HomeMy WebLinkAboutStaff Report 11522
City of Palo Alto (ID # 11522)
City Council Staff Report
Report Type: Informational Report Meeting Date: 8/3/2020
City of Palo Alto Page 1
Summary Title: City Council Recess Summary Report
Title: City Council Recess Summary Report
From: City Manager
Lead Department: City Manager
Recommended Motion
Informational Report
Staff Report
City Council Recess Summary Report
Discussion
The following informational report provides a brief update on activities accomplished during the City
Council’s July recess. The updates are organized by department. While the summary is not an exhaustive
list of staff activities, it seeks to inform the City Council and the broader community about items
completed since the last City Council meeting of the fiscal year or recent efforts underway. The report is
transmitted with the August 3 City Council meeting packet.
Administrative Services Department
End of Fiscal Year and New Fiscal Year Activities: Over the past 6 weeks, ASD staff have been hard at
work transitioning from one fiscal year to a new fiscal year, it is the “New Years” for financial staff. Not
only has staff completed the normal review of contracts and revenues and expenses to begin the
comprehensive annual financial report for FY 2020 and begin the FY 2021 fiscal year, they have
completed the annual inventory of both warehouses at the Municipal Services Center and Regional
Water Quality Control Plant (RWQCP) requiring the physical count of inventory with no material
discrepancies; implemented the new employment contracts for payroll processing including the
management and professional concessions such as the vacation limit and furlough adjustments as well
as the new Family First Corona Virus Relief Act (FFCRA) with the sunset of the administrative leave
provision on June 30, 2020.
Other Administrative Activities: Other staff activities included the submittal of certification for CARES
Act funds as designated by the Governor’s Office of $845,000 as outlined in his May revise budget
approved by the legislature in late June 2020. Processed and issued 48 small business grants to date
totaling $477,000 with an cross functional team pulled together for this special project. Staff remotely
City of Palo Alto Page 2
processed over 360 parking permit renewals for the first time in the University Avenue and California
Avenue districts. As well as completed configurations and preparations for a new pilot on-line parking
permit program. As a smaller parking permit area, staff selected College Terrace as a testing opportunity
to pilot the online system that will go live on Monday, August 3. Revenue Collections and Transportation
staff training on the new system will conclude by July 31.
City Manager’s Office
Race and Equity Framework Progress: The City Manager’s Office continues to move forward several
efforts focused on Race and Equity, including a series of community engagement opportunities. In
addition, all Council Ad Hoc committees have met over the July recess and an update is tentatively
scheduled for August 24 for further Council input and community feedback. Staff recently was accepted
as a member of the Government Alliance on Race and Equity (GARE) to take our race and equity efforts
further through training, learning from other agencies and best practices employed.
Staff has begun implementing a series of ways for the community to join the conversation on race and
equity and additional planning is underway. The approaches range from panel discussions, Q and A
sessions, speaker series, and public forums, to digital conversations through a social media campaign
and online forum over the next several months.
A brief description and timeline of the conversations and events are listed below:
Police Community Briefings began on July 1 and are a series of four learning sessions. YouTube
comments are open for the public to comment. Police Department Introduction: July 1, Use of Force:
July 8, Search and Seizure: July 15, and Transparency and Accountability: July 22
Q and A session with Kaloma Smith, City Manager Ed Shikada, and Chief Jonsen- completed on July 2
and available here. The recorded event is available on YouTube and community comments are still
being taken.
8 Can’t Wait Panel Discussion, hosted by the Human Relations Commission – completed on July 9 and
available here.
Panel included:
• Chief Robert Jonson – Palo Alto Police Department
• David Alan Sklansky - Co-Director of Criminal Justice Center Stanford
• Kenan Moos - Justice Vanguard Foundation
• Matthew Clair – Assistant Professor of Sociology, Stanford University
• Anand Subramanian - Managing Director, Policy Link
8 Can't Wait Review with the Human Relations Commission and Public Forum- completed on July 22
and available here. Review by staff and HRC public forum took place. Recommendations and input
received will be presented to the City Council during a study session tentatively scheduled on August 24.
Human Relations Commission Public Forum on the Current and History of Black and Brown
Community Experiences: August 13. Discussion and public forum sharing experiences is planned. City
City of Palo Alto Page 3
social media campaign and online forum will complement this conversation by encouraging experiences
sent via video or other digital mediums to share with the commission.
Author Series – Palo Alto Reads: In partnership with Stanford University, the Palo Alto Library is hosting
an author series in August and exploring other author talks for September focused on race and equity.
Library youth and teen programming will be offered around this author series focused on inclusion and
diversity.
Expanded Communications: Staff is currently working on a series of communications to engage and
inform on race and equity. A few examples include a new website:
www.cityofpaloalto.org/raceandequity, initial Blog post and Additional blog post. Staff is also
encouraging email input by emailing the City Manager’s Office here: raceandequity@cityofpaloalto.org.
Summer Streets Program Progress: Reopening and recovery work continues as we implement the City
Council’s priorities of supporting our community and uplifting local businesses during this challenging
time. Staff coordination includes one on one meetings, weekly check-in meetings with Cal Ave and
University Avenue/Downtown core businesses. An online survey, direct email correspondence and site
visits were also conducted to gain an ongoing understanding of how the street closures, signage,
parklets and other efforts are impacting restaurants, retail stores and other business operations.
Changes to the program continue to be made based on business input. In addition, we’ve offered
community check-in meetings via Zoom and an online survey for the community to also provide
feedback on their experiences. Print and digital advertising is underway to promote the program and
encourage local and regional visitors to eat, shop and celebrate summer, supporting local businesses
safely through the summer months. For additional details, go to www.cityofpaloalto.org/summerstreets
Community Services Department
Summer Camp Progress: The Community Services Department launched virtual and in-person summer
camps in July. Camps include music, dance and theatre (7 camps/11 sessions), art (4 camps/12
sessions), science (4 camps/11 sessions), and sports/recreation (13 camps/18 session). Special interest
camps are also offered (7 camps/9 sessions). All in-person camps are following social distancing and
hygiene guidelines in the most recent County Health Order.
Community Programming Continues: CSD continues to provide opportunities to engage the community
through programming. Examples include a potter’s wheel rental program (Art Center), virtual theatre
performances (Children’s Theatre), and a mural event for teens called “What Keeps You Afloat?”
(Children’s Theatre).
Public Art Installations Underway: The Public Art program was busy with the Black Lives Matter mural
initiative, a Public Arts Commission-led effort; installing the public art at the new Junior Museum and
Zoo; and restoring The Boy with a Fishing Pole mural (Greg Brown) on the side of the downtown Post
Office.
Commission Coordination: Staff are working closely with the Public Art Commission and Human
Relations Commission to respond to Council referrals on Black Lives Matter and 8 Can’t Wait. The
Human Relations Commission hosted two community conversations around police practices in July on
July 9 and July 22. Go here for their meeting details including recordings of the conversations.
City of Palo Alto Page 4
Parks and Recreation Commission Coordination: Parks and Open Space staff assisted the Parks and
Recreation Commission to host a panel discussion on July 28 related to Foothills Park access to
nonresidents. The City Council will discuss this topic on August 3.
Cubberley Coordination and Tenant Support: Staff worked closely with Palo Alto Unified School District
(PAUSD) to find suitable room assignments for each long-term tenant that was displaced from Cubberley
due to the new lease agreement. In addition, staff was recently notified that two tenants are closing
due to impacts from COVID-19 and staff is evaluating space usage. Staff is also working on a
prioritization policy for Cubberley hourly renters. PAUSD will also allow hourly rental use of several
rooms to frequent past renters.
Office of Emergency Services
Emergency Services Activities: OES staff continues to monitor the ongoing pandemic emergency,
participating in County EOC conference calls, coordinating with other regional partners, and tracking
emerging trends. Staff is working with the County specifically on new opportunities to expand COVID-19
testing in Palo Alto in August and September.
OES is also continuing the mission to prevent, prepare for, respond to, and recover from all hazards. The
threats of wildland fire, terrorism, cyber, and numerous other hazards continue, even as most people
focus on the pandemic. See www.cityofpaloalto.org/thira. OES has also made progress on the grant-
funded Solar Generator Trailer project, with the RFP concluded, the vendor selected, and delivery
expected in early 2021. OES is also continuing to conduct socially-distanced training for our Emergency
Services Volunteers (ESV), a program that is continuing to add members during this pandemic.
Fire Department
Hog Fire Strike Team Redeployment: On the morning of July 21 the Palo Alto Fire Department received
a mutual aid request from Contra Costa County to join a strike team responding to the Hog Fire located
west of Susanville near the Hog Flat Reservoir in Lassen County. The Palo Alto four-member crew
assigned to the event includes a Captain, Engineer, Firefighter Paramedic and Firefighter. PAFD Engine
365 returned from their strike team deployment to the Hog Fire on July 29. As of July 30, the Hog Fire is
currently 9565 acres and 82% contained.
Human Resources Department
Human Resources Activities: As a result of fiscal challenges and revenue shortfalls reflected in the
adopted budget, HR staff completed position reductions and layoffs impacting up to 7 full time
employees and 53 hourly employees. Staff are continuing to facilitate the redeployment of impacted
employees to help minimize employee separations. Staff was able to work with union leadership to
defer 15 public safety employee layoffs, through a combination of a Public Safety early retirement
program, salary concessions and other measures. Staff also assisted with implementing furloughs and
salary freezes for Management and Professional Employees. At the same time, staff supported critical
recruitments to ensure stable staffing in critical services including planning and building inspectors.
Human Resources staff also partnered with Community Services to hire and on board approximately 30
City of Palo Alto Page 5
hourly employees to launch this year’s summer camps. Staff is leading evaluation of the newest County
protocols related to COVID-19.
Library Department
Recent Library Award Announced: Palo Alto Library’s Robotics in Libraries has been selected to receive
an Outstanding Achievement in Local Government Innovation Award from the Alliance for Innovation!
Sidewalk Service Continues: The library began Sidewalk holds pickup services at Mitchell Park
and Rinconada branches from June 26. More than 14,000 items have been picked up by community
members.
Palo Alto Reads Program Planning: The Library is honored to announce its first virtual Palo Alto Reads
event and book selection, The Color of Law: A Forgotten History of How Our Government Segregated
America by Richard Rothstein. Published in 2017, The Color of Law tells the history of the design and
segregation of American communities along racial lines. Rothstein focuses on many Bay Area
communities, including Palo Alto, which thwarted efforts back in 1947 to create integrated and working-
classing housing near Stanford University. This historical book provides great context into exploring
today’s ongoing inequities in housing, education, income and health.
From August 15 to September 15, free copies of The Color of Law will be available at Mitchell Park
and Rinconada Libraries during Sidewalk Service hours. We hope that Palo Alto joins in this community
read and conversation. We will be offering a series of events for all ages during this time, including
a virtual conversation with author Richard Rothstein on Thursday, August 27 at 7 p.m. This author event
is sponsored and hosted by The Bill Lane Center for the American West of Stanford University. Palo Alto
Reads is joint partnership with the City of Palo Alto and its Race & Equity Initiatives. Many thanks to the
City, Stanford University and the Friends of the Palo Alto Library for their support!
Library Book to Action Program Launched: Palo Alto Library was chosen out of a competitive field of
applicants to participate in Book to Action, a California Center for the Book/California State Library
program that takes the book club concept and expands it into a series of events for adults and
intergenerational groups. For our program, we selected the adult graphic novel Wrinkles by Paco Roca,
and have put together a series of events designed to generate empathy and inspire connection with the
Seniors in our community. Starting this week, we will be making copies of Wrinkles available to patrons
(for free!) while supplies last.
Library Virtual Events and Other Programming: The Library hosted 29 live/interactive events with 2367
attendees virtual events. Virtual Storytimes started on July 6 and run Monday-Friday at 11 AM on
Facebook Live. We’ve had 12 events with 1816 views. Summer Reading Program launched on July 1 with
817 signups so far. Our 3 Wacky Wednesdays have attracted 408 attendees and our special SRP videos
(First Chapter Fridays and Saturday Crafternoons) have attracted 880 views.
Planning and Development Services Department
Regional Housing Needs Allocation (RHNA) and Plan Bay Area 2050: The City Council received an
informational report regarding these two regional planning processed. City Council will hold a public
City of Palo Alto Page 6
meeting on August 3. Public comments on the Plan Bay Area 2050 draft Blueprint are due on or before
August 10.
Summer Streets: The Summer Streets program, kicked off by Council adoption of a resolution and
interim urgency ordinance, has been well-received by businesses and community members. On
California Avenue and University Avenue, dining al fresco has become the new modus operandi. In
addition, over 20 applications for parklets have been received, reviewed, and/or issued. Five parklets
have been constructed and are currently serving patrons. Likewise, several private and public parking
spaces have been repurposed as outdoor dining or retail areas. The Council will receive an update and
consider program modifications on August 10, 2020.
Inspection Services: The City has received numerous complaints about the delay in scheduling
inspections for construction projects. While recruitment is underway for two new inspectors (one is
limited term) authorized by the City Council during the budget process, staff has onboarded additional
consultant inspectors using salary savings. Efforts to reduce the backlog have been successful. The
waitlist has been reduced from 6 weeks to approximately 1 week. The City’s inspection manager and
even our Chief Building Official have conducted inspections to help better serve our customers.
Online Permitting Services System: The Online Permitting Services System began as a temporary
measure to respond changes in the shelter in place protocols. It has enabled many customers to submit
plans and review comments electronically. Staff review of the system is underway to address customer
issues raised and staff is creating a series of online tutorials to make the system more accessible. The
Online Permitting Services system is moving from a temporary tool to one that can sustain us over the
duration of the pandemic and through recovery. This year, the department will issue a request for
proposals for a more permanent online solution.
Castilleja School: The Final Environmental Impact Report for Castilleja was released on July 29. Public
hearings on the project will begin with the Architecture Review Board on August 20 followed by the
Planning and Transportation Commission on August 26. A significant amount of public engagement is
anticipated, and it will take several meetings each of these bodies and the HRB before the project
advances to the City Council in November (tentative).
High Speed Rail Project Draft Environmental Impact Report Released: The California High Speed Rail
Authority has released a DIER/EIS for the project section between San Francisco and San Jose. The public
comment period ends August 24, 2020. City staff led by the Office of Transportation, are reviewing the
document and anticipate sending a comment letter. More information and access to the document is
available here.
340 Portage (Former Fry’s Site) Application Filed: An application was received requesting a zoning text
amendment to allow more flexible use of the space vacated Fry’s Electronics. The applicant indicates
Target has a strong interest to occupy about 30KSF of the building and requests code language
precluding the expansion of other land uses, including office, be removed. The property is zoned RM-40
but is allowed to maintain commercial uses through a provision written into the City’s zoning code. No
hearing dates are scheduled at this time.
788 San Antonio Housing Project Application: This application for 100 units and possible extension of
the Housing Incentive Program along portions of San Antonio is schedule for hearings before the
City of Palo Alto Page 7
Planning and Transportation Commission on August 12, 2020 and Architectural Review Board on August
20, 2020. This is a legislative and quasi-judicial project that will also be scheduled before the City Council
tentatively in October.
North Ventura Coordinated Area Plan (NVCAP): The NVCAP Working Group has continued virtual
meetings, which started in May 2020. The Working Group has used small, subcommittee meetings to
work towards consensus on several important topics. The Working Group will continue meeting in
August. In September and October, staff and the consultant team will translate the outcomes of the
subcommittee meetings into at least 2 draft alternatives that will be presented to the Planning and
Transportation Commission, and ultimately City Council.
Wireless Ordinance: Prior to the coronavirus pandemic, staff was on schedule to present this ordinance
to Council in April. Early cancellation of the PTC meetings and need to shift staff resources to other
priorities resulted in delays to the schedule. Staff anticipates bring a draft resolution to the PTC
following its request to meet with industry officials and make some adjustment to the ordinance. Those
hearings will resume in September/October and be presented to the City Council around November.
East Palo Alto University Avenue Office Project: City staff responded to a Notice of Preparation to
prepare an Environmental Impact Report for the University Circle Phase II Office Project proposed at the
corner of University Avenue and Woodland Avenue in East Palo Alto. The project proposes to redevelop
an existing parking lot located in the southeast corner of the project site with a six-story, approximately
180,000-square-foot office building above three levels of below grade parking. The tenant(s) for the
office space are not yet known.
City of Palo alto Staff anticipates that the project will result in both construction and operational traffic
impacts that would affect residents within the City of Palo Alto and has requested that a traffic analysis
be prepared to analyze these local traffic impacts. The City also requested that the City of East Palo Alto
identify and address other impacts that may affect the quality of life of residents within Palo Alto as a
result of construction or operation of the proposed project. They include but are not limited to: air
quality, aesthetics, noise, and parking.
The Notice of Preparation is the beginning phase of an environmental review process. There will be
additional opportunities to provide public input in the future. Staff anticipates that the City of Palo Alto
will review and provide a formal comment letter on the Draft Environmental Impact Report once it is
published.
Police Department
Police Community Briefings: For the first time, the Police Department delivered four separate live
presentations to the public via Zoom and YouTube during the month of July to share department details.
The series of one-hour online community briefings offer insight into the Police Department and some
aspects of law enforcement. The community briefings are loosely based on the curriculum provided in the
Police Department’s popular Basic Citizens Police Academy and takes community members on a deep
dive into law enforcement topics as a foundation to upcoming broader community briefing sessions.
Chief Robert Jonsen, Assistant Chief Andrew Binder, and Acting Captain James Reifschneider each
hosted at least one of the sessions, all of which can be watched on the PAPD YouTube channel:
City of Palo Alto Page 8
Overview of PAPD, Use of Force Policy and Use of Force Investigations, Laws of Arrest and Search &
Seizure, and Accountability Within PAPD.
Participated in Ongoing Race and Equity Conversations: Led by Chief Robert Jonsen and joined by
other members of the PAPD executive staff, the Police Department spent much of July participating in
the ongoing race and equity conversations occurring in our community. PAPD participated in multiple
meetings of the four City Council Ad Hoc Committees, made presentations and addressed questions at
two public meetings of the Human Relations Commission, and participated in two community
roundtable discussions on racial and social injustice in America hosted by the Mid-Pen Media Center.
The Police Department looks forward to continuing to participate in these important conversations as
we move into August.
Response to Fireworks Complaints: During the shelter-in-place period, there has been a rise across the
United States in the number of illegal fireworks, and the Palo Alto area has been no exception. Our
officers routinely responded to fireworks complaints from residents, but unfortunately the fireworks
were only heard or seen in the sky, and the location from which they were being launched was most
often in adjoining cities. The Police Department joined other City departments in launching a public
education campaign targeting the illegality of fireworks and the ramifications and dangers that illegal
fireworks bring to communities. For more information, see the City’s new web page dedicated to this
ongoing problem here.
Public Works Services Department
Bike Bridge Construction Continues: The construction contract for the Highway 101 pedestrian/bike
bridge was approved in November 2019 and construction started this year in February. During July,
utility relocations that required a new joint trench were completed on the West Bayshore side. On the
East Bayshore side, construction of all 16 foundation piles was completed, and column construction is in
progress and is visible. Fabrication of the main span steel bridge over Highway 101 and the smaller
Adobe Creek bridge is underway.
California Avenue Garage Progress: Steady progress has continued over the summer and we expect the
garage to be completed by late September. The remaining work includes the grand staircase facing Birch
Street, terra cotta exterior architectural elements, elevators, parking stall striping, landscaping and
signage, the parking guidance system, and the garage’s 32 EV chargers.
Deconstruction Ordinance Began July 1, 2020: A new Palo Alto Deconstruction Ordinance became
effective on July 1, requiring that certain large projects separate materials as a building is taken down,
rather than demolishing it in in the old-fashioned way. Deconstruction, rather than demolition, allows
for more salvaging and recycling; reduces landfilling; conserves materials and resources; and helps
implement the City’s Zero Waste and Sustainability /Climate Action Plans. The July 1 date is the first
phase of this initiative and includes projects that are taking down an entire building, where the Building
permit is applied for after July 1. Staff expects about 115 projects per year; maybe less this year with
COVID-19 induced delays. Since July 1, there have been five Building permit applications submitted
which will trigger deconstruction; all of which are single family residential. Palo Alto is one of the first
cities, nationally, to implement this program. Additional information, outreach materials, and resources
are available on the City’s website, by emailing Deconstruction@CityofPaloAlto.org, or by calling (650)
496-5910.
City of Palo Alto Page 9
Office of Transportation
Transportation Data Counts: Transportation conducted data counts to determine detour traffic due to
Summer Streets closures on University Avenue. Staff also conducted ongoing parking counts to evaluate
the impacts of summer streets closures on parking demand and led pedestrian and bicycle data counts
in the Cal Avenue and University Avenue areas to determine related impacts. Data collected will be
presented to the City Council as part of the August 10 City Council meeting item on the Summer Streets
program.
Rail Virtual Town Hall: Office of Transportation, AECOM, and the City Manager’s Office is working to
develop a virtual Town Hall to discuss grade separation (Connecting Palo Alto) that will occur in mid-
August. This online opportunity will catch up the community on what’s new and provide a new
opportunity virtually to inform and engage on the City’s Grade Separation conversations in advance of
moving to the next phase of this initiative.
Rail Expanded Community Advisory Panel (XCAP) Meeting Progress: XCAP meetings have continued
through the summer. The XCAP is starting to draft their final report and nearing deliberation of grade
separation alternatives. XCAP plans to provide an update to Council in September.
Caltrain Fiscal Challenges: Staff has been tracking Caltrain fiscal challenges including the potential
placement of an 1/8 cent sales tax measure on the November 2020 ballot. This topic is added to the
August 3 City Council meeting to consider and discuss next steps.
Parking Updates: Staff has renegotiated contract parking enforcement with a significant cost savings, as
described in the budgeting process. The contract with SP+ has been terminated and is in the process of
switching the Residential Preferential Parking (RPP) permit process to a new vendor (Duncan) for virtual
permitting. Staff is preparing to switch to the virtual permits using License Plate Recognition (LPR)
technology and will return to Council with more details. Parking programs policy review is underway and
will return to Council for review. In addition, the new Cal Ave garage will be opening this fall, and staff
will return with plans for permit distribution and potential changes to the neighboring Residential
Permit Program. Automated Parking Guidance Systems will be implemented in the new Cal Ave garage
and the process for implementing a similar system in downtown is being developed.
Transportation Planning: Transportation Demand Management (TDM) Ordinance development is
underway, and the Planning and Transportation Commission recently reviewed the proposed ordinance
during a study session. Staff plans to return to PTC with the TDM ordinance in the first half of the year
and to the City Council afterwards. The Safe Routes to School program has developed online resources
and provided virtual lessons and trainings. Currently staff are preparing to re-align typical plans with the
school districts plans. Due to COVID-19, the bike/scooter share program has not initiated. Staff plans to
request Council to extend the pilot.
Transportation Engineering: Staff is working on contracts to continue Capital Improvement Projects and
will return to council for approval of contracts. The Crescent Park neighborhood traffic calming pilot
project will go to the Planning and Transportation Commission for review, followed by Council. Staff
expects to bring a contract award to Council for approval for the Alma/Churchill Rail safety Section 130
grant-funded project soon.
City of Palo Alto Page 10
Utilities Department
Utilities Staffing: Approximately half of the Utilities department staff have returned to work and half of
the staff continue to work remotely. Almost all Operations staff are physically reporting to work to carry
out field maintenance and operations projects and respond to emergency service calls. Customer
Support Service staff rotate in and out of the office. Staff in the Administration, Resource Management
and Engineering divisions are mostly working remotely, although some are choosing to return to in-
person work. Utilities had suspended reading meters in backyards and behind locked facilities in
accordance with the shelter in place requirements but resumed all meter reading at the beginning of
June once some of the restrictions were lifted.
Modifications to Utilities Programs: When the County lifted restrictions on construction activities, some
energy efficiency projects resumed this summer, including commercial energy efficiency projects, solar
installations, EV charger installations, and other work that does not require staff or consultant visits
inside occupied residential dwellings. The County’s construction protocol requirements continue to be in
effect. Since all visits inside occupied residential dwellings are temporarily on hold, staff are modifying
programs to offer virtual services.
Saving Energy and Water While Sheltering in Place: Utilities launched an outreach campaign with
energy and water efficiency tips to help keep bills low while people are working and studying from
home. A new “Summer Sustainability for Kids” e-newsletter series aims to educate younger Palo Alto
community members and provide family-friendly activities for children as they spend more time at
home this summer.
Utilities Projects Progress: Each year Utilities performs a routine inspection of the gas distribution
system to check for leaks and contractors are currently walking residential areas for this inspection. Staff
are replacing utility poles in various areas of the city. In addition, the utilities meter audit project
continues and is expected to wrap up in the fall.
Timeline, Resource Impact, Policy Implications (If Applicable)
N/A
Stakeholder Engagement
N/A
Environmental Review
This report is not subject to environmental review.