a ':0 0.-- -, (I) cu I ! I W-J r- 0 ~, " TJ ;:u 6 cv L- CD c '- '-- c:J Q '--~, L.....J ~: 1 _, I- I :;" ,I n L ___ -.J \ I I : i I . -' .. , ." ... L_~_~ -:--; 1 . -: : , , I -'----' , --; , I ! . -, , , -' -, , j '--- --, i i n --.J : I r : , 1 l i ;---, I l' .. ! i ~: I~_~ , I -;; '.o !! =:' o .. D " _~ ___ .:..._l.. ___ ;_ , , ---'-" -iii, 0; 0 .. .. ;;; i .!... _____ L.LJ '-~~ --, - \. ": j,; D, _~_~_~_I ~--, -- -'--, D, ;; -----,~, ___ '~ . . co cO c: (,'1 '. ~ ~, 'J \ n J ,~, "-' -"'----C;J D-C» r; 0 ~ ~ ",-, 0, « c 0 0 ::0 CO 0 " D-,~ -'------' CO cC) L.;.... W < · . ----r-, ~ · · 5 · · 0 , - · ; · · -;; ;; 1; ----- · · · ! · · 0 ;; 1; · : · " ; · · ! · ! :; c ;; , · · · ; · · , , ,I 'f 0 I I " " I, • == ~ i ! ."'--__ L-J_-'-_ .. U--!: e c;' '---l -'~;.. I -'0 ' ~- C 0 Q ;; <; ;; <; , ---L-...:. _________ L ___ l -' : .,! 0 I " I ';) I -11:0 l I: I L:" ___ - - -'---l! ! ~ __ J : · · · ~ · · · ! · <; ; = ;; 0 <; 0 -'----! --~---, · ; · · i · · · · ! · · -· -: 0 ! :; 0; ;; 0 , " c 0 • • ..-'!!..--------------.-----_._-· · , ----. · . 0 · ~ L..." · · · · · · ~ · · · · · ~ ,_J __ ~ • ;; ;; ;; <5 <5 • I , . . . . ;; (; , , (0 ri"1 v~ C) Q o < 0 (C) {, '~'- ~,--- 0:: IS) W ('t" ~ > ~ (1J :) C ~:: -, ...... , w <C '--, o , s ~ 5 > ~ t 5' :;.. S co ~ '~ '" ;3 Q :.:; c c 0 {.:; .s " ;:; -:'-, C: C ,-'------' -,-'-----'- I , } t " ~ ii >; .j 0:::\ '-CL o o CCi2 [L 0 C) co L_ W ~~ r: 10 L. . l __ ~L _0:..c-=O~~O~, . . . . . . -0 5 -'-'-~ co CI) c 0 C! Q .:;,j 0 ~ -c CL Cj OJ 0 ~ 0 -"-' <C CD > ~ 0 ~ "- CD Ci) 0_ , -'c: -"-' D C0 « (\) iU I ! 1'1 i J ! ; .-"', -;'r, " ~.;: o 5 U) ""':l o :> C-J , -,-, -, --::. Q.. ,:.; . -c ::­ <,~ '_1 " ~~ $~ <---___ .! _______ .-'-__ J-__ ~_~ __ ~ I-~I I ~ i I I c I 1~ I-~ I " ' 1-' --~ '" "::::' > '; '> L....._I ::..:' ,~ " ~~ co " 0 rI:' .:;.' '" 0 0 _____ ...L o -"=-~ c' 65 ~ " .' '" 0 c > ',) 0 0' ,,'J 0; o >­"'-coc OL..:.J ~ ::; '" 0 C > 0 0 ,~, -,------'------' .1. OJ -~ U.J 0 C Q 0 0 en '-I"--.,i C1-c CD 01 0 c5 ~ « m '- 0 0 cO E (, '-- -' -'-r::) Q. ~ ,'-" (J) 0 cO LJJ [--~·-I .-----j i:;: I! -c .. " _!IE --.~,---'- 1 ___ i ~ ~ :~: I f I; ;Hi 1 · I I I · I · · r--- I -, , : I j ;, · , • • I · I ; . , I,J -I ! L......-..! I I '-----' : i ~,-Ji -.. -. , , . ~ . . . i i I · • I · i , , · , ; , .J.j i r L:~ J ~ I - ~~._.l ; c ;; 1 c ._, __ 1 _~_I ___ ~ !i ; \ I r_~-:-, !-------- ~J 111 ..... 1 : 'n: .:L~ , !: ;: I I ---. -. · i ;; ;; ;; ;; ;; . -;; ;; ;; , .. l 0" 0" 0-I I.:; : i I 1'-' I r , i t .-L~_'-L.L-'---'--'_ Ll..J 1 I:-----~---l r----, Ii: .: I I :] ~i i--j : I : : : : ~ I ~ .. I . • I 0, .;, <!', ceQ, L _______ --.--J !. ____ ~~~_! ~_I __ 1 ~L' ~~"---' o " l I ~ ~ ~. :i -1 i , , .j f ., , f i i ~ cD rr, I y~ r"' i v Q 0 L ,'-' . , t-..!...._ 0 4--' <C 0 OJ ,--. LL. ~ (0 cO iU 1 ___ , c: 0 ~ Cj ~~..: C cti (J) '--0 0') C 0 G:l ~ 0. C) ..,.-., u \._-' L . .. ... C' :r:: .. S, ~, 5 o . . ;; J , ;; ---~------.---~--. - CD C1) c- O (J Q-"-= _---., '.0 '0 r'-J L C-O_ _~I ,--0) I ,-, c __ U 0 I c -'-' I ~ 'C) iii <C > " -~ 0 CD '- ~ CO U) (1 C ~ E -:-' D OJ « W W ~i I I ---J --I o ': Q ::;, o U) :: ~ r.;::. -:s - ,3 r ,:..::, ::3 -' ------,---~ C' ,~;' ;5 " :;' 0} " - i .::, 5 " " S ~, -, ~, -:l '-' > " , >-" "-r, :: ' .. ) -, ,f-r.::, 5 0 <' $ () :;; > " --" --" '';;:; -, ? :: ,-.~ ,'] ~:3 c '" "' >->-" -" --" " 0 ~ :~ :: -:: c ., L~ :: :;, " c ;;; co " " 5 0 ,3 0 '-lJ 0 L..:.... cO ':...) -- "> 5 :: " > 6 u -" Q) -:: " -:;; 0 c' 0 0 ----_._- 1'EAII A Oii 00 -lEi 0 0 , sergeant - 'I'EA..l1. B 1600-0200 ;-:;=='--- ,----Sun _Sergeant 1 x seregant 2 o Officer ~ Officer Z Office.r , officer 4 Offcier 5 Officer 6 Officer 7 Officer S officer 9 Officer .10 officer 11 Officer 12 x officer 13 Officer 14 TOTAL 8 x (> X X X X Y X G X X 0 0 , X __ ~ ____ -L __ o o 0 8 S I , ,. [ -- X X o 0 8 x X --- 0 X 0 0 0 ~._l 0 -+-~" 0 X X o 20CO-060C Sergean~ 1 X x -t--"----+---"--+­o c ): -~--':"-+~---I-- Se!"egant :2 Officer 1 Officer 2 Officer 3 Officer 4 Officer S e o x x x o x o -+_Y_, --rY' ,. x e x o o o Officer 9 0 x: X X 0 0 I ~O~f~f~'~'~~_e~L~--_~'-O--+--o~--rI~~~-~~x--+-~x~ ~~~~-~~x~--r~o-~'I Otficer 11 _......,I_.:o __ -+I~()=--0 _~_X,,-_-+_ X X X I-'::.:~:..:::..:::.;. :::;:::;::.....;:;~;:;:-_-... --+I-~:~· ~~~-1I_·_~:.::~~~~~li ~~:~-......,I-.::.: t--':'" --I-':::~-+--': -. ._.,._--t--'--+- Offics..:' 14 r X X I X I' 0 COX 1I--"="-'-'c.::....-=-.o--t-'-'----1'--' .... --t-'-'----t· --'--+---" . B 18 !a 8 8 LB---.J TOTAL 8 APPENDIX B City's .A.ctuai Costs lor RED Team PartiCipation April 4, 1992 • February 19, 1993 Sergeant Agent Two Officers OJartime costs (RED Team and patrol backfilO Tota! Cost $ 74,034 $ 68,695 $127,125 $269,854 $ 69,765 $339,619 $ 3,000 860 450 150 1,250 560 750 6,300 $19,650 Total APPENDIX C Two Laptop computers Trinlum sights ($115 each) 3tld ~.ash~ght attachments ($100 ead1) Compact door ram Ballistic shield SWAT mimJr with extension Video equipment with zoom capabilities Nylon duty belts, mesh unfform shirts, raid jackets ($140 each) Rental of undercover vahides. (Average cost is $4!Hl9 per day) PersooaI computer and Laser Jet printer Night vison equipment