Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutORD 2233~ . ·:· ;'·~--~ ' ~:' .,, : ... !."' ) ... 4 -~·-,c.:<_ .. ( ·.-,(~-~:;·, ;>, ::··-: -~· : ;·.;::~f-~:': ~-~ .,-".·.:-<.:: .. -; · •· .. -.'" 1 ;,' >''i',•;:::<\ _,_,.·~ · ....... 5\r~!J!!,%1>~'!.'~~'"''~""'e"'"'""''' ·'""'""''"'"'"""""'" , ..• ,.~., . .,. " -~ '"' ""-" -·· '"=-· ·---. -:: . . " .. ,. _./'. I· ,._: Y. ·: . ~-, . ~-~ ORDINANCE NO. _ 2233 _ OliDINANCE OF THE COUNCIL OF !HE CITY OF PALO ALTO ·Al.fENDING :>EtnciN 3~02 OF ORDINANCE NO. 1324, THE ZONING ORDINANCE, CHANGING l'RE ZONING OF CERTAIN PROPERTY .mOWN AS 403 CURI'N.ER AVENUE FROM C-3:S 1'0 R-5 The Council .. of the City of Palo Alto does ORDAIN as follows: f)j:CTI.9N_l.:.. Ordinance :No~ l3t4, the Zoning Ordinanc.e, is hereby amend eel by amending':;:Seetimr ':3. 02, the uzoning Map", by changing the zoning of certain property known as 403 Curtner ·, Avenue from C~3:S to R-5. SECTION ~:.. Said property is shown on a TnaJ? attached hereto, incoq.orated het·ein by reference, and entitled " Ch.attge of District o~: 403 Curtner Avenue from C-3 :S to R-5 11 • SECTION :t:_ Tllis ordinance shall become effective upon the expiration of thirty days from its passaged. INTRODUCED: Uay 10, 1965 PASSED: May 24# 1965 AYES: Arbud:,le. Arnold, Byxbee, Comstock, Cooley, Debs, Dias., Fl4"'lt1 Rodgers, Rohrs, Rua. Woodward, ~ NOF.S: None ABSENT: Beahr11, Porter .. Zweng. AT'J~EST: Al'P7 AS r CONI'ENT: t .i: ...... tfiuA (At ,~,~· ~.('>.,~ ;!~: .~~~ ~ ·:~{~;~ ., .,· ' .. :>:. -~~- ··' . :-_:: .': : ·:~- -~<;; ... ·-:~-;: ,:,: . ')_ I ~:. ,.,, -_,,.· ·:.· . :_:~· :A .'~ ;1/' :~1· < .. ;, ' ).~: ,-:i: -.~:: • X '• I."'-, .... , _ _.. ..._,, .~i'- _-1(.:" -~ " ,., ·i- ,.. .! ... ~ .-. "li~I:l;.E_,_. , .. '{ow"_, ... ;.:.. '( ·p>"" :--.,....· ,. i.;·· ·-· < f~ " ·#·~;, . ' ' ~::;', ~--" ~·~ ,~ ~:. ·:.·::~ ._ /,:· /l if,· ... :r.:l·' -~-~~.,:~ ~- : ,_ ... :> ·\;. rl'·'·~ !):){. . ;i' if'•t f!!".i '. < •. ·~···· . ' c;; ,:·,· :--_;.. -:.1 ,;. !' )···: '"'!·-·;. r;, :·~ ~:•\~ -~r~· "'" ·•.'1::-:;;,'(_:_-~ ::r· :.; . :-. :1 :·-SJ':~:-~"":"o'~;~ ~ 1: (--~-~ ;··:~:~r.~~:~;:"•)~if':~~:·: '·~~~"' ~-·l.:'j'·f,'·-1;.o ,,. -~:•1'.'.:' ., .,.~·-· ................... ,. .... . . . . " ,::~~;: ·:·. ..:::;~~i;~:.,~· ~. \ •'' 411' ~.~ ·.~ ,I ; ' ·'· ""'·""' CB-.::1 QF DISmlCT at 403 CU1DtD. .lthllr.l naM C-3:5 l'l\ 1.-S • ~ ~\ ~· / -·---.Z'o .v.~;.: · · 1~-.-.:e-.c·x;.s r 1 A/ tS Z o .u c B ou A.l ,c.; A~;.; -·--t:,_--0--C .1 r r' L /.M 1 r s B o u 1./0 J'l H .,_, F-::::':""::+::..:..:::::-·r--::-..:.~~:::::T"-~ a' /ia.,· ~c· l. That the reclllLssificl!ltion and smendment of said Ordinanc·e as 'bereinaf.ter :recOCITlended is in harmony with the General Plan of the City of Palo Alto. 2. That the publi.c interest, health~ safety, morals, peace, c·omfort., convenience ancl general welfare requir~ ·the rE·elaasification of the subject property. • l' ''.. . ~ ... •'' ~ ,~ :'·<-~ '"I • ·, .. , :· .. : •: ·-,_. ~; !I: ~·/· ···~ "" ];~ -~~!i~~~; II- ., f;~~~~.:.~~~:.:..;.,!r.l---·~-"l'f:/11,, Joe- ;" •)if:' r· .. ... 1·<..:·· :1( ;~ . : ..... :~pf/ ') '-' " ....... ..,., "'-". /.T ,._,,,....,.,,1M';•~ \'( ..,-.•o,fl.'ol or-'<I','..Ji, t-.J '•'J'I''·'""''~~'('l'/•'";~,~'tl.:.},''ll\'l'i'l\4.<\o,'''·"·'·. , .• , ,•\1\1,\.".,. ~ •11(/,:i·'."!/Ji ', ~--~/,',·,:i~;,-.;, .. ;·rc\.'~''~·N ~··•~ •, ,"·••;.., ,.\'fr"' T':.' ,.,, , • , .,•L· •·,.·,r ¥ "L' ....... '~' ·o'• ,~ ,. ' •• -~ .... ,, ~ '( --~,·~ •,; ........ 'aESOWTlON NO.~ A H!SOUJTION OF 'mE l'!.ANNI:t«; CCttMISSION OF !HE CITY OF Pi\.1:.0 AI.TO tm:!MMENDlNG !'HE RECLA.SS!FICAnON OF CER'l'AIN Plt.OPPJU'Y AND RENDERING IN CONNECTION THEREWITli A REPORT Ol~ FINDnGS Ah"D SUMMA:RY CE HEARING 6s~zc-s ___!HILIP DeROSA ~,[i!:REAS:. the·re has b.r::en filed with this. Plann:i.ng Commisuion ~n application <>:~ proposal to oiUDemJ·, the :Palo Alto ~oning Ordinance, Ordina.'lce No. 1324 (Sec:::icm .3.02. the Zoning Map): by the reclassification of cer,tain property. pQ.n~:IUAnt to th~ provisions of Article 27 of said Ordinanc:e as follows: Ai't,licatiou Nov ~5-ZC-5 .attached hereto as Exhibit "111 t(> reclauify property known as 403 Curtner Avenue £rout C··J:S r.o R-.5 as more fully described in Exhibit 11 2" at:ached hereto. A!~) W'HFJlEAS, this Comrnissiotl has held a public hearing 1>n thi.s matter after ~iving notice of the time and place of hearing as required by law and h.as clialy .and fully considered the said propoocd reclaasifit:a.tion as aforesaid. NUl, THEREFORE, BE IT R.ESO'LVED by the Planning Commissitm of the City of Palo Alto that the follO'Aing t'eport, findings and recoall'lendations are he1:eby Sl.l:)Qlitted to the City Council of the City of Palo Alto: ~t,!Mr;x of Hearing: Af::er due and proper notice given pursuant to Section 27 06 of said Ordinance, this Cooomiasion held a public hE:·aring.. on the said proposed recl.aasification and amend­ moe·nt to said Ordinance on the following date, to wit: _,_hpril 28_._ 1965 At: the time of said hearing this Commission considered th!l report of the ~Planning Officer of the City of Palo AJ. t:o. which report is attached hereto as Exhibit "3". A 1:urther wt'itten report concerning the matters and ev:.dence presented at said hearing is contained in the c<>py of the minutes of this Commiseion pertaining to th:.s matter attach,~d hereto as Exhibit "4u and hereby im~orporaterl hereill. Further written 01: documentary ev:.dence or matter:>, if any, before this Commission dul·ing said proceedings s:re attached hereto as Exhibit "5'i- Findings: Bat.ed upon the for<:goi.ng rtf'erred to evidence .and hear­ in;f;, this Commission has ll'lade ::he following findings with re:ierence to the ssid pr.oposed recl&seificstion and ameru;l·· met:.t of said Ordin~nce, to wit: 1. That the recla&si£ic~tio~ and amendment of said CTdin~nce as hereinafter recommended is in harmony with the General Plan of the City of Palo Alto. 2. That the public interest, health, saf~ty, morals, peace, comfort, convenience and general welfare require the re~lassification of the subject property. ----·--1 ~ • ,' .. _.. \\ l\ i\ !! ir ,I 1\ !! ~ .• <);.~wl * ' :, ,, ;.;, ·t- -~- ' .~, ... ""_. •'·' r,,_.,._,~ ... ('<.~.,...,,u.~ .. ,""...., '!t.;r.• ,..,l'".¥.\'>tJ11\\1 ,·,-:·r.•«(ll'll'$·f"'> •)l·~:.~.-;"-'•.'·~··'"' ";""/J:·w·. ' ·. · '/ffi,I'~\',;.Y~;, •;.·· ~,--. ,, ... , · I'"" u •'II< --l.~l ~01 :me:r.dati..2.U!: This COU1nission, pursuant to the afore recited 5WiZ114ry of hc:arin& and report of findings, does hereby recommend to tbe City Council o:f the City of Palo Alto the adoption of attend~..,"tt to S-ection 3.02 of. said Ordinance as. set fcn:tt. in Exhibit ,.P 1 attached her.eto, reclassifying fr~ ~.District to !,::i District, rupectively, tl'>.at certain prop~rty or properties as more particularly designated, oesc.J:ibed and shown ou Exhibit ••1 ... BE ll FURTHER RESOLVED~ that this resolution and report be sub­ mitted to the Ci~y Coun.cU of .the City of Palo Alto for action pu:rsu&l:'l.t to the provisions of Se.ction 27.08 of said Ordina.n<:\e. ADOPT.W this 28th d&y of ~ril 1 1965 by the Planning COt!.'Zmi:;sion of the City of P.tlo Alto, by the following vote: AYES: Brenner 1 Brophy~ Kimball, Kopriva, Rice, Stromqui.st. NOES: None ABSEN'l: Ncne Harry M. Kimball, Chairn~ ,. ;; ;'I ~. :~ I ]. - , . . ~ -- :- - - 4 ~- t :~ .. . -~ < -~ (" _ J ·~ p~ . , ; ·; : : ~~ .. . . L. ~_ ; ; - : : ' .• .. . :· - - ;; ' ·- - ~ - :- - ~ rl :- - ' <: ~ !. _ i i ·' l c. .. . ~- ~ l ._ , I ;: _ [ ~: ~ I u i "' j e ~~ r ' - · l ~~ ~ !- - ' ~ '- - 0 : : ' ~· I ) ~- · r d • , [ :: I \. _ j •. ) -- - t I I ! j I [ i j ' ! i ! I ! I l i j l i : l l l .. , : : _) -· ; , , "_ ) --:~ :t ~ u -~ J n . ~ ~ -( J ~ .. . j I l ·I .. ·i . ') .. ~ -; d : I I I I j ! l ! I ! ! I ! ! ! f 1 i i ; ! j ~ , I i l l l I ~ ! l I I • I i ! ' i I . I ! ' ! ' i :! . ! ' : i I I [ ' I I .. I I I l I i > ~- J ! ~- - ! J .- . l : .. . - ' ' j '~ : ; _ I -- - - - I ~ ' I ·- - < i .. . ) .. ·• . ~. . ; : ~. : : · :, . ; z ( j J J ' i I I I j ! ~ ' I _, .. -· ~ ~· -- >· ~ J ·- I j : ., _ , <, ) - 0 _. . , '4 .: ; , ) -~ ~- : , . .. ·- - -~ 0 0- 1 -- ~ .. ~' -~ -- :• :. . . _ . ·- · -; ' ' ~) ,. . ; j -- ~. ) .. . ~. . : - ·- ~ ~ ._ , ,. _ .. . :. · . 0 .. . . ~ v ; ' (1 ' ;; . :. -- · __ ; i I ' , · j ' •. ~- ' 'J -- ,_ l i .. ; ; -- i ! ! .. . ., '· ! , ' i l ; i : -i ; ! l - · j cx l 1 1 - - - - .. - : : : c : r I ' 5 : : J - > < « 3 W - . 1 ?~ . ~ .: : s ' ·. ~ ! (; ' . [' - i ~? .. _ ~ .. . . . . CO ) , .. . , · ~~ II ~ .. I; .. .. .. II i~ lt .. .. ~ u ;; • u n ;; " 1 ~ ~ ij I ~ p ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ' L ~ i! ~ :: ~ ~ !: " ~ ~ •' ~ ~ " q ~ u ~ I ~ I u , ~ I J I! J u " A • d 1 ~ ~ n g '~ ~ • ~ ~ II J p I' J r . ' '· .. r {,'"'''""'':V.~~i•,'l•·.-.orv 1·,~.1'~•>•<,,,,.,;~r'''"'' olit~.,..,,.,,.,,,,LI' "'' \ "·'" ,,., • ... ~ ..... ~ ' -..,;. Ncr:riCE: OF PUBLIC HEAliNG tJ!\1 'l'HE A\PPI.:ICATI.ON OF PlPL!l"' D<!ROSA FCft. A CB.A.lliCE CE DIStRICT OF PROP.Q.T.i l<.NOWN AS 40.3 CURTNER AVE!'.I'UE, ~AI..O ALTO, CALIFOR.'UA~ FR<M C~3:S TO R-5 A."SffJ/CM. ~ UCH ~R D!S'JJUCT J.S TilE I'l.AhSING CCMMISSION MAY RECCM­ MEND. NO'I'ICE: IS HEREBY GIVJ N t':1at the PLAN'.iUN(; r.OMMISSION o{ the City of Palo Alto will bold a Ptr:BLIC HlA!U:NG on !J.!?..d.n~s.;!!t;{~ t:b.e 28th day __ ~)£ April_, 1965 at_:L_~2.Q !.:.!!:.. 3n the Council Chambers of the City Hall, 1313 New:~ll Road, Palo Alto, at 'Whi.ch time and pl.ace all perso·ns ::kntcrt~st6d or their agents will be h':ud upon the application of l'hiU.p DeRosa for a change of dictrict of a portion of Lou 1 and 4,. WilUam G\.trtne!' 'l'ract, -'thcrwise kn.own as 403 Curtner Av~:m1e, from c:<5:S (Get'ler.al (Ot'l:)ruerci.al Distr:kt:Spcd.al Po~n:'k"ing Re.gulat:icns) to R-5 (Gene:tal Aparttnrent D:istri.ct-l.imi::<!d) and/or such other di~Hrict as the PLan­ ning CO!m:lission may tr!co:~;nd. TI'.e application .'lnd plans t •. ' which re£er(!nce is made for p.articul~ ra iire <m file ~,n the Ci::y Planning Dep'.lrt.ment) City P.sll, 1313 Nc~reH Road,· Palo Alto) CHlifornia. (65-ZC-5) City of Paln Alto Apdl 16, 1965 ~ LOtW> J .. 'RCR~"/. SECR.f~! PLAI."'flH ~ ¢ ·~7·,- COMMISSION PROPOSED Cli.A.NG.E Of.' DIS:l'R!Cl' 0.1:' l'HE AllOVE DESCRIBED PROPERH FROM C··3:S TO R-5 &''~o"D/OR SUCH OTHER DISTRICT AS THE f?L.A."'LNl!'iG CCMMXS!>IO!if M...o\Y REC~:END. ~ ~ ~tr-zc: .. 6" • • -··-.ZaNE Ch-AN G.E B.o VA/.OAI? }' • •-EX/SrtiV~':i Zo~V£ BoUN'OARf" .--.4 ~;-Cn~F L/Mirs Bov..vo .tJR.'r' ~ •ul8,-~ iJ\11l;J ~ -~ -~ .•. • ·~~ .. i£ ~AP,O,. 4" • ,<.;,~~~ ... ~~!~ ... "OIIC}!!•,_!~)III£"'1~N"•"'"""· r-~ .~ - .. .. , ~~~~~~~~.::._ -.:.:L~~oo.;L,;l.~"~ ...... ··. .. .. .. ... 1o '" ... •.. .. .. .... " .. .. "' .;,' •• ~: .. •• .• I) " ~~ ·~ •• •• .. •• " ~ It Ill .. ~. . • • TO: FRet!: "' "','"• ,, '\ ·--:•}•'::,' ,. -~· .· •/' .. '• ··;· ..... "',' .• !,.•, ' ·: 1 1' y 0 F P A L 0 A L ! 0 Planning COI:llllissj on DATE: April 23~ 1965 2lanning Offi~er DEPT: Planning SU.SJ£CT: Appli<:a:::ion of Philip ))~:Rosa for a Change of Di.strict of P:rop lrty Known .;::s 403: Cur t:ne:r Av<1:0ue from C-3: S to R-5 '65~C-5l. _ 1. The Subject Pioperty: !he subject property is a vo1cant p.arce::. 7S feet: wicle and 165 feet deep, or 12)375 square feet in area. 2 • ~·U.ace n!__ Pr o.P_e. :.£.! : !Wo single-: axnily dwellin.~s .are on the parcel next door on the north i1. t:ne RM5 Zone. One single··family dvelling is on the !'rop( rty at the reax <)n the eas::; in the RMS Zone. A reducing ~ alon .smd its parking lot and an automobile muffler shop, bor.h on El CS'Jl1i.no Real in the C~3:S District, are on the s 'utherly side of the subje:.:t property and a parcel irnpro red with one s:Lngl.e-family dwelling and 4 duplex struc :ures is on the opposite side of Curtner Avenue in th• R-5 District • 3. The hoposal: '!'ne applicant proposes R-5 zoning. 4. T}\€. General Plan: The proposal :sin harmony with the General Pian which proposes medi1:m density residential use of property in the o.rea, with t'ru; exception of property a:.ong El Caml.no Rca.l where commerc:t ill usc is pr oposcd. 5,. ~'lJ..xs.i,s: l'ht'! subject pm eel is not: a p;nt: of th~:: commerci.ul p11rcels facing El Camir o Real and is not n~~ces1<a:y to the continued commercial us~:~ ,:;~f thes~ parcels. A cm•mercial use fronting on Curtner AvE:n le would not be desirable. \Jndl!!r RMS zoni.n.;, an ap.anment buildin~; containing ten (lO) units could be constn:cted. Other po:;:~,ible uses of the ~ubject propert~ in the R-5 District, with a Use Permit, are: a. hotel b. motel c ... church d. private s•hool e. _. nursery s1bool or day car~ center f. parking gn:age or parking lot 6. £~~= It is -recommended tb.at the s~.:b,)~::c.~·~ property b~ reclassified ft'oe.lm C-3:S t<; R-5. , l·:·'",'T t..i~~ liD: .. • ,, .. :i .. ~. '~ ~· r"'" "' <; ,.,.· ·~ { <' (• ~>-: <J .. "~' ~' · ;u 1 ,,,,.·. • ~-· ••• ~,, .' 1,., .. ~I : .... 111 e Zone ;Chz:m,ae~ A',g_licat ion ~ 2.!l L li_p DeRo&.!, ill Cu:rtner: A1cnue -C:-~l.,S_.,!:~:.? ,{65~Z.C-S) This was the t:iroe set for pul lie hearing on th~:: application of Philip DeRo~a for a c:hange o.t' distr:ct of a portion of: Lots 1 and 4, William :urener !n~ct t from C~3 :S (G£ neral Com:nercial District :Special Parking Regul;!l.tions) :o R~S (General A.partment Distri·::t.-Lim.ited) and/or su .... :-t other district as the Plam1it1;; Commission may ·recommend. It was noted for the record that nN.:ice of this hearing had been given as 1:equired and the .affidllllie of publicat lon a.ld certificate of mailing were on file. '!he Planning O:f.f.icer r11oted tho~t the property is located on C<Jrtner Ave!lue immediately ~'ehind a C1'!ll!'llercial e$tabl:1 ehmenc occupying the corner of El C~1mino ar..d Cur tnt r which is on :he same parcel as the subject prop(:rt.y. The .subject property is enveloped on three sides by R"·S z.oning. It is vacant and is 75 feet wide by 165 feet deep, or 11,}375 square feet in area. He concluded that the subject property should be reclassified as requ~ated. The public hear in~ was d!eclare I oper: and Donal<! J. Kennedy, 3860 P.:nk :St.)ulevard, repr·\!Senting M.r. Dei~osa stated that Gurtner Avenue is all developed with .lpartments and L comme:r.cial e.stublishment: on the subject propert>' would not be ; n harmony with the rest of th*~ street. As th~r.e was no one wishing to speak in opposition to the application, the hearing was declared close~. It was moved and seconded and unanimously carried that the Cc::nmission adopt R~:solution No. 14 recomrncnd1.ng approval of the application to rczc1ne the property from C-3 :S to R-5. On motion. made ar.cl s~conded, thl Co~m~ission als•::• recommended adoption of an or::linanc.e i:hangi:ng the fi':e zone for this property from fire .. Zone !!2 to Fire :?.one #3 . .... '· .... __.,"'.!.., UsNermit A~es.1 -62-UP-16 ]wcA;:X~:l Alma ~~ ...... .... (Cotm~issi~rs Brophy and St~·omquist the d:i.sc,.tSS~tQ of this rnat:t(H") ... left the· room during _,... ... "' / .. /" ,/ this was the time set or p~blic hearing on the appeal o£ ~id F. an~ Millicent G. Dillen fr, . he de.:::i.sion of the Zoning Adrnt.Jr(strator to conditi<,nally approve m. pl ent ttled "Master PLsm a.¢...-Ceneral P.lar.ting Plan, YWCA Lou He':lry H''cver ~ial" dated "RevJ~ Jan .. 65", applying to property at 41.-51 Altll$. Street~ otherwise kn~' as portions of Lots 5 and 6, J ... r. M01:-ris Subdi• .on of tj:M(M. ::;. Loucks Tract, Zone District R·l :B·S :A (Sirl.gle-Fo.mil · Re de¢C-Special Building Si:te: Agricultural Regulations.) It w",s :lO for the ;;ecord that nol~:!.ce of this hearing h~1:d be<m give:n 1u uir and tbe affidavit of publication and Ct~rtit'icate o/; J:'ne Zoning Administrator su rhed his findin~on this application and explai.ned the vari<)u lans ~i:ld corrcsponden'"''~·nvolved. He noted, for the record, th.at 9 ies of Sill ne had been sent the members o£ the Planning Comrni¢on prior to :his hearing. /' The Zoning ~~is·~rat<lr nvt:ed th.u: the letter of appeal 'nclicates the basis of~ection to be a materi.\1 add1.tional us•: of the CA p.remiscs, i.e., ,;;Me playground ftlCilitie.s ar:d the noise geMrated the by.. The ZonJ.dS Administrator £~1rthcr note( that it was hin opinion the laygrouncl a legitimate accessory fun<:tior of the YWCA Op4!Ution and the -.basic /4•;estion involved • .. ras ~rhethex: or :rot the playground as i:t~dicated on the · pla.ns should be ap~·:roved. Furt:.he:1, it was his optnion that the screen planting 1 the six (6) foot solid 1: oard fence, and tht:: thirty (30) foot sep.ar.at:l.on ft'om the ne.at:rest propel! ty line are sufficient to justify the app:r1~val of the phyground £4cilities. ~3- "' I 1:• ,(~~--.~.~~.i~.~:L~~~~ .. ~~·-'·. -~ ..