Loading...
The URL can be used to link to this page
Your browser does not support the video tag.
Home
My WebLink
About
2025-07-28 City Council Emails
DOCUMENTS IN THIS PACKET INCLUDE: LETTERS FROM CITIZENS TO THE MAYOR OR CITY COUNCIL RESPONSES FROM STAFF TO LETTERS FROM CITIZENS ITEMS FROM MAYOR AND COUNCIL MEMBERS ITEMS FROM OTHER COMMITTEES AND AGENCIES ITEMS FROM CITY, COUNTY, STATE, AND REGIONAL AGENCIES Prepared for: 7/28/2025 Document dates: 7/21/2025 - 7/28/2025 Note: Documents for every category may not have been received for packet reproduction in a given week. 701-32 From:Martin WassermanTo:Donna WallachCc:Salem Ajluni; Aram James; Veenker, Vicki; Lythcott-Haims, Julie; Reckdahl, Keith; Ed Lauing; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, AssemblyDistrict 23; Lori Meyers; Sheree Roth; h.etzko@gmail.com; Binder, Andrew; Mark Turner; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; Josh Becker; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov;Julie Lythcott-Haims; Figueroa, Eric; Doug Minkler; Gerry Gras; EPA Today; Gennady Sheyner; city.council@menlopark.gov; dcombs@menlopark.gov; Steve Wagstaffe; Jeff Rosen;Jeff Conrad; Jeff Hayden; Jay Boyarsky; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas; Mickie Winkler; Sean Allen; Cait James; San JoséSpotlight; board@pausd.org; boardfeedback@smcgov.org; board@valleywater.org; BoardOperations; Braden Cartwright; Raymond Goins; Rodriguez, Miguel; editor@paweekly.com;Wagner, April; Don Austin; Donna Wallach; Burt, Patrick; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov; Palo Alto Free Press; Seher Awan; Daniel Barton; David Piper; Foley, Michael; Zelkha, Mila;Palo Alto Renters" Association; Diana Diamond; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com; ladoris cordell; cromero@cityofepa.org; rabrica@cityofepa.org; Bill Newell; Bill Johnson; Bill James;Pat M; Carla Torres; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; Council, City; GRP-City Council; Perron, Zachary; City Attorney; citycouncil@mountainview.gov; Clerk, City; GRP-City Clerk;Friends of Cubberley; Lotus Fong; ParkRec Commission; Gardener, Liz; Human Relations Commission; Holman, Karen (external); Liz Kniss; Patrice Ventresca; Rowena Chiu; DanaSt. George; Damon Silver; Daniel Kottke; Dennis Upton; Zahra Billoo; james pitkin; Roberta Ahlquist; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Supervisor Otto Lee; Stump, Molly; Rosen, Jeff;Baker, Rob; Ruth Silver Taube; Tom DuBois; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Jasso, Tamara; DuJuan Green; Dennis Upton; dennis burns; Jensen, Eric; Afanasiev, Alex; Lee, Craig; AnnaGriffin; Angel, David; Greg Tanaka; Reifschneider, James; Bryan Gobin; Yolanda Conaway; Vara RamakrishnanSubject:Re: Famine Expert: Israel"s Starvation of Gaza Most "Minutely Designed and Controlled" Since WWII Date:Monday, July 28, 2025 2:22:44 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking onlinks. Donna, You're only describing what Israel has done to the Arabs, without any mention of what the Arabs have done to the Israelis to bring about these responses. It's like analyzing World War II by only looking at the Allied bombings of Germany, with noreference to the actions of the Germans that necessitated these bombings. Martin Wasserman On Jul 24, 2025, at 10:09 PM, Donna Wallach <cats4jazz@gmail.com> wrote: When I lived in Occupied Palestine aka Israel for 15 years, 1981 - 1997, I saw and experienced the outright racismof the Israeli State towards the Palestinians. Even the Palestinian villages and towns and cities inside Israel had itmuch worse than Jewish Israeli cities, towns, kibbiutzes and moshavs. The funding for schools in Palestinianschools was much lower than even the schools for Jewish students in the Development Towns. Almost all citiesand towns and all kibbutzes and moshavs are segregated. Only a few cities inside the Israeli State have Jews andPalestinians living in the same city, like Ramle, Yaffa, Akko and Jerusalem, but they are still segregated withinthe cities, they don't live next to each other. But much worse is the way soldiers treat Palestinians. I think it was in the late 1980s maybe the early or mid 1990s Gideon Levy wrote an article in the Ha'aretz weekend paper of the dozens of Palestinian children who hadbeen shot in the head while sitting in their classrooms in Gaza, some of them dying, some of them losing theireyes. During the years of the first Intifada, around 1987 I think, the Israeli govt. shut down Bir Zeit University in theWest Bank, and also closed many schools throughout Gaza. So the Palestinians had to open community schools. Israel practices their Apartheid policies on its own Jewish citizens. Jews who were forced to immigrate to Israelfrom Arab countries were sent to Development Towns, not to the big cities. There were meager job opportunitiesin the Development Towns and the funding for the schools was very low, so those students didn't get as good aneducation as students who were of European descent. On the radio we only heard accents of Jewish Israelis whospoke with an Ashkenazi accent, none who spoke with an accent of someone who's native tongue was Arabic andat least half of all Jewish Israelis are Arabs, i.e. they come from Iraq, Morocco, Tunisia, Algeria, Yemen, etc.There were horrendous racist jokes about Moroccan Jews and of course even worse jokes about Palestinians. Most Jewish Israelis and the entire Israeli govt. cares nothing about the well being of the Palestinians. I have seenso much during the time I lived there, again when I visited in 2002 and again when I lived in Gaza in 2008 for 4months. In 2002 there was a month siege on the entire city of Ramallah. 24 hours a day for weeks, nobody couldleave their house, not for food, not for medicine, not to go to work, not to go to school. Many Palestinians wereshot and maimed or killed just for standing outside on the rooftops to their homes or even standing next to an open window in their own home. Also, people would go out to try to buy pita, and the Israeli soldiers driving aroundwould shoot them dead, The israeli soldiers used their tanks and other heavy armored vehicles to drive over thevehicles of the Palestinians, destroying the vehicles. Also the Israeli soldiers went into govt offices, destroying and/or stealing computers, hard drives, video cameras, paper files of the file cabinets. The soldiers defacated andurinated in the offices and the homes of Palestinians. The Israeli soldiers stole money and other properties ofPalstinians whose homes they invaded. Banks were broken into and the entire infrastructure was destroyed. The Israeli soldiers went into office buildings and either destroyed or stole everything in the stores. They broke intothe office of a NeoNatal Doctor and destroyed his office, broke down his door. They also refused to let him go tohis clients, women who were giving birth. During that time the maternity hospital near Bethlehem was bombed. When I lived in Gaza in 2008, I witnessed how the siege on Gaza, 2 years after it started, already had a severeimpact on the entire population of Gaza. Many buildings stood unfinished. Israel refused to allow the buildingsupplies in so that the doors, windows, etc could be installed into the buildings. Many people were unemployed because of the lack of supplies and the suppressed economy. Already then at least 20% if not more of the childrenwere malnourished. The Israeli Navy was severely limiting how far Palestinians fishers could go out into theirinternationally recognized waters to fish and have a livelihood and provide a good source of protein for the Palestinians living in Gaza. Some of us International volunteers went out with the fishers on their boats andwitnessed the Israeli Navy come and shoot at their boats and their nets and equipment, preventing them fromhaving a good catch of fish and also denying them their right to fish in their own waters. The Israeli Navy alsoused high powered hoses to spray water onto the boats, damaging the boats and injuring people. Then they startedusing stinky water in their high powered hoses, spraying the stinky water after a catch of fish was cast onto theboat, destroying the catch of the day. In previous years the Israeli army had invaded the Beit Hanoun area in northern Gaza and decimated the fruitgroves, so all the trees that used to be there were gone. I witnessed humongous Israeli bulldozers come in throughthe Apartheid Wall through a gate and dig up agricultural land. The ongoing genocide and the starvation is beyond despicable and you Martin have totally lost any sense ofhumanity that you could claim that the Palestinians are responsible for this. The Palestinian people are one of themost kindest, generous, loving people on this planet! I saw Hamas providing tents to Palestinians in Gaza in the 1980s when the Israeli soldiers were stationed there and were destroying many Palestinian homes. Hamas alsoprovided supplies for the families who needed supplies. Hamas also provided kindergartens for the children.Hamas means Islamic Resistance Movement and according to International Law, occupied people have the right to rebel against their occupiers! Israeli soldiers and settlers are constantly invading Palestinian lands! If you really want to know how Israel treated the Palestinians prior to 1948 and from 1948 onwards read these books:"State of Terror: How Terrorism Created Modern Israel" by Thomas Suarezhttp://thomassuarez.com/SoT.html "The Hundred Years War on Palestine"by Rashid Khalidi "The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine"by Illan Pappe Donna Wallach On Thu, Jul 24, 2025 at 6:36 PM Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:This is utter nonsense. If Israel's modus operandi has always been "maximal violence and aggression with littleto no regard for the sanctity of lives of civilian non-combatants,” why did they sign the 1993 Oslo Accord which brought Yasser Arafat and the PLO out of exile and gave them sovereignty of Arab areas in Judea and Samaria?And why did they forcibly evacuate all Jewish settlements in Gaza in 2005 instead of strengthening thosesettlements and digging in? The reality is, it was always the Arab leadership that sought to exterminate the Jews, giving the Jews no choice but to fight back. When Israel goes to war, it goes to great lengths to avoid civilian casualties, but groups like Hamas go out of their way to target Israeli civilians, and the Palestinian Authority gives large cash rewards to any Arab whomurders any Jew, whether civilian or otherwise. Right now, people in Gaza are starving, not because of Israel, but because Hamas refuses to lay down its armsand release the hostages. The conflict would be over tomorrow if Hamas would do these simple things. In fact,Hamas tries forcibly, often with gunfire, to prevent Gazans from receiving life-giving aid that doesn't comethrough them, saying that receiving such aid amounts to "collaborating with the enemy.” The truth is, Israel has displayed more concern for the lives of Gazan civilians than the Gazans’ own leadershave. Perhaps the reason for this is that Israeli culture is based on reverence for life, while Hamas culture definesitself as revering death, and seeking martyrdom in battle as the highest possible goal. Martin Wasserman On Jul 24, 2025, at 2:45 PM, Salem Ajluni <ajluni@hotmail.com> wrote: As a modest contribution to a better understanding of the thinking and practices of the Israeli state, past and present, I recommend a very useful and short book that I read more than 40 years ago. It was written by Livia Rokach, the daughter of Israel Rokach who was the Israeli Interior Minister in the government of Moshe Sharett, the latter being the second prime minister of the new state (1953-1955). She translated and published her father's diaries, as well as parts of Sharett's diaries, both of which give us insights into the private elite thinking, planning and actions of main actors in the Israeli state vis-a-vis its neighboring countries in the 1950s (and vis-s-vis the U.S. and European powers) (see https://ia804501.us.archive.org/17/items/sacred- terrorism/Sacred-Terrorism.pdf). The resonance and parallels between Israeli leadership thinking and actions in the 1950s (as explained by Rokach) and in the 21st century with regard to the states and peoples of Lebanon, Syria, the West Bank, Gaza and Egypt (and, by extension, Iraq, Yemen and Iran) are instructive. There are considerable continuities across time and space: aggressive and domineering (supremicist?) thinking and behavior; an expansionist impulse; a sociopathic and homicidal (genocidal?) animus towards Arabs, especially Palestinians. It was all there in the 1940s and 1950s, as Rokach tells us, and it's all there now, as we witness on a daily basis. Israel certainly didn't need Hamas to induce such thinking and behavior. In fact, the Hamas movement wasn't formally inaugurated until late 1987, almost two generations after the establishment of the state of Israel. Reading historical accounts of the conflict teaches us that only the bugaboo changes (e.g. Nasser, the PLO, Saddam Hussein, Hizballah, Hamas, the Houthis, Iran, etc.)—the Israeli modus operandi is more or less a constant--maximal violence and aggression with little to no regard for the sanctity of the lives of civilian non-combatants. The Israeli state was ushered in and made possible by the intial displacement of the majority of Mandate Palestine's Arab population during 1947-1949 (on these events, see Ilan Pappe's book based in large part on official Israeli archival sourceshttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ethnic_Cleansing_of_Palestine). It behooves us to remember that about two-thirds of Gaza's population are themselves refugees from Madate Palestine or the offspring of those refugees. No disconinuities there either. Regards, Salem From: Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:23 PM To: Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> Cc: Veenker, Vicki <Vicki.Veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lythcott-Haims, Julie <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Keith Reckdahl <reckdahl@yahoo.com>; Ed Lauing <elauing@equitysearchpartners.com>; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23 <jessica@speiser.net>; Lori Meyers <meyers.lk@gmail.com>; Sheree Roth <ssroth29@gmail.com>; Henry Etzkowitz <H.Etzko@gmail.com>; Binder, Andrew <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mark Turner <mark.turner@morganhill.ca.gov>; CityCouncil <CityCouncil@morganhill.ca.gov>; Michelle Bigelow <Michelle.Bigelow@morganhill.ca.gov>; Josh Becker <becker.josh@gmail.com>; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov<assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <julieforpaloalto@gmail.com>;eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org <eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org>; Doug Minkler <dminkler@dminkler.com>; Gerry Gras <gerrygras@earthlink.net>; EPA Today <epatoday@epatoday.org>; Gennady Sheyner <gsheyner@embarcaderomedia.org>; city.council@menlopark.gov <city.council@menlopark.gov>; dcombs@menlopark.gov <dcombs@menlopark.gov>; Steve Wagstaffe <swagstaffe@smcgov.org>; Jeff Rosen <info@jeffrosen.org>; Jeff Conrad <jeff_conrad@msn.com>; Jeff Hayden <laptoplg@mac.com>; Jay Boyarsky <jboyarsky@dao.sccgov.org>; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto <wilpf.peninsula.paloalto@gmail.com>; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com> <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas <nicholas.enberg@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mickie Winkler <mickie650@gmail.com>; Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com>; Cait James <caitlin.a.james@gmail.com>; San José Spotlight <info@sanjosespotlight.com>; board@pausd.org <board@pausd.org>; boardfeedback@smcgov.org <boardfeedback@smcgov.org>; board@valleywater.org<board@valleywater.org>; BoardOperations <BoardOperations@cob.sccgov.org>; Braden Cartwright <bcartwright@padailypost.com>; Raymond Goins <goinsrayl@gmail.com>; Rodriguez, Miguel <miguel.rodriguez@pdo.sccgov.org>; editor@paweekly.com <editor@paweekly.com>; April Wagner <april.wagner@cityofpaloalto.org>; Don Austin <daustin@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <donnaisanactivist@gmail.com>; Burt, Patrick <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov <Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov>; Palo Alto Free Press <paloaltofreepress@gmail.com>; Seher Awan <firebrand.dr@gmail.com>; Daniel Barton <dbarton@nbo.law>; David Piper <david.piper@wvm.edu>; michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org <michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mila Zelkha <mila.zelkha@gmail.com>; Palo Alto Renters' Association <info@paloaltorenters.org>; Diana Diamond <dianaLdiamond@gmail.com>; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com <jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com>; ladoris cordell <ladoris@judgecordell.com>; cromero@cityofepa.org <cromero@cityofepa.org>; rabrica@cityofepa.org<rabrica@cityofepa.org>; Bill Newell <billnewell2850@gmail.com>; Bill Johnson <bjohnson@paweekly.com>; Bill James <billjames99@gmail.com>; Pat M <p.marshall81@ymail.com>; Carla Torres <xicanamagic@hotmail.com>; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan <mayor@sanjoseca.gov>; CityCouncil <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Council <council@redwoodcity.org>; Zachary.Perron@CityofPaloAlto.org <zachary.perron@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Attorney <CityAttorney@santaclaraca.gov>; citycouncil@mountainview.gov <citycouncil@mountainview.gov>; Clerk, City <city.clerk@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Clerk <CLERK2@redwoodcity.org>; Friends of Cubberley <friendsofcubberley94303@gmail.com>; Lotus Fong <lyfong@pacbell.net>; ParkRec Commission <ParkRec.commission@cityofpaloalto.org>; Liz Gardner <Gardnerjaqua@gmail.com>; Human Relations Commission <hrc@cityofpaloalto.org>; Karen Holman <kcholman@sbcglobal.net>; Liz Kniss <lizkniss@earthlink.net>; Patrice Ventresca <patriceventresca@gmail.com>; Rowena Chiu <rowena.chiu@gmail.com>; Dana St. George <danasg@earthlink.net>; Damon Silver <damon.silver@pdo.sccgov.org>; Daniel Kottke <daniel.k@earthlink.net>; Dennis Upton <kathy8420@qq.com>; Zahra Billoo <zbilloo@cair.com>; james pitkin <jamespitkin777@yahoo.com>; Roberta Ahlquist <roberta.ahlquist@sjsu.edu>; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg <supervisor.ellenberg@bos.sccgov.org>; Supervisor Otto Lee <supervisor.lee@bos.sccgov.org>; Salem Ajluni <ajluni@hotmail.com>; Stump, Molly <molly.stump@cityofpaloalto.org>; Rosen, Jeff <JRosen@dao.sccgov.org>; Baker, Rob <rbaker@dao.sccgov.org>; Ruth Silver Taube <ruthsilvertaube16@gmail.com>; Tom DuBois <tom.dubois@gmail.com>; Blackshire, Geoffrey <Geo.Blackshire@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jasso, Tamara <Tamara.Jasso@cityofpaloalto.org>; DuJuan Green <dujuang@sbcglobal.net>; Dennis Upton <denkafer1@yahoo.com>; dennis burns <dennis.r.burns@gmail.com>; Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org <Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org>; Alex Afanasiev <Alex.Afanasiev@cityofpaloalto.org>; craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org <craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org>; Anna Griffin <griffinam@sbcglobal.net>; Angel, David <dangel@dao.sccgov.org>; Greg Tanaka <greg@gregtanaka.org>; Reifschneider, James <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Bryan Gobin <appeal.bryan.gobin@gmail.com>; Yolanda Conaway <yconaway@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <cats4jazz@gmail.com>; Vara Ramakrishnan <vara@acm.org> Subject: Re: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' Since WWII The bias of the author is evident in the fact that the entire article mentions Hamas only once, in passing. Hamas could end the suffering tomorrow just by laying down their arms and releasing the hostages. But they care more about scoring propaganda points against Israel than about saving the lives of their own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 22, 2025, at 3:08 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvationof Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' Since WWII Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' Since WWII |Common Dreamshttps://www.commondreams.org/news/famine-expert-israel-s-starvation-of-gaza-most-minutely-designed-and-controlled-since-wwii -- Books you must read: "Against Our Better Judgement: The hidden history of how the U.S. was used to create Israel" by Alison Weir http://www.againstourbetterjudgment.com/ "State of Terror: How Terrorism Created Modern Israel" by Thomas Suarezhttp://thomassuarez.com/SoT.html "The Hundred Years War on Palestine"by Rashid Khalidi "The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine"by Illan Pappe Other important websites to visithttp://www.ifamericansknew.orghttps://wearenotnumbers.org/https://electronicintifada.net/https://www.palestinechronicle.com End the illegal Blockade/Siege/collective punishment on Gaza!Tear down all the Apartheid Walls in West Bank & Gaza!Tear down all the illegal checkpoints throughout the West Bank!End the illegal War Criminal Settler-Colonial Apartheid Terrorist Israeli Occupation of all of Historic Palestine!Right to Return to their homes and land in Historic Palestine for all Palestinians!End all U.S. aid to IsraelFree Palestine! Long Live Palestine! Support Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions (BDS) & Palestinian Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel (PACBI) Campaigns!http://www.bdsmovement.nethttp://www.WhoProfits.orghttp://www.pacbi.org Support Solidarity with the Freedom Flotilla - We will sail until Palestine is Free! https://freedomflotilla.org/ Support ISM volunteers in West Bank and Gaza Strip!http://www.palsolidarity.org Donna Wallachcats4jazz@gmail.comSkype: palestinewillbeTwitter: @PalestineWillBe(cell) 408-569-6608 From:Sean Allen To:Martin WassermanCc:Salem Ajluni; Aram James; Veenker, Vicki; Lythcott-Haims, Julie; Reckdahl, Keith; Ed Lauing; jessica@speiser.net; Lori Meyers; Sheree Roth; h.etzko@gmail.com; Binder, Andrew; Mark Turner; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; Josh Becker;Assemblymember.Berman@assembly.ca.gov; Julie Lythcott-Haims; Figueroa, Eric; Doug Minkler; Gerry Gras; Today EPA; Gennady Sheyner; city.council@menlopark.gov; dcombs@menlopark.gov; Steve Wagstaffe; Jeff Rosen; Jeff Conrad; JeffHayden; Jay Boyarsky; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com; Enberg, Nicholas; Mickie Winkler; Cait James; San José Spotlight; board@pausd.org; boardfeedback@smcgov.org; board@valleywater.org; BoardOperations;Braden Cartwright; Raymond Goins; Miguel Rodriguez; editor@paweekly.com; Wagner, April; Don Austin; Donna Wallach; Burt, Patrick; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov; Palo Alto Free Press; Seher Awan; Daniel Barton; David Piper; Foley,Michael; Zelkha, Mila; Renters" Association Palo Alto; Diana Diamond; jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com; ladoris cordell; cromero@cityofepa.org; rabrica@cityofepa.org; Bill Newell; Bill Johnson; Bill James; Pat M; Carla Torres; The Officeof Mayor Matt Mahan; Council, City; GRP-City Council; Perron, Zachary; City Attorney; citycouncil@mountainview.gov; Clerk, City; GRP-City Clerk; Friends of Cubberley; Lotus Fong; ParkRec Commission; Gardener, Liz; Human RelationsCommission; Holman, Karen (external); Liz Kniss; Patrice Ventresca; Rowena Chiu; Dana St. George; Damon Silver; Daniel Kottke; Dennis Upton; Zahra Billoo; james pitkin; Roberta Ahlquist; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Supervisor Otto Lee;Stump, Molly; Jeff Rosen; Rob Baker; Ruth Silver Taube; Tom DuBois; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Jasso, Tamara; DuJuan Green; Dennis Upton; dennis burns; Jensen, Eric; Afanasiev, Alex; Lee, Craig; Anna Griffin; David Angel; Greg Tanaka;Reifschneider, James; Bryan Gobin; Yolanda Conaway; Donna Wallach; Vara RamakrishnanSubject:Re: Famine Expert: Israel"s Starvation of Gaza Most "Minutely Designed and Controlled" Since WWII Date:Monday, July 28, 2025 2:21:17 PMAttachments:image1.png CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. Good evening, Martin, I want to start by expressing my apologies before we delve into today’s discussion. Unfortunately, several major U.S. media outlets have reported perspectives that contradict yourposition. I find that your argument lacks substantial logic. Given the global perception of the United States as a superior military power, it raises the question of how the people ofGaza, even under Hamas leadership, could pose a significant threat to any country supported by U.S. military resources. The attached photos speak volumes and challenge the validityof your position. Best regards, Sean Sent from my iPhone On Jul 24, 2025, at 6:36 PM, Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote: This is utter nonsense. If Israel's modus operandi has always been "maximal violence and aggression with little to no regard for the sanctity of lives ofcivilian non-combatants,” why did they sign the 1993 Oslo Accord which brought Yasser Arafat and the PLO out of exile and gave them sovereignty ofArab areas in Judea and Samaria? And why did they forcibly evacuate all Jewish settlements in Gaza in 2005 instead of strengthening those settlementsand digging in? The reality is, it was always the Arab leadership that sought to exterminate the Jews, giving the Jews no choice but to fight back. When Israel goes to war, it goes to great lengths to avoid civilian casualties, but groups like Hamas go out of their way to target Israeli civilians, and thePalestinian Authority gives large cash rewards to any Arab who murders any Jew, whether civilian or otherwise. Right now, people in Gaza are starving, not because of Israel, but because Hamas refuses to lay down its arms and release the hostages. The conflictwould be over tomorrow if Hamas would do these simple things. In fact, Hamas tries forcibly, often with gunfire, to prevent Gazans from receiving life-giving aid that doesn't come through them, saying that receiving such aid amounts to "collaborating with the enemy.” The truth is, Israel has displayed more concern for the lives of Gazan civilians than the Gazans’ own leaders have. Perhaps the reason for this is thatIsraeli culture is based on reverence for life, while Hamas culture defines itself as revering death, and seeking martyrdom in battle as the highestpossible goal. Martin Wasserman On Jul 24, 2025, at 2:45 PM, Salem Ajluni <ajluni@hotmail.com> wrote: As a modest contribution to a better understanding of the thinking and practices of the Israeli state, past and present, I recommend a very useful and short book that I read more than 40 years ago. It was written by Livia Rokach, the daughter of Israel Rokach who was the Israeli Interior Minister in the government of Moshe Sharett, the latter being the second prime minister of the new state (1953-1955). She translated and published her father's diaries, as well as parts of Sharett's diaries, both of which give us insights into the private elite thinking, planning and actions of main actors in the Israeli state vis-a-vis its neighboring countries in the 1950s (and vis-s-vis the U.S. and European powers) (see https://ia804501.us.archive.org/17/items/sacred-terrorism/Sacred-Terrorism.pdf). The resonance and parallels between Israeli leadership thinking and actions in the 1950s (as explained by Rokach) and in the 21st century with regard to the states and peoples of Lebanon, Syria, the West Bank, Gaza and Egypt (and, by extension, Iraq, Yemen and Iran) are instructive. There are considerable continuities across time and space: aggressive and domineering (supremicist?) thinking and behavior; an expansionist impulse; a sociopathic and homicidal (genocidal?) animus towards Arabs, especially Palestinians. It was all there in the 1940s and 1950s, as Rokach tells us, and it's all there now, as we witness on a daily basis. Israel certainly didn't need Hamas to induce such thinking and behavior. In fact, the Hamas movement wasn't formally inaugurated until late 1987, almost two generations after the establishment of the state of Israel. Reading historical accounts of the conflict teaches us that only the bugaboo changes (e.g. Nasser, the PLO, Saddam Hussein, Hizballah, Hamas, the Houthis, Iran, etc.)—the Israeli modus operandi is more or less a constant--maximal violence and aggression with little to no regard for the sanctity of the lives of civilian non-combatants. The Israeli state was ushered in and made possible by the intial displacement of the majority of Mandate Palestine's Arab population during 1947-1949 (on these events, see Ilan Pappe's book based in large part on official Israeli archival sourceshttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ethnic_Cleansing_of_Palestine). It behooves us to remember that about two- thirds of Gaza's population are themselves refugees from Madate Palestine or the offspring of those refugees. No disconinuities there either. Regards, Salem From: Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:23 PM To: Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> Cc: Veenker, Vicki <Vicki.Veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lythcott-Haims, Julie <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Keith Reckdahl <reckdahl@yahoo.com>; Ed Lauing <elauing@equitysearchpartners.com>; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23 <jessica@speiser.net>; Lori Meyers <meyers.lk@gmail.com>; Sheree Roth <ssroth29@gmail.com>; Henry Etzkowitz <H.Etzko@gmail.com>; Binder, Andrew <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mark Turner <mark.turner@morganhill.ca.gov>; CityCouncil <CityCouncil@morganhill.ca.gov>; Michelle Bigelow <Michelle.Bigelow@morganhill.ca.gov>; Josh Becker <becker.josh@gmail.com>; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov<assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <julieforpaloalto@gmail.com>;eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org <eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org>; Doug Minkler <dminkler@dminkler.com>; Gerry Gras <gerrygras@earthlink.net>; EPA Today <epatoday@epatoday.org>; Gennady Sheyner <gsheyner@embarcaderomedia.org>; city.council@menlopark.gov <city.council@menlopark.gov>; dcombs@menlopark.gov <dcombs@menlopark.gov>; Steve Wagstaffe <swagstaffe@smcgov.org>; Jeff Rosen <info@jeffrosen.org>; Jeff Conrad <jeff_conrad@msn.com>; Jeff Hayden <laptoplg@mac.com>; Jay Boyarsky <jboyarsky@dao.sccgov.org>; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto <wilpf.peninsula.paloalto@gmail.com>; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com> <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas <nicholas.enberg@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mickie Winkler <mickie650@gmail.com>; Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com>; Cait James <caitlin.a.james@gmail.com>; San José Spotlight <info@sanjosespotlight.com>; board@pausd.org <board@pausd.org>; boardfeedback@smcgov.org <boardfeedback@smcgov.org>; board@valleywater.org<board@valleywater.org>; BoardOperations <BoardOperations@cob.sccgov.org>; Braden Cartwright <bcartwright@padailypost.com>; Raymond Goins <goinsrayl@gmail.com>; Rodriguez, Miguel <miguel.rodriguez@pdo.sccgov.org>; editor@paweekly.com <editor@paweekly.com>; April Wagner <april.wagner@cityofpaloalto.org>; Don Austin <daustin@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <donnaisanactivist@gmail.com>; Burt, Patrick <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov <Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov>; Palo Alto Free Press <paloaltofreepress@gmail.com>; Seher Awan <firebrand.dr@gmail.com>; Daniel Barton <dbarton@nbo.law>; David Piper <david.piper@wvm.edu>; michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org <michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mila Zelkha <mila.zelkha@gmail.com>; Palo Alto Renters' Association <info@paloaltorenters.org>; Diana Diamond <dianaLdiamond@gmail.com>; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com <jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com>; ladoris cordell <ladoris@judgecordell.com>; cromero@cityofepa.org <cromero@cityofepa.org>; rabrica@cityofepa.org<rabrica@cityofepa.org>; Bill Newell <billnewell2850@gmail.com>; Bill Johnson <bjohnson@paweekly.com>; Bill James <billjames99@gmail.com>; Pat M <p.marshall81@ymail.com>; Carla Torres <xicanamagic@hotmail.com>; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan <mayor@sanjoseca.gov>; CityCouncil <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Council <council@redwoodcity.org>; Zachary.Perron@CityofPaloAlto.org <zachary.perron@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Attorney <CityAttorney@santaclaraca.gov>; citycouncil@mountainview.gov <citycouncil@mountainview.gov>; Clerk, City <city.clerk@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Clerk <CLERK2@redwoodcity.org>; Friends of Cubberley <friendsofcubberley94303@gmail.com>; Lotus Fong <lyfong@pacbell.net>; ParkRec Commission <ParkRec.commission@cityofpaloalto.org>; Liz Gardner <Gardnerjaqua@gmail.com>; Human Relations Commission <hrc@cityofpaloalto.org>; Karen Holman <kcholman@sbcglobal.net>; Liz Kniss <lizkniss@earthlink.net>; Patrice Ventresca <patriceventresca@gmail.com>; Rowena Chiu <rowena.chiu@gmail.com>; Dana St. George <danasg@earthlink.net>; Damon Silver <damon.silver@pdo.sccgov.org>; Daniel Kottke <daniel.k@earthlink.net>; Dennis Upton <kathy8420@qq.com>; Zahra Billoo <zbilloo@cair.com>; james pitkin <jamespitkin777@yahoo.com>; Roberta Ahlquist <roberta.ahlquist@sjsu.edu>; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg <supervisor.ellenberg@bos.sccgov.org>; Supervisor Otto Lee <supervisor.lee@bos.sccgov.org>; Salem Ajluni <ajluni@hotmail.com>; Stump, Molly <molly.stump@cityofpaloalto.org>; Rosen, Jeff <JRosen@dao.sccgov.org>; Baker, Rob <rbaker@dao.sccgov.org>; Ruth Silver Taube <ruthsilvertaube16@gmail.com>; Tom DuBois <tom.dubois@gmail.com>; Blackshire, Geoffrey <Geo.Blackshire@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jasso, Tamara <Tamara.Jasso@cityofpaloalto.org>; DuJuan Green <dujuang@sbcglobal.net>; Dennis Upton <denkafer1@yahoo.com>; dennis burns <dennis.r.burns@gmail.com>; Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org <Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org>; Alex Afanasiev <Alex.Afanasiev@cityofpaloalto.org>; craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org <craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org>; Anna Griffin <griffinam@sbcglobal.net>; Angel, David <dangel@dao.sccgov.org>; Greg Tanaka <greg@gregtanaka.org>; Reifschneider, James <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Bryan Gobin <appeal.bryan.gobin@gmail.com>; Yolanda Conaway <yconaway@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <cats4jazz@gmail.com>; Vara Ramakrishnan <vara@acm.org> Subject: Re: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' Since WWII The bias of the author is evident in the fact that the entire article mentions Hamas only once, in passing. Hamas could end thesuffering tomorrow just by laying down their arms and releasing the hostages. But they care more about scoring propagandapoints against Israel than about saving the lives of their own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 22, 2025, at 3:08 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvationof Gaza Most 'Minutely Designedand Controlled' Since WWII Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' Since WWII | CommonDreamshttps://www.commondreams.org/news/famine-expert-israel-s-starvation-of-gaza-most-minutely-designed-and-controlled-since-wwii From:Martin WassermanTo:Salem Ajluni Cc:Aram James; Veenker, Vicki; Lythcott-Haims, Julie; Reckdahl, Keith; Ed Lauing; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District23; Lori Meyers; Sheree Roth; h.etzko@gmail.com; Binder, Andrew; Mark Turner; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; Josh Becker;assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Julie Lythcott-Haims; Figueroa, Eric; Doug Minkler; Gerry Gras; EPA Today; Gennady Sheyner;city.council@menlopark.gov; dcombs@menlopark.gov; Steve Wagstaffe; Jeff Rosen; Jeff Conrad; Jeff Hayden; Jay Boyarsky; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto;<michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas; Mickie Winkler; Sean Allen; Cait James; San José Spotlight; board@pausd.org; boardfeedback@smcgov.org;board@valleywater.org; BoardOperations; Braden Cartwright; Raymond Goins; Rodriguez, Miguel; editor@paweekly.com; Wagner, April; Don Austin; Donna Wallach;Burt, Patrick; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov; Palo Alto Free Press; Seher Awan; Daniel Barton; David Piper; Foley, Michael; Zelkha, Mila; Palo Alto Renters" Association;Diana Diamond; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com; ladoris cordell; cromero@cityofepa.org; rabrica@cityofepa.org; Bill Newell; Bill Johnson; Bill James; Pat M; Carla Torres;The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; Council, City; GRP-City Council; Perron, Zachary; City Attorney; citycouncil@mountainview.gov; Clerk, City; GRP-City Clerk; Friends ofCubberley; Lotus Fong; ParkRec Commission; Gardener, Liz; Human Relations Commission; Holman, Karen (external); Liz Kniss; Patrice Ventresca; Rowena Chiu; DanaSt. George; Damon Silver; Daniel Kottke; Dennis Upton; Zahra Billoo; james pitkin; Roberta Ahlquist; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Supervisor Otto Lee; Stump, Molly;Rosen, Jeff; Baker, Rob; Ruth Silver Taube; Tom DuBois; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Jasso, Tamara; DuJuan Green; Dennis Upton; dennis burns; Jensen, Eric; Afanasiev,Alex; Lee, Craig; Anna Griffin; Angel, David; Greg Tanaka; Reifschneider, James; Bryan Gobin; Yolanda Conaway; Donna Wallach; Vara Ramakrishnan Subject:Re: Famine Expert: Israel"s Starvation of Gaza Most "Minutely Designed and Controlled" Since WWIIDate:Monday, July 28, 2025 2:21:08 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments andclicking on links. This is utter nonsense. If Israel's modus operandi has always been "maximal violence and aggression with little to noregard for the sanctity of lives of civilian non-combatants,” why did they sign the 1993 Oslo Accord which broughtYasser Arafat and the PLO out of exile and gave them sovereignty of Arab areas in Judea and Samaria? And why didthey forcibly evacuate all Jewish settlements in Gaza in 2005 instead of strengthening those settlements and diggingin? The reality is, it was always the Arab leadership that sought to exterminate the Jews, giving the Jews no choice but to fight back. When Israel goes to war, it goes to great lengths to avoid civilian casualties, but groups like Hamas go out of their way to target Israeli civilians, and the Palestinian Authority gives large cash rewards to any Arab who murders anyJew, whether civilian or otherwise. Right now, people in Gaza are starving, not because of Israel, but because Hamas refuses to lay down its arms andrelease the hostages. The conflict would be over tomorrow if Hamas would do these simple things. In fact, Hamastries forcibly, often with gunfire, to prevent Gazans from receiving life-giving aid that doesn't come through them,saying that receiving such aid amounts to "collaborating with the enemy.” The truth is, Israel has displayed more concern for the lives of Gazan civilians than the Gazans’ own leaders have.Perhaps the reason for this is that Israeli culture is based on reverence for life, while Hamas culture defines itself as revering death, and seeking martyrdom in battle as the highest possible goal. Martin Wasserman On Jul 24, 2025, at 2:45 PM, Salem Ajluni <ajluni@hotmail.com> wrote: As a modest contribution to a better understanding of the thinking and practices of the Israeli state, past and present, I recommend a very useful and short book that I read more than 40 years ago. It was written by Livia Rokach, the daughter of Israel Rokach who was the Israeli Interior Minister in the government of Moshe Sharett, the latter being the second prime minister of the new state (1953-1955). She translated and published her father's diaries, as well as parts of Sharett's diaries, both of which give us insights into the private elite thinking, planning and actions of main actors in the Israeli state vis-a-vis its neighboring countries in the 1950s (and vis-s-vis the U.S. and European powers) (see https://ia804501.us.archive.org/17/items/sacred-terrorism/Sacred-Terrorism.pdf). The resonance and parallels between Israeli leadership thinking and actions in the 1950s (as explained by Rokach) and in the 21st century with regard to the states and peoples of Lebanon, Syria, the West Bank, Gaza and Egypt (and, by extension, Iraq, Yemen and Iran) are instructive. There are considerable continuities across time and space: aggressive and domineering (supremicist?) thinking and behavior; an expansionist impulse; a sociopathic and homicidal (genocidal?) animus towards Arabs, especially Palestinians. It was all there in the 1940s and 1950s, as Rokach tells us, and it's all there now, as we witness on a daily basis. Israel certainly didn't need Hamas to induce such thinking and behavior. In fact, the Hamas movement wasn't formally inaugurated until late 1987, almost two generations after the establishment of the state of Israel. Reading historical accounts of the conflict teaches us that only the bugaboo changes (e.g. Nasser, the PLO, Saddam Hussein, Hizballah, Hamas, the Houthis, Iran, etc.)—the Israeli modus operandi is more or less a constant--maximal violence and aggression with little to no regard for the sanctity of the lives of civilian non- combatants. The Israeli state was ushered in and made possible by the intial displacement of the majority of Mandate Palestine's Arab population during 1947-1949 (on these events, see Ilan Pappe's book based in large part on official Israeli archival sourceshttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ethnic_Cleansing_of_Palestine). It behooves us to remember that about two-thirds of Gaza's population are themselves refugees from Madate Palestine or the offspring of those refugees. No disconinuities there either. Regards, Salem From: Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:23 PM To: Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> Cc: Veenker, Vicki <Vicki.Veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lythcott-Haims, Julie <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Keith Reckdahl <reckdahl@yahoo.com>; Ed Lauing <elauing@equitysearchpartners.com>; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23 <jessica@speiser.net>; Lori Meyers <meyers.lk@gmail.com>; Sheree Roth <ssroth29@gmail.com>; Henry Etzkowitz <H.Etzko@gmail.com>; Binder, Andrew <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mark Turner <mark.turner@morganhill.ca.gov>; CityCouncil <CityCouncil@morganhill.ca.gov>; Michelle Bigelow <Michelle.Bigelow@morganhill.ca.gov>; Josh Becker <becker.josh@gmail.com>; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov<assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <julieforpaloalto@gmail.com>;eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org <eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org>; Doug Minkler <dminkler@dminkler.com>; Gerry Gras <gerrygras@earthlink.net>; EPA Today <epatoday@epatoday.org>; Gennady Sheyner <gsheyner@embarcaderomedia.org>; city.council@menlopark.gov <city.council@menlopark.gov>; dcombs@menlopark.gov <dcombs@menlopark.gov>; Steve Wagstaffe <swagstaffe@smcgov.org>; Jeff Rosen <info@jeffrosen.org>; Jeff Conrad <jeff_conrad@msn.com>; Jeff Hayden <laptoplg@mac.com>; Jay Boyarsky <jboyarsky@dao.sccgov.org>; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto <wilpf.peninsula.paloalto@gmail.com>; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com> <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas <nicholas.enberg@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mickie Winkler <mickie650@gmail.com>; Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com>; Cait James <caitlin.a.james@gmail.com>; San José Spotlight <info@sanjosespotlight.com>; board@pausd.org <board@pausd.org>; boardfeedback@smcgov.org <boardfeedback@smcgov.org>; board@valleywater.org<board@valleywater.org>; BoardOperations <BoardOperations@cob.sccgov.org>; Braden Cartwright <bcartwright@padailypost.com>; Raymond Goins <goinsrayl@gmail.com>; Rodriguez, Miguel <miguel.rodriguez@pdo.sccgov.org>; editor@paweekly.com <editor@paweekly.com>; April Wagner <april.wagner@cityofpaloalto.org>; Don Austin <daustin@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <donnaisanactivist@gmail.com>; Burt, Patrick <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov <Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov>; Palo Alto Free Press <paloaltofreepress@gmail.com>; Seher Awan <firebrand.dr@gmail.com>; Daniel Barton <dbarton@nbo.law>; David Piper <david.piper@wvm.edu>; michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org <michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mila Zelkha <mila.zelkha@gmail.com>; Palo Alto Renters' Association <info@paloaltorenters.org>; Diana Diamond <dianaLdiamond@gmail.com>; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com <jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com>; ladoris cordell <ladoris@judgecordell.com>; cromero@cityofepa.org <cromero@cityofepa.org>; rabrica@cityofepa.org<rabrica@cityofepa.org>; Bill Newell <billnewell2850@gmail.com>; Bill Johnson <bjohnson@paweekly.com>; Bill James <billjames99@gmail.com>; Pat M <p.marshall81@ymail.com>; Carla Torres <xicanamagic@hotmail.com>; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan <mayor@sanjoseca.gov>; CityCouncil <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Council <council@redwoodcity.org>; Zachary.Perron@CityofPaloAlto.org <zachary.perron@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Attorney <CityAttorney@santaclaraca.gov>; citycouncil@mountainview.gov <citycouncil@mountainview.gov>; Clerk, City <city.clerk@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Clerk <CLERK2@redwoodcity.org>; Friends of Cubberley <friendsofcubberley94303@gmail.com>; Lotus Fong <lyfong@pacbell.net>; ParkRec Commission <ParkRec.commission@cityofpaloalto.org>; Liz Gardner <Gardnerjaqua@gmail.com>; Human Relations Commission <hrc@cityofpaloalto.org>; Karen Holman <kcholman@sbcglobal.net>; Liz Kniss <lizkniss@earthlink.net>; Patrice Ventresca <patriceventresca@gmail.com>; Rowena Chiu <rowena.chiu@gmail.com>; Dana St. George <danasg@earthlink.net>; Damon Silver <damon.silver@pdo.sccgov.org>; Daniel Kottke <daniel.k@earthlink.net>; Dennis Upton <kathy8420@qq.com>; Zahra Billoo <zbilloo@cair.com>; james pitkin <jamespitkin777@yahoo.com>; Roberta Ahlquist <roberta.ahlquist@sjsu.edu>; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg <supervisor.ellenberg@bos.sccgov.org>; Supervisor Otto Lee <supervisor.lee@bos.sccgov.org>; Salem Ajluni <ajluni@hotmail.com>; Stump, Molly <molly.stump@cityofpaloalto.org>; Rosen, Jeff <JRosen@dao.sccgov.org>; Baker, Rob <rbaker@dao.sccgov.org>; Ruth Silver Taube <ruthsilvertaube16@gmail.com>; Tom DuBois <tom.dubois@gmail.com>; Blackshire, Geoffrey <Geo.Blackshire@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jasso, Tamara <Tamara.Jasso@cityofpaloalto.org>; DuJuan Green <dujuang@sbcglobal.net>; Dennis Upton <denkafer1@yahoo.com>; dennis burns <dennis.r.burns@gmail.com>; Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org <Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org>; Alex Afanasiev <Alex.Afanasiev@cityofpaloalto.org>; craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org <craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org>; Anna Griffin <griffinam@sbcglobal.net>; Angel, David <dangel@dao.sccgov.org>; Greg Tanaka <greg@gregtanaka.org>; Reifschneider, James <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Bryan Gobin <appeal.bryan.gobin@gmail.com>; Yolanda Conaway <yconaway@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <cats4jazz@gmail.com>; Vara Ramakrishnan <vara@acm.org> Subject: Re: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' Since WWII The bias of the author is evident in the fact that the entire article mentions Hamas only once, in passing. Hamas could end the suffering tomorrow just by laying down their arms and releasing the hostages. But they care more about scoring propaganda points against Israel than about saving the lives of their own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 22, 2025, at 3:08 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvationof Gaza Most 'Minutely Designedand Controlled' Since WWII Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' Since WWII | Common Dreamshttps://www.commondreams.org/news/famine-expert-israel-s-starvation-of-gaza-most-minutely- designed-and-controlled-since-wwii From:Martin WassermanTo:Aram JamesCc:Sean Allen; Salem Ajluni; Veenker, Vicki; Lythcott-Haims, Julie; Reckdahl, Keith; Ed Lauing; jessica@speiser.net; Lori Meyers; Sheree Roth; h.etzko@gmail.com; Binder, Andrew; Mark Turner; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; Josh Becker; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Julie Lythcott-Haims; Figueroa, Eric; Doug Minkler; Gerry Gras; Today EPA; Gennady Sheyner; city.council@menlopark.gov; dcombs@menlopark.gov; Steve Wagstaffe; Jeff Rosen; Jeff Conrad; Jeff Hayden; Jay Boyarsky; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com; Enberg,Nicholas; Mickie Winkler; Cait James; San José Spotlight; board@pausd.org; boardfeedback@smcgov.org; board@valleywater.org; BoardOperations; Braden Cartwright; Raymond Goins; Miguel Rodriguez; editor@paweekly.com; Wagner, April; Don Austin; Donna Wallach; Burt, Patrick; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov; Palo Alto Free Press; Seher Awan; Daniel Barton; David Piper; Foley, Michael; Zelkha, Mila; Renters" Association Palo Alto; Diana Diamond; jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com; ladoris cordell; cromero@cityofepa.org; rabrica@cityofepa.org; Bill Newell; BillJohnson; Bill James; Pat M; Carla Torres; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; Council, City; GRP-City Council; Perron, Zachary; City Attorney; citycouncil@mountainview.gov; Clerk, City; GRP-City Clerk; Friends of Cubberley; Lotus Fong; ParkRec Commission; Gardener, Liz; Human Relations Commission; Holman, Karen (external); Liz Kniss; Patrice Ventresca; Rowena Chiu; Dana St. George; Damon Silver; Daniel Kottke; Dennis Upton; Zahra Billoo; james pitkin; Roberta Ahlquist; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Supervisor Otto Lee; Stump, Molly; Jeff Rosen; Rob Baker; Ruth SilverTaube; Tom DuBois; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Jasso, Tamara; DuJuan Green; Dennis Upton; dennis burns; Jensen, Eric; Afanasiev, Alex; Lee, Craig; Anna Griffin; David Angel; Greg Tanaka; Reifschneider, James; Bryan Gobin; Yolanda Conaway; Donna Wallach; Vara RamakrishnanSubject:Re: Famine Expert: Israel"s Starvation of Gaza Most "Minutely Designed and Controlled" Since WWIIDate:Monday, July 28, 2025 2:20:51 PMAttachments:image1.png CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. Hamas could end the suffering anytime it wants just by laying down its arms and releasing the hostages. But it has no interest in ending the suffering. As part of a culture that defines itself as revering death rather than life, Hamas believes that any Gazan who dies of starvation will go straight to heaven as a martyr, so there's really no problem. And it also serves asgood anti-Israel propaganda. Martin Wasserman On Jul 25, 2025, at 8:26 AM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Why Is the World Letting It Happen?”: U.K. Surgeon, Back from Gaza, on Starving Children | Democracy Now! https://www.democracynow.org/2025/7/25/nick_maynard_gaza On Fri, Jul 25, 2025 at 12:30 AM Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com > wrote: Good evening, Martin, I want to start by expressing my apologies before we delve into today’s discussion. Unfortunately, several major U.S. media outlets have reported perspectives that contradict your position. I find that your argument lacks substantial logic. Given the global perception of the United States as a superior military power, it raises the question of how the people of Gaza, even under Hamas leadership,could pose a significant threat to any country supported by U.S. military resources. The attached photos speak volumes and challenge the validity of your position. Best regards, Sean Sent from my iPhone On Jul 24, 2025, at 6:36 PM, Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote: This is utter nonsense. If Israel's modus operandi has always been "maximal violence and aggression with little to no regard for the sanctity of lives of civilian non-combatants,” why did they sign the 1993 Oslo Accord which brought Yasser Arafat and the PLO out of exile and gave them sovereignty of Arab areas in Judea and Samaria? Andwhy did they forcibly evacuate all Jewish settlements in Gaza in 2005 instead of strengthening those settlements and digging in? The reality is, it was always the Arab leadership that sought to exterminate the Jews, giving the Jews no choice but to fight back. When Israel goes to war, it goes to great lengths to avoid civilian casualties, but groups like Hamas go out of their way to target Israeli civilians, and the Palestinian Authority gives large cash rewards to any Arab who murders any Jew, whether civilian or otherwise. Right now, people in Gaza are starving, not because of Israel, but because Hamas refuses to lay down its arms and release the hostages. The conflict would be over tomorrow if Hamas would do these simple things. In fact, Hamas tries forcibly, often with gunfire, to prevent Gazans from receiving life-giving aid that doesn't come through them,saying that receiving such aid amounts to "collaborating with the enemy.” The truth is, Israel has displayed more concern for the lives of Gazan civilians than the Gazans’ own leaders have. Perhaps the reason for this is that Israeli culture is based on reverence for life, while Hamas culture defines itself as revering death, and seeking martyrdom in battle as the highest possible goal. Martin Wasserman On Jul 24, 2025, at 2:45 PM, Salem Ajluni <ajluni@hotmail.com> wrote: As a modest contribution to a better understanding of the thinking and practices of the Israeli state, past and present, I recommend a very useful and short book that I read more than 40 years ago. It was written by Livia Rokach, the daughter of Israel Rokach who was the Israeli Interior Minister in the government of Moshe Sharett, the latter being the second prime minister of the new state (1953-1955). She translated and published her father's diaries, as well as parts of Sharett's diaries, both of which give us insights into the private elite thinking, planning and actions of main actors in the Israeli state vis-a-vis its neighboring countries in the 1950s (and vis-s-vis the U.S. and European powers) (see https://ia804501.us.archive.org/17/items/sacred-terrorism/Sacred-Terrorism.pdf). The resonance and parallels between Israeli leadership thinking and actions in the 1950s (as explained by Rokach) and in the 21st century with regard to the states and peoples of Lebanon, Syria, the West Bank, Gaza and Egypt (and, by extension, Iraq, Yemen and Iran) are instructive. There are considerable continuities across time and space: aggressive and domineering (supremicist?) thinking and behavior; an expansionist impulse; a sociopathic and homicidal (genocidal?) animus towards Arabs, especially Palestinians. It was all there in the 1940s and 1950s, as Rokach tells us, and it's all there now, as we witness on a daily basis. Israel certainly didn't need Hamas to induce such thinking and behavior. In fact, the Hamas movement wasn't formally inaugurated until late 1987, almost two generations after the establishment of the state of Israel. Reading historical accounts of the conflict teaches us that only thebugaboo changes (e.g. Nasser, the PLO, Saddam Hussein, Hizballah, Hamas, the Houthis, Iran, etc.)—the Israeli modus operandi is more or less a constant--maximal violence and aggression with little to no regard for the sanctity of the lives of civilian non-combatants. The Israeli state was ushered in and made possible by the intial displacement of the majority of Mandate Palestine's Arab population during 1947-1949 (on these events, see Ilan Pappe's book based in large part on official Israeli archivalsourceshttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ethnic_Cleansing_of_Palestine). It behooves us to remember that about two-thirds of Gaza's population are themselves refugees from Madate Palestine or the offspring of those refugees. No disconinuities there either. Regards, Salem From: Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:23 PMTo: Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com>Cc: Veenker, Vicki <Vicki.Veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lythcott-Haims, Julie <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Keith Reckdahl <reckdahl@yahoo.com>; Ed Lauing <elauing@equitysearchpartners.com>; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23 <jessica@speiser.net>; Lori Meyers <meyers.lk@gmail.com>; Sheree Roth<ssroth29@gmail.com>; Henry Etzkowitz <H.Etzko@gmail.com>; Binder, Andrew <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mark Turner <mark.turner@morganhill.ca.gov>; CityCouncil <CityCouncil@morganhill.ca.gov>; Michelle Bigelow <Michelle.Bigelow@morganhill.ca.gov>; Josh Becker <becker.josh@gmail.com>;assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov<assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <julieforpaloalto@gmail.com>;eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org <eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org>; Doug Minkler <dminkler@dminkler.com>; Gerry Gras <gerrygras@earthlink.net>; EPA Today <epatoday@epatoday.org>; Gennady Sheyner <gsheyner@embarcaderomedia.org>;city.council@menlopark.gov <city.council@menlopark.gov>; dcombs@menlopark.gov <dcombs@menlopark.gov>; Steve Wagstaffe <swagstaffe@smcgov.org>; Jeff Rosen <info@jeffrosen.org>; Jeff Conrad <jeff_conrad@msn.com>; Jeff Hayden <laptoplg@mac.com>; Jay Boyarsky <jboyarsky@dao.sccgov.org>; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto <wilpf.peninsula.paloalto@gmail.com>;<michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com> <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas <nicholas.enberg@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mickie Winkler <mickie650@gmail.com>; Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com>; Cait James <caitlin.a.james@gmail.com>; San José Spotlight <info@sanjosespotlight.com>; board@pausd.org <board@pausd.org>; boardfeedback@smcgov.org<boardfeedback@smcgov.org>; board@valleywater.org<board@valleywater.org>; BoardOperations <BoardOperations@cob.sccgov.org>; Braden Cartwright <bcartwright@padailypost.com>; Raymond Goins <goinsrayl@gmail.com>; Rodriguez, Miguel <miguel.rodriguez@pdo.sccgov.org>; editor@paweekly.com <editor@paweekly.com>; April Wagner <april.wagner@cityofpaloalto.org>; DonAustin <daustin@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <donnaisanactivist@gmail.com>; Burt, Patrick <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov <Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov>; Palo Alto Free Press <paloaltofreepress@gmail.com>; Seher Awan <firebrand.dr@gmail.com>; Daniel Barton <dbarton@nbo.law>; David Piper <david.piper@wvm.edu>; michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org<michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mila Zelkha <mila.zelkha@gmail.com>; Palo Alto Renters' Association <info@paloaltorenters.org>; Diana Diamond <dianaLdiamond@gmail.com>; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com <jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com>; ladoris cordell <ladoris@judgecordell.com>; cromero@cityofepa.org <cromero@cityofepa.org>; rabrica@cityofepa.org<rabrica@cityofepa.org>;Bill Newell <billnewell2850@gmail.com>; Bill Johnson <bjohnson@paweekly.com>; Bill James <billjames99@gmail.com>; Pat M <p.marshall81@ymail.com>; Carla Torres <xicanamagic@hotmail.com>; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan <mayor@sanjoseca.gov>; CityCouncil <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Council <council@redwoodcity.org>; Zachary.Perron@CityofPaloAlto.org<zachary.perron@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Attorney <CityAttorney@santaclaraca.gov>; citycouncil@mountainview.gov <citycouncil@mountainview.gov>; Clerk, City <city.clerk@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Clerk <CLERK2@redwoodcity.org>; Friends of Cubberley <friendsofcubberley94303@gmail.com>; Lotus Fong <lyfong@pacbell.net>; ParkRec Commission<ParkRec.commission@cityofpaloalto.org>; Liz Gardner <Gardnerjaqua@gmail.com>; Human Relations Commission <hrc@cityofpaloalto.org>; Karen Holman <kcholman@sbcglobal.net>; Liz Kniss <lizkniss@earthlink.net>; Patrice Ventresca <patriceventresca@gmail.com>; Rowena Chiu <rowena.chiu@gmail.com>; Dana St. George <danasg@earthlink.net>; Damon Silver<damon.silver@pdo.sccgov.org>; Daniel Kottke <daniel.k@earthlink.net>; Dennis Upton <kathy8420@qq.com>; Zahra Billoo <zbilloo@cair.com>; james pitkin <jamespitkin777@yahoo.com>; Roberta Ahlquist <roberta.ahlquist@sjsu.edu>; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg <supervisor.ellenberg@bos.sccgov.org>; Supervisor Otto Lee <supervisor.lee@bos.sccgov.org>; Salem Ajluni <ajluni@hotmail.com>;Stump, Molly <molly.stump@cityofpaloalto.org>; Rosen, Jeff <JRosen@dao.sccgov.org>; Baker, Rob <rbaker@dao.sccgov.org>; Ruth Silver Taube <ruthsilvertaube16@gmail.com>; Tom DuBois <tom.dubois@gmail.com>; Blackshire, Geoffrey <Geo.Blackshire@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jasso, Tamara <Tamara.Jasso@cityofpaloalto.org>; DuJuan Green <dujuang@sbcglobal.net>; Dennis Upton<denkafer1@yahoo.com>; dennis burns <dennis.r.burns@gmail.com>; Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org <Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org>; Alex Afanasiev <Alex.Afanasiev@cityofpaloalto.org>; craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org <craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org>; Anna Griffin <griffinam@sbcglobal.net>; Angel, David <dangel@dao.sccgov.org>; Greg Tanaka <greg@gregtanaka.org>; Reifschneider, James<james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Bryan Gobin <appeal.bryan.gobin@gmail.com>; Yolanda Conaway <yconaway@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <cats4jazz@gmail.com>; Vara Ramakrishnan <vara@acm.org>Subject: Re: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' Since WWII The bias of the author is evident in the fact that the entire article mentions Hamas only once, in passing. Hamas could end the suffering tomorrow just by laying down their arms and releasing the hostages. But they care more about scoring propaganda points against Israel than about saving the lives oftheir own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 22, 2025, at 3:08 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvationof Gaza Most 'Minutely Designedand Controlled' Since WWII Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' Since WWII | Common Dreamshttps://www.commondreams.org/news/famine-expert-israel-s-starvation-of-gaza-most-minutely-designed-and-controlled-since-wwii From:Donna WallachTo:Martin Wasserman Cc:Salem Ajluni; Aram James; Veenker, Vicki; Lythcott-Haims, Julie; Reckdahl, Keith; Ed Lauing; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23; Lori Meyers; Sheree Roth; h.etzko@gmail.com;Binder, Andrew; Mark Turner; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; Josh Becker; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Julie Lythcott-Haims; Figueroa, Eric; Doug Minkler; Gerry Gras; EPA Today; Gennady Sheyner;city.council@menlopark.gov; dcombs@menlopark.gov; Steve Wagstaffe; Jeff Rosen; Jeff Conrad; Jeff Hayden; Jay Boyarsky; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas; Mickie Winkler; Sean Allen;Cait James; San José Spotlight; board@pausd.org; boardfeedback@smcgov.org; board@valleywater.org; BoardOperations; Braden Cartwright; Raymond Goins; Rodriguez, Miguel; editor@paweekly.com; Wagner, April; Don Austin;Donna Wallach; Burt, Patrick; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov; Palo Alto Free Press; Seher Awan; Daniel Barton; David Piper; Foley, Michael; Zelkha, Mila; Palo Alto Renters" Association; Diana Diamond; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com;ladoris cordell; cromero@cityofepa.org; rabrica@cityofepa.org; Bill Newell; Bill Johnson; Bill James; Pat M; Carla Torres; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; Council, City; GRP-City Council; Perron, Zachary; City Attorney;citycouncil@mountainview.gov; Clerk, City; GRP-City Clerk; Friends of Cubberley; Lotus Fong; ParkRec Commission; Gardener, Liz; Human Relations Commission; Holman, Karen (external); Liz Kniss; Patrice Ventresca; Rowena Chiu;Dana St. George; Damon Silver; Daniel Kottke; Dennis Upton; Zahra Billoo; james pitkin; Roberta Ahlquist; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Supervisor Otto Lee; Stump, Molly; Rosen, Jeff; Baker, Rob; Ruth Silver Taube; Tom DuBois;Blackshire, Geoffrey; Jasso, Tamara; DuJuan Green; Dennis Upton; dennis burns; Jensen, Eric; Afanasiev, Alex; Lee, Craig; Anna Griffin; Angel, David; Greg Tanaka; Reifschneider, James; Bryan Gobin; Yolanda Conaway; VaraRamakrishnan Subject:Re: Famine Expert: Israel"s Starvation of Gaza Most "Minutely Designed and Controlled" Since WWIIDate:Monday, July 28, 2025 2:20:09 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. i When I lived in Occupied Palestine aka Israel for 15 years, 1981 - 1997, I saw and experienced the outright racism of the Israeli State towards the Palestinians.Even the Palestinian villages and towns and cities inside Israel had it much worse than Jewish Israeli cities, towns, kibbiutzes and moshavs. The funding forschools in Palestinian schools was much lower than even the schools for Jewish students in the Development Towns. Almost all cities and towns and allkibbutzes and moshavs are segregated. Only a few cities inside the Israeli State have Jews and Palestinians living in the same city, like Ramle, Yaffa, Akko andJerusalem, but they are still segregated within the cities, they don't live next to each other. But much worse is the way soldiers treat Palestinians. I think it was in the late 1980s maybe the early or mid 1990s Gideon Levy wrote an article in theHa'aretz weekend paper of the dozens of Palestinian children who had been shot in the head while sitting in their classrooms in Gaza, some of them dying,some of them losing their eyes. During the years of the first Intifada, around 1987 I think, the Israeli govt. shut down Bir Zeit University in the West Bank, and also closed many schoolsthroughout Gaza. So the Palestinians had to open community schools. Israel practices their Apartheid policies on its own Jewish citizens. Jews who were forced to immigrate to Israel from Arab countries were sent to DevelopmentTowns, not to the big cities. There were meager job opportunities in the Development Towns and the funding for the schools was very low, so those studentsdidn't get as good an education as students who were of European descent. On the radio we only heard accents of Jewish Israelis who spoke with an Ashkenaziaccent, none who spoke with an accent of someone who's native tongue was Arabic and at least half of all Jewish Israelis are Arabs, i.e. they come from Iraq,Morocco, Tunisia, Algeria, Yemen, etc. There were horrendous racist jokes about Moroccan Jews and of course even worse jokes about Palestinians. Most Jewish Israelis and the entire Israeli govt. cares nothing about the well being of the Palestinians. I have seen so much during the time I lived there, againwhen I visited in 2002 and again when I lived in Gaza in 2008 for 4 months. In 2002 there was a month siege on the entire city of Ramallah. 24 hours a day forweeks, nobody could leave their house, not for food, not for medicine, not to go to work, not to go to school. Many Palestinians were shot and maimed orkilled just for standing outside on the rooftops to their homes or even standing next to an open window in their own home. Also, people would go out to try tobuy pita, and the Israeli soldiers driving around would shoot them dead, The israeli soldiers used their tanks and other heavy armored vehicles to drive over thevehicles of the Palestinians, destroying the vehicles. Also the Israeli soldiers went into govt offices, destroying and/or stealing computers, hard drives, videocameras, paper files of the file cabinets. The soldiers defacated and urinated in the offices and the homes of Palestinians. The Israeli soldiers stole money andother properties of Palstinians whose homes they invaded. Banks were broken into and the entire infrastructure was destroyed. The Israeli soldiers went intooffice buildings and either destroyed or stole everything in the stores. They broke into the office of a NeoNatal Doctor and destroyed his office, broke down hisdoor. They also refused to let him go to his clients, women who were giving birth. During that time the maternity hospital near Bethlehem was bombed. When I lived in Gaza in 2008, I witnessed how the siege on Gaza, 2 years after it started, already had a severe impact on the entire population of Gaza. Manybuildings stood unfinished. Israel refused to allow the building supplies in so that the doors, windows, etc could be installed into the buildings. Many peoplewere unemployed because of the lack of supplies and the suppressed economy. Already then at least 20% if not more of the children were malnourished. TheIsraeli Navy was severely limiting how far Palestinians fishers could go out into their internationally recognized waters to fish and have a livelihood andprovide a good source of protein for the Palestinians living in Gaza. Some of us International volunteers went out with the fishers on their boats and witnessedthe Israeli Navy come and shoot at their boats and their nets and equipment, preventing them from having a good catch of fish and also denying them theirright to fish in their own waters. The Israeli Navy also used high powered hoses to spray water onto the boats, damaging the boats and injuring people. Thenthey started using stinky water in their high powered hoses, spraying the stinky water after a catch of fish was cast onto the boat, destroying the catch of theday. In previous years the Israeli army had invaded the Beit Hanoun area in northern Gaza and decimated the fruit groves, so all the trees that used to be there weregone. I witnessed humongous Israeli bulldozers come in through the Apartheid Wall through a gate and dig up agricultural land. The ongoing genocide and the starvation is beyond despicable and you Martin have totally lost any sense of humanity that you could claim that the Palestiniansare responsible for this. The Palestinian people are one of the most kindest, generous, loving people on this planet! I saw Hamas providing tents to Palestiniansin Gaza in the 1980s when the Israeli soldiers were stationed there and were destroying many Palestinian homes. Hamas also provided supplies for the familieswho needed supplies. Hamas also provided kindergartens for the children. Hamas means Islamic Resistance Movement and according to International Law,occupied people have the right to rebel against their occupiers! Israeli soldiers and settlers are constantly invading Palestinian lands! If you really want to know how Israel treated the Palestinians prior to 1948 and from 1948 onwards read these books:"State of Terror: How Terrorism Created Modern Israel" by Thomas Suarezhttp://thomassuarez.com/SoT.html "The Hundred Years War on Palestine"by Rashid Khalidi "The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine"by Illan Pappe Donna Wallach This message needs your attentionThis is a personal email address.This is their first email to your company. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast On Thu, Jul 24, 2025 at 6:36 PM Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:This is utter nonsense. If Israel's modus operandi has always been "maximal violence and aggression with little to no regard for the sanctity of lives ofcivilian non-combatants,” why did they sign the 1993 Oslo Accord which brought Yasser Arafat and the PLO out of exile and gave them sovereignty of Arabareas in Judea and Samaria? And why did they forcibly evacuate all Jewish settlements in Gaza in 2005 instead of strengthening those settlements anddigging in? The reality is, it was always the Arab leadership that sought to exterminate the Jews, giving the Jews no choice but to fight back. When Israel goes to war, it goes to great lengths to avoid civilian casualties, but groups like Hamas go out of their way to target Israeli civilians, and thePalestinian Authority gives large cash rewards to any Arab who murders any Jew, whether civilian or otherwise. Right now, people in Gaza are starving, not because of Israel, but because Hamas refuses to lay down its arms and release the hostages. The conflict wouldbe over tomorrow if Hamas would do these simple things. In fact, Hamas tries forcibly, often with gunfire, to prevent Gazans from receiving life-giving aidthat doesn't come through them, saying that receiving such aid amounts to "collaborating with the enemy.” The truth is, Israel has displayed more concern for the lives of Gazan civilians than the Gazans’ own leaders have. Perhaps the reason for this is that Israeliculture is based on reverence for life, while Hamas culture defines itself as revering death, and seeking martyrdom in battle as the highest possible goal. Martin Wasserman On Jul 24, 2025, at 2:45 PM, Salem Ajluni <ajluni@hotmail.com> wrote: As a modest contribution to a better understanding of the thinking and practices of the Israeli state, past and present, I recommend a very useful and short book that I read more than 40 years ago. It was written by Livia Rokach, the daughter of Israel Rokach who was the Israeli Interior Minister in the government of Moshe Sharett, the latter being the second prime minister of the new state (1953-1955). She translated and published her father's diaries, as well as parts of Sharett's diaries, both of which give us insights into the private elite thinking, planning and actions of main actors in the Israeli state vis-a-vis its neighboring countries in the 1950s (and vis-s-vis the U.S. and European powers) (see https://ia804501.us.archive.org/17/items/sacred-terrorism/Sacred-Terrorism.pdf). The resonance and parallels between Israeli leadership thinking and actions in the 1950s (as explained by Rokach) and in the 21st century with regard to the states and peoples of Lebanon, Syria, the West Bank, Gaza and Egypt (and, by extension, Iraq, Yemen and Iran) are instructive. There are considerable continuities across time and space: aggressive and domineering (supremicist?) thinking and behavior; an expansionist impulse; a sociopathic and homicidal (genocidal?) animus towards Arabs, especially Palestinians. It was all there in the 1940s and 1950s, as Rokach tells us, and it's all there now, as we witness on a daily basis. Israel certainly didn't need Hamas to induce such thinking and behavior. In fact, the Hamas movement wasn't formally inaugurated until late 1987, almost two generations after the establishment of the state of Israel. Reading historical accounts of the conflict teaches us that only the bugaboo changes (e.g. Nasser, the PLO, Saddam Hussein, Hizballah, Hamas, the Houthis, Iran, etc.)—the Israeli modus operandi is more or less a constant--maximal violence and aggression with little to no regard for the sanctity of the lives of civilian non-combatants. The Israeli state was ushered in and made possible by the intial displacement of the majority of Mandate Palestine's Arab population during 1947-1949 (on these events, see Ilan Pappe's book based in large part on official Israeli archival sourceshttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ethnic_Cleansing_of_Palestine). It behooves us to remember that about two- thirds of Gaza's population are themselves refugees from Madate Palestine or the offspring of those refugees. No disconinuities there either. Regards, Salem From: Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:23 PM To: Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> Cc: Veenker, Vicki <Vicki.Veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lythcott-Haims, Julie <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Keith Reckdahl <reckdahl@yahoo.com>; Ed Lauing <elauing@equitysearchpartners.com>; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23 <jessica@speiser.net>; Lori Meyers <meyers.lk@gmail.com>; Sheree Roth <ssroth29@gmail.com>; Henry Etzkowitz <H.Etzko@gmail.com>; Binder, Andrew <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mark Turner <mark.turner@morganhill.ca.gov>; CityCouncil <CityCouncil@morganhill.ca.gov>; Michelle Bigelow <Michelle.Bigelow@morganhill.ca.gov>; Josh Becker <becker.josh@gmail.com>; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov<assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <julieforpaloalto@gmail.com>;eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org <eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org>; Doug Minkler <dminkler@dminkler.com>; Gerry Gras <gerrygras@earthlink.net>; EPA Today <epatoday@epatoday.org>; Gennady Sheyner <gsheyner@embarcaderomedia.org>; city.council@menlopark.gov <city.council@menlopark.gov>; dcombs@menlopark.gov <dcombs@menlopark.gov>; Steve Wagstaffe <swagstaffe@smcgov.org>; Jeff Rosen <info@jeffrosen.org>; Jeff Conrad <jeff_conrad@msn.com>; Jeff Hayden <laptoplg@mac.com>; Jay Boyarsky <jboyarsky@dao.sccgov.org>; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto <wilpf.peninsula.paloalto@gmail.com>; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com> <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas <nicholas.enberg@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mickie Winkler <mickie650@gmail.com>; Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com>; Cait James <caitlin.a.james@gmail.com>; San José Spotlight <info@sanjosespotlight.com>; board@pausd.org <board@pausd.org>; boardfeedback@smcgov.org <boardfeedback@smcgov.org>; board@valleywater.org<board@valleywater.org>; BoardOperations <BoardOperations@cob.sccgov.org>; Braden Cartwright <bcartwright@padailypost.com>; Raymond Goins <goinsrayl@gmail.com>; Rodriguez, Miguel <miguel.rodriguez@pdo.sccgov.org>; editor@paweekly.com <editor@paweekly.com>; April Wagner <april.wagner@cityofpaloalto.org>; Don Austin <daustin@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <donnaisanactivist@gmail.com>; Burt, Patrick <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov <Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov>; Palo Alto Free Press <paloaltofreepress@gmail.com>; Seher Awan <firebrand.dr@gmail.com>; Daniel Barton <dbarton@nbo.law>; David Piper <david.piper@wvm.edu>; michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org <michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mila Zelkha <mila.zelkha@gmail.com>; Palo Alto Renters' Association <info@paloaltorenters.org>; Diana Diamond <dianaLdiamond@gmail.com>; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com <jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com>; ladoris cordell <ladoris@judgecordell.com>; cromero@cityofepa.org <cromero@cityofepa.org>; rabrica@cityofepa.org<rabrica@cityofepa.org>; Bill Newell <billnewell2850@gmail.com>; Bill Johnson <bjohnson@paweekly.com>; Bill James <billjames99@gmail.com>; Pat M <p.marshall81@ymail.com>; Carla Torres <xicanamagic@hotmail.com>; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan <mayor@sanjoseca.gov>; CityCouncil <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Council <council@redwoodcity.org>; Zachary.Perron@CityofPaloAlto.org <zachary.perron@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Attorney <CityAttorney@santaclaraca.gov>; citycouncil@mountainview.gov <citycouncil@mountainview.gov>; Clerk, City <city.clerk@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Clerk <CLERK2@redwoodcity.org>; Friends of Cubberley <friendsofcubberley94303@gmail.com>; Lotus Fong <lyfong@pacbell.net>; ParkRec Commission <ParkRec.commission@cityofpaloalto.org>; Liz Gardner <Gardnerjaqua@gmail.com>; Human Relations Commission <hrc@cityofpaloalto.org>; Karen Holman <kcholman@sbcglobal.net>; Liz Kniss <lizkniss@earthlink.net>; Patrice Ventresca <patriceventresca@gmail.com>; Rowena Chiu <rowena.chiu@gmail.com>; Dana St. George <danasg@earthlink.net>; Damon Silver <damon.silver@pdo.sccgov.org>; Daniel Kottke <daniel.k@earthlink.net>; Dennis Upton <kathy8420@qq.com>; Zahra Billoo <zbilloo@cair.com>; james pitkin <jamespitkin777@yahoo.com>; Roberta Ahlquist <roberta.ahlquist@sjsu.edu>; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg <supervisor.ellenberg@bos.sccgov.org>; Supervisor Otto Lee <supervisor.lee@bos.sccgov.org>; Salem Ajluni <ajluni@hotmail.com>; Stump, Molly <molly.stump@cityofpaloalto.org>; Rosen, Jeff <JRosen@dao.sccgov.org>; Baker, Rob <rbaker@dao.sccgov.org>; Ruth Silver Taube <ruthsilvertaube16@gmail.com>; Tom DuBois <tom.dubois@gmail.com>; Blackshire, Geoffrey <Geo.Blackshire@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jasso, Tamara <Tamara.Jasso@cityofpaloalto.org>; DuJuan Green <dujuang@sbcglobal.net>; Dennis Upton <denkafer1@yahoo.com>; dennis burns <dennis.r.burns@gmail.com>; Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org <Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org>; Alex Afanasiev <Alex.Afanasiev@cityofpaloalto.org>; craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org <craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org>; Anna Griffin <griffinam@sbcglobal.net>; Angel, David <dangel@dao.sccgov.org>; Greg Tanaka <greg@gregtanaka.org>; Reifschneider, James <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Bryan Gobin <appeal.bryan.gobin@gmail.com>; Yolanda Conaway <yconaway@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <cats4jazz@gmail.com>; Vara Ramakrishnan <vara@acm.org> Subject: Re: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' Since WWII The bias of the author is evident in the fact that the entire article mentions Hamas only once, in passing. Hamas could end the suffering tomorrow just by laying down their arms and releasing the hostages. But they care more about scoring propaganda points against Israel than about saving the lives of their own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 22, 2025, at 3:08 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvationof Gaza Most 'Minutely Designedand Controlled' Since WWII Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' Since WWII | CommonDreamshttps://www.commondreams.org/news/famine-expert-israel-s-starvation-of-gaza-most-minutely-designed-and-controlled-since-wwii -- Books you must read: "Against Our Better Judgement: The hidden history of how the U.S. was used to create Israel" by Alison Weirhttp://www.againstourbetterjudgment.com/ "State of Terror: How Terrorism Created Modern Israel" by Thomas Suarezhttp://thomassuarez.com/SoT.html "The Hundred Years War on Palestine"by Rashid Khalidi "The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine"by Illan Pappe Other important websites to visithttp://www.ifamericansknew.orghttps://wearenotnumbers.org/https://electronicintifada.net/https://www.palestinechronicle.com End the illegal Blockade/Siege/collective punishment on Gaza!Tear down all the Apartheid Walls in West Bank & Gaza!Tear down all the illegal checkpoints throughout the West Bank!End the illegal War Criminal Settler-Colonial Apartheid Terrorist Israeli Occupation of all of Historic Palestine!Right to Return to their homes and land in Historic Palestine for all Palestinians!End all U.S. aid to IsraelFree Palestine! Long Live Palestine! Support Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions (BDS) & Palestinian Campaign for the Academic and Cultural Boycott of Israel (PACBI) Campaigns!http://www.bdsmovement.nethttp://www.WhoProfits.orghttp://www.pacbi.org Support Solidarity with the Freedom Flotilla - We will sail until Palestine is Free! https://freedomflotilla.org/ Support ISM volunteers in West Bank and Gaza Strip!http://www.palsolidarity.org Donna Wallachcats4jazz@gmail.comSkype: palestinewillbeTwitter: @PalestineWillBe(cell) 408-569-6608 From:Salem Ajluni To:Martin Wasserman; Aram James Cc:Veenker, Vicki; Lythcott-Haims, Julie; Reckdahl, Keith; Ed Lauing; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23; Lori Meyers; Sheree Roth; h.etzko@gmail.com; Binder, Andrew; Mark Turner; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; Josh Becker; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Julie Lythcott-Haims; Figueroa, Eric; Doug Minkler; Gerry Gras; EPA Today; Gennady Sheyner; city.council@menlopark.gov; dcombs@menlopark.gov; Steve Wagstaffe; Jeff Rosen; Jeff Conrad; Jeff Hayden; Jay Boyarsky; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas; Mickie Winkler; Sean Allen; Cait James; San José Spotlight; board@pausd.org; boardfeedback@smcgov.org; board@valleywater.org; BoardOperations; Braden Cartwright; Raymond Goins; Rodriguez, Miguel; editor@paweekly.com; Wagner, April; Don Austin; Donna Wallach; Burt, Patrick; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov; Palo Alto Free Press; Seher Awan; Daniel Barton; David Piper; Foley, Michael; Zelkha, Mila; Palo Alto Renters" Association; Diana Diamond; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com; ladoris cordell; cromero@cityofepa.org; rabrica@cityofepa.org; Bill Newell; Bill Johnson; Bill James; Pat M; Carla Torres; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; Council, City; GRP-City Council; Perron, Zachary; City Attorney; citycouncil@mountainview.gov; Clerk, City; GRP- City Clerk; Friends of Cubberley; Lotus Fong; ParkRec Commission; Gardener, Liz; Human Relations Commission; Holman, Karen (external); Liz Kniss; Patrice Ventresca; Rowena Chiu; Dana St. George; Damon Silver; Daniel Kottke; Dennis Upton; Zahra Billoo; james pitkin; Roberta Ahlquist; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Supervisor Otto Lee; Stump, Molly; Rosen, Jeff; Baker, Rob; Ruth Silver Taube; Tom DuBois; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Jasso, Tamara; DuJuan Green; Dennis Upton; dennis burns; Jensen, Eric; Afanasiev, Alex; Lee, Craig; Anna Griffin; Angel, David; Greg Tanaka; Reifschneider, James; Bryan Gobin; Yolanda Conaway; Donna Wallach; Vara Ramakrishnan Subject:Re: Famine Expert: Israel"s Starvation of Gaza Most "Minutely Designed and Controlled" Since WWII Date:Monday, July 28, 2025 2:20:09 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. i As a modest contribution to a better understanding of the thinking and practices of the Israeli state, past and present, I recommend a very useful and short book that I read more than 40 years ago. It was written by Livia Rokach, the daughter of Israel Rokach who was the Israeli Interior Minister in the government of Moshe Sharett, the latter being the second prime minister of the new state (1953-1955). She translated and published her father's diaries, as well as parts of Sharett's diaries, both of which give us insights into the private elite thinking, planning and actions of main actors in the Israeli state vis-a-vis its neighboring countries in the 1950s (and vis-s-vis the U.S. and European powers) (see https://ia804501.us.archive.org/17/items/sacred-terrorism/Sacred- Terrorism.pdf). This message needs your attention This is a personal email address. This is their first email to your company. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast The resonance and parallels between Israeli leadership thinking and actions in the 1950s (as explained by Rokach) and in the 21st century with regard to the states and peoples of Lebanon, Syria, the West Bank, Gaza and Egypt (and, by extension, Iraq, Yemen and Iran) are instructive. There are considerable continuities across time and space: aggressive and domineering (supremicist?) thinking and behavior; an expansionist impulse; a sociopathic and homicidal (genocidal?) animus towards Arabs, especially Palestinians. It was all there in the 1940s and 1950s, as Rokach tells us, and it's all there now, as we witness on a daily basis. Israel certainly didn't need Hamas to induce such thinking and behavior. In fact, the Hamas movement wasn't formally inaugurated until late 1987, almost two generations after the establishment of the state of Israel. Reading historical accounts of the conflict teaches us that only the bugaboo changes (e.g. Nasser, the PLO, Saddam Hussein, Hizballah, Hamas, the Houthis, Iran, etc.)—the Israeli modus operandi is more or less a constant--maximal violence and aggression with little to no regard for the sanctity of the lives of civilian non-combatants. The Israeli state was ushered in and made possible by the intial displacement of the majority of Mandate Palestine's Arab population during 1947-1949 (on these events, see Ilan Pappe's book based in large part on official Israeli archival sources https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ethnic_Cleansing_of_Palestine). It behooves us to remember that about two-thirds of Gaza's population are themselves refugees from Madate Palestine or the offspring of those refugees. No disconinuities there either. Regards, Salem From: Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:23 PM To: Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> Cc: Veenker, Vicki <Vicki.Veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lythcott-Haims, Julie <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Keith Reckdahl <reckdahl@yahoo.com>; Ed Lauing <elauing@equitysearchpartners.com>; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23 <jessica@speiser.net>; Lori Meyers <meyers.lk@gmail.com>; Sheree Roth <ssroth29@gmail.com>; Henry Etzkowitz <H.Etzko@gmail.com>; Binder, Andrew <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mark Turner <mark.turner@morganhill.ca.gov>; CityCouncil <CityCouncil@morganhill.ca.gov>; Michelle Bigelow <Michelle.Bigelow@morganhill.ca.gov>; Josh Becker <becker.josh@gmail.com>; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov <assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <julieforpaloalto@gmail.com>; eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org <eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org>; Doug Minkler <dminkler@dminkler.com>; Gerry Gras <gerrygras@earthlink.net>; EPA Today <epatoday@epatoday.org>; Gennady Sheyner <gsheyner@embarcaderomedia.org>; city.council@menlopark.gov <city.council@menlopark.gov>; dcombs@menlopark.gov <dcombs@menlopark.gov>; Steve Wagstaffe <swagstaffe@smcgov.org>; Jeff Rosen <info@jeffrosen.org>; Jeff Conrad <jeff_conrad@msn.com>; Jeff Hayden <laptoplg@mac.com>; Jay Boyarsky <jboyarsky@dao.sccgov.org>; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto <wilpf.peninsula.paloalto@gmail.com>; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com> <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas <nicholas.enberg@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mickie Winkler <mickie650@gmail.com>; Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com>; Cait James <caitlin.a.james@gmail.com>; San José Spotlight <info@sanjosespotlight.com>; board@pausd.org <board@pausd.org>; boardfeedback@smcgov.org <boardfeedback@smcgov.org>; board@valleywater.org <board@valleywater.org>; BoardOperations <BoardOperations@cob.sccgov.org>; Braden Cartwright <bcartwright@padailypost.com>; Raymond Goins <goinsrayl@gmail.com>; Rodriguez, Miguel <miguel.rodriguez@pdo.sccgov.org>; editor@paweekly.com <editor@paweekly.com>; April Wagner <april.wagner@cityofpaloalto.org>; Don Austin <daustin@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <donnaisanactivist@gmail.com>; Burt, Patrick <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov <Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov>; Palo Alto Free Press <paloaltofreepress@gmail.com>; Seher Awan <firebrand.dr@gmail.com>; Daniel Barton <dbarton@nbo.law>; David Piper <david.piper@wvm.edu>; michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org <michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mila Zelkha <mila.zelkha@gmail.com>; Palo Alto Renters' Association <info@paloaltorenters.org>; Diana Diamond <dianaLdiamond@gmail.com>; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com <jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com>; ladoris cordell <ladoris@judgecordell.com>; cromero@cityofepa.org <cromero@cityofepa.org>; rabrica@cityofepa.org <rabrica@cityofepa.org>; Bill Newell <billnewell2850@gmail.com>; Bill Johnson <bjohnson@paweekly.com>; Bill James <billjames99@gmail.com>; Pat M <p.marshall81@ymail.com>; Carla Torres <xicanamagic@hotmail.com>; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan <mayor@sanjoseca.gov>; CityCouncil <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Council <council@redwoodcity.org>; Zachary.Perron@CityofPaloAlto.org <zachary.perron@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Attorney <CityAttorney@santaclaraca.gov>; citycouncil@mountainview.gov <citycouncil@mountainview.gov>; Clerk, City <city.clerk@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Clerk <CLERK2@redwoodcity.org>; Friends of Cubberley <friendsofcubberley94303@gmail.com>; Lotus Fong <lyfong@pacbell.net>; ParkRec Commission <ParkRec.commission@cityofpaloalto.org>; Liz Gardner <Gardnerjaqua@gmail.com>; Human Relations Commission <hrc@cityofpaloalto.org>; Karen Holman <kcholman@sbcglobal.net>; Liz Kniss <lizkniss@earthlink.net>; Patrice Ventresca <patriceventresca@gmail.com>; Rowena Chiu <rowena.chiu@gmail.com>; Dana St. George <danasg@earthlink.net>; Damon Silver <damon.silver@pdo.sccgov.org>; Daniel Kottke <daniel.k@earthlink.net>; Dennis Upton <kathy8420@qq.com>; Zahra Billoo <zbilloo@cair.com>; james pitkin <jamespitkin777@yahoo.com>; Roberta Ahlquist <roberta.ahlquist@sjsu.edu>; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg <supervisor.ellenberg@bos.sccgov.org>; Supervisor Otto Lee <supervisor.lee@bos.sccgov.org>; Salem Ajluni <ajluni@hotmail.com>; Stump, Molly <molly.stump@cityofpaloalto.org>; Rosen, Jeff <JRosen@dao.sccgov.org>; Baker, Rob <rbaker@dao.sccgov.org>; Ruth Silver Taube <ruthsilvertaube16@gmail.com>; Tom DuBois <tom.dubois@gmail.com>; Blackshire, Geoffrey <Geo.Blackshire@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jasso, Tamara <Tamara.Jasso@cityofpaloalto.org>; DuJuan Green <dujuang@sbcglobal.net>; Dennis Upton <denkafer1@yahoo.com>; dennis burns <dennis.r.burns@gmail.com>; Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org <Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org>; Alex Afanasiev <Alex.Afanasiev@cityofpaloalto.org>; craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org <craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org>; Anna Griffin <griffinam@sbcglobal.net>; Angel, David <dangel@dao.sccgov.org>; Greg Tanaka <greg@gregtanaka.org>; Reifschneider, James <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Bryan Gobin <appeal.bryan.gobin@gmail.com>; Yolanda Conaway <yconaway@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <cats4jazz@gmail.com>; Vara Ramakrishnan <vara@acm.org> Subject: Re: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' Since WWII The bias of the author is evident in the fact that the entire article mentions Hamas only once, in passing. Hamas could end the suffering tomorrow just by laying down their arms and releasing the hostages. But they care more about scoring propagandapoints against Israel than about saving the lives of their own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 22, 2025, at 3:08 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvationof Gaza Most 'Minutely Designedand Controlled' Since WWII Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed andControlled' Since WWII | Common Dreamshttps://www.commondreams.org/news/famine-expert-israel-s-starvation-of-gaza-most-minutely-designed-and-controlled-since-wwii 1 Bissell, Nicole From:Magdalena Cabrera <magdalenac@gmail.com> Sent:Monday, July 28, 2025 11:06 AM To:Bansal, Megha Cc:Council, City; Andrea Wald; Angela Dellaporta; Claire Elliott; Rebecca Sanders; Joye, Ken; Barry M Katz Subject:Re: This gate blocking mechanism is broken already CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. i This message needs your attention This is a personal email address. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast Good morning Megha, Yes, I saw that. Thank you. The city has not yet painted a crosswalk on Fernando Ave indicating the safest place for pedestrians to cross. We are pretty inundated with folks driving to the park and taking all the parking places away from residents. No one seems to be parking on the Chestnut or Lambert side of the park. JUst FYI. Also, the curb for the handicapped parking space has not been painted blue YET. Why is this project so seemingly uncoordinated? And is the city planning on painting the curb red for "no parking" where the fire hydrant is??? Once there was a fire a few houses up from the park and the firefighters did not even see that hydrant. What's up with that? And there is still no signage about dogs in the playground. Are they allowed or are they not???? What about food and drink in the play area and the dog park? According to all the in depth research my colleagues and I have done, there should be no food or drink anywhere near the artificial turf. There is virtually no warning about high temperatures of the turf on a hot day. The meadow is a disgrace and almost NO ONE uses it. It is very uninviting and not even pretty to look at.. I am sorry but my neighborhood and Palo Alto residents deserve MUCH BETTER than this project. disappointedly, Magdalena Cabrera On Mon, Jul 28, 2025 at 10:11 AM Bansal, Megha <Megha.Bansal@paloalto.gov> wrote: 2 Good morning, Magdalena. This gate locking system was fixed by the City staff a couple of weeks ago. Best regards, Megha Megha Bansal, PE, PMP Senior Engineer, Public Works 250 Hamilton Avenue | Palo Alto, CA 94301 D: 650.329.2693 | E: megha.bansal@paloalto.gov www.paloalto.gov From: Magdalena Cabrera <magdalenac@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, July 2, 2025 5:04 PM To: Bansal, Megha <Megha.Bansal@paloalto.gov> Subject: This gate blocking mechanism is broken already CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. From:City Mgr To:Council, City; Shikada, Ed Cc:Executive Leadership Team; City Mgr; Clerk, City Subject:City Council Bundle - July 28 Date:Monday, July 28, 2025 9:37:17 AM Attachments:image001.pngimage002.pngRE Request for 2-Hour Parking Restrictions on Sheridan Avenue (Adjacent to 2747 Park Blvd.).msgRE Incessant increase in the number of RVs in Palo Alto..msgRe Feedback on Flat Sewer Charges.msg Dear Mayor and Council Members, On behalf of City Manager Ed Shikada, please see the attached staff responses to emails received in the Council inbox through July 28, 2025. Respectfully, Danille Danille RiceAdministrative AssistantCity Manager’s Office|Human Resources|Transportation(650) 329-2229 | danille.rice@PaloAlto.gov www.PaloAlto.gov From:Annette Ross To:City Mgr Cc:Council, City; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Chris Saccheri Subject:Stanford Terrace Inn Date:Sunday, July 27, 2025 11:15:56 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. Can there possibly be an acceptable reason why 531 Stanford Ave, site of the fully deteriorated Stanford TerraceInn, is allowed to remain in its current condition? Not only is it an eyesore, it is a fire hazard, a terrible precedent toset vis-a-vis planning and development for a site, and a breeding ground for rodents, which makes it a communityhealth hazard. And it has been this way for more than a year. Why not at least fully demolish it and clear the land to eliminate the existing hazards? Maybe PAFD could use it for a training exercise. I’d like to see this issue addressed in the City Manager’s report that is recited at every Council meeting until thematter is resolved. This will give the public the opportunity to see what progress is being made to remedy thesituation. It will also provide an opportunity to see how effective (or ineffective) the City’s code enforcementefforts are. I hope the City is at least imposing fines for the property owner’s failure to correct this situation. If not,it makes no sense to me to go after low hanging fruit such as increased permit and parking fees but not impose fineson a property owner who is blatantly neglecting the responsibilities of ownership. Annette RossCollege Terrace From:Aram James To:Reckdahl, Keith; Lauing, Ed; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader forCalifornia Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23; Josh Becker; Gennady Sheyner; Jeff Rosen; Jay Boyarsky;Dave Price; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Veenker, Vicki; Julie Lythcott-Haims; Council, City; board@pausd.org;board@valleywater.org; BoardOperations; Zelkha, Mila; Human Relations Commission; GRP-City Council;city.council@menlopark.gov; citycouncil@nenlopark.org; Binder, Andrew; Mark Turner Subject:In one context, you talk about the creation myth of Israel and how Israelis are unwilling to question what they’re conditioned to believe about the state of Israel. Date:Sunday, July 27, 2025 7:08:00 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. In it, you talk about the use of myth to justify or perpetuate war. In one context, you talk about the creation myth of Israel and how Israelis are unwilling to question what they’re conditioned to believe about the state ofIsrael. Source: The Intercept Starvation as a Weapon: Chris Hedges on Gaza https://share.google/QmqqFEiuHOTTQStYX From:Diane Walker To:Council, City Cc:Diane Walker Subject:4256 El Camino Project Review Date:Sunday, July 27, 2025 6:47:14 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. i Hello: I am concerned about proposed plan for 4256 El Camino because it is totally oversized for thissmall / shallow parcel of land. The Redwoods condominium complex next door is primarily 3 stories height with only 4 set-back units at 4 stories. The plan for new construction is a 6 storydesign with no set-backs to allow light. The proposed height will block sunlight and open sky to PARedwoods residences & endanger the heritage trees on our property. We need morehousing in Palo Alto, but please, let's consider a plan that is scaled to be harmonious with neighborhood. Thank you, Diane Walker 4250 El Camino Real C224, Palo Alto, CA 94306 This message needs your attention This is a personal email address. This is their first email to your company. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast View this email in your browser MARK YOUR CALENDAR! August 1 - Coffee & Cobbler - 9-10:30am, midtown Palo Alto (info below) August 10 - County Book Club: "Factfulness" - 3-5pm, Saratoga Library (info below) From:League of Women Voters of Palo AltoTo:Council, CitySubject:LWVPA July News: Coffee & Cobbler on 8/1, Good Trouble was had by all, and more!Date:Sunday, July 27, 2025 3:33:23 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious ofopening attachments and clicking on links. August 17: Meet your District 16 CongressionalRepresentative! County League speaker event featuring REP. SAM LICCARDO, 2-4pm, at Mitchell Park Community Center (info below) August 26: LWVPA Board retreat and Meeting, PCC Raptor Room, 3:30- 7pm. If you're interested in joining the meeting, please email contact@lwvpaloalto.org and someone will get back to you. September 9: Join us for a very timely conversation with PROFESSORS PAM KARLAN and DAVID SLOSS at the County League speaker event on "Limits of Executive Power: Has it Grown Too Big?" at the Quinlan Community Center in Cupertino, 7-9pm. Registration info coming soon. VOLUNTEERS NEEDED - let us know if you can help. October 2: watch for details on our upcoming program on water, at Palo Alto City Hall October 4 or 5: LWVPA October Kickoff at Mitchell Park - planning underway - watch this space! Friday, August 1: LWV Palo Alto Event Coffee & Cobbler Whether you’re brand new, a long-time member looking to reconnect, or just "League-curious," you’re warmly invited to join us on Friday, August 1 from 9-10:30am at the home of SUNNY DYKWEL. Everyone is welcome! Come chat with friends and neighbors while enjoying fresh hot coffee and homemade fruit cobbler. This informal gathering with League leadership is a great opportunity to learn about our recent activities, discover ways to get involved, and mingle with fellow members. Feel free to bring a friend and enjoy some lively conversation! RSVP to Sunny at 650/400-6960. Address: 480 Gary Court, in midtown Palo Alto 94306. SUNNY DYKWEL Sunday, August 17: County League Event Meet our own REP. SAM LICCARDO, here to listen to his constituents. 2:00-4pm, at Mitchell Park Community Center, 3700 Middlefield Rd, Palo Alto, CA 94303. Program at 2:30pm. REGISTER HERE - submit your question for Rep. Liccardo when you register. PALO ALTO NEWS LWVPA Update: Good Trouble Lives On! July 17 was another encouraging day for democracy. Read all about it in the article by local reporter GRACE GORMLEY: Hundreds gather at 'Good Trouble Lives On' event - Palo Alto Online. Thanks to all our wonderful volunteers who made our tabling at the Good Trouble rally a huge success, and to our co-president LISA RATNER for the important message she delivered as a rally speaker! Our signs, handouts and "I Will Vote" picture frame (visitors really enjoyed taking pictures) were a big draw. Photos below by Grace Gormley and Mariya Genzel Call for Nominating Committee Members! Help shape the future of our organization! League members: be a part of our nominating team and help identify and recruit passionate leaders. Join us in preparing a dynamic slate of officers and directors for the Annual Meeting while collaborating with the board and Leadership Development Team to ensure key roles are filled for a strong and effective board. If interested, please contact ERIKA BUCK at erikabuck@gmail.com or (650) 743-6943. ERIKA BUCK Check out our website! New video added to our Speaker Playlist: In Studio with Berkeley Law School Dean ERWIN CHEMERINSKY: Defining the Limits of Free Speech (2018) "His remarks on the First Amendment are extremelyrelevant today." - LISA RATNER, LWVPA co-president Distinguished Berkeley Law School Dean ERWIN CHEMERINSKY—named most influential person in US legal education by the "National Jurist" magazine and author of "Free Speech on Campus"—discusses the limits of free speech as related to hate speech and its impact on civic engagement before a studio audience at Midpen Media Center, Palo Alto, CA. The forum was moderated by Stanford Law Professor JOHN J. DONOHOE and sponsored by the League of Women Voters - Palo Alto. Produced by MAUREEN O'KICKI. ©LWVPA 2018 Interested in volunteering? We owe a HUGE thanks to long-time webmaster and member RACHEL KELLERMAN for her cheerful service! Rachel is ready to hand over the reins to another member - let LAURA BAJUK know if you're interested, at laurasbajuk@gmail.com. Rachel, enjoy your well-deserved vacation! RACHEL KELLERMAN I N M E M O R I A M Long-time League member VIRGINIA DEBS passed away recently at the age of 101. An informal celebration of life will be held in fall at Parents Nursery School, where she taught for decades. For information, please contact her family at RememberingGrandmaVirginia@gmail.com. Updates & Events from other Leagues STATE NEWS Meet our new state president, Gloria Chun Hoo It is both an honor and a privilege to take on the role of president of the League of Women Voters of California. This is a critical time for our nation and for our democracy, and I step into this role with humility, gratitude, and a deep sense of purpose. Now is the time to recommit. We are not afraid. We will not be silenced. For more than 100 years, the League has stood strong, grounded in our principles and powered by our members. That legacy continues with you. I look forward to doing this work, united with you. GLORIA CHUN HOO Read her complete greeting at Meet Gloria Chun Hoo, Our New LWVC President - League of Women Voters of California California news changes quickly. Get trustworthy information from our state LWV, when you sign up for LWVC Communications here. You can choose which type(s) of news you want: Action Alerts, Voter Info Updates, and/or the LWVC Newsletter. LWVC News https://lwvc.org/news/ What's happening at our local Leagues? Cupertino/Sunnyvale Los Altos/Mountain View Palo Alto San Jose/Santa Clara Southwest Santa Clara Valley North & Central San Mateo County COUNTY NEWS: SANTA CLARA Santa Clara County-Wide League Book Club Meeting - 8.10.25 You're invited to a county-wide book club! Join us at this one-off book club meeting of members and friends from the five Santa Clara County Leagues to gather and discuss a more hopeful book. Meet and chat with other League members who love books and care about our democracy. Organized by the membership chairs of LWV SCC. When: August 10, 3-5pm | Where: Saratoga Library - 13650 Saratoga Ave, Saratoga Register here: https://forms.gle/pXsybqogvXGLz1TS6 Factfulness: Ten Reasons We're Wrong About the World – and Why Things Are Better Than You Think. by Hans Rosling, Ola Rosling, Anna Rosling Rönnlund - click here to view on Goodreads "One of the most important books I've ever read -- an indispensable guide to thinking clearly about the world." - Bill Gates We envision a democracy where every person has the desire,the right, the knowledge, and the confidence to participate. The League of Women Voters is a nonpartisan, political organization that encourages informed and active participation in government, works to increase understanding of major public policy issues, and influences public policy through education and advocacy. Just so you know, the League is not just for women, but for anyone who supports democracy and voting rights for all. Join today, and... · Make connections and build lasting friendships · Explore new interests and build skills · Learn about important local issues · Give back to your community Give today! Your support empowers voters and protects democracy. Thank you! We'd love to hear from you! Our mailing address is LWVPA, 3921 E Bayshore Road, Palo Alto, CA 94303 Email to communications@lwvpaloalto.org Subscribe to our newsletters: sign up using the subscription form Want to change how you receive these emails?You can update your preferences or unsubscribe from this list. From:Neil Murphy To:Council, City Subject:Public comment on 4256 El Camino Real proposal (2025) Date:Sunday, July 27, 2025 12:28:09 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. i Members of our City Council, I am writing to submit public comments regarding the proposed development project at 4256 El Camino Real. While I support the addition of housing in our community, this proposal has some irreconcilable flaws: Parking issues: Total dependency on mechanical stacking. 96/100 stalls are puzzle-lift type. Highmaintenance, low throughput, prone to downtime.Accessible parking deficiency. Only 5 accessible stalls—exactly 5%—bare minimum,no margin for future ADA upgrades or aging tenants.Ingress/egress conflict. Entry/exit drive aisle intersects lobby access and elevator zone.Pedestrian-vehicular conflict risk.Circulation problems. No turnaround space; if lifts fail, no alternate parking path oregress loop.No EV chargers indicated. Noncompliant with California CALGreen for newresidential. Traffic circulation issues: No affordance for service vehicles or rideshares. No internal holding area, forcing double-parking on El Camino.For reference, our comparable facility of 117 units has continuous delivery trucks and vans, two garbage trucks, constant rideshare pickup/dropoff, a daily mailtruck. The developer appears to intend to use a lane of public traffic on ECR to get aloading zone for free, to the detriment of public use and safety. If the intention is for all service vehicles to park in the first lane of traffic on ECR,this will continually halt the flow of traffic on ECR and obstruct bike lanes.Curbside congestion. No designated loading zone or lay-by for rideshare, deliveries,garbage, or mail. Conflicts inevitable with protected bike lanes.Protected bike lane barrier. Direct curb access from El Camino is blocked; vehiclesmust cross bike lanes, creating dangerous conflict points for cyclists. This message needs your attention This is a personal email address. This is their first email to you. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast Service vehicle access. Turning radius insufficient for dual garbage trucks and deliveryvans without obstructing traffic/bike lanes, assuming the intention is for these vehicles to enter the site.Entry bottleneck. Single narrow driveway (approx. 20’) shared for all vehicle types. High conflict, inefficient throughput. Traffic will back up onto ECR. Design issues: Single stair access. West wing lacks compliant second stair; trap risk in fire event.Trash room access. Some residents will need to carry dripping garbage ~150 ft to the trash chute.Light/air deficiency. North-facing interior units (~460 SF studios) face a narrow courtyard (~31’ wide), risking inadequate natural light/ventilation. Units facing onlyinto 41’ wide courtyard may not meet CBC 1202.5 for natural light/ventilation due to limited sky exposure.Elevator location. Poor central access; far from western units. Poor accessibility, move- in/out logistics.Elevator redundancy. When one elevator goes down, how are elderly or disabled residents meant to exit the facility?Neighbor privacy. Exterior balconies on W and S faces look directly into our own balconies, bedrooms, and living rooms. I urge the City to carefully consider these points in evaluating the project. Thank you, Neil Murphy 650-504-44334250 El Camino Real From:JS To:Council, CitySubject:4256 El Camino Real Council pre-screening meeting Date:Sunday, July 27, 2025 11:30:04 AM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments andclicking on links. i Subject: Oppse 4256 El Camino Real proposal Dear Mayor Stone, Vice Mayor Vicki Veenker, Pat Burt, George Lu, Julie Lythcott-Haims, Keith Reckdahl, EdLauing, Carlos Romero, and Webster Lincoln, I am writing to express my concerns regarding the 4256 El Camino Real poorly designed housing project. As a resident of the neighborhood, I believe this matter could significantly affect the immediate community in terms of congextive traffic, high desnity living conditon with studio and one bedroom units, inadequate parking spaces in proposal. Concern: 1. Puzzle Lift Stacker parking style: Each Puzzle module can hold 6-50 cars. Drivers park their car in entry platform, and lifted to available spot. Only one car can go in and out of the system - commute hours will create problems for residents. Need to empty grocery, backpacks or furniture before car enters platform (takes time). During power outage, no car can go in or out. Imagine during busy time to go to work or school, you have to load everything into your care before driving away from the platform. Please remember On El Camino Real where we have designated bike lanes,there is no parking on the street where you can load or unload your stuff from your car before you enter or exit the car platform. Please ask developer to add more parking spaces. __________________________________________________________________________________ 2. No Plaza, rest area or clubhouse or swimming pool either, for the well- being of the residents who live in a small cram space:studios or one bedrooms......... We need to have quality housing - not boxed homes like in the slump areas or housing projects in SAn Francisco. We need livable housing. Please don't give up quality of living in Palo Alto for Quantity housing projects in government subsidized areas. This message needs your attention This is a personal email address.This is their first email to your company. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast Thank you very much for your time. I believe addressing these 2 main concerns will lead to better outcomes for both current and futrue residents. I appreciate your attention to this matter and encourage the city council to take these concerns into careful consideration. Sincerely, Jee Smith Ventura resident Jeesm5@aol.com From:rdmto@aol.com To:Council, CitySubject:4256 El Camino Real Council pre-screening meeting Date:Sunday, July 27, 2025 11:23:59 AM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments andclicking on links. i Subject: Oppse 4256 El Camino Real : poorly designed housing project Dear Vice Mayor Vicki Veenker and council members Pat Burt, George Lu, Julie Lythcott-Haims, KeithReckdahl, Ed Lauing, Carlos Romero, and Webster Lincoln, I am writing to express my concerns regarding the 4256 Elcamino Real poorly designed housing project. As a resident of the neighborhood, I believe this matter could significantly affect the immediate community in terms of congextive traffic, high desnity living conditon with studio and one bedroom units, inadequate parking spaces in proposal. Concern: Tracffic congestion on already crowded Major road: El Camino Real . There are only 100 parking spaces for 100 units. Units breakdown: 44 studios 44 one bedroom units 8 two bedroom units 4 three bedroom units ----------------------------------- 100 total units. Puzzle Lift Stacker parking style: Each Puzzle module can hold 6-50 cars. Drivers park their car in entry platform, and lifted to available spot. Only one car can go in and out of the system - commute hours will create problems for residents. Need to empty grocery, backpacks or furniture before car enters platform (takes time). During power outage, no car can go in or out. Imagine during busy time to go to work or school, you have to load everything into your care before driving away from the platform. Please remember On El Camino Real where we have designated bike lanes,there is no parking on the street where you can load or unload your stuff from your car before you enter or exit the car platform. This message needs your attentionThis is a personal email address. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast Please STOP this poorly designed project. __________________________________________________________________________________ No Plaza, rest area or clubhouse or swimming pool either, for the well- being of the residents who live in a small cram space:studios or one bedrooms......... We need to have quality housing - not boxed homes like in the slump areas or housing projects in SAn Francisco. We need livable housing. Please don't give up quality of living in Palo Alto for Quantity housing projects in government subsidized areas. Thank you very much for your time. I believe addressing these 2 main concerns will lead to better outcomes for both current and futrue residents. I appreciate your attention to this matter and encourage the city council to take these concerns into careful consideration. Sincerely, Mary Young Charleston Meadow resident rdmto@aol.com From:rdmto@aol.com To:Council, City Subject:4256 El Camino Real Council pre-screening meeting Date:Sunday, July 27, 2025 11:17:44 AM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments andclicking on links. i Subject: Oppse 4256 El Camino Real : poorly designed housing project Dear Mayor Greer Stone, I am writing to express my concerns regarding the 4256 Elcamino Real poorly designed housing project. As a resident of the neighborhood, I believe this matter could significantly affect the immediate community in terms of congextive traffic, high desnity living conditon with studio and one bedroom units, inadequate parking spaces in proposal. Concern: Tracffic congestion on already crowded Major road: El Camino Real . There are only 100 parking spaces for 100 units. Units breakdown: 44 studios 44 one bedroom units 8 two bedroom units 4 three bedroom units ----------------------------------- 100 total units. Puzzle Lift Stacker parking style: Each Puzzle module can hold 6-50 cars. Drivers park their car in entry platform, and lifted to available spot. Only one car can go in and out of the system - commute hours will create problems for residents. Need to empty grocery, backpacks or furniture before car enters platform (takes time). During power outage, no car can go in or out. Imagine during busy time to go to work or school, you have to load everything into your care before driving away from the platform. Please remember On El Camino Real where we have designated bike lanes,there is no parking on the street where you can load or unload your stuff from your car before you enter or exit the car platform. Please STOP this poorly designed project. __________________________________________________________________________________ This message needs your attentionThis is a personal email address. This is their first email to you. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast No Plaza, rest area or clubhouse or swimming pool either, for the well- being of the residents who live in a small cram space:studios or one bedrooms......... We need to have quality housing - not boxed homes like in the slump areas or housing projects in SAn Francisco. We need livable housing. Please don't give up quality of living in Palo Alto for Quantity housing projects in government subsidized areas. Thank you very much for your time. I believe addressing these 2 main concerns will lead to better outcomes for both current and futrue residents. I appreciate your attention to this matter and encourage the city council to take these concerns into careful consideration. Sincerely, Mary Young Charleston Meadow resident rdmto@aol.com From:Aram James To:Mark Turner; Marty Wasserman; Palo Alto Free Press; Dave Price; Emily Mibach; Seher Awan; Sean Allen;Michelle Bigelow; Council, City; Donna Wallach; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Josh Becker;Gardener, Liz; Tim James; Cait James; board@valleywater.org; district1@bos.sccgov.org; Jay Boyarsky;h.etzko@gmail.com; Jeff Rosen; planning.commission@cityofpaloalto.0rg; Human Relations Commission; BillNewell; board@pausd.org; BoardOperations; GRP-City Council; city.council@menlopark.gov; Binder, Andrew;Reifschneider, James; dennis burns; DuJuan Green; Zelkha, Mila; EPA Today; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com; PatM; Burt, Patrick; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov; frances.Rothschild@jud.ca.gov Subject:Man who murdered Palestinian American 6-year-old boy dies in custody, officials say Date:Sunday, July 27, 2025 10:06:30 AM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. Man who murdered Palestinian American 6-year-old boy dies in custody, officials say Source: USA TODAY https://share.newsbreak.com/e8y7043n?s=i0 From:Aram James To:Palo Alto Free Press Cc:Veenker, Vicki; Lythcott-Haims, Julie; Reckdahl, Keith; Ed Lauing; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23; Lori Meyers; Sheree Roth; h.etzko@gmail.com; Binder, Andrew; Mark Turner; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; Josh Becker; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Julie Lythcott-Haims; Figueroa, Eric; Doug Minkler; Gerry Gras; EPA Today; Gennady Sheyner; city.council@menlopark.gov; dcombs@menlopark.gov; Steve Wagstaffe; Jeff Rosen; Jeff Conrad; Jeff Hayden; Jay Boyarsky; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas; Mickie Winkler; Sean Allen; Cait James; San José Spotlight; board@pausd.org; boardfeedback@smcgov.org; board@valleywater.org; BoardOperations; Braden Cartwright; Raymond Goins; Rodriguez, Miguel; editor@paweekly.com; Wagner, April; Don Austin; Donna Wallach; Burt, Patrick; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov; Seher Awan; Daniel Barton; David Piper; Foley, Michael; Zelkha, Mila; Palo Alto Renters" Association; Diana Diamond; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com; ladoris cordell; cromero@cityofepa.org; rabrica@cityofepa.org; Bill Newell; Bill Johnson; Bill James; Pat M; Carla Torres; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; Council, City; GRP-City Council; Perron, Zachary; City Attorney; citycouncil@mountainview.gov; Clerk, City; GRP-City Clerk; Friends of Cubberley; Lotus Fong; ParkRec Commission; Gardener, Liz; Human Relations Commission; Holman, Karen (external); Liz Kniss; Patrice Ventresca; Rowena Chiu; Dana St. George; Damon Silver; Daniel Kottke; Dennis Upton; Zahra Billoo; james pitkin; Roberta Ahlquist; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Supervisor Otto Lee; Salem Ajluni; Stump, Molly; Rosen, Jeff; Baker, Rob; Ruth Silver Taube; Tom DuBois; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Jasso, Tamara; DuJuan Green; Dennis Upton; dennis burns; Jensen, Eric; Afanasiev, Alex; Lee, Craig; Anna Griffin; Angel, David; Greg Tanaka; Reifschneider, James; Bryan Gobin; Yolanda Conaway; Donna Wallach; Vara Ramakrishnan; Dave Price; Dan Okonkwo; Jennifer Morrow San José Spotlight; Emily Mibach; MGR-Melissa Stevenson Diaz; vramirez@redwoodcity.org; Nicole Chiu-Wang; Rowena Chiu; Senator Becker; frances.Rothschild@jud.ca.gov; Michael Pati; Marina Lopez; Josie James-Le; Tim James; sharon jackson; Lewis James; Douglas A. Murray; Freddie.Quintana@sen.ca.gov; Michael Ybarra; yolanda; Seher Awan; Roberta Ahlquist; Marty Wasserman Subject:Re: Famine Expert: Israel"s Starvation of Gaza Most "Minutely Designed and Controlled" Since WWII Date:Sunday, July 27, 2025 9:22:41 AM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. Folks: please read the Intercept interview of the brilliant and acclaimed journalist, author, and speaker Chris Hedges ( Starvation as a weapon). You can also listen to it ( 38 mins) Published July 25, 2025 Israel’s Creation Myth In it, you talk about the use of myth to justify or perpetuate war. In one context, you talk about the creation myth of Israel and how Israelis are unwilling to question what they’re conditioned to believe about the state of Israel. Source: The Intercept Starvation as a Weapon: Chris Hedges onGaza https://share.google/QmqqFEiuHOTTQStYX On Sun, Jul 27, 2025 at 9:03 AM Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Mark, I place no blame on Hamas for the current situation. For decades, the U.S. andIsrael have kept the people of Gaza in what can only be described as the largest outdoor prison and concentration camp in world history. This reality is well-documented by Jewish scholars like Norman Finkelstein and Israeli scholar Ilan Pappé. Like Nat Turner Hamas members can be viewed as freedom fighters of the firstorder. . It was known to Israel that Hamas was preparing for the October 7 attack for asignificant period—possibly weeks or even months—before the actual event.The IDF was ordered to stand down by military leaders with the full consent ofPrime Minister Bibi Netanyahu. It seems that Israel sought a precipitating eventto trigger violence, aiming toward the total ethnic cleansing of the Palestinianpeople from their historic homeland. Based on historical records that predate its establishment in 1948, Israel and itsZionist leadership have always planned to expel the Palestinian people throughviolence and military force. The Israelis routinely dehumanize the Palestinianpeople, similarly to how Europeans characterized Native Americans, providingjustification for land theft and atrocities (Settler Colonialism). This is not a conflict between two equal parties. It is Israel, supported bysubstantial military and financial aid from the U.S. (billions of dollars everyyear), engaged in a systematic slaughter of the Palestinian people. Israel possesses one of the most powerful militaries in the world, with afunctioning army, navy, air force, and nuclear weapons. In contrast, Palestinehas no army, no navy, no air force, and no nuclear weapons. The Palestinians survive through their resourcefulness, while Israel relies onmilitary strength supplied by the U.S. This situation transcends the classicnarrative of David versus Goliath. Avram “Eliminate the state of Israel now." — Finkelstein On Tue, Jul 22, 2025 at 10:28 PM Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote:The ongoing genocide and war crimes committed by Israel, with the full support of the United States, will eventually be prosecuted in the International Criminal Court in The Hague. This will happen regardless of any alleged actions by Hamas. It is crucial tounderstand that the ongoing genocide is a separate and distinct crimefrom the alleged behavior of the group referred to as Hamas (freedom fighters). As Bob Dylan famously said, “You don't need a weatherman to know whichway the wind blows.” In a similar vein, you don’t need a genocide expert torecognize that Israel is currently engaged in a massive, full-blown genocide ofthe Palestinian people. One can offer various intellectual rationalizations, but the reality remains indisputable—the actions of the state of Israel amount togenocide beyond all reasonable doubt. Israel is guilty as charged of war crimes and genocide. Avram “Let The Prosecution Begin” Finkelstein On Sun, Jul 27, 2025 at 8:58 AM Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:Aram, I don't think too many Gazans would agree with your characterization of Hamas as "freedom fighters." They've never done anything to make Gazans freer. Infact, they’ve oppressed them far worse than the Israelis ever did, and theirfanatical hatred against Jews and Israel has brought nothing but death and destruction to Gaza. Your theory that Israel intentionally allowed October 7 to happen in order tohave a pretext to invade Gaza is beyond ludicrous. If Israel wanted a pretext, it could easily have found one that involved no loss of Jewish lives, let alone over 1200 Jewish lives! Your claim that Israel always planned to expel all the Palestinian Arabs is also absurd. If so, why did they grant full Israeli citizenship to so many of them, over a million of which continue to enjoy the benefits of Israeli citizenship today,including the right to vote. It's true that some pre-state Jewish leaders considered the possibility of expelling the Arabs in light of their continued hostility, but this has never beenthe policy of the State. On the other hand, top Arab leaders have repeatedlyboasted, especially in 1948 and 1967, that they were going to “ massacre” the Jews and “drive them into the sea,” and Hamas to this day insists that its goal is to remove every single Jew from the Land of Israel. You accuse Israel of dehumanizing the Palestinians. You should take a look at how Jews are portrayed in Palestinian textbooks and classrooms. It seems that everything you accuse Israel of doing to the Arabs are things that the Arabs do, or try to do, to the Jews. Your claim that the conflict is not between equals is also disingenuous. Hamas itself is no match for Israel, but it's important to recognize that Hamas is just one branch of a larger movement called the Muslim Brotherhood. It also has wealthyand powerful patrons in Arab and Muslim countries, and it's diverted hundreds of millions of dollars in international aid, intended to benefit the Gazan people,into militarizing the Strip for protracted warfare against Israel. And given its fanatical dedication to killing Jews, which it regards as a religious obligation, and its being willing and even eager to give their own lives to do so, it indeed poses an existential threat that Israel must deal with in a very forceful way. Martin Wasserman On Jul 25, 2025, at 9:58 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Hi Mark, I place no blame on Hamas for the current situation. For decades, the U.S. and Israel have kept the people of Gaza in what can only be described as the largest outdoor prison and concentration camp in world history. This reality is well-documented by Jewish scholarslike Norman Finkelstein and Israeli scholar Ilan Pappé. Like Nat Turner Hamas members can be viewed as freedom fighters of the first order. . It was known to Israel that Hamas was preparing for the October 7 attack for a significant period—possibly weeks or even months— before the actual event. The IDF was ordered to stand down bymilitary leaders with the full consent of Prime Minister BibiNetanyahu. It seems that Israel sought a precipitating event to trigger violence, aiming toward the total ethnic cleansing of the Palestinian people from their historic homeland. Based on historical records that predate its establishment in 1948, Israel and its Zionist leadership have always planned to expel the Palestinian people through violence and military force. The Israelis routinely dehumanize the Palestinian people, similarly to howEuropeans characterized Native Americans, providing justification for land theft and atrocities (Settler Colonialism). This is not a conflict between two equal parties. It is Israel, supportedby substantial military and financial aid from the U.S. (billions of dollars every year), engaged in a systematic slaughter of the Palestinian people. Israel possesses one of the most powerful militaries in the world, with a functioning army, navy, air force, and nuclear weapons. Incontrast, Palestine has no army, no navy, no air force, and no nuclear weapons. The Palestinians survive through their resourcefulness, while Israelrelies on military strength supplied by the U.S. This situationtranscends the classic narrative of David versus Goliath. Avram “Eliminate the state of Israel now." — Finkelstein On Tue, Jul 22, 2025 at 10:28 PM Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote:The ongoing genocide and war crimes committed by Israel, with the full support of the United States, will eventually be prosecutedin the International Criminal Court in The Hague. This will happenregardless of any alleged actions by Hamas. It is crucial to understand that the ongoing genocide is a separate and distinct crime from the alleged behavior of the group referred to as Hamas(freedom fighters). As Bob Dylan famously said, “You don't need a weatherman to know which way the wind blows.” In a similar vein, you don’t needa genocide expert to recognize that Israel is currently engaged in amassive, full-blown genocide of the Palestinian people. One can offer various intellectual rationalizations, but the reality remains indisputable—the actions of the state of Israel amount to genocide beyond all reasonable doubt. Israel is guilty as charged of warcrimes and genocide. Avram “Let The Prosecution Begin” Finkelstein On Tue, Jul 22, 2025 at 10:23 PM Martin Wasserman<deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:The bias of the author is evident in the fact that the entire article mentions Hamas only once, in passing. Hamas could end thesuffering tomorrow just by laying down their arms and releasingthe hostages. But they care more about scoring propaganda points against Israel than about saving the lives of their own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 22, 2025, at 3:08 PM, Aram James<abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvationof Gaza Most 'Minutely Designedand Controlled' Since WWII Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'MinutelyDesigned and Controlled' Since WWII | Common Dreamshttps://www.commondreams.org/news/famine-expert-israel-s-starvation-of-gaza-most-minutely-designed-and-controlled-since-wwii From:Aram James To:Martin Wasserman Cc:Palo Alto Free Press; Veenker, Vicki; Lythcott-Haims, Julie; Reckdahl, Keith; Ed Lauing; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23; Lori Meyers; Sheree Roth; h.etzko@gmail.com; Binder, Andrew; Mark Turner; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; Josh Becker; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Julie Lythcott-Haims; Figueroa, Eric; Doug Minkler; Gerry Gras; EPA Today; Gennady Sheyner; city.council@menlopark.gov; dcombs@menlopark.gov; Steve Wagstaffe; Jeff Rosen; Jeff Conrad; Jeff Hayden; Jay Boyarsky; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas; Mickie Winkler; Sean Allen; Cait James; San José Spotlight; board@pausd.org; boardfeedback@smcgov.org; board@valleywater.org; BoardOperations; Braden Cartwright; Raymond Goins; Rodriguez, Miguel; editor@paweekly.com; Wagner, April; Don Austin; Donna Wallach; Burt, Patrick; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov; Seher Awan; Daniel Barton; David Piper; Foley, Michael; Zelkha, Mila; Palo Alto Renters" Association; Diana Diamond; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com; ladoris cordell; cromero@cityofepa.org; rabrica@cityofepa.org; Bill Newell; Bill Johnson; Bill James; Pat M; Carla Torres; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; Council, City; GRP-City Council; Perron, Zachary; City Attorney; citycouncil@mountainview.gov; Clerk, City; GRP- City Clerk; Friends of Cubberley; Lotus Fong; ParkRec Commission; Gardener, Liz; Human Relations Commission; Holman, Karen (external); Liz Kniss; Patrice Ventresca; Rowena Chiu; Dana St. George; Damon Silver; Daniel Kottke; Dennis Upton; Zahra Billoo; james pitkin; Roberta Ahlquist; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Supervisor Otto Lee; Salem Ajluni; Stump, Molly; Rosen, Jeff; Baker, Rob; Ruth Silver Taube; Tom DuBois; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Jasso, Tamara; DuJuan Green; Dennis Upton; dennis burns; Jensen, Eric; Afanasiev, Alex; Lee, Craig; Anna Griffin; Angel, David; Greg Tanaka; Reifschneider, James; Bryan Gobin; Yolanda Conaway; Donna Wallach; Vara Ramakrishnan; Dave Price; Dan Okonkwo; Jennifer Morrow San José Spotlight; Emily Mibach; MGR-Melissa Stevenson Diaz; vramirez@redwoodcity.org; Nicole Chiu-Wang; Rowena Chiu; Senator Becker; frances.Rothschild@jud.ca.gov; Michael Pati; Marina Lopez; Josie James-Le; Tim James; sharon jackson; Lewis James; Douglas A. Murray; Freddie.Quintana@sen.ca.gov; Michael Ybarra; yolanda; Seher Awan; Roberta Ahlquist Subject:Re: Famine Expert: Israel"s Starvation of Gaza Most "Minutely Designed and Controlled" Since WWII Date:Sunday, July 27, 2025 9:03:55 AM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Becautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. Mark, I place no blame on Hamas for the current situation. For decades, the U.S. and Israel have kept the people of Gaza in what can only be described as the largest outdoor prison and concentration camp in world history. This reality is well- documented by Jewish scholars like Norman Finkelstein and Israeli scholar Ilan Pappé. Like Nat Turner Hamas members can be viewed as freedom fighters of the first order. . It was known to Israel that Hamas was preparing for the October 7 attack for asignificant period—possibly weeks or even months—before the actual event. The IDF was ordered to stand down by military leaders with the full consent of Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu. It seems that Israel sought a precipitating event to trigger violence, aiming toward the total ethnic cleansing of the Palestinian peoplefrom their historic homeland. Based on historical records that predate its establishment in 1948, Israel and its Zionist leadership have always planned to expel the Palestinian people throughviolence and military force. The Israelis routinely dehumanize the Palestinian people, similarly to how Europeans characterized Native Americans, providing justification for land theft and atrocities (Settler Colonialism). This is not a conflict between two equal parties. It is Israel, supported by substantial military and financial aid from the U.S. (billions of dollars every year), engaged in a systematic slaughter of the Palestinian people. Israel possesses one of the most powerful militaries in the world, with a functioning army, navy, air force, and nuclear weapons. In contrast, Palestine has no army, no navy, no air force, and no nuclear weapons. The Palestinians survive through their resourcefulness, while Israel relies on military strength supplied by the U.S. This situation transcends the classic narrative of David versus Goliath. Avram “Eliminate the state of Israel now." — Finkelstein On Tue, Jul 22, 2025 at 10:28 PM Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com > wrote: The ongoing genocide and war crimes committed by Israel, with the full support of the United States, will eventually be prosecuted in the International Criminal Court in The Hague. This will happen regardless of any alleged actions by Hamas. It is crucial to understand that the ongoing genocide is a separate and distinct crime from the alleged behavior of the group referred to as Hamas (freedom fighters). As Bob Dylan famously said, “You don't need a weatherman to know which way the wind blows.” In a similar vein, you don’t need a genocide expert to recognize that Israel is currently engaged in a massive, full-blown genocide of the Palestinian people. One can offer various intellectual rationalizations, butthe reality remains indisputable—the actions of the state of Israel amount to genocide beyond all reasonable doubt. Israel is guilty as charged of war crimes and genocide. Avram “Let The Prosecution Begin” Finkelstein On Sun, Jul 27, 2025 at 8:58 AM Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:Aram, I don't think too many Gazans would agree with your characterization of Hamas as "freedom fighters." They've never done anything to make Gazans freer. In fact, they’ve oppressed them far worse than the Israelis ever did, and their fanaticalhatred against Jews and Israel has brought nothing but death and destruction to Gaza. Your theory that Israel intentionally allowed October 7 to happen in order to have a pretext to invade Gaza is beyond ludicrous. If Israel wanted a pretext, it could easily have found one that involved no loss of Jewish lives, let alone over 1200Jewish lives! Your claim that Israel always planned to expel all the Palestinian Arabs is also absurd. If so, why did they grant full Israeli citizenship to so many of them, over amillion of which continue to enjoy the benefits of Israeli citizenship today,including the right to vote. It's true that some pre-state Jewish leaders considered the possibility of expellingthe Arabs in light of their continued hostility, but this has never been the policy ofthe State. On the other hand, top Arab leaders have repeatedly boasted, especially in 1948 and 1967, that they were going to “ massacre” the Jews and “drive them into the sea,” and Hamas to this day insists that its goal is to remove every single Jew from the Land of Israel. You accuse Israel of dehumanizing the Palestinians. You should take a look at how Jews are portrayed in Palestinian textbooks and classrooms. It seems that everything you accuse Israel of doing to the Arabs are things that the Arabs do, ortry to do, to the Jews. Your claim that the conflict is not between equals is also disingenuous. Hamas itself is no match for Israel, but it's important to recognize that Hamas is just onebranch of a larger movement called the Muslim Brotherhood. It also has wealthy and powerful patrons in Arab and Muslim countries, and it's diverted hundreds of millions of dollars in international aid, intended to benefit the Gazan people, into militarizing the Strip for protracted warfare against Israel. And given its fanaticaldedication to killing Jews, which it regards as a religious obligation, and its being willing and even eager to give their own lives to do so, it indeed poses an existential threat that Israel must deal with in a very forceful way. Martin Wasserman On Jul 25, 2025, at 9:58 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Hi Mark, I place no blame on Hamas for the current situation. For decades, the U.S. and Israel have kept the people of Gaza in what can only be described as the largest outdoor prison and concentration camp in world history. This reality is well- documented by Jewish scholars like Norman Finkelstein and Israeli scholar Ilan Pappé. Like Nat Turner Hamas members can be viewed as freedom fighters of the first order. . It was known to Israel that Hamas was preparing for the October 7 attack for a significant period—possibly weeks or even months —before the actual event. The IDF was ordered to stand down by military leaders with the full consent of Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu. It seems that Israel sought a precipitating event to trigger violence, aiming toward the total ethnic cleansing of the Palestinian people from their historic homeland. Based on historical records that predate its establishment in 1948, Israel and its Zionist leadership have always planned to expel the Palestinian people through violence and military force. The Israelis routinely dehumanize the Palestinian people, similarly to how Europeans characterized Native Americans, providing justification for land theft and atrocities (Settler Colonialism). This is not a conflict between two equal parties. It is Israel, supported by substantial military and financial aid from the U.S. (billions of dollars every year), engaged in a systematic slaughter of the Palestinian people. Israel possesses one of the most powerful militaries in the world, with a functioning army, navy, air force, and nuclear weapons. In contrast, Palestine has no army, no navy, no air force, and no nuclear weapons. The Palestinians survive through their resourcefulness, while Israel relies on military strength supplied by the U.S. This situation transcends the classic narrative of David versus Goliath. Avram “Eliminate the state of Israel now." — Finkelstein On Tue, Jul 22, 2025 at 10:28 PM Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: The ongoing genocide and war crimes committed by Israel, with the full support of the United States, will eventually be prosecuted in the International Criminal Court in The Hague. This will happen regardless of any alleged actions by Hamas. It is crucial to understand that the ongoing genocide is a separate and distinct crime from the alleged behavior of the group referred to as Hamas (freedom fighters). As Bob Dylan famously said, “You don't need a weatherman to know which way the wind blows.” In a similar vein, you don’t need a genocide expert to recognize that Israel is currently engaged in a massive, full-blown genocide of the Palestinian people. One can offer various intellectual rationalizations, but the reality remains indisputable—the actions of the state of Israel amount to genocide beyond all reasonable doubt. Israel is guilty as charged of war crimes and genocide. Avram “Let The Prosecution Begin” Finkelstein On Tue, Jul 22, 2025 at 10:23 PM Martin Wasserman<deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:The bias of the author is evident in the fact that the entire article mentions Hamas only once, in passing. Hamas could end the suffering tomorrow just by laying down their arms and releasing the hostages. But they care more about scoring propaganda pointsagainst Israel than about saving the lives of their own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 22, 2025, at 3:08 PM, Aram James<abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvationof Gaza Most 'Minutely Designedand Controlled' Since WWII Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'MinutelyDesigned and Controlled' Since WWII | Common Dreamshttps://www.commondreams.org/news/famine-expert-israel-s-starvation-of-gaza-most-minutely-designed-and-controlled-since-wwii From:Martin Wasserman To:Aram James Cc:Palo Alto Free Press; Veenker, Vicki; Lythcott-Haims, Julie; Reckdahl, Keith; Ed Lauing; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23; Lori Meyers; Sheree Roth; h.etzko@gmail.com; Binder, Andrew; Mark Turner; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; Josh Becker; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Julie Lythcott-Haims; Figueroa, Eric; Doug Minkler; Gerry Gras; EPA Today; Gennady Sheyner; city.council@menlopark.gov; dcombs@menlopark.gov; Steve Wagstaffe; Jeff Rosen; Jeff Conrad; Jeff Hayden; Jay Boyarsky; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas; Mickie Winkler; Sean Allen; Cait James; San José Spotlight; board@pausd.org; boardfeedback@smcgov.org; board@valleywater.org; BoardOperations; Braden Cartwright; Raymond Goins; Rodriguez, Miguel; editor@paweekly.com; Wagner, April; Don Austin; Donna Wallach; Burt, Patrick; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov; Seher Awan; Daniel Barton; David Piper; Foley, Michael; Zelkha, Mila; Palo Alto Renters" Association; Diana Diamond; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com; ladoris cordell; cromero@cityofepa.org; rabrica@cityofepa.org; Bill Newell; Bill Johnson; Bill James; Pat M; Carla Torres; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; Council, City; GRP-City Council; Perron, Zachary; City Attorney; citycouncil@mountainview.gov; Clerk, City; GRP- City Clerk; Friends of Cubberley; Lotus Fong; ParkRec Commission; Gardener, Liz; Human Relations Commission; Holman, Karen (external); Liz Kniss; Patrice Ventresca; Rowena Chiu; Dana St. George; Damon Silver; Daniel Kottke; Dennis Upton; Zahra Billoo; james pitkin; Roberta Ahlquist; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Supervisor Otto Lee; Salem Ajluni; Stump, Molly; Rosen, Jeff; Baker, Rob; Ruth Silver Taube; Tom DuBois; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Jasso, Tamara; DuJuan Green; Dennis Upton; dennis burns; Jensen, Eric; Afanasiev, Alex; Lee, Craig; Anna Griffin; Angel, David; Greg Tanaka; Reifschneider, James; Bryan Gobin; Yolanda Conaway; Donna Wallach; Vara Ramakrishnan; Dave Price; Dan Okonkwo; Jennifer Morrow San José Spotlight; Emily Mibach; MGR-Melissa Stevenson Diaz; vramirez@redwoodcity.org; Nicole Chiu-Wang; Rowena Chiu; Senator Becker; frances.Rothschild@jud.ca.gov; Michael Pati; Marina Lopez; Josie James-Le; Tim James; sharon jackson; Lewis James; Douglas A. Murray; Freddie.Quintana@sen.ca.gov; Michael Ybarra; yolanda; Seher Awan; Roberta Ahlquist Subject:Re: Famine Expert: Israel"s Starvation of Gaza Most "Minutely Designed and Controlled" Since WWII Date:Sunday, July 27, 2025 8:58:25 AM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. Aram, I don't think too many Gazans would agree with your characterization of Hamas as "freedom fighters." They've never done anything to make Gazans freer. In fact, they’ve oppressed them far worse than the Israelis ever did, and their fanaticalhatred against Jews and Israel has brought nothing but death and destruction toGaza. Your theory that Israel intentionally allowed October 7 to happen in order to have apretext to invade Gaza is beyond ludicrous. If Israel wanted a pretext, it could easilyhave found one that involved no loss of Jewish lives, let alone over 1200 Jewish lives! Your claim that Israel always planned to expel all the Palestinian Arabs is alsoabsurd. If so, why did they grant full Israeli citizenship to so many of them, over a million of which continue to enjoy the benefits of Israeli citizenship today, including the right to vote. It's true that some pre-state Jewish leaders considered the possibility of expelling the Arabs in light of their continued hostility, but this has never been the policy of the State. On the other hand, top Arab leaders have repeatedly boasted, especially in 1948 and 1967, that they were going to “ massacre” the Jews and “drive them into the sea,” and Hamas to this day insists that its goal is to remove every single Jewfrom the Land of Israel. You accuse Israel of dehumanizing the Palestinians. You should take a look at how Jews are portrayed in Palestinian textbooks and classrooms. It seems that everythingyou accuse Israel of doing to the Arabs are things that the Arabs do, or try to do, tothe Jews. Your claim that the conflict is not between equals is also disingenuous. Hamas itselfis no match for Israel, but it's important to recognize that Hamas is just one branchof a larger movement called the Muslim Brotherhood. It also has wealthy and powerful patrons in Arab and Muslim countries, and it's diverted hundreds of millions of dollars in international aid, intended to benefit the Gazan people, intomilitarizing the Strip for protracted warfare against Israel. And given its fanaticaldedication to killing Jews, which it regards as a religious obligation, and its being willing and even eager to give their own lives to do so, it indeed poses an existential threat that Israel must deal with in a very forceful way. Martin Wasserman On Jul 25, 2025, at 9:58 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Hi Mark, I place no blame on Hamas for the current situation. For decades, the U.S. and Israel have kept the people of Gaza in what can only be described as the largest outdoor prison and concentration camp in world history. This reality is well-documented by Jewish scholars like Norman Finkelstein and Israeli scholar Ilan Pappé. Like Nat Turner Hamas members can be viewed as freedom fighters of the first order. . It was known to Israel that Hamas was preparing for the October 7 attack for a significant period—possibly weeks or even months —before the actual event. The IDF was ordered to stand down by military leaders with the full consent of Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu. It seems that Israel sought a precipitating event to trigger violence, aiming toward the total ethnic cleansing of the Palestinian people from their historic homeland. Based on historical records that predate its establishment in 1948, Israel and its Zionist leadership have always planned to expel the Palestinian people through violence and military force. The Israelis routinely dehumanize the Palestinian people, similarly to how Europeans characterized Native Americans, providing justification for land theft and atrocities (Settler Colonialism). This is not a conflict between two equal parties. It is Israel, supported by substantial military and financial aid from the U.S. (billions of dollars every year), engaged in a systematic slaughter of the Palestinian people. Israel possesses one of the most powerful militaries in the world, with a functioning army, navy, air force, and nuclear weapons. In contrast, Palestine has no army, no navy, no air force, and no nuclear weapons. The Palestinians survive through their resourcefulness, while Israel relies on military strength supplied by the U.S. This situation transcends the classic narrative of David versus Goliath. Avram “Eliminate the state of Israel now." — Finkelstein On Tue, Jul 22, 2025 at 10:28 PM Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: The ongoing genocide and war crimes committed by Israel, with the full support of the United States, will eventually be prosecuted in the International Criminal Court in The Hague. This will happen regardless of any alleged actions by Hamas. It is crucial to understand that the ongoing genocide is a separate and distinct crime from the alleged behavior of the group referred to as Hamas (freedom fighters). As Bob Dylan famously said, “You don't need a weatherman to know which way the wind blows.” In a similar vein, you don’t need a genocide expert to recognize that Israel is currently engaged in a massive, full-blown genocide of the Palestinian people. One can offer various intellectual rationalizations, but the reality remains indisputable—the actions of the state of Israel amount to genocide beyond all reasonable doubt. Israel is guilty as charged of war crimes and genocide. Avram “Let The Prosecution Begin” Finkelstein On Tue, Jul 22, 2025 at 10:23 PM Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:The bias of the author is evident in the fact that the entire article mentions Hamas only once, in passing. Hamas could end the suffering tomorrow just by laying down their arms and releasing thehostages. But they care more about scoring propaganda pointsagainst Israel than about saving the lives of their own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 22, 2025, at 3:08 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com>wrote: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvationof Gaza Most 'Minutely Designedand Controlled' Since WWII Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'MinutelyDesigned and Controlled' Since WWII | Common Dreams https://www.commondreams.org/news/famine-expert-israel-s-starvation-of-gaza-most-minutely-designed-and-controlled-since- wwii From:Henry Etzkowitz To:Joe Penko; Winter Dellenbach; mickie winkler; Avroh Shah; Brian Good; Christiane Gebhardt; Devrim GöktepeHultén; Ellen Fox; Christopher M Kwong; Devrim Göktepe Hultén; Josep Miquel Piqué Huerta; Rebecca Eisenberg Cc:Council, City; Office of the Provost; Jeanne Fleming; Jim Hersh; Marty Wasserman; Roseline Rasolovoahangy; Roberta Ahlquist; Aram James Subject:Why is L.A."s fire-evacuation plan still untested? - Los Angeles Times Date:Sunday, July 27, 2025 7:55:04 AM Attachments:Why is L.A."s fire-evacuation plan still untested - Los Angeles Times.pdfATT00001.txt CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. Dear Joe Has Palo Alto/mid Penn plan been tested. Indeed, what is the plan? Has it been presented tocouncil and the public. If so, kindly share link. All best Henry Neighbors for Environmental and Social Justice 2024 Candidate for Palo Alto City CouncilWww.triplehelix.net https://www.latimes.com/environment/story/2025-07-25/l-a-fire-evacuation-plans-remain-untested Lauren Martinez, right, talks about the delayed evacuation warnings during the Eaton fire to locals gathered at the Good Neighbor Bar in Altadena on June 2. (Carlin Stiehl / Los Angeles Times) CLIMATE & ENVIRONMENT Months after the Jan. 7 fires, L.A.’s evacuation plans remain untested ALITADENA CALFORNAUSA 國效 Sections 7/27/25, 7:42 AMPage 1 of 14 By Noah Haggerty Staff Writer | Follow July 25, 2025 3 AM PT A state law requires cities and counties to evaluate whether quick and safe evacuations are feasible. The city of L.A. has failed to publicly report such an analysis. Meanwhile, L.A. County simply listed every road that is paved, public and not a dead end. Just before sunrise on Nov. 8, 2018, a power line fell from a wind-worn Pacific Gas & Electric transmission tower and whipped into the structure nestled in the Sierra foothills. An electric arc sent molten metal into the dry vegetation below. It ignited. Five minutes later, a PG&E employee spotted the fire while driving on a nearby highway and reported it. Within two hours of the sighting, the town of Paradise, seven miles away, sent its first evacuation order, but it was already too late. Within two minutes, flames were reported at the town’s edge. Landing embers quickly ignited dozens of spot fires in town. With only four major roads out of town, the streets quickly gridlocked. Paradise burned. Sixty-four people died in Paradise during the agonizing seven-hour evacuation. Six of them were found in or next to their cars as they tried to evacuate. 7/27/25, 7:42 AMPage 2 of 14 Marc Levine, a state legislator at the time, listened over radio to the horrific scenes of people, stuck in traffic, abandoning their cars to flee on foot. “It made me think of the people falling from the World Trade Centers on 9/11,” he said. “They were going to be incinerated or they were going to jump. … They knew they would die either way.” So, Levine wrote legislation requiring California cities and counties to analyze whether their roads could support a quick evacuation during emergencies such as fires, floods and tsunamis. Assembly Bill 747 passed in 2019. Yet, to date, the city of Los Angeles has failed to publicly report such an analysis, while fire safety advocates say L.A. County’s evacuation analysis fails to meet the law’s requirements. The Times reached out to nearly a dozen city, county and state agencies involved with evacuation planning. All either did not respond to requests for comment, could not to point to an evacuation analysis in line with the state’s guidelines for AB 747 or indicated the responsibility for doing the work lies with other agencies. “The fact that local government leaders would not do as much as they can to protect human life and safety is just shocking to me,” Levine said. In January, the streets of Pacific Palisades mirrored the scene that distressed Levine in 2018. Traffic was at a standstill on Sunset Boulevard and Palisades Drive — two of the only routes out of the burning landscape. When a spot fire exploded next to the route, police ran down the street, shouting at evacuees to 7/27/25, 7:42 AMPage 3 of 14 run for their lives. Every year, dozens of evacuations are ordered in California, organized and completed without any casualties — or even a news story. In these cases, public safety officials have all the lead time that they need to organize a safe and orderly evacuation before a fire reaches a community. But it’s the much more dire evacuation scenarios — when the lead time is shorter than the time it takes to evacuate, like in the Palisades — where emergency planning is both most important and often ignored. “There’s no incentive to ever present an evacuation plan that isn’t very positive,” said Thomas Cova, a professor at the University of Utah who studies wildfire evacuation analysis. “Why would an emergency planner — say some young upstart in an emergency operation center — ever want to present a plan to their colleagues that involves some people burning?” The chaos of these worst-case scenario evacuations often looks nothing like the orderly phased evacuations cities often focus on. Unlike in “blue sky” evacuations, smoke can hinder visibility and cause crashes. Often whole towns must leave at once. Power outages can prevent public safety officials from communicating with residents. It’s why Marylee Guinon — president of the State Alliance for Firesafe Road Regulations, an advocacy group aimed at protecting and expanding the state’s community fire safety requirements — suspects AB 747 is facing pushback from local governments. “They don’t want data that would tell them that it’s going to 7/27/25, 7:42 AMPage 4 of 14 be a nine-hour evacuation,” she said. All the while, the risk of fast-moving fires is growing. In a 2024 study, researchers from the University of Colorado in Boulder analyzed more than 60,000 fires documented by NASA satellites in the first two decades of the 21st century. By 2020, fires in California were growing, on average, four times faster than they were in 2001. L.A.’s missing evacuation analyses AB 747 requires local governments to include their evacuation analyses in the safety element of their general plan — the long-term blueprint for future development of a city or county. The city of L.A.’s current safety element provides no such analysis. Instead, it simply lists evacuation planning as “ongoing.” In a statement to The Times, the city’s Planning Department, responsible for writing and revising the general plan, said details of evacuation routes are not made publicly available since “large urban cities such as the City of Los Angeles are high profile targets for terrorist attacks.” The city did not immediately clarify what legal authority it has to keep the analysis private as California law generally requires safety elements to be public. 7/27/25, 7:42 AMPage 5 of 14 “It is a mystery how hiding evacuation route capacity and viability can save lives when community members are fleeing a natural disaster,” Levine said in an email to The Times. “It is a dubious claim that terrorists could possibly be well positioned to take advantage of such a catastrophic situation.” Meanwhile, the county said it complied through an analysis it included in its 2025 safety element. However, fire safety advocates criticized the county’s analysis as simplistic and failing to adequately determine whether quick and safe evacuations are feasible. The Governor’s Office of Land Use and Climate Innovation, which provides guidance on state planning laws, recommended that local governments use traffic software to simulate different evacuations to estimate how long they might take. Instead, the county grabbed a list of all roads in unincorporated areas within its borders and listed them as “evacuation routes” so long as they were paved, public and not a dead end. The intent of the law is “not ‘just list the roads you have,’” Levine said. “So I’m super disappointed that L.A. County is dismissive in this way. You would expect, particularly post this year’s fires, Palisades and Eaton, they would take this far more seriously.” When pressed on their deviations from the state’s guidance, both the city and county planning departments deferred to the California Department of Forestry and Fire Protection, which indicated in assessments that the two departments’ safety elements were compliant. 7/27/25, 7:42 AMPage 6 of 14 Cal Fire, however, said that its assessments were nonbinding and that complying with the law falls on the city and county. Yet, none of the local or state agencies directly responded to an inquiry from The Times asking them to explain the discrepancy between the guidance and the safety elements. The city and county both have detailed evacuation plans that coordinate how public safety officials in the emergency operations and police and fire departments would orchestrate a mass exodus. However, the analysis of roadway networks to estimate how long those evacuations — even if perfectly orchestrated — may take, is different. “Historically, fire agencies put forth evacuation plans that are operationally driven,” said retired Fire Battalion Chief Doug Flaherty. “They talk about communications. They talk about unified command. … What is missing is an actual detailed, road-by-roadway capacity analysis of the time that it’s going to take for people to safely evacuate the area.” For Guinon, the lack of follow-through from cities and counties across the state is indicative of a common trend in wildfire legislation. “Virtually every piece of legislation that I dig into, I find out it was the result of a tragic catastrophe,” she said. “This legislation comes out with really, really clear intent over and over, and then it gets forgotten.” Understanding the problem is half the solution 7/27/25, 7:42 AMPage 7 of 14 Despite the complexity of simulating cars on a computerized network of roads to understand evacuation times, the scientific prowess exists — and the software to do it is widely accessible. When Flaherty, a Tahoe Basin resident, became frustrated with his area’s lack of movement on the issue, he commissioned an evacuation study through his nonprofit, TahoeCleanAir.org. The retired fire battalion chief, with 50 years of emergency response planning experience under his belt, partnered with Leo Zlimen, fresh out of UC Berkeley and co-founder of the emergency management software startup Ladris. “We fell into this wildfire space because everywhere we looked, people were [asking] ‘draw a circle on the map and tell me how long it takes to get those people out,’” Zlimen said. “And it turns out, that’s actually a really complicated problem.” Ladris’ software simulates realistic fire evacuations. It starts by taking a map of roads in a community and plopping little purple dots at virtually every home. Each one represents a vehicle. A fire starts on the map. It spreads. The purple dots get orders to flee, and the evacuation starts. The computer can play out a multihour evacuation in mere seconds, and it can account for an excruciating amount of detail. A roadblock, representing a falling tree or car crash, can stop purple dots from using a portion of the road. Some 7/27/25, 7:42 AMPage 8 of 14 purple dots, not realizing how dire the situation is, wait an extra few minutes — or hours — to evacuate. The dots even wait their turn at stop signs, crosswalks and traffic lights. Ladris’ software simulates realistic fire evacuations. It starts by taking a map of roads in a community and plopping little purple dots at virtually every home. Each one represents a vehicle. (Ladris) Ladris’ program almost looks like a video game. Officials can test evacuation scenarios far in advance or in real time during an emergency. The company is also working to use artificial intelligence to help quickly configure scenarios so users can almost literally “draw a circle on the map” and get an evacuation time. 7/27/25, 7:42 AMPage 9 of 14 Flaherty said his detailed Tahoe Basin study, a comprehensive analysis based on Ladris’ simulations, had a price tag just shy of $100,000 — roughly equivalent to the cost of installing one traffic light in town. “In the scheme of things, it’s very cost effective and reasonably priced,” he said. Another piece of software from Old Dominion University — simpler than Ladris’ — is available to the public for free. It takes less than half an hour to set up a simulation in the program, called FLEET (for “Fast Local Emergency Evacuation Times”). Consequently, it’s been used not only by local governments making fire evacuation plans, but also by Scouting America troops interested in flood hazards and sporting event planners wondering how bad the postgame traffic may be. Among those using FLEET simulations for evacuation planning: the town of Paradise. How to shorten a five-hour evacuation After the Camp fire, Paradise became an inadvertent experiment in how towns can better prepare for evacuations. After the disaster, it won a $199-million federal grant for infrastructure projects designed to rebuild Paradise into a more fire-safe town. Before the fire, the town’s entire yearly budget was around $12 million. 7/27/25, 7:42 AMPage 10 of 14 After the Camp fire, Paradise hired a traffic consulting firm that used FLEET. It found an evacuation would take over five hours under perfect conditions while utilizing all traffic lanes. It then used the modeling to understand what could be done to alter traffic flow to reduce that time. For Paradise — as is the case for many towns — a big problem is traffic bottlenecks: To evacuate, virtually the entire town has to use one of four main roads. The seemingly most straightforward solution? Build more roads. However, these projects get complicated fast, said Marc Mattox, Paradise’s public works director and town engineer. Often the roads that a municipality needs to improve evacuation would have to go through private property — a nonstarter for residents in the proposed path. Or, it’s simply too costly. Although Paradise has received funds to widen two evacuation routes and connect three dead ends with the rest of town, a new evacuation route out of town would be prohibitively expensive. Mattox estimated such a route, navigating Paradise’s steep ridges and canyons, would cost in excess of half a billion dollars. So, Paradise has also invested in a much cheaper, yet still effective tool to speed up evacuations: clear communication. Paradise installed signs all over town that proclaim when residents enter and exit different evacuation zones. The town is also looking into using a different 7/27/25, 7:42 AMPage 11 of 14 color sign for private or dead-end roads that warn drivers to avoid them, as well as digital signs above key roadways that can display real-time evacuation information. In Southern California, Malibu — which completed an evacuation analysis after it suffered the Woolsey fire the same day as the Camp fire — has similar plans. Malibu is adding reflective markers to roadways to reduce the chances of crashes amid thick smoke. For neighborhoods with few evacuation routes and individuals with limited mobility, the city encourages evacuating whenever the National Weather Service warns of dangerous fire weather — well before a possible ignition. Los Angeles is much bigger than Malibu and Paradise — L.A. has a population of 3.9 million; Paradise’s is just over 9,100. But evacuation experts said it’s no excuse for letting California’s rural towns take the lead on evacuation planning. Asked whether the sprawling labyrinth of L.A. roads would make doing these analyses more difficult, Zlimen smiled. “Not really — no,” he said, noting Ladris has completed analyses in the San Francisco Bay Area. “It’s totally possible.” Guinon hopes the results of evacuation analyses can also help — or force — cities to make more responsible residential development plans in the first place. “It’s not rocket science,” she said. “Let’s just take on protection of our existing 7/27/25, 7:42 AMPage 12 of 14 Noah Haggerty Noah Haggerty is an environment, health and science reporter at the Los Angeles Times. With a background in physics, he has conducted research on spacecraft propulsion, fusion energy and plasma — the stuff that makes up communities and let the chips fall where they may with new development: If it’s unsafe, don’t build it.” More to Read Months after the fires, how safe is it to swim at L.A.’s beaches? May 16, 2025 Do you live in a wildfire hazard zone? Here’s what that means April 3, 2025 New fire maps increase hazard zones in L.A. and Southern California by 3.5 million acres March 24, 2025 7/27/25, 7:42 AMPage 13 of 14 Copyright © 2025, Los Angeles Times | Terms of Service | Privacy Policy | CA Notice of Collection | Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information lightning and the sun. He joined The Times in 2024 as an AAAS Mass Media Fellow. 7/27/25, 7:42 AMPage 14 of 14 From:Aram James To:Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Veenker, Vicki Cc:Josh Becker; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23; Jeff Rosen; Jeff Hayden; Jeff Conrad; Marty Wasserman; Palo Alto Free Press; Donna Wallach; Gardener, Liz; Lotus Fong; Roberta Ahlquist; Reifschneider, James; james pitkin; Mark Turner; Michelle Bigelow; CityCouncil; Binder, Andrew; Don Austin; Yolanda Conaway; Emily Mibach; Dave Price; Gerry Gras; Dana St. George; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; District3@sanjoseca.gov; Councilmember Chappie Jones; District4@sanjoseca.gov; District5@sanjoseca.gov; District9@sanjoseca.gov; dennis burns; DuJuan Green; Roberta Ahlquist; Friends of Cubberley; Sheree Roth; Lori Meyers; Steve Wagstaffe; Doug Minkler; Donna Wallach; Figueroa, Eric; Afanasiev, Alex; Sean Allen; EPA Today; Gennady Sheyner; Council, City; GRP-City Council; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com; Julie Lythcott-Haims; Templeton, Cari; Cribbs, Anne; planning.commission@cityofpaloalto.0rg; ParkRec Commission Subject:Source: The Intercept— Israel’s creation myth Date:Saturday, July 26, 2025 9:42:23 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. In it, you talk about the use of myth to justify or perpetuate war. In one context, you talk about the creation myth of Israel and how Israelis are unwilling toquestion what they’re conditioned to believe about the state of Israel. Source: The Intercept Starvation as a Weapon: Chris Hedges on Gazahttps://share.google/QmqqFEiuHOTTQStYX From:Peggy E. Kraft To:Council, City Subject:Rail Committee Meetings Date:Saturday, July 26, 2025 12:11:42 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. To whom it may concern, The latest City of Palo Alto Uplift newsletter says that there will be Rail Committee meetings in August for Grade Separation. The website for the Rail Committee states that they are every Tuesday, but when I open the link for meetings I cannot find any meetings listed. Can you please direct me to the person or website that can tell me how to attend the next Rail Committee meeting? Thank you. Peggy Kraft Palo Alto ,CA From:Aram James To:Palo Alto Free Press Cc:Veenker, Vicki; Lythcott-Haims, Julie; Reckdahl, Keith; Ed Lauing; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23; Lori Meyers; Sheree Roth; h.etzko@gmail.com; Binder, Andrew; Mark Turner; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; Josh Becker; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Julie Lythcott-Haims; Figueroa, Eric; Doug Minkler; Gerry Gras; EPA Today; Gennady Sheyner; city.council@menlopark.gov; dcombs@menlopark.gov; Steve Wagstaffe; Jeff Rosen; Jeff Conrad; Jeff Hayden; Jay Boyarsky; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas; Mickie Winkler; Sean Allen; Cait James; San José Spotlight; board@pausd.org; boardfeedback@smcgov.org; board@valleywater.org; BoardOperations; Braden Cartwright; Raymond Goins; Rodriguez, Miguel; editor@paweekly.com; Wagner, April; Don Austin; Donna Wallach; Burt, Patrick; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov; Seher Awan; Daniel Barton; David Piper; Foley, Michael; Zelkha, Mila; Palo Alto Renters" Association; Diana Diamond; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com; ladoris cordell; cromero@cityofepa.org; rabrica@cityofepa.org; Bill Newell; Bill Johnson; Bill James; Pat M; Carla Torres; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; Council, City; GRP-City Council; Perron, Zachary; City Attorney; citycouncil@mountainview.gov; Clerk, City; GRP-City Clerk; Friends of Cubberley; Lotus Fong; ParkRec Commission; Gardener, Liz; Human Relations Commission; Holman, Karen (external); Liz Kniss; Patrice Ventresca; Rowena Chiu; Dana St. George; Damon Silver; Daniel Kottke; Dennis Upton; Zahra Billoo; james pitkin; Roberta Ahlquist; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Supervisor Otto Lee; Salem Ajluni; Stump, Molly; Rosen, Jeff; Baker, Rob; Ruth Silver Taube; Tom DuBois; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Jasso, Tamara; DuJuan Green; Dennis Upton; dennis burns; Jensen, Eric; Afanasiev, Alex; Lee, Craig; Anna Griffin; Angel, David; Greg Tanaka; Reifschneider, James; Bryan Gobin; Yolanda Conaway; Donna Wallach; Vara Ramakrishnan; Marty Wasserman; Dave Price; Dan Okonkwo; Jennifer Morrow San José Spotlight; Emily Mibach; MGR-Melissa Stevenson Diaz; vramirez@redwoodcity.org; Nicole Chiu-Wang; Rowena Chiu; Senator Becker; frances.Rothschild@jud.ca.gov; Michael Pati; Marina Lopez; Josie James-Le; Tim James; sharon jackson; Lewis James; Douglas A. Murray; Freddie.Quintana@sen.ca.gov; Michael Ybarra; yolanda; Seher Awan; Roberta Ahlquist Subject:Re: Famine Expert: Israel"s Starvation of Gaza Most "Minutely Designed and Controlled" Since WWII Date:Friday, July 25, 2025 9:58:35 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. Hi Mark, I place no blame on Hamas for the current situation. For decades, the U.S. and Israel have kept the people of Gaza in what can only be described as the largest outdoor prison and concentration camp in world history. This reality is well-documented by Jewish scholars like Norman Finkelstein and Israeli scholar Ilan Pappé. Like Nat Turner Hamas members can be viewed as freedom fighters of the first order. . It was known to Israel that Hamas was preparing for the October 7 attack for a significant period—possibly weeks or even months—before the actual event. The IDF was ordered to stand down by military leaders with the full consent of Prime Minister Bibi Netanyahu. It seems that Israel sought a precipitating event to trigger violence, aiming toward the total ethnic cleansing of the Palestinian people from their historic homeland. Based on historical records that predate its establishment in 1948, Israel and its Zionist leadership have always planned to expel the Palestinian people through violence and military force. The Israelis routinely dehumanize the Palestinian people, similarly to how Europeans characterized Native Americans, providing justification for land theft and atrocities (Settler Colonialism). This is not a conflict between two equal parties. It is Israel, supported by substantial military and financial aid from the U.S. (billions of dollars every year), engaged in a systematic slaughter of the Palestinian people. Israel possesses one of the most powerful militaries in the world, with a functioning army, navy, air force, and nuclear weapons. In contrast, Palestine has no army, no navy, no air force, and no nuclear weapons. The Palestinians survive through their resourcefulness, while Israel relies on military strength supplied by the U.S. This situation transcends the classic narrative of David versus Goliath. Avram “Eliminate the state of Israel now." — Finkelstein On Tue, Jul 22, 2025 at 10:28 PM Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: The ongoing genocide and war crimes committed by Israel, with the full support of the United States, will eventually be prosecuted in the International Criminal Court in The Hague. This will happen regardless of any alleged actions by Hamas. It is crucial to understand that the ongoing genocide is a separate and distinct crime from the alleged behavior of the group referred to as Hamas (freedom fighters). As Bob Dylan famously said, “You don't need a weatherman to know which way the wind blows.” In a similar vein, you don’t need a genocide expert to recognize that Israel is currently engaged in a massive, full- blown genocide of the Palestinian people. One can offer various intellectual rationalizations, but the reality remains indisputable—the actions of the state of Israel amount to genocide beyond all reasonable doubt. Israel is guilty as charged of war crimes and genocide. Avram “Let The Prosecution Begin” Finkelstein On Tue, Jul 22, 2025 at 10:23 PM Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote: The bias of the author is evident in the fact that the entire article mentionsHamas only once, in passing. Hamas could end the suffering tomorrow just by laying down their arms and releasing the hostages. But they care more about scoring propaganda points against Israel than about saving the lives of their own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 22, 2025, at 3:08 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvationof Gaza Most 'Minutely Designedand Controlled' Since WWII Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed andControlled' Since WWII | Common Dreams https://www.commondreams.org/news/famine-expert-israel-s-starvation-of-gaza-most-minutely-designed-and-controlled-since-wwii From:Aram JamesTo:Donna WallachCc:Martin Wasserman; Sean Allen; Salem Ajluni; Veenker, Vicki; Lythcott-Haims, Julie; Reckdahl, Keith; Ed Lauing; jessica@speiser.net; Lori Meyers; Sheree Roth; h.etzko@gmail.com; Binder, Andrew; Mark Turner; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; Josh Becker;assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Julie Lythcott-Haims; Figueroa, Eric; Doug Minkler; Gerry Gras; Today EPA; Gennady Sheyner; city.council@menlopark.gov; dcombs@menlopark.gov; Steve Wagstaffe; Jeff Rosen; Jeff Conrad; Jeff Hayden; JayBoyarsky; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com; Enberg, Nicholas; Mickie Winkler; Cait James; San José Spotlight; board@pausd.org; boardfeedback@smcgov.org; board@valleywater.org; BoardOperations; Braden Cartwright; RaymondGoins; Miguel Rodriguez; editor@paweekly.com; Wagner, April; Don Austin; Burt, Patrick; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov; Palo Alto Free Press; Seher Awan; Daniel Barton; David Piper; Foley, Michael; Zelkha, Mila; Renters" Association Palo Alto; Diana Diamond;jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com; ladoris cordell; cromero@cityofepa.org; rabrica@cityofepa.org; Bill Newell; Bill Johnson; Bill James; Pat M; Carla Torres; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; Council, City; GRP-City Council; Perron, Zachary; City Attorney;citycouncil@mountainview.gov; Clerk, City; GRP-City Clerk; Friends of Cubberley; Lotus Fong; ParkRec Commission; Gardener, Liz; Human Relations Commission; Holman, Karen (external); Liz Kniss; Patrice Ventresca; Rowena Chiu; Dana St. George; DamonSilver; Daniel Kottke; Dennis Upton; Zahra Billoo; james pitkin; Roberta Ahlquist; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Supervisor Otto Lee; Stump, Molly; Jeff Rosen; Rob Baker; Ruth Silver Taube; Tom DuBois; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Jasso, Tamara; DuJuan Green;Dennis Upton; dennis burns; Jensen, Eric; Afanasiev, Alex; Lee, Craig; Anna Griffin; David Angel; Greg Tanaka; Reifschneider, James; Bryan Gobin; Yolanda Conaway; Donna Wallach; Vara Ramakrishnan; Tim James; Tim James; Lewis James; JIM MINKLER1;Dave Price; Emily Mibach; frances.Rothschild@jud.ca.gov; Michael Pati; Henry RiggsSubject:Re: Famine Expert: Israel"s Starvation of Gaza Most "Minutely Designed and Controlled" Since WWIIDate:Friday, July 25, 2025 5:52:48 PMAttachments:image1.png CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. Excellent piece, Donna! Aram On Fri, Jul 25, 2025 at 5:16 PM Donna Wallach <donnaisanactivist@gmail.com> wrote:Martin Wasserman you are as despicable as all the other Zionists who refuse to open your eyes, your mind and your hearts. You are the same as the hateful Klu Klux Klan who murdered andcontinue to murder Black Americans just because they are Black. There is so much truthful online information about the War Crimes, genocide, starvation that the Israeli govt is committing infull live stream view for the entire world to see. Israeli journalists are reporting about it, i.e. Gideon Levy and Amira Hass. Other Israelis are reporting about it, Ilan Pappe is one, right now I'mforgetting the name of the other one. Tens of thousands of young American Jews protested on campuses across the USA along with tens of thousands of other students against the genocide, many of them sacrificed their diplomas. JVP has issued many statements and calls for ending the genocide, calling for a ceasefire. The Palestinians have done nothing to deserve this genocide, Ethnic cleansing and starvation, that recently Ralph Nader is calling an Omnicide meaning that the intent of Israel is to eliminate theentire Palestinian population living there from the face of the earth. The Israeli govt continues to say that their goal is to make Gaza Jewish and to annex the entire West Bank and to remove byforce each and every Palestinian Martin get your head out of your butt! You disgust me beyond words! The Palestinans are one of the most kindest, lovingest, generous people I have ever met and lived among. Free Palestine! Long Live Palestine! "Nobody in the world, nobody in history, has ever gotten their freedom by appealing to the moral sense of the people who were oppressing them."Assata Shakur Books you must read: "Against Our Better Judgement: The hidden history of how the U.S. was used to create Israel" by Alison Weirhttp://www.againstourbetterjudgment.com/ "State of Terror: How Terrorism Created Modern Israel" by Thomas Suarezhttp://thomassuarez.com/SoT.html "The Hundred Years War on Palestine"by Rashid Khalidi "The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine"by Illan Pappé Free Palestine!Right of Return to Palestine for all Palestinians! Free all political prisoners! Mumia Abu-Jamal @mumiafreedomtourThe Holy Land Five: Shukri Abu Baker Ghassan Elashi Mufid Abdulqader Abdulrahman Odeh Mohammad Elmezainhttps://www.mintpressnews.com/the-trial-and-conviction-of-the-holy-land-foundation-five/237440/and thousands more End Solitary Confinementhttps://prisonerhungerstrikesolidarity.wordpress.com California Prison Focus http://newest.prisons.org/our_story End United $tates of Amerikkka invasions and occupationsU.S. Government and UN Occupation Force Soldiers - Hands off Haiti!http://www.haitisolidarity.net/ Syria Solidarity Movement, Solidarity with the Syrian people https://syriasupportmovement.org Donna WallachDonnaIsAnActivist@gmail.comInstagram: @palestine_is_and_will_be_freeInstagram: @donnawallach1Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/donna.wallachTwitter: @PalestineWillBe(cell) 408-569-6608 On Fri, Jul 25, 2025, 12:26 Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:Hamas could end the suffering anytime it wants just by laying down its arms and releasing the hostages. But it has no interest in ending the suffering. As part of a culturethat defines itself as revering death rather than life, Hamas believes that any Gazan who dies of starvation will go straight to heaven as a martyr, so there's really noproblem. And it also serves as good anti-Israel propaganda. Martin Wasserman On Jul 25, 2025, at 8:26 AM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Why Is the World Letting It Happen?”: U.K. Surgeon, Back from Gaza, on Starving Children | Democracy Now! https://www.democracynow.org/2025/7/25/nick_maynard_gaza On Fri, Jul 25, 2025 at 12:30 AM Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com > wrote: Good evening, Martin, I want to start by expressing my apologies before we delve into today’s discussion. Unfortunately, several major U.S. media outlets have reported perspectives that contradictyour position. I find that your argument lacks substantial logic. Given the global perception of the United States as a superior military power, it raises the question of how thepeople of Gaza, even under Hamas leadership, could pose a significant threat to any country supported by U.S. military resources. The attached photos speak volumes andchallenge the validity of your position. Best regards, Sean Sent from my iPhone On Jul 24, 2025, at 6:36 PM, Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote: This is utter nonsense. If Israel's modus operandi has always been "maximal violence and aggression with little to no regard for the sanctity oflives of civilian non-combatants,” why did they sign the 1993 Oslo Accord which brought Yasser Arafat and the PLO out of exile and gave themsovereignty of Arab areas in Judea and Samaria? And why did they forcibly evacuate all Jewish settlements in Gaza in 2005 instead ofstrengthening those settlements and digging in? The reality is, it was always the Arab leadership that sought to exterminate the Jews, giving theJews no choice but to fight back. When Israel goes to war, it goes to great lengths to avoid civilian casualties, but groups like Hamas go out of their way to target Israeli civilians,and the Palestinian Authority gives large cash rewards to any Arab who murders any Jew, whether civilian or otherwise. Right now, people in Gaza are starving, not because of Israel, but because Hamas refuses to lay down its arms and release the hostages. Theconflict would be over tomorrow if Hamas would do these simple things. In fact, Hamas tries forcibly, often with gunfire, to prevent Gazans fromreceiving life-giving aid that doesn't come through them, saying that receiving such aid amounts to "collaborating with the enemy.” The truth is, Israel has displayed more concern for the lives of Gazan civilians than the Gazans’ own leaders have. Perhaps the reason for this isthat Israeli culture is based on reverence for life, while Hamas culture defines itself as revering death, and seeking martyrdom in battle as thehighest possible goal. Martin Wasserman On Jul 24, 2025, at 2:45 PM, Salem Ajluni <ajluni@hotmail.com> wrote: As a modest contribution to a better understanding of the thinking and practices of the Israeli state, past and present, I recommend a very useful and short book that I read more than 40 years ago. It was written by Livia Rokach, the daughter of Israel Rokach who was the Israeli Interior Minister in the government of Moshe Sharett, the latter being the second prime minister of the new state (1953-1955). She translated and published her father's diaries, as well as parts of Sharett's diaries, both of which give us insights into the private elite thinking, planning and actions of main actors in the Israeli state vis-a-vis its neighboring countries in the 1950s (and vis-s-vis the U.S. and European powers) (see https://ia804501.us.archive.org/17/items/sacred-terrorism/Sacred-Terrorism.pdf). The resonance and parallels between Israeli leadership thinking and actions in the 1950s (as explained by Rokach) and in the 21st century with regard to the states and peoples of Lebanon, Syria, the West Bank, Gaza and Egypt (and, by extension, Iraq, Yemen and Iran) are instructive. There are considerable continuities across time and space: aggressive and domineering (supremicist?) thinking and behavior; an expansionist impulse; a sociopathic and homicidal (genocidal?) animus towards Arabs, especially Palestinians. It was all there in the 1940s and 1950s, as Rokach tells us, and it's all there now, as we witness on a daily basis. Israel certainly didn't need Hamas to induce such thinking and behavior. In fact, the Hamas movement wasn't formally inaugurated until late 1987, almost two generations after the establishment of the state of Israel. Reading historical accounts of the conflict teaches us that only the bugaboo changes (e.g. Nasser, the PLO, Saddam Hussein, Hizballah, Hamas, the Houthis, Iran, etc.)—the Israeli modus operandi is more or less a constant--maximal violence and aggression with little to no regard for the sanctity of the lives of civilian non-combatants. The Israeli state was ushered in and made possible by the intial displacement of the majority of Mandate Palestine's Arab population during 1947-1949 (on these events, see Ilan Pappe's book based in large part on official Israeli archival sourceshttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ethnic_Cleansing_of_Palestine). It behooves us to remember that about two-thirds of Gaza's population are themselves refugees from Madate Palestine or the offspring of those refugees. No disconinuities there either. Regards, Salem From: Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:23 PMTo: Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> Cc: Veenker, Vicki <Vicki.Veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lythcott-Haims, Julie <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Keith Reckdahl <reckdahl@yahoo.com>; Ed Lauing <elauing@equitysearchpartners.com>; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23 <jessica@speiser.net>; Lori Meyers <meyers.lk@gmail.com>; Sheree Roth <ssroth29@gmail.com>; Henry Etzkowitz <H.Etzko@gmail.com>; Binder, Andrew <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mark Turner <mark.turner@morganhill.ca.gov>; CityCouncil <CityCouncil@morganhill.ca.gov>; Michelle Bigelow <Michelle.Bigelow@morganhill.ca.gov>; Josh Becker <becker.josh@gmail.com>; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov<assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <julieforpaloalto@gmail.com>;eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org <eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org>; Doug Minkler <dminkler@dminkler.com>; Gerry Gras <gerrygras@earthlink.net>; EPA Today <epatoday@epatoday.org>; Gennady Sheyner <gsheyner@embarcaderomedia.org>; city.council@menlopark.gov <city.council@menlopark.gov>; dcombs@menlopark.gov <dcombs@menlopark.gov>; Steve Wagstaffe <swagstaffe@smcgov.org>; Jeff Rosen <info@jeffrosen.org>; Jeff Conrad <jeff_conrad@msn.com>; Jeff Hayden <laptoplg@mac.com>; Jay Boyarsky <jboyarsky@dao.sccgov.org>; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto <wilpf.peninsula.paloalto@gmail.com>; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com> <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas <nicholas.enberg@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mickie Winkler <mickie650@gmail.com>; Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com>; Cait James <caitlin.a.james@gmail.com>; San José Spotlight <info@sanjosespotlight.com>; board@pausd.org <board@pausd.org>; boardfeedback@smcgov.org <boardfeedback@smcgov.org>; board@valleywater.org<board@valleywater.org>; BoardOperations <BoardOperations@cob.sccgov.org>; Braden Cartwright <bcartwright@padailypost.com>; Raymond Goins <goinsrayl@gmail.com>; Rodriguez, Miguel <miguel.rodriguez@pdo.sccgov.org>; editor@paweekly.com <editor@paweekly.com>; April Wagner <april.wagner@cityofpaloalto.org>; Don Austin <daustin@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <donnaisanactivist@gmail.com>; Burt, Patrick <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov <Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov>; Palo Alto Free Press <paloaltofreepress@gmail.com>; Seher Awan <firebrand.dr@gmail.com>; Daniel Barton <dbarton@nbo.law>; David Piper <david.piper@wvm.edu>; michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org <michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mila Zelkha <mila.zelkha@gmail.com>; Palo Alto Renters' Association <info@paloaltorenters.org>; Diana Diamond <dianaLdiamond@gmail.com>; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com <jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com>; ladoris cordell <ladoris@judgecordell.com>; cromero@cityofepa.org <cromero@cityofepa.org>; rabrica@cityofepa.org<rabrica@cityofepa.org>; Bill Newell <billnewell2850@gmail.com>; Bill Johnson <bjohnson@paweekly.com>; Bill James <billjames99@gmail.com>; Pat M <p.marshall81@ymail.com>; Carla Torres <xicanamagic@hotmail.com>; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan <mayor@sanjoseca.gov>; CityCouncil <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Council <council@redwoodcity.org>; Zachary.Perron@CityofPaloAlto.org <zachary.perron@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Attorney <CityAttorney@santaclaraca.gov>; citycouncil@mountainview.gov <citycouncil@mountainview.gov>; Clerk, City <city.clerk@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Clerk <CLERK2@redwoodcity.org>; Friends of Cubberley <friendsofcubberley94303@gmail.com>; Lotus Fong <lyfong@pacbell.net>; ParkRec Commission <ParkRec.commission@cityofpaloalto.org>; Liz Gardner <Gardnerjaqua@gmail.com>; Human Relations Commission <hrc@cityofpaloalto.org>; Karen Holman <kcholman@sbcglobal.net>; Liz Kniss <lizkniss@earthlink.net>; Patrice Ventresca <patriceventresca@gmail.com>; Rowena Chiu <rowena.chiu@gmail.com>; Dana St. George <danasg@earthlink.net>; Damon Silver <damon.silver@pdo.sccgov.org>; Daniel Kottke <daniel.k@earthlink.net>; Dennis Upton <kathy8420@qq.com>; Zahra Billoo <zbilloo@cair.com>; james pitkin <jamespitkin777@yahoo.com>; Roberta Ahlquist <roberta.ahlquist@sjsu.edu>; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg <supervisor.ellenberg@bos.sccgov.org>; Supervisor Otto Lee <supervisor.lee@bos.sccgov.org>; Salem Ajluni <ajluni@hotmail.com>; Stump, Molly <molly.stump@cityofpaloalto.org>; Rosen, Jeff <JRosen@dao.sccgov.org>; Baker, Rob <rbaker@dao.sccgov.org>; Ruth Silver Taube <ruthsilvertaube16@gmail.com>; Tom DuBois <tom.dubois@gmail.com>; Blackshire, Geoffrey <Geo.Blackshire@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jasso, Tamara <Tamara.Jasso@cityofpaloalto.org>; DuJuan Green <dujuang@sbcglobal.net>; Dennis Upton <denkafer1@yahoo.com>; dennis burns <dennis.r.burns@gmail.com>; Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org <Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org>; Alex Afanasiev <Alex.Afanasiev@cityofpaloalto.org>; craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org <craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org>; Anna Griffin <griffinam@sbcglobal.net>; Angel, David <dangel@dao.sccgov.org>; Greg Tanaka <greg@gregtanaka.org>; Reifschneider, James <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Bryan Gobin <appeal.bryan.gobin@gmail.com>; Yolanda Conaway <yconaway@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <cats4jazz@gmail.com>; Vara Ramakrishnan <vara@acm.org> Subject: Re: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' Since WWII The bias of the author is evident in the fact that the entire article mentions Hamas only once, in passing. Hamas could end the suffering tomorrow just by laying down their arms and releasing the hostages. But they care more about scoringpropaganda points against Israel than about saving the lives of their own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 22, 2025, at 3:08 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvationof Gaza Most 'Minutely Designedand Controlled' Since WWII Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' Since WWII | CommonDreamshttps://www.commondreams.org/news/famine-expert-israel-s-starvation-of-gaza-most-minutely-designed-and-controlled-since-wwii From:Aram JamesTo:Josh Becker; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23Cc:Martin Wasserman; Sean Allen; Salem Ajluni; Veenker, Vicki; Lythcott-Haims, Julie; Reckdahl, Keith; Ed Lauing; Lori Meyers; Sheree Roth; h.etzko@gmail.com; Binder, Andrew; Mark Turner; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow;assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Julie Lythcott-Haims; Figueroa, Eric; Doug Minkler; Gerry Gras; Today EPA; Gennady Sheyner; city.council@menlopark.gov; dcombs@menlopark.gov; Steve Wagstaffe; Jeff Rosen; Jeff Conrad; Jeff Hayden; JayBoyarsky; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com; Enberg, Nicholas; Mickie Winkler; Cait James; San José Spotlight; board@pausd.org; boardfeedback@smcgov.org; board@valleywater.org; BoardOperations; Braden Cartwright; RaymondGoins; Miguel Rodriguez; editor@paweekly.com; Wagner, April; Don Austin; Burt, Patrick; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov; Palo Alto Free Press; Seher Awan; Daniel Barton; David Piper; Foley, Michael; Zelkha, Mila; Renters" Association Palo Alto; Diana Diamond;jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com; ladoris cordell; cromero@cityofepa.org; rabrica@cityofepa.org; Bill Newell; Bill Johnson; Bill James; Pat M; Carla Torres; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; Council, City; GRP-City Council; Perron, Zachary; City Attorney;citycouncil@mountainview.gov; Clerk, City; GRP-City Clerk; Friends of Cubberley; Lotus Fong; ParkRec Commission; Gardener, Liz; Human Relations Commission; Holman, Karen (external); Liz Kniss; Patrice Ventresca; Rowena Chiu; Dana St. George; DamonSilver; Daniel Kottke; Dennis Upton; Zahra Billoo; james pitkin; Roberta Ahlquist; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Supervisor Otto Lee; Stump, Molly; Jeff Rosen; Rob Baker; Ruth Silver Taube; Tom DuBois; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Jasso, Tamara; DuJuan Green;Dennis Upton; dennis burns; Jensen, Eric; Afanasiev, Alex; Lee, Craig; Anna Griffin; David Angel; Greg Tanaka; Reifschneider, James; Bryan Gobin; Yolanda Conaway; Donna Wallach; Vara Ramakrishnan; Tim James; Dave Price; MGR-Melissa Stevenson Diaz;vramirez@redwoodcity.org; Marina Lopez; JIM MINKLER1; yolanda; Emily Mibach; sharon jackson; Palo Alto Weekly; Henry Riggs; Roberta Ahlquist; Donna WallachSubject:Re: Famine Expert: Israel"s Starvation of Gaza Most "Minutely Designed and Controlled" Since WWIIDate:Friday, July 25, 2025 5:47:46 PMAttachments:image1.png CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. On Fri, Jul 25, 2025 at 5:16 PM Donna Wallach <donnaisanactivist@gmail.com> wrote:Martin Wasserman you are as despicable as all the other Zionists who refuse to open your eyes, your mind and your hearts. You are the same as the hateful Klu Klux Klan who murdered andcontinue to murder Black Americans just because they are Black. There is so much truthful online information about the War Crimes, genocide, starvation that the Israeli govt is committing infull live stream view for the entire world to see. Israeli journalists are reporting about it, i.e. Gideon Levy and Amira Hass. Other Israelis are reporting about it, Ilan Pappe is one, right now I'mforgetting the name of the other one. Tens of thousands of young American Jews protested on campuses across the USA along with tens of thousands of other students against the genocide, many of them sacrificed their diplomas. JVP has issued many statements and calls for ending the genocide, calling for a ceasefire. The Palestinians have done nothing to deserve this genocide, Ethnic cleansing and starvation, that recently Ralph Nader is calling an Omnicide meaning that the intent of Israel is to eliminate theentire Palestinian population living there from the face of the earth. The Israeli govt continues to say that their goal is to make Gaza Jewish and to annex the entire West Bank and to remove byforce each and every Palestinian Martin get your head out of your butt! You disgust me beyond words! The Palestinans are one of the most kindest, lovingest, generous people I have ever met and lived among. Free Palestine! Long Live Palestine! "Nobody in the world, nobody in history, has ever gotten their freedom by appealing to the moral sense of the people who were oppressing them."Assata Shakur Books you must read: "Against Our Better Judgement: The hidden history of how the U.S. was used to create Israel" by Alison Weirhttp://www.againstourbetterjudgment.com/ "State of Terror: How Terrorism Created Modern Israel" by Thomas Suarezhttp://thomassuarez.com/SoT.html "The Hundred Years War on Palestine"by Rashid Khalidi "The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine"by Illan Pappé Free Palestine!Right of Return to Palestine for all Palestinians! Free all political prisoners! Mumia Abu-Jamal @mumiafreedomtourThe Holy Land Five: Shukri Abu Baker Ghassan Elashi Mufid Abdulqader Abdulrahman Odeh Mohammad Elmezainhttps://www.mintpressnews.com/the-trial-and-conviction-of-the-holy-land-foundation-five/237440/and thousands more End Solitary Confinementhttps://prisonerhungerstrikesolidarity.wordpress.com California Prison Focus http://newest.prisons.org/our_story End United $tates of Amerikkka invasions and occupationsU.S. Government and UN Occupation Force Soldiers - Hands off Haiti!http://www.haitisolidarity.net/ Syria Solidarity Movement, Solidarity with the Syrian people https://syriasupportmovement.org Donna WallachDonnaIsAnActivist@gmail.comInstagram: @palestine_is_and_will_be_freeInstagram: @donnawallach1Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/donna.wallachTwitter: @PalestineWillBe(cell) 408-569-6608 On Fri, Jul 25, 2025, 12:26 Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:Hamas could end the suffering anytime it wants just by laying down its arms and releasing the hostages. But it has no interest in ending the suffering. As part of a culturethat defines itself as revering death rather than life, Hamas believes that any Gazan who dies of starvation will go straight to heaven as a martyr, so there's really noproblem. And it also serves as good anti-Israel propaganda. Martin Wasserman On Jul 25, 2025, at 8:26 AM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Why Is the World Letting It Happen?”: U.K. Surgeon, Back from Gaza, on Starving Children | Democracy Now! https://www.democracynow.org/2025/7/25/nick_maynard_gaza On Fri, Jul 25, 2025 at 12:30 AM Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com > wrote: Good evening, Martin, I want to start by expressing my apologies before we delve into today’s discussion. Unfortunately, several major U.S. media outlets have reported perspectives that contradictyour position. I find that your argument lacks substantial logic. Given the global perception of the United States as a superior military power, it raises the question of how thepeople of Gaza, even under Hamas leadership, could pose a significant threat to any country supported by U.S. military resources. The attached photos speak volumes andchallenge the validity of your position. Best regards, Sean Sent from my iPhone On Jul 24, 2025, at 6:36 PM, Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote: This is utter nonsense. If Israel's modus operandi has always been "maximal violence and aggression with little to no regard for the sanctity oflives of civilian non-combatants,” why did they sign the 1993 Oslo Accord which brought Yasser Arafat and the PLO out of exile and gave themsovereignty of Arab areas in Judea and Samaria? And why did they forcibly evacuate all Jewish settlements in Gaza in 2005 instead ofstrengthening those settlements and digging in? The reality is, it was always the Arab leadership that sought to exterminate the Jews, giving theJews no choice but to fight back. When Israel goes to war, it goes to great lengths to avoid civilian casualties, but groups like Hamas go out of their way to target Israeli civilians,and the Palestinian Authority gives large cash rewards to any Arab who murders any Jew, whether civilian or otherwise. Right now, people in Gaza are starving, not because of Israel, but because Hamas refuses to lay down its arms and release the hostages. Theconflict would be over tomorrow if Hamas would do these simple things. In fact, Hamas tries forcibly, often with gunfire, to prevent Gazans fromreceiving life-giving aid that doesn't come through them, saying that receiving such aid amounts to "collaborating with the enemy.” The truth is, Israel has displayed more concern for the lives of Gazan civilians than the Gazans’ own leaders have. Perhaps the reason for this isthat Israeli culture is based on reverence for life, while Hamas culture defines itself as revering death, and seeking martyrdom in battle as thehighest possible goal. Martin Wasserman On Jul 24, 2025, at 2:45 PM, Salem Ajluni <ajluni@hotmail.com> wrote: As a modest contribution to a better understanding of the thinking and practices of the Israeli state, past and present, I recommend a very useful and short book that I read more than 40 years ago. It was written by Livia Rokach, the daughter of Israel Rokach who was the Israeli Interior Minister in the government of Moshe Sharett, the latter being the second prime minister of the new state (1953-1955). She translated and published her father's diaries, as well as parts of Sharett's diaries, both of which give us insights into the private elite thinking, planning and actions of main actors in the Israeli state vis-a-vis its neighboring countries in the 1950s (and vis-s-vis the U.S. and European powers) (see https://ia804501.us.archive.org/17/items/sacred-terrorism/Sacred-Terrorism.pdf). The resonance and parallels between Israeli leadership thinking and actions in the 1950s (as explained by Rokach) and in the 21st century with regard to the states and peoples of Lebanon, Syria, the West Bank, Gaza and Egypt (and, by extension, Iraq, Yemen and Iran) are instructive. There are considerable continuities across time and space: aggressive and domineering (supremicist?) thinking and behavior; an expansionist impulse; a sociopathic and homicidal (genocidal?) animus towards Arabs, especially Palestinians. It was all there in the 1940s and 1950s, as Rokach tells us, and it's all there now, as we witness on a daily basis. Israel certainly didn't need Hamas to induce such thinking and behavior. In fact, the Hamas movement wasn't formally inaugurated until late 1987, almost two generations after the establishment of the state of Israel. Reading historical accounts of the conflict teaches us that only the bugaboo changes (e.g. Nasser, the PLO, Saddam Hussein, Hizballah, Hamas, the Houthis, Iran, etc.)—the Israeli modus operandi is more or less a constant--maximal violence and aggression with little to no regard for the sanctity of the lives of civilian non-combatants. The Israeli state was ushered in and made possible by the intial displacement of the majority of Mandate Palestine's Arab population during 1947-1949 (on these events, see Ilan Pappe's book based in large part on official Israeli archival sourceshttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ethnic_Cleansing_of_Palestine). It behooves us to remember that about two-thirds of Gaza's population are themselves refugees from Madate Palestine or the offspring of those refugees. No disconinuities there either. Regards, Salem From: Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:23 PMTo: Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> Cc: Veenker, Vicki <Vicki.Veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lythcott-Haims, Julie <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Keith Reckdahl <reckdahl@yahoo.com>; Ed Lauing <elauing@equitysearchpartners.com>; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23 <jessica@speiser.net>; Lori Meyers <meyers.lk@gmail.com>; Sheree Roth <ssroth29@gmail.com>; Henry Etzkowitz <H.Etzko@gmail.com>; Binder, Andrew <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mark Turner <mark.turner@morganhill.ca.gov>; CityCouncil <CityCouncil@morganhill.ca.gov>; Michelle Bigelow <Michelle.Bigelow@morganhill.ca.gov>; Josh Becker <becker.josh@gmail.com>; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov<assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <julieforpaloalto@gmail.com>;eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org <eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org>; Doug Minkler <dminkler@dminkler.com>; Gerry Gras <gerrygras@earthlink.net>; EPA Today <epatoday@epatoday.org>; Gennady Sheyner <gsheyner@embarcaderomedia.org>; city.council@menlopark.gov <city.council@menlopark.gov>; dcombs@menlopark.gov <dcombs@menlopark.gov>; Steve Wagstaffe <swagstaffe@smcgov.org>; Jeff Rosen <info@jeffrosen.org>; Jeff Conrad <jeff_conrad@msn.com>; Jeff Hayden <laptoplg@mac.com>; Jay Boyarsky <jboyarsky@dao.sccgov.org>; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto <wilpf.peninsula.paloalto@gmail.com>; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com> <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas <nicholas.enberg@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mickie Winkler <mickie650@gmail.com>; Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com>; Cait James <caitlin.a.james@gmail.com>; San José Spotlight <info@sanjosespotlight.com>; board@pausd.org <board@pausd.org>; boardfeedback@smcgov.org <boardfeedback@smcgov.org>; board@valleywater.org<board@valleywater.org>; BoardOperations <BoardOperations@cob.sccgov.org>; Braden Cartwright <bcartwright@padailypost.com>; Raymond Goins <goinsrayl@gmail.com>; Rodriguez, Miguel <miguel.rodriguez@pdo.sccgov.org>; editor@paweekly.com <editor@paweekly.com>; April Wagner <april.wagner@cityofpaloalto.org>; Don Austin <daustin@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <donnaisanactivist@gmail.com>; Burt, Patrick <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov <Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov>; Palo Alto Free Press <paloaltofreepress@gmail.com>; Seher Awan <firebrand.dr@gmail.com>; Daniel Barton <dbarton@nbo.law>; David Piper <david.piper@wvm.edu>; michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org <michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mila Zelkha <mila.zelkha@gmail.com>; Palo Alto Renters' Association <info@paloaltorenters.org>; Diana Diamond <dianaLdiamond@gmail.com>; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com <jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com>; ladoris cordell <ladoris@judgecordell.com>; cromero@cityofepa.org <cromero@cityofepa.org>; rabrica@cityofepa.org<rabrica@cityofepa.org>; Bill Newell <billnewell2850@gmail.com>; Bill Johnson <bjohnson@paweekly.com>; Bill James <billjames99@gmail.com>; Pat M <p.marshall81@ymail.com>; Carla Torres <xicanamagic@hotmail.com>; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan <mayor@sanjoseca.gov>; CityCouncil <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Council <council@redwoodcity.org>; Zachary.Perron@CityofPaloAlto.org <zachary.perron@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Attorney <CityAttorney@santaclaraca.gov>; citycouncil@mountainview.gov <citycouncil@mountainview.gov>; Clerk, City <city.clerk@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Clerk <CLERK2@redwoodcity.org>; Friends of Cubberley <friendsofcubberley94303@gmail.com>; Lotus Fong <lyfong@pacbell.net>; ParkRec Commission <ParkRec.commission@cityofpaloalto.org>; Liz Gardner <Gardnerjaqua@gmail.com>; Human Relations Commission <hrc@cityofpaloalto.org>; Karen Holman <kcholman@sbcglobal.net>; Liz Kniss <lizkniss@earthlink.net>; Patrice Ventresca <patriceventresca@gmail.com>; Rowena Chiu <rowena.chiu@gmail.com>; Dana St. George <danasg@earthlink.net>; Damon Silver <damon.silver@pdo.sccgov.org>; Daniel Kottke <daniel.k@earthlink.net>; Dennis Upton <kathy8420@qq.com>; Zahra Billoo <zbilloo@cair.com>; james pitkin <jamespitkin777@yahoo.com>; Roberta Ahlquist <roberta.ahlquist@sjsu.edu>; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg <supervisor.ellenberg@bos.sccgov.org>; Supervisor Otto Lee <supervisor.lee@bos.sccgov.org>; Salem Ajluni <ajluni@hotmail.com>; Stump, Molly <molly.stump@cityofpaloalto.org>; Rosen, Jeff <JRosen@dao.sccgov.org>; Baker, Rob <rbaker@dao.sccgov.org>; Ruth Silver Taube <ruthsilvertaube16@gmail.com>; Tom DuBois <tom.dubois@gmail.com>; Blackshire, Geoffrey <Geo.Blackshire@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jasso, Tamara <Tamara.Jasso@cityofpaloalto.org>; DuJuan Green <dujuang@sbcglobal.net>; Dennis Upton <denkafer1@yahoo.com>; dennis burns <dennis.r.burns@gmail.com>; Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org <Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org>; Alex Afanasiev <Alex.Afanasiev@cityofpaloalto.org>; craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org <craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org>; Anna Griffin <griffinam@sbcglobal.net>; Angel, David <dangel@dao.sccgov.org>; Greg Tanaka <greg@gregtanaka.org>; Reifschneider, James <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Bryan Gobin <appeal.bryan.gobin@gmail.com>; Yolanda Conaway <yconaway@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <cats4jazz@gmail.com>; Vara Ramakrishnan <vara@acm.org> Subject: Re: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' Since WWII The bias of the author is evident in the fact that the entire article mentions Hamas only once, in passing. Hamas could end the suffering tomorrow just by laying down their arms and releasing the hostages. But they care more about scoringpropaganda points against Israel than about saving the lives of their own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 22, 2025, at 3:08 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvationof Gaza Most 'Minutely Designedand Controlled' Since WWII Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' Since WWII | CommonDreamshttps://www.commondreams.org/news/famine-expert-israel-s-starvation-of-gaza-most-minutely-designed-and-controlled-since-wwii From:Donna WallachTo:Martin WassermanCc:Aram James; Sean Allen; Salem Ajluni; Veenker, Vicki; Lythcott-Haims, Julie; Reckdahl, Keith; Ed Lauing; jessica@speiser.net; Lori Meyers; Sheree Roth; h.etzko@gmail.com; Binder, Andrew; Mark Turner; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; Josh Becker; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Julie Lythcott-Haims; Figueroa, Eric; Doug Minkler; Gerry Gras; Today EPA; Gennady Sheyner; city.council@menlopark.gov; dcombs@menlopark.gov; Steve Wagstaffe; Jeff Rosen; Jeff Conrad; Jeff Hayden; Jay Boyarsky; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com;Enberg, Nicholas; Mickie Winkler; Cait James; San José Spotlight; board@pausd.org; boardfeedback@smcgov.org; board@valleywater.org; BoardOperations; Braden Cartwright; Raymond Goins; Miguel Rodriguez; editor@paweekly.com; Wagner, April; Don Austin; Burt, Patrick; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov; Palo Alto Free Press; Seher Awan; Daniel Barton; David Piper; Foley, Michael; Zelkha, Mila; Renters" Association Palo Alto; Diana Diamond; jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com; ladoris cordell; cromero@cityofepa.org; rabrica@cityofepa.org; Bill Newell; Bill Johnson; BillJames; Pat M; Carla Torres; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; Council, City; GRP-City Council; Perron, Zachary; City Attorney; citycouncil@mountainview.gov; Clerk, City; GRP-City Clerk; Friends of Cubberley; Lotus Fong; ParkRec Commission; Gardener, Liz; Human Relations Commission; Holman, Karen (external); Liz Kniss; Patrice Ventresca; Rowena Chiu; Dana St. George; Damon Silver; Daniel Kottke; Dennis Upton; Zahra Billoo; james pitkin; Roberta Ahlquist; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Supervisor Otto Lee; Stump, Molly; Jeff Rosen; Rob Baker; Ruth Silver Taube; TomDuBois; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Jasso, Tamara; DuJuan Green; Dennis Upton; dennis burns; Jensen, Eric; Afanasiev, Alex; Lee, Craig; Anna Griffin; David Angel; Greg Tanaka; Reifschneider, James; Bryan Gobin; Yolanda Conaway; Donna Wallach; Vara RamakrishnanSubject:Re: Famine Expert: Israel"s Starvation of Gaza Most "Minutely Designed and Controlled" Since WWIIDate:Friday, July 25, 2025 5:19:05 PMAttachments:image1.pngimage1.png CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. i Martin Wasserman you are as despicable as all the other Zionists who refuse to open your eyes, your mind and your hearts. You are the same as the hateful Klu Klux Klan who murdered and continue to murder Black Americans just because they are Black. There is so much truthful online information about the War Crimes, genocide, starvation that the Israeli govt is committing in full live stream view for the entireworld to see. Israeli journalists are reporting about it, i.e. Gideon Levy and Amira Hass. Other Israelis are reporting about it, Ilan Pappe is one, right now I'm forgetting the name of the other one. Tens of thousands of young American Jews protested on campuses across the USA along with tens of thousands of other students against the genocide, many of them sacrificed their diplomas. JVP has issued many statements and calls for ending the genocide, calling for a ceasefire. The Palestinians have done nothing to deserve this genocide, Ethnic cleansing and starvation, that recently Ralph Nader is calling an Omnicide meaning that the intent of Israel is to eliminate the entire Palestinian population living there from the face of the earth. The Israeli govt continues to say that their goal is to make Gaza Jewish and to annex the entire West Bank and to remove by force each and everyPalestinian Martin get your head out of your butt! You disgust me beyond words! The Palestinans are one of the most kindest, lovingest, generous people I have ever met and lived among. Free Palestine! Long Live Palestine! "Nobody in the world, nobody in history, has ever gotten their freedom by appealing to the moral sense of the people who were oppressing them."Assata Shakur Books you must read: "Against Our Better Judgement: The hidden history of how the U.S. was used to create Israel" by Alison Weirhttp://www.againstourbetterjudgment.com/ "State of Terror: How Terrorism Created Modern Israel" by Thomas Suarezhttp://thomassuarez.com/SoT.html "The Hundred Years War on Palestine"by Rashid Khalidi "The Ethnic Cleansing of Palestine"by Illan Pappé Free Palestine!Right of Return to Palestine for all Palestinians! Free all political prisoners!Mumia Abu-Jamal @mumiafreedomtourThe Holy Land Five: Shukri Abu Baker Ghassan Elashi Mufid Abdulqader Abdulrahman Odeh Mohammad Elmezainhttps://www.mintpressnews.com/the-trial-and-conviction-of-the-holy-land-foundation-five/237440/and thousands more End Solitary Confinementhttps://prisonerhungerstrikesolidarity.wordpress.com California Prison Focus http://newest.prisons.org/our_story End United $tates of Amerikkka invasions and occupationsU.S. Government and UN Occupation Force Soldiers - Hands off Haiti!http://www.haitisolidarity.net/ Syria Solidarity Movement, Solidarity with the Syrian people https://syriasupportmovement.org Donna WallachDonnaIsAnActivist@gmail.comInstagram: @palestine_is_and_will_be_freeInstagram: @donnawallach1Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/donna.wallachTwitter: @PalestineWillBe(cell) 408-569-6608 On Fri, Jul 25, 2025, 12:26 Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:Hamas could end the suffering anytime it wants just by laying down its arms and releasing the hostages. But it has no interest in ending the suffering. As part of a culture that defines itself as revering death rather than life, Hamas believes that any Gazan who dies of starvation will go straight to heaven as a martyr, so there's really no problem. And it also serves asgood anti-Israel propaganda. Martin Wasserman On Jul 25, 2025, at 8:26 AM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Why Is the World Letting It Happen?”: U.K. Surgeon, Back from Gaza, on Starving Children | Democracy Now! https://www.democracynow.org/2025/7/25/nick_maynard_gaza On Fri, Jul 25, 2025 at 12:30 AM Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com > wrote: Good evening, Martin, I want to start by expressing my apologies before we delve into today’s discussion. Unfortunately, several major U.S. media outlets have reported perspectives that contradict your position. I find that your argument lacks substantial logic. Given the global perception of the United States as a superior military power, it raises the question of how the people of Gaza, even under Hamas leadership,could pose a significant threat to any country supported by U.S. military resources. The attached photos speak volumes and challenge the validity of your position. Best regards, Sean This message needs your attentionThis is a personal email address.This is their first email to your company. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast Sent from my iPhone On Jul 24, 2025, at 6:36 PM, Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote: This is utter nonsense. If Israel's modus operandi has always been "maximal violence and aggression with little to no regard for the sanctity of lives of civilian non-combatants,” why did they sign the 1993 Oslo Accord which brought Yasser Arafat and the PLO out of exile and gave them sovereignty of Arab areas in Judea and Samaria? Andwhy did they forcibly evacuate all Jewish settlements in Gaza in 2005 instead of strengthening those settlements and digging in? The reality is, it was always the Arab leadership that sought to exterminate the Jews, giving the Jews no choice but to fight back. When Israel goes to war, it goes to great lengths to avoid civilian casualties, but groups like Hamas go out of their way to target Israeli civilians, and the Palestinian Authority gives large cash rewards to any Arab who murders any Jew, whether civilian or otherwise. Right now, people in Gaza are starving, not because of Israel, but because Hamas refuses to lay down its arms and release the hostages. The conflict would be over tomorrow if Hamas would do these simple things. In fact, Hamas tries forcibly, often with gunfire, to prevent Gazans from receiving life-giving aid that doesn't come through them,saying that receiving such aid amounts to "collaborating with the enemy.” The truth is, Israel has displayed more concern for the lives of Gazan civilians than the Gazans’ own leaders have. Perhaps the reason for this is that Israeli culture is based on reverence for life, while Hamas culture defines itself as revering death, and seeking martyrdom in battle as the highest possible goal. Martin Wasserman On Jul 24, 2025, at 2:45 PM, Salem Ajluni <ajluni@hotmail.com> wrote: As a modest contribution to a better understanding of the thinking and practices of the Israeli state, past and present, I recommend a very useful and short book that I read more than 40 years ago. It was written by Livia Rokach, the daughter of Israel Rokach who was the Israeli Interior Minister in the government of Moshe Sharett, the latter being the second prime minister of the new state (1953-1955). She translated and published her father's diaries, as well as parts of Sharett's diaries, both of which give us insights into the private elite thinking, planning and actions of main actors in the Israeli state vis-a-vis its neighboring countries in the 1950s (and vis-s-vis the U.S. and European powers) (see https://ia804501.us.archive.org/17/items/sacred-terrorism/Sacred-Terrorism.pdf). The resonance and parallels between Israeli leadership thinking and actions in the 1950s (as explained by Rokach) and in the 21st century with regard to the states and peoples of Lebanon, Syria, the West Bank, Gaza and Egypt (and, by extension, Iraq, Yemen and Iran) are instructive. There are considerable continuities across time and space: aggressive and domineering (supremicist?) thinking and behavior; an expansionist impulse; a sociopathic and homicidal (genocidal?) animus towards Arabs, especially Palestinians. It was all there in the 1940s and 1950s, as Rokach tells us, and it's all there now, as we witness on a daily basis. Israel certainly didn't need Hamas to induce such thinking and behavior. In fact, the Hamas movement wasn't formally inaugurated until late 1987, almost two generations after the establishment of the state of Israel. Reading historical accounts of the conflict teaches us that only thebugaboo changes (e.g. Nasser, the PLO, Saddam Hussein, Hizballah, Hamas, the Houthis, Iran, etc.)—the Israeli modus operandi is more or less a constant--maximal violence and aggression with little to no regard for the sanctity of the lives of civilian non-combatants. The Israeli state was ushered in and made possible by the intial displacement of the majority of Mandate Palestine's Arab population during 1947-1949 (on these events, see Ilan Pappe's book based in large part on official Israeli archivalsourceshttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ethnic_Cleansing_of_Palestine). It behooves us to remember that about two-thirds of Gaza's population are themselves refugees from Madate Palestine or the offspring of those refugees. No disconinuities there either. Regards, Salem From: Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com>Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:23 PM To: Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com>Cc: Veenker, Vicki <Vicki.Veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lythcott-Haims, Julie <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Keith Reckdahl <reckdahl@yahoo.com>; Ed Lauing <elauing@equitysearchpartners.com>; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23 <jessica@speiser.net>; Lori Meyers <meyers.lk@gmail.com>; Sheree Roth<ssroth29@gmail.com>; Henry Etzkowitz <H.Etzko@gmail.com>; Binder, Andrew <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mark Turner <mark.turner@morganhill.ca.gov>; CityCouncil <CityCouncil@morganhill.ca.gov>; Michelle Bigelow <Michelle.Bigelow@morganhill.ca.gov>; Josh Becker<becker.josh@gmail.com>; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov<assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <julieforpaloalto@gmail.com>;eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org <eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org>; Doug Minkler <dminkler@dminkler.com>; Gerry Gras <gerrygras@earthlink.net>; EPA Today <epatoday@epatoday.org>; Gennady Sheyner<gsheyner@embarcaderomedia.org>; city.council@menlopark.gov <city.council@menlopark.gov>; dcombs@menlopark.gov <dcombs@menlopark.gov>; Steve Wagstaffe <swagstaffe@smcgov.org>; Jeff Rosen <info@jeffrosen.org>; Jeff Conrad <jeff_conrad@msn.com>; Jeff Hayden <laptoplg@mac.com>; Jay Boyarsky <jboyarsky@dao.sccgov.org>; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto<wilpf.peninsula.paloalto@gmail.com>; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com> <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas <nicholas.enberg@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mickie Winkler <mickie650@gmail.com>; Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com>; Cait James <caitlin.a.james@gmail.com>; San José Spotlight<info@sanjosespotlight.com>; board@pausd.org <board@pausd.org>; boardfeedback@smcgov.org <boardfeedback@smcgov.org>; board@valleywater.org<board@valleywater.org>; BoardOperations <BoardOperations@cob.sccgov.org>; Braden Cartwright <bcartwright@padailypost.com>; Raymond Goins <goinsrayl@gmail.com>; Rodriguez, Miguel<miguel.rodriguez@pdo.sccgov.org>; editor@paweekly.com <editor@paweekly.com>; April Wagner <april.wagner@cityofpaloalto.org>; Don Austin <daustin@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <donnaisanactivist@gmail.com>; Burt, Patrick <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov <Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov>; Palo Alto Free Press <paloaltofreepress@gmail.com>; Seher Awan<firebrand.dr@gmail.com>; Daniel Barton <dbarton@nbo.law>; David Piper <david.piper@wvm.edu>; michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org <michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mila Zelkha <mila.zelkha@gmail.com>; Palo Alto Renters' Association <info@paloaltorenters.org>; Diana Diamond <dianaLdiamond@gmail.com>; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com <jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com>; ladoriscordell <ladoris@judgecordell.com>; cromero@cityofepa.org <cromero@cityofepa.org>; rabrica@cityofepa.org<rabrica@cityofepa.org>; Bill Newell <billnewell2850@gmail.com>; Bill Johnson <bjohnson@paweekly.com>; Bill James <billjames99@gmail.com>; Pat M <p.marshall81@ymail.com>; Carla Torres <xicanamagic@hotmail.com>; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan <mayor@sanjoseca.gov>;CityCouncil <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Council <council@redwoodcity.org>; Zachary.Perron@CityofPaloAlto.org <zachary.perron@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Attorney <CityAttorney@santaclaraca.gov>; citycouncil@mountainview.gov <citycouncil@mountainview.gov>; Clerk, City <city.clerk@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Clerk <CLERK2@redwoodcity.org>; Friends of Cubberley<friendsofcubberley94303@gmail.com>; Lotus Fong <lyfong@pacbell.net>; ParkRec Commission <ParkRec.commission@cityofpaloalto.org>; Liz Gardner <Gardnerjaqua@gmail.com>; Human Relations Commission <hrc@cityofpaloalto.org>; Karen Holman <kcholman@sbcglobal.net>; Liz Kniss <lizkniss@earthlink.net>; Patrice Ventresca <patriceventresca@gmail.com>; Rowena Chiu<rowena.chiu@gmail.com>; Dana St. George <danasg@earthlink.net>; Damon Silver <damon.silver@pdo.sccgov.org>; Daniel Kottke <daniel.k@earthlink.net>; Dennis Upton <kathy8420@qq.com>; Zahra Billoo <zbilloo@cair.com>; james pitkin <jamespitkin777@yahoo.com>; Roberta Ahlquist <roberta.ahlquist@sjsu.edu>; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg <supervisor.ellenberg@bos.sccgov.org>;Supervisor Otto Lee <supervisor.lee@bos.sccgov.org>; Salem Ajluni <ajluni@hotmail.com>; Stump, Molly <molly.stump@cityofpaloalto.org>; Rosen, Jeff <JRosen@dao.sccgov.org>; Baker, Rob <rbaker@dao.sccgov.org>; Ruth Silver Taube <ruthsilvertaube16@gmail.com>; Tom DuBois <tom.dubois@gmail.com>; Blackshire, Geoffrey <Geo.Blackshire@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jasso, Tamara<Tamara.Jasso@cityofpaloalto.org>; DuJuan Green <dujuang@sbcglobal.net>; Dennis Upton <denkafer1@yahoo.com>; dennis burns <dennis.r.burns@gmail.com>; Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org <Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org>; Alex Afanasiev <Alex.Afanasiev@cityofpaloalto.org>; craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org <craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org>; Anna Griffin <griffinam@sbcglobal.net>; Angel, David<dangel@dao.sccgov.org>; Greg Tanaka <greg@gregtanaka.org>; Reifschneider, James <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Bryan Gobin <appeal.bryan.gobin@gmail.com>; Yolanda Conaway <yconaway@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <cats4jazz@gmail.com>; Vara Ramakrishnan <vara@acm.org>Subject: Re: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' Since WWII The bias of the author is evident in the fact that the entire article mentions Hamas only once, in passing. Hamas could end the suffering tomorrow just by laying down their arms and releasing the hostages. But they care more about scoring propaganda points against Israel than about saving the lives oftheir own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 22, 2025, at 3:08 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvationof Gaza Most 'Minutely Designedand Controlled' Since WWII Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' Since WWII | Common Dreamshttps://www.commondreams.org/news/famine-expert-israel-s-starvation-of-gaza-most-minutely-designed-and-controlled-since-wwii From:Gathering Permit To:Alice Smith; Gathering Permit; Council, City Cc:Gennady Sheyner Subject:RE: Status of Gathering Permit request Date:Friday, July 25, 2025 11:05:21 AM Hi Alice, You may disregard this message. I'm simply reviewing and clearing duplicate requests, as multiple submissions were received and a few are still in the queue. Apologies for any confusion. Than you, Neha From: Alice Smith <alice.smith@gmail.com> Sent: Friday, July 25, 2025 9:56 AM To: Gathering Permit <Gathering.Permit@PaloAlto.gov>; Council, City <city.council@PaloAlto.gov> Cc: Gennady Sheyner <gsheyner@paweekly.com> Subject: Re: Status of Gathering Permit request CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious ofopening attachments and clicking on links. We had the event with our issued gathering permit On 7/17/25 with estimated 1200 showing up and no problems reported. What was the reason for this email? Please explain. Copying to the city council and city manager. Free speech is alive and must remain alive and well in Palo Alto. S Bewildered, Alice Schaffer Smith Executive Director National Voter Corps 650 283 2822 www.nationalvotercorps.org On Fri, Jul 25, 2025 at 9:34 AM gathering.permit@paloalto.gov <gathering.permit@paloalto.gov> wrote: header Status of Gathering Permit request Hello, Thank you for your submission. After careful consideration, we regret to inform you that we are unable to approve your event at this time. For further clarification or to discuss this matter in more detail, please feel free to contact us directly at Gathering.Permit@PaloAlto.Gov or by phone at 650-329-2418. Additionally, you will receive a separate email outlining the specific reasons for the decision. Thank you, Community Services Gathering Permits Community Services Department (650) 329-2418 | Gathering.Permit@PaloAlto.Gov www.PaloAlto.gov Event is now in the past Sent using OpenForms From:Alice Smith To:Gathering Permit; Council, City Cc:Gennady Sheyner Subject:Re: Status of Gathering Permit request Date:Friday, July 25, 2025 9:56:32 AM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. i We had the event with our issued gathering permit On 7/17/25 with estimated 1200 showing up and no problems reported. What was the reason for this email? Please explain. Copying to the city council and citymanager. Free speech is alive and must remain alive and well in Palo Alto. S Bewildered, Alice Schaffer Smith Executive Director National Voter Corps 650 283 2822 www.nationalvotercorps.org On Fri, Jul 25, 2025 at 9:34 AM gathering.permit@paloalto.gov<gathering.permit@paloalto.gov> wrote: header This message needs your attention This is a personal email address. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast Status of Gathering Permit request Hello, Thank you for your submission. After careful consideration, we regret to inform you that we are unable to approve your event at this time. For further clarification or to discuss this matter in more detail, please feel free to contact us directly at Gathering.Permit@PaloAlto.Gov or by phone at 650-329-2418. Additionally, you will receive a separate email outlining the specific reasons for the decision. Thank you, Community Services Gathering Permits Community Services Department (650) 329-2418 | Gathering.Permit@PaloAlto.Gov www.PaloAlto.gov Event is now in the past Sent using OpenForms From:Aram James To:Veenker, Vicki Cc:Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23; Josh Becker; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Emily Mibach; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Council, City; Figueroa, Eric; Dave Price; Don Austin; Yolanda Conaway; Seher Awan; Sean Allen; james pitkin; planning.commission@cityofpaloalto.0rg; ParkRec Commission; Jeff Rosen; Jay Boyarsky; Gardener, Liz; Donna Wallach; Friends of Cubberley; Lotus Fong; Zelkha, Mila; Baker, Rob; Daniel Barton; Raymond Goins; Gerry Gras; Dana St. George; board@valleywater.org; board@pausd.org; vramirez@redwoodcity.org; editor@almanacnews.com; Dave Price; Angel, David; Pat M; Roberta Ahlquist; Sameena Usman; Vara Ramakrishnan; Mark Turner; CityCouncil; Binder, Andrew; Reifschneider, James; Tim James; Rodriguez, Miguel; Michael Ybarra; yolanda; Bryan Gobin; editor@paweekly.com; Diana Diamond; Bill Newell; Rowena Chiu; Tom DuBois; Holman, Karen (external); Steve Wagstaffe Subject:Rep. Rashida Tlaib on Gaza Siege, American Killed by Israeli Settlers & Epstein’s Financial Network Date:Friday, July 25, 2025 9:46:27 AM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. https://www.democracynow.org/2025/7/25/rashida_tlaib From:Aram James To:Council, City; Lauing, Ed; Reckdahl, Keith; Vicki Veenker; Burt, Patrick; Lu, George; gstone22@gmail.com Cc:h.etzko@gmail.com; Gardener, Liz; Lotus Fong; Sean Allen; ladoris cordell; Human Relations Commission; board@valleywater.org; BoardOperations; Jay Boyarsky; boardfeedback@smcgov.org; Jeff Rosen; Baker, Rob; Dan Okonkwo Subject:Re: forever Date:Friday, July 25, 2025 9:33:24 AM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. On Fri, Jul 25, 2025 at 6:56 AM Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Each of your name's your silence on the genocide are burnt into the psyche of our community in perpetuity ( you will each live in infamy as the history of this genocide is written). Leaders ( the entire city council) whose silent complicity speaks volumes about each of your individual characters. Shame across future generations will attach to your names forever, forever. From:Aram James To:Sean Allen; sharon jackson; Carla Torres; Pat M; Seher Awan; David Piper; Ruth Silver Taube; William Armaline;Damon Silver; Rodriguez, Miguel; Lewis James; Yolanda Conaway; Dan Okonkwo; Steve Wagstaffe Cc:Mark Turner; Binder, Andrew; Reifschneider, James; Wagner, April; Perron, Zachary; Jeff Rosen; Jay Boyarsky; Rowena Chiu; Barberini, Christopher; Dave Price; cromero@cityofepa.org; Raymond Goins; rabrica@cityofepa.org; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23; District3@sanjoseca.gov; District4@sanjoseca.gov; District5@sanjoseca.gov; District9@sanjoseca.gov; MGR-Melissa Stevenson Diaz; Diana Diamond; San José Spotlight; Jeff Conrad; Baker, Rob; Robert Salonga; Roberta Ahlquist; Kaloma Smith; Lythcott-Haims, Julie; Human Relations Commission; Emily Mibach; h.etzko@gmail.com; Angel, David; Dave Price; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Zelkha, Mila; Doug Minkler; Friends of Cubberley; Veenker, Vicki; Burt, Patrick; Gerry Gras; Gennady Sheyner; Council, City; Zahra Billoo; Salem Ajluni; Rick Callender; EXT.Richard.Hobbs; Dana St. George; Bill Newell; Figueroa, Eric; Lotus Fong; Donna Wallach; Tom DuBois; Michael Pati; Michelle; Don Austin; Rose Lynn; Nicole Chiu-Wang; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; board@pausd.org; boardfeedback@smcgov.org; board@valleywater.org; BoardOperations; citycouncil@mountainview.gov; city.council@menlopark.gov; vramirez@redwoodcity.org; eddie.aubrey@sanjoseca.gov; Lauing, Ed; Josh Becker; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Enberg, Nicholas; Afanasiev, Alex; Nious, Kevin (NBCUniversal); Gennady Sheyner; Liz Kniss; Reckdahl, Keith; Gardener, Liz; Tim James; Cait James; Marina Lopez; Josie James- Le Subject:Ben Crump on Breonna Taylor, William McNeil, Saniyah Cheatham & Demand to Release Malcolm X Files Date:Friday, July 25, 2025 9:19:28 AM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. https://www.democracynow.org/2025/7/25/ben_crump_breonna_taylor From:Aram James To:Sean AllenCc:Martin Wasserman; Salem Ajluni; Veenker, Vicki; Lythcott-Haims, Julie; Reckdahl, Keith; Ed Lauing; jessica@speiser.net; Lori Meyers; Sheree Roth; h.etzko@gmail.com; Binder, Andrew; Mark Turner; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; Josh Becker;assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Julie Lythcott-Haims; Figueroa, Eric; Doug Minkler; Gerry Gras; Today EPA; Gennady Sheyner; city.council@menlopark.gov; dcombs@menlopark.gov; Steve Wagstaffe; Jeff Rosen; Jeff Conrad; JeffHayden; Jay Boyarsky; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com; Enberg, Nicholas; Mickie Winkler; Cait James; San José Spotlight; board@pausd.org; boardfeedback@smcgov.org; board@valleywater.org; BoardOperations;Braden Cartwright; Raymond Goins; Miguel Rodriguez; editor@paweekly.com; Wagner, April; Don Austin; Donna Wallach; Burt, Patrick; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov; Palo Alto Free Press; Seher Awan; Daniel Barton; David Piper; Foley, Michael;Zelkha, Mila; Renters" Association Palo Alto; Diana Diamond; jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com; ladoris cordell; cromero@cityofepa.org; rabrica@cityofepa.org; Bill Newell; Bill Johnson; Bill James; Pat M; Carla Torres; The Office of MayorMatt Mahan; Council, City; GRP-City Council; Perron, Zachary; City Attorney; citycouncil@mountainview.gov; Clerk, City; GRP-City Clerk; Friends of Cubberley; Lotus Fong; ParkRec Commission; Gardener, Liz; Human Relations Commission;Holman, Karen (external); Liz Kniss; Patrice Ventresca; Rowena Chiu; Dana St. George; Damon Silver; Daniel Kottke; Dennis Upton; Zahra Billoo; james pitkin; Roberta Ahlquist; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Supervisor Otto Lee; Stump, Molly; JeffRosen; Rob Baker; Ruth Silver Taube; Tom DuBois; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Jasso, Tamara; DuJuan Green; Dennis Upton; dennis burns; Jensen, Eric; Afanasiev, Alex; Lee, Craig; Anna Griffin; David Angel; Greg Tanaka; Reifschneider, James; BryanGobin; Yolanda Conaway; Donna Wallach; Vara Ramakrishnan Subject:Re: Famine Expert: Israel"s Starvation of Gaza Most "Minutely Designed and Controlled" Since WWIIDate:Friday, July 25, 2025 8:26:58 AM Attachments:image1.png CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. Why Is the World Letting It Happen?”: U.K. Surgeon, Back from Gaza, on Starving Children | Democracy Now! https://www.democracynow.org/2025/7/25/nick_maynard_gaza On Fri, Jul 25, 2025 at 12:30 AM Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com > wrote: Good evening, Martin, I want to start by expressing my apologies before we delve into today’s discussion. Unfortunately, several major U.S. media outlets have reported perspectives that contradict yourposition. I find that your argument lacks substantial logic. Given the global perception of the United States as a superior military power, it raises the question of how the people ofGaza, even under Hamas leadership, could pose a significant threat to any country supported by U.S. military resources. The attached photos speak volumes and challenge the validityof your position. Best regards, Sean Sent from my iPhone On Jul 24, 2025, at 6:36 PM, Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote: This is utter nonsense. If Israel's modus operandi has always been "maximal violence and aggression with little to no regard for the sanctity of lives ofcivilian non-combatants,” why did they sign the 1993 Oslo Accord which brought Yasser Arafat and the PLO out of exile and gave them sovereignty ofArab areas in Judea and Samaria? And why did they forcibly evacuate all Jewish settlements in Gaza in 2005 instead of strengthening those settlementsand digging in? The reality is, it was always the Arab leadership that sought to exterminate the Jews, giving the Jews no choice but to fight back. When Israel goes to war, it goes to great lengths to avoid civilian casualties, but groups like Hamas go out of their way to target Israeli civilians, and thePalestinian Authority gives large cash rewards to any Arab who murders any Jew, whether civilian or otherwise. Right now, people in Gaza are starving, not because of Israel, but because Hamas refuses to lay down its arms and release the hostages. The conflictwould be over tomorrow if Hamas would do these simple things. In fact, Hamas tries forcibly, often with gunfire, to prevent Gazans from receiving life-giving aid that doesn't come through them, saying that receiving such aid amounts to "collaborating with the enemy.” The truth is, Israel has displayed more concern for the lives of Gazan civilians than the Gazans’ own leaders have. Perhaps the reason for this is thatIsraeli culture is based on reverence for life, while Hamas culture defines itself as revering death, and seeking martyrdom in battle as the highestpossible goal. Martin Wasserman On Jul 24, 2025, at 2:45 PM, Salem Ajluni <ajluni@hotmail.com> wrote: As a modest contribution to a better understanding of the thinking and practices of the Israeli state, past and present, I recommend a very useful and short book that I read more than 40 years ago. It was written by Livia Rokach, the daughter of Israel Rokach who was the Israeli Interior Minister in the government of Moshe Sharett, the latter being the second prime minister of the new state (1953-1955). She translated and published her father's diaries, as well as parts of Sharett's diaries, both of which give us insights into the private elite thinking, planning and actions of main actors in the Israeli state vis-a-vis its neighboring countries in the 1950s (and vis-s-vis the U.S. and European powers) (see https://ia804501.us.archive.org/17/items/sacred-terrorism/Sacred-Terrorism.pdf). The resonance and parallels between Israeli leadership thinking and actions in the 1950s (as explained by Rokach) and in the 21st century with regard to the states and peoples of Lebanon, Syria, the West Bank, Gaza and Egypt (and, by extension, Iraq, Yemen and Iran) are instructive. There are considerable continuities across time and space: aggressive and domineering (supremicist?) thinking and behavior; an expansionist impulse; a sociopathic and homicidal (genocidal?) animus towards Arabs, especially Palestinians. It was all there in the 1940s and 1950s, as Rokach tells us, and it's all there now, as we witness on a daily basis. Israel certainly didn't need Hamas to induce such thinking and behavior. In fact, the Hamas movement wasn't formally inaugurated until late 1987, almost two generations after the establishment of the state of Israel. Reading historical accounts of the conflict teaches us that only the bugaboo changes (e.g. Nasser, the PLO, Saddam Hussein, Hizballah, Hamas, the Houthis, Iran, etc.)—the Israeli modus operandi is more or less a constant--maximal violence and aggression with little to no regard for the sanctity of the lives of civilian non-combatants. The Israeli state was ushered in and made possible by the intial displacement of the majority of Mandate Palestine's Arab population during 1947-1949 (on these events, see Ilan Pappe's book based in large part on official Israeli archival sourceshttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ethnic_Cleansing_of_Palestine). It behooves us to remember that about two- thirds of Gaza's population are themselves refugees from Madate Palestine or the offspring of those refugees. No disconinuities there either. Regards, Salem From: Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:23 PMTo: Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> Cc: Veenker, Vicki <Vicki.Veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lythcott-Haims, Julie <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Keith Reckdahl <reckdahl@yahoo.com>; Ed Lauing <elauing@equitysearchpartners.com>; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23 <jessica@speiser.net>; Lori Meyers <meyers.lk@gmail.com>; Sheree Roth <ssroth29@gmail.com>; Henry Etzkowitz <H.Etzko@gmail.com>; Binder, Andrew <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mark Turner <mark.turner@morganhill.ca.gov>; CityCouncil <CityCouncil@morganhill.ca.gov>; Michelle Bigelow <Michelle.Bigelow@morganhill.ca.gov>; Josh Becker <becker.josh@gmail.com>; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov<assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <julieforpaloalto@gmail.com>;eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org <eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org>; Doug Minkler <dminkler@dminkler.com>; Gerry Gras <gerrygras@earthlink.net>; EPA Today <epatoday@epatoday.org>; Gennady Sheyner <gsheyner@embarcaderomedia.org>; city.council@menlopark.gov <city.council@menlopark.gov>; dcombs@menlopark.gov <dcombs@menlopark.gov>; Steve Wagstaffe <swagstaffe@smcgov.org>; Jeff Rosen <info@jeffrosen.org>; Jeff Conrad <jeff_conrad@msn.com>; Jeff Hayden <laptoplg@mac.com>; Jay Boyarsky <jboyarsky@dao.sccgov.org>; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto <wilpf.peninsula.paloalto@gmail.com>; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com> <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas <nicholas.enberg@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mickie Winkler <mickie650@gmail.com>; Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com>; Cait James <caitlin.a.james@gmail.com>; San José Spotlight <info@sanjosespotlight.com>; board@pausd.org <board@pausd.org>; boardfeedback@smcgov.org <boardfeedback@smcgov.org>; board@valleywater.org<board@valleywater.org>; BoardOperations <BoardOperations@cob.sccgov.org>; Braden Cartwright <bcartwright@padailypost.com>; Raymond Goins <goinsrayl@gmail.com>; Rodriguez, Miguel <miguel.rodriguez@pdo.sccgov.org>; editor@paweekly.com <editor@paweekly.com>; April Wagner <april.wagner@cityofpaloalto.org>; Don Austin <daustin@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <donnaisanactivist@gmail.com>; Burt, Patrick <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov <Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov>; Palo Alto Free Press <paloaltofreepress@gmail.com>; Seher Awan <firebrand.dr@gmail.com>; Daniel Barton <dbarton@nbo.law>; David Piper <david.piper@wvm.edu>; michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org <michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mila Zelkha <mila.zelkha@gmail.com>; Palo Alto Renters' Association <info@paloaltorenters.org>; Diana Diamond <dianaLdiamond@gmail.com>; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com <jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com>; ladoris cordell <ladoris@judgecordell.com>; cromero@cityofepa.org <cromero@cityofepa.org>; rabrica@cityofepa.org<rabrica@cityofepa.org>; Bill Newell <billnewell2850@gmail.com>; Bill Johnson <bjohnson@paweekly.com>; Bill James <billjames99@gmail.com>; Pat M <p.marshall81@ymail.com>; Carla Torres <xicanamagic@hotmail.com>; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan <mayor@sanjoseca.gov>; CityCouncil <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Council <council@redwoodcity.org>; Zachary.Perron@CityofPaloAlto.org <zachary.perron@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Attorney <CityAttorney@santaclaraca.gov>; citycouncil@mountainview.gov <citycouncil@mountainview.gov>; Clerk, City <city.clerk@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Clerk <CLERK2@redwoodcity.org>; Friends of Cubberley <friendsofcubberley94303@gmail.com>; Lotus Fong <lyfong@pacbell.net>; ParkRec Commission <ParkRec.commission@cityofpaloalto.org>; Liz Gardner <Gardnerjaqua@gmail.com>; Human Relations Commission <hrc@cityofpaloalto.org>; Karen Holman <kcholman@sbcglobal.net>; Liz Kniss <lizkniss@earthlink.net>; Patrice Ventresca <patriceventresca@gmail.com>; Rowena Chiu <rowena.chiu@gmail.com>; Dana St. George <danasg@earthlink.net>; Damon Silver <damon.silver@pdo.sccgov.org>; Daniel Kottke <daniel.k@earthlink.net>; Dennis Upton <kathy8420@qq.com>; Zahra Billoo <zbilloo@cair.com>; james pitkin <jamespitkin777@yahoo.com>; Roberta Ahlquist <roberta.ahlquist@sjsu.edu>; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg <supervisor.ellenberg@bos.sccgov.org>; Supervisor Otto Lee <supervisor.lee@bos.sccgov.org>; Salem Ajluni <ajluni@hotmail.com>; Stump, Molly <molly.stump@cityofpaloalto.org>; Rosen, Jeff <JRosen@dao.sccgov.org>; Baker, Rob <rbaker@dao.sccgov.org>; Ruth Silver Taube <ruthsilvertaube16@gmail.com>; Tom DuBois <tom.dubois@gmail.com>; Blackshire, Geoffrey <Geo.Blackshire@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jasso, Tamara <Tamara.Jasso@cityofpaloalto.org>; DuJuan Green <dujuang@sbcglobal.net>; Dennis Upton <denkafer1@yahoo.com>; dennis burns <dennis.r.burns@gmail.com>; Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org <Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org>; Alex Afanasiev <Alex.Afanasiev@cityofpaloalto.org>; craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org <craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org>; Anna Griffin <griffinam@sbcglobal.net>; Angel, David <dangel@dao.sccgov.org>; Greg Tanaka <greg@gregtanaka.org>; Reifschneider, James <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Bryan Gobin <appeal.bryan.gobin@gmail.com>; Yolanda Conaway <yconaway@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <cats4jazz@gmail.com>; Vara Ramakrishnan <vara@acm.org> Subject: Re: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' Since WWII The bias of the author is evident in the fact that the entire article mentions Hamas only once, in passing. Hamas could end the suffering tomorrow just by laying down their arms and releasing the hostages. But they care more about scoring propaganda points against Israel than about saving the lives of their own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 22, 2025, at 3:08 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvationof Gaza Most 'Minutely Designedand Controlled' Since WWII Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' Since WWII | CommonDreamshttps://www.commondreams.org/news/famine-expert-israel-s-starvation-of-gaza-most-minutely-designed-and-controlled-since-wwii From:Aram James To:Shikada, Ed; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Jasso, Tamara; Gerry Gras; Council, City; Sean Allen; h.etzko@gmail.com;Binder, Andrew; Reifschneider, James; Yolanda Conaway; Don Austin; EPA Today; Raymond Goins; Gardener,Liz; Liz Kniss; DuJuan Green; dennis burns; Gennady Sheyner; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; CouncilmemberChappie Jones; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23;board@valleywater.org; board@pausd.org; BoardOperations; boardfeedback@smcgov.org; Jeff Rosen;jay.boyarsky@da.sccgov.org; Friends of Cubberley; GRP-City Council; city.council@menlopark.gov;citycouncil@mountainview.gov; Wagner, April; Perron, Zachary; Human Relations Commission; Kaloma Smith;Baker, Rob; Bill Newell Subject:They are still discovering bodies in Altadena 6 months after fire. Are there other victims? Date:Friday, July 25, 2025 6:23:54 AM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. They are still discovering bodies in Altadena 6 months after fire. Are there other victims? https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2025-07-25/la-firestorm-31st-victim-found From:Aram James To:Salem Ajluni Cc:Martin Wasserman; Veenker, Vicki; Lythcott-Haims, Julie; Reckdahl, Keith; Ed Lauing; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23; Lori Meyers; Sheree Roth; h.etzko@gmail.com; Binder, Andrew; Mark Turner; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; Josh Becker; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Julie Lythcott-Haims; Figueroa, Eric; Doug Minkler; Gerry Gras; EPA Today; Gennady Sheyner; city.council@menlopark.gov; dcombs@menlopark.gov; Steve Wagstaffe; Jeff Rosen; Jeff Conrad; Jeff Hayden; Jay Boyarsky; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas; Mickie Winkler; Sean Allen; Cait James; San José Spotlight; board@pausd.org; boardfeedback@smcgov.org; board@valleywater.org; BoardOperations; Braden Cartwright; Raymond Goins; Rodriguez, Miguel; editor@paweekly.com; Wagner, April; Don Austin; Donna Wallach; Burt, Patrick; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov; Palo Alto Free Press; Seher Awan; Daniel Barton; David Piper; Foley, Michael; Zelkha, Mila; Palo Alto Renters" Association; Diana Diamond; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com; ladoris cordell; cromero@cityofepa.org; rabrica@cityofepa.org; Bill Newell; Bill Johnson; Bill James; Pat M; Carla Torres; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; Council, City; GRP-City Council; Perron, Zachary; City Attorney; citycouncil@mountainview.gov; Clerk, City; GRP-City Clerk; Friends of Cubberley; Lotus Fong; ParkRec Commission; Gardener, Liz; Human Relations Commission; Holman, Karen (external); Liz Kniss; Patrice Ventresca; Rowena Chiu; Dana St. George; Damon Silver; Daniel Kottke; Dennis Upton; Zahra Billoo; james pitkin; Roberta Ahlquist; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Supervisor Otto Lee; Stump, Molly; Rosen, Jeff; Baker, Rob; Ruth Silver Taube; Tom DuBois; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Jasso, Tamara; DuJuan Green; Dennis Upton; dennis burns; Jensen, Eric; Afanasiev, Alex; Lee, Craig; Anna Griffin; Angel, David; Greg Tanaka; Reifschneider, James; Bryan Gobin; Yolanda Conaway; Donna Wallach; Vara Ramakrishnan; Dave Price; Henry Riggs; Lewis James; Kaloma Smith; Palo Alto Weekly; Jennifer Morrow San José Spotlight; Raj Jayadev; Nicole Chiu-Wang; Dan Okonkwo; Rose Lynn; frances.Rothschild@jud.ca.gov; planning.commission@cityofpaloalto.0rg; Paul George @ PPJC; Roberta Ahlquist; ladoris cordell; Marina Lopez; Tim James; Josie James-Le; josh@joshsalcman.com; San Mateo Peace Action; EXT.Richard.Hobbs; Dave Price; Penni Wilson; Freddie.Quintana@sen.ca.gov; Vicki Veenker; yolanda; Councilmember Chappie Jones; District3@sanjoseca.gov; District4@sanjoseca.gov; District5@sanjoseca.gov; District9@sanjoseca.gov; District2@sanjoseca.gov Subject:Re: Famine Expert: Israel"s Starvation of Gaza Most "Minutely Designed and Controlled" Since WWII Date:Thursday, July 24, 2025 9:18:18 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. Salem, Thank you for your well-reasoned thoughtful and historically supported statement. Your scholarship on the topic is evident in every word and sentence you write. As a trial lawyer, if I were litigating the question of Israel’s guilt or innocence regarding war crimes and genocide, you would be my most compelling expert witness on the relevant issues. Because of your grasp of the facts the attorney attempting to defend Israel would have an impossible job of impeaching your credibility. I suspect the jurors would love your testimony regarding the history of Israel’s birth and your measured delivery. I would remove for cause from the jury all Zionists white supremacists cult members each badly in need of deprogramming. Freedom fighters of all backgrounds are welcome on the jury I would select. Your post contains zero wasted words or any standard Israel talk. I learned a tremendous amount from your post and realize how much more I need to learn to be even borderline conversant on the topic. So much appreciate you, Avram Finkelstein On Thu, Jul 24, 2025 at 2:45 PM, Salem Ajluni <ajluni@hotmail.com> wrote:As a modest contribution to a better understanding of the thinking and practices of the Israeli state, past and present, I recommend a very useful and short book that I read more than 40 years ago. It was written by Livia Rokach, the daughter of Israel Rokach who was the Israeli Interior Minister in the government of Moshe Sharett, the latter being the second prime minister of the new state (1953-1955). She translated and published her father's diaries, as well as parts of Sharett's diaries, both of which give us insights into the private elite thinking, planning and actions of main actors in the Israeli state vis-a-vis its neighboring countries in the 1950s (and vis-s- vis the U.S. and European powers) (see https://ia804501.us.archive.org/17/items/sacred-terrorism/Sacred- Terrorism.pdf). The resonance and parallels between Israeli leadership thinking and actions in the 1950s (as explained by Rokach) and in the 21st century with regard to the states and peoples of Lebanon, Syria, the West Bank, Gaza and Egypt (and, by extension, Iraq, Yemen and Iran) are instructive. There are considerable continuities across time and space: aggressive and domineering (supremicist?) thinking and behavior; an expansionist impulse; a sociopathic and homicidal (genocidal?) animus towards Arabs, especially Palestinians. It was all there in the 1940s and 1950s, as Rokach tells us, and it's all there now, as we witness on a daily basis. Israel certainly didn't need Hamas to induce such thinking and behavior. In fact, the Hamas movement wasn't formally inaugurated until late 1987, almost two generations after the establishment of the state of Israel. Reading historical accounts of the conflict teaches us that only the bugaboo changes (e.g. Nasser, the PLO, Saddam Hussein, Hizballah, Hamas, the Houthis, Iran, etc.)—the Israeli modus operandi is more or less a constant--maximal violence and aggression with little to no regard for the sanctity of the lives of civilian non- combatants. The Israeli state was ushered in and made possible by the intial displacement of the majority of Mandate Palestine's Arab population during 1947-1949 (on these events, see Ilan Pappe's book based in large part on official Israeli archival sources https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Ethnic_Cleansing_of_Palestine). It behooves us to remember that about two-thirds of Gaza's population are themselves refugees from Madate Palestine or the offspring of those refugees. No disconinuities there either. Regards, Salem From: Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> Sent: Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:23 PM To: Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> Cc: Veenker, Vicki <Vicki.Veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lythcott-Haims, Julie <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Keith Reckdahl <reckdahl@yahoo.com>; Ed Lauing <elauing@equitysearchpartners.com>; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23 <jessica@speiser.net>; Lori Meyers <meyers.lk@gmail.com>; Sheree Roth <ssroth29@gmail.com>; Henry Etzkowitz <H.Etzko@gmail.com>; Binder, Andrew <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mark Turner <mark.turner@morganhill.ca.gov>; CityCouncil <CityCouncil@morganhill.ca.gov>; Michelle Bigelow <Michelle.Bigelow@morganhill.ca.gov>; Josh Becker <becker.josh@gmail.com>; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov <assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <julieforpaloalto@gmail.com>; eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org <eric.figueroa@cityofpaloalto.org>; Doug Minkler <dminkler@dminkler.com>; Gerry Gras <gerrygras@earthlink.net>; EPA Today <epatoday@epatoday.org>; Gennady Sheyner <gsheyner@embarcaderomedia.org>; city.council@menlopark.gov <city.council@menlopark.gov>; dcombs@menlopark.gov <dcombs@menlopark.gov>; Steve Wagstaffe <swagstaffe@smcgov.org>; Jeff Rosen <info@jeffrosen.org>; Jeff Conrad <jeff_conrad@msn.com>; Jeff Hayden <laptoplg@mac.com>; Jay Boyarsky <jboyarsky@dao.sccgov.org>; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto <wilpf.peninsula.paloalto@gmail.com>; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com> <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas <nicholas.enberg@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mickie Winkler <mickie650@gmail.com>; Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com>; Cait James <caitlin.a.james@gmail.com>; San José Spotlight <info@sanjosespotlight.com>; board@pausd.org <board@pausd.org>; boardfeedback@smcgov.org <boardfeedback@smcgov.org>; board@valleywater.org <board@valleywater.org>; BoardOperations <BoardOperations@cob.sccgov.org>; Braden Cartwright <bcartwright@padailypost.com>; Raymond Goins <goinsrayl@gmail.com>; Rodriguez, Miguel <miguel.rodriguez@pdo.sccgov.org>; editor@paweekly.com <editor@paweekly.com>; April Wagner <april.wagner@cityofpaloalto.org>; Don Austin <daustin@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <donnaisanactivist@gmail.com>; Burt, Patrick <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov <Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov>; Palo Alto Free Press <paloaltofreepress@gmail.com>; Seher Awan <firebrand.dr@gmail.com>; Daniel Barton <dbarton@nbo.law>; David Piper <david.piper@wvm.edu>; michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org <michael.foley@cityofpaloalto.org>; Mila Zelkha <mila.zelkha@gmail.com>; Palo Alto Renters' Association <info@paloaltorenters.org>; Diana Diamond <dianaLdiamond@gmail.com>; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com <jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com>; ladoris cordell <ladoris@judgecordell.com>; cromero@cityofepa.org <cromero@cityofepa.org>; rabrica@cityofepa.org <rabrica@cityofepa.org>; Bill Newell <billnewell2850@gmail.com>; Bill Johnson <bjohnson@paweekly.com>; Bill James <billjames99@gmail.com>; Pat M <p.marshall81@ymail.com>; Carla Torres <xicanamagic@hotmail.com>; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan <mayor@sanjoseca.gov>; CityCouncil <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Council <council@redwoodcity.org>; Zachary.Perron@CityofPaloAlto.org <zachary.perron@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Attorney <CityAttorney@santaclaraca.gov>; citycouncil@mountainview.gov <citycouncil@mountainview.gov>; Clerk, City <city.clerk@cityofpaloalto.org>; GRP-City Clerk <CLERK2@redwoodcity.org>; Friends of Cubberley <friendsofcubberley94303@gmail.com>; Lotus Fong <lyfong@pacbell.net>; ParkRec Commission <ParkRec.commission@cityofpaloalto.org>; Liz Gardner <Gardnerjaqua@gmail.com>; Human Relations Commission <hrc@cityofpaloalto.org>; Karen Holman <kcholman@sbcglobal.net>; Liz Kniss <lizkniss@earthlink.net>; Patrice Ventresca <patriceventresca@gmail.com>; Rowena Chiu <rowena.chiu@gmail.com>; Dana St. George <danasg@earthlink.net>; Damon Silver <damon.silver@pdo.sccgov.org>; Daniel Kottke <daniel.k@earthlink.net>; Dennis Upton <kathy8420@qq.com>; Zahra Billoo <zbilloo@cair.com>; james pitkin <jamespitkin777@yahoo.com>; Roberta Ahlquist <roberta.ahlquist@sjsu.edu>; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg <supervisor.ellenberg@bos.sccgov.org>; Supervisor Otto Lee <supervisor.lee@bos.sccgov.org>; Salem Ajluni <ajluni@hotmail.com>; Stump, Molly <molly.stump@cityofpaloalto.org>; Rosen, Jeff <JRosen@dao.sccgov.org>; Baker, Rob <rbaker@dao.sccgov.org>; Ruth Silver Taube <ruthsilvertaube16@gmail.com>; Tom DuBois <tom.dubois@gmail.com>; Blackshire, Geoffrey <Geo.Blackshire@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jasso, Tamara <Tamara.Jasso@cityofpaloalto.org>; DuJuan Green <dujuang@sbcglobal.net>; Dennis Upton <denkafer1@yahoo.com>; dennis burns <dennis.r.burns@gmail.com>; Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org <Eric.Jensen@cityofpaloalto.org>; Alex Afanasiev <Alex.Afanasiev@cityofpaloalto.org>; craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org <craig.lee@cityofpaloalto.org>; Anna Griffin <griffinam@sbcglobal.net>; Angel, David <dangel@dao.sccgov.org>; Greg Tanaka <greg@gregtanaka.org>; Reifschneider, James <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Bryan Gobin <appeal.bryan.gobin@gmail.com>; Yolanda Conaway <yconaway@pausd.org>; Donna Wallach <cats4jazz@gmail.com>; Vara Ramakrishnan <vara@acm.org> Subject: Re: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' Since WWII The bias of the author is evident in the fact that the entire article mentions Hamas only once, in passing. Hamas could end the suffering tomorrow just by laying down their arms and releasing the hostages. But they care more about scoringpropaganda points against Israel than about saving the lives of their own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 22, 2025, at 3:08 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvationof Gaza Most 'Minutely Designedand Controlled' Since WWII Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed andControlled' Since WWII | Common Dreamshttps://www.commondreams.org/news/famine-expert-israel-s-starvation-of-gaza-most-minutely-designed-and-controlled-since-wwii From:Larry AltonTo:Council, City Subject:Fwd: It"s sad to see people like Galvin, a homeless man known to many for the damage he causes and the insults he says to people on University Avenue in Downtown Palo Alto. — NextdoorDate:Thursday, July 24, 2025 8:10:43 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. ! Sent from my iPhone Begin forwarded message: From: Larry Alton <lalton@pacbell.net>Date: July 23, 2025 at 10:04:02 AM PDTTo: Zongqi Alton <zqalton@gmail.com>Subject: It's sad to see people like Galvin, a homeless man known to many for the damage he causes and the insults he says to peopleon University Avenue in Downtown Palo Alto. — Nextdoor Something should be done about this man, the downtown sidewalks are disgustingly polluted and dirty Check out this post on Nextdoor: https://nextdoor.com/p/gYDKNX3xDfpN?utm_source=share&extras=MTgxNTE0&ne_link_preview_links=&share_platform=6&utm_campaign=1753290231087&share_action_id=a3e7d691-e2d2-4a75-a4b3-a002368f7891 Sent from my iPhone This message could be suspiciousThe sender's email address couldn't be verified. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast From:Carolyn Sledge To:Council, City Subject:Fw: No new pickle ball courts at Mitchell park Date:Thursday, July 24, 2025 4:59:14 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. i ----- Forwarded Message ----- From: Carolyn Sledge <carsledge@yahoo.com>To: City.Council@paloalto.gov <city.council@paloalto.gov>Cc: "parkrec.commision@paloalto.gov" <parkrec.commision@paloalto.gov>Sent: Thursday, July 24, 2025 at 04:55:27 PM PDTSubject: No new pickle ball courts at Mitchell park Hi ,I strongly appose adding anymore new pickle ball courts at Mitchell Park.The noise from the ones already there is very offensive.Parks should be a place to relax and stroll about. Noise pollution makes relaxation impossible.Please no additional Pickle ball courts. Thank you, Carolyn Sledge850 college avenue Palo Alto Ca This message needs your attention This is a personal email address. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast From:Carolyn Sledge To:Council, City Cc:ParkRec.commision@paloalto.gov Subject:No new pickle ball courts at Mitchell park Date:Thursday, July 24, 2025 4:55:47 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. Hi , I strongly appose adding anymore new pickle ball courts at Mitchell Park.The noise from the ones already there is very offensive.Parks should be a place to relax and stroll about. Noise pollution makes relaxation impossible. Please no additional Pickle ball courts. Thank you, Carolyn Sledge850 college avenue Palo Alto Ca From:matt@evolutionaryteams.comTo:fridaysforfuturepaloalto@gmail.com; Palo-Alto@fridaysforfutureusa.orgSubject:FFF Follow Up from July 18 (Week #184)Date:Thursday, July 24, 2025 2:46:35 PM Attachments:image003.png CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. i We enjoyed meeting under the cool shade of the blue-trunk magnolia trees as George kicked us off with our acknowledgment that we are on unceded lands of the Muwekma Ohlone and bear the obligation to care for the air, water and land that sustains all life. Thank you, George! Robin had no climate news to report though both she, Debbi and others expressed gratitude for our community of the climate-concerned. Thanks to you both for being in our community! Casey is stunned at the cascade of crises that we are now witnessing if not directly experiencing. We watch in horror the series of climate and ecological collapses. Now collapse is spilling over into socio-political realm. She is grateful that we have each other to navigate these collapses together. Thanks, Casey! Rick was pleased that 200 people attended San Mateo’s Good Trouble Lives On rally. He also gave advice on how to cope with the traumas of collapse, highlight being in a supportive community, spending time in nature, and taking walks, especially with a dog. Great suggestions, Rick, and congrats on the successful rally! Ingrid gleefully reported that she completed another book! In her new book, From Faith To Action: Stories of Engaged Discipleship, our prolific author presents 41 interviews organized into 5 sections: 1) Seeking justice; 2) Loving kindness; 3) Walking humbly; 4) Serving others; and 5) Creating beauty. She is pleased with the diversity of ideas and perspectives that the interviewees expressed and is eager to share them with the world. Find her book here. Thank you, Ingrid, for all your work and for promoting these important stories. George, seeking respite from depressing climate news, decided to re-read a favorite novel, Hitchhiker’s Guide to the Galaxy, only to realize how relevant that book is to our sad state of affairs. So long, and thanks for all the fish. Sorry, George, no escape for humans, only space-traveling dolphins. Brigette updated us on several alarming news items, notably the defunding of the Public Broadcast Corporation and the cancellation of Stephen Colbert’s Late Show. Alarming indeed that dissenting voices critical of Trump’s authoritarian regime are being systematically cancelled as institution after institution bends to the regime’s will. We are truly living in dark times. Thanks, Brigette, for staying on the alert. Both Ian and Carol K. warn that tech companies are promoting chat bot friends to “end loneliness.” They are confounded by how technology that socially isolates people can be marketed in that way. Tech companies relentless pursuit of our attention will indeed only serve isolate us, not bring us together. We must stay on guard for that, for ourselves, our friends, and our family, especially the young people. Thanks, Ian and Carol, for highlighting this. Blaine noted that deluging a population with news is a psychological warfare technique to debilitate the population and keep them from uniting, rising up and resisting. To avoid debilitation, he encourages us to: 1) not be alone; 2) be in friendship; and 3) socialize. Great advice, Blaine, thank you! Krista, the Besty Ross of Palo Alto and former Waldorf school teacher, joined us and shared her passion about the harm mobile devices and tech companies are perpetrating on people, especially young people. She has made it her life’s mission to ensure that these harms are minimized within our systems of education. Thank you, Krista, for doing this important work. Your newsletter author, Matt, expressed gratitude for our local black community members for raising their voices at the Good Trouble Lives On rally in Palo Alto. He notes that our local resistance movement has been attended predominantly by members of the white community. For our movement to grow, we must be inclusive and diverse if we are to hit our goal of 3.5% of the population on the street. It was very encouraging to see the diversity at the rally and, perhaps, this marks a positive step forward for the movement. Thanks to Indivisible Palo Alto Plus, speakers, musicians and information tablers for producing the successful Good Trouble Lives On Rally in Palo Alto. The organizers estimate there were over 1200 in attendance! Read IPA+’s report on the rally here. Notably Gregg Castro of the Ramaytush Ohlone Tribe spoke poignantly on this occasion as did Dr. Clarence Jones, personal advisor to Dr. Martin Luther King Jr. and friend of John Lewis. Listen to their important words here. Thanks, everyone, for the energizing rally! Carol P. and the SUFSS team continue to plan for the next Stand Up for Science and Sanity Rally on Friday August 18 in Lytton Plaza, with a terrific lineup of speakers from 5:30 to 6:30 followed by Mitchell Park Band rockin’ ‘til 9. Come join the fun! Mauni Jalali spoke at the last rally. Listen to his speech highlights here. Thanks, Carol P. and team! Emma just launched a BlueSky presence for her new project, palliative care for humanity. Be sure to follow the project here: https://bsky.app/profile/palliativehumanity.bsky.social Thanks for launching this, Emma -- more popcorn, please! Judy and the Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom have arranged for Helen Jaccard of the Golden Ruyle Project to speak on the dangers of nuclear annihilation on the 80th anniversary of the US bombing of Hiroshima, August 8 in Los Altos. See details below. With increasing geo-political instability, misinformation, cession of control to AI, nuclear war is as big a threat as ever. Thanks, Judy, for this important event and commemoration. In addition to weekly actions in front of the Tesla Showrooms at Stanford Shopping Center and on El Camino, the Tesla Takedown Wolves have added an additional action on Mondays at 4 to 6PM in front of the Tesla Engineering Headquarters on the intersection of Page Mill Rd. and Hanover St. The #teslatakedown efforts are remarkably successful! Gleefully, Tesla just reported double-digit declines in earnings and revenue for the quarter. Enjoy this latest comical addition to the protest. Keep up the great work! Looking forward to hearing about all the GOOD TROUBLE everyone has been up to this past week. See you Friday (7/25) at noon in King Plaza! Keep Up the Fight! This message needs your attentionSome Recipients have never replied to this person. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast RISE UP AND RESIST! Upcoming Events Friday, July 25, Noon to 1:00: Climate Strike! –– We meet at King Plaza in front of Palo Alto City Hall. Every Monday, 4 to 6PM: Protest! Elon Musk’s Illegal Government Takeover – Tesla Engineering Headquarters at Page Mill and Hanover. Every Wednesday, 4 to 6PM: Protest! Elon Musk’s Illegal Government Takeover – Tesla Showroom, 4180 El Camino Real. https://www.mobilize.us/ipaplus/ Every Saturday, Noon to 2PM: Protest! Elon Musk’s Illegal Government Takeover – Tesla Showroom at Stanford Shopping Center. https://www.mobilize.us/ipaplus/ Every Saturday, 1PM to 3PM: Protest! Elon Musk’s Illegal Government Takeover – Tesla Showroom, 4180 El Camino Real. https://www.mobilize.us/ipaplus/ Friday, Aug 1, Noon to 1:00: Climate March! –– We meet at King Plaza in front of Palo Alto City Hall and march through the streets of downtown Palo Alto. Photos and Videos of Recent Actions Speakers at the Good Trouble Lives On Rally: https://photos.google.com/photo/AF1QipPTqbZXu70dB1LjcNBRk_jrM_AMa345lWExfpWS Indivisible Palo Alto Plus Rally report: https://indivisiblepaloaltoplus.org/share-the-news/f/good-trouble-lives-on-in-palo-alto Climate Strike pictures: https://photos.google.com/photo/AF1QipPEcOy-5S81pNNrozu-woO62IUu9ItK4HWbEkAI Mauni Jalali speaks at the Stand Up For Science and Sanity Rally: https://youtu.be/gBH92YMYX58 What We Are Reading/Watching/Listening to: Reporting by Democracy Now! here Commentary by The Majority Report: here Heat Pump Water Heater and Home Electrification Program Update As of:7/1 6/2 5/1 3/31 HPWH full-service interest list signups 1411 1385 1364 1333 Site assessment agreements (SAA) sent 1411 1385 1364 1333 Signed SAAs 1169 1149 1127 1013 Completed site assessments 1064 1055 1040 1023 Installations Total Full Service HPWHs installed 433 427 421 414 Total DIY HPWH installed 132 131 126 115 Total Emergency HPWH installations 24 22 19 19 Total HPWHs installed 589 580 566 548 Target Installations 1000 1000 1000 1000 Monthly Installation Rate Monthly Installation Rate 9 14 18 14 Target Monthly Installation Rate 83 83 83 83 Follow Fridays For Future Palo Alto: Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/fridaysforfuture_paloalto/ YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@FridaysForFuturePaloAlto Email notifications of FFF Palo Alto events: https://mailchi.mp/c8c130127345/join-fridays-for-future-palo-alto You are receiving this email because you have expressed an interest in supporting climate action in Palo Alto. If you no longer wish to receive these emails, please let me know. Matt Schlegel Schlegel Consulting 650-924-8923 Author: Teamwork 9.0 Website: evolutionaryteams.com YouTube: youtube.com/channel/UCLkUMHuG4HVa831s9yeoZ5Q From:David Page To:davidP Subject:Join me; community party on Saturday! Date:Thursday, July 24, 2025 2:37:04 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. i Saturday, July 26, 2025 | 10:00 AM to 02:00 PM Palo Alto is hosting an Open House at the Municipal Service Center (MSC) to showcase some of the “behind the scenes” work that we do for the community. Bring your family, friends, and neighbors for a fun and educational day that is sure to please people of all ages! David Page This message needs your attention This is a personal email address. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast From:Martin Wasserman To:Aram James Cc:Veenker, Vicki; Lythcott-Haims, Julie; Reckdahl, Keith; Ed Lauing; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23; Lori Meyers; Sheree Roth; h.etzko@gmail.com; Binder, Andrew; Mark Turner; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; Josh Becker; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Julie Lythcott-Haims; Figueroa, Eric; Doug Minkler; Gerry Gras; EPA Today; Gennady Sheyner; city.council@menlopark.gov; dcombs@menlopark.gov; Steve Wagstaffe; Jeff Rosen; Jeff Conrad; Jeff Hayden; Jay Boyarsky; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas; Mickie Winkler; Sean Allen; Cait James; San José Spotlight; board@pausd.org; boardfeedback@smcgov.org; board@valleywater.org; BoardOperations; Braden Cartwright; Raymond Goins; Rodriguez, Miguel; editor@paweekly.com; Wagner, April; Don Austin; Donna Wallach; Burt, Patrick; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov; Palo Alto Free Press; Seher Awan; Daniel Barton; David Piper; Foley, Michael; Zelkha, Mila; Palo Alto Renters" Association; Diana Diamond; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com; ladoris cordell; cromero@cityofepa.org; rabrica@cityofepa.org; Bill Newell; Bill Johnson; Bill James; Pat M; Carla Torres; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; Council, City; GRP-City Council; Perron, Zachary; City Attorney; citycouncil@mountainview.gov; Clerk, City; GRP- City Clerk; Friends of Cubberley; Lotus Fong; ParkRec Commission; Gardener, Liz; Human Relations Commission; Holman, Karen (external); Liz Kniss; Patrice Ventresca; Rowena Chiu; Dana St. George; Damon Silver; Daniel Kottke; Dennis Upton; Zahra Billoo; james pitkin; Roberta Ahlquist; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Supervisor Otto Lee; Salem Ajluni; Stump, Molly; Rosen, Jeff; Baker, Rob; Ruth Silver Taube; Tom DuBois; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Jasso, Tamara; DuJuan Green; Dennis Upton; dennis burns; Jensen, Eric; Afanasiev, Alex; Lee, Craig; Anna Griffin; Angel, David; Greg Tanaka; Reifschneider, James; Bryan Gobin; Yolanda Conaway; Donna Wallach; Vara Ramakrishnan Subject:Re: Famine Expert: Israel"s Starvation of Gaza Most "Minutely Designed and Controlled" Since WWII Date:Thursday, July 24, 2025 12:13:08 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. The bias of the author is evident in the fact that the entire article mentions Hamasonly once, in passing. Hamas could end the suffering tomorrow just by laying downtheir arms and releasing the hostages. But they care more about scoring propaganda points against Israel than about saving the lives of their own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 22, 2025, at 3:08 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvationof Gaza Most 'Minutely Designedand Controlled' Since WWII Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed andControlled' Since WWII | Common Dreamshttps://www.commondreams.org/news/famine-expert-israel-s-starvation-of-gaza-most-minutely-designed-and-controlled-since-wwii From:Jennifer Landesmann To:repsamliccardo@mail8.housecommunications.gov Cc:Eric.Henshall@mail.house.gov; Council, City Subject:REQUEST FOR ASSISTANCE - Extension needed for public comment on FAA and DOT orders about procedures toimplement NEPA Date:Thursday, July 24, 2025 9:17:20 AM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. Dear Representative Liccardo, The FAA and DOT are updating Orders 1050.1F and 5610.C per Federal register notices FAA-2025-1571 and DOT–OST–2025–0171 both issued on July 9; comments due by August 4. If at all possible, please intervene to extend the public comment period. The FAA'songoing review of Aviation Noise policy (1050.1F) generated over 4000 comments in FederalRegister FAA- 2023-0855-0001 - many from MidPeninsula cities. These orders directlyimpact your constituents who greatly prioritize the protection of the natural and humanenvironment, and we look to you to ensure that we are given appropriate notice and outreachwhen something could alter the practices of federal and local agencies as regards transparencyand public involvement to help make informed decisions. The reasons why these notices demand an extension are as follows: 1) FAA's 1050.1F has generated extraordinary public interest, and the FAA invited peopleto sign up to receive email updates to track the FAA's Noise Policy Review but theseinterested parties have not been notified about changes to 1050.1F or 5610.C. The generalpublic and people who stand to be affected by airport projects are also being left in the dark.An extension should be made known to the FAA's email list about both FR notices anddeadlines. 2) How the changes are being made in the orders themselves is impossible to understand, asnoted by the comment submitted by the City of Phoenix: Meaningful Engagement: It seems unlikely that most stakeholders impacted by proposed changes would reasonably be able to review it without a “red line” or track changes version comparing it to 1050.1F. The FAA should consider posting a document that provides comparable review value and should extend the comment deadline an additional 30 days from when that comparable review version is available. The irony is that NEPA is meant to foster transparency but transparency dies in the issuance of the rules. Please HELP! Thank you, Jennifer Landesmann Palo Alto, CA From:Santa Dasu Kondapalli To:Council, City Subject:hello - Seeking a meeting with Mayor of Palo Alto Date:Wednesday, July 23, 2025 11:26:25 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. i Dear Mayor of Palo Alto, I am a resident of Palo Alto for the past 25 years. I am the founder of a non profit that presents classical indian performing arts through various concerts in theaters, studios and parks since 2006. Is it possible for me to meet with you to discuss specifically our mission and seek any help from your offices.About 20 minutes would be sufficient. Thanks in advance Santa Dasu http://www.yuvabharati.org http://www.swaralahari.org ThanksSanta Dasu 408 3733714 This message needs your attention This is a personal email address. This is their first email to you. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast From:Frank Holland To:Council, City Subject:Reconsideration of Palo Alto’s Endorsement of SB 54 and Sanctuary Policy Date:Wednesday, July 23, 2025 10:58:20 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. i Dear Mayor Stone and Members of the Palo Alto City Council, I write as a concerned resident to respectfully urge this Council to revisit and reconsider the City’s support for California’s sanctuary law, SB 54 (the California Values Act), and the related policies it has inspired at the local level. While I appreciate the motivations behind the sanctuary framework, it has become increasingly clear that the law is not achieving its intended goals and that it is contributing to deeper national polarization and local confusion about the limits and responsibilities of city authority. SB 54 was designed to foster trust, promote public safety, and ensure more effective use of local resources. However, real-world outcomes tell a different story: 1. Public Safety and Trust: SB 54’s limitations on cooperation with federal authorities have inadvertently led to more large-scale ICE raids in residential and commercial areas: including across parts of Santa Barbara and Ventura Counties earlier this year. These high- visibility operations spread fear across immigrant communities and undercut the very trust that SB 54 was meant to foster. Local families are not safer when federal enforcement escalates due to state or local non-cooperation. 2. Resource Misalignment: California has now spent over $50 million in just the past five months to legally and politically resist federal immigration enforcement with a further $120 million proposed. Palo Alto’s moral endorsement of such policies carries weight. These resources could instead support housing, schools, or public safety initiatives that directly benefit residents of all immigration statuses. 3. Polarization and Stalled Reform: When local jurisdictions align unconditionally with maximalist sanctuary policies, they feed into a broader federal-state conflict that paralyzes meaningful immigration reform. Cities known for innovation, inclusion, and pragmatic leadership, like Palo Alto, have a unique opportunity to advocate for a more balanced, solution-oriented approach. This message needs your attention This is a personal email address. This is their first email to your company. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast I urge the Council to take the following actions: Publicly call for a state-level reassessment of SB 54, particularly around policies that prevent cooperation in cases beyond violent felonies already authorized by SB 54. Support a framework for selective cooperation with federal agencies when due process has been observed and humanitarian concerns have been weighed: particularly for long- term residents and DACA-eligible individuals. Ensure future “Know Your Rights” events provide accurate constitutional context, including acknowledgment of Article VI of the U.S. Constitution, which affirms the supremacy of federal law. Palo Alto should not be forced to choose between compassion and compliance. We can lead by advocating for lawful, humane, and practical immigration enforcement and we should not be endorsing blanket policies that are no longer serving our city or our country effectively. I respectfully request the courtesy of a response outlining each Council member’s position on this issue and any intended actions to address the concerns raised above. Thank you for your attention and leadership on this critical matter. Sincerely, Frank Holland dutch_06@yahoo.com Xenia CzischVice President ofOperations phone: (650) 858-2491mobile: (650) 804-4225fax: (650) 858-2494 4047 Transport StPalo Alto, CA 94303www.qualitymetalspinning.us From:Osbaldo RTo:Xenia Czisch; Bill McLaneCc:Marguerite Poyatos; Ramon Moreno; Lester Wong; Maor Greenberg; Dave Stellman; Patrick Kelly; Gaines, Chantal; Manu Kumar; Becchetti, Benjamin; Cathi Lerch; Dave Stellman; City Mgr; Moffatt, Pete; Jacob@onemovemovers.com; david@paloaltoconcrete.com; Steve Wong; nancy@drewmaran.com; Dan McKinley; McDonough, Melissa; Reifschneider, James; Transportation; John Lerch; Binder, Andrew; Jade Jin; City Attorney; Lauing, Ed; Lydia Kou; Veenker, Vicki; Council, City; Burt, Patrick; Stone, Greer; Lythcott-Haims, Julie; Staceytomson@qmsshields.comSubject:RE: Industrial/Transport/Commercial SafetyDate:Wednesday, July 23, 2025 1:59:54 PMAttachments:image011.pngimage015.pngimage016.pngimage017.pngimage018.pngimage019.pngimage020.pngimage021.png CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. i O.R. Builders Inc.Osbaldo RomeroPresident 939 Industrial AvePalo Alto, Ca. 94303Phone: 650.938.2222Fax: 650.938.2224Cell: 415.215.6788 From: Xenia Czisch <xenia@qmsshields.com> Sent: Wednesday, July 23, 2025 1:53 PMTo: 'Bill McLane' <bill@paloaltoglass.com>Cc: 'Marguerite Poyatos' <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com>; 'Ramon Moreno' <ramonmorenoschool@gmail.com>; 'Lester Wong' <LWong@wongelectric.com>; 'Maor Greenberg' <maor@greenberg.construction>; 'Dave Stellman' <davestellman@gmail.com>; 'Patrick Kelly' <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org; osbaldo@or-builders.com; 'Manu Kumar' <manu@k9ventures.com>; 'Benjamin Becchetti' <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; 'Cathi Lerch'<cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; 'Dave Stellman' <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; 'City Mgr' <CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; 'Pete Moffatt' <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com; david@paloaltoconcrete.com; 'Steve Wong' <SWong@wongelectric.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com; 'Dan McKinley' <danmck@scientific-equipment.com>; 'Melissa McDonough' <Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; 'James Reifschneider' <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; 'Transportation'<transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; 'John Lerch' <john@lerchconstruction.com>; 'Andrew Binder' <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; 'Jade Jin' <JJin@wongelectric.com>; 'City Attorney' <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; 'Ed Lauing' <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; 'Lydia Kou' <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; 'Vicki Veenker' <vicki.veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; 'City Council' <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; 'Patrick Burt' <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; 'Greer Stone'<Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; 'Julie Lythcott-Haims' <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Staceytomson@qmsshields.comSubject: RE: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety + Staceytomson@qmsshields.com From: Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> Sent: Wednesday, July 23, 2025 1:48 PMTo: Xenia Czisch <xenia@qmsshields.com>Cc: Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com>; Ramon Moreno <ramonmorenoschool@gmail.com>; Lester Wong <LWong@wongelectric.com>; Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction>; Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org; osbaldo@or-builders.com; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Cathi Lerch<cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr <CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com; david@paloaltoconcrete.com; Steve Wong <SWong@wongelectric.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific-equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough <Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation<transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <vicki.veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>;Julie Lythcott-Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety I didn’t get my tape measure out, but I’d be willing to bet this is more than 18 inches from the curb. I believe that’s a violation of California parking laws. This message needs your attentionThis is their first mail to some recipients. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast Xenia CzischVice President ofOperations phone: (650) 858-2491mobile: (650) 804-4225 4047 Transport StPalo Alto, CA 94303 Bill McLane---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc.4085 Transport StreetPalo Alto, CA 94303650-494-7000 Officewww.paloaltoglass.com On Wed, Jul 23, 2025 at 1:25 PM Xenia Czisch <xenia@qmsshields.com> wrote: + staceytomson@qmsshields.com fax: (650) 858-2494 www.qualitymetalspinning.us From: Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com> Sent: Wednesday, July 23, 2025 1:13 PMTo: Ramon Moreno <ramonmorenoschool@gmail.com>Cc: Lester Wong <LWong@wongelectric.com>; Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction>; Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org; osbaldo@or-builders.com; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr<CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com; david@paloaltoconcrete.com; Steve Wong <SWong@wongelectric.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific-equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough <Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder<Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <vicki.veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott-Haims<Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety Chantal, Please see the attached images. An enforcement officer went around this morning and gave out the 72 hour tow notices. I watched the gentleman with the Raiders RV (in attached image) remove all tow notices from his vehicles and will not move them. I will be taking pictures of his vehicles in the next coming days to show that he will be in violation of the notices. Also, he has a propane tank (also in attached image) that has been sitting in the street for a few months now. Can that be addressed? The other picture shows a tow notice sitting in the gutter, which is where many of these end up. Can there be any enforcement for littering? As others are stating, I would also hope something can be done for the safety of pedestrians. As I was walking to my car today, I was almost hit by a car because there is no visibility for cars coming down the street or pedestrians. Thank you. On Mon, Jul 21, 2025 at 12:12 PM Ramon Moreno <ramonmorenoschool@gmail.com> wrote: Dear City of Palo Alto, I am writing to express my deep concern regarding the ongoing issues caused by the RV encampments in Palo Alto, which are directly impacting my business and the safety of my students and their families. As the owner of the Ramon Moreno School of Ballet, I am dedicated to maintaining a safe, clean, and welcoming environment for our students and their families. However, recent circumstances are making that increasingly difficult. One of the most pressing issues is illegal dumping. Individuals from the RV encampments have been using my business’s garbage disposal for their personal waste, resulting in contamination. Because of this, the city has refused to collect the trash, and I have now been left to clean and dispose of everything myself—at my own expense. If I don’t, I’ve been informed that I may face additional charges. This is unacceptable and places an unfair financial andoperational burden on my business. I understand that I am not alone—many neighboring businesses are facing similar challenges. Additionally, the presence of these encampments has created ongoing safety concerns. Several families have shared their discomfort and hesitation about bringing their children to class, due to the unpredictable and sometimes unsafe conditions surrounding my studio. This is not just an inconvenience; it poses a direct risk to the well-being of the children, their families, my staff, and the reputation of our school. I would like to know what specific actions the city is taking to address these challenges. While I understand that this is a complex issue, local businesses should not be expected to shoulder the consequences alone. The safety of our community and the ability for small businesses to operate without disruption should be a priority. I urge the City of Palo Alto to present a clear and immediate plan of action that includes: Proper and reliable waste management enforcementIncreased monitoring and enforcement of local ordinancesMeasures to ensure public safety for local families and business owners Attached to this email are photos documenting the contamination of my garbage disposal and the resulting conditions. I hope these images convey the seriousness of the situation and the urgent need for intervention. Thank you for your attention to this matter. I look forward to your response and to seeing meaningful steps taken to support the well-being of our local business community. Sincerely, Ramon Moreno Owner & Director Ramon Moreno School of Ballet Please feel free to text or call:650-304-1909 Thank you, Ramon Moreno www.ramonmorenoballet.comwww.facebook.com/pg/RamonMorenoSchool On Thu, Mar 13, 2025 at 12:43 PM Lester Wong <LWong@wongelectric.com> wrote: Commercial St. was cleared last night. Thank you for your efforts! Lester Wong | Vice PresidentO: 650.813.9999 ext. 22 | C: 650.720.84554067 Transport Street | Palo Alto | CA 94303Celebrating Our 46th Anniversary 1978 – 2024 A Proud Member of the U.S. Green Building Council From: Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com>Sent: Thursday, March 13, 2025 12:37:47 PMTo: Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction>Cc: Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org <chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org>; osbaldo@or-builders.com <osbaldo@or-builders.com>; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lester Wong <LWong@wongelectric.com>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman<dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr <CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com <Jacob@onemovemovers.com>; david@paloaltoconcrete.com <david@paloaltoconcrete.com>; Steve Wong <SWong@wongelectric.com>; RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com <RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com <nancy@drewmaran.com>; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific-equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough<Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker<vicki.veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety The wooden RV seems to be a severe safety issue. A former coworker spoke to the man living in it a couple years ago and was told there is a wood burning oven/stove inside the RV, which he uses. Seems like that could be a severe safety hazard not only for the man residing in it, as well as for the surrounding RV's/vehicles & businesses if it were ever to catch fire. We have had to face a number of safety hazards on this street. It is unsafe for pedestrians. We have had attempted break ins at night. We have been harassed by people associated with these RV's, as well as loose dogs, just to name a couple issues. Luckily, police officers do respond and try to help but there will be a time when they will be too late to prevent injury. The community officers coming through and putting notices on vehicles is nowhere near the solution needed for this area. The notices are thrown away and the vehicles rarely move. I believe this email string started in 2023 and we have had minimal progress with the actual issues at hand. On Thu, Mar 13, 2025 at 12:19 PM Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction> wrote: City of palo alto!! please let me know how this is Legal for driving also come and clean the street as it’s not safe see attached Maor Greenberg CEO maor@greenberg.construction | 650-610-7711Greenberg.Construction | 650-600-9536 x101 | Fax 925-269-2325 908 Industrial Ave, Palo Alto 94303 From: Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2025 10:56:09 AMTo: Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>Cc: Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>; Marguerite Poyatos <MARGUERITE@paloaltoglass.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org <chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org>; osbaldo@or-builders.com <osbaldo@or-builders.com>; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lester Wong <lwong@wongelectric.com>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr<CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com <Jacob@onemovemovers.com>; david@paloaltoconcrete.com <david@paloaltoconcrete.com>; Steve Wong <swong@wongelectric.com>; RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com <RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com <nancy@drewmaran.com>; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific-equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough <Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>;James Reifschneider <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <vicki.veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council<city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction>Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety What is it going to take for the city of Palo Alto to catch up to the rest of the country? A lawsuit when someone in our neighborhood is injured because of the unsafe conditions that exist here? This email chain alone would be enough evidence to show the city’s knowledge of the problem and inaction. With newly enacted laws giving cities the legal right to clean up our public spaces, local cities like Mountain View, Santa Clara and San Jose have already begun the process of relocating and housing these people that need it. Why not Palo Alto? Its not a money issue here, and even if it was, wouldn’t it be less costly to tow some vehicles and help relocate them to a safer area than to pay the cost of litigation? We are asking the city to stop ignoring this issue before it becomes an even bigger problem. On Mar 12, 2025, at 9:17 AM, Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com> wrote: Hi Ben,Please take action. The safety of our employees and locals is critical. Anyone walking or driving on Industrial/Transport/Commercial is constantly at risk. Every crosswalk and entry is a major risk for anyone walking the sidewalks or pulling into any of these facilities where illegally parked abandoned vehicles are encamped. The visibility is very poor and the reason there are height and length restrictions for these types of streets; There are There are illegally running generators with unsafe live electrical lines oftentimes in the sidewalk or even running across entryways There are collections of volatile liquids like gasoline and oil (environmental issues aside) that pose additional hazards to anyone in the vicinity Please let us know what you need from us to support your team in enforcing our city regulations in order to make our workplaces safer for our employees. Respectfully, Patrick Kelly | CIODMD Systems Recovery, LLC.C: 650.492.9003patrick.kelly@dmdsystems.com | www.dmdsystems.com<Outlook-DMD Logo.png> <Outlook-larpkod1.png> Book time to meet with me From: Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>Sent: Wednesday, February 5, 2025 12:39 PMTo: Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com>Cc: Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org <chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org>; osbaldo@or-builders.com <osbaldo@or-builders.com>; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lester Wong <lwong@wongelectric.com>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr <CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt<pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com <Jacob@onemovemovers.com>; david@paloaltoconcrete.com <david@paloaltoconcrete.com>; Steve Wong <swong@wongelectric.com>; RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com <RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com <nancy@drewmaran.com>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific-equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough<Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <James.Reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <Transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing<Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <Vicki.Veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <Pat.Burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Maor <maor@greenberg.construction>Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial concernsA citation for double parking and expired tags is what is needed here. I’m positive that’s what the police would do to me if I did the same. That is unless there are two separate sets of laws that govsophospsmartbannerendA citation for double parking and expired tags is what is needed here. I’m positive that’s what the police would do to me if I did the same. That is unless there are two separate sets of laws that govern the city of Palo Alto and the state of California. Bill McLane---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc.4085 Transport StreetPalo Alto, CA 94303650-494-7000 Officewww.paloaltoglass.com On Wed, Feb 5, 2025 at 10:13 AM Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: Please see the attached image. The pictured RV & associated white truck pulled up over night. As pictured, they disregarded marked parking spots, which is one of the things that exacerbates our parking issue. A small car or motorcycle may fit there but in a commercial area where most vehicles are trucks, this does not help. Can you please send a community officer to leave notices on the RVs? I hope this doesn't come across as petty, but every spot really does matter on this block. Employees of some businesses have to park in lots that belong to other businesses, which can create tension amongst neighbors. Thank you. On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 9:19 PM Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com> wrote: The police also responded and were very helpful. Initially the people involved denied everything, but when I sent the videos to the officer and he showed it to them they admitted to dumping their RV waste. They were cited for misdemeanor illegal waste dumping and will be going to court. They were then told to leave the area - and freed up two parking spaces. Thank you Palo Alto Police and Fire. Apparently reportingviolations of every kind is what is going to have to be done on a regular basis if we want our streets cleaned up. On Dec 21, 2024, at 3:39 PM, Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: Thank you, Dave! Bill McLane---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc.4085 Transport StreetPalo Alto, CA 94303650-494-7000 Officewww.paloaltoglass.com On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 8:22 AM Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com> wrote: I just called the hotline for Palo Alto for hazardous waste dumping and gave them all of this information including license numbers. These vehicles are still parked there.They are sending the fire department out to flush the street and these people better be held accountable. On Dec 21, 2024, at 7:56 AM, Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: License plate of the accomplice<IMG_0142.jpeg> Bill McLane---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc.4085 Transport StreetPalo Alto, CA 94303650-494-7000 Officewww.paloaltoglass.com On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 5:13 AM Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: Still parked right across from my building. Note, NO rear license plate. I do think that is against the law. I do also have video of them driving up, proof of the vehicle operating on city streets. Do you think they have insurance? <image.png> Bill McLane---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc.4085 Transport StreetPalo Alto, CA 94303650-494-7000 Officewww.paloaltoglass.com On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 4:54 AM Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: Here, they are emptying their waste in front of my building. Bill McLane---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc.4085 Transport StreetPalo Alto, CA 94303650-494-7000 Officewww.paloaltoglass.com On Fri, Dec 20, 2024 at 9:18 PM Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com> wrote: Chantal, It looks like somehow most of the city council members, Vice Mayor and Mayor must have inadvertently been deleted from your last email response. I have added them back in to make sure they stay apprised of the situation. I hope it doesn't take the legal channels mentioned to start cleaning up our neighborhood immediately; this has gotten out of control and kicking the problem back and forth to different members of your city staff is not going to make it go away. Dave StellmanTransport St. On Fri, Dec 20, 2024 at 8:16 AM Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction> wrote:Dear Chantal, Your response, while detailed, fails to address the critical and ongoing violations of law, public safety, and business rights in the area. The City of Palo Alto has both the authority and obligation to take immediate and decisive action to protect its residents, businesses, and public spaces. Allowing illegally parked, unsafe, and hazardous RVs to persist is unacceptable and directly violates state and local regulations. Below are specific legal and factual challenges tothe City’s approach, along with demands for corrective action: 1. Illegally Parked and Unsafe RVs California Vehicle Code § 4000(a)(1) and Palo Alto Municipal Code § 10.48.010 clearly require all vehicles parked on public streets to display valid registration. Many of the RVs in question lack valid registration, making their presence illegal. Further, under California Vehicle Code § 22651(o) and PAMC § 10.48.120, any vehicle unregistered for six months or more may be towed immediately. Additionally, vehicles with exposed sewage tanks, missing wheels, or other structural hazards are in direct violation of California Vehicle Code § 24002, which prohibits parking or operating vehicles in unsafe conditions. These RVs also create a public health hazard under California Health and Safety Code § 117490, which prohibits improper disposal of waste and sewage. **2. Clarification Requested Regarding Unregistered Vehicles In light of your response, please confirm whether the City of Palo Alto allows unregistered vehicles to be driven on its streets. - I have some fun vehicles I would love to order from Alibaba and drive them around Palo Alto... • California Vehicle Code § 4000(a)(1) expressly prohibits the operation of unregistered vehicles. If these RVs are being moved every 72 hours as claimed, and they lack proper registration, their operation is illegal under state law. • Allowing unregistered vehicles to remain or operate within city limits undermines traffic safety and compliance standards. This point must be clarified explicitly: Does the City of Palo Alto condone the operation of unregistered vehicles? 3. Abuse of the 72-Hour Rule The City’s reliance on PAMC § 10.36.060 to justify the continued presence of these RVs is flawed. Surveillance footage and eyewitness accounts confirm that many RVs are circumventing the 72-hour rule by wiping off chalk markings rather than physically moving. This is blatant non-compliance and undermines the intent of the ordinance. Furthermore, California Vehicle Code § 22669 explicitly allows for the removal of vehicles that are “wrecked, dismantled, or inoperative,” even if they are moved every 72 hours. The City has the authority to act, and failing to do so jeopardizes public safety and traffic flow. 4. Public Safety and Sanitation Violations The exposed sewage tanks, illegal dumping, and general neglect by these RV occupants pose significant health and environmental risks. The City’s failure to enforce sanitation laws, such as California Health and Safety Code § 117490 and PAMC § 16.09.100, endangers residents, workers, and the environment. Additionally, blocking roadways and driveways is a clear violation of California Vehicle Code § 22500, which prohibits parking that obstructs trafficflow or access. 5. Impact on Businesses and Traffic Flow Businesses in the area are suffering due to blocked roadways, limited parking for customers, and safety concerns. Under California Vehicle Code § 21101(c) and PAMC § 10.48.120, the City has the authority to regulate parking to ensure the safety of businesses and residents. The City’s failure to allocate parking for business deliveries, customers, or even emergency services is a gross dereliction of duty. Blocking roadways for long periods creates safety hazards, violates municipal code, and disrupts commerce. Conclusion and Final Demands The City of Palo Alto has the legal authority and responsibility to act under the following regulations: • PAMC § 10.48.120: Authorizes the removal of unregistered vehicles. • California Vehicle Code § 22651(o): Allows towing of unregistered vehicles. • California Vehicle Code § 22669: Mandates removal of inoperative vehicles. • California Health and Safety Code § 117490: Prohibits illegal waste disposal. • California Vehicle Code § 21101(c): Permits parking restrictions to ensure safety. We demand the immediate implementation of the following measures: 1. Impound all unregistered, unsafe, or inoperative RVs within two weeks. 2. Establish designated loading zones and 2-hour parking areas near businesses. 3. Conduct regular sanitation inspections and impose penalties for violations. 4. Provide a clear timeline for resolution and enforcement updates. The continued failure to act exposes the City to liability for neglecting public health and safety under California Government Code § 815.6, which requires municipalities to perform mandatory duties. We expect a formal response with a clear action plan within 14 days. If no satisfactory action is taken, we reserve the right to escalate this matter through legal channels to protect our businesses, employees, and the community. <email-signture_87b8d7a2-c4f4-4cbf-b474-af2f32118dd2.png> Maor Greenberg CEOmaor@greenberg.construction | 650-610-7711 Greenberg.Construction | 650-600-9536 x101 | Fax 925-269-2325 908 Industrial Ave, Palo Alto 94303 <F_1bc77f31-68bf-4143-80ea-3f34f539ea07.png> <insta_26696304-1b39-4259-9776-9f137454bed9.png> <yelp_e821c57e-caea-4e87-a5dd-5905e7ca4fb1.png> <Houzz_7abe75ad-d6ee-48ac-943b-592713e31957.png> <P_aece63f3-754b-4dca-a0a9-e93b94de4930.png> <google_04352117-2fb4-4963-bb3e-cc5317269360.png> From: Gaines, Chantal <Chantal.Gaines@CityofPaloAlto.org>Date: Friday, December 20, 2024 at 7:12 AMTo: Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction>, Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com>, osbaldo@or-builders.com <osbaldo@or-builders.com>Cc: Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>, Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>, Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>, Becchetti, Benjamin <Benjamin.Becchetti@CityofPaloAlto.org>, Lester Wong <lwong@wongelectric.com>, Cathi Lerch < --Marguerite PoyatosPalo Alto Glass, Inc.4085 Transport StreetPalo Alto CA 94303(650) 494-7000(650) 494-7087 (FAX) Xenia CzischVice President ofOperations phone: (650) 858-2491mobile: (650) 804-4225fax: (650) 858-2494 4047 Transport StPalo Alto, CA 94303www.qualitymetalspinning.us From:Xenia CzischTo:"Bill McLane"Cc:"Marguerite Poyatos"; "Ramon Moreno"; "Lester Wong"; "Maor Greenberg"; "Dave Stellman"; "Patrick Kelly"; Gaines, Chantal; osbaldo@or-builders.com; "Manu Kumar"; Becchetti, Benjamin; "Cathi Lerch"; "Dave Stellman"; City Mgr; Moffatt, Pete; Jacob@onemovemovers.com; david@paloaltoconcrete.com; "Steve Wong"; nancy@drewmaran.com; "Dan McKinley"; McDonough, Melissa; Reifschneider, James; Transportation; "John Lerch"; Binder, Andrew; "Jade Jin"; City Attorney; Lauing, Ed; "Lydia Kou"; Veenker, Vicki; Council, City; Burt, Patrick; Stone, Greer; Lythcott-Haims, Julie; Staceytomson@qmsshields.comSubject:RE: Industrial/Transport/Commercial SafetyDate:Wednesday, July 23, 2025 1:53:02 PMAttachments:image004.pngimage005.pngimage006.pngimage007.pngimage008.pngimage009.pngimage010.png CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. + Staceytomson@qmsshields.com From: Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> Sent: Wednesday, July 23, 2025 1:48 PMTo: Xenia Czisch <xenia@qmsshields.com>Cc: Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com>; Ramon Moreno <ramonmorenoschool@gmail.com>; Lester Wong <LWong@wongelectric.com>; Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction>; Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org; osbaldo@or-builders.com; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Cathi Lerch<cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr <CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com; david@paloaltoconcrete.com; Steve Wong <SWong@wongelectric.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific-equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough <Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation<transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <vicki.veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>;Julie Lythcott-Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety I didn’t get my tape measure out, but I’d be willing to bet this is more than 18 inches from the curb. I believe that’s a violation of California parking laws. Xenia CzischVice President ofOperations Bill McLane---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc.4085 Transport StreetPalo Alto, CA 94303650-494-7000 Officewww.paloaltoglass.com On Wed, Jul 23, 2025 at 1:25 PM Xenia Czisch <xenia@qmsshields.com> wrote: + staceytomson@qmsshields.com phone: (650) 858-2491mobile: (650) 804-4225fax: (650) 858-2494 4047 Transport StPalo Alto, CA 94303 www.qualitymetalspinning.us From: Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com> Sent: Wednesday, July 23, 2025 1:13 PMTo: Ramon Moreno <ramonmorenoschool@gmail.com>Cc: Lester Wong <LWong@wongelectric.com>; Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction>; Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org; osbaldo@or-builders.com; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr<CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com; david@paloaltoconcrete.com; Steve Wong <SWong@wongelectric.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific-equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough <Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder<Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <vicki.veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott-Haims<Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety Chantal, Please see the attached images. An enforcement officer went around this morning and gave out the 72 hour tow notices. I watched the gentleman with the Raiders RV (in attached image) remove all tow notices from his vehicles and will not move them. I will be taking pictures of his vehicles in the next coming days to show that he will be in violation of the notices. Also, he has a propane tank (also in attached image) that has been sitting in the street for a few months now. Can that be addressed? The other picture shows a tow notice sitting in the gutter, which is where many of these end up. Can there be any enforcement for littering? As others are stating, I would also hope something can be done for the safety of pedestrians. As I was walking to my car today, I was almost hit by a car because there is no visibility for cars coming down the street or pedestrians. Thank you. On Mon, Jul 21, 2025 at 12:12 PM Ramon Moreno <ramonmorenoschool@gmail.com> wrote: Dear City of Palo Alto, I am writing to express my deep concern regarding the ongoing issues caused by the RV encampments in Palo Alto, which are directly impacting my business and the safety of my students and their families. As the owner of the Ramon Moreno School of Ballet, I am dedicated to maintaining a safe, clean, and welcoming environment for our students and their families. However, recent circumstances are making that increasingly difficult. One of the most pressing issues is illegal dumping. Individuals from the RV encampments have been using my business’s garbage disposal for their personal waste, resulting in contamination. Because of this, the city has refused to collect the trash, and I have now been left to clean and dispose of everything myself—at my own expense. If I don’t, I’ve been informed that I may face additional charges. This is unacceptable and places an unfair financial andoperational burden on my business. I understand that I am not alone—many neighboring businesses are facing similar challenges. Additionally, the presence of these encampments has created ongoing safety concerns. Several families have shared their discomfort and hesitation about bringing their children to class, due to the unpredictable and sometimes unsafe conditions surrounding my studio. This is not just an inconvenience; it poses a direct risk to the well-being of the children, their families, my staff, and the reputation of our school. I would like to know what specific actions the city is taking to address these challenges. While I understand that this is a complex issue, local businesses should not be expected to shoulder the consequences alone. The safety of our community and the ability for small businesses to operate without disruption should be a priority. I urge the City of Palo Alto to present a clear and immediate plan of action that includes: Proper and reliable waste management enforcementIncreased monitoring and enforcement of local ordinancesMeasures to ensure public safety for local families and business owners Attached to this email are photos documenting the contamination of my garbage disposal and the resulting conditions. I hope these images convey the seriousness of the situation and the urgent need for intervention. Thank you for your attention to this matter. I look forward to your response and to seeing meaningful steps taken to support the well-being of our local business community. Sincerely, Ramon Moreno Owner & Director Ramon Moreno School of Ballet Please feel free to text or call:650-304-1909 Thank you, Ramon Moreno www.ramonmorenoballet.com www.facebook.com/pg/RamonMorenoSchool On Thu, Mar 13, 2025 at 12:43 PM Lester Wong <LWong@wongelectric.com> wrote: Commercial St. was cleared last night. Thank you for your efforts! Lester Wong | Vice PresidentO: 650.813.9999 ext. 22 | C: 650.720.84554067 Transport Street | Palo Alto | CA 94303Celebrating Our 46th Anniversary 1978 – 2024 A Proud Member of the U.S. Green Building Council From: Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com>Sent: Thursday, March 13, 2025 12:37:47 PMTo: Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction>Cc: Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org <chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org>; osbaldo@or-builders.com <osbaldo@or-builders.com>; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lester Wong <LWong@wongelectric.com>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman<dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr <CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com <Jacob@onemovemovers.com>; david@paloaltoconcrete.com <david@paloaltoconcrete.com>; Steve Wong <SWong@wongelectric.com>; RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com <RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com <nancy@drewmaran.com>; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific-equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough<Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker<vicki.veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety The wooden RV seems to be a severe safety issue. A former coworker spoke to the man living in it a couple years ago and was told there is a wood burning oven/stove inside the RV, which he uses. Seems like that could be a severe safety hazard not only for the man residing in it, as well as for the surrounding RV's/vehicles & businesses if it were ever to catch fire. We have had to face a number of safety hazards on this street. It is unsafe for pedestrians. We have had attempted break ins at night. We have been harassed by people associated with these RV's, as well as loose dogs, just to name a couple issues. Luckily, police officers do respond and try to help but there will be a time when they will be too late to prevent injury. The community officers coming through and putting notices on vehicles is nowhere near the solution needed for this area. The notices are thrown away and the vehicles rarely move. I believe this email string started in 2023 and we have had minimal progress with the actual issues at hand. On Thu, Mar 13, 2025 at 12:19 PM Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction> wrote: City of palo alto!! please let me know how this is Legal for driving also come and clean the street as it’s not safe see attached Maor Greenberg CEO maor@greenberg.construction | 650-610-7711Greenberg.Construction | 650-600-9536 x101 | Fax 925-269-2325 908 Industrial Ave, Palo Alto 94303 From: Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2025 10:56:09 AMTo: Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>Cc: Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>; Marguerite Poyatos <MARGUERITE@paloaltoglass.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org <chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org>; osbaldo@or-builders.com <osbaldo@or-builders.com>; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lester Wong <lwong@wongelectric.com>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr<CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com <Jacob@onemovemovers.com>; david@paloaltoconcrete.com <david@paloaltoconcrete.com>; Steve Wong <swong@wongelectric.com>; RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com <RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com <nancy@drewmaran.com>; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific-equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough <Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>;James Reifschneider <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <vicki.veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council<city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction>Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety What is it going to take for the city of Palo Alto to catch up to the rest of the country? A lawsuit when someone in our neighborhood is injured because of the unsafe conditions that exist here? This email chain alone would be enough evidence to show the city’s knowledge of the problem and inaction. With newly enacted laws giving cities the legal right to clean up our public spaces, local cities like Mountain View, Santa Clara and San Jose have already begun the process of relocating and housing these people that need it. Why not Palo Alto? Its not a money issue here, and even if it was, wouldn’t it be less costly to tow some vehicles and help relocate them to a safer area than to pay the cost of litigation? We are asking the city to stop ignoring this issue before it becomes an even bigger problem. On Mar 12, 2025, at 9:17 AM, Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com> wrote: Hi Ben,Please take action. The safety of our employees and locals is critical. Anyone walking or driving on Industrial/Transport/Commercial is constantly at risk. Every crosswalk and entry is a major risk for anyone walking the sidewalks or pulling into any of these facilities where illegally parked abandoned vehicles are encamped. The visibility is very poor and the reason there are height and length restrictions for these types of streets; There are There are illegally running generators with unsafe live electrical lines oftentimes in the sidewalk or even running across entryways There are collections of volatile liquids like gasoline and oil (environmental issues aside) that pose additional hazards to anyone in the vicinity Please let us know what you need from us to support your team in enforcing our city regulations in order to make our workplaces safer for our employees. Respectfully, Patrick Kelly | CIODMD Systems Recovery, LLC.C: 650.492.9003patrick.kelly@dmdsystems.com | www.dmdsystems.com<Outlook-DMD Logo.png> <Outlook-larpkod1.png> Book time to meet with me From: Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>Sent: Wednesday, February 5, 2025 12:39 PMTo: Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com>Cc: Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org <chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org>; osbaldo@or-builders.com <osbaldo@or-builders.com>; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lester Wong <lwong@wongelectric.com>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr <CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt<pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com <Jacob@onemovemovers.com>; david@paloaltoconcrete.com <david@paloaltoconcrete.com>; Steve Wong <swong@wongelectric.com>; RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com <RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com <nancy@drewmaran.com>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific-equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough<Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <James.Reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <Transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing<Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <Vicki.Veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <Pat.Burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Maor <maor@greenberg.construction>Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial concerns A citation for double parking and expired tags is what is needed here. I’m positive that’s what the police would do to me if I did the same. That is unless there are two separate sets of laws that govsophospsmartbannerendA citation for double parking and expired tags is what is needed here. I’m positive that’s what the police would do to me if I did the same. That is unless there are two separate sets of laws that govern the city of Palo Alto and the state of California. Bill McLane---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc.4085 Transport StreetPalo Alto, CA 94303650-494-7000 Officewww.paloaltoglass.com On Wed, Feb 5, 2025 at 10:13 AM Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: Please see the attached image. The pictured RV & associated white truck pulled up over night. As pictured, they disregarded marked parking spots, which is one of the things that exacerbates our parking issue. A small car or motorcycle may fit there but in a commercial area where most vehicles are trucks, this does not help. Can you please send a community officer to leave notices on the RVs? I hope this doesn't come across as petty, but every spot really does matter on this block. Employees of some businesses have to park in lots that belong to other businesses, which can create tension amongst neighbors. Thank you. On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 9:19 PM Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com> wrote: The police also responded and were very helpful. Initially the people involved denied everything, but when I sent the videos to the officer and he showed it to them they admitted to dumping their RV waste. They were cited for misdemeanor illegal waste dumping and will be going to court. They were then told to leave the area - and freed up two parking spaces. Thank you Palo Alto Police and Fire. Apparently reporting violations of every kind is what is going to have to be done on a regular basis if we want our streets cleaned up. On Dec 21, 2024, at 3:39 PM, Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: Thank you, Dave! Bill McLane---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc.4085 Transport StreetPalo Alto, CA 94303650-494-7000 Officewww.paloaltoglass.com On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 8:22 AM Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com> wrote: I just called the hotline for Palo Alto for hazardous waste dumping and gave them all of this information including license numbers. These vehicles are still parked there.They are sending the fire department out to flush the street and these people better be held accountable. On Dec 21, 2024, at 7:56 AM, Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: License plate of the accomplice<IMG_0142.jpeg> Bill McLane---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc.4085 Transport StreetPalo Alto, CA 94303650-494-7000 Officewww.paloaltoglass.com On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 5:13 AM Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote:Still parked right across from my building. Note, NO rear license plate. I do think that is against the law. I do also have video of them driving up, proof of the vehicle operating on city streets. Do you think they have insurance? <image.png> Bill McLane---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc.4085 Transport StreetPalo Alto, CA 94303650-494-7000 Officewww.paloaltoglass.com On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 4:54 AM Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: Here, they are emptying their waste in front of my building. Bill McLane---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc.4085 Transport StreetPalo Alto, CA 94303650-494-7000 Officewww.paloaltoglass.com On Fri, Dec 20, 2024 at 9:18 PM Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com> wrote: Chantal, It looks like somehow most of the city council members, Vice Mayor and Mayor must have inadvertently been deleted from your last email response. I have added them back in to make sure they stay apprised of the situation. I hope it doesn't take the legal channels mentioned to start cleaning up our neighborhood immediately; this has gotten out of control and kicking the problem back and forth to different members of your city staff is not going to make it go away. Dave StellmanTransport St. On Fri, Dec 20, 2024 at 8:16 AM Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction> wrote:Dear Chantal, Your response, while detailed, fails to address the critical and ongoing violations of law, public safety, and business rights in the area. The City of Palo Alto has both the authority and obligation to take immediate and decisive action to protect its residents, businesses, and public spaces. Allowing illegally parked, unsafe, and hazardous RVs to persist is unacceptable and directly violates state and local regulations. Below are specific legal and factual challenges tothe City’s approach, along with demands for corrective action: 1. Illegally Parked and Unsafe RVs California Vehicle Code § 4000(a)(1) and Palo Alto Municipal Code § 10.48.010 clearly require all vehicles parked on public streets to display valid registration. Many of the RVs in question lack valid registration, making their presence illegal. Further, under California Vehicle Code § 22651(o) and PAMC § 10.48.120, any vehicle unregistered for six months or more may be towed immediately. Additionally, vehicles with exposed sewage tanks, missing wheels, or other structural hazards are in direct violation of California Vehicle Code § 24002, which prohibits parking or operating vehicles in unsafe conditions. These RVs also create a public health hazard under California Health and Safety Code § 117490, which prohibits improper disposal of waste and sewage. **2. Clarification Requested Regarding Unregistered Vehicles In light of your response, please confirm whether the City of Palo Alto allows unregistered vehicles to be driven on its streets. - I have some fun vehicles I would love to order from Alibaba and drive them around Palo Alto... • California Vehicle Code § 4000(a)(1) expressly prohibits the operation of unregistered vehicles. If these RVs are being moved every 72 hours as claimed, and they lack proper registration, their operation is illegal under state law. • Allowing unregistered vehicles to remain or operate within city limits undermines traffic safety and compliance standards. This point must be clarified explicitly: Does the City of Palo Alto condone the operation of unregistered vehicles? 3. Abuse of the 72-Hour Rule The City’s reliance on PAMC § 10.36.060 to justify the continued presence of these RVs is flawed. Surveillance footage and eyewitness accounts confirm that many RVs are circumventing the 72-hour rule by wiping off chalk markings rather than physically moving. This is blatant non-compliance and undermines the intent of the ordinance. Furthermore, California Vehicle Code § 22669 explicitly allows for the removal of vehicles that are “wrecked, dismantled, or inoperative,” even if they are moved every 72 hours. The City has the authority to act, and failing to do so jeopardizes public safety and traffic flow. 4. Public Safety and Sanitation Violations The exposed sewage tanks, illegal dumping, and general neglect by these RV occupants pose significant health and environmental risks. The City’s failure to enforce sanitation laws, such as California Health and Safety Code § 117490 and PAMC § 16.09.100, endangers residents, workers, and the environment. Additionally, blocking roadways and driveways is a clear violation of California Vehicle Code § 22500, which prohibits parking that obstructs trafficflow or access. 5. Impact on Businesses and Traffic Flow Businesses in the area are suffering due to blocked roadways, limited parking for customers, and safety concerns. Under California Vehicle Code § 21101(c) and PAMC § 10.48.120, the City has the authority to regulate parking to ensure the safety of businesses and residents. The City’s failure to allocate parking for business deliveries, customers, or even emergency services is a gross dereliction of duty. Blocking roadways for long periods creates safety hazards, violates municipal code, and disrupts commerce. Conclusion and Final Demands The City of Palo Alto has the legal authority and responsibility to act under the following regulations: • PAMC § 10.48.120: Authorizes the removal of unregistered vehicles. • California Vehicle Code § 22651(o): Allows towing of unregistered vehicles. • California Vehicle Code § 22669: Mandates removal of inoperative vehicles. • California Health and Safety Code § 117490: Prohibits illegal waste disposal. • California Vehicle Code § 21101(c): Permits parking restrictions to ensure safety. We demand the immediate implementation of the following measures: 1. Impound all unregistered, unsafe, or inoperative RVs within two weeks. 2. Establish designated loading zones and 2-hour parking areas near businesses. 3. Conduct regular sanitation inspections and impose penalties for violations. 4. Provide a clear timeline for resolution and enforcement updates. The continued failure to act exposes the City to liability for neglecting public health and safety under California Government Code § 815.6, which requires municipalities to perform mandatory duties. We expect a formal response with a clear action plan within 14 days. If no satisfactory action is taken, we reserve the right to escalate this matter through legal channels to protect our businesses, employees, and the community. <email-signture_87b8d7a2-c4f4-4cbf-b474-af2f32118dd2.png> Maor Greenberg CEO maor@greenberg.construction | 650-610-7711 Greenberg.Construction | 650-600-9536 x101 | Fax 925-269-2325 908 Industrial Ave, Palo Alto 94303 <F_1bc77f31-68bf-4143-80ea-3f34f539ea07.png> <insta_26696304-1b39-4259-9776-9f137454bed9.png> <yelp_e821c57e-caea-4e87-a5dd-5905e7ca4fb1.png> <Houzz_7abe75ad-d6ee-48ac-943b-592713e31957.png> <P_aece63f3-754b-4dca-a0a9-e93b94de4930.png> <google_04352117-2fb4-4963-bb3e-cc5317269360.png> From: Gaines, Chantal <Chantal.Gaines@CityofPaloAlto.org>Date: Friday, December 20, 2024 at 7:12 AMTo: Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction>, Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com>, osbaldo@or-builders.com <osbaldo@or-builders.com>Cc: Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>, Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>, Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>, Becchetti, Benjamin <Benjamin.Becchetti@CityofPaloAlto.org>, Lester Wong <lwong@wongelectric.com>, Cathi Lerch < --Marguerite PoyatosPalo Alto Glass, Inc.4085 Transport StreetPalo Alto CA 94303(650) 494-7000(650) 494-7087 (FAX) From:Bill McLane To:Xenia Czisch Cc:Marguerite Poyatos; Ramon Moreno; Lester Wong; Maor Greenberg; Dave Stellman; Patrick Kelly; Gaines, Chantal; osbaldo@or-builders.com; Manu Kumar; Becchetti, Benjamin; Cathi Lerch; Dave Stellman; City Mgr; Moffatt, Pete; Jacob@onemovemovers.com; david@paloaltoconcrete.com; Steve Wong; nancy@drewmaran.com; Dan McKinley; McDonough, Melissa; Reifschneider, James; Transportation; John Lerch; Binder, Andrew; Jade Jin; City Attorney; Lauing, Ed; Lydia Kou; Veenker, Vicki; Council, City; Burt, Patrick; Stone, Greer; Lythcott-Haims, Julie Subject:Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety Date:Wednesday, July 23, 2025 1:51:29 PM Attachments:image004.pngimage003.pngimage009.pngimage006.pngimage005.pngimage008.pngimage007.png CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. i I didn’t get my tape measure out, but I’d be willing to bet this is more than 18 inches from thecurb. I believe that’s a violation of California parking laws. This message needs your attention This is their first mail to some recipients. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast Xenia Czisch Vice President of Operationsphone: (650) 858-2491mobile: (650) 804-4225 4047 Transport St Palo Alto, CA 94303 www.qualitymetalspinning.us Bill McLane --------------------------------- Palo Alto Glass, Inc. 4085 Transport Street Palo Alto, CA 94303 650-494-7000 Office www.paloaltoglass.com On Wed, Jul 23, 2025 at 1:25 PM Xenia Czisch <xenia@qmsshields.com> wrote: + staceytomson@qmsshields.com fax: (650) 858-2494 From: Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com> Sent: Wednesday, July 23, 2025 1:13 PM To: Ramon Moreno <ramonmorenoschool@gmail.com> Cc: Lester Wong <LWong@wongelectric.com>; Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction>; Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org; osbaldo@or-builders.com; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr <CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com; david@paloaltoconcrete.com; Steve Wong <SWong@wongelectric.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific- equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough <Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <vicki.veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott- Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org> Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety Chantal, Please see the attached images. An enforcement officer went around this morning and gaveout the 72 hour tow notices. I watched the gentleman with the Raiders RV (in attached image) remove all tow noticesfrom his vehicles and will not move them. I will be taking pictures of his vehicles in the nextcoming days to show that he will be in violation of the notices. Also, he has a propane tank(also in attached image) that has been sitting in the street for a few months now. Can that beaddressed? The other picture shows a tow notice sitting in the gutter, which is where many of these end up. Can there be any enforcement for littering? As others are stating, I would also hope something can be done for the safety of pedestrians.As I was walking to my car today, I was almost hit by a car because there is no visibility for cars coming down the street or pedestrians. Thank you. On Mon, Jul 21, 2025 at 12:12 PM Ramon Moreno <ramonmorenoschool@gmail.com>wrote: Dear City of Palo Alto, I am writing to express my deep concern regarding the ongoing issues caused by the RVencampments in Palo Alto, which are directly impacting my business and the safety of mystudents and their families. As the owner of the Ramon Moreno School of Ballet, I am dedicated to maintaining asafe, clean, and welcoming environment for our students and their families. However,recent circumstances are making that increasingly difficult. One of the most pressing issues is illegal dumping. Individuals from the RV encampmentshave been using my business’s garbage disposal for their personal waste, resulting incontamination. Because of this, the city has refused to collect the trash, and I have nowbeen left to clean and dispose of everything myself—at my own expense. If I don’t, I’vebeen informed that I may face additional charges. This is unacceptable and places anunfair financial and operational burden on my business. I understand that I am not alone—many neighboring businesses are facing similar challenges. Additionally, the presence of these encampments has created ongoing safety concerns.Several families have shared their discomfort and hesitation about bringing their childrento class, due to the unpredictable and sometimes unsafe conditions surrounding my studio.This is not just an inconvenience; it poses a direct risk to the well-being of the children,their families, my staff, and the reputation of our school. I would like to know what specific actions the city is taking to address these challenges. While I understand that this is a complex issue, local businesses should not be expected toshoulder the consequences alone. The safety of our community and the ability for small businesses to operate without disruption should be a priority. I urge the City of Palo Alto to present a clear and immediate plan of action that includes: Proper and reliable waste management enforcement Increased monitoring and enforcement of local ordinancesMeasures to ensure public safety for local families and business owners Attached to this email are photos documenting the contamination of my garbage disposal and the resulting conditions. I hope these images convey the seriousness of the situationand the urgent need for intervention. Thank you for your attention to this matter. I look forward to your response and to seeingmeaningful steps taken to support the well-being of our local business community. Sincerely, Ramon Moreno Owner & Director Ramon Moreno School of Ballet Please feel free to text or call: 650-304-1909 Thank you, Ramon Moreno www.ramonmorenoballet.com www.facebook.com/pg/RamonMorenoSchool On Thu, Mar 13, 2025 at 12:43 PM Lester Wong <LWong@wongelectric.com> wrote: Commercial St. was cleared last night. Thank you for your efforts! Lester Wong | Vice President O: 650.813.9999 ext. 22 | C: 650.720.8455 4067 Transport Street | Palo Alto | CA 94303 Celebrating Our 46th Anniversary 1978 – 2024 A Proud Member of the U.S. Green Building Council From: Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com> Sent: Thursday, March 13, 2025 12:37:47 PM To: Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction> Cc: Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org <chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org>; osbaldo@or- builders.com <osbaldo@or-builders.com>; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lester Wong <LWong@wongelectric.com>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr <CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com <Jacob@onemovemovers.com>; david@paloaltoconcrete.com <david@paloaltoconcrete.com>; Steve Wong <SWong@wongelectric.com>; RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com <RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com <nancy@drewmaran.com>; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific-equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough <Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <vicki.veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org> Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety The wooden RV seems to be a severe safety issue. A former coworker spoke to the man living in it a couple years ago and was told there is a wood burning oven/stove insidethe RV, which he uses. Seems like that could be a severe safety hazard not only for the man residing in it, as well as for the surrounding RV's/vehicles & businesses if it wereever to catch fire. We have had to face a number of safety hazards on this street. It is unsafe for pedestrians. We have had attempted break ins at night. We have been harassed bypeople associated with these RV's, as well as loose dogs, just to name a couple issues. Luckily, police officers do respond and try to help but there will be a time when theywill be too late to prevent injury. The community officers coming through and putting notices on vehicles is nowherenear the solution needed for this area. The notices are thrown away and the vehicles rarely move. I believe this email string started in 2023 and we have had minimalprogress with the actual issues at hand. On Thu, Mar 13, 2025 at 12:19 PM Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction>wrote: City of palo alto!! please let me know how this is Legal for driving also come andclean the street as it’s not safe see attached Maor Greenberg CEO maor@greenberg.construction | 650-610-7711 Greenberg.Construction | 650-600-9536 x101 | Fax 925-269-2325 908 Industrial Ave, Palo Alto 94303 From: Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2025 10:56:09 AM To: Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com> Cc: Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>; Marguerite Poyatos <MARGUERITE@paloaltoglass.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org <chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org>; osbaldo@or-builders.com <osbaldo@or- builders.com>; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lester Wong <lwong@wongelectric.com>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr <CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com <Jacob@onemovemovers.com>; david@paloaltoconcrete.com <david@paloaltoconcrete.com>; Steve Wong <swong@wongelectric.com>; RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com <RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com <nancy@drewmaran.com>; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific-equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough <Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <vicki.veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction> Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety What is it going to take for the city of Palo Alto to catch up to the rest of the country?A lawsuit when someone in our neighborhood is injured because of the unsafeconditions that exist here? This email chain alone would be enough evidence to showthe city’s knowledge of the problem and inaction. With newly enacted laws giving cities the legal right to clean up our public spaces,local cities like Mountain View, Santa Clara and San Jose have already begun the process of relocating and housing these people that need it. Why not Palo Alto? Itsnot a money issue here, and even if it was, wouldn’t it be less costly to tow some vehicles and help relocate them to a safer area than to pay the cost of litigation? We are asking the city to stop ignoring this issue before it becomes an even biggerproblem. On Mar 12, 2025, at 9:17 AM, Patrick Kelly<Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com> wrote: Hi Ben, Please take action. The safety of our employees and locals is critical. Anyone walking or drivingon Industrial/Transport/Commercial is constantly at risk. Every crosswalk and entry is a major risk for anyone walking the sidewalks or pulling into any ofthese facilities where illegally parked abandoned vehicles are encamped. The visibility is very poor and the reason there are height and length restrictions for these types of streets; There are There are illegally running generators with unsafe live electrical lines oftentimes in the sidewalk or even running across entryways There are collections of volatile liquids like gasoline and oil (environmental issues aside) that pose additional hazards to anyone in the vicinity Please let us know what you need from us to support your team in enforcingour city regulations in order to make our workplaces safer for our employees. Respectfully, Patrick Kelly | CIO DMD Systems Recovery, LLC. C: 650.492.9003 patrick.kelly@dmdsystems.com | www.dmdsystems.com <Outlook-DMD Logo.png> <Outlook- larpkod1.png> Book time to meet with me From: Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> Sent: Wednesday, February 5, 2025 12:39 PM To: Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com> Cc: Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org <chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org>; osbaldo@or-builders.com <osbaldo@or-builders.com>; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lester Wong <lwong@wongelectric.com>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr <CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com <Jacob@onemovemovers.com>; david@paloaltoconcrete.com <david@paloaltoconcrete.com>; Steve Wong <swong@wongelectric.com>; RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com <RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com <nancy@drewmaran.com>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific-equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough <Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <James.Reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <Transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <Vicki.Veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <Pat.Burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Maor <maor@greenberg.construction> Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial concerns A citation for double parking and expired tags is what is needed here. I’m positive that’s what the police would do to me if I did the same. That is unless there are two separate sets of laws that gov sophospsmartbannerend A citation for double parking and expired tags is what is needed here.I’m positive that’s what the police would do to me if I did the same. That is unless there are two separate sets of laws that govern the city of PaloAlto and the state of California. Bill McLane ---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc. 4085 Transport Street Palo Alto, CA 94303 650-494-7000 Office www.paloaltoglass.com On Wed, Feb 5, 2025 at 10:13 AM Marguerite Poyatos<marguerite@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: Please see the attached image. The pictured RV & associated white truck pulled up over night. Aspictured, they disregarded marked parking spots, which is one of the things that exacerbates our parking issue. A small car or motorcycle may fit there but in a commercial areawhere most vehicles are trucks, this does not help. Can you please send a community officer to leave notices on the RVs? I hope this doesn't come across as petty, but every spot really doesmatter on this block. Employees of some businesses have to park in lots that belong to other businesses, which can create tension amongstneighbors. Thank you. On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 9:19 PM Dave Stellman<davestellman@gmail.com> wrote: The police also responded and were very helpful. Initially thepeople involved denied everything, but when I sent the videos to theofficer and he showed it to them they admitted to dumping their RVwaste. They were cited for misdemeanor illegal waste dumping andwill be going to court. They were then told to leave the area - andfreed up two parking spaces. Thank you Palo Alto Police and Fire.Apparently reporting violations of every kind is what is going tohave to be done on a regular basis if we want our streets cleaned up. On Dec 21, 2024, at 3:39 PM, Bill McLane<bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: Thank you, Dave! Bill McLane --------------------------------- Palo Alto Glass, Inc. 4085 Transport Street Palo Alto, CA 94303 650-494-7000 Office www.paloaltoglass.com On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 8:22 AM Dave Stellman<davestellman@gmail.com> wrote: I just called the hotline for Palo Alto for hazardouswaste dumping and gave them all of this informationincluding license numbers. These vehicles are still parked there.They are sending the fire department outto flush the street and these people better be held accountable. On Dec 21, 2024, at 7:56 AM, BillMcLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>wrote: License plate of the accomplice <IMG_0142.jpeg> Bill McLane --------------------------------- Palo Alto Glass, Inc. 4085 Transport Street Palo Alto, CA 94303 650-494-7000 Office www.paloaltoglass.com On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 5:13 AM BillMcLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>wrote: Still parked right across from my building. Note, NO rear license plate. I do think that is against the law. I do also have video of them driving up, proof of the vehicle operating on city streets. Do you think they have insurance? <image.png> Bill McLane ---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc. 4085 Transport Street Palo Alto, CA 94303 650-494-7000 Office www.paloaltoglass.com On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 4:54 AM BillMcLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: Here, they are emptying their waste in front of my building. Bill McLane ---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc. 4085 Transport Street Palo Alto, CA 94303 650-494-7000 Office www.paloaltoglass.com On Fri, Dec 20, 2024 at 9:18 PMDave Stellman<davestellman@gmail.com> wrote: Chantal, It looks like somehow most of the city council members, ViceMayor and Mayor must have inadvertently been deleted from your last email response. I have added them back in tomake sure they stay apprised of the situation. I hope it doesn't takethe legal channels mentioned to start cleaning up ourneighborhood immediately; this has gotten out of control andkicking the problem back and forth to different members of yourcity staff is not going to make it go away. Dave Stellman Transport St. On Fri, Dec 20, 2024 at 8:16 AMMaor Greenberg<maor@greenberg.construction>wrote: Dear Chantal, Your response, while detailed, fails to address the critical and ongoing violations of law, public safety, and business rights in the area. The City of Palo Alto has both the authority and obligation to take immediate and decisive action to protect its residents, businesses, and public spaces. Allowing illegally parked, unsafe, and hazardous RVs to persist is unacceptable and directly violates state and local regulations. Below are specific legal and factual challenges to the City’s approach, along with demands for corrective action: 1. Illegally Parked and UnsafeRVs California Vehicle Code § 4000(a) (1) and Palo Alto Municipal Code § 10.48.010 clearly require all vehicles parked on public streets to display valid registration. Many of the RVs in question lack valid registration, making their presence illegal. Further, under CaliforniaVehicle Code §22651(o) and PAMC § 10.48.120, any vehicle unregistered for six months or more may be towed immediately. Additionally, vehicles with exposed sewage tanks, missing wheels, or other structural hazards are in direct violation of California Vehicle Code § 24002, which prohibits parking or operating vehicles in unsafe conditions. These RVs also create a public health hazard under California Health and Safety Code § 117490, which prohibits improper disposal of waste and sewage. **2. Clarification RequestedRegarding UnregisteredVehicles In light of your response, pleaseconfirm whether the City of PaloAlto allows unregistered vehiclesto be driven on its streets. - I havesome fun vehicles I would love toorder from Alibaba and drivethem around Palo Alto... • California Vehicle Code § 4000(a)(1) expressly prohibits the operation of unregisteredvehicles. If these RVs are being moved every 72 hours as claimed, and they lack proper registration, their operation is illegal under state law. • Allowing unregistered vehicles to remain or operate within city limits undermines traffic safety and compliance standards. This point must be clarifiedexplicitly: Does the City of Palo Alto condone the operation ofunregistered vehicles? 3. Abuse of the 72-Hour Rule The City’s reliance on PAMC § 10.36.060 to justify the continued presence of these RVs is flawed. Surveillance footage and eyewitness accounts confirm that many RVs are circumventing the 72-hour rule by wiping off chalk markings rather than physically moving. This is blatant non-compliance and undermines the intent of the ordinance. Furthermore, California Vehicle Code § 22669 explicitly allows for the removal of vehicles that are “wrecked, dismantled, or inoperative,” even if they are moved every 72 hours. The City has the authority to act, and failing to do so jeopardizes public safety and traffic flow. 4. Public Safety and SanitationViolations The exposed sewage tanks, illegal dumping, and general neglect by these RV occupants pose significant health and environmental risks. The City’s failure to enforce sanitation laws, such as California Healthand Safety Code § 117490 and PAMC § 16.09.100, endangers residents, workers, and the environment. Additionally, blocking roadways and driveways is a clear violation of CaliforniaVehicle Code § 22500, which prohibits parking that obstructs traffic flow or access. 5. Impact on Businesses andTraffic Flow Businesses in the area are suffering due to blocked roadways, limited parking for customers, and safety concerns. Under California Vehicle Code § 21101(c) and PAMC § 10.48.120, the City has the authority to regulate parking to ensure the safety of businesses and residents. The City’s failure to allocate parking for business deliveries, customers, or even emergency services is a gross dereliction of duty. Blocking roadways for long periods creates safety hazards, violates municipal code, and disrupts commerce. Conclusion and Final Demands The City of Palo Alto has the legal authority and responsibility to act under the following regulations: • PAMC § 10.48.120: Authorizes the removal of unregistered vehicles. • California Vehicle Code § 22651(o): Allows towing of unregistered vehicles. • California Vehicle Code § 22669: Mandates removal of inoperative vehicles. • California Health and Safety Code § 117490: Prohibits illegal waste disposal. • California Vehicle Code §21101(c): Permits parking restrictions to ensure safety. We demand the immediate implementation of the following measures: 1. Impound all unregistered, unsafe, or inoperative RVs within two weeks. 2. Establish designated loading zones and 2-hour parking areas near businesses. 3. Conduct regular sanitation inspections and impose penalties for violations. 4. Provide a clear timeline for resolution and enforcement updates. The continued failure to act exposes the City to liability for neglecting public health and safety under California GovernmentCode § 815.6, which requires municipalities to perform mandatory duties. We expect a formal response with a clear action plan within 14 days. If no satisfactory action is taken, we reserve the right to escalate this matter through legal channels to protect our businesses, employees, and the community. <email- signture_87b8d7a2-c4f4-4cbf-b474- af2f32118dd2.png> Maor Greenberg CEO maor@greenberg.construction |650-610-7711 Greenberg.Construction | 650-600-9536 x101 | Fax 925-269-2325 908 Industrial Ave, Palo Alto94303 <F_1bc77f31-68bf-4143-80ea-3f34f539ea07.png> <insta_26696304-1b39- 4259-9776-9f137454bed9.png> <yelp_e821c57e-caea- 4e87-a5dd-5905e7ca4fb1.png> <Houzz_7abe75ad-d6ee- 48ac-943b-592713e31957.png> <P_aece63f3-754b-4dca- a0a9-e93b94de4930.png> <google_04352117-2fb4-4963-bb3e- cc5317269360.png> From: Gaines, Chantal <Chantal.Gaines@CityofPaloAlto.org>Date: Friday, December 20, 2024 at 7:12 AMTo: Maor Greenberg<maor@greenberg.construction>, Marguerite Poyatos<marguerite@paloaltoglass.com>, osbaldo@or-builders.com<osbaldo@or-builders.com>Cc: Bill McLane<bill@paloaltoglass.com>,Dave Stellman<davestellman@gmail.com>,Manu Kumar<manu@k9ventures.com>,Becchetti, Benjamin<Benjamin.Becchetti@CityofPaloAlto.org>, Lester Wong<lwong@wongelectric.com>,Cathi Lerch < -- Marguerite Poyatos Palo Alto Glass, Inc. 4085 Transport Street Palo Alto CA 94303 (650) 494-7000 (650) 494-7087 (FAX) Xenia CzischVice President ofOperations phone: (650) 858-2491mobile: (650) 804-4225fax: (650) 858-2494 4047 Transport StPalo Alto, CA 94303 www.qualitymetalspinning.us From:Xenia Czisch To:"Marguerite Poyatos"; "Ramon Moreno" Cc:"Lester Wong"; "Maor Greenberg"; "Dave Stellman"; "Patrick Kelly"; "Bill McLane"; Gaines, Chantal; osbaldo@or-builders.com; "Manu Kumar"; Becchetti, Benjamin; "Cathi Lerch"; "Dave Stellman";City Mgr; Moffatt, Pete; Jacob@onemovemovers.com; david@paloaltoconcrete.com; "Steve Wong"; nancy@drewmaran.com; "Dan McKinley"; McDonough, Melissa; Reifschneider, James;Transportation; "John Lerch"; Binder, Andrew; "Jade Jin"; City Attorney; Lauing, Ed; "Lydia Kou"; Veenker, Vicki; Council, City; Burt, Patrick; Stone, Greer; Lythcott-Haims, Julie Subject:RE: Industrial/Transport/Commercial SafetyDate:Wednesday, July 23, 2025 1:25:47 PM Attachments:image003.pngimage004.pngimage005.pngimage006.pngimage007.pngimage008.pngimage009.png CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. i + staceytomson@qmsshields.com From: Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com> Sent: Wednesday, July 23, 2025 1:13 PM To: Ramon Moreno <ramonmorenoschool@gmail.com> Cc: Lester Wong <LWong@wongelectric.com>; Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction>; Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org; osbaldo@or-builders.com; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr <CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com; david@paloaltoconcrete.com; Steve Wong <SWong@wongelectric.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific-equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough <Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <vicki.veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org> Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety Chantal, Please see the attached images. An enforcement officer went around this morning and gave out the 72 hour tow notices. I watched the gentleman with the Raiders RV (in attached image) remove all tow notices from his vehicles and will not move them. I will be taking pictures of his vehicles in the next coming days to show that he will be in violation of the notices. Also, he has a propane tank (also in attached image) that has been sitting in the street for a few months now. Can that be addressed? The other picture shows a tow notice sitting in the gutter, which is where many of these end up. Can there be any enforcement for littering? As others are stating, I would also hope something can be done for the safety of pedestrians. As I was walking to my car today, I was almost hit by a car because there is no visibility for cars coming down the street or pedestrians. Thank you. On Mon, Jul 21, 2025 at 12:12 PM Ramon Moreno <ramonmorenoschool@gmail.com> wrote: Dear City of Palo Alto, I am writing to express my deep concern regarding the ongoing issues caused by the RV encampments in Palo Alto, which are directly impacting mybusiness and the safety of my students and their families. As the owner of the Ramon Moreno School of Ballet, I am dedicated to maintaining a safe, clean, and welcoming environment for our students and This message needs your attentionThis is their first mail to some recipients. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast their families. However, recent circumstances are making that increasingly difficult. One of the most pressing issues is illegal dumping. Individuals from the RV encampments have been using my business’s garbage disposal for theirpersonal waste, resulting in contamination. Because of this, the city has refused to collect the trash, and I have now been left to clean and dispose ofeverything myself—at my own expense. If I don’t, I’ve been informed that I may face additional charges. This is unacceptable and places an unfairfinancial and operational burden on my business. I understand that I am not alone—many neighboring businesses are facing similar challenges. Additionally, the presence of these encampments has created ongoing safety concerns. Several families have shared their discomfort and hesitationabout bringing their children to class, due to the unpredictable and sometimes unsafe conditions surrounding my studio. This is not just aninconvenience; it poses a direct risk to the well-being of the children, their families, my staff, and the reputation of our school. I would like to know what specific actions the city is taking to address these challenges. While I understand that this is a complex issue, localbusinesses should not be expected to shoulder the consequences alone. The safety of our community and the ability for small businesses to operatewithout disruption should be a priority. I urge the City of Palo Alto to present a clear and immediate plan of action that includes: Proper and reliable waste management enforcementIncreased monitoring and enforcement of local ordinancesMeasures to ensure public safety for local families and business owners Attached to this email are photos documenting the contamination of my garbage disposal and the resulting conditions. I hope these images convey theseriousness of the situation and the urgent need for intervention. Thank you for your attention to this matter. I look forward to your response and to seeing meaningful steps taken to support the well-being of our localbusiness community. Sincerely, Ramon Moreno Owner & Director Ramon Moreno School of Ballet Please feel free to text or call: 650-304-1909 Thank you, Ramon Moreno www.ramonmorenoballet.com www.facebook.com/pg/RamonMorenoSchool On Thu, Mar 13, 2025 at 12:43 PM Lester Wong <LWong@wongelectric.com> wrote: Commercial St. was cleared last night. Thank you for your efforts! Lester Wong | Vice President O: 650.813.9999 ext. 22 | C: 650.720.8455 4067 Transport Street | Palo Alto | CA 94303 Celebrating Our 46th Anniversary 1978 – 2024 A Proud Member of the U.S. Green Building Council From: Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com> Sent: Thursday, March 13, 2025 12:37:47 PM To: Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction> Cc: Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org <chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org>; osbaldo@or-builders.com <osbaldo@or-builders.com>; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lester Wong <LWong@wongelectric.com>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr <CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com <Jacob@onemovemovers.com>; david@paloaltoconcrete.com <david@paloaltoconcrete.com>; Steve Wong <SWong@wongelectric.com>; RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com <RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com <nancy@drewmaran.com>; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific-equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough <Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <vicki.veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org> Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety The wooden RV seems to be a severe safety issue. A former coworker spoke to the man living in it a couple years ago and was told there is a wood burning oven/stove inside the RV, which he uses. Seems like that could be a severe safety hazard not only for the man residing in it, as well as for the surrounding RV's/vehicles & businesses if it were ever to catch fire. We have had to face a number of safety hazards on this street. It is unsafe for pedestrians. We have had attempted break ins at night. We have been harassed by people associated with these RV's, as well as loose dogs, just to name a couple issues. Luckily, police officers do respond and try to help but there will be a time when they will be too late to prevent injury. The community officers coming through and putting notices on vehicles is nowhere near the solution needed for this area. The notices are thrown away and the vehicles rarely move. I believe this email string started in 2023 and we have had minimal progress with the actual issues at hand. On Thu, Mar 13, 2025 at 12:19 PM Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction> wrote: City of palo alto!! please let me know how this is Legal for driving also come and clean the street as it’s not safe see attached Maor Greenberg CEO maor@greenberg.construction | 650-610-7711 Greenberg.Construction | 650-600-9536 x101 | Fax925-269-2325 908 Industrial Ave, Palo Alto 94303 From: Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2025 10:56:09 AM To: Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com> Cc: Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>; Marguerite Poyatos <MARGUERITE@paloaltoglass.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org <chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org>; osbaldo@or-builders.com <osbaldo@or-builders.com>; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lester Wong <lwong@wongelectric.com>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr <CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com <Jacob@onemovemovers.com>; david@paloaltoconcrete.com <david@paloaltoconcrete.com>; Steve Wong <swong@wongelectric.com>; RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com <RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com <nancy@drewmaran.com>; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific-equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough <Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <vicki.veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction> Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety What is it going to take for the city of Palo Alto to catch up to the rest of the country? A lawsuit when someone in our neighborhood is injured because of the unsafe conditions that exist here? This email chain alone would be enough evidence to show the city’s knowledge of the problem and inaction. With newly enacted laws giving cities the legal right to clean up our public spaces, local cities like Mountain View, Santa Clara and San Jose have already begun the process of relocating and housing these people that need it. Why not Palo Alto? Its not a money issue here, and even if it was, wouldn’t it be less costly to tow some vehicles and help relocate them to a safer area than to pay the cost of litigation? We are asking the city to stop ignoring this issue before it becomes an even bigger problem. On Mar 12, 2025, at 9:17 AM, Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com> wrote: Hi Ben, Please take action. The safety of our employees and locals is critical. Anyone walking or driving on Industrial/Transport/Commercial is constantly at risk. Every crosswalk and entry is a major risk for anyone walking the sidewalks or pulling into any of these facilities where illegally parked abandoned vehicles are encamped. The visibility is very poor and the reason there are height and length restrictions for these types of streets; There are There are illegally running generators with unsafe live electrical lines oftentimes in the sidewalk or even running across entryways There are collections of volatile liquids like gasoline and oil (environmental issues aside) that pose additional hazards to anyone in the vicinity Please let us know what you need from us to support your team in enforcing our city regulations in order to make our workplaces safer for our employees. Respectfully, Patrick Kelly | CIODMD Systems Recovery, LLC. C: 650.492.9003patrick.kelly@dmdsystems.com | www.dmdsystems.com <Outlook-DMD Logo.png> <Outlook- larpkod1.png> Book time to meet with me From: Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> Sent: Wednesday, February 5, 2025 12:39 PM To: Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com> Cc: Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org <chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org>; osbaldo@or- builders.com <osbaldo@or-builders.com>; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lester Wong <lwong@wongelectric.com>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr <CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com <Jacob@onemovemovers.com>; david@paloaltoconcrete.com <david@paloaltoconcrete.com>; Steve Wong <swong@wongelectric.com>; RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com <RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com <nancy@drewmaran.com>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific-equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough <Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <James.Reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <Transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <Vicki.Veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <Pat.Burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Maor <maor@greenberg.construction> Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial concerns A citation for double parking and expired tags is what is needed here. I’m positive that’s what the police would do to me if I did the same. That is unless there are two separate sets of laws that govsophospsmartbannerendA citation for double parking and expired tags is what is needed here. I’m positive that’s what the police would do to me if I did the same. That is unless there are two separate sets of laws that govern the city of Palo Alto and the state of California. Bill McLane ---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc. 4085 Transport Street Palo Alto, CA 94303 650-494-7000 Office www.paloaltoglass.com On Wed, Feb 5, 2025 at 10:13 AM Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: Please see the attached image. The pictured RV & associated white truck pulled up over night. As pictured, they disregarded marked parking spots, which is one of the things that exacerbates our parking issue. A small car or motorcycle may fit there but in a commercial area where most vehicles are trucks, this does not help. Can you please send a community officer to leave notices on the RVs? I hope this doesn't come across as petty, but every spot really does matter on this block. Employees of some businesses have to park in lots that belong to other businesses, which can create tension amongst neighbors. Thank you. On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 9:19 PM Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com> wrote: The police also responded and were very helpful. Initially the people involved denied everything, but when I sent the videos to the officer and he showed it to them they admitted to dumping their RV waste. They were cited for misdemeanor illegal waste dumping and will be going to court. They were then told to leave the area - and freed up two parking spaces. Thank you Palo Alto Police and Fire. Apparently reporting violations of every kind is what is going to have to be done on a regular basis if we want our streets cleaned up. On Dec 21, 2024, at 3:39 PM, Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: Thank you, Dave! Bill McLane ---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc. 4085 Transport Street Palo Alto, CA 94303 650-494-7000 Office www.paloaltoglass.com On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 8:22 AM Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com> wrote: I just called the hotline for Palo Alto for hazardous waste dumping and gave them all of this information including license numbers. These vehicles are still parked there.They are sending the fire department out to flush the street and these people better be held accountable. On Dec 21, 2024, at 7:56 AM, Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: License plate of the accomplice <IMG_0142.jpeg> Bill McLane ---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc.4085 Transport StreetPalo Alto, CA 94303650-494-7000 Officewww.paloaltoglass.com On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 5:13 AM Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: Still parked right across from my building. Note, NO rear license plate. I do think that is against the law. I do also have video of them driving up, proof of the vehicle operating on city streets. Do you think they have insurance? <image.png> Bill McLane ---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc.4085 Transport StreetPalo Alto, CA 94303650-494-7000 Office www.paloaltoglass.com On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 4:54 AM Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: Here, they are emptying their waste in front of my building. Bill McLane ---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc.4085 Transport StreetPalo Alto, CA 94303650-494-7000 Officewww.paloaltoglass.com On Fri, Dec 20, 2024 at 9:18 PM Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com> wrote: Chantal, It looks like somehow most of the city council members, Vice Mayor and Mayor must have inadvertently been deleted from your last email response. I have added them back in to make sure they stay apprised of the situation. I hope it doesn't take the legal channels mentioned to start cleaning up our neighborhood immediately; this has gotten out of control and kicking the problem back and forth to different members of your city staff is not going to make it go away. Dave Stellman Transport St. On Fri, Dec 20, 2024 at 8:16 AM Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction> wrote: Dear Chantal, Your response, while detailed, fails to address the critical and ongoing violations of law, public safety, and business rights in the area. The City of Palo Alto has both the authority and obligation to take immediateand decisive action to protect its residents, businesses, and public spaces. Allowing illegally parked,unsafe, and hazardous RVs to persist is unacceptable and directly violates state and local regulations.Below are specific legal and factual challenges to the City’s approach, along with demands for correctiveaction: 1. Illegally Parked and Unsafe RVs California Vehicle Code § 4000(a)(1) and Palo Alto Municipal Code § 10.48.010 clearly require allvehicles parked on public streets to display valid registration. Many of the RVs in question lack validregistration, making their presence illegal. Further, under California Vehicle Code §22651(o) and PAMC § 10.48.120, any vehicle unregistered for six months or more may be towedimmediately. Additionally, vehicles with exposed sewage tanks, missing wheels, or other structural hazards are in directviolation of California Vehicle Code § 24002, which prohibits parking or operating vehicles in unsafe conditions. These RVs also create a public health hazard under California Health and Safety Code §117490, which prohibits improper disposal of waste and sewage. **2. Clarification Requested Regarding Unregistered Vehicles In light of your response, please confirm whether the City of Palo Alto allows unregistered vehicles tobe driven on its streets. - I have some fun vehicles I would love to order from Alibaba and drivethem around Palo Alto... • California Vehicle Code § 4000(a)(1) expressly prohibits the operation of unregistered vehicles. Ifthese RVs are being moved every 72 hours as claimed, and they lack proper registration, their operationis illegal under state law. • Allowing unregistered vehicles to remain or operate within city limits undermines traffic safety andcompliance standards. This point must be clarified explicitly: Does the City of Palo Alto condone the operation ofunregistered vehicles? 3. Abuse of the 72-Hour Rule The City’s reliance on PAMC § 10.36.060 to justify the continued presence of these RVs is flawed.Surveillance footage and eyewitness accounts confirm that many RVs are circumventing the 72-hour ruleby wiping off chalk markings rather than physically moving. This is blatant non-compliance andundermines the intent of the ordinance. Furthermore, California Vehicle Code § 22669 explicitly allows for the removal of vehicles that are“wrecked, dismantled, or inoperative,” even if they are moved every 72 hours. The City has the authorityto act, and failing to do so jeopardizes public safety and traffic flow. 4. Public Safety and Sanitation Violations The exposed sewage tanks, illegal dumping, and general neglect by these RV occupants pose significanthealth and environmental risks. The City’s failure to enforce sanitation laws, such as California Healthand Safety Code § 117490 and PAMC § 16.09.100, endangers residents, workers, and the environment.Additionally, blocking roadways and driveways is a clear violation of California Vehicle Code § 22500,which prohibits parking that obstructs traffic flow or access. 5. Impact on Businesses and Traffic Flow Businesses in the area are suffering due to blocked roadways, limited parking for customers, and safetyconcerns. Under California Vehicle Code § 21101(c) and PAMC § 10.48.120, the City has the authorityto regulate parking to ensure the safety of businesses and residents. The City’s failure to allocate parking for business deliveries, customers, or even emergency services is agross dereliction of duty. Blocking roadways for long periods creates safety hazards, violates municipal code, and disrupts commerce. Conclusion and Final Demands The City of Palo Alto has the legal authority and responsibility to act under the following regulations: • PAMC § 10.48.120: Authorizes the removal of unregistered vehicles. • California Vehicle Code § 22651(o): Allows towing of unregistered vehicles. • California Vehicle Code § 22669: Mandates removal of inoperative vehicles. • California Health and Safety Code § 117490: Prohibits illegal waste disposal. • California Vehicle Code § 21101(c): Permits parking restrictions to ensure safety. We demand the immediate implementation of the following measures: 1. Impound all unregistered, unsafe, or inoperative RVs within two weeks. 2. Establish designated loading zones and 2-hour parking areas near businesses. 3. Conduct regular sanitation inspections and impose penalties for violations. 4. Provide a clear timeline for resolution and enforcement updates. The continued failure to act exposes the City to liability for neglecting public health and safetyunder California Government Code § 815.6, which requires municipalities to perform mandatory duties.We expect a formal response with a clear action plan within 14 days. If no satisfactory action is taken, wereserve the right to escalate this matter through legal channels to protect our businesses, employees, andthe community. Maor Greenberg CEO maor@greenberg.construction | 650-610-7711 Greenberg.Construction | 650-600-9536 x101 |Fax 925-269-2325 908 Industrial Ave, Palo Alto 94303 <F_1bc77f31-68bf-4143-80ea- 3f34f539ea07.png> <email-signture_87b8d7a2-c4f4-4cbf- b474-af2f32118dd2.png> <insta_26696304-1b39-4259-9776- 9f137454bed9.png> <yelp_e821c57e-caea-4e87-a5dd- 5905e7ca4fb1.png> <Houzz_7abe75ad-d6ee-48ac-943b- 592713e31957.png> <P_aece63f3-754b-4dca-a0a9- e93b94de4930.png> <google_04352117-2fb4-4963-bb3e- cc5317269360.png> From: Gaines, Chantal <Chantal.Gaines@CityofPaloAlto.org> Date: Friday, December 20, 2024 at 7:12 AM To: Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction>, Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com>, osbaldo@or-builders.com <osbaldo@or- builders.com> Cc: Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>, Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>, Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>, Becchetti, Benjamin <Benjamin.Becchetti@CityofPaloAlto.org>, Lester Wong <lwong@wongelectric.com>, Cathi Lerch < -- Marguerite Poyatos Palo Alto Glass, Inc. 4085 Transport Street Palo Alto CA 94303 (650) 494-7000 (650) 494-7087 (FAX) From:Marguerite Poyatos To:Ramon Moreno Cc:Lester Wong; Maor Greenberg; Dave Stellman; Patrick Kelly; Bill McLane; Gaines, Chantal; osbaldo@or- builders.com; Manu Kumar; Becchetti, Benjamin; Cathi Lerch; Dave Stellman; City Mgr; Moffatt, Pete; Jacob@onemovemovers.com; david@paloaltoconcrete.com; Steve Wong; nancy@drewmaran.com; Dan McKinley; McDonough, Melissa; Reifschneider, James; Transportation; John Lerch; Binder, Andrew; Jade Jin; Xenia Czisch; City Attorney; Lauing, Ed; Lydia Kou; Veenker, Vicki; Council, City; Burt, Patrick; Stone, Greer; Lythcott-Haims, Julie Subject:Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety Date:Wednesday, July 23, 2025 1:15:17 PM Attachments:google_04352117-2fb4-4963-bb3e-cc5317269360.pngyelp_e821c57e-caea-4e87-a5dd-5905e7ca4fb1.pngP_aece63f3-754b-4dca-a0a9-e93b94de4930.pngHouzz_7abe75ad-d6ee-48ac-943b-592713e31957.pnginsta_26696304-1b39-4259-9776-9f137454bed9.pngemail-signture_87b8d7a2-c4f4-4cbf-b474-af2f32118dd2.pngF_1bc77f31-68bf-4143-80ea-3f34f539ea07.png CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. Chantal, Please see the attached images. An enforcement officer went around this morning and gave out the 72 hour tow notices. I watched the gentleman with the Raiders RV (in attached image) remove all tow notices fromhis vehicles and will not move them. I will be taking pictures of his vehicles in the next coming days to show that he will be in violation of the notices. Also, he has a propane tank(also in attached image) that has been sitting in the street for a few months now. Can that be addressed? The other picture shows a tow notice sitting in the gutter, which is where many of these endup. Can there be any enforcement for littering? As others are stating, I would also hope something can be done for the safety of pedestrians. As I was walking to my car today, I was almost hit by a car because there is no visibility forcars coming down the street or pedestrians. Thank you. On Mon, Jul 21, 2025 at 12:12 PM Ramon Moreno <ramonmorenoschool@gmail.com> wrote: Dear City of Palo Alto, I am writing to express my deep concern regarding the ongoing issues caused by the RV encampments in Palo Alto, which are directly impacting my business and the safety of mystudents and their families. As the owner of the Ramon Moreno School of Ballet, I am dedicated to maintaining a safe, clean, and welcoming environment for our students and their families. However, recentcircumstances are making that increasingly difficult. One of the most pressing issues is illegal dumping. Individuals from the RV encampments have been using my business’s garbage disposal for their personal waste, resulting incontamination. Because of this, the city has refused to collect the trash, and I have now been left to clean and dispose of everything myself—at my own expense. If I don’t, I’ve beeninformed that I may face additional charges. This is unacceptable and places an unfair financial and operational burden on my business. I understand that I am not alone—manyneighboring businesses are facing similar challenges. Additionally, the presence of these encampments has created ongoing safety concerns. Several families have shared their discomfort and hesitation about bringing their children toclass, due to the unpredictable and sometimes unsafe conditions surrounding my studio. This is not just an inconvenience; it poses a direct risk to the well-being of the children, theirfamilies, my staff, and the reputation of our school. I would like to know what specific actions the city is taking to address these challenges. While I understand that this is a complex issue, local businesses should not be expected toshoulder the consequences alone. The safety of our community and the ability for small businesses to operate without disruption should be a priority. I urge the City of Palo Alto to present a clear and immediate plan of action that includes: Proper and reliable waste management enforcement Increased monitoring and enforcement of local ordinances Measures to ensure public safety for local families and business owners Attached to this email are photos documenting the contamination of my garbage disposal and the resulting conditions. I hope these images convey the seriousness of the situation andthe urgent need for intervention. Thank you for your attention to this matter. I look forward to your response and to seeingmeaningful steps taken to support the well-being of our local business community. Sincerely, Ramon Moreno Owner & Director Ramon Moreno School of Ballet Please feel free to text or call: 650-304-1909 Thank you, Ramon Moreno www.ramonmorenoballet.comwww.facebook.com/pg/RamonMorenoSchool On Thu, Mar 13, 2025 at 12:43 PM Lester Wong <LWong@wongelectric.com> wrote:Commercial St. was cleared last night. Thank you for your efforts! Lester Wong | Vice President O: 650.813.9999 ext. 22 | C: 650.720.8455 4067 Transport Street | Palo Alto | CA 94303 Celebrating Our 46th Anniversary 1978 – 2024 A Proud Member of the U.S. Green Building Council From: Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com> Sent: Thursday, March 13, 2025 12:37:47 PM To: Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction> Cc: Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org <chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org>; osbaldo@or-builders.com <osbaldo@or-builders.com>; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lester Wong <LWong@wongelectric.com>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr <CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com <Jacob@onemovemovers.com>; david@paloaltoconcrete.com <david@paloaltoconcrete.com>; Steve Wong <SWong@wongelectric.com>; RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com <RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com <nancy@drewmaran.com>; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific- equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough <Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <vicki.veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott- Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org> Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety The wooden RV seems to be a severe safety issue. A former coworker spoke to the man living in it a couple years ago and was told there is a wood burning oven/stove inside theRV, which he uses. Seems like that could be a severe safety hazard not only for the man residing in it, as well as for the surrounding RV's/vehicles & businesses if it were ever tocatch fire. We have had to face a number of safety hazards on this street. It is unsafe for pedestrians. We have had attempted break ins at night. We have been harassed by people associatedwith these RV's, as well as loose dogs, just to name a couple issues. Luckily, police officers do respond and try to help but there will be a time when they will be too late toprevent injury. The community officers coming through and putting notices on vehicles is nowhere nearthe solution needed for this area. The notices are thrown away and the vehicles rarely move. I believe this email string started in 2023 and we have had minimal progress withthe actual issues at hand. On Thu, Mar 13, 2025 at 12:19 PM Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction>wrote: City of palo alto!! please let me know how this is Legal for driving also come and cleanthe street as it’s not safe see attached Maor Greenberg CEO maor@greenberg.construction | 650-610-7711 Greenberg.Construction | 650-600-9536 x101 | Fax 925-269-2325908 Industrial Ave, Palo Alto 94303 From: Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2025 10:56:09 AM To: Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com> Cc: Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>; Marguerite Poyatos <MARGUERITE@paloaltoglass.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org <chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org>; osbaldo@or-builders.com <osbaldo@or-builders.com>; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lester Wong <lwong@wongelectric.com>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr <CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com <Jacob@onemovemovers.com>; david@paloaltoconcrete.com <david@paloaltoconcrete.com>; Steve Wong <swong@wongelectric.com>; RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com <RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com <nancy@drewmaran.com>; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific- equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough <Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <vicki.veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction> Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety What is it going to take for the city of Palo Alto to catch up to the rest of the country? Alawsuit when someone in our neighborhood is injured because of the unsafe conditionsthat exist here? This email chain alone would be enough evidence to show the city’sknowledge of the problem and inaction. With newly enacted laws giving cities the legal right to clean up our public spaces, localcities like Mountain View, Santa Clara and San Jose have already begun the process ofrelocating and housing these people that need it. Why not Palo Alto? Its not a moneyissue here, and even if it was, wouldn’t it be less costly to tow some vehicles and helprelocate them to a safer area than to pay the cost of litigation? We are asking the city to stop ignoring this issue before it becomes an even biggerproblem. On Mar 12, 2025, at 9:17 AM, Patrick Kelly<Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com> wrote: Hi Ben, Please take action. The safety of our employees and locals is critical. Anyone walking or driving on Industrial/Transport/Commercial is constantly at risk. Every crosswalk and entry is a major risk for anyone walking the sidewalks or pulling into any of these facilities where illegally parked abandoned vehicles are encamped. The visibility is very poor and the reason there are height and length restrictions for these types of streets; There are There are illegally running generators with unsafe live electrical lines oftentimes in the sidewalk or even running across entryways There are collections of volatile liquids like gasoline and oil (environmental issues aside) that pose additional hazards to anyone in the vicinity Please let us know what you need from us to support your team in enforcing our city regulations in order to make our workplaces safer for our employees. Respectfully, Patrick Kelly | CIODMD Systems Recovery, LLC. C: 650.492.9003 patrick.kelly@dmdsystems.com | www.dmdsystems.com<Outlook-DMD Logo.png> <Outlook-larpkod1.png>Book time to meet with me From: Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> Sent: Wednesday, February 5, 2025 12:39 PM To: Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com> Cc: Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org <chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org>; osbaldo@or-builders.com <osbaldo@or-builders.com>; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lester Wong <lwong@wongelectric.com>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr <CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com <Jacob@onemovemovers.com>; david@paloaltoconcrete.com <david@paloaltoconcrete.com>; Steve Wong <swong@wongelectric.com>; RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com <RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com <nancy@drewmaran.com>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific- equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough <Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <James.Reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <Transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <Vicki.Veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <Pat.Burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Maor <maor@greenberg.construction> Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial concerns A citation for double parking and expired tags is what is needed here. I’mpositive that’s what the police would do to me if I did the same. That is unless there are two separate sets of laws that govern the city of Palo Altoand the state of California. Bill McLane ---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc. 4085 Transport Street Palo Alto, CA 94303 650-494-7000 Office www.paloaltoglass.com On Wed, Feb 5, 2025 at 10:13 AM Marguerite Poyatos<marguerite@paloaltoglass.com> wrote:Please see the attached image. The pictured RV & associated white truck pulled up over night. Aspictured, they disregarded marked parking spots, which is one of thethings that exacerbates our parking issue. A small car or motorcycle may fit there but in a commercial area wheremost vehicles are trucks, this does not help. Can you please send a community officer to leave notices on the RVs? Ihope this doesn't come across as petty, but every spot really does matteron this block. Employees of some businesses have to park in lots thatbelong to other businesses, which can create tension amongst neighbors. Thank you. On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 9:19 PM Dave Stellman<davestellman@gmail.com> wrote:The police also responded and were very helpful. Initially the peopleinvolved denied everything, but when I sent the videos to the officerand he showed it to them they admitted to dumping their RV waste. They were cited for misdemeanor illegal waste dumping and will begoing to court. They were then told to leave the area - and freed up twoparking spaces. Thank you Palo Alto Police and Fire. Apparentlyreporting violations of every kind is what is going to have to be done ona regular basis if we want our streets cleaned up. On Dec 21, 2024, at 3:39 PM, Bill McLane<bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: Thank you, Dave! Bill McLane --------------------------------- Palo Alto Glass, Inc. 4085 Transport Street Palo Alto, CA 94303 650-494-7000 Office www.paloaltoglass.com On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 8:22 AM Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com> wrote:I just called the hotline for Palo Alto for hazardous waste dumping and gave them all of this information includinglicense numbers. These vehicles are still parked there.They are sending the fire department out to flushthe street and these people better be held accountable. On Dec 21, 2024, at 7:56 AM, Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: License plate of the accomplice <IMG_0142.jpeg> Bill McLane ---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc. 4085 Transport Street Palo Alto, CA 94303 650-494-7000 Office www.paloaltoglass.com On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 5:13 AM BillMcLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: Still parked right across from my building. Note, NO rear license plate. I do think that is against the law. I do also have video of them driving up, proof of the vehicle operating on city streets. Do you think they have insurance? <image.png> Bill McLane --------------------------------- Palo Alto Glass, Inc. 4085 Transport Street Palo Alto, CA 94303 650-494-7000 Office www.paloaltoglass.com On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 4:54 AM Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: Here, they are emptying their waste in front of my building. Bill McLane --------------------------------- Palo Alto Glass, Inc. 4085 Transport Street Palo Alto, CA 94303 650-494-7000 Office www.paloaltoglass.com On Fri, Dec 20, 2024 at 9:18 PM DaveStellman <davestellman@gmail.com>wrote:Chantal, It looks like somehow most of the citycouncil members, Vice Mayor andMayor must have inadvertently beendeleted from your last email response. I have added them back in to makesure they stay apprised of the situation.I hope it doesn't take the legalchannels mentioned to start cleaningup our neighborhood immediately; thishas gotten out of control and kickingthe problem back and forth to differentmembers of your city staff is not goingto make it go away. Dave StellmanTransport St. On Fri, Dec 20, 2024 at 8:16 AMMaor Greenberg<maor@greenberg.construction>wrote: Dear Chantal, Your response, while detailed, fails to address the critical and ongoing violations of law, public safety, and business rights in the area. The City of Palo Alto has both the authority and obligation to take immediate and decisive action to protect its residents, businesses, and public spaces. Allowing illegally parked, unsafe, and hazardous RVs to persist is unacceptable and directly violates state and local regulations. Below are specific legal and factual challenges to the City’s approach, along with demands for corrective action: 1. Illegally Parked and Unsafe RVs California Vehicle Code § 4000(a)(1) and Palo Alto Municipal Code § 10.48.010 clearly require all vehicles parked on public streets to display valid registration. Many of the RVs in question lack valid registration, making their presence illegal. Further, under California Vehicle Code § 22651(o) and PAMC § 10.48.120, any vehicle unregistered for six months or more may be towed immediately. Additionally, vehicles with exposed sewage tanks, missing wheels, or other structural hazards are in direct violation of California Vehicle Code § 24002, which prohibits parking or operating vehicles in unsafe conditions. These RVs also create a public health hazard under California Health and Safety Code § 117490, which prohibits improper disposal of waste and sewage. **2. Clarification RequestedRegarding Unregistered Vehicles In light of your response, please confirmwhether the City of Palo Alto allowsunregistered vehicles to be driven on itsstreets. - I have some fun vehicles Iwould love to order from Alibaba anddrive them around Palo Alto... • California Vehicle Code § 4000(a) (1) expressly prohibits the operation of unregistered vehicles. If these RVs are being moved every 72 hours as claimed, and they lack proper registration, their operation is illegal under state law. • Allowing unregistered vehicles to remain or operate within city limits undermines traffic safety and compliance standards. This point must be clarified explicitly:Does the City of Palo Alto condone theoperation of unregistered vehicles? 3. Abuse of the 72-Hour Rule The City’s reliance on PAMC § 10.36.060 to justify the continued presence of these RVs is flawed. Surveillance footage and eyewitness accounts confirm that many RVs are circumventing the 72-hour rule by wiping off chalk markings rather than physically moving. This is blatant non-compliance and undermines the intent of the ordinance. Furthermore, California Vehicle Code §22669 explicitly allows for the removal of vehicles that are “wrecked, dismantled, or inoperative,” even if they are moved every 72 hours. The City has the authority to act, and failing to do so jeopardizes public safety and traffic flow. 4. Public Safety and SanitationViolations The exposed sewage tanks, illegal dumping, and general neglect by these RV occupants pose significant health and environmental risks. The City’s failure to enforce sanitation laws, such as California Health and Safety Code § 117490 and PAMC § 16.09.100, endangers residents, workers, and the environment. Additionally, blocking roadways and driveways is a clear violation of California Vehicle Code § 22500, which prohibits parking that obstructs traffic flow or access. 5. Impact on Businesses and TrafficFlow Businesses in the area are suffering due to blocked roadways, limited parking for customers, and safety concerns. Under California Vehicle Code § 21101(c) and PAMC § 10.48.120, the City has the authority to regulate parking to ensure the safety of businesses and residents. The City’s failure to allocate parking for business deliveries, customers, or even emergency services is a gross dereliction of duty. Blocking roadways for long periods creates safety hazards, violates municipal code, and disrupts commerce. Conclusion and Final Demands The City of Palo Alto has the legal authority and responsibility to act under the following regulations: • PAMC § 10.48.120: Authorizes the removal of unregistered vehicles. • California Vehicle Code § 22651(o): Allows towing of unregistered vehicles. • California Vehicle Code § 22669: Mandates removal of inoperative vehicles. • California Health and Safety Code § 117490: Prohibits illegal waste disposal. • California Vehicle Code § 21101(c): Permits parking restrictions to ensure safety. We demand the immediate implementation of the following measures: 1. Impound all unregistered, unsafe, or inoperative RVs within two weeks. 2. Establish designated loading zones and 2-hour parking areas near businesses. 3. Conduct regular sanitation inspections and impose penalties for violations. 4. Provide a clear timeline for resolution and enforcement updates. The continued failure to act exposes theCity to liability for neglecting public health and safety under California Government Code § 815.6, which requires municipalities to performmandatory duties. We expect a formal response with a clear action plan within 14 days. If no satisfactory action is taken, we reserve the right to escalate this matterthrough legal channels to protect our businesses, employees, and the community. <email-signture_87b8d7a2- c4f4-4cbf-b474-af2f32118dd2.png> Maor Greenberg CEO maor@greenberg.construction |650-610-7711 Greenberg.Construction | 650-600-9536 x101 | Fax 925-269-2325908 Industrial Ave, Palo Alto94303 <F_1bc77f31-68bf-4143- 80ea-3f34f539ea07.png> <insta_26696304-1b39-4259-9776- 9f137454bed9.png> <yelp_e821c57e-caea-4e87-a5dd- 5905e7ca4fb1.png> <Houzz_7abe75ad-d6ee-48ac-943b- 592713e31957.png> <P_aece63f3-754b-4dca-a0a9-e93b94de4930.png> <google_04352117-2fb4- 4963-bb3e-cc5317269360.png> From: Gaines, Chantal <Chantal.Gaines@CityofPaloAlto.org> Date: Friday, December 20, 2024 at 7:12 AM To: Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction>, Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com>, osbaldo@or-builders.com <osbaldo@or-builders.com> Cc: Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>, Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>, Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>, Becchetti, Benjamin <Benjamin.Becchetti@CityofPaloAlto.org>, Lester Wong <lwong@wongelectric.com>, Cathi Lerch < -- Marguerite Poyatos Palo Alto Glass, Inc. 4085 Transport Street Palo Alto CA 94303 (650) 494-7000 (650) 494-7087 (FAX) Nour_box.png CODEPINK Chicago outside McNally Capital. Send a letter condemning McNally Capital for investingin genocide! Send a letter! From:Aram James To:Sean Allen; Seher Awan; Pat M; Michael Ybarra; Nicole Chiu-Wang; Yusra Hussain; Yolanda Conaway; DonAustin; Kaloma Smith; Human Relations Commission; Council, City; citycouncil@mountainview.gov; Nash, Betsy;dcombs@menlopark.gov; GRP-City Council; city.council@menlopark.gov; Bill Newell; Raymond Goins; GerryGras; Dana St. George; james pitkin; Roberta Ahlquist Subject:Re: The worst way to make money… Date:Wednesday, July 23, 2025 11:13:05 AM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. On Wed, Jul 23, 2025 at 10:01 AM Jenin, CODEPINK <info@codepink.org> wrote: CODEPINK.ORG Dear Aram, I am writing this to you in a very bleak time. While one part of the world is enjoying summertime with lavish dinners and pool parties, another is being starved to the brink of extermination. Palestinians in Gaza are pleading with the rest of the world to recognize the fact that there is no food left as people are dying due to malnutrition on a daily basis. The Al-Jazeera journalist, Anas al- Sharif, recently broke down crying during a broadcast of a Palestinian woman collapsing on the floor through sheer exhaustion and starvation. It takes little to imagine what the Israeli military said about this: they accused Al-Sharif of “crocodile tears.” A very ironic statement from a self-victimizing settler colonial state that regularly weaponizes crocodile tears to manufacture consent for the genocide in Gaza. Now, the genocide has unfolded to its deadliest phase, where Palestinians aren’t just experiencing mass casualties from bombardment, but from manufactured starvation as well. What makes it worse is that there are investment firms profiting off the Gaza “Humanitarian” Foundation’s (GHF) barbaric starvation campaign to kill Palestinians. One of the culprits is right here in Chicago – add your name to our letter to shame McNally Capital and I will deliver it to their front door! Yesterday, I attended a protest here in Chicago outside McNally Capital, the financial investors of the fake aid organization GHF. A spokesperson previously spoke on McNally’s involvement with GHF’s logistics company, Safe Reach Solutions (SRS): “McNally Capital has provided administrative advice to SRS and worked in collaboration with multiple parties to enable SRS to carry out its mission.”* Hundreds of people were gathered outside to call out the investment firm for maintaining economic ties to an organization created to kill Palestinians desperately trying to receive flour. With that information, I ask you: Is it just a coincidence that the GHF has become the privatized replacement for governmental organizations like UNRWA? Is it just a coincidence that the GHF is made up of U.S. organizations like Safe Reach Solutions, McNally Capital, and Boston Consulting Group — who all have ties to the U.S. and Israeli governments? Is it a coincidence that the aid distribution sites run by the GHF have been called “death traps”? The privatization of humanitarian aid by capitalist companies has led to the formulation of what we all know to be peace’s enemy: ethnic cleansing fueled by corporations with the intent of profiting off the land in the future. These CEOs believe that Gaza can be theirs if they kill everyone there, after which they’ll be able to sell beautiful oceanfront real estate — or drill Gaza’s oil and take the profits for themselves. Tell McNally Capital, the funders of the murderous Gaza “Humanitarian” Foundation: Shame on you! What Gaza is experiencing is textbook manufactured famine, yet international organizations like the U.N. have hesitated to say so. What will it take for the world to call what is happening in Gaza what it is? It seems that while every atrocity has been committed, no suitable action has been taken by our institutions. Just this weekend, the National Education Association’s (NEA) executive committee cancelled a vote by its rank and file to drop the Anti-Defamation League (ADL) from schools all across the country. Unsurprisingly, these executives met with the heads of the ADL before making their decision. Every detriment to our society’s welfare is working in conjunction with one another. Never forget that the forces of imperialism, capitalism, and propaganda that are influencing the NEA’s decision are the same ones that are behind the dystopian GHF. The state of Israel and the U.S., forces of capitalism and imperialism, wreak havoc all over the world. Still though, what gives me hope is the fact that these truths are being uncovered by the public and being recognized as twisted schemes by many. You all reading this email know these things, you know how cruel and ruthless these companies and governments are. And that is all I need to know to have a kernel of faith in my heart, because the truth will always prevail — these wicked CEOs and politicians won’t get away with this forever. The situation in Gaza is dire. We need to keep the people’s pleas alive; you all know the truth and can mobilize yourselves and your communities to take action. The people in Gaza have called for a week of action, so please look here to see if there are any events in your area that you can turn out to. We must be in the streets with a clear message to end the horrific forced starvation and genocide the people of Palestine are being subjected to. Join us for 30 minutes of nonstop calling to McNally Capital on Friday, July 25th, at 1 pm ET to end their investment in genocide! Here are other ways to engage: Watch our Summer School Session on Resisting Propaganda! Join us at the Detroit People's Conference for Palestine! Tell Airbnb: Stop Listing Properties On Stolen Land! Follow along with our Boycott Birthright Series! Join our Palestine Working Group! Check out our bold new arrivals at our CODEPINK Store! Until Liberation, Jenin and the entire CODEPINK team *Read the Reuters article, “Chicago private equity firm has stake in Gaza aid company." P.S. Hello everyone, my name is Jenin and I am the new Palestine lead here at CODEPINK! I am a first-generation Palestinian American, born to two Palestinian immigrant parents. I’m from the city of Al-Khalil and have been blessed with the privilege of being able to visit Palestine many times. If you’re wondering why I’m named after the Palestinian city of Jenin (but not from there), I was born in June 2002, a few months after the massacre of Jenin. In April of that year, Israeli forces launched an unprecedented attack on Jenin Refugee Camp, where dozens were killed and the camp was left almost entirely destroyed. Today, Jenin continues to be targeted by the Israeli military’s unlawful assaults. I grew up with the knowledge of my name; the weight of the city I amnamed after, a city known for its resilience and principle, is something I carry every day to motivate me in this long, hard struggle. My commitment to Palestine is unmatched. I hope I can honor my people and my homeland by engaging with you Palestine and organizing meaningful actions – until Palestine is free. Lovely to meet you all! Donate Now! Make a one-time donation or choose monthly giving. This email was sent to abjpd1@gmail.com. To unsubscribe, click here. To update your email subscription, contact info@codepink.org. © 2025 CODEPINK.ORG | Created with NationBuilder From:Aram James To:Veenker, Vicki; Lythcott-Haims, Julie Cc:Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23; editor@almanacnews.com; Ed Lauing; editor@paweekly.com; Reckdahl, Keith; Reckdahl, Keith; Gennady Sheyner; Gardener, Liz; Lotus Fong; Council, City; Mark Turner; Michelle Bigelow; city.council@menlopark.gov; citycouncil@mountainview.gov; City Attorney; Friends of Cubberley; GRP-City Council; GRP-City Clerk; Human Relations Commission; citycouncil@menlopark.org; Perron, Zachary; Binder, Andrew; Jay Boyarsky; Reifschneider, James; Jeff Rosen Subject:DEIR AL-BALAH, Gaza Strip — More than 1,000 Palestinians have been killed by Israeli forces since May whiletrying to get food in the Gaza Strip, mostly near aid sites run by an American contractor, the U.N. human rightsoffice said Tuesday. Date:Wednesday, July 23, 2025 9:30:31 AM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. DEIR AL-BALAH, Gaza Strip — More than 1,000 Palestinians have been killed by Israeli forces since May while trying to get food in the Gaza Strip, mostly near aid sites run by an American contractor, the U.N. human rights office said Tuesday. . https://edition.pagesuite.com/popovers/dynamic_article_popover.aspx?guid=e478ba3a-a98c-4756-9301-6192a18c2b1e&appcode=SAN252&eguid=00981d02-bb69-41db-805f- b0ba4a0c85fa&pnum=14# For more great content like this subscribe to the The MercuryNews e-edition app here: From:Aram James To:Veenker, Vicki Cc:Sean Allen; Jeff Rosen; Jay Boyarsky; Veenker, Vicki; h.etzko@gmail.com; jessica@speiser.net; Foley, Michael; GRP-City Council; Raymond Goins; RajJayadev; Patrice Ventresca; Figueroa, Eric; Lotus Fong; Reifschneider, James; Binder, Andrew; Gardener, Liz; Diana Diamond; Yolanda Conaway; yolanda;Don Austin; jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com; Human Relations Commission; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; Perron, Zachary; Robert Salonga; Rob Baker;Robert. Jonsen; Roberta Ahlquist; Steve Wagstaffe; Wagner, April; Jeff Conrad; Burt, Patrick; PD Kristina Bell; Bill Newell; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan;Councilmember Chappie Jones; District9@sanjoseca.gov; District4@sanjoseca.gov; District5@sanjoseca.gov; District2@sanjoseca.gov; Today EPA; GennadySheyner; Council, City; city.council@menlopark.gov; Vara Ramakrishnan; cromero@cityofepa.org; Cribbs, Anne; michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com; Stump,Molly; board@pausd.org; BoardOperations; Damon Silver; Miguel Rodriguez; Cait James; Josh Becker; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Zelkha,Mila; dennis burns; DuJuan Green; Gerry Gras; Enberg, Nicholas; Rowena Chiu; Barberini, Christopher; Reckdahl, Keith; Dana St. George; Blackshire,Geoffrey; Tom DuBois; Friends of Cubberley; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Greg Tanaka; Bil Barber; Ed Lauing; Yi Chen; Donna Wallach; Mickie Winkler;Supervisor Otto Lee; Mark Turner; City Attorney; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; Seher Awan; Pat M; Carla Torres; David Piper; Lori Meyers; Sheree Roth;Ellen Fox; Marty Wasserman; Dave Price; Angel, David Subject:Re: Block the Bombs_1_2 sheet Date:Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:32:20 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments andclicking on links. The ongoing genocide and war crimes committed by Israel, with the full support of the United States, will eventually be prosecuted in the International Criminal Court in The Hague. This will happen regardless of any alleged actions by Hamas. It is crucial to understand that the ongoing genocide is a separate and distinct crime from the alleged behavior of the group referred to as Hamas (freedom fighters). As Bob Dylan famously said, “You don't need a weatherman to know which way the wind blows.” In a similar vein, you don’t need a genocide expert to recognize that Israel is currently engaged in a massive, full-blown genocideof the Palestinian people. One can offer various intellectual rationalizations, but the reality remains indisputable—the actions of the state of Israel amount to genocide beyond all reasonable doubt. Israel is guilty as charged ofwar crimes and genocide. Avram “Let The Prosecution Begin” Finkelstein On Tue, Jul 22, 2025 at 10:05 PM Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:Sean, There's a very popular ideology nowadays, which I'm guessing you subscribe to, that the world would be a better place ifeveryone would give up their national and religious identities and join in a common universal culture. I strongly doubt thiswill ever happen. First, the differences between nations can be so profound that it’s impossible to create a cultureacceptable to all. Also, peoples’ identities are very important to them. Asking people to stop being who they are for somenebulous goal of peace is a definite nonstarter. This is certainly true of Jews. People have been trying to erase Jewishidentity for over 3000 years, including some of the most powerful empires in history. As a believing Jew, I believe God haspreserved us because he has a purpose for us. And I don't think that purpose is to renounce our connection to Him, lose ouridentity and live according to other people's dictates. You say Israel lacks humanitarianism toward African refugees. I would argue that Israel’s humanitarianism is second tonone. But there's a limit. It's a tiny country surrounded by enemies. It's taken in many African refugees that it didn't have to.But why is all your criticism directed at tiny Israel when the vast Arab world refuses to do anything at all for theserefugees, most of whom are their own coreligionists? I’ll also note that the world is a highly competitive place where nations compete for power and domination every singleday. Israel knows that it has to fight if it wants to survive. Although it has strong humanitarian instincts, it's primaryobjective has to be to maintain its existence and its integrity, and the values that have sustained us as a people for over threemillennia. Caring for the humanitarian needs of strangers, though indeed an important Jewish value, definitely has to besecondary to this. Best,Martin On Jul 21, 2025, at 6:00 PM, Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com> wrote: Hi Martin, Thank you for sharing your thoughts. I understand your perspective on the importance of national security, and your response highlights my previous point regarding Israel's desire to maintain its purity and identity. Yourremarks seem to support the premise that Israel’s actions promote a sense of exclusivity, prioritizing itsnational identity over the humanitarian needs of others. Moreover, your position suggesting that Muslims and others should seek assistance outside of Israel reinforcesthe notion of maintaining a specific national identity, which further emphasizes purity but also points todiscrimination against those who don't fit that identity. The refusal to support those seeking refuge can be seenas a troubling aspect of how Israel navigates its humanitarian obligations. Additionally, the United States has a lengthy history of championing humanitarian efforts, being a countrybuilt on the foundation of immigration and diversity. It feels counterintuitive for the U.S. to support nationsthat do not uphold the same values of compassion and assistance to those in need, especially when taxpayermoney is involved. The commitment to shared responsibility and collective morality should guide ourpartnerships and aid. While I appreciate the unique history and culture of the Jewish people, it is possible to uphold national identitywhile also extending compassion and support to those facing perilous situations. Finding a balance betweenthese values is essential for fostering a more inclusive and just society. Looking forward to your thoughts. Best, Sean Sent from my iPhone On Jul 21, 2025, at 5:08 PM, Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote: Sean, Humanitarian values are important, but realistically, national security concerns will alwaysoverride them in virtually any country on Earth. In fact, any nation that puts humanitarianismabove its own national security interests probably won't be a nation for long. And if we accept theidea that any person’s need creates an obligation for others to fulfill that need, the world wouldvery quickly sink into chaos. Regarding African refugees in Israel, it's a testimony to Israel’s humanitarianism that theserefugees, mostly Muslims, know they'll receive more compassionate care in the one Jewish statethan in any Arab or Muslim state. Nevertheless, Israel is a very small country, and it's also thenation state of the Jewish people, a people with their own unique religion, language, and cultureand a very long history. If it opened its gates to everyone who was in need, it would quickly beswamped, and would no longer be the nation state of the Jewish people. Israel is not going tocompromise its national identity, and it's unreasonable to think that it should, for the sake ofhelping strangers who have no particular connection to Jews or Judaism. Best,Martin On Jul 21, 2025, at 12:03 PM, Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com> wrote: Martin, I appreciate your perspective on the complexities of national security andhumanitarian obligations. However, it's crucial to recognize that viewing civilians as"enemies" can lead to a dangerous precedent where humanitarian needs aredisregarded in the name of security. In both the case of African asylum-seekers and Palestinians in Gaza, the individualsaffected are often civilians who are fleeing violence, persecution, or dire living conditions. They should not be categorized merely as "enemy civilians," as thisoversimplifies the multifaceted nature of conflict and ignores their humanity. Treatingany civilian population as an enemy undermines the basic principles of internationalhumanitarian law, which emphasize the protection of non-combatants in conflictsituations. The actions of Israel toward African asylum-seekers further illustrate this point. In theface of significant geopolitical and humanitarian challenges, Israel has opted to deportEritrean and Sudanese asylum-seekers, often leaving them vulnerable to persecutionin third countries, demonstrating a troubling pattern of prioritizing security measuresover humanitarian responsibilities. Like the civilians in Gaza, these asylum-seekersare fleeing perilous situations; thus, their humanity should be recognized regardless ofthe circumstances surrounding their migration. Regarding your historical references, while it is true that during times of war, nationshave made decisions that prioritize military objectives, it's essential to acknowledgethat the moral implications of such decisions have evolved. The internationalcommunity increasingly recognizes the importance of humanitarian considerationseven amid conflict. Ignoring humanitarian needs, particularly of vulnerablepopulations, can perpetuate cycles of violence and instability that ultimately harmnational interests in the long run. Additionally, while you mention Israeli perspectives on Gazan civilians voting forHamas, it's critical to understand that many civilians may have done so under coerciveconditions or without the full capacity to consider the implications of their choices.Many Gazans are indeed caught in a cycle of violence, facing repercussions for thedecisions made by leadership they may not support. You also note Israel's earlier actions to facilitate the entry of food and supplies intoGaza. However, the effectiveness and sufficiency of this aid must be contextualizedagainst the wider backdrop of blockades and military operations that significantlyrestrict access to essential services, creating a humanitarian crisis. In summary, while national security is undoubtedly critical, it should not come at thecost of abandoning the fundamental human rights and dignity of civilians caught inconflict. The tragic plight of those affected by violence—whether they are asylum-seekers or civilians in Gaza—demands a compassionate and just approach thatacknowledges their humanity. Is the refusal to recognize the humanity of theseindividuals truly an acceptable stance in the pursuit of security, or is it more aboutmaintaining purity? Regards, Sean Sent from my iPhone On Jul 21, 2025, at 10:31 AM, Martin Wasserman<deeperlook@aol.com> wrote: Sean, I appreciate your concern for humanitarian issues. However, the reality isthat when a nation is fighting for its very existence, as Israel is doingright now, its highest priority has to be to defeat the enemy, and caringfor the humanitarian needs of enemy civilians has to be a much lowerpriority. In fact, most nations would ridicule the idea of helping enemy civilianswhile a war is ongoing, arguing that it’s equivalent to helping the enemyhimself. During World War II, for example, the overriding imperative wasvictory, and the US showed no concern for the humanitarian well-beingof the enemy civilians it was bombing, nor did any other nation involvedin that conflict. Humanitarian concerns could be addressed after the war,but not during it. It’s also worth noting that Israelis don't necessarily see Gazan civilians asinnocent bystanders. They remember how they voted Hamas into power,and how many of them followed Hamas into Israel on October 7 and tookdirect part in the plunder and pillage of that day. They also recall theoutbursts of delirious joy as the Israeli hostages were paraded through thestreets of Gaza, and how not a single Gazan did anything to help theIsraeli hostages escape from their captivity. Nevertheless, Israel has shown more concern for humanitarian issuesthan virtually any other country in a similar situation. Earlier in the war,it allowed huge amounts of food and supplies into Gaza, even though itknew that most of the aid was being stolen by Hamas, thereby prolongingthe war and making victory more difficult to achieve. Incidentally, therewere many in Israel who thought this policy was very foolish and highlycounterproductive. Regards,Martin Wasserman On Jul 20, 2025, at 8:34 PM, Sean Allen<sallen6444@yahoo.com> wrote: Martin, Thank you for sharing your perspective. While it's importantto consider the complex dynamics at play, the impact ofrationing food and resources cannot be overlooked. Limitingaccess to basic necessities can lead to dire consequences forthe civilian population, contributing to significant sufferingand hardship, irrespective of intent. Historically, we have seen that during crises, peopleinstinctively fight and even resort to violence over limitedresources. This was evident in the aftermath of HurricaneKatrina in the United States, where widespread desperationfor food, water, and safety led to chaos and alarming acts ofviolence. Reports from that time highlighted how individualslooted stores and clashed with each other as they scrambledfor basic survival needs, demonstrating how fragile socialorder can become when resources are scarce. Similarly, inSomalia, we witnessed violence surrounding the distributionof humanitarian aid, as factions vied for control over theresources being provided to those in need. Rationing food and resources has the potential to produceoutcomes that are as devastating as direct violence, akin tothe effects of bombing a population. Furthermore, militaryunits should never base their decisions to slaughter non-combatants on the basis that their opposition does not releasehostages, regardless of the justification for conflict. Unlessthe motive is to create more chaos through infighting, whichwould lead to similar devastation as bombing non-combatantcommunities, the humane approach is to provide theseindividuals with the necessary amount of humanitarian aidand stop the slaughter. Bombing non-combatants is not war;it’s slaughter and inhumane. Even our Constitution prohibitspunishing a group of people because of the actions of others. While military objectives may focus on specific groups, wemust recognize that the broader impact on civilian livesremains profound. The suffering of Gazans should not bediminished or overlooked, as their well-being is affected bythe decisions made in the context of this conflict. Best, Sean Allen Sent from my iPhone On Jul 20, 2025, at 3:30 PM, Aram James<abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Condemn Israel or be complicit in genocide': Colombia's Gustavo Petro By Al Mayadeen English Source: The Guardian 8 Jul 2025 13:47 2 Shares 4 Min Read Colombian President Gustavo Petro, in a Guardian op-ed, accuses Netanyahu of genocide in Gaza and urges global action. Listen On Tuesday, The Guardian published an opinion piece by Colombian President Gustavo Petro, in which he accused Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of orchestrating a "campaign of devastation" in Gaza and called on the international community to move beyond symbolic outrage toward concrete action in defense of international law. Petro has emerged as one of the most outspoken world leaders condemning "Israel’s" war on Gaza, and his latest opinion piece adds to a growing series of forceful critiques directed at the ongoing Israeli genocide. Denouncing what he described as 600 days of systematic atrocities, Petro wrote that the world's inaction risks legitimizing a model of impunity where colonial violence, ethnic cleansing, and siege warfare are normalized against a captive population. "If we fail to act now," he wrote, "we not only betray the Palestinian people, we become complicit in the atrocities committed by Netanyahu's government." Moral break The president highlighted a landmark United Nations General Assembly resolution adopted in September 2024, which called for "Israel" to end its illegal occupation within 12 months. He noted that Colombia was among the 124 countries that voted in favor, thereby assuming binding obligations that include sanctions, legal action, and trade measures. "The clock is now ticking," he warned, reaffirming Colombia's commitment by recalling its concrete step: suspending coal exports to "Israel." Related News 650 days of genocide: 125,000 tons of bombs 2.4 mln lives shattered Starved by 'Israel': People of Gaza are dying while the world watches In his piece, Petro mentioned that he had declared earlier this year: "We cannot fuel the machinery that slaughters Palestinian children and then claim neutrality." This is not the first bold move by the Colombian president. In May, his government formally cut diplomatic ties with "Israel," citing what Petro explicitly described as a "genocide." His administration also appointed Colombia’s first ambassador to Palestine, pledging medical treatment in Colombian hospitals for injured children from Gaza. The newly appointed ambassador, Jorge Iván Ospina, later echoed Petro’s position, warning of a "macabre intention to erase the identity of a people." In Tuesday's article, Petro praised similar actions taken by countries like Malaysia, which banned Israeli ships from its ports, and South Africa, which brought "Israel" before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) on charges of genocide. It is worth noting that Colombia joined that case as an intervening party, further deepening its legal opposition to "Israel's" war. Read more: US defends Israeli use of starvation as weapon of war before ICJ Global reckoning Looking ahead, Petro mentioned that Colombia and South Africa, co-chairs of the Hague Group, will host an emergency summit regarding Gaza on July 15. The conference aims to develop a coordinated, multilateral strategy to isolate "Israel" diplomatically and economically while restoring credibility to the global legal order. With the UN's proposed international peace conference indefinitely postponed, Petro cast the July summit as a necessary corrective to global paralysis. The Colombian president framed the Gaza crisis not just as a moral catastrophe but as an existential test for international law and nations of the Global South. "We can either stand firm in defense of the legal principles that seek to prevent war and conflict," he wrote, "or watch helplessly as the international system collapses under the weight of unchecked power politics." He concluded his piece by stressing that the choice is between complicity in colonial violence and collective resistance against it. On Sun, Jul 20, 2025 at 3:12 PM MartinWasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:Aram, Amnesty International is not a credible sourceon this issue. It appears that the once-respectable organization has been taken overby malevolent actors with a political axe togrind. Their anti-Israel bias is evidentthroughout the report. They accuse Israel of genocide but make nomention at all of Hamas’ explicit genocidalpolicy against Jews. They accuse Israel of violating internationallaw, but make no reference at all to the factthat Israel is facing a ruthless enemy thatobserves no international laws whatsoever. When they mention Hamas’ transgressions atall, they do it in the mildest language possible,and then use the most damning possiblelanguage when describing Israel's actions. They take it as a given that Israel is anapartheid state, a blatantly false accusationthat is very easily disproved. They take it as a given that Israel is illegallyoccupying Palestinian land, as if the territoriesof Judea and Samaria, the heartland of theancient Jewish nation, don't belong to Jews atall, but are instead the property of a fictitiouscountry called “Palestine” which has neveractually existed in any historical period. In short, this entire report is a politicallymotivated “hatchet job” that deserves nocredibility whatsoever. Martin Wasserman On Jul 20, 2025, at 11:39 AM,Aram James<abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Amnesty Internationalinvestigation concludesIsrael is committing genocide againstPalestinians in Gaza Amnesty International’s research has found sufficient basisto conclude that Israel has committed and is continuing tocommit genocide against Palestinians in the occupied GazaStrip, the organization said in a landmark new reportpublished today. The report, ‘You Feel Like You Are Subhuman’: Israel’sGenocide Against Palestinians in Gaza, documents how,during its military offensive launched in the wake of thedeadly Hamas-led attacks in southern Israel on 7 October2023, Israel has unleashed hell and destruction onPalestinians in Gaza brazenly, continuously and with total impunity. “Amnesty International’s report demonstrates that Israel hascarried out acts prohibited under the Genocide Convention, withthe specific intent to destroy Palestinians in Gaza. These actsinclude killings, causing serious bodily or mental harm anddeliberately inflicting on Palestinians in Gaza conditions of life calculated to bring about their physical destruction. Month after month, Israel has treated Palestinians in Gaza as a subhumangroup unworthy of human rights and dignity, demonstrating itsintent to physically destroy them,” said Agnès Callamard,Secretary General of Amnesty International. “Our damning findings must serve as a wake-up call to the international community: this is genocide. It must stop now. “States that continue to transfer arms to Israel at this timemust know they are violating their obligation to preventgenocide and are at risk of becoming complicit in genocide.All states with influence over Israel, particularly key armssuppliers like the USA and Germany, but also other EU member states, the UK and others, must act now to bring Israel’s atrocities against Palestinians in Gaza to animmediate end.” Over the past two months the crisis has grown particularlyacute in the North Gaza governorate, where a besiegedpopulation is facing starvation, displacement and annihilation amid relentless bombardment and suffocating restrictions on life-saving humanitarian aid. “Our research reveals that, for months, Israel has persisted incommitting genocidal acts, fully aware of the irreparable harm itwas inflicting on Palestinians in Gaza. It continued to do so indefiance of countless warnings about the catastrophic humanitarian situation and of legally binding decisions from the International Court of Justice (ICJ) ordering Israel to takeimmediate measures to enable the provision of humanitarianassistance to civilians in Gaza,” said Agnès Callamard. “Israel has repeatedly argued that its actions in Gaza arelawful and can be justified by its military goal to eradicate Hamas. But genocidal intent can co-exist alongside military goals and does not need to be Israel’s sole intent.” Amnesty International examined Israel’s acts in Gazaclosely and in their totality, taking into account theirrecurrence and simultaneous occurrence, and both their immediate impact and their cumulative and mutuallyreinforcing consequences. The organization considered thescale and severity of the casualties and destruction over time. It also analysed public statements by officials, findingthat prohibited acts were often announced or called for inthe first place by high-level officials in charge of the warefforts. “Taking into account the pre-existing context ofdispossession, apartheid and unlawful military occupation in which these acts have been committed, we could find onlyone reasonable conclusion: Israel’s intent is the physicaldestruction of Palestinians in Gaza, whether in parallel with,or as a means to achieve, its military goal of destroyingHamas,” said Agnès Callamard. “The atrocity crimes committed on 7 October 2023 by Hamas and other armed groups against Israelis and victimsof other nationalities, including deliberate mass killings andhostage-taking, can never justify Israel’s genocide againstPalestinians in Gaza.” International jurisprudence recognizes that the perpetrator does not need to succeed in their attempts to destroy the protected group, either in whole or in part, for genocide tohave been committed. The commission of prohibited actswith the intent to destroy the group, as such, is sufficient. Amnesty International’s report examines in detail Israel’sviolations in Gaza over nine months between 7 October 2023 and early July 2024. The organization interviewed 212 people, including Palestinian victims and witnesses, localauthorities in Gaza, healthcare workers, conducted fieldworkand analysed an extensive range of visual and digitalevidence, including satellite imagery. It also analysedstatements by senior Israeli government and military officials, and official Israeli bodies. On multiple occasions, the organization shared its findings with the Israeliauthorities but had received no substantive response at thetime of publication. Unprecedented scale and magnitude Israel’s actions following Hamas’s deadly attacks on 7 October 2023 have brought Gaza’s population to the brinkof collapse. Its brutal military offensive had killed more than42,000 Palestinians, including over 13,300 children, andinjured over 97,000 more, by 7 October 2024, many of themin direct or deliberately indiscriminate attacks, often wiping out entire multigenerational families. It has caused unprecedented destruction, which experts say occurred at alevel and speed not seen in any other conflict in the 21stcentury, levelling entire cities and destroying criticalinfrastructure, agricultural land and cultural and religious sites. It thereby rendered large swathes of Gaza uninhabitable. Mohammed, who fled with his family from Gaza City toRafah in March 2024 and was displaced again in May 2024,described their struggle to survive in horrifying conditions: “Here in Deir al-Balah, it’s like an apocalypse… You have toprotect your children from insects, from the heat, and there is no clean water, no toilets, all while the bombing never stops. You feel like you are subhuman here.” Israel imposed conditions of life in Gaza that created a deadly mixture of malnutrition, hunger and diseases, andexposed Palestinians to a slow, calculated death. Israel alsosubjected hundreds of Palestinians from Gaza toincommunicado detention, torture and other ill-treatment. Viewed in isolation, some of the acts investigated by Amnesty International constitute serious violations of international humanitarian law or international human rightslaw. But in looking at the broader picture of Israel’s militarycampaign and the cumulative impact of its policies and acts,genocidal intent is the only reasonable conclusion. Intent to destroy To establish Israel’s specific intent to physically destroyPalestinians in Gaza, as such, Amnesty Internationalanalysed the overall pattern of Israel’s conduct in Gaza,reviewed dehumanizing and genocidal statements by Israeli government and military officials, particularly those at the highest levels, and considered the context of Israel’s systemof apartheid, its inhumane blockade of Gaza and theunlawful 57-year-old military occupation of the Palestinianterritory. Before reaching its conclusion, Amnesty International examined Israel’s claims that its military lawfully targeted Hamas and other armed groups throughout Gaza, and thatthe resulting unprecedented destruction and denial of aidwere the outcome of unlawful conduct by Hamas and otherarmed groups, such as locating fighters among the civilianpopulation or the diversion of aid. The organization concluded these claims are not credible. The presence ofHamas fighters near or within a densely populated areadoes not absolve Israel from its obligations to take allfeasible precautions to spare civilians and avoidindiscriminate or disproportionate attacks. Its research found Israel repeatedly failed to do so, committing multiple crimes under international law for which there can be nojustification based on Hamas’s actions. AmnestyInternational also found no evidence that the diversion of aidcould explain Israel’s extreme and deliberate restrictions on life-saving humanitarian aid. In its analysis, the organization also considered alternative arguments such as ones that Israel was acting recklessly orthat it simply wanted to destroy Hamas and did not care if itneeded to destroy Palestinians in the process,demonstrating a callous disregard for their lives rather than genocidal intent. Our damning findings must serve as a wake-up call to the international community: this isgenocide. It must stop now. Agnès Callamard, Amnesty International However, regardless of whether Israel sees the destruction of Palestinians as instrumental to destroying Hamas or asan acceptable by-product of this goal, this view ofPalestinians as disposable and not worthy of consideration is in itself evidence of genocidal intent. Many of the unlawful acts documented by AmnestyInternational were preceded by officials urging their implementation. The organization reviewed 102 statements that were issued by Israeli government and military officialsand others between 7 October 2023 and 30 June 2024 anddehumanized Palestinians, called for or justified genocidalacts or other crimes against them. Of these, Amnesty International identified 22 statements made by senior officials in charge of managing the offensive that appeared to call for, or justify, genocidal acts, providingdirect evidence of genocidal intent. This language wasfrequently replicated, including by Israeli soldiers on theground, as evidenced by audiovisual content verified by Amnesty International showing soldiers making calls to “erase” Gaza or to make it uninhabitable, and celebratingthe destruction of Palestinian homes, mosques, schools anduniversities. Killing and causing serious bodily ormental harm Amnesty International documented the genocidal acts ofkilling and causing serious mental and bodily harm toPalestinians in Gaza by reviewing the results ofinvestigations it conducted into 15 air strikes between 7October 2023 and 20 April 2024 that killed at least 334 civilians, including 141 children, and wounded hundreds of others. Amnesty International found no evidence that any ofthese strikes were directed at a military objective. In one illustrative case, on 20 April 2024, an Israeli air strikedestroyed the Abdelal family house in the Al-Jneinahneighbourhood in eastern Rafah, killing three generations of Palestinians, including 16 children, while they were sleeping. While these represent just a fraction of Israel’s aerialattacks, they are indicative of a broader pattern of repeateddirect attacks on civilians and civilian objects or deliberatelyindiscriminate attacks. The attacks were also conducted in ways designed to cause a very high number of fatalities and injuries among the civilian population. Inflicting conditions of life calculatedto bring about physical destruction The report documents how Israel deliberately inflicted conditions of life on Palestinians in Gaza intended to lead, over time, to their destruction. These conditions wereimposed through three simultaneous patterns thatrepeatedly compounded the effect of each other’sdevastating impacts: damage to and destruction of life-sustaining infrastructure and other objects indispensable to the survival of the civilian population; the repeated use ofsweeping, arbitrary and confusing mass “evacuation” ordersto forcibly displace almost all of Gaza’s population; and thedenial and obstruction of the delivery of essential services,humanitarian assistance and other life-saving supplies into and within Gaza. After 7 October 2023, Israel imposed a total siege on Gaza cutting off electricity, water and fuel. In the nine months reviewed for this report, Israel maintained a suffocating,unlawful blockade, tightly controlled access to energysources, failed to facilitate meaningful humanitarian accesswithin Gaza, and obstructed the import and delivery of life- saving goods and humanitarian aid, particularly to areas north of Wadi Gaza. They thereby exacerbated an alreadyexisting humanitarian crisis. This, combined with theextensive damage to Gaza’s homes, hospitals, water andsanitation facilities and agricultural land, and mass forceddisplacement, caused catastrophic levels of hunger and led to the spread of diseases at alarming rates. The impact was especially harsh on young children and pregnant orbreastfeeding women, with anticipated long-termconsequences for their health. The international community’s seismic,shameful failure for over a year to pressIsrael to end its atrocities in Gaza, by firstdelaying calls for a ceasefire and thencontinuing arms transfers, is and will remain a stain on our collective conscience.Agnès Callamard, Amnesty International Time and again, Israel had the chance to improve thehumanitarian situation in Gaza, yet for over a year it hasrepeatedly refused to take steps blatantly within its power todo so, such as opening sufficient access points to Gaza or lifting tight restrictions on what could enter the Strip or their obstruction of aid deliveries within Gaza while the situationhas grown progressively worse. Through its repeated “evacuation” orders Israel displacednearly 1.9 million Palestinians – 90% of Gaza’s population –into ever-shrinking, unsafe pockets of land under inhumane conditions, some of them up to 10 times. These multiple waves of forced displacement left many jobless and deeplytraumatized, especially since some 70% of Gaza’s residentsare refugees or descendants of refugees whose towns andvillages were ethnically cleansed by Israel during the 1948Nakba. Despite conditions quickly becoming unfit for human life, Israeli authorities refused to consider measures that wouldhave protected displaced civilians and ensured their basicneeds were met, showing that their actions weredeliberate. They refused to allow those displaced to return to their homes in northern Gaza or relocate temporarily to other parts of the Occupied Palestinian Territory or Israel,continuing to deny many Palestinians their right to return under international law to areas they were displaced from in 1948. They did so knowing that there was nowheresafe for Palestinians in Gaza to flee to. Accountability for genocide “The international community’s seismic, shameful failure forover a year to press Israel to end its atrocities in Gaza, byfirst delaying calls for a ceasefire and then continuing arms transfers, is and will remain a stain on our collectiveconscience,” said Agnès Callamard. “Governments must stop pretending they are powerless to end this genocide, which was enabled by decades of impunity for Israel’s violations of international law. Statesneed to move beyond mere expressions of regret or dismayand take strong and sustained international action, howeveruncomfortable a finding of genocide may be for some ofIsrael’s allies. “The International Criminal Court’s (ICC) arrest warrants for Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former DefenseMinister Yoav Gallant for war crimes and crimes againsthumanity issued last month offer real hope of long-overduejustice for victims. States must demonstrate their respect forthe court’s decision and for universal international law principles by arresting and handing over those wanted bythe ICC. “We are calling on the Office of the Prosecutor of theInternational Criminal Court (ICC) to urgently consideradding genocide to the list of crimes it is investigating and for all states to use every legal avenue to bring perpetrators to justice. No one should be allowed to commit genocideand remain unpunished.” Amnesty International is also calling for all civilian hostagesto be released unconditionally and for Hamas and otherPalestinian armed groups responsible for the crimes committed on 7 October to be held to account. The organization is also calling for the UN Security Council to impose targeted sanctions against Israeli and Hamasofficials most implicated in crimes under international law. Background On 7 October 2023 Hamas and other armed groups indiscriminately fired rockets into southernIsrael and carried out deliberate mass killings andhostage-taking there, killing 1,200 people, including over800 civilians, and abducted 223 civilians and captured 27soldiers. The crimes perpetrated by Hamas and other armedgroups during this attack will be the focus of a forthcoming Amnesty International report. Since October 2023, Amnesty International has conducted in-depth investigations into the multiple violations and crimes underinternational law committed by Israeli forces, including directattacks on civilians and civilian objects and deliberatelyindiscriminate attacks killing hundreds of civilians, as well as other unlawful attacks on and collective punishment of the civilian population. The organization has called on the Office of the ICCProsecutor to expedite its investigation into the situation in theState of Palestine and is campaigning for an immediate ceasefire. For the Hebrew translation of this press release, clickhere. INTERNATIONAL JUSTICE ISRAEL AND THE OCCUPIED PALESTINIAN TERRITORY MIDDLE EAST MIDDLE EAST AND NORTH AFRICA NEWS PRESS RELEASE WAR CRIMES AND CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY Related Content COUNTRY Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territory NEWS New NATO defence commitments must notcome at cost of human rights NEWS Gaza: Starvation or gunfire – this is not ahumanitarian response NEWS DRC: Peace deal with Rwanda fails toaddress serious crimes committed ineastern DRC NEWS Gaza: Evidence points to Israel’s continueduse of starvation to inflict genocide againstPalestinians Recently added Cambodia: Scamming crisis survivors must be protected amid police crackdown Ireland: Amnesty’s head urges Irish governmentto press ahead with Occupied Territories Bill Angola: Authorities must respect and ensurethe right to freedom of peaceful assembly Russia: Proposed amendments to counter- extremism laws escalate assault on dissent EU-Israel: Refusal to suspend the EU-IsraelAssociation Agreement is a ‘cruel and unlawful betrayal’ DONATE TO PROTECTHUMAN RIGHTS Women's Day protest in Mexico Together we can fight for human rightseverywhere. Your donation can transform thelives of millions. ABOUT US Contact UsHow We’re RunModern Slavery Act StatementFinances RESOURCES Media CentreHuman Rights EducationHuman Rights CoursesAnnual report archive GET INVOLVED JoinTake ActionVolunteerLATEST NewsCampaignsResearchWORK WITH US If you are talented and passionate about human rights then AmnestyInternational wants to hear fromyou. Privacy Policy From:Aram James To:Martin Wasserman Cc:Veenker, Vicki; Lythcott-Haims, Julie; Reckdahl, Keith; Ed Lauing; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23; Lori Meyers; Sheree Roth; h.etzko@gmail.com; Binder, Andrew; Mark Turner; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; Josh Becker; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Julie Lythcott-Haims; Figueroa, Eric; Doug Minkler; Gerry Gras; EPA Today; Gennady Sheyner; city.council@menlopark.gov; dcombs@menlopark.gov; Steve Wagstaffe; Jeff Rosen; Jeff Conrad; Jeff Hayden; Jay Boyarsky; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas; Mickie Winkler; Sean Allen; Cait James; San José Spotlight; board@pausd.org; boardfeedback@smcgov.org; board@valleywater.org; BoardOperations; Braden Cartwright; Raymond Goins; Rodriguez, Miguel; editor@paweekly.com; Wagner, April; Don Austin; Donna Wallach; Burt, Patrick; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov; Palo Alto Free Press; Seher Awan; Daniel Barton; David Piper; Foley, Michael; Zelkha, Mila; Palo Alto Renters" Association; Diana Diamond; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com; ladoris cordell; cromero@cityofepa.org; rabrica@cityofepa.org; Bill Newell; Bill Johnson; Bill James; Pat M; Carla Torres; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; Council, City; GRP-City Council; Perron, Zachary; City Attorney; citycouncil@mountainview.gov; Clerk, City; GRP- City Clerk; Friends of Cubberley; Lotus Fong; ParkRec Commission; Gardener, Liz; Human Relations Commission; Holman, Karen (external); Liz Kniss; Patrice Ventresca; Rowena Chiu; Dana St. George; Damon Silver; Daniel Kottke; Dennis Upton; Zahra Billoo; james pitkin; Roberta Ahlquist; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Supervisor Otto Lee; Salem Ajluni; Stump, Molly; Rosen, Jeff; Baker, Rob; Ruth Silver Taube; Tom DuBois; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Jasso, Tamara; DuJuan Green; Dennis Upton; dennis burns; Jensen, Eric; Afanasiev, Alex; Lee, Craig; Anna Griffin; Angel, David; Greg Tanaka; Reifschneider, James; Bryan Gobin; Yolanda Conaway; Donna Wallach; Vara Ramakrishnan Subject:Re: Famine Expert: Israel"s Starvation of Gaza Most "Minutely Designed and Controlled" Since WWII Date:Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:28:31 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. The ongoing genocide and war crimes committed by Israel, with the full support of the United States, will eventually be prosecuted in the International Criminal Court in The Hague. This will happen regardless of any alleged actions by Hamas. It is crucial to understand that the ongoing genocide is a separate and distinct crime from the alleged behavior of the group referred to as Hamas (freedom fighters). As Bob Dylan famously said, “You don't need a weatherman to know which way the wind blows.” In a similar vein, you don’t need a genocide expert to recognize that Israel is currently engaged in a massive, full-blown genocide of the Palestinian people. One can offer various intellectual rationalizations, but the reality remains indisputable—the actions of the state of Israel amount to genocide beyond all reasonable doubt. Israel is guilty as charged of war crimes and genocide. Avram “Let The Prosecution Begin” Finkelstein On Tue, Jul 22, 2025 at 10:23 PM Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:The bias of the author is evident in the fact that the entire article mentions Hamasonly once, in passing. Hamas could end the suffering tomorrow just by layingdown their arms and releasing the hostages. But they care more about scoring propaganda points against Israel than about saving the lives of their own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 22, 2025, at 3:08 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Famine Expert: Israel's Starvationof Gaza Most 'Minutely Designedand Controlled' Since WWII Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed andControlled' Since WWII | Common Dreamshttps://www.commondreams.org/news/famine-expert-israel-s-starvation-of-gaza-most-minutely-designed-and-controlled-since-wwii From:Martin Wasserman To:Sean Allen Cc:Aram James; Jeff Rosen; Jay Boyarsky; Veenker, Vicki; h.etzko@gmail.com; jessica@speiser.net; Foley, Michael; GRP-City Council; Raymond Goins; Raj Jayadev;Patrice Ventresca; Figueroa, Eric; Lotus Fong; Reifschneider, James; Binder, Andrew; Gardener, Liz; Diana Diamond; Yolanda Conaway; yolanda; Don Austin;jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com; Human Relations Commission; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; Perron, Zachary; Robert Salonga; Rob Baker; Robert. Jonsen;Roberta Ahlquist; Steve Wagstaffe; Wagner, April; Jeff Conrad; Burt, Patrick; PD Kristina Bell; Bill Newell; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; CouncilmemberChappie Jones; District9@sanjoseca.gov; District4@sanjoseca.gov; District5@sanjoseca.gov; District2@sanjoseca.gov; Today EPA; Gennady Sheyner; Council,City; city.council@menlopark.gov; Vara Ramakrishnan; cromero@cityofepa.org; Cribbs, Anne; michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com; Stump, Molly; board@pausd.org;BoardOperations; Damon Silver; Miguel Rodriguez; Cait James; Josh Becker; Assemblymember.Berman@assembly.ca.gov; Zelkha, Mila; dennis burns; DuJuanGreen; Gerry Gras; Enberg, Nicholas; Rowena Chiu; Barberini, Christopher; Reckdahl, Keith; Dana St. George; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Tom DuBois; Friends ofCubberley; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Greg Tanaka; Bil Barber; Ed Lauing; Yi Chen; Donna Wallach; Mickie Winkler; Supervisor Otto Lee; Mark Turner; CityAttorney; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; Seher Awan; Pat M; Carla Torres; David Piper; Lori Meyers; Sheree Roth; Ellen Fox Subject:Re: Block the Bombs_1_2 sheet Date:Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:05:31 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments andclicking on links. Sean, There's a very popular ideology nowadays, which I'm guessing you subscribe to, that the world would be a better place ifeveryone would give up their national and religious identities and join in a common universal culture. I strongly doubt this willever happen. First, the differences between nations can be so profound that it’s impossible to create a culture acceptable to all.Also, peoples’ identities are very important to them. Asking people to stop being who they are for some nebulous goal of peaceis a definite nonstarter. This is certainly true of Jews. People have been trying to erase Jewish identity for over 3000 years,including some of the most powerful empires in history. As a believing Jew, I believe God has preserved us because he has apurpose for us. And I don't think that purpose is to renounce our connection to Him, lose our identity and live according to otherpeople's dictates. You say Israel lacks humanitarianism toward African refugees. I would argue that Israel’s humanitarianism is second to none.But there's a limit. It's a tiny country surrounded by enemies. It's taken in many African refugees that it didn't have to. But whyis all your criticism directed at tiny Israel when the vast Arab world refuses to do anything at all for these refugees, most ofwhom are their own coreligionists? I’ll also note that the world is a highly competitive place where nations compete for power and domination every single day.Israel knows that it has to fight if it wants to survive. Although it has strong humanitarian instincts, it's primary objective has tobe to maintain its existence and its integrity, and the values that have sustained us as a people for over three millennia. Caringfor the humanitarian needs of strangers, though indeed an important Jewish value, definitely has to be secondary to this. Best,Martin On Jul 21, 2025, at 6:00 PM, Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com> wrote: Hi Martin, Thank you for sharing your thoughts. I understand your perspective on the importance of national security, andyour response highlights my previous point regarding Israel's desire to maintain its purity and identity. Yourremarks seem to support the premise that Israel’s actions promote a sense of exclusivity, prioritizing its nationalidentity over the humanitarian needs of others. Moreover, your position suggesting that Muslims and others should seek assistance outside of Israel reinforces thenotion of maintaining a specific national identity, which further emphasizes purity but also points to discriminationagainst those who don't fit that identity. The refusal to support those seeking refuge can be seen as a troublingaspect of how Israel navigates its humanitarian obligations. Additionally, the United States has a lengthy history of championing humanitarian efforts, being a country built onthe foundation of immigration and diversity. It feels counterintuitive for the U.S. to support nations that do notuphold the same values of compassion and assistance to those in need, especially when taxpayer money isinvolved. The commitment to shared responsibility and collective morality should guide our partnerships and aid. While I appreciate the unique history and culture of the Jewish people, it is possible to uphold national identitywhile also extending compassion and support to those facing perilous situations. Finding a balance between thesevalues is essential for fostering a more inclusive and just society. Looking forward to your thoughts. Best, Sean Sent from my iPhone On Jul 21, 2025, at 5:08 PM, Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote: Sean, Humanitarian values are important, but realistically, national security concerns will always overridethem in virtually any country on Earth. In fact, any nation that puts humanitarianism above its ownnational security interests probably won't be a nation for long. And if we accept the idea that anyperson’s need creates an obligation for others to fulfill that need, the world would very quickly sinkinto chaos. Regarding African refugees in Israel, it's a testimony to Israel’s humanitarianism that these refugees,mostly Muslims, know they'll receive more compassionate care in the one Jewish state than in anyArab or Muslim state. Nevertheless, Israel is a very small country, and it's also the nation state of theJewish people, a people with their own unique religion, language, and culture and a very long history.If it opened its gates to everyone who was in need, it would quickly be swamped, and would no longerbe the nation state of the Jewish people. Israel is not going to compromise its national identity, and it'sunreasonable to think that it should, for the sake of helping strangers who have no particularconnection to Jews or Judaism. Best,Martin On Jul 21, 2025, at 12:03 PM, Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com> wrote: Martin, I appreciate your perspective on the complexities of national security and humanitarianobligations. However, it's crucial to recognize that viewing civilians as "enemies" can leadto a dangerous precedent where humanitarian needs are disregarded in the name ofsecurity. In both the case of African asylum-seekers and Palestinians in Gaza, the individualsaffected are often civilians who are fleeing violence, persecution, or dire living conditions.They should not be categorized merely as "enemy civilians," as this oversimplifies themultifaceted nature of conflict and ignores their humanity. Treating any civilianpopulation as an enemy undermines the basic principles of international humanitarian law,which emphasize the protection of non-combatants in conflict situations. The actions of Israel toward African asylum-seekers further illustrate this point. In theface of significant geopolitical and humanitarian challenges, Israel has opted to deportEritrean and Sudanese asylum-seekers, often leaving them vulnerable to persecution inthird countries, demonstrating a troubling pattern of prioritizing security measures overhumanitarian responsibilities. Like the civilians in Gaza, these asylum-seekers are fleeingperilous situations; thus, their humanity should be recognized regardless of thecircumstances surrounding their migration. Regarding your historical references, while it is true that during times of war, nations havemade decisions that prioritize military objectives, it's essential to acknowledge that themoral implications of such decisions have evolved. The international communityincreasingly recognizes the importance of humanitarian considerations even amid conflict.Ignoring humanitarian needs, particularly of vulnerable populations, can perpetuate cyclesof violence and instability that ultimately harm national interests in the long run. Additionally, while you mention Israeli perspectives on Gazan civilians voting for Hamas,it's critical to understand that many civilians may have done so under coercive conditionsor without the full capacity to consider the implications of their choices. Many Gazans are indeed caught in a cycle of violence, facing repercussions for the decisions made byleadership they may not support. You also note Israel's earlier actions to facilitate the entry of food and supplies into Gaza.However, the effectiveness and sufficiency of this aid must be contextualized against thewider backdrop of blockades and military operations that significantly restrict access toessential services, creating a humanitarian crisis. In summary, while national security is undoubtedly critical, it should not come at the costof abandoning the fundamental human rights and dignity of civilians caught in conflict.The tragic plight of those affected by violence—whether they are asylum-seekers orcivilians in Gaza—demands a compassionate and just approach that acknowledges theirhumanity. Is the refusal to recognize the humanity of these individuals truly an acceptablestance in the pursuit of security, or is it more about maintaining purity? Regards, Sean Sent from my iPhone On Jul 21, 2025, at 10:31 AM, Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com>wrote: Sean, I appreciate your concern for humanitarian issues. However, the reality is thatwhen a nation is fighting for its very existence, as Israel is doing right now,its highest priority has to be to defeat the enemy, and caring for thehumanitarian needs of enemy civilians has to be a much lower priority. In fact, most nations would ridicule the idea of helping enemy civilians whilea war is ongoing, arguing that it’s equivalent to helping the enemy himself. During World War II, for example, the overriding imperative was victory,and the US showed no concern for the humanitarian well-being of the enemycivilians it was bombing, nor did any other nation involved in that conflict.Humanitarian concerns could be addressed after the war, but not during it. It’s also worth noting that Israelis don't necessarily see Gazan civilians asinnocent bystanders. They remember how they voted Hamas into power, andhow many of them followed Hamas into Israel on October 7 and took directpart in the plunder and pillage of that day. They also recall the outbursts ofdelirious joy as the Israeli hostages were paraded through the streets of Gaza,and how not a single Gazan did anything to help the Israeli hostages escapefrom their captivity. Nevertheless, Israel has shown more concern for humanitarian issues thanvirtually any other country in a similar situation. Earlier in the war, it allowedhuge amounts of food and supplies into Gaza, even though it knew that mostof the aid was being stolen by Hamas, thereby prolonging the war and makingvictory more difficult to achieve. Incidentally, there were many in Israel whothought this policy was very foolish and highly counterproductive. Regards,Martin Wasserman On Jul 20, 2025, at 8:34 PM, Sean Allen<sallen6444@yahoo.com> wrote: Martin, Thank you for sharing your perspective. While it's important toconsider the complex dynamics at play, the impact of rationingfood and resources cannot be overlooked. Limiting access tobasic necessities can lead to dire consequences for the civilianpopulation, contributing to significant suffering and hardship,irrespective of intent. Historically, we have seen that during crises, people instinctivelyfight and even resort to violence over limited resources. This wasevident in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina in the UnitedStates, where widespread desperation for food, water, and safetyled to chaos and alarming acts of violence. Reports from thattime highlighted how individuals looted stores and clashed witheach other as they scrambled for basic survival needs,demonstrating how fragile social order can become whenresources are scarce. Similarly, in Somalia, we witnessedviolence surrounding the distribution of humanitarian aid, asfactions vied for control over the resources being provided tothose in need. Rationing food and resources has the potential to produceoutcomes that are as devastating as direct violence, akin to theeffects of bombing a population. Furthermore, military unitsshould never base their decisions to slaughter non-combatants onthe basis that their opposition does not release hostages,regardless of the justification for conflict. Unless the motive is tocreate more chaos through infighting, which would lead tosimilar devastation as bombing non-combatant communities, thehumane approach is to provide these individuals with thenecessary amount of humanitarian aid and stop the slaughter.Bombing non-combatants is not war; it’s slaughter andinhumane. Even our Constitution prohibits punishing a group ofpeople because of the actions of others. While military objectives may focus on specific groups, we mustrecognize that the broader impact on civilian lives remainsprofound. The suffering of Gazans should not be diminished oroverlooked, as their well-being is affected by the decisions madein the context of this conflict. Best, Sean Allen Sent from my iPhone On Jul 20, 2025, at 3:30 PM, Aram James<abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Condemn Israel or be complicit in genocide': Colombia's Gustavo Petro By Al Mayadeen English Source: The Guardian 8 Jul 2025 13:47 2 Shares 4 Min Read Colombian President Gustavo Petro, in a Guardian op-ed, accuses Netanyahu of genocide in Gaza and urges global action. Listen On Tuesday, The Guardian published an opinion piece by Colombian President Gustavo Petro, in which he accused Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of orchestrating a "campaign of devastation" in Gaza and called on the international community to move beyond symbolic outrage toward concrete action in defense of international law. Petro has emerged as one of the most outspoken world leaders condemning "Israel’s" war on Gaza, and his latest opinion piece adds to a growing series of forceful critiques directed at the ongoing Israeli genocide. Denouncing what he described as 600 days of systematic atrocities, Petro wrote that the world's inaction risks legitimizing a model of impunity where colonial violence, ethnic cleansing, and siege warfare are normalized against a captive population. "If we fail to act now," he wrote, "we not only betray the Palestinian people, we become complicit in the atrocities committed by Netanyahu's government." Moral break The president highlighted a landmark United Nations General Assembly resolution adopted in September 2024, which called for "Israel" to end its illegal occupation within 12 months. He noted that Colombia was among the 124 countries that voted in favor, thereby assuming binding obligations that include sanctions, legal action, and trade measures. "The clock is now ticking," he warned, reaffirming Colombia's commitment by recalling its concrete step: suspending coal exports to "Israel." Related News 650 days of genocide: 125,000 tons of bombs 2.4 mln lives shattered Starved by 'Israel': People of Gaza are dying while the world watches In his piece, Petro mentioned that he had declared earlier this year: "We cannot fuel the machinery that slaughters Palestinian children and then claim neutrality." This is not the first bold move by the Colombian president. In May, his government formally cut diplomatic ties with "Israel," citing what Petro explicitly described as a "genocide." His administration also appointed Colombia’s first ambassador to Palestine, pledging medical treatment in Colombian hospitals for injured children from Gaza. The newly appointed ambassador, Jorge Iván Ospina, later echoed Petro’s position, warning of a "macabre intention to erase the identity of a people." In Tuesday's article, Petro praised similar actions taken by countries like Malaysia, which banned Israeli ships from its ports, and South Africa, which brought "Israel" before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) on charges of genocide. It is worth noting that Colombia joined that case as an intervening party, further deepening its legal opposition to "Israel's" war. Read more: US defends Israeli use of starvation as weapon of war before ICJ Global reckoning Looking ahead, Petro mentioned that Colombia and South Africa, co-chairs of the Hague Group, will host an emergency summit regarding Gaza on July 15. The conference aims to develop a coordinated, multilateral strategy to isolate "Israel" diplomatically and economically while restoring credibility to the global legal order. With the UN's proposed international peace conference indefinitely postponed, Petro cast the July summit as a necessary corrective to global paralysis. The Colombian president framed the Gaza crisis not just as a moral catastrophe but as an existential test for international law and nations of the Global South. "We can either stand firm in defense of the legal principles that seek to prevent war and conflict," he wrote, "or watch helplessly as the international system collapses under the weight of unchecked power politics." He concluded his piece by stressing that the choice is between complicity in colonial violence and collective resistance against it. On Sun, Jul 20, 2025 at 3:12 PM Martin Wasserman<deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:Aram, Amnesty International is not a credible source onthis issue. It appears that the once-respectableorganization has been taken over by malevolentactors with a political axe to grind. Their anti-Israel bias is evident throughout the report. They accuse Israel of genocide but make nomention at all of Hamas’ explicit genocidal policyagainst Jews. They accuse Israel of violating international law,but make no reference at all to the fact that Israelis facing a ruthless enemy that observes nointernational laws whatsoever. When they mention Hamas’ transgressions at all,they do it in the mildest language possible, andthen use the most damning possible languagewhen describing Israel's actions. They take it as a given that Israel is an apartheidstate, a blatantly false accusation that is very easilydisproved. They take it as a given that Israel is illegallyoccupying Palestinian land, as if the territories ofJudea and Samaria, the heartland of the ancientJewish nation, don't belong to Jews at all, but areinstead the property of a fictitious country called“Palestine” which has never actually existed in anyhistorical period. In short, this entire report is a politically motivated“hatchet job” that deserves no credibilitywhatsoever. Martin Wasserman On Jul 20, 2025, at 11:39 AM, AramJames <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Amnesty Internationalinvestigation concludesIsrael is committinggenocide againstPalestinians in Gaza Amnesty International’s research has found sufficient basis to conclude that Israel has committed and is continuing tocommit genocide against Palestinians in the occupied GazaStrip, the organization said in a landmark new reportpublished today. The report, ‘You Feel Like You Are Subhuman’: Israel’sGenocide Against Palestinians in Gaza, documents how,during its military offensive launched in the wake of thedeadly Hamas-led attacks in southern Israel on 7 October 2023, Israel has unleashed hell and destruction onPalestinians in Gaza brazenly, continuously and with total impunity. “Amnesty International’s report demonstrates that Israel hascarried out acts prohibited under the Genocide Convention, with the specific intent to destroy Palestinians in Gaza. These actsinclude killings, causing serious bodily or mental harm anddeliberately inflicting on Palestinians in Gaza conditions of lifecalculated to bring about their physical destruction. Month aftermonth, Israel has treated Palestinians in Gaza as a subhuman group unworthy of human rights and dignity, demonstrating itsintent to physically destroy them,” said Agnès Callamard,Secretary General of Amnesty International. “Our damning findings must serve as a wake-up call to theinternational community: this is genocide. It must stop now. “States that continue to transfer arms to Israel at this timemust know they are violating their obligation to preventgenocide and are at risk of becoming complicit in genocide. All states with influence over Israel, particularly key armssuppliers like the USA and Germany, but also other EU member states, the UK and others, must act now to bringIsrael’s atrocities against Palestinians in Gaza to animmediate end.” Over the past two months the crisis has grown particularly acute in the North Gaza governorate, where a besiegedpopulation is facing starvation, displacement andannihilation amid relentless bombardment and suffocating restrictions on life-saving humanitarian aid. “Our research reveals that, for months, Israel has persisted incommitting genocidal acts, fully aware of the irreparable harm itwas inflicting on Palestinians in Gaza. It continued to do so indefiance of countless warnings about the catastrophic humanitarian situation and of legally binding decisions from theInternational Court of Justice (ICJ) ordering Israel to takeimmediate measures to enable the provision of humanitarian assistance to civilians in Gaza,” said Agnès Callamard. “Israel has repeatedly argued that its actions in Gaza are lawful and can be justified by its military goal to eradicateHamas. But genocidal intent can co-exist alongside militarygoals and does not need to be Israel’s sole intent.” Amnesty International examined Israel’s acts in Gazaclosely and in their totality, taking into account theirrecurrence and simultaneous occurrence, and both theirimmediate impact and their cumulative and mutuallyreinforcing consequences. The organization considered the scale and severity of the casualties and destruction overtime. It also analysed public statements by officials, findingthat prohibited acts were often announced or called for in the first place by high-level officials in charge of the warefforts. “Taking into account the pre-existing context of dispossession,apartheid and unlawful military occupation in which these actshave been committed, we could find only one reasonable conclusion: Israel’s intent is the physical destruction ofPalestinians in Gaza, whether in parallel with, or as a means toachieve, its military goal of destroying Hamas,” said AgnèsCallamard. “The atrocity crimes committed on 7 October 2023 by Hamas and other armed groups against Israelis and victimsof other nationalities, including deliberate mass killings andhostage-taking, can never justify Israel’s genocide against Palestinians in Gaza.” International jurisprudence recognizes that the perpetrator does not need to succeed in their attempts to destroy theprotected group, either in whole or in part, for genocide tohave been committed. The commission of prohibited acts with the intent to destroy the group, as such, is sufficient. Amnesty International’s report examines in detail Israel’s violations in Gaza over nine months between 7 October2023 and early July 2024. The organization interviewed 212people, including Palestinian victims and witnesses, local authorities in Gaza, healthcare workers, conducted fieldworkand analysed an extensive range of visual and digitalevidence, including satellite imagery. It also analysedstatements by senior Israeli government and militaryofficials, and official Israeli bodies. On multiple occasions, the organization shared its findings with the Israeliauthorities but had received no substantive response at thetime of publication. Unprecedented scale and magnitude Israel’s actions following Hamas’s deadly attacks on 7 October 2023 have brought Gaza’s population to the brinkof collapse. Its brutal military offensive had killed more than42,000 Palestinians, including over 13,300 children, and injured over 97,000 more, by 7 October 2024, many of themin direct or deliberately indiscriminate attacks, often wiping out entire multigenerational families. It has causedunprecedented destruction, which experts say occurred at alevel and speed not seen in any other conflict in the 21st century, levelling entire cities and destroying criticalinfrastructure, agricultural land and cultural and religioussites. It thereby rendered large swathes of Gazauninhabitable. Mohammed, who fled with his family from Gaza City to Rafah in March 2024 and was displaced again in May 2024,described their struggle to survive in horrifying conditions: “Here in Deir al-Balah, it’s like an apocalypse… You have toprotect your children from insects, from the heat, and thereis no clean water, no toilets, all while the bombing never stops. You feel like you are subhuman here.” Israel imposed conditions of life in Gaza that created adeadly mixture of malnutrition, hunger and diseases, and exposed Palestinians to a slow, calculated death. Israel alsosubjected hundreds of Palestinians from Gaza to incommunicado detention, torture and other ill-treatment. Viewed in isolation, some of the acts investigated byAmnesty International constitute serious violations of international humanitarian law or international human rightslaw. But in looking at the broader picture of Israel’s military campaign and the cumulative impact of its policies and acts,genocidal intent is the only reasonable conclusion. Intent to destroy To establish Israel’s specific intent to physically destroyPalestinians in Gaza, as such, Amnesty Internationalanalysed the overall pattern of Israel’s conduct in Gaza,reviewed dehumanizing and genocidal statements by Israeli government and military officials, particularly those at thehighest levels, and considered the context of Israel’s systemof apartheid, its inhumane blockade of Gaza and the unlawful 57-year-old military occupation of the Palestinianterritory. Before reaching its conclusion, Amnesty Internationalexamined Israel’s claims that its military lawfully targetedHamas and other armed groups throughout Gaza, and that the resulting unprecedented destruction and denial of aidwere the outcome of unlawful conduct by Hamas and otherarmed groups, such as locating fighters among the civilianpopulation or the diversion of aid. The organizationconcluded these claims are not credible. The presence of Hamas fighters near or within a densely populated areadoes not absolve Israel from its obligations to take allfeasible precautions to spare civilians and avoid indiscriminate or disproportionate attacks. Its research foundIsrael repeatedly failed to do so, committing multiple crimesunder international law for which there can be nojustification based on Hamas’s actions. AmnestyInternational also found no evidence that the diversion of aid could explain Israel’s extreme and deliberate restrictions on life-saving humanitarian aid. In its analysis, the organization also considered alternativearguments such as ones that Israel was acting recklessly or that it simply wanted to destroy Hamas and did not care if itneeded to destroy Palestinians in the process,demonstrating a callous disregard for their lives rather thangenocidal intent. Our damning findings must serve as a wake-up call to the international community: this isgenocide. It must stop now. Agnès Callamard, Amnesty International However, regardless of whether Israel sees the destruction of Palestinians as instrumental to destroying Hamas or asan acceptable by-product of this goal, this view of Palestinians as disposable and not worthy of considerationis in itself evidence of genocidal intent. Many of the unlawful acts documented by Amnesty International were preceded by officials urging theirimplementation. The organization reviewed 102 statements that were issued by Israeli government and military officialsand others between 7 October 2023 and 30 June 2024 anddehumanized Palestinians, called for or justified genocidal acts or other crimes against them. Of these, Amnesty International identified 22 statementsmade by senior officials in charge of managing the offensivethat appeared to call for, or justify, genocidal acts, providingdirect evidence of genocidal intent. This language was frequently replicated, including by Israeli soldiers on theground, as evidenced by audiovisual content verified byAmnesty International showing soldiers making calls to “erase” Gaza or to make it uninhabitable, and celebratingthe destruction of Palestinian homes, mosques, schools anduniversities. Killing and causing serious bodily ormental harm Amnesty International documented the genocidal acts of killing and causing serious mental and bodily harm toPalestinians in Gaza by reviewing the results ofinvestigations it conducted into 15 air strikes between 7 October 2023 and 20 April 2024 that killed at least 334civilians, including 141 children, and wounded hundreds ofothers. Amnesty International found no evidence that any of these strikes were directed at a military objective. In one illustrative case, on 20 April 2024, an Israeli air strike destroyed the Abdelal family house in the Al-Jneinahneighbourhood in eastern Rafah, killing three generations ofPalestinians, including 16 children, while they were sleeping. While these represent just a fraction of Israel’s aerial attacks, they are indicative of a broader pattern of repeateddirect attacks on civilians and civilian objects or deliberatelyindiscriminate attacks. The attacks were also conducted in ways designed to cause a very high number of fatalities and injuries among the civilian population. Inflicting conditions of life calculatedto bring about physical destruction The report documents how Israel deliberately inflictedconditions of life on Palestinians in Gaza intended to lead, over time, to their destruction. These conditions wereimposed through three simultaneous patterns thatrepeatedly compounded the effect of each other’s devastating impacts: damage to and destruction of life-sustaining infrastructure and other objects indispensable to the survival of the civilian population; the repeated use ofsweeping, arbitrary and confusing mass “evacuation” ordersto forcibly displace almost all of Gaza’s population; and the denial and obstruction of the delivery of essential services,humanitarian assistance and other life-saving supplies intoand within Gaza. After 7 October 2023, Israel imposed a total siege on Gazacutting off electricity, water and fuel. In the nine months reviewed for this report, Israel maintained a suffocating,unlawful blockade, tightly controlled access to energysources, failed to facilitate meaningful humanitarian access within Gaza, and obstructed the import and delivery of life-saving goods and humanitarian aid, particularly to areas north of Wadi Gaza. They thereby exacerbated an alreadyexisting humanitarian crisis. This, combined with theextensive damage to Gaza’s homes, hospitals, water and sanitation facilities and agricultural land, and mass forceddisplacement, caused catastrophic levels of hunger and ledto the spread of diseases at alarming rates. The impact was especially harsh on young children and pregnant orbreastfeeding women, with anticipated long-term consequences for their health. The international community’s seismic,shameful failure for over a year to pressIsrael to end its atrocities in Gaza, by first delaying calls for a ceasefire and thencontinuing arms transfers, is and will remaina stain on our collective conscience.Agnès Callamard, Amnesty International Time and again, Israel had the chance to improve the humanitarian situation in Gaza, yet for over a year it hasrepeatedly refused to take steps blatantly within its power todo so, such as opening sufficient access points to Gaza or lifting tight restrictions on what could enter the Strip or theirobstruction of aid deliveries within Gaza while the situation has grown progressively worse. Through its repeated “evacuation” orders Israel displacednearly 1.9 million Palestinians – 90% of Gaza’s population – into ever-shrinking, unsafe pockets of land under inhumaneconditions, some of them up to 10 times. These multiple waves of forced displacement left many jobless and deeplytraumatized, especially since some 70% of Gaza’s residentsare refugees or descendants of refugees whose towns and villages were ethnically cleansed by Israel during the 1948Nakba. Despite conditions quickly becoming unfit for human life, Israeli authorities refused to consider measures that would have protected displaced civilians and ensured their basicneeds were met, showing that their actions were deliberate. They refused to allow those displaced to return to their homes in northern Gaza or relocate temporarily to otherparts of the Occupied Palestinian Territory or Israel,continuing to deny many Palestinians their right to returnunder international law to areas they were displaced from in 1948. They did so knowing that there was nowhere safe for Palestinians in Gaza to flee to. Accountability for genocide “The international community’s seismic, shameful failure forover a year to press Israel to end its atrocities in Gaza, by first delaying calls for a ceasefire and then continuing armstransfers, is and will remain a stain on our collectiveconscience,” said Agnès Callamard. “Governments must stop pretending they are powerless toend this genocide, which was enabled by decades of impunity for Israel’s violations of international law. Statesneed to move beyond mere expressions of regret or dismayand take strong and sustained international action, however uncomfortable a finding of genocide may be for some ofIsrael’s allies. “The International Criminal Court’s (ICC) arrest warrants forPrime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former DefenseMinister Yoav Gallant for war crimes and crimes against humanity issued last month offer real hope of long-overduejustice for victims. States must demonstrate their respect forthe court’s decision and for universal international law principles by arresting and handing over those wanted bythe ICC. “We are calling on the Office of the Prosecutor of theInternational Criminal Court (ICC) to urgently consideradding genocide to the list of crimes it is investigating and for all states to use every legal avenue to bring perpetratorsto justice. No one should be allowed to commit genocideand remain unpunished.” Amnesty International is also calling for all civilian hostagesto be released unconditionally and for Hamas and other Palestinian armed groups responsible for the crimescommitted on 7 October to be held to account. The organization is also calling for the UN Security Councilto impose targeted sanctions against Israeli and Hamasofficials most implicated in crimes under international law. Background On 7 October 2023 Hamas and other armed groups indiscriminately fired rockets into southern Israel and carried out deliberate mass killings and hostage-takingthere, killing 1,200 people, including over 800 civilians, andabducted 223 civilians and captured 27 soldiers. The crimesperpetrated by Hamas and other armed groups during this attack will be the focus of a forthcoming AmnestyInternational report. Since October 2023, Amnesty International has conducted in- depth investigations into the multiple violations and crimes underinternational law committed by Israeli forces, including directattacks on civilians and civilian objects and deliberatelyindiscriminate attacks killing hundreds of civilians, as well asother unlawful attacks on and collective punishment of the civilian population. The organization has called on the Office of the ICCProsecutor to expedite its investigation into the situation in theState of Palestine and is campaigning for an immediate ceasefire. For the Hebrew translation of this press release, click here. INTERNATIONAL JUSTICE ISRAEL AND THE OCCUPIED PALESTINIAN TERRITORY MIDDLE EAST MIDDLE EAST AND NORTH AFRICA NEWS PRESS RELEASE WAR CRIMES AND CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY Related Content COUNTRY Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territory NEWS New NATO defence commitments must notcome at cost of human rights NEWS Gaza: Starvation or gunfire – this is not ahumanitarian response NEWS DRC: Peace deal with Rwanda fails toaddress serious crimes committed ineastern DRC NEWS Gaza: Evidence points to Israel’s continueduse of starvation to inflict genocide againstPalestinians Recently added Cambodia: Scamming crisis survivors must be protected amid police crackdown Ireland: Amnesty’s head urges Irish governmentto press ahead with Occupied Territories Bill Angola: Authorities must respect and ensure the right to freedom of peaceful assembly Russia: Proposed amendments to counter-extremism laws escalate assault on dissent EU-Israel: Refusal to suspend the EU-IsraelAssociation Agreement is a ‘cruel and unlawfulbetrayal’ DONATE TO PROTECTHUMAN RIGHTS Women's Day protest in Mexico Together we can fight for human rights everywhere. Your donation can transform thelives of millions. ABOUT US Contact UsHow We’re Run Modern Slavery Act StatementFinancesRESOURCES Media Centre Human Rights EducationHuman Rights CoursesAnnual report archiveGET INVOLVED JoinTake Action Volunteer LATEST News CampaignsResearchWORK WITH US If you are talented and passionate about human rights then AmnestyInternational wants to hear from you. Privacy PolicyAccessibilityCookie StatementPermissionsRefunds of Donations © 2025 Amnesty International FOLLOW US ON:Facebook Instagram X TikTok Bluesky YouTube LinkedIn On Sun, Jul 20, 2025 at 10:03 AMMartin Wasserman<deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:Aram, If that's the definition of genocide,then Israel is clearly NOTcommitting genocide in Gaza. IfIsrael were trying to kill as manyGazans as possible, the death tollwould be much, much higher than itis. They wouldn't allow any food ormedicine in at all, and they wouldn'tissue evacuation warnings beforestriking Hamas targets. The truth is, Israel goes to greatlengths to avoid civilian casualties,but Hamas makes it very difficult bydeliberately placing their commandcenters in civilian locations such asschools and hospitals. The only group that Israel wants todestroy is Hamas, which does havean explicit policy of genocide (byyour definition) against Jews. Yes, the Gazans are suffering, butHamas could end their suffering tomorrow if they wanted to. Allthey have to do is lay down theirarms and release the hostages, andthe war would be over immediately.But Hamas has no interest in endingthe suffering of the Gazans. Whatthey're actually calling for is anopen-ended war of attrition againstIsrael, no matter what the cost totheir own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 18, 2025, at8:26 PM, Aram James<abjpd1@gmail.com>wrote: Genocide defined: the deliberate killing of a large number ofpeople from a particular nation or ethnic group with the aim of destroying that nation or group. "a campaign of genocide" On Fri, Jul 18, 2025 at4:04 PM MartinWasserman<deeperlook@aol.com>wrote:It appears that"genocide" can be defined in severaldifferent ways.Perhaps we shouldstop using that term altogether andstick to words thathave clear andunambiguous meanings. On Jul18, 2025,at12:25 PM, AramJames<abjpd1@gmail.com>wrote: I’m a Genocide Scholar. I Know It When I See It”: Prof. Omer Bartov on the Growing Consensus on Gaza My inescapable conclusion has become that Israel is committing genocide against the Palestinian people. Having grown up in a Zionist home, lived the first half of my life in Israel, served in the I.D.F. as a soldier and officer and spent most of my career researching and writing on war crimes and the Holocaust, this was a painful conclusion to reach, and one that I resisted as long as I could. But I have been teaching classes on genocide for a quarter of a century. I can recognize one when I see one A month after the Hamas attack on Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, I believed there was evidence that the Israeli military had committed war crimes and potentially crimes against humanity in its counterattack on Gaza. But contrary to the cries of Israel’s fiercest critics, the evidence did not seem to me to rise to the crime of genocide. By May 2024, the Israel Defense Forces had ordered about one million Palestinians sheltering in Rafah — the southernmost and last remaining relatively undamaged city of the Gaza Strip — to move to the beach area of the Mawasi, where there was little to no shelter. The army then proceeded to destroy much of Rafah, a feat mostly accomplished by August. At that point it appeared no longer possible to deny that the pattern of I.D.F. operations was consistent with the statements denoting genocidal intent made by Israeli leaders in the days after the Hamas attack. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had promised that the enemy would pay a “huge price” for the attack and that the I.D.F. would turn parts of Gaza, where Hamas was operating, “into rubble,” and he called on “the residents of Gaza” to “leave now because we will operate forcefully everywhere.” Mr. Netanyahu had urged his citizens to remember “what Amalek did to you,” a quote many interpreted as a reference to the demand in a biblical passage calling for the Israelites to “kill alike men and women, infants and sucklings” of their ancient enemy. Government and military officials said they were fighting “human animals” and, later, called for “total annihilation.” Nissim Vaturi, the deputy speaker of Parliament, said on Xthat Israel’s task must be “erasing the Gaza Strip from the face of the earth.” Israel’s actions could be understood only as the implementation of the expressed intent to make the Gaza Strip uninhabitable for its Palestinian population. I believe the goal was — and remains today — to force the population to leave the Strip altogether or, considering that it has nowhere to go, to debilitate the enclave through bombings and severe deprivation of food, clean water, sanitation and medical aid to such an extent that it is impossible for Palestinians in Gaza to maintain or reconstitute their existence as a group. ADVERTISEMENT SKIP ADVERTISEMENT My inescapable conclusion has become that Israel is committing genocide against the Palestinian people. Having grown up in a Zionist home, lived the first half of my life in Israel, served in the I.D.F. as a soldier and officer and spent most of my career researching and writing on war crimes and the Holocaust, this was a painful conclusion to reach, and one that I resisted as long as I could. But I have been teaching classes on genocide for a quarter of a century. I can recognize one when I see one. This is not just my conclusion. A growing number of experts in genocide studies and international law have concluded that Israel’s actions in Gaza can only be defined as genocide. So has Francesca Albanese, the U.N. special rapporteur for the West Bank and Gaza, and Amnesty International. South Africa has brought a genocide case against Israel at the International Court of Justice.ImagePeople inspecting a huge pile of rubble. Credit...Jehad Alshrafi/Associat edPress The continued denial of this designation by states, international organizations and legal and scholarly experts will cause unmitigated damage not just to the people of Gaza and Israel but also to the system of international law established in the wake of the horrors of the Holocaust, designed to prevent such atrocities from happening ever again. It is a threat to the very foundations of the moral order on which we all depend.*** The crime of genocide was defined in 1948 by the United Nations as the “intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such.” In determining what constitutes genocide, therefore, we must both establish intent and show that it is being carried out. In Israel’s case, that intent has been publicly expressed by numerous officials and leaders. But intent can also be derived from a pattern of operations on the ground, and this pattern became clear by May 2024 — and has since become ever clearer — as the I.D.F. has systematically destroyed the Gaza Strip. ADVERTISEM ENT SKIPADVERTISEMENT Most genocide scholars are cautious about applying this term to contemporary events, precisely because of the tendency, since it was coined by the Jewish-Polish lawyer Raphael Lemkin in 1944, to attribute it to any case of massacre or inhumanity. Indeed, some argue that the categorization should be entirely discarded, because it often serves more to express outrage than to identify a particular crime. Yet as Mr. Lemkin recognized, and as the United Nations later agreed, it is crucial to be able to distinguish the attempt to destroy a particular group of people from other crimes under international law, such as war crimes and crimes against humanity. This is because, while other crimes entail indiscriminate or deliberate killing of civilians as individuals, genocide denotes the killing of people as members of a group, geared at irreparably destroying the group itself so that it would never be able to reconstitute itself as a political, social or cultural entity. And, as the international community signaled by adopting the convention, it is incumbent upon all signatory states to prevent such an attempt, to do all they can to stop it while it is occurring and to subsequently punish those who were engaged in this crime of crimes — even if it occurred within the borders of a sovereign state. The designation has major political, legal and moral ramifications. Nations, politicians and military personnel suspected of, indicted on a charge of or found guilty of genocide are seen as beyond the pale of humanity and may compromise or lose their right to remain members of the international community. A finding by the International Court of Justice that a particular state is engaged in genocide, especially if enforced by the U.N. Security Council, can lead to severe sanctions. Sign up for the Opinion Today newsletter Get expert analysis of the news and a guide to the big ideas shaping the world every weekday morning. Get it sent to your inbox. Politicians or generals indicted on a charge of or found guilty of genocide or other breaches of international humanitarian law by the International Criminal Court can face arrest outside of their country. And a society that condones and is complicit in genocide, whatever the stand of its individual citizens may be, will carry this mark of Cain long after the fires of hatred and violence are put out.*** From:Gregory Bell To:Council, City Subject:City Council: missed opportunity; we need to show more EV cars at city events Date:Tuesday, July 22, 2025 4:03:49 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. i City Event:Displaying only 4 models EV of 60+ 2025 EV's is far too few. I was so surprised the upcoming EV show at the municipality yard will only have three or four EV cars. I've been displaying my car(s) at EV shows for 7+ years and I've found a min of 10cars brings people over to take a look because it's a solid representation of EV's in the market. Given there are more than 60 EV models available, shoppers may think they are only a fewavailable to buy. We know there are more, but the general public may not. I am totally convinced for these reasons we need to have at least 10 EV's to make it worth a potential EVbuyer's time to stop by and have a look. Let me know your thoughts, seems there's enough physical space in the huge municipality yard. You can expand available parking, then ask more EV drivers and I'm sure you'll get 10cars on display by the weekend, July 26, 2025. Greg Bell. ——Make your home more comfortable & reduce your energy bill. I type less and talk more by phone. Greg M. Bell —— This message needs your attention This is a personal email address. This is their first email to you. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast From:Aram James To:Veenker, Vicki; Lythcott-Haims, Julie Cc:Reckdahl, Keith; Ed Lauing; Jessica Speiser, Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23; Lori Meyers; Sheree Roth; h.etzko@gmail.com; Binder, Andrew; Mark Turner; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; Josh Becker; assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Julie Lythcott-Haims; Figueroa, Eric; Doug Minkler; Gerry Gras; Dave Price; EPA Today; Gennady Sheyner; city.council@menlopark.gov; Nash, Betsy; dcombs@menlopark.gov; Steve Wagstaffe; Jeff Rosen; Jeff Conrad; Jeff Hayden; Jay Boyarsky; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Enberg, Nicholas; Mickie Winkler; Marty Wasserman; Tim James; Sean Allen; Cait James; San José Spotlight; board@pausd.org; boardfeedback@smcgov.org; board@valleywater.org; BoardOperations; Braden Cartwright; Raymond Goins; Rodriguez, Miguel; Emily Mibach; editor@paweekly.com; Wagner, April; Don Austin; Donna Wallach; Freddie.Quintana@sen.ca.gov; Burt, Patrick; Patricia.Guerrero@jud.ca.gov; Palo Alto Free Press; Seher Awan; Daniel Barton; David Piper; Foley, Michael; Zelkha, Mila; Palo Alto Renters" Association; Diana Diamond; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com; ladoris cordell; cromero@cityofepa.org; rabrica@cityofepa.org; Bill Newell; Bill Johnson; Bill James; Pat M; Carla Torres; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; Council, City; GRP-City Council; Perron, Zachary; City Attorney; citycouncil@mountainview.gov; Clerk, City; GRP-City Clerk; Friends of Cubberley; Lotus Fong; planning.commission@cityofpaloalto.0rg; ParkRec Commission; Gardener, Liz; Human Relations Commission; Holman, Karen (external); Liz Kniss; Patrice Ventresca; Rowena Chiu; Dana St. George; Damon Silver; Daniel Kottke; Dennis Upton; Zahra Billoo; james pitkin; Roberta Ahlquist; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Supervisor Otto Lee; Salem Ajluni; Stump, Molly; Rosen, Jeff; Baker, Rob; Ruth Silver Taube; Tom DuBois; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Jasso, Tamara; DuJuan Green; Dennis Upton; dennis burns; Jensen, Eric; Afanasiev, Alex; Lee, Craig; Anna Griffin; Angel, David; Greg Tanaka; Reifschneider, James; Bryan Gobin; Yolanda Conaway; Donna Wallach; Vara Ramakrishnan Subject:Famine Expert: Israel"s Starvation of Gaza Most "Minutely Designed and Controlled" Since WWII Date:Tuesday, July 22, 2025 3:09:41 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking on links. Famine Expert: Israel's Starvationof Gaza Most 'Minutely Designedand Controlled' Since WWII Famine Expert: Israel's Starvation of Gaza Most 'Minutely Designed and Controlled' SinceWWII | Common Dreams https://www.commondreams.org/news/famine-expert-israel-s- starvation-of-gaza-most-minutely-designed-and-controlled-since-wwii From:David Page To:Sustainability Email; Council, City Cc:Sherry Listgarten Subject:“natural” gas rates Date:Tuesday, July 22, 2025 2:56:26 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. i Dear Council Members, I'd like to comment on proposed methane rate hikes. If you're sincere about severely reducing greenhouse gases and local pollution, you'd move toeliminate unnatural gas from utility service offerings. But popular opinion would be against this. The Council has failed to come up with a decent compromise on the matter since at least 2005-when the Palo Alto Green Ribbon Task Force report was released. Getting residents to switch from using gas to using electricity could be done by gradually raising rates on gas every year, while annually lowering rates on electricity. But thishasn't happened. So, what to do? In my opinion, residents are generally unaware of the dangers and drawbacks regarding the production and burning of methane. How much would it cost to create a public awareness campaign about the lethal consequencesinvolved with the gas? Why not send out a flyer - with every monthly bill - including information about the ugly impacts methane has on local and global health? To shift public opinion, understanding is needed. There are people at Stanford who areknowledgeable about this; let them help. Thank you very much,David Page Midtown This message needs your attention This is a personal email address. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast From:Ron Baker To:PWD Cc:Council, City Subject:Dangerous Road Condition Date:Tuesday, July 22, 2025 2:54:34 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. i Hi there. I’m a PA resident and am writing about the dangerous condition in the alley behind the west side of the block of 3900 El Camino Real, where Happy Donuts and other retailersare located. This alley, which you must enter to exit some of the one way parking lots on that block, has a hole in the surface that is about a foot deep. Moreover, the pavement is missingor broken for a significant portion of the alley. I drive an SUV and felt unsafe crossing the hole out of fear that I’d do damage to my axle. Really crazy. If you want I can send you a photo, but you really should inspect that. I believe from thelooks of it that this is a public road, but ask you if you can check on that. If so, I believe that the city may have liability for damage caused to vehicles. This is no ordinary pothole, andclearly this alley hasn’t been paved in at least 20 years, and possibly a great deal longer. Sincerely, Ron Baker This message needs your attention This is a personal email address. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast From:Jeff Hoel To:UAC Cc:Hoel, Jeff (external); Council, City Subject:TRANSCRIPT & COMMENTS -- 07-09-25 UAC meeting -- Utility Director"s Report Date:Tuesday, July 22, 2025 1:27:05 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. Commissioners, Here's a TRANSCIPT & COMMENTS of your 07-09-25 UAC meeting, just the Utilities Director's Report. My COMMENTS are paragraphs in red beginning with "### ." 07-06-25 UAC meeting -- videohttps://midpenmedia.org/utilities-advisory-commission-792025/ Thanks. Jeff =============================================================================== TRANSCRIPT 0:18:38: Chair Scharff: And that brings us to the Utilities Director's Report 0:18:43: Director Kurotori: Yes. I have some updates for the Commission. I did want to mention that we do havean Approval Exchange Agreement with the Midpeninsula Open Space District. This will allow us toaccess to do the final completion of our utility undergrounding in the Foothills Project. So, all the way tothe top, serving AT&T and the FAA. So, we're very pleased with that. So, staff will be working verydiligently to complete that project. I did want to mention, we're also looking at undergrounding to theservice level. So, as we looked at all the customers out there, many were already undergrounded. So,there's just a handful of customers, including Midpeninsula and AT&T and FAA. So, we'll beundergrounding those as well. So, undergrounded all the way. Completely. So, we're very pleased withthat expansion of those services that we are providing. 0:19:33: You may have noticed that staff and City Council has been looking to purchase a property for thestorage. We have a lot of storage we need for the Utility itself. So, we're looking at a property within PaloAlto. In the past, we've been leasing property outside, in Mountain View, for our AMI project. But withGrid Mod coming up, we really need to have enclosed storage for our transformers and other equipment. ### A portion of the Colorado substation is currently being used for unenclosed storage of transformers,breakers, etc. It's crowding the space reserved for the FTTP hut. (Unofficially, I've heard that the hut sitemight be moved.) So, we're very pleased with moving that forward as well. So, that will be coming back to the Council inthe future. ### When it goes to Council, will it be an action item? Will it go to UAC first? 0:20:06: Just a couple other updates. On the legislative and regulatory side, it's -- We should be noting that theCongress has passed the One Big Beautiful Bill Act, where it has some significant impacts to tax cuts,renewable energy, EV credits, and energy efficiency, etc., etc. So, we are, you know, looking at that, andalso the impacts of tariffs. So, a lot of utilities are taking that into account, as we look at our future powerpurchase agreements. What would that look like? And those impacts. And we'll be having that as part ofour discussion today as one of our battery storage procurement projects today. So, I just wanted to letthe Commission know about that. 0:20:55: We also are sending out our Consumer Confidence Report for the water utility. It's our 2024 information,but it comes out in 2025. So, just to let you know about that as well. 0:21:04: And, more importantly, our MSC Open House is on Saturday, July 26th. The first one I'll be able toattend. I've heard it's a fantastic event. Though I don't know if it will match the 4th of July Barbecue -- or,excuse me, Chili. I was able to be one of the judges for that event. So, it was my first attendance tosomething so uniquely Palo Alto. So, very pleased to be there. And it was a very good turnout as well. So, that completes my report. 0:21:40: Chair Scharff: Thank you. From:Maia Harris To:Lo, Ria Cc:Baird, Nathan; Shikada, Ed; Council, City Subject:RE: Request for 2-Hour Parking Restrictions on Sheridan Avenue (Adjacent to 2747 Park Blvd.) Date:Tuesday, July 22, 2025 10:22:56 AM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. Dear Director Lo, I’m following up on my message below regarding our request to implement 2-hr parking near our downtown property. We remain eager to meet with your team to discuss a path forward. Regards, Maia Harris | Jay Paul Company Director, Special Projects & Community Relations Four Embarcadero Center, Suite 3620 San Francisco, CA 94111 Office: 415 263 2929 | Mobile: 415 465 0419 mharris@jaypaul.com From: Maia Harris Sent: Monday, July 7, 2025 5:00 PM To: ria.lo@paloalto.gov Cc: nathan.baird@paloalto.gov; ed.shikada@cityofpaloalto.gov; City.Council@PaloAlto.gov Subject: Request for 2-Hour Parking Restrictions on Sheridan Avenue (Adjacent to 2747 Park Blvd.) Dear Director Lo, I’m writing on behalf of Jay Paul Company to formally request the implementation of 2-hour parking limits—or other reasonable parking restrictions—on Sheridan Avenue between Park Blvd. and Page Mill Road, adjacent to our property at 2747 Park Blvd. This section of Sheridan is currently the only nearby street without parking restrictions. We believe it would be a strong candidate for inclusion in the Downtown Residential PreferentialParking (RPP) program within the California Avenue Business District. Over the past year, the street has increasingly become a site for long-term vehicle storage,including RVs and vans that have remained parked in the same location without moving. Thishas raised ongoing concerns from our existing tenant, who has indicated that continued inaction on this issue may impact their decision to renew their lease. Attached are a map of the property and weekly photos from the past three months that illustrate the scope andconsistency of the issue. We appreciated the City’s implementation of “No Overnight Parking” signage along the 100block of Page Mill Road earlier this year, which helped address similar challenges. In May, wesubmitted a follow-up request to City staff but have not yet received a response. We would welcome the opportunity to meet with your team to discuss a path forward and arehappy to coordinate a time at your earliest convenience. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Maia Harris | Jay Paul Company Director, Special Projects & Community Relations Four Embarcadero Center, Suite 3620 San Francisco, CA 94111 Office: 415 263 2929 | Mobile: 415 465 0419 mharris@jaypaul.com From:Sean Allen To:Martin Wasserman Cc:Aram James; Jeff Rosen; Jay Boyarsky; Veenker, Vicki; h.etzko@gmail.com; jessica@speiser.net; Foley, Michael; GRP-City Council; Raymond Goins; RajJayadev; Patrice Ventresca; Figueroa, Eric; Lotus Fong; Reifschneider, James; Binder, Andrew; Gardener, Liz; Diana Diamond; Yolanda Conaway;yolanda; Don Austin; jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com; Human Relations Commission; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; Perron, Zachary; Robert Salonga;Rob Baker; Robert. Jonsen; Roberta Ahlquist; Steve Wagstaffe; Wagner, April; Jeff Conrad; Burt, Patrick; PD Kristina Bell; Bill Newell; The Office ofMayor Matt Mahan; Councilmember Chappie Jones; District9@sanjoseca.gov; District4@sanjoseca.gov; District5@sanjoseca.gov;District2@sanjoseca.gov; Today EPA; Gennady Sheyner; Council, City; city.council@menlopark.gov; Vara Ramakrishnan; cromero@cityofepa.org;Cribbs, Anne; michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com; Stump, Molly; board@pausd.org; BoardOperations; Damon Silver; Miguel Rodriguez; Cait James; JoshBecker; Assemblymember.Berman@assembly.ca.gov; Zelkha, Mila; dennis burns; DuJuan Green; Gerry Gras; Enberg, Nicholas; Rowena Chiu; Barberini,Christopher; Reckdahl, Keith; Dana St. George; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Tom DuBois; Friends of Cubberley; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Greg Tanaka; BilBarber; Ed Lauing; Yi Chen; Donna Wallach; Mickie Winkler; Supervisor Otto Lee; Mark Turner; City Attorney; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; SeherAwan; Pat M; Carla Torres; David Piper; Lori Meyers; Sheree Roth; Ellen Fox Subject:Re: Block the Bombs_1_2 sheet Date:Tuesday, July 22, 2025 8:05:10 AM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachmentsand clicking on links. i Hi Martin, Thank you for sharing your thoughts. I understand your perspective on the importance of national security, and yourresponse highlights my previous point regarding Israel's desire to maintain its purity and identity. Your remarks seem tosupport the premise that Israel’s actions promote a sense of exclusivity, prioritizing its national identity over thehumanitarian needs of others. Moreover, your position suggesting that Muslims and others should seek assistance outside of Israel reinforces the notionof maintaining a specific national identity, which further emphasizes purity but also points to discrimination against thosewho don't fit that identity. The refusal to support those seeking refuge can be seen as a troubling aspect of how Israelnavigates its humanitarian obligations. Additionally, the United States has a lengthy history of championing humanitarian efforts, being a country built on thefoundation of immigration and diversity. It feels counterintuitive for the U.S. to support nations that do not uphold thesame values of compassion and assistance to those in need, especially when taxpayer money is involved. Thecommitment to shared responsibility and collective morality should guide our partnerships and aid. While I appreciate the unique history and culture of the Jewish people, it is possible to uphold national identity while alsoextending compassion and support to those facing perilous situations. Finding a balance between these values is essentialfor fostering a more inclusive and just society. Looking forward to your thoughts. Best, Sean Sent from my iPhone On Jul 21, 2025, at 5:08 PM, Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote: Sean, Humanitarian values are important, but realistically, national security concerns will always override them invirtually any country on Earth. In fact, any nation that puts humanitarianism above its own national securityinterests probably won't be a nation for long. And if we accept the idea that any person’s need creates an This message needs your attention This is a personal email address. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast obligation for others to fulfill that need, the world would very quickly sink into chaos. Regarding African refugees in Israel, it's a testimony to Israel’s humanitarianism that these refugees, mostlyMuslims, know they'll receive more compassionate care in the one Jewish state than in any Arab or Muslimstate. Nevertheless, Israel is a very small country, and it's also the nation state of the Jewish people, a peoplewith their own unique religion, language, and culture and a very long history. If it opened its gates toeveryone who was in need, it would quickly be swamped, and would no longer be the nation state of theJewish people. Israel is not going to compromise its national identity, and it's unreasonable to think that itshould, for the sake of helping strangers who have no particular connection to Jews or Judaism. Best,Martin On Jul 21, 2025, at 12:03 PM, Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com> wrote: Martin, I appreciate your perspective on the complexities of national security and humanitarianobligations. However, it's crucial to recognize that viewing civilians as "enemies" can lead to adangerous precedent where humanitarian needs are disregarded in the name of security. In both the case of African asylum-seekers and Palestinians in Gaza, the individuals affected areoften civilians who are fleeing violence, persecution, or dire living conditions. They should notbe categorized merely as "enemy civilians," as this oversimplifies the multifaceted nature ofconflict and ignores their humanity. Treating any civilian population as an enemy underminesthe basic principles of international humanitarian law, which emphasize the protection of non-combatants in conflict situations. The actions of Israel toward African asylum-seekers further illustrate this point. In the face ofsignificant geopolitical and humanitarian challenges, Israel has opted to deport Eritrean andSudanese asylum-seekers, often leaving them vulnerable to persecution in third countries,demonstrating a troubling pattern of prioritizing security measures over humanitarianresponsibilities. Like the civilians in Gaza, these asylum-seekers are fleeing perilous situations;thus, their humanity should be recognized regardless of the circumstances surrounding theirmigration. Regarding your historical references, while it is true that during times of war, nations have madedecisions that prioritize military objectives, it's essential to acknowledge that the moralimplications of such decisions have evolved. The international community increasinglyrecognizes the importance of humanitarian considerations even amid conflict. Ignoringhumanitarian needs, particularly of vulnerable populations, can perpetuate cycles of violenceand instability that ultimately harm national interests in the long run. Additionally, while you mention Israeli perspectives on Gazan civilians voting for Hamas, it'scritical to understand that many civilians may have done so under coercive conditions or withoutthe full capacity to consider the implications of their choices. Many Gazans are indeed caught ina cycle of violence, facing repercussions for the decisions made by leadership they may notsupport. You also note Israel's earlier actions to facilitate the entry of food and supplies into Gaza.However, the effectiveness and sufficiency of this aid must be contextualized against the widerbackdrop of blockades and military operations that significantly restrict access to essentialservices, creating a humanitarian crisis. In summary, while national security is undoubtedly critical, it should not come at the cost ofabandoning the fundamental human rights and dignity of civilians caught in conflict. The tragicplight of those affected by violence—whether they are asylum-seekers or civilians in Gaza—demands a compassionate and just approach that acknowledges their humanity. Is the refusal torecognize the humanity of these individuals truly an acceptable stance in the pursuit of security,or is it more about maintaining purity? Regards, Sean Sent from my iPhone On Jul 21, 2025, at 10:31 AM, Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote: Sean, I appreciate your concern for humanitarian issues. However, the reality is that whena nation is fighting for its very existence, as Israel is doing right now, its highestpriority has to be to defeat the enemy, and caring for the humanitarian needs ofenemy civilians has to be a much lower priority. In fact, most nations would ridicule the idea of helping enemy civilians while a waris ongoing, arguing that it’s equivalent to helping the enemy himself. During World War II, for example, the overriding imperative was victory, and theUS showed no concern for the humanitarian well-being of the enemy civilians itwas bombing, nor did any other nation involved in that conflict. Humanitarianconcerns could be addressed after the war, but not during it. It’s also worth noting that Israelis don't necessarily see Gazan civilians as innocentbystanders. They remember how they voted Hamas into power, and how many ofthem followed Hamas into Israel on October 7 and took direct part in the plunderand pillage of that day. They also recall the outbursts of delirious joy as the Israelihostages were paraded through the streets of Gaza, and how not a single Gazan didanything to help the Israeli hostages escape from their captivity. Nevertheless, Israel has shown more concern for humanitarian issues than virtuallyany other country in a similar situation. Earlier in the war, it allowed huge amountsof food and supplies into Gaza, even though it knew that most of the aid was beingstolen by Hamas, thereby prolonging the war and making victory more difficult toachieve. Incidentally, there were many in Israel who thought this policy was veryfoolish and highly counterproductive. Regards,Martin Wasserman On Jul 20, 2025, at 8:34 PM, Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com>wrote: Martin, Thank you for sharing your perspective. While it's important toconsider the complex dynamics at play, the impact of rationing foodand resources cannot be overlooked. Limiting access to basicnecessities can lead to dire consequences for the civilian population,contributing to significant suffering and hardship, irrespective of intent. Historically, we have seen that during crises, people instinctively fightand even resort to violence over limited resources. This was evident inthe aftermath of Hurricane Katrina in the United States, wherewidespread desperation for food, water, and safety led to chaos andalarming acts of violence. Reports from that time highlighted how individuals looted stores and clashed with each other as they scrambledfor basic survival needs, demonstrating how fragile social order canbecome when resources are scarce. Similarly, in Somalia, we witnessedviolence surrounding the distribution of humanitarian aid, as factionsvied for control over the resources being provided to those in need. Rationing food and resources has the potential to produce outcomesthat are as devastating as direct violence, akin to the effects of bombinga population. Furthermore, military units should never base theirdecisions to slaughter non-combatants on the basis that their oppositiondoes not release hostages, regardless of the justification for conflict.Unless the motive is to create more chaos through infighting, whichwould lead to similar devastation as bombing non-combatantcommunities, the humane approach is to provide these individuals withthe necessary amount of humanitarian aid and stop the slaughter.Bombing non-combatants is not war; it’s slaughter and inhumane. Evenour Constitution prohibits punishing a group of people because of theactions of others. While military objectives may focus on specific groups, we mustrecognize that the broader impact on civilian lives remains profound.The suffering of Gazans should not be diminished or overlooked, astheir well-being is affected by the decisions made in the context of thisconflict. Best, Sean Allen Sent from my iPhone On Jul 20, 2025, at 3:30 PM, Aram James<abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Condemn Israel or be complicit in genocide': Colombia's Gustavo Petro By Al Mayadeen English Source: The Guardian 8 Jul 2025 13:47 2 Shares 4 Min Read Colombian President Gustavo Petro, in a Guardian op-ed, accuses Netanyahu of genocide in Gaza and urges global action. Listen On Tuesday, The Guardian published an opinion piece by Colombian President Gustavo Petro, in which he accused Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of orchestrating a "campaign of devastation" in Gaza and called on the international community to move beyond symbolic outrage toward concrete action in defense of international law. Petro has emerged as one of the most outspoken world leaders condemning "Israel’s" war on Gaza, and his latest opinion piece adds to a growing series of forceful critiques directed at the ongoing Israeli genocide. Denouncing what he described as 600 days of systematic atrocities, Petro wrote that the world's inaction risks legitimizing a model of impunity where colonial violence, ethnic cleansing, and siege warfare are normalized against a captive population. "If we fail to act now," he wrote, "we not only betray the Palestinian people, we become complicit in the atrocities committed by Netanyahu's government." Moral break The president highlighted a landmark United Nations General Assembly resolution adopted in September 2024, which called for "Israel" to end its illegal occupation within 12 months. He noted that Colombia was among the 124 countries that voted in favor, thereby assuming binding obligations that include sanctions, legal action, and trade measures. "The clock is now ticking," he warned, reaffirming Colombia's commitment by recalling its concrete step: suspending coal exports to "Israel." Related News 650 days of genocide: 125,000 tons of bombs 2.4 mln lives shattered Starved by 'Israel': People of Gaza are dying while the world watches In his piece, Petro mentioned that he had declared earlier this year: "We cannot fuel the machinery that slaughters Palestinian children and then claim neutrality." This is not the first bold move by the Colombian president. In May, his government formally cut diplomatic ties with "Israel," citing what Petro explicitly described as a "genocide." His administration also appointed Colombia’s first ambassador to Palestine, pledging medical treatment in Colombian hospitals for injured children from Gaza. The newly appointed ambassador, Jorge Iván Ospina, later echoed Petro’s position, warning of a "macabre intention to erase the identity of a people." In Tuesday's article, Petro praised similar actions taken by countries like Malaysia, which banned Israeli ships from its ports, and South Africa, which brought "Israel" before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) on charges of genocide. It is worth noting that Colombia joined that case as an intervening party, further deepening its legal opposition to "Israel's" war. Read more: US defends Israeli use of starvation as weapon of war before ICJ Global reckoning Looking ahead, Petro mentioned that Colombia and South Africa, co-chairs of the Hague Group, will host an emergency summit regarding Gaza on July 15. The conference aims to develop a coordinated, multilateral strategy to isolate "Israel" diplomatically and economically while restoring credibility to the global legal order. With the UN's proposed international peace conference indefinitely postponed, Petro cast the July summit as a necessary corrective to global paralysis. The Colombian president framed the Gaza crisis not just as a moral catastrophe but as an existential test for international law and nations of the Global South. "We can either stand firm in defense of the legal principles that seek to prevent war and conflict," he wrote, "or watch helplessly as the international system collapses under the weight of unchecked power politics." He concluded his piece by stressing that the choice is between complicity in colonial violence and collective resistance against it. On Sun, Jul 20, 2025 at 3:12 PM Martin Wasserman<deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:Aram, Amnesty International is not a credible source on thisissue. It appears that the once-respectable organizationhas been taken over by malevolent actors with a politicalaxe to grind. Their anti-Israel bias is evident throughoutthe report. They accuse Israel of genocide but make no mention atall of Hamas’ explicit genocidal policy against Jews. They accuse Israel of violating international law, butmake no reference at all to the fact that Israel is facing aruthless enemy that observes no international lawswhatsoever. When they mention Hamas’ transgressions at all, they doit in the mildest language possible, and then use the mostdamning possible language when describing Israel'sactions. They take it as a given that Israel is an apartheid state, ablatantly false accusation that is very easily disproved. They take it as a given that Israel is illegally occupyingPalestinian land, as if the territories of Judea andSamaria, the heartland of the ancient Jewish nation, don't belong to Jews at all, but are instead the property of afictitious country called “Palestine” which has neveractually existed in any historical period. In short, this entire report is a politically motivated“hatchet job” that deserves no credibility whatsoever. Martin Wasserman On Jul 20, 2025, at 11:39 AM, Aram James<abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Amnesty Internationalinvestigation concludesIsrael is committinggenocide againstPalestinians in Gaza Amnesty International’s research has found sufficient basisto conclude that Israel has committed and is continuing tocommit genocide against Palestinians in the occupied GazaStrip, the organization said in a landmark new report published today. The report, ‘You Feel Like You Are Subhuman’: Israel’sGenocide Against Palestinians in Gaza, documents how,during its military offensive launched in the wake of the deadly Hamas-led attacks in southern Israel on 7 October 2023, Israel has unleashed hell and destruction onPalestinians in Gaza brazenly, continuously and with totalimpunity. “Amnesty International’s report demonstrates that Israel has carried out acts prohibited under the Genocide Convention, withthe specific intent to destroy Palestinians in Gaza. These actsinclude killings, causing serious bodily or mental harm anddeliberately inflicting on Palestinians in Gaza conditions of lifecalculated to bring about their physical destruction. Month after month, Israel has treated Palestinians in Gaza as a subhuman group unworthy of human rights and dignity, demonstrating its intent to physically destroy them,” said Agnès Callamard,Secretary General of Amnesty International. “Our damning findings must serve as a wake-up call to the international community: this is genocide. It must stop now. “States that continue to transfer arms to Israel at this timemust know they are violating their obligation to prevent genocide and are at risk of becoming complicit in genocide. All states with influence over Israel, particularly key armssuppliers like the USA and Germany, but also other EUmember states, the UK and others, must act now to bringIsrael’s atrocities against Palestinians in Gaza to animmediate end.” Over the past two months the crisis has grown particularlyacute in the North Gaza governorate, where a besieged population is facing starvation, displacement and annihilation amid relentless bombardment and suffocating restrictions on life-saving humanitarian aid. “Our research reveals that, for months, Israel has persisted incommitting genocidal acts, fully aware of the irreparable harm it was inflicting on Palestinians in Gaza. It continued to do so in defiance of countless warnings about the catastrophichumanitarian situation and of legally binding decisions from theInternational Court of Justice (ICJ) ordering Israel to takeimmediate measures to enable the provision of humanitarianassistance to civilians in Gaza,” said Agnès Callamard. “Israel has repeatedly argued that its actions in Gaza arelawful and can be justified by its military goal to eradicateHamas. But genocidal intent can co-exist alongside militarygoals and does not need to be Israel’s sole intent.” Amnesty International examined Israel’s acts in Gazaclosely and in their totality, taking into account theirrecurrence and simultaneous occurrence, and both theirimmediate impact and their cumulative and mutually reinforcing consequences. The organization considered the scale and severity of the casualties and destruction over time. It also analysed public statements by officials, findingthat prohibited acts were often announced or called for inthe first place by high-level officials in charge of the warefforts. “Taking into account the pre-existing context of dispossession,apartheid and unlawful military occupation in which these actshave been committed, we could find only one reasonableconclusion: Israel’s intent is the physical destruction ofPalestinians in Gaza, whether in parallel with, or as a means to achieve, its military goal of destroying Hamas,” said Agnès Callamard. “The atrocity crimes committed on 7 October 2023 byHamas and other armed groups against Israelis and victims of other nationalities, including deliberate mass killings and hostage-taking, can never justify Israel’s genocide againstPalestinians in Gaza.” International jurisprudence recognizes that the perpetrator does not need to succeed in their attempts to destroy the protected group, either in whole or in part, for genocide tohave been committed. The commission of prohibited actswith the intent to destroy the group, as such, is sufficient. Amnesty International’s report examines in detail Israel’s violations in Gaza over nine months between 7 October2023 and early July 2024. The organization interviewed 212people, including Palestinian victims and witnesses, localauthorities in Gaza, healthcare workers, conducted fieldworkand analysed an extensive range of visual and digital evidence, including satellite imagery. It also analysed statements by senior Israeli government and militaryofficials, and official Israeli bodies. On multiple occasions,the organization shared its findings with the Israeliauthorities but had received no substantive response at thetime of publication. Unprecedented scale and magnitude Israel’s actions following Hamas’s deadly attacks on 7 October 2023 have brought Gaza’s population to the brink of collapse. Its brutal military offensive had killed more than42,000 Palestinians, including over 13,300 children, andinjured over 97,000 more, by 7 October 2024, many of themin direct or deliberately indiscriminate attacks, often wipingout entire multigenerational families. It has caused unprecedented destruction, which experts say occurred at a level and speed not seen in any other conflict in the 21st century, levelling entire cities and destroying criticalinfrastructure, agricultural land and cultural and religioussites. It thereby rendered large swathes of Gazauninhabitable. Mohammed, who fled with his family from Gaza City toRafah in March 2024 and was displaced again in May 2024,described their struggle to survive in horrifying conditions: “Here in Deir al-Balah, it’s like an apocalypse… You have to protect your children from insects, from the heat, and thereis no clean water, no toilets, all while the bombing neverstops. You feel like you are subhuman here.” Israel imposed conditions of life in Gaza that created a deadly mixture of malnutrition, hunger and diseases, andexposed Palestinians to a slow, calculated death. Israel alsosubjected hundreds of Palestinians from Gaza toincommunicado detention, torture and other ill-treatment. Viewed in isolation, some of the acts investigated byAmnesty International constitute serious violations ofinternational humanitarian law or international human rightslaw. But in looking at the broader picture of Israel’s militarycampaign and the cumulative impact of its policies and acts, genocidal intent is the only reasonable conclusion. Intent to destroy To establish Israel’s specific intent to physically destroy Palestinians in Gaza, as such, Amnesty Internationalanalysed the overall pattern of Israel’s conduct in Gaza,reviewed dehumanizing and genocidal statements by Israeligovernment and military officials, particularly those at thehighest levels, and considered the context of Israel’s system of apartheid, its inhumane blockade of Gaza and the unlawful 57-year-old military occupation of the Palestinianterritory. Before reaching its conclusion, Amnesty International examined Israel’s claims that its military lawfully targeted Hamas and other armed groups throughout Gaza, and thatthe resulting unprecedented destruction and denial of aidwere the outcome of unlawful conduct by Hamas and otherarmed groups, such as locating fighters among the civilianpopulation or the diversion of aid. The organization concluded these claims are not credible. The presence of Hamas fighters near or within a densely populated area does not absolve Israel from its obligations to take allfeasible precautions to spare civilians and avoid indiscriminate or disproportionate attacks. Its research found Israel repeatedly failed to do so, committing multiple crimes under international law for which there can be nojustification based on Hamas’s actions. AmnestyInternational also found no evidence that the diversion of aidcould explain Israel’s extreme and deliberate restrictions onlife-saving humanitarian aid. In its analysis, the organization also considered alternativearguments such as ones that Israel was acting recklessly orthat it simply wanted to destroy Hamas and did not care if itneeded to destroy Palestinians in the process, demonstrating a callous disregard for their lives rather than genocidal intent. Our damning findings must serve as a wake-up call to the international community: this isgenocide. It must stop now. Agnès Callamard, Amnesty International However, regardless of whether Israel sees the destructionof Palestinians as instrumental to destroying Hamas or as an acceptable by-product of this goal, this view of Palestinians as disposable and not worthy of considerationis in itself evidence of genocidal intent. Many of the unlawful acts documented by Amnesty International were preceded by officials urging their implementation. The organization reviewed 102 statementsthat were issued by Israeli government and military officialsand others between 7 October 2023 and 30 June 2024 anddehumanized Palestinians, called for or justified genocidalacts or other crimes against them. Of these, Amnesty International identified 22 statementsmade by senior officials in charge of managing the offensivethat appeared to call for, or justify, genocidal acts, providingdirect evidence of genocidal intent. This language was frequently replicated, including by Israeli soldiers on the ground, as evidenced by audiovisual content verified byAmnesty International showing soldiers making calls to“erase” Gaza or to make it uninhabitable, and celebratingthe destruction of Palestinian homes, mosques, schools anduniversities. Killing and causing serious bodily ormental harm Amnesty International documented the genocidal acts of killing and causing serious mental and bodily harm toPalestinians in Gaza by reviewing the results ofinvestigations it conducted into 15 air strikes between 7October 2023 and 20 April 2024 that killed at least 334civilians, including 141 children, and wounded hundreds of others. Amnesty International found no evidence that any of these strikes were directed at a military objective. In one illustrative case, on 20 April 2024, an Israeli air strikedestroyed the Abdelal family house in the Al-Jneinah neighbourhood in eastern Rafah, killing three generations of Palestinians, including 16 children, while they were sleeping. While these represent just a fraction of Israel’s aerialattacks, they are indicative of a broader pattern of repeateddirect attacks on civilians and civilian objects or deliberately indiscriminate attacks. The attacks were also conducted in ways designed to cause a very high number of fatalities andinjuries among the civilian population. Inflicting conditions of life calculatedto bring about physical destruction The report documents how Israel deliberately inflictedconditions of life on Palestinians in Gaza intended to lead,over time, to their destruction. These conditions were imposed through three simultaneous patterns that repeatedly compounded the effect of each other’sdevastating impacts: damage to and destruction of life-sustaining infrastructure and other objects indispensable tothe survival of the civilian population; the repeated use ofsweeping, arbitrary and confusing mass “evacuation” orders to forcibly displace almost all of Gaza’s population; and the denial and obstruction of the delivery of essential services, humanitarian assistance and other life-saving supplies intoand within Gaza. After 7 October 2023, Israel imposed a total siege on Gaza cutting off electricity, water and fuel. In the nine months reviewed for this report, Israel maintained a suffocating,unlawful blockade, tightly controlled access to energysources, failed to facilitate meaningful humanitarian accesswithin Gaza, and obstructed the import and delivery of life-saving goods and humanitarian aid, particularly to areas north of Wadi Gaza. They thereby exacerbated an already existing humanitarian crisis. This, combined with theextensive damage to Gaza’s homes, hospitals, water andsanitation facilities and agricultural land, and mass forceddisplacement, caused catastrophic levels of hunger and ledto the spread of diseases at alarming rates. The impact was especially harsh on young children and pregnant or breastfeeding women, with anticipated long-term consequences for their health. The international community’s seismic,shameful failure for over a year to pressIsrael to end its atrocities in Gaza, by firstdelaying calls for a ceasefire and thencontinuing arms transfers, is and will remain a stain on our collective conscience.Agnès Callamard, Amnesty International Time and again, Israel had the chance to improve thehumanitarian situation in Gaza, yet for over a year it hasrepeatedly refused to take steps blatantly within its power todo so, such as opening sufficient access points to Gaza or lifting tight restrictions on what could enter the Strip or their obstruction of aid deliveries within Gaza while the situation has grown progressively worse. Through its repeated “evacuation” orders Israel displaced nearly 1.9 million Palestinians – 90% of Gaza’s population – into ever-shrinking, unsafe pockets of land under inhumaneconditions, some of them up to 10 times. These multiplewaves of forced displacement left many jobless and deeplytraumatized, especially since some 70% of Gaza’s residentsare refugees or descendants of refugees whose towns and villages were ethnically cleansed by Israel during the 1948 Nakba. Despite conditions quickly becoming unfit for human life,Israeli authorities refused to consider measures that would have protected displaced civilians and ensured their basic needs were met, showing that their actions were deliberate. They refused to allow those displaced to return to their homes in northern Gaza or relocate temporarily to other parts of the Occupied Palestinian Territory or Israel, continuing to deny many Palestinians their right to returnunder international law to areas they were displaced from in 1948. They did so knowing that there was nowheresafe for Palestinians in Gaza to flee to. Accountability for genocide “The international community’s seismic, shameful failure for over a year to press Israel to end its atrocities in Gaza, by first delaying calls for a ceasefire and then continuing arms transfers, is and will remain a stain on our collectiveconscience,” said Agnès Callamard. “Governments must stop pretending they are powerless to end this genocide, which was enabled by decades of impunity for Israel’s violations of international law. Statesneed to move beyond mere expressions of regret or dismayand take strong and sustained international action, howeveruncomfortable a finding of genocide may be for some ofIsrael’s allies. “The International Criminal Court’s (ICC) arrest warrants forPrime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former DefenseMinister Yoav Gallant for war crimes and crimes againsthumanity issued last month offer real hope of long-overdue justice for victims. States must demonstrate their respect for the court’s decision and for universal international lawprinciples by arresting and handing over those wanted bythe ICC. “We are calling on the Office of the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court (ICC) to urgently consideradding genocide to the list of crimes it is investigating andfor all states to use every legal avenue to bring perpetratorsto justice. No one should be allowed to commit genocideand remain unpunished.” Amnesty International is also calling for all civilian hostagesto be released unconditionally and for Hamas and otherPalestinian armed groups responsible for the crimescommitted on 7 October to be held to account. The organization is also calling for the UN Security Council to impose targeted sanctions against Israeli and Hamas officials most implicated in crimes under international law. Background On 7 October 2023 Hamas and other armed groups indiscriminately fired rockets into southernIsrael and carried out deliberate mass killings andhostage-taking there, killing 1,200 people, including over800 civilians, and abducted 223 civilians and captured 27soldiers. The crimes perpetrated by Hamas and other armed groups during this attack will be the focus of a forthcoming Amnesty International report. Since October 2023, Amnesty International has conducted in-depth investigations into the multiple violations and crimes under international law committed by Israeli forces, including direct attacks on civilians and civilian objects and deliberately indiscriminate attacks killing hundreds of civilians, as well asother unlawful attacks on and collective punishment of the civilianpopulation. The organization has called on the Office of the ICCProsecutor to expedite its investigation into the situation in theState of Palestine and is campaigning for an immediate ceasefire. For the Hebrew translation of this press release, click here. INTERNATIONAL JUSTICE ISRAEL AND THE OCCUPIED PALESTINIANTERRITORY MIDDLE EAST MIDDLE EAST AND NORTH AFRICA NEWS PRESS RELEASE WAR CRIMES AND CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY Related Content COUNTRY Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territory NEWS New NATO defence commitments must notcome at cost of human rights NEWS Gaza: Starvation or gunfire – this is not ahumanitarian response NEWS DRC: Peace deal with Rwanda fails toaddress serious crimes committed ineastern DRC NEWS Gaza: Evidence points to Israel’s continueduse of starvation to inflict genocide againstPalestinians Recently added Cambodia: Scamming crisis survivors must beprotected amid police crackdown Ireland: Amnesty’s head urges Irish government to press ahead with Occupied Territories Bill Angola: Authorities must respect and ensurethe right to freedom of peaceful assembly Russia: Proposed amendments to counter-extremism laws escalate assault on dissent EU-Israel: Refusal to suspend the EU-Israel Association Agreement is a ‘cruel and unlawful betrayal’ DONATE TO PROTECTHUMAN RIGHTS Women's Day protest in Mexico Together we can fight for human rights everywhere. Your donation can transform the lives of millions. ABOUT US Contact Us How We’re Run Modern Slavery Act Statement FinancesRESOURCES Media Centre Human Rights EducationHuman Rights CoursesAnnual report archiveGET INVOLVED JoinTake ActionVolunteerLATEST NewsCampaigns Research WORK WITH US If you are talented and passionate about human rights then Amnesty International wants to hear from you. Privacy Policy Accessibility Cookie StatementPermissionsRefunds of Donations © 2025 Amnesty International FOLLOW US ON: Facebook Instagram X TikTok Bluesky YouTube LinkedIn On Sun, Jul 20, 2025 at 10:03 AM MartinWasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:Aram, If that's the definition of genocide, thenIsrael is clearly NOT committing genocide in Gaza. If Israel were trying to kill asmany Gazans as possible, the death tollwould be much, much higher than it is.They wouldn't allow any food or medicinein at all, and they wouldn't issueevacuation warnings before strikingHamas targets. The truth is, Israel goes to great lengths toavoid civilian casualties, but Hamasmakes it very difficult by deliberatelyplacing their command centers in civilianlocations such as schools and hospitals. The only group that Israel wants todestroy is Hamas, which does have anexplicit policy of genocide (by yourdefinition) against Jews. Yes, the Gazans are suffering, but Hamascould end their suffering tomorrow if theywanted to. All they have to do is lay downtheir arms and release the hostages, andthe war would be over immediately. ButHamas has no interest in ending thesuffering of the Gazans. What they'reactually calling for is an open-ended warof attrition against Israel, no matter whatthe cost to their own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 18, 2025, at 8:26 PM,Aram James<abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Genocide defined: the deliberate killing of a large number of people from a particular nation orethnic group with the aim of destroying that nation or group. "a campaign of genocide" On Fri, Jul 18, 2025 at4:04 PM Martin Wasserman<deeperlook@aol.com>wrote:It appears that"genocide" can bedefined in several different ways. Perhapswe should stop using that term altogether and stick to words that haveclear and unambiguous meanings. On Jul 18,2025, at12:25 PM,Aram James<abjpd1@gmail.com>wrote: I’m a Genocide Scholar. I Know It When I See It”: Prof.Omer Bartov on the Growing Consensus on Gaza My inescapable conclusion has become that Israel is committing genocide against the Palestinian people. Having grown up in a Zionist home, lived the first half of my life in Israel, served in the I.D.F. as a soldier and officer and spent most of my career researching and writing on war crimes and the Holocaust, this was a painful conclusion to reach, and one that I resisted as long as I could. But I have been teaching classes on genocide for a quarter of a century. I can recognize one when I see one A month after the Hamas attack on Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, I believed there was evidence that the Israeli military had committed war crimes and potentially crimes against humanity in its counterattack on Gaza. But contrary to the cries of Israel’s fiercest critics, the evidence did not seem to me to rise to the crime of genocide. By May 2024, the Israel Defense Forces had ordered about one million Palestinians sheltering in Rafah — the southernmost and last remaining relatively undamaged city of the Gaza Strip — to move to the beach area of the Mawasi, where there was little to no shelter. The army then proceeded to destroy much of Rafah, a feat mostly accomplished by August. At that point it appeared no longer possible to deny that the pattern of I.D.F. operations was consistent with the statements denoting genocidal intent made by Israeli leaders in the days after the Hamas attack. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had promised that the enemy would pay a “huge price” for the attack and that the I.D.F. would turn parts of Gaza, where Hamas was operating, “into rubble,” and he called on “the residents of Gaza” to “leave now because we will operate forcefully everywhere.” Mr. Netanyahu had urged his citizens to remember “what Amalek did to you,” a quote many interpreted as a reference to the demand in a biblical passage calling for the Israelites to “kill alike men and women, infants and sucklings” of their ancient enemy. Government and military officials said they were fighting “human animals” and, later, called for “total annihilation.” Nissim Vaturi, the deputy speaker of Parliament, said on Xthat Israel’s task must be “erasing the Gaza Strip from the face of the earth.” Israel’s actions could be understood only as the implementation of the expressed intent to make the Gaza Strip uninhabitable for its Palestinian population. I believe the goal was — and remains today — to force the population to leave the Strip altogether or, considering that it has nowhere to go, to debilitate the enclave through bombings and severe deprivation of food, clean water, sanitation and medical aid to such an extent that it is impossible for Palestinians in Gaza to maintain or reconstitute their existence as a group. ADVERTISEMENT SKIP ADVERTISEMENT My inescapable conclusion has become that Israel is committing genocide against the Palestinian people. Having grown up in a Zionist home, lived the first half of my life in Israel, served in the I.D.F. as a soldier and officer and spent most of my career researching and writing on war crimes and the Holocaust, this was a painful conclusion to reach, and one that I resisted as long as I could. But I have been teaching classes on genocide for a quarter of a century. I can recognize one when I see one. This is not just my conclusion. A growing number of experts in genocide studies and international law have concluded that Israel’s actions in Gaza can only be defined as genocide. So has Francesca Albanese, the U.N. special rapporteur for the West Bank and Gaza, and Amnesty International. South Africa has brought a genocide case against Israel at the International Court of Justice. ImagePeople inspecting a huge pile of rubble. Credit...JehadAlshrafi/Associated Press The continued denial of this designation by states, international organizations and legal and scholarly experts will cause unmitigated damage not just to the people of Gaza and Israel but also to the system of international law established in the wake of the horrors of the Holocaust, designed to prevent such atrocities from happening ever again. It is a threat to the very foundations of the moral order on which we all depend.*** The crime of genocide was defined in 1948 by the United Nations as the “intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such.” In determining what constitutes genocide, therefore, we must both establish intent and show that it is being carried out. In Israel’s case, that intent has been publicly expressed by numerous officials and leaders. But intent can also be derived from a pattern of operations on the ground, and this pattern became clear by May 2024 — and has since become ever clearer — as the I.D.F. has systematically destroyed the Gaza Strip. ADVERTISEMENT SKIPADVERTISEMENT Most genocide scholars are cautious about applying this term to contemporary events, precisely because of the tendency, since it was coined by the Jewish-Polish lawyer Raphael Lemkin in 1944, to attribute it to any case of massacre or inhumanity. Indeed, some argue that the categorization should be entirely discarded, because it often serves more to express outrage than to identify a particular crime. Yet as Mr. Lemkin recognized, and as the United Nations later agreed, it is crucial to be able to distinguish the attempt to destroy a particular group of people from other crimes under international law, such as war crimes and crimes against humanity. This is because, while other crimes entail indiscriminate or deliberate killing of civilians as individuals, genocide denotes the killing of people as members of a group, geared at irreparably destroying the group itself so that it would never be able to reconstitute itself as a political, social or cultural entity. And, as the international community signaled by adopting the convention, it is incumbent upon all signatory states to prevent such an attempt, to do all they can to stop it while it is occurring and to subsequently punish those who were engaged in this crime of crimes — even if it occurred within the borders of a sovereign state. The designation has major political, legal and moral ramifications. Nations, politicians and military personnel suspected of, indicted on a charge of or found guilty of genocide are seen as beyond the pale of humanity and may compromise or lose their right to remain members of the international community. A finding by the International Court of Justice that a particular state is engaged in genocide, especially if enforced by the U.N. Security Council, can lead to severe sanctions. Sign up for the Opinion Today newsletter Get expert analysis of the news and a guide to the big ideas shaping the world every weekday morning. Get it sent to your inbox. Politicians or generals indicted on a charge of or found guilty of genocide or other breaches of international humanitarian law by the International Criminal Court can face arrest outside of their country. And a society that condones and is complicit in genocide, whatever the stand of its individual citizens may be, will carry this mark of Cain long after the fires of hatred and violence are put out.*** From:Winter Dellenbach To:Council, City Subject:Nine households control 15% of wealth in Silicon Valley as inequality widens Date:Monday, July 21, 2025 10:21:55 PM Dear vacationing Council members - I think this is a "must read". It's not long. Winter Dellenbach Nine households control 15% of wealth in Silicon Valley as inequality widens https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2025/jul/21/silicon-valley-income-wealth-gap?CMP=Share_iOSApp_Other From:Sean Allen To:Martin Wasserman Cc:Aram James; Jeff Rosen; Jay Boyarsky; Veenker, Vicki; h.etzko@gmail.com; jessica@speiser.net; Foley, Michael; Emily Mibach; Dave Price; GRP-City Council; Raymond Goins; Raj Jayadev; Patrice Ventresca; Figueroa, Eric; Lotus Fong; Reifschneider, James; Binder,Andrew; Gardener, Liz; Diana Diamond; Yolanda Conaway; yolanda; Don Austin; jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com; HumanRelations Commission; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; Perron, Zachary; Robert Salonga; roberta ahlquist; Rob Baker; Robert. Jonsen;Roberta Ahlquist; Steve Wagstaffe; Wagner, April; Freddie.Quintana@sen.ca.gov; Jeff Conrad; Burt, Patrick; PD Kristina Bell; BillNewell; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; Councilmember Chappie Jones; District9@sanjoseca.gov; District4@sanjoseca.gov;District5@sanjoseca.gov; District2@sanjoseca.gov; Today EPA; Gennady Sheyner; Council, City; city.council@menlopark.gov; Betsy Nash; Vara Ramakrishnan; cromero@cityofepa.org; Cribbs, Anne; michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com; Stump, Molly; board@pausd.org;BoardOperations; Damon Silver; Miguel Rodriguez; Cait James; Tim James; Josh Becker; Assemblymember.Berman@assembly.ca.gov;Zelkha, Mila; dennis burns; DuJuan Green; Gerry Gras; Enberg, Nicholas; Rowena Chiu; Barberini, Christopher; Reckdahl, Keith; DanaSt. George; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Greg Tanaka; Tom DuBois; Friends of Cubberley; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Greg Tanaka; BilBarber; Ed Lauing; Yi Chen; Donna Wallach; Mickie Winkler; Supervisor Otto Lee; Mark Turner; City Attorney; CityCouncil; MichelleBigelow; Seher Awan; Pat M; Carla Torres; David Piper Subject:Re: Block the Bombs_1_2 sheet Date:Monday, July 21, 2025 6:35:36 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of openingattachments and clicking on links. i Martin, I appreciate your perspective on the complexities of national security and humanitarian obligations.However, it's crucial to recognize that viewing civilians as "enemies" can lead to a dangerous precedentwhere humanitarian needs are disregarded in the name of security. In both the case of African asylum-seekers and Palestinians in Gaza, the individuals affected are oftencivilians who are fleeing violence, persecution, or dire living conditions. They should not be categorizedmerely as "enemy civilians," as this oversimplifies the multifaceted nature of conflict and ignores theirhumanity. Treating any civilian population as an enemy undermines the basic principles of internationalhumanitarian law, which emphasize the protection of non-combatants in conflict situations. The actions of Israel toward African asylum-seekers further illustrate this point. In the face of significantgeopolitical and humanitarian challenges, Israel has opted to deport Eritrean and Sudanese asylum-seekers,often leaving them vulnerable to persecution in third countries, demonstrating a troubling pattern ofprioritizing security measures over humanitarian responsibilities. Like the civilians in Gaza, these asylum-seekers are fleeing perilous situations; thus, their humanity should be recognized regardless of thecircumstances surrounding their migration. Regarding your historical references, while it is true that during times of war, nations have made decisionsthat prioritize military objectives, it's essential to acknowledge that the moral implications of such decisionshave evolved. The international community increasingly recognizes the importance of humanitarianconsiderations even amid conflict. Ignoring humanitarian needs, particularly of vulnerable populations, canperpetuate cycles of violence and instability that ultimately harm national interests in the long run. Additionally, while you mention Israeli perspectives on Gazan civilians voting for Hamas, it's critical tounderstand that many civilians may have done so under coercive conditions or without the full capacity toconsider the implications of their choices. Many Gazans are indeed caught in a cycle of violence, facingrepercussions for the decisions made by leadership they may not support. You also note Israel's earlier actions to facilitate the entry of food and supplies into Gaza. However, theeffectiveness and sufficiency of this aid must be contextualized against the wider backdrop of blockades and This message needs your attentionThis is a personal email address. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast military operations that significantly restrict access to essential services, creating a humanitarian crisis. In summary, while national security is undoubtedly critical, it should not come at the cost of abandoning thefundamental human rights and dignity of civilians caught in conflict. The tragic plight of those affected byviolence—whether they are asylum-seekers or civilians in Gaza—demands a compassionate and justapproach that acknowledges their humanity. Is the refusal to recognize the humanity of these individualstruly an acceptable stance in the pursuit of security, or is it more about maintaining purity? Regards, Sean Sent from my iPhone On Jul 21, 2025, at 10:31 AM, Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote: Sean, I appreciate your concern for humanitarian issues. However, the reality is that when a nation isfighting for its very existence, as Israel is doing right now, its highest priority has to be to defeatthe enemy, and caring for the humanitarian needs of enemy civilians has to be a much lowerpriority. In fact, most nations would ridicule the idea of helping enemy civilians while a war is ongoing,arguing that it’s equivalent to helping the enemy himself. During World War II, for example, the overriding imperative was victory, and the US showedno concern for the humanitarian well-being of the enemy civilians it was bombing, nor did anyother nation involved in that conflict. Humanitarian concerns could be addressed after the war,but not during it. It’s also worth noting that Israelis don't necessarily see Gazan civilians as innocent bystanders.They remember how they voted Hamas into power, and how many of them followed Hamas intoIsrael on October 7 and took direct part in the plunder and pillage of that day. They also recallthe outbursts of delirious joy as the Israeli hostages were paraded through the streets of Gaza,and how not a single Gazan did anything to help the Israeli hostages escape from their captivity. Nevertheless, Israel has shown more concern for humanitarian issues than virtually any othercountry in a similar situation. Earlier in the war, it allowed huge amounts of food and suppliesinto Gaza, even though it knew that most of the aid was being stolen by Hamas, therebyprolonging the war and making victory more difficult to achieve. Incidentally, there were manyin Israel who thought this policy was very foolish and highly counterproductive. Regards,Martin Wasserman On Jul 20, 2025, at 8:34 PM, Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com> wrote: Martin, Thank you for sharing your perspective. While it's important to consider thecomplex dynamics at play, the impact of rationing food and resources cannot beoverlooked. Limiting access to basic necessities can lead to dire consequences forthe civilian population, contributing to significant suffering and hardship,irrespective of intent. Historically, we have seen that during crises, people instinctively fight and evenresort to violence over limited resources. This was evident in the aftermath ofHurricane Katrina in the United States, where widespread desperation for food,water, and safety led to chaos and alarming acts of violence. Reports from that timehighlighted how individuals looted stores and clashed with each other as theyscrambled for basic survival needs, demonstrating how fragile social order canbecome when resources are scarce. Similarly, in Somalia, we witnessed violencesurrounding the distribution of humanitarian aid, as factions vied for control overthe resources being provided to those in need. Rationing food and resources has the potential to produce outcomes that are asdevastating as direct violence, akin to the effects of bombing a population.Furthermore, military units should never base their decisions to slaughter non-combatants on the basis that their opposition does not release hostages, regardless ofthe justification for conflict. Unless the motive is to create more chaos throughinfighting, which would lead to similar devastation as bombing non-combatantcommunities, the humane approach is to provide these individuals with thenecessary amount of humanitarian aid and stop the slaughter. Bombing non-combatants is not war; it’s slaughter and inhumane. Even our Constitution prohibitspunishing a group of people because of the actions of others. While military objectives may focus on specific groups, we must recognize that thebroader impact on civilian lives remains profound. The suffering of Gazans shouldnot be diminished or overlooked, as their well-being is affected by the decisionsmade in the context of this conflict. Best, Sean Allen Sent from my iPhone On Jul 20, 2025, at 3:30 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com>wrote: Condemn Israel or be complicit in genocide': Colombia's Gustavo Petro By Al Mayadeen English Source: The Guardian 8 Jul 2025 13:47 2 Shares 4 Min Read Colombian President Gustavo Petro, in a Guardian op-ed, accuses Netanyahu of genocide in Gaza and urges global action. Listen On Tuesday, The Guardian published an opinion piece by Colombian President Gustavo Petro, in which he accused Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of orchestrating a "campaign of devastation" in Gaza and called on the international community to move beyond symbolic outrage toward concrete action in defense of international law. Petro has emerged as one of the most outspoken world leaders condemning "Israel’s" war on Gaza, and his latest opinion piece adds to a growing series of forceful critiques directed at the ongoing Israeli genocide. Denouncing what he described as 600 days of systematic atrocities, Petro wrote that the world's inaction risks legitimizing a model of impunity where colonial violence, ethnic cleansing, and siege warfare are normalized against a captive population. "If we fail to act now," he wrote, "we not only betray the Palestinian people, we become complicit in the atrocities committed by Netanyahu's government." Moral break The president highlighted a landmark United Nations General Assembly resolution adopted in September 2024, which called for "Israel" to end its illegal occupation within 12 months. He noted that Colombia was among the 124 countries that voted in favor, thereby assuming binding obligations that include sanctions, legal action, and trade measures. "The clock is now ticking," he warned, reaffirming Colombia's commitment by recalling its concrete step: suspending coal exports to "Israel." Related News 650 days of genocide: 125,000 tons of bombs 2.4 mln lives shattered Starved by 'Israel': People of Gaza are dying while the world watches In his piece, Petro mentioned that he had declared earlier this year: "We cannot fuel the machinery that slaughters Palestinian children and then claim neutrality." This is not the first bold move by the Colombian president. In May, his government formally cut diplomatic ties with "Israel," citing what Petro explicitly described as a "genocide." His administration also appointed Colombia’s first ambassador to Palestine, pledging medical treatment in Colombian hospitals for injured children from Gaza. The newly appointed ambassador, Jorge Iván Ospina, later echoed Petro’s position, warning of a "macabre intention to erase the identity of a people." In Tuesday's article, Petro praised similar actions taken by countries like Malaysia, which banned Israeli ships from its ports, and South Africa, which brought "Israel" before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) on charges of genocide. It is worth noting that Colombia joined that case as an intervening party, further deepening its legal opposition to "Israel's" war. Read more: US defends Israeli use of starvation as weapon of war before ICJ Global reckoning Looking ahead, Petro mentioned that Colombia and South Africa, co-chairs of the Hague Group, will host an emergency summit regarding Gaza on July 15. The conference aims to develop a coordinated, multilateral strategy to isolate "Israel" diplomatically and economically while restoring credibility to the global legal order. With the UN's proposed international peace conference indefinitely postponed, Petro cast the July summit as a necessary corrective to global paralysis. The Colombian president framed the Gaza crisis not just as a moral catastrophe but as an existential test for international law and nations of the Global South. "We can either stand firm in defense of the legal principles that seek to prevent war and conflict," he wrote, "or watch helplessly as the international system collapses under the weight of unchecked power politics." He concluded his piece by stressing that the choice is between complicity in colonial violence and collective resistance against it. On Sun, Jul 20, 2025 at 3:12 PM Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:Aram, Amnesty International is not a credible source on this issue. Itappears that the once-respectable organization has been taken over bymalevolent actors with a political axe to grind. Their anti-Israel biasis evident throughout the report. They accuse Israel of genocide but make no mention at all of Hamas’explicit genocidal policy against Jews. They accuse Israel of violating international law, but make noreference at all to the fact that Israel is facing a ruthless enemy thatobserves no international laws whatsoever. When they mention Hamas’ transgressions at all, they do it in themildest language possible, and then use the most damning possiblelanguage when describing Israel's actions. They take it as a given that Israel is an apartheid state, a blatantlyfalse accusation that is very easily disproved. They take it as a given that Israel is illegally occupying Palestinianland, as if the territories of Judea and Samaria, the heartland of theancient Jewish nation, don't belong to Jews at all, but are instead theproperty of a fictitious country called “Palestine” which has neveractually existed in any historical period. In short, this entire report is a politically motivated “hatchet job” thatdeserves no credibility whatsoever. Martin Wasserman On Jul 20, 2025, at 11:39 AM, Aram James<abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Amnesty Internationalinvestigation concludesIsrael is committinggenocide againstPalestinians in Gaza Amnesty International’s research has found sufficient basisto conclude that Israel has committed and is continuing to commit genocide against Palestinians in the occupied Gaza Strip, the organization said in a landmark new reportpublished today. The report, ‘You Feel Like You Are Subhuman’: Israel’sGenocide Against Palestinians in Gaza, documents how, during its military offensive launched in the wake of thedeadly Hamas-led attacks in southern Israel on 7 October 2023, Israel has unleashed hell and destruction on Palestinians in Gaza brazenly, continuously and with totalimpunity. “Amnesty International’s report demonstrates that Israel hascarried out acts prohibited under the Genocide Convention, with the specific intent to destroy Palestinians in Gaza. These actsinclude killings, causing serious bodily or mental harm and deliberately inflicting on Palestinians in Gaza conditions of life calculated to bring about their physical destruction. Month aftermonth, Israel has treated Palestinians in Gaza as a subhuman group unworthy of human rights and dignity, demonstrating itsintent to physically destroy them,” said Agnès Callamard, Secretary General of Amnesty International. “Our damning findings must serve as a wake-up call to the international community: this is genocide. It must stop now. “States that continue to transfer arms to Israel at this timemust know they are violating their obligation to preventgenocide and are at risk of becoming complicit in genocide. All states with influence over Israel, particularly key armssuppliers like the USA and Germany, but also other EU member states, the UK and others, must act now to bringIsrael’s atrocities against Palestinians in Gaza to animmediate end.” Over the past two months the crisis has grown particularly acute in the North Gaza governorate, where a besiegedpopulation is facing starvation, displacement and annihilation amid relentless bombardment and suffocating restrictions on life-saving humanitarian aid. “Our research reveals that, for months, Israel has persisted incommitting genocidal acts, fully aware of the irreparable harm it was inflicting on Palestinians in Gaza. It continued to do so in defiance of countless warnings about the catastrophichumanitarian situation and of legally binding decisions from the International Court of Justice (ICJ) ordering Israel to takeimmediate measures to enable the provision of humanitarian assistance to civilians in Gaza,” said Agnès Callamard. “Israel has repeatedly argued that its actions in Gaza are lawful and can be justified by its military goal to eradicateHamas. But genocidal intent can co-exist alongside military goals and does not need to be Israel’s sole intent.” Amnesty International examined Israel’s acts in Gaza closely and in their totality, taking into account theirrecurrence and simultaneous occurrence, and both their immediate impact and their cumulative and mutually reinforcing consequences. The organization considered thescale and severity of the casualties and destruction over time. It also analysed public statements by officials, findingthat prohibited acts were often announced or called for in the first place by high-level officials in charge of the war efforts. “Taking into account the pre-existing context of dispossession, apartheid and unlawful military occupation in which these acts have been committed, we could find only one reasonableconclusion: Israel’s intent is the physical destruction of Palestinians in Gaza, whether in parallel with, or as a means toachieve, its military goal of destroying Hamas,” said Agnès Callamard. “The atrocity crimes committed on 7 October 2023 by Hamas and other armed groups against Israelis and victimsof other nationalities, including deliberate mass killings and hostage-taking, can never justify Israel’s genocide againstPalestinians in Gaza.” International jurisprudence recognizes that the perpetratordoes not need to succeed in their attempts to destroy the protected group, either in whole or in part, for genocide tohave been committed. The commission of prohibited actswith the intent to destroy the group, as such, is sufficient. Amnesty International’s report examines in detail Israel’s violations in Gaza over nine months between 7 October2023 and early July 2024. The organization interviewed 212 people, including Palestinian victims and witnesses, local authorities in Gaza, healthcare workers, conducted fieldworkand analysed an extensive range of visual and digital evidence, including satellite imagery. It also analysedstatements by senior Israeli government and militaryofficials, and official Israeli bodies. On multiple occasions, the organization shared its findings with the Israeliauthorities but had received no substantive response at the time of publication. Unprecedented scale and magnitude Israel’s actions following Hamas’s deadly attacks on 7October 2023 have brought Gaza’s population to the brink of collapse. Its brutal military offensive had killed more than42,000 Palestinians, including over 13,300 children, and injured over 97,000 more, by 7 October 2024, many of them in direct or deliberately indiscriminate attacks, often wipingout entire multigenerational families. It has caused unprecedented destruction, which experts say occurred at alevel and speed not seen in any other conflict in the 21st century, levelling entire cities and destroying critical infrastructure, agricultural land and cultural and religioussites. It thereby rendered large swathes of Gaza uninhabitable. Mohammed, who fled with his family from Gaza City to Rafah in March 2024 and was displaced again in May 2024,described their struggle to survive in horrifying conditions: “Here in Deir al-Balah, it’s like an apocalypse… You have to protect your children from insects, from the heat, and thereis no clean water, no toilets, all while the bombing never stops. You feel like you are subhuman here.” Israel imposed conditions of life in Gaza that created a deadly mixture of malnutrition, hunger and diseases, andexposed Palestinians to a slow, calculated death. Israel also subjected hundreds of Palestinians from Gaza to incommunicado detention, torture and other ill-treatment. Viewed in isolation, some of the acts investigated byAmnesty International constitute serious violations of international humanitarian law or international human rightslaw. But in looking at the broader picture of Israel’s militarycampaign and the cumulative impact of its policies and acts, genocidal intent is the only reasonable conclusion. Intent to destroy To establish Israel’s specific intent to physically destroy Palestinians in Gaza, as such, Amnesty International analysed the overall pattern of Israel’s conduct in Gaza,reviewed dehumanizing and genocidal statements by Israeli government and military officials, particularly those at thehighest levels, and considered the context of Israel’s systemof apartheid, its inhumane blockade of Gaza and the unlawful 57-year-old military occupation of the Palestinianterritory. Before reaching its conclusion, Amnesty International examined Israel’s claims that its military lawfully targeted Hamas and other armed groups throughout Gaza, and thatthe resulting unprecedented destruction and denial of aid were the outcome of unlawful conduct by Hamas and otherarmed groups, such as locating fighters among the civilian population or the diversion of aid. The organization concluded these claims are not credible. The presence ofHamas fighters near or within a densely populated area does not absolve Israel from its obligations to take allfeasible precautions to spare civilians and avoidindiscriminate or disproportionate attacks. Its research found Israel repeatedly failed to do so, committing multiple crimesunder international law for which there can be no justification based on Hamas’s actions. AmnestyInternational also found no evidence that the diversion of aidcould explain Israel’s extreme and deliberate restrictions on life-saving humanitarian aid. In its analysis, the organization also considered alternativearguments such as ones that Israel was acting recklessly or that it simply wanted to destroy Hamas and did not care if it needed to destroy Palestinians in the process,demonstrating a callous disregard for their lives rather than genocidal intent. Our damning findings must serve as a wake-up call to the international community: this is genocide. It must stop now. Agnès Callamard, Amnesty International However, regardless of whether Israel sees the destructionof Palestinians as instrumental to destroying Hamas or as an acceptable by-product of this goal, this view ofPalestinians as disposable and not worthy of consideration is in itself evidence of genocidal intent. Many of the unlawful acts documented by Amnesty International were preceded by officials urging theirimplementation. The organization reviewed 102 statements that were issued by Israeli government and military officials and others between 7 October 2023 and 30 June 2024 anddehumanized Palestinians, called for or justified genocidal acts or other crimes against them. Of these, Amnesty International identified 22 statementsmade by senior officials in charge of managing the offensivethat appeared to call for, or justify, genocidal acts, providing direct evidence of genocidal intent. This language wasfrequently replicated, including by Israeli soldiers on the ground, as evidenced by audiovisual content verified byAmnesty International showing soldiers making calls to“erase” Gaza or to make it uninhabitable, and celebrating the destruction of Palestinian homes, mosques, schools anduniversities. Killing and causing serious bodily ormental harm Amnesty International documented the genocidal acts of killing and causing serious mental and bodily harm toPalestinians in Gaza by reviewing the results of investigations it conducted into 15 air strikes between 7October 2023 and 20 April 2024 that killed at least 334 civilians, including 141 children, and wounded hundreds of others. Amnesty International found no evidence that any ofthese strikes were directed at a military objective. In one illustrative case, on 20 April 2024, an Israeli air strike destroyed the Abdelal family house in the Al-Jneinah neighbourhood in eastern Rafah, killing three generations ofPalestinians, including 16 children, while they were sleeping. While these represent just a fraction of Israel’s aerial attacks, they are indicative of a broader pattern of repeateddirect attacks on civilians and civilian objects or deliberately indiscriminate attacks. The attacks were also conducted inways designed to cause a very high number of fatalities and injuries among the civilian population. Inflicting conditions of life calculatedto bring about physical destruction The report documents how Israel deliberately inflicted conditions of life on Palestinians in Gaza intended to lead,over time, to their destruction. These conditions were imposed through three simultaneous patterns thatrepeatedly compounded the effect of each other’s devastating impacts: damage to and destruction of life- sustaining infrastructure and other objects indispensable tothe survival of the civilian population; the repeated use of sweeping, arbitrary and confusing mass “evacuation” ordersto forcibly displace almost all of Gaza’s population; and the denial and obstruction of the delivery of essential services, humanitarian assistance and other life-saving supplies intoand within Gaza. After 7 October 2023, Israel imposed a total siege on Gaza cutting off electricity, water and fuel. In the nine months reviewed for this report, Israel maintained a suffocating,unlawful blockade, tightly controlled access to energy sources, failed to facilitate meaningful humanitarian accesswithin Gaza, and obstructed the import and delivery of life- saving goods and humanitarian aid, particularly to areas north of Wadi Gaza. They thereby exacerbated an alreadyexisting humanitarian crisis. This, combined with the extensive damage to Gaza’s homes, hospitals, water andsanitation facilities and agricultural land, and mass forced displacement, caused catastrophic levels of hunger and led to the spread of diseases at alarming rates. The impact wasespecially harsh on young children and pregnant or breastfeeding women, with anticipated long-termconsequences for their health. The international community’s seismic, shameful failure for over a year to pressIsrael to end its atrocities in Gaza, by first delaying calls for a ceasefire and thencontinuing arms transfers, is and will remaina stain on our collective conscience. Agnès Callamard, Amnesty International Time and again, Israel had the chance to improve thehumanitarian situation in Gaza, yet for over a year it has repeatedly refused to take steps blatantly within its power todo so, such as opening sufficient access points to Gaza orlifting tight restrictions on what could enter the Strip or their obstruction of aid deliveries within Gaza while the situationhas grown progressively worse. Through its repeated “evacuation” orders Israel displaced nearly 1.9 million Palestinians – 90% of Gaza’s population – into ever-shrinking, unsafe pockets of land under inhumaneconditions, some of them up to 10 times. These multiplewaves of forced displacement left many jobless and deeply traumatized, especially since some 70% of Gaza’s residentsare refugees or descendants of refugees whose towns and villages were ethnically cleansed by Israel during the 1948Nakba. Despite conditions quickly becoming unfit for human life,Israeli authorities refused to consider measures that would have protected displaced civilians and ensured their basicneeds were met, showing that their actions were deliberate. They refused to allow those displaced to return to their homes in northern Gaza or relocate temporarily to otherparts of the Occupied Palestinian Territory or Israel, continuing to deny many Palestinians their right to returnunder international law to areas they were displacedfrom in 1948. They did so knowing that there was nowhere safe for Palestinians in Gaza to flee to. Accountability for genocide “The international community’s seismic, shameful failure forover a year to press Israel to end its atrocities in Gaza, by first delaying calls for a ceasefire and then continuing armstransfers, is and will remain a stain on our collective conscience,” said Agnès Callamard. “Governments must stop pretending they are powerless to end this genocide, which was enabled by decades ofimpunity for Israel’s violations of international law. States need to move beyond mere expressions of regret or dismayand take strong and sustained international action, howeveruncomfortable a finding of genocide may be for some of Israel’s allies. “The International Criminal Court’s (ICC) arrest warrants forPrime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former DefenseMinister Yoav Gallant for war crimes and crimes against humanity issued last month offer real hope of long-overduejustice for victims. States must demonstrate their respect for the court’s decision and for universal international lawprinciples by arresting and handing over those wanted bythe ICC. “We are calling on the Office of the Prosecutor of the International Criminal Court (ICC) to urgently consideradding genocide to the list of crimes it is investigating andfor all states to use every legal avenue to bring perpetrators to justice. No one should be allowed to commit genocideand remain unpunished.” Amnesty International is also calling for all civilian hostages to be released unconditionally and for Hamas and other Palestinian armed groups responsible for the crimescommitted on 7 October to be held to account. The organization is also calling for the UN Security Councilto impose targeted sanctions against Israeli and Hamas officials most implicated in crimes under international law. Background On 7 October 2023 Hamas and other armedgroups indiscriminately fired rockets into southernIsrael and carried out deliberate mass killings and hostage-taking there, killing 1,200 people, including over 800 civilians, and abducted 223 civilians and captured 27soldiers. The crimes perpetrated by Hamas and other armedgroups during this attack will be the focus of a forthcoming Amnesty International report. Since October 2023, Amnesty International has conducted in-depth investigations into the multiple violations and crimes underinternational law committed by Israeli forces, including direct attacks on civilians and civilian objects and deliberatelyindiscriminate attacks killing hundreds of civilians, as well as other unlawful attacks on and collective punishment of the civilianpopulation. The organization has called on the Office of the ICCProsecutor to expedite its investigation into the situation in the State of Palestine and is campaigning for an immediate ceasefire. For the Hebrew translation of this press release, click here. INTERNATIONAL JUSTICE ISRAEL AND THE OCCUPIED PALESTINIAN TERRITORY MIDDLE EAST MIDDLE EAST AND NORTH AFRICA NEWS PRESS RELEASE WAR CRIMES AND CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY Related Content COUNTRY Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territory NEWS New NATO defence commitments must notcome at cost of human rights NEWS Gaza: Starvation or gunfire – this is not ahumanitarian response NEWS DRC: Peace deal with Rwanda fails toaddress serious crimes committed ineastern DRC NEWS Gaza: Evidence points to Israel’s continueduse of starvation to inflict genocide againstPalestinians Recently added Cambodia: Scamming crisis survivors must be protected amid police crackdown Ireland: Amnesty’s head urges Irish governmentto press ahead with Occupied Territories Bill Angola: Authorities must respect and ensure the right to freedom of peaceful assembly Russia: Proposed amendments to counter-extremism laws escalate assault on dissent EU-Israel: Refusal to suspend the EU-Israel Association Agreement is a ‘cruel and unlawfulbetrayal’ DONATE TO PROTECTHUMAN RIGHTS Women's Day protest in Mexico Together we can fight for human rightseverywhere. Your donation can transform thelives of millions. ABOUT US Contact UsHow We’re Run Modern Slavery Act Statement FinancesRESOURCES Media CentreHuman Rights EducationHuman Rights Courses Annual report archiveGET INVOLVED Join Take ActionVolunteer LATEST NewsCampaigns ResearchWORK WITH US If you are talented and passionate about human rights then Amnesty International wants to hear from you. Privacy Policy Accessibility Cookie StatementPermissions Refunds of Donations © 2025 Amnesty International FOLLOW US ON: Facebook Instagram X TikTok Bluesky YouTube LinkedIn On Sun, Jul 20, 2025 at 10:03 AM Martin Wasserman<deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:Aram, If that's the definition of genocide, then Israel is clearlyNOT committing genocide in Gaza. If Israel weretrying to kill as many Gazans as possible, the death tollwould be much, much higher than it is. They wouldn'tallow any food or medicine in at all, and they wouldn'tissue evacuation warnings before striking Hamastargets. The truth is, Israel goes to great lengths to avoidcivilian casualties, but Hamas makes it very difficultby deliberately placing their command centers incivilian locations such as schools and hospitals. The only group that Israel wants to destroy is Hamas,which does have an explicit policy of genocide (byyour definition) against Jews. Yes, the Gazans are suffering, but Hamas could endtheir suffering tomorrow if they wanted to. All theyhave to do is lay down their arms and release thehostages, and the war would be over immediately. ButHamas has no interest in ending the suffering of theGazans. What they're actually calling for is an open-ended war of attrition against Israel, no matter what thecost to their own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 18, 2025, at 8:26 PM, Aram James<abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Genocide defined: the deliberate killing of a large number of people from a particular nation or ethnic group with the aim of destroying that nation or group. "a campaign of genocide" On Fri, Jul 18, 2025 at 4:04 PM MartinWasserman <deeperlook@aol.com>wrote:It appears that "genocide" can be defined in several different ways. Perhaps we should stop using thatterm altogether and stick to wordsthat have clear and unambiguous meanings. On Jul 18, 2025, at12:25 PM, Aram James<abjpd1@gmail.com>wrote: I’m a Genocide Scholar. I Know It When I See It”: Prof.Omer Bartov on the Growing Consensus on Gaza My inescapable conclusion has become that Israel is committing genocide against the Palestinian people. Having grown up in a Zionist home, lived the first half of my life in Israel, served in the I.D.F. as a soldier and officer and spent most of my career researching and writing on war crimes and the Holocaust, this was a painful conclusion to reach, and one that I resisted as long as I could. But I have been teaching classes on genocide for a quarter of a century. I can recognize one when I see one A month after the Hamas attack on Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, I believed there was evidence that the Israeli military had committed war crimes and potentially crimes against humanity in its counterattack on Gaza. But contrary to the cries of Israel’s fiercest critics, the evidence did not seem to me to rise to the crime of genocide. By May 2024, the Israel Defense Forces had ordered about one million Palestinians sheltering in Rafah — the southernmost and last remaining relatively undamaged city of the Gaza Strip — to move to the beach area of the Mawasi, where there was little to no shelter. The army then proceeded to destroy much of Rafah, a feat mostly accomplished by August. At that point it appeared no longer possible to deny that the pattern of I.D.F. operations was consistent with the statements denoting genocidal intent made by Israeli leaders in the days after the Hamas attack. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had promised that the enemy would pay a “huge price” for the attack and that the I.D.F. would turn parts of Gaza, where Hamas was operating, “into rubble,” and he called on “the residents of Gaza” to “leave now because we will operate forcefully everywhere.” Mr. Netanyahu had urged his citizens to remember “what Amalek did to you,” a quote many interpreted as a reference to the demand in a biblical passage calling for the Israelites to “kill alike men and women, infants and sucklings” of their ancient enemy. Government and military officials said they were fighting “human animals” and, later, called for “total annihilation.” Nissim Vaturi, the deputy speaker of Parliament, said on Xthat Israel’s task must be “erasing the Gaza Strip from the face of the earth.” Israel’s actions could be understood only as the implementation of the expressed intent to make the Gaza Strip uninhabitable for its Palestinian population. I believe the goal was — and remains today — to force the population to leave the Strip altogether or, considering that it has nowhere to go, to debilitate the enclave through bombings and severe deprivation of food, clean water, sanitation and medical aid to such an extent that it is impossible for Palestinians in Gaza to maintain or reconstitute their existence as a group. ADVERTISEMENT SKIP ADVERTISEMENT My inescapable conclusion has become that Israel is committing genocide against the Palestinian people. Having grown up in a Zionist home, lived the first half of my life in Israel, served in the I.D.F. as a soldier and officer and spent most of my career researching and writing on war crimes and the Holocaust, this was a painful conclusion to reach, and one that I resisted as long as I could. But I have been teaching classes on genocide for a quarter of a century. I can recognize one when I see one. This is not just my conclusion. A growing number of experts in genocide studies and international law have concluded that Israel’s actions in Gaza can only be defined as genocide. So has Francesca Albanese, the U.N. special rapporteur for the West Bank and Gaza, and Amnesty International. South Africa has brought a genocide case against Israel at the International Court of Justice. Image People inspecting a huge pile of rubble. Credit...JehadAlshrafi/Associated Press The continued denial of this designation by states, international organizations and legal and scholarly experts will cause unmitigated damage not just to the people of Gaza and Israel but also to the system of international law established in the wake of the horrors of the Holocaust, designed to prevent such atrocities from happening ever again. It is a threat to the very foundations of the moral order on which we all depend.*** The crime of genocide was defined in 1948 by the United Nations as the “intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such.” In determining what constitutes genocide, therefore, we must both establish intent and show that it is being carried out. In Israel’s case, that intent has been publicly expressed by numerous officials and leaders. But intent can also be derived from a pattern of operations on the ground, and this pattern became clear by May 2024 — and has since become ever clearer — as the I.D.F. has systematically destroyed the Gaza Strip. ADVERTISEMENT SKIP ADVERTISEMENT Most genocide scholars are cautious about applying this term to contemporary events, precisely because of the tendency, since it was coined by the Jewish-Polish lawyer Raphael Lemkin in 1944, to attribute it to any case of massacre or inhumanity. Indeed, some argue that the categorization should be entirely discarded, because it often serves more to express outrage than to identify a particular crime. Yet as Mr. Lemkin recognized, and as the United Nations later agreed, it is crucial to be able to distinguish the attempt to destroy a particular group of people from other crimes under international law, such as war crimes and crimes against humanity. This is because, while other crimes entail indiscriminate or deliberate killing of civilians as individuals, genocide denotes the killing of people as members of a group, geared at irreparably destroying the group itself so that it would never be able to reconstitute itself as a political, social or cultural entity. And, as the international community signaled by adopting the convention, it is incumbent upon all signatory states to prevent such an attempt, to do all they can to stop it while it is occurring and to subsequently punish those who were engaged in this crime of crimes — even if it occurred within the borders of a sovereign state. The designation has major political, legal and moral ramifications. Nations, politicians and military personnel suspected of, indicted on a charge of or found guilty of genocide are seen as beyond the pale of humanity and may compromise or lose their right to remain members of the international community. A finding by the International Court of Justice that a particular state is engaged in genocide, especially if enforced by the U.N. Security Council, can lead to severe sanctions. Sign up for the Opinion Today newsletter Get expert analysis of the news and a guide to the big ideas shaping the world every weekday morning. Get it sent to your inbox. Politicians or generals indicted on a charge of or found guilty of genocide or other breaches of international humanitarian law by the International Criminal Court can face arrest outside of their country. And a society that condones and is complicit in genocide, whatever the stand of its individual citizens may be, will carry this mark of Cain long after the fires of hatred and violence are put out.*** From:Martin Wasserman To:Aram James Cc:assemblymember.berman@assembly.ca.gov; Josh Becker; Jeff Rosen; Jay Boyarsky; Veenker, Vicki; h.etzko@gmail.com; Jessica Speiser,Educational Leader for California Democratic Delegate, Assembly District 23; Foley, Michael; Dave Price; GRP-City Council; Raymond Goins;Raj Jayadev; Patrice Ventresca; Figueroa, Eric; Lotus Fong; Reifschneider, James; Binder, Andrew; Gardener, Liz; Diana Diamond; YolandaConaway; yolanda; Don Austin; jgreen@dailynewsgroup.com; Human Relations Commission; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto; Perron, Zachary;Robert Salonga; Baker, Rob; Robert. Jonsen; Roberta Ahlquist; Steve Wagstaffe; Wagner, April; Jeff Conrad; Burt, Patrick; PD Kristina Bell;Bill Newell; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; Councilmember Chappie Jones; District9@sanjoseca.gov; District4@sanjoseca.gov;District5@sanjoseca.gov; District2@sanjoseca.gov; EPA Today; Gennady Sheyner; Council, City; city.council@menlopark.gov; VaraRamakrishnan; cromero@cityofepa.org; Cribbs, Anne; <michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com>; Stump, Molly; board@pausd.org;BoardOperations; Damon Silver; Rodriguez, Miguel; Cait James; Zelkha, Mila; dennis burns; DuJuan Green; Gerry Gras; Enberg, Nicholas;Rowena Chiu; Barberini, Christopher; Reckdahl, Keith; Dana St. George; Blackshire, Geoffrey; Tom DuBois; Friends of Cubberley;Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Greg Tanaka; Ed Lauing; Yi Chen; Donna Wallach; Mickie Winkler; Supervisor Otto Lee; Mark Turner; CityAttorney; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; Sean Allen; Seher Awan; Pat M; Carla Torres; David Piper; josh@joshsalcman.com;board@valleywater.org; boardfeedback@smcgov.org; Jay Boyarsky; Linda Jolley; San José Spotlight; vramirez@redwoodcity.org Subject:Re: Block the Bombs_1_2 sheet Date:Monday, July 21, 2025 6:33:08 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of openingattachments and clicking on links. Again, Hamas could end the suffering tomorrow just by laying down their arms and releasing the hostages. Martin Wasserman On Jul 21, 2025, at 10:59 AM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Sew Zee Palestinians Are Collapsing inGaza's Streets From Israeli-ImposedStarvation Campaign A frontline report on a people forced to face death from starvation or being shot in aperilous quest to obtain meager rations ABDEL QADER SABBAH AND SHARIF ABDEL KOUDDOUS JUL 21 READ IN APP The level of killing and forced starvation in Gaza by the Israeli military in recent days has been difficult to fathom. Journalist Abdel Qader Sabbah, who reported this story from northern Gaza, is himself struggling to fight the spreading famine. He is severely weakened and can barely stand on his own two feet anymore. On Sunday, his meal for the entire day consisted of half a loaf of bread. “There is nothing to eat,” he said. His bravery and resilience in reporting on the unfolding genocide in Gaza is remarkable. We have a commitment to ensuring that our journalism is not locked behind a paywall. But the only way we can sustain this is through the voluntary support of our community of readers. If you are a free subscriber and you support our work, please consider upgrading to a paid subscription. You can also make a 501(c)(3) tax-deductible donation to support our work. Upgrade to paid The bodies of Palestinians killed in an Israeli attack on the Zikim area in the northern Gaza Strip are seen lying on the ground at Al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza City, Gaza, on July 20, 2025. (Photo by Saeed M. M. T. Jaras/Anadolu via Getty Images) GAZA CITY—Israel's war of extermination in Gaza continues to plunge to new depths of horror. Starving Palestinians have begun to collapse in the streets and die of hunger as a result of the siege. Those who try to get food are gunned down in ever deadlier aid massacres. The Israeli military issues frequent mass expulsion orders and further expands its ground operations, slicing up the enclave and forcibly displacing Palestinians into more concentrated zones. All the while, the relentless aerial assault and ground attacks persist. Over the past five days alone, more than 550 Palestinians have been killed in Gaza, according to ministry of health figures. The confirmed death toll since the beginning of the war crossed 59,000 on Monday in what is widely acknowledged to be a vast undercount. Over the past two months, more than 1,000 Palestinians have been killed as they are forced to seek aid in militarized zones in a system mostly overseen by the Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF), a shadowy U.S.- and Israeli-backed group. One of the deadliest days for aid seekers came on Sunday, when over 70 people were killed, at least 67 of them in northern Gaza where Israeli troops opened fire on crowds trying to get food from a World Food Program convoy entering through the Zikim crossing. “The tank came, surrounded us, and started shooting at us and we kept raising our hands,” Ibrahim Hamada, who was wounded in the leg, told Drop Site as he lay on a hospital gurney wincing in pain. “There were many martyrs, no one was able to retrieve them. I crawled on my stomach just to reach a car to take me to the hospital,” he said. “I went there to eat, because there was no food at home.” Scenes from Shifa hospital after Israeli troops opened fire on Palestinians seeking aid near the Zikim crossing. Video by Abdel Qader Sabbah. July 20, 2025. Over 150 people were wounded in the attack. Al-Shifa Hospital in Gaza City was overwhelmed with the dead and wounded, most of them young men and boys. Malnourished, gaunt faces poked out of white shrouds laid over their bodies on the ground. At the nearby Sheikh Radwan clinic, more than a dozen corpses in white body bags were lined up in the courtyard. Relatives searching for their loved ones came and gingerly pulled back part of the surface of the body bags to peer inside and see if they recognized anyone. “The situation is very difficult. We transported the martyrs, as you can see, and moved the injured from a place close to the area that was targeted by quadcopter bombs, gunfire, or by the new [weaponized] crane located at the aid distribution site,” said Mohammed al-Hout, an emergency medical worker with the Red Crescent. “People were shot in the head or the feet.… Some of the martyrs have shattered skulls.” Scenes from Sheikh Radwan clinic after Israeli troops opened fire on Palestinians seeking aid near the Zikim crossing. Video by Abdel Qader Sabbah. July 20, 2025. The UN World Food Program said in a statement that 25 trucks carrying food entered Gaza on Sunday through the Zikim crossing “destined for starving communities in northern Gaza.” “Shortly after passing the final checkpoint beyond the Zikim crossing point into Gaza, the convoy encountered large crowds of civilians anxiously waiting to access desperately needed food supplies,” the WFP said. “As the convoy approached, the surrounding crowd came under fire from Israeli tanks, snipers, and other gunfire.” The statement added: “These people were simply trying to access food to feed themselves and their families on the brink of starvation.” Also on Sunday, nine Palestinians were killed near an “aid distribution” hub in Rafah run by the GHF. The killings happened at the same site where over 20 people had been killed a few days earlier when GHF guards gassedstarving Palestinians fenced in at the hub, causing many to die from suffocation and a stampede. These daily killings of Palestinians desperate for food and an imminent famine have combined to create an unprecedented emergency in Gaza. Israel’s full-spectrum blockade imposed on March 2 was nominally lifted on May 27 when meager amounts of aid began to be distributed to four militarized GHF hubs, three of which are located in the southern end of Gaza and one in Wadi Gaza. With the entire population on the brink of famine, Palestinians have no choice but to starve or risk their lives at so-called aid distribution hubs. “People got hungry. They had no choice but to head towards the places of death. Either way, they’re going to die,” Abu Maher Al-Masry, who witnessed Sunday’s killings near the Zikim crossing, told Drop Site. “I am a grown man who can't even walk from hunger. It has been more than a day since I last had a single bite to eat.” On Sunday, the health ministry said that 18 people had died from starvation over the past day. A day earlier, the ministry issued an urgent bulletin saying “unprecedented numbers of starving people of all ages are arriving at emergency rooms in a state of extreme exhaustion and fatigue. We warn that hundreds of those whose bodies have emaciated will be at risk of certain death as a result of starvation and their bodies' ability to withstand being overwhelmed.” Multiple reports have documented Palestinians sifting through garbage, scraping spilled food from the ground and eating from trash in the streets. The UN estimates that nearly one in three people is not eating for days. Journalist Nahed Hajjaj posted on social media: “Do not be surprised when we journalists stop covering news here. I swear by God that today I could not get up from the hunger. There is no food. Even if someone has money, there is nothing in the market to even purchase.” Meanwhile, Al Jazeera correspondent Anas al-Sharif broke down in tears during a live broadcast outside Al-Shifa Hospital as a woman nearby collapsed from hunger. “People are collapsing in the streets from hunger—just falling right there from extreme starvation,” he said. In response, an Israeli military spokesperson jeered at Al- Sharif on social media, saying it was “nothing but crocodile tears that comes as part of a deceptive and staged Hamas performance.” A total of 86 Palestinians, including 76 children, have died of hunger and malnutrition since the war began in what the health ministry on Sunday called “a silent massacre.” Drop Site News is reader-supported. Consider becoming a free or paid subscriber. Upgrade to paid Philippe Lazzarini, the head of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees (UNRWA)—that used to help oversee aid distribution in Gaza before Israel imposed its blockade and barred independent organizations—said on social media that the crisis was “all man-made, in total impunity.” “Food is available only a few kilometers away,” Lazzarini posted on X on Sunday. “UNRWA alone has enough stock available outside of #Gaza for the entire population for the next 3 months. We have not been allowed to bring any aid in since 2 March.” The widening starvation and famine comes as the Israeli military continues to expand its ground invasion, issuing repeated displacement orders, with more than 86% of Gaza now in a so-called “red zone”—either under active displacement orders or in a “combat” zone. For the first time since the beginning of the war, the Israeli military on Saturday issueddisplacement orders in an area of Deir al-Balah in central Gaza, stretching to the coastline, along the so-called “Kissufim corridor.” Deir al- Balah is one of the few areas where Israeli ground troops have rarely operated and where the headquarters of several UN agencies and medical NGOs are based. The expulsion order effectively cuts access between Deir al- Balah and cities in the south of Khan Younis and Rafah. The Israeli military ordered people to head south to al- Mawasi, a tent camp on the southern coast that has been designated a “humanitarian zone,” which Israel has regularly bombed—most recently killing over 20 people, including children, sheltering in tents in an airstrike on Sunday. Displacement orders were also reissued for northern Gaza, with the entire area north of al-Quds street and Salah Khalaf street designated an off limit “combat zone.” Last week, the Israeli military announced it had finished bulldozing a 15-kilometer (9.3-mile) path through Khan Younis establishing what it called the "Magen Oz" corridor, cutting eastern Khan Younis off from the west side. The corridor is the latest of several zones that the Israeli military has carved through Gaza using wide-scale demolitions to divide the strip into separate regions: the Morag corridor, which adjoins Magen Oz and cuts Rafah off from Khan Younis; the Mefalsim corridor, which separates northern Gaza from Gaza City; and the Netzarim corridor, which runs along Wadi Gaza, cutting off the north from the south. There are no signs that Israel’s assault will ease anytime soon and the international community has taken no steps to force Israel to end its attacks and to allow massive amounts of aid needed to stave off mass starvation. “Damn this silence. Damn this famine,” said Eyad Amawi, a representative of the Gaza Relief Committee and a coordinator for local NGOs. “Damn it all—humanity has collapsed.” Drop Site News Middle East Research Fellow Jawa Ahmad contributed to this report. Leave a comment A guest post by Abdel Qader Sabbah journalist and videographer in northern Gaza Subscribe to Abdel Become a Drop Site News PaidSubscriber Drop Site News is reader-supported. Please consider becoming a paid subscribertoday. Upgrade to paid A paid subscription gets you: 15% off Drop Site store Access to our Discord, subscriber-only AMAs, chats, and invites to events, both virtual and IRL Post comments and join the community The knowledge you are supporting independent media making the lives of the powerful miserable You can also now find us on podcast platforms and on Facebook, Twitter, Bluesky, Telegram, and YouTube. LIKE COMMENT RESTACK © 2025 Drop Site News, Inc.Drop Site News Inc., 4315 50th St. NWSte 100 Unit #2560, Washington, DC 20016Unsubscribe On Mon, Jul 21, 2025 at 10:46 AM Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:Hi Avram, There seems to be a contradiction in your statement. You say you want Israel to beeliminated, but also say that you want it to pay reparations for 100 years. How could itpay reparations if it no longer exists? Martin Wasserman On Jul 20, 2025, at 8:08 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Subject: A Call for Change Hi Martin, I want to be very clear about my position. I support the elimination of Israel and advocate for a one-state solution. Israel must pay reparations to the Palestinian people for a hundred years and rebuild Gaza and the West Bank. The genocidal Israeli war criminals must be held fully accountable, just like the Nazi war criminals. As a secular Jew, I find no value in Hebrew scripture; to me, it is merely creative writing and fantasy at best. The nations that have stood up to the Nazi- like Israeli state are the true heroes. Avram “Eliminate Israel Now” Finkelstein On Sun, Jul 20, 2025 at 7:26 PM Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:The Hebrew Scriptures predict a time when all the nations will gathertogether against Israel, and God will then intervene on Israel’s behalf and judge all those nations with truth and justice. We appear to be approaching that time very rapidly, and I strongly suspect that those people and nationswho have dedicated themselves to Israel’s destruction will fare verypoorly in those judgments! Martin Wasserman On Jul 20, 2025, at 3:30 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com>wrote: Condemn Israel or be complicit in genocide': Colombia's Gustavo Petro By Al Mayadeen English Source: The Guardian 8 Jul 2025 13:47 2 Shares 4 Min Read Colombian President Gustavo Petro, in a Guardian op-ed, accuses Netanyahu of genocide in Gaza and urges global action. Listen On Tuesday, The Guardian published an opinion piece by Colombian President Gustavo Petro, in which he accused Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of orchestrating a "campaign of devastation" in Gaza and called on the international community to move beyond symbolic outrage toward concrete action in defense of international law. Petro has emerged as one of the most outspoken world leaders condemning "Israel’s" war on Gaza, and his latest opinion piece adds to a growing series of forceful critiques directed at the ongoing Israeli genocide. Denouncing what he described as 600 days of systematic atrocities, Petro wrote that the world's inaction risks legitimizing a model of impunity where colonial violence, ethnic cleansing, and siege warfare are normalized against a captive population. "If we fail to act now," he wrote, "we not only betray the Palestinian people, we become complicit in the atrocities committed by Netanyahu's government." Moral break The president highlighted a landmark United Nations General Assembly resolution adopted in September 2024, which called for "Israel" to end its illegal occupation within 12 months. He noted that Colombia was among the 124 countries that voted in favor, thereby assuming binding obligations that include sanctions, legal action, and trade measures. "The clock is now ticking," he warned, reaffirming Colombia's commitment by recalling its concrete step: suspending coal exports to "Israel." Related News 650 days of genocide: 125,000 tons of bombs 2.4 mln lives shattered Starved by 'Israel': People of Gaza are dying while the world watches In his piece, Petro mentioned that he had declared earlier this year: "We cannot fuel the machinery that slaughters Palestinian children and then claim neutrality." This is not the first bold move by the Colombian president. In May, his government formally cut diplomatic ties with "Israel," citing what Petro explicitly described as a "genocide." His administration also appointed Colombia’s first ambassador to Palestine, pledging medical treatment in Colombian hospitals for injured children from Gaza. The newly appointed ambassador, Jorge Iván Ospina, later echoed Petro’s position, warning of a "macabre intention to erase the identity of a people." In Tuesday's article, Petro praised similar actions taken by countries like Malaysia, which banned Israeli ships from its ports, and South Africa, which brought "Israel" before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) on charges of genocide. It is worth noting that Colombia joined that case as an intervening party, further deepening its legal opposition to "Israel's" war. Read more: US defends Israeli use of starvation as weapon of war before ICJ Global reckoning Looking ahead, Petro mentioned that Colombia and South Africa, co-chairs of the Hague Group, will host an emergency summit regarding Gaza on July 15. The conference aims to develop a coordinated, multilateral strategy to isolate "Israel" diplomatically and economically while restoring credibility to the global legal order. With the UN's proposed international peace conference indefinitely postponed, Petro cast the July summit as a necessary corrective to global paralysis. The Colombian president framed the Gaza crisis not just as a moral catastrophe but as an existential test for international law and nations of the Global South. "We can either stand firm in defense of the legal principles that seek to prevent war and conflict," he wrote, "or watch helplessly as the international system collapses under the weight of unchecked power politics." He concluded his piece by stressing that the choice is between complicity in colonial violence and collective resistance against it. On Sun, Jul 20, 2025 at 3:12 PM Martin Wasserman<deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:Aram, Amnesty International is not a credible source on this issue. Itappears that the once-respectable organization has been taken overby malevolent actors with a political axe to grind. Their anti-Israelbias is evident throughout the report. They accuse Israel of genocide but make no mention at all of Hamas’explicit genocidal policy against Jews. They accuse Israel of violating international law, but make noreference at all to the fact that Israel is facing a ruthless enemy thatobserves no international laws whatsoever. When they mention Hamas’ transgressions at all, they do it in themildest language possible, and then use the most damning possiblelanguage when describing Israel's actions. They take it as a given that Israel is an apartheid state, a blatantlyfalse accusation that is very easily disproved. They take it as a given that Israel is illegally occupying Palestinianland, as if the territories of Judea and Samaria, the heartland of theancient Jewish nation, don't belong to Jews at all, but are instead theproperty of a fictitious country called “Palestine” which has neveractually existed in any historical period. In short, this entire report is a politically motivated “hatchet job” thatdeserves no credibility whatsoever. Martin Wasserman On Jul 20, 2025, at 11:39 AM, Aram James<abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Amnesty Internationalinvestigation concludesIsrael is committinggenocide againstPalestinians in Gaza Amnesty International’s research has found sufficient basisto conclude that Israel has committed and is continuing tocommit genocide against Palestinians in the occupied GazaStrip, the organization said in a landmark new reportpublished today. The report, ‘You Feel Like You Are Subhuman’: Israel’s Genocide Against Palestinians in Gaza, documents how,during its military offensive launched in the wake of thedeadly Hamas-led attacks in southern Israel on 7 October2023, Israel has unleashed hell and destruction onPalestinians in Gaza brazenly, continuously and with totalimpunity. “Amnesty International’s report demonstrates that Israel hascarried out acts prohibited under the Genocide Convention, withthe specific intent to destroy Palestinians in Gaza. These actsinclude killings, causing serious bodily or mental harm anddeliberately inflicting on Palestinians in Gaza conditions of lifecalculated to bring about their physical destruction. Month aftermonth, Israel has treated Palestinians in Gaza as a subhumangroup unworthy of human rights and dignity, demonstrating itsintent to physically destroy them,” said Agnès Callamard,Secretary General of Amnesty International. “Our damning findings must serve as a wake-up call to theinternational community: this is genocide. It must stop now. “States that continue to transfer arms to Israel at this timemust know they are violating their obligation to prevent genocide and are at risk of becoming complicit in genocide. All states with influence over Israel, particularly key arms suppliers like the USA and Germany, but also other EU member states, the UK and others, must act now to bring Israel’s atrocities against Palestinians in Gaza to an immediate end.” Over the past two months the crisis has grown particularly acute in the North Gaza governorate, where a besieged population is facing starvation, displacement and annihilation amid relentless bombardment and suffocating restrictions on life-saving humanitarian aid. “Our research reveals that, for months, Israel has persisted incommitting genocidal acts, fully aware of the irreparable harm itwas inflicting on Palestinians in Gaza. It continued to do so indefiance of countless warnings about the catastrophichumanitarian situation and of legally binding decisions from theInternational Court of Justice (ICJ) ordering Israel to take immediate measures to enable the provision of humanitarian assistance to civilians in Gaza,” said Agnès Callamard. “Israel has repeatedly argued that its actions in Gaza arelawful and can be justified by its military goal to eradicateHamas. But genocidal intent can co-exist alongside militarygoals and does not need to be Israel’s sole intent.” Amnesty International examined Israel’s acts in Gazaclosely and in their totality, taking into account theirrecurrence and simultaneous occurrence, and both theirimmediate impact and their cumulative and mutuallyreinforcing consequences. The organization considered thescale and severity of the casualties and destruction overtime. It also analysed public statements by officials, findingthat prohibited acts were often announced or called for inthe first place by high-level officials in charge of the warefforts. “Taking into account the pre-existing context of dispossession,apartheid and unlawful military occupation in which these actshave been committed, we could find only one reasonableconclusion: Israel’s intent is the physical destruction ofPalestinians in Gaza, whether in parallel with, or as a means toachieve, its military goal of destroying Hamas,” said AgnèsCallamard. “The atrocity crimes committed on 7 October 2023 byHamas and other armed groups against Israelis and victimsof other nationalities, including deliberate mass killings andhostage-taking, can never justify Israel’s genocide againstPalestinians in Gaza.” International jurisprudence recognizes that the perpetratordoes not need to succeed in their attempts to destroy theprotected group, either in whole or in part, for genocide tohave been committed. The commission of prohibited actswith the intent to destroy the group, as such, is sufficient. Amnesty International’s report examines in detail Israel’s violations in Gaza over nine months between 7 October 2023 and early July 2024. The organization interviewed 212 people, including Palestinian victims and witnesses, local authorities in Gaza, healthcare workers, conducted fieldwork and analysed an extensive range of visual and digital evidence, including satellite imagery. It also analysed statements by senior Israeli government and military officials, and official Israeli bodies. On multiple occasions, the organization shared its findings with the Israeli authorities but had received no substantive response at the time of publication. Unprecedented scale and magnitude Israel’s actions following Hamas’s deadly attacks on 7October 2023 have brought Gaza’s population to the brinkof collapse. Its brutal military offensive had killed more than42,000 Palestinians, including over 13,300 children, andinjured over 97,000 more, by 7 October 2024, many of themin direct or deliberately indiscriminate attacks, often wipingout entire multigenerational families. It has causedunprecedented destruction, which experts say occurred at alevel and speed not seen in any other conflict in the 21stcentury, levelling entire cities and destroying criticalinfrastructure, agricultural land and cultural and religioussites. It thereby rendered large swathes of Gazauninhabitable. Mohammed, who fled with his family from Gaza City toRafah in March 2024 and was displaced again in May 2024,described their struggle to survive in horrifying conditions: “Here in Deir al-Balah, it’s like an apocalypse… You have to protect your children from insects, from the heat, and thereis no clean water, no toilets, all while the bombing neverstops. You feel like you are subhuman here.” Israel imposed conditions of life in Gaza that created a deadly mixture of malnutrition, hunger and diseases, and exposed Palestinians to a slow, calculated death. Israel also subjected hundreds of Palestinians from Gaza to incommunicado detention, torture and other ill-treatment. Viewed in isolation, some of the acts investigated by Amnesty International constitute serious violations of international humanitarian law or international human rights law. But in looking at the broader picture of Israel’s military campaign and the cumulative impact of its policies and acts, genocidal intent is the only reasonable conclusion. Intent to destroy To establish Israel’s specific intent to physically destroyPalestinians in Gaza, as such, Amnesty Internationalanalysed the overall pattern of Israel’s conduct in Gaza,reviewed dehumanizing and genocidal statements by Israeli government and military officials, particularly those at the highest levels, and considered the context of Israel’s system of apartheid, its inhumane blockade of Gaza and the unlawful 57-year-old military occupation of the Palestinian territory. Before reaching its conclusion, Amnesty International examined Israel’s claims that its military lawfully targeted Hamas and other armed groups throughout Gaza, and that the resulting unprecedented destruction and denial of aid were the outcome of unlawful conduct by Hamas and other armed groups, such as locating fighters among the civilian population or the diversion of aid. The organization concluded these claims are not credible. The presence of Hamas fighters near or within a densely populated area does not absolve Israel from its obligations to take all feasible precautions to spare civilians and avoid indiscriminate or disproportionate attacks. Its research found Israel repeatedly failed to do so, committing multiple crimes under international law for which there can be no justification based on Hamas’s actions. Amnesty International also found no evidence that the diversion of aid could explain Israel’s extreme and deliberate restrictions on life-saving humanitarian aid. In its analysis, the organization also considered alternative arguments such as ones that Israel was acting recklessly or that it simply wanted to destroy Hamas and did not care if it needed to destroy Palestinians in the process, demonstrating a callous disregard for their lives rather than genocidal intent. Our damning findings must serve as a wake-up call to the international community: this isgenocide. It must stop now. Agnès Callamard, Amnesty International However, regardless of whether Israel sees the destructionof Palestinians as instrumental to destroying Hamas or asan acceptable by-product of this goal, this view ofPalestinians as disposable and not worthy of considerationis in itself evidence of genocidal intent. Many of the unlawful acts documented by AmnestyInternational were preceded by officials urging theirimplementation. The organization reviewed 102 statementsthat were issued by Israeli government and military officialsand others between 7 October 2023 and 30 June 2024 anddehumanized Palestinians, called for or justified genocidalacts or other crimes against them. Of these, Amnesty International identified 22 statementsmade by senior officials in charge of managing the offensivethat appeared to call for, or justify, genocidal acts, providingdirect evidence of genocidal intent. This language wasfrequently replicated, including by Israeli soldiers on the ground, as evidenced by audiovisual content verified by Amnesty International showing soldiers making calls to “erase” Gaza or to make it uninhabitable, and celebrating the destruction of Palestinian homes, mosques, schools and universities. Killing and causing serious bodily ormental harm Amnesty International documented the genocidal acts of killing and causing serious mental and bodily harm to Palestinians in Gaza by reviewing the results of investigations it conducted into 15 air strikes between 7 October 2023 and 20 April 2024 that killed at least 334 civilians, including 141 children, and wounded hundreds of others. Amnesty International found no evidence that any of these strikes were directed at a military objective. In one illustrative case, on 20 April 2024, an Israeli air strike destroyed the Abdelal family house in the Al-Jneinah neighbourhood in eastern Rafah, killing three generations of Palestinians, including 16 children, while they were sleeping. While these represent just a fraction of Israel’s aerial attacks, they are indicative of a broader pattern of repeated direct attacks on civilians and civilian objects or deliberately indiscriminate attacks. The attacks were also conducted in ways designed to cause a very high number of fatalities and injuries among the civilian population. Inflicting conditions of life calculatedto bring about physical destruction The report documents how Israel deliberately inflicted conditions of life on Palestinians in Gaza intended to lead, over time, to their destruction. These conditions were imposed through three simultaneous patterns that repeatedly compounded the effect of each other’s devastating impacts: damage to and destruction of life- sustaining infrastructure and other objects indispensable to the survival of the civilian population; the repeated use of sweeping, arbitrary and confusing mass “evacuation” orders to forcibly displace almost all of Gaza’s population; and the denial and obstruction of the delivery of essential services, humanitarian assistance and other life-saving supplies into and within Gaza. After 7 October 2023, Israel imposed a total siege on Gaza cutting off electricity, water and fuel. In the nine months reviewed for this report, Israel maintained a suffocating, unlawful blockade, tightly controlled access to energy sources, failed to facilitate meaningful humanitarian access within Gaza, and obstructed the import and delivery of life- saving goods and humanitarian aid, particularly to areas north of Wadi Gaza. They thereby exacerbated an already existing humanitarian crisis. This, combined with the extensive damage to Gaza’s homes, hospitals, water and sanitation facilities and agricultural land, and mass forced displacement, caused catastrophic levels of hunger and led to the spread of diseases at alarming rates. The impact was especially harsh on young children and pregnant or breastfeeding women, with anticipated long-term consequences for their health. The international community’s seismic,shameful failure for over a year to pressIsrael to end its atrocities in Gaza, by firstdelaying calls for a ceasefire and thencontinuing arms transfers, is and will remaina stain on our collective conscience.Agnès Callamard, Amnesty International Time and again, Israel had the chance to improve thehumanitarian situation in Gaza, yet for over a year it hasrepeatedly refused to take steps blatantly within its power todo so, such as opening sufficient access points to Gaza orlifting tight restrictions on what could enter the Strip or theirobstruction of aid deliveries within Gaza while the situationhas grown progressively worse. Through its repeated “evacuation” orders Israel displacednearly 1.9 million Palestinians – 90% of Gaza’s population –into ever-shrinking, unsafe pockets of land under inhumaneconditions, some of them up to 10 times. These multiplewaves of forced displacement left many jobless and deeplytraumatized, especially since some 70% of Gaza’s residentsare refugees or descendants of refugees whose towns andvillages were ethnically cleansed by Israel during the 1948Nakba. Despite conditions quickly becoming unfit for human life,Israeli authorities refused to consider measures that wouldhave protected displaced civilians and ensured their basicneeds were met, showing that their actions were deliberate. They refused to allow those displaced to return to theirhomes in northern Gaza or relocate temporarily to otherparts of the Occupied Palestinian Territory or Israel,continuing to deny many Palestinians their right to returnunder international law to areas they were displacedfrom in 1948. They did so knowing that there was nowhere safe for Palestinians in Gaza to flee to. Accountability for genocide “The international community’s seismic, shameful failure forover a year to press Israel to end its atrocities in Gaza, byfirst delaying calls for a ceasefire and then continuing armstransfers, is and will remain a stain on our collectiveconscience,” said Agnès Callamard. “Governments must stop pretending they are powerless to end this genocide, which was enabled by decades of impunity for Israel’s violations of international law. States need to move beyond mere expressions of regret or dismay and take strong and sustained international action, however uncomfortable a finding of genocide may be for some of Israel’s allies. “The International Criminal Court’s (ICC) arrest warrants for Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former Defense Minister Yoav Gallant for war crimes and crimes against humanity issued last month offer real hope of long-overdue justice for victims. States must demonstrate their respect for the court’s decision and for universal international law principles by arresting and handing over those wanted by the ICC. “We are calling on the Office of the Prosecutor of theInternational Criminal Court (ICC) to urgently consider adding genocide to the list of crimes it is investigating and for all states to use every legal avenue to bring perpetrators to justice. No one should be allowed to commit genocide and remain unpunished.” Amnesty International is also calling for all civilian hostagesto be released unconditionally and for Hamas and otherPalestinian armed groups responsible for the crimescommitted on 7 October to be held to account. The organization is also calling for the UN Security Councilto impose targeted sanctions against Israeli and Hamasofficials most implicated in crimes under international law. Background On 7 October 2023 Hamas and other armed groups indiscriminately fired rockets into southern Israel andcarried out deliberate mass killings and hostage-takingthere, killing 1,200 people, including over 800 civilians, and abducted 223 civilians and captured 27 soldiers. The crimes perpetrated by Hamas and other armed groups during this attack will be the focus of a forthcoming Amnesty International report. Since October 2023, Amnesty International has conducted in- depth investigations into the multiple violations and crimes under international law committed by Israeli forces, including direct attacks on civilians and civilian objects and deliberately indiscriminate attacks killing hundreds of civilians, as well as other unlawful attacks on and collective punishment of the civilian population. The organization has called on the Office of the ICC Prosecutor to expedite its investigation into the situation in the State of Palestine and is campaigning for an immediate ceasefire. For the Hebrew translation of this press release, click here. INTERNATIONAL JUSTICE ISRAEL AND THE OCCUPIED PALESTINIAN TERRITORY MIDDLE EAST MIDDLE EAST AND NORTH AFRICA NEWS PRESS RELEASE WAR CRIMES AND CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY Related Content COUNTRY Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territory NEWS New NATO defence commitments must notcome at cost of human rights NEWS Gaza: Starvation or gunfire – this is not ahumanitarian response NEWS DRC: Peace deal with Rwanda fails toaddress serious crimes committed ineastern DRC NEWS Gaza: Evidence points to Israel’s continueduse of starvation to inflict genocide againstPalestinians Recently added Cambodia: Scamming crisis survivors must beprotected amid police crackdown Ireland: Amnesty’s head urges Irish government to press ahead with Occupied Territories Bill Angola: Authorities must respect and ensure the right to freedom of peaceful assembly Russia: Proposed amendments to counter- extremism laws escalate assault on dissent EU-Israel: Refusal to suspend the EU-IsraelAssociation Agreement is a ‘cruel and unlawfulbetrayal’ DONATE TO PROTECTHUMAN RIGHTS Women's Day protest in Mexico Together we can fight for human rights everywhere. Your donation can transform the lives of millions. ABOUT US Contact UsHow We’re RunModern Slavery Act StatementFinancesRESOURCES Media CentreHuman Rights EducationHuman Rights CoursesAnnual report archiveGET INVOLVED Join Take Action Volunteer LATEST News Campaigns Research WORK WITH US If you are talented and passionate about human rightsthen Amnesty International wants to hear from you. Privacy Policy Accessibility Cookie Statement Permissions Refunds of Donations © 2025 Amnesty International FOLLOW US ON:Facebook Instagram X TikTok Bluesky YouTube LinkedIn On Sun, Jul 20, 2025 at 10:03 AM Martin Wasserman<deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:Aram, If that's the definition of genocide, then Israel isclearly NOT committing genocide in Gaza. If Israelwere trying to kill as many Gazans as possible, thedeath toll would be much, much higher than it is. Theywouldn't allow any food or medicine in at all, and theywouldn't issue evacuation warnings before strikingHamas targets. The truth is, Israel goes to great lengths to avoidcivilian casualties, but Hamas makes it very difficultby deliberately placing their command centers incivilian locations such as schools and hospitals. The only group that Israel wants to destroy is Hamas,which does have an explicit policy of genocide (byyour definition) against Jews. Yes, the Gazans are suffering, but Hamas could endtheir suffering tomorrow if they wanted to. All theyhave to do is lay down their arms and release the hostages, and the war would be over immediately. ButHamas has no interest in ending the suffering of theGazans. What they're actually calling for is an open-ended war of attrition against Israel, no matter whatthe cost to their own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 18, 2025, at 8:26 PM, Aram James<abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Genocide defined: the deliberate killing of a large number of people from a particular nation or ethnic group with the aim of destroying that nation or group. "a campaign of genocide" On Fri, Jul 18, 2025 at 4:04 PM MartinWasserman <deeperlook@aol.com>wrote:It appears that "genocide" can be defined in several different ways.Perhaps we should stop using thatterm altogether and stick to words that have clear and unambiguous meanings. On Jul 18, 2025, at12:25 PM, Aram James<abjpd1@gmail.com>wrote: I’m a Genocide Scholar. I Know It When I See It”: Prof.Omer Bartov on the Growing Consensus on Gaza My inescapable conclusion has become that Israel is committing genocide against the Palestinian people. Having grown up in a Zionist home, lived the first half of my life in Israel, served in the I.D.F. as a soldier and officer and spent most of my career researching and writing on war crimes and the Holocaust, this was a painful conclusion to reach, and one that I resisted as long as I could. But I have been teaching classes on genocide for a quarter of a century. I can recognize one when I see one A month after the Hamas attack on Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, I believed there was evidence that the Israeli military had committed war crimes and potentially crimes against humanity in its counterattack on Gaza. But contrary to the cries of Israel’s fiercest critics, the evidence did not seem to me to rise to the crime of genocide. By May 2024, the Israel Defense Forces had ordered about one million Palestinians sheltering in Rafah — the southernmost and last remaining relatively undamaged city of the Gaza Strip — to move to the beach area of the Mawasi, where there was little to no shelter. The army then proceeded to destroy much of Rafah, a feat mostly accomplished by August. At that point it appeared no longer possible to deny that the pattern of I.D.F. operations was consistent with the statements denoting genocidal intent made by Israeli leaders in the days after the Hamas attack. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had promised that the enemy would pay a “ From:Martin Wasserman To:Sean Allen Cc:Aram James; Jeff Rosen; Jay Boyarsky; Veenker, Vicki; h.etzko@gmail.com; jessica@speiser.net; Foley, Michael; GRP-City Council; RaymondGoins; Raj Jayadev; Patrice Ventresca; Figueroa, Eric; Lotus Fong; Reifschneider, James; Binder, Andrew; Gardener, Liz; Diana Diamond;Yolanda Conaway; yolanda; Don Austin; jason.green@bayareanewsgroup.com; Human Relations Commission; WILPF Peninsula Palo Alto;Perron, Zachary; Robert Salonga; Rob Baker; Robert. Jonsen; Roberta Ahlquist; Steve Wagstaffe; Wagner, April; Jeff Conrad; Burt, Patrick; PDKristina Bell; Bill Newell; The Office of Mayor Matt Mahan; Councilmember Chappie Jones; District9@sanjoseca.gov; District4@sanjoseca.gov;District5@sanjoseca.gov; District2@sanjoseca.gov; Today EPA; Gennady Sheyner; Council, City; city.council@menlopark.gov; VaraRamakrishnan; cromero@cityofepa.org; Cribbs, Anne; michael.gennaco@oirgroup.com; Stump, Molly; board@pausd.org; BoardOperations;Damon Silver; Miguel Rodriguez; Cait James; Josh Becker; Assemblymember.Berman@assembly.ca.gov; Zelkha, Mila; dennis burns; DuJuanGreen; Gerry Gras; Enberg, Nicholas; Rowena Chiu; Barberini, Christopher; Reckdahl, Keith; Dana St. George; Blackshire, Geoffrey; TomDuBois; Friends of Cubberley; Supervisor Susan Ellenberg; Greg Tanaka; Bil Barber; Ed Lauing; Yi Chen; Donna Wallach; Mickie Winkler;Supervisor Otto Lee; Mark Turner; City Attorney; CityCouncil; Michelle Bigelow; Seher Awan; Pat M; Carla Torres; David Piper; Lori Meyers;Sheree Roth; Ellen Fox Subject:Re: Block the Bombs_1_2 sheet Date:Monday, July 21, 2025 5:08:55 PM CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of openingattachments and clicking on links. Sean, Humanitarian values are important, but realistically, national security concerns will always override them invirtually any country on Earth. In fact, any nation that puts humanitarianism above its own national securityinterests probably won't be a nation for long. And if we accept the idea that any person’s need creates an obligationfor others to fulfill that need, the world would very quickly sink into chaos. Regarding African refugees in Israel, it's a testimony to Israel’s humanitarianism that these refugees, mostlyMuslims, know they'll receive more compassionate care in the one Jewish state than in any Arab or Muslim state.Nevertheless, Israel is a very small country, and it's also the nation state of the Jewish people, a people with theirown unique religion, language, and culture and a very long history. If it opened its gates to everyone who was inneed, it would quickly be swamped, and would no longer be the nation state of the Jewish people. Israel is notgoing to compromise its national identity, and it's unreasonable to think that it should, for the sake of helpingstrangers who have no particular connection to Jews or Judaism. Best,Martin On Jul 21, 2025, at 12:03 PM, Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com> wrote: Martin, I appreciate your perspective on the complexities of national security and humanitarian obligations.However, it's crucial to recognize that viewing civilians as "enemies" can lead to a dangerousprecedent where humanitarian needs are disregarded in the name of security. In both the case of African asylum-seekers and Palestinians in Gaza, the individuals affected are oftencivilians who are fleeing violence, persecution, or dire living conditions. They should not becategorized merely as "enemy civilians," as this oversimplifies the multifaceted nature of conflict andignores their humanity. Treating any civilian population as an enemy undermines the basic principlesof international humanitarian law, which emphasize the protection of non-combatants in conflictsituations. The actions of Israel toward African asylum-seekers further illustrate this point. In the face ofsignificant geopolitical and humanitarian challenges, Israel has opted to deport Eritrean and Sudaneseasylum-seekers, often leaving them vulnerable to persecution in third countries, demonstrating atroubling pattern of prioritizing security measures over humanitarian responsibilities. Like the civiliansin Gaza, these asylum-seekers are fleeing perilous situations; thus, their humanity should berecognized regardless of the circumstances surrounding their migration. Regarding your historical references, while it is true that during times of war, nations have madedecisions that prioritize military objectives, it's essential to acknowledge that the moral implications of such decisions have evolved. The international community increasingly recognizes the importance ofhumanitarian considerations even amid conflict. Ignoring humanitarian needs, particularly ofvulnerable populations, can perpetuate cycles of violence and instability that ultimately harm nationalinterests in the long run. Additionally, while you mention Israeli perspectives on Gazan civilians voting for Hamas, it's criticalto understand that many civilians may have done so under coercive conditions or without the fullcapacity to consider the implications of their choices. Many Gazans are indeed caught in a cycle ofviolence, facing repercussions for the decisions made by leadership they may not support. You also note Israel's earlier actions to facilitate the entry of food and supplies into Gaza. However,the effectiveness and sufficiency of this aid must be contextualized against the wider backdrop ofblockades and military operations that significantly restrict access to essential services, creating ahumanitarian crisis. In summary, while national security is undoubtedly critical, it should not come at the cost ofabandoning the fundamental human rights and dignity of civilians caught in conflict. The tragic plightof those affected by violence—whether they are asylum-seekers or civilians in Gaza—demands acompassionate and just approach that acknowledges their humanity. Is the refusal to recognize thehumanity of these individuals truly an acceptable stance in the pursuit of security, or is it more aboutmaintaining purity? Regards, Sean Sent from my iPhone On Jul 21, 2025, at 10:31 AM, Martin Wasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote: Sean, I appreciate your concern for humanitarian issues. However, the reality is that when anation is fighting for its very existence, as Israel is doing right now, its highest priority hasto be to defeat the enemy, and caring for the humanitarian needs of enemy civilians has tobe a much lower priority. In fact, most nations would ridicule the idea of helping enemy civilians while a war isongoing, arguing that it’s equivalent to helping the enemy himself. During World War II, for example, the overriding imperative was victory, and the USshowed no concern for the humanitarian well-being of the enemy civilians it wasbombing, nor did any other nation involved in that conflict. Humanitarian concerns couldbe addressed after the war, but not during it. It’s also worth noting that Israelis don't necessarily see Gazan civilians as innocentbystanders. They remember how they voted Hamas into power, and how many of themfollowed Hamas into Israel on October 7 and took direct part in the plunder and pillage ofthat day. They also recall the outbursts of delirious joy as the Israeli hostages wereparaded through the streets of Gaza, and how not a single Gazan did anything to help theIsraeli hostages escape from their captivity. Nevertheless, Israel has shown more concern for humanitarian issues than virtually anyother country in a similar situation. Earlier in the war, it allowed huge amounts of foodand supplies into Gaza, even though it knew that most of the aid was being stolen byHamas, thereby prolonging the war and making victory more difficult to achieve. Incidentally, there were many in Israel who thought this policy was very foolish andhighly counterproductive. Regards,Martin Wasserman On Jul 20, 2025, at 8:34 PM, Sean Allen <sallen6444@yahoo.com> wrote: Martin, Thank you for sharing your perspective. While it's important to consider thecomplex dynamics at play, the impact of rationing food and resources cannotbe overlooked. Limiting access to basic necessities can lead to direconsequences for the civilian population, contributing to significant sufferingand hardship, irrespective of intent. Historically, we have seen that during crises, people instinctively fight andeven resort to violence over limited resources. This was evident in theaftermath of Hurricane Katrina in the United States, where widespreaddesperation for food, water, and safety led to chaos and alarming acts ofviolence. Reports from that time highlighted how individuals looted storesand clashed with each other as they scrambled for basic survival needs,demonstrating how fragile social order can become when resources arescarce. Similarly, in Somalia, we witnessed violence surrounding thedistribution of humanitarian aid, as factions vied for control over theresources being provided to those in need. Rationing food and resources has the potential to produce outcomes that areas devastating as direct violence, akin to the effects of bombing a population.Furthermore, military units should never base their decisions to slaughternon-combatants on the basis that their opposition does not release hostages,regardless of the justification for conflict. Unless the motive is to create morechaos through infighting, which would lead to similar devastation as bombingnon-combatant communities, the humane approach is to provide theseindividuals with the necessary amount of humanitarian aid and stop theslaughter. Bombing non-combatants is not war; it’s slaughter and inhumane.Even our Constitution prohibits punishing a group of people because of theactions of others. While military objectives may focus on specific groups, we must recognizethat the broader impact on civilian lives remains profound. The suffering ofGazans should not be diminished or overlooked, as their well-being isaffected by the decisions made in the context of this conflict. Best, Sean Allen Sent from my iPhone On Jul 20, 2025, at 3:30 PM, Aram James <abjpd1@gmail.com>wrote: Condemn Israel or be complicit in genocide': Colombia's Gustavo Petro By Al Mayadeen English Source: The Guardian 8 Jul 2025 13:47 2 Shares 4 Min Read Colombian President Gustavo Petro, in a Guardian op- ed, accuses Netanyahu of genocide in Gaza and urges global action. Listen On Tuesday, The Guardian published an opinion piece by Colombian President Gustavo Petro, in which he accused Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of orchestrating a "campaign of devastation" in Gaza and called on the international community to move beyond symbolic outrage toward concrete action in defense of international law. Petro has emerged as one of the most outspoken world leaders condemning "Israel’s" war on Gaza, and his latest opinion piece adds to a growing series of forceful critiques directed at the ongoing Israeli genocide. Denouncing what he described as 600 days of systematic atrocities, Petro wrote that the world's inaction risks legitimizing a model of impunity where colonial violence, ethnic cleansing, and siege warfare are normalized against a captive population. "If we fail to act now," he wrote, "we not only betray the Palestinian people, we become complicit in the atrocities committed by Netanyahu's government." Moral break The president highlighted a landmark United Nations General Assembly resolution adopted in September 2024, which called for "Israel" to end its illegal occupation within 12 months. He noted that Colombia was among the 124 countries that voted in favor, thereby assuming binding obligations that include sanctions, legal action, and trade measures. "The clock is now ticking," he warned, reaffirming Colombia's commitment by recalling its concrete step: suspending coal exports to "Israel." Related News 650 days of genocide: 125,000 tons of bombs 2.4 mln lives shattered Starved by 'Israel': People of Gaza are dying while the world watches In his piece, Petro mentioned that he had declared earlier this year: "We cannot fuel the machinery that slaughters Palestinian children and then claim neutrality." This is not the first bold move by the Colombian president. In May, his government formally cut diplomatic ties with "Israel," citing what Petro explicitly described as a "genocide." His administration also appointed Colombia’s first ambassador to Palestine, pledging medical treatment in Colombian hospitals for injured children from Gaza. The newly appointed ambassador, Jorge Iván Ospina, later echoed Petro’s position, warning of a "macabre intention to erase the identity of a people." In Tuesday's article, Petro praised similar actions taken by countries like Malaysia, which banned Israeli ships from its ports, and South Africa, which brought "Israel" before the International Court of Justice (ICJ) on charges of genocide. It is worth noting that Colombia joined that case as an intervening party, further deepening its legal opposition to "Israel's" war. Read more: US defends Israeli use of starvation as weapon of war before ICJ Global reckoning Looking ahead, Petro mentioned that Colombia and South Africa, co-chairs of the Hague Group, will host an emergency summit regarding Gaza on July 15. The conference aims to develop a coordinated, multilateral strategy to isolate "Israel" diplomatically and economically while restoring credibility to the global legal order. With the UN's proposed international peace conference indefinitely postponed, Petro cast the July summit as a necessary corrective to global paralysis. The Colombian president framed the Gaza crisis not just as a moral catastrophe but as an existential test for international law and nations of the Global South. "We can either stand firm in defense of the legal principles that seek to prevent war and conflict," he wrote, "or watch helplessly as the international system collapses under the weight of unchecked power politics." He concluded his piece by stressing that the choice is between complicity in colonial violence and collective resistance against it. On Sun, Jul 20, 2025 at 3:12 PM Martin Wasserman<deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:Aram, Amnesty International is not a credible source on this issue. Itappears that the once-respectable organization has been takenover by malevolent actors with a political axe to grind. Theiranti-Israel bias is evident throughout the report. They accuse Israel of genocide but make no mention at all ofHamas’ explicit genocidal policy against Jews. They accuse Israel of violating international law, but make noreference at all to the fact that Israel is facing a ruthless enemythat observes no international laws whatsoever. When they mention Hamas’ transgressions at all, they do it inthe mildest language possible, and then use the most damningpossible language when describing Israel's actions. They take it as a given that Israel is an apartheid state, ablatantly false accusation that is very easily disproved. They take it as a given that Israel is illegally occupyingPalestinian land, as if the territories of Judea and Samaria, theheartland of the ancient Jewish nation, don't belong to Jews atall, but are instead the property of a fictitious country called“Palestine” which has never actually existed in any historicalperiod. In short, this entire report is a politically motivated “hatchetjob” that deserves no credibility whatsoever. Martin Wasserman On Jul 20, 2025, at 11:39 AM, Aram James<abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Amnesty Internationalinvestigation concludesIsrael is committinggenocide againstPalestinians in Gaza Amnesty International’s research has found sufficient basisto conclude that Israel has committed and is continuing tocommit genocide against Palestinians in the occupied Gaza Strip, the organization said in a landmark new report published today. The report, ‘You Feel Like You Are Subhuman’: Israel’s Genocide Against Palestinians in Gaza, documents how, during its military offensive launched in the wake of thedeadly Hamas-led attacks in southern Israel on 7 October 2023, Israel has unleashed hell and destruction on Palestinians in Gaza brazenly, continuously and with total impunity. “Amnesty International’s report demonstrates that Israel hascarried out acts prohibited under the Genocide Convention, with the specific intent to destroy Palestinians in Gaza. These actsinclude killings, causing serious bodily or mental harm anddeliberately inflicting on Palestinians in Gaza conditions of life calculated to bring about their physical destruction. Month after month, Israel has treated Palestinians in Gaza as a subhumangroup unworthy of human rights and dignity, demonstrating itsintent to physically destroy them,” said Agnès Callamard, Secretary General of Amnesty International. “Our damning findings must serve as a wake-up call to theinternational community: this is genocide. It must stop now. “States that continue to transfer arms to Israel at this time must know they are violating their obligation to preventgenocide and are at risk of becoming complicit in genocide.All states with influence over Israel, particularly key arms suppliers like the USA and Germany, but also other EU member states, the UK and others, must act now to bringIsrael’s atrocities against Palestinians in Gaza to animmediate end.” Over the past two months the crisis has grown particularly acute in the North Gaza governorate, where a besiegedpopulation is facing starvation, displacement andannihilation amid relentless bombardment and suffocating restrictions on life-saving humanitarian aid. “Our research reveals that, for months, Israel has persisted incommitting genocidal acts, fully aware of the irreparable harm it was inflicting on Palestinians in Gaza. It continued to do so in defiance of countless warnings about the catastrophichumanitarian situation and of legally binding decisions from theInternational Court of Justice (ICJ) ordering Israel to take immediate measures to enable the provision of humanitarian assistance to civilians in Gaza,” said Agnès Callamard. “Israel has repeatedly argued that its actions in Gaza are lawful and can be justified by its military goal to eradicate Hamas. But genocidal intent can co-exist alongside militarygoals and does not need to be Israel’s sole intent.” Amnesty International examined Israel’s acts in Gaza closely and in their totality, taking into account their recurrence and simultaneous occurrence, and both theirimmediate impact and their cumulative and mutuallyreinforcing consequences. The organization considered the scale and severity of the casualties and destruction over time. It also analysed public statements by officials, findingthat prohibited acts were often announced or called for inthe first place by high-level officials in charge of the war efforts. “Taking into account the pre-existing context of dispossession, apartheid and unlawful military occupation in which these acts have been committed, we could find only one reasonable conclusion: Israel’s intent is the physical destruction ofPalestinians in Gaza, whether in parallel with, or as a means toachieve, its military goal of destroying Hamas,” said Agnès Callamard. “The atrocity crimes committed on 7 October 2023 byHamas and other armed groups against Israelis and victims of other nationalities, including deliberate mass killings and hostage-taking, can never justify Israel’s genocide againstPalestinians in Gaza.” International jurisprudence recognizes that the perpetrator does not need to succeed in their attempts to destroy the protected group, either in whole or in part, for genocide tohave been committed. The commission of prohibited actswith the intent to destroy the group, as such, is sufficient. Amnesty International’s report examines in detail Israel’sviolations in Gaza over nine months between 7 October2023 and early July 2024. The organization interviewed 212 people, including Palestinian victims and witnesses, local authorities in Gaza, healthcare workers, conducted fieldworkand analysed an extensive range of visual and digitalevidence, including satellite imagery. It also analysed statements by senior Israeli government and military officials, and official Israeli bodies. On multiple occasions,the organization shared its findings with the Israeliauthorities but had received no substantive response at the time of publication. Unprecedented scale and magnitude Israel’s actions following Hamas’s deadly attacks on 7October 2023 have brought Gaza’s population to the brink of collapse. Its brutal military offensive had killed more than 42,000 Palestinians, including over 13,300 children, andinjured over 97,000 more, by 7 October 2024, many of themin direct or deliberately indiscriminate attacks, often wiping out entire multigenerational families. It has caused unprecedented destruction, which experts say occurred at alevel and speed not seen in any other conflict in the 21stcentury, levelling entire cities and destroying critical infrastructure, agricultural land and cultural and religious sites. It thereby rendered large swathes of Gazauninhabitable. Mohammed, who fled with his family from Gaza City to Rafah in March 2024 and was displaced again in May 2024,described their struggle to survive in horrifying conditions: “Here in Deir al-Balah, it’s like an apocalypse… You have to protect your children from insects, from the heat, and there is no clean water, no toilets, all while the bombing neverstops. You feel like you are subhuman here.” Israel imposed conditions of life in Gaza that created a deadly mixture of malnutrition, hunger and diseases, and exposed Palestinians to a slow, calculated death. Israel alsosubjected hundreds of Palestinians from Gaza toincommunicado detention, torture and other ill-treatment. Viewed in isolation, some of the acts investigated by Amnesty International constitute serious violations ofinternational humanitarian law or international human rightslaw. But in looking at the broader picture of Israel’s military campaign and the cumulative impact of its policies and acts, genocidal intent is the only reasonable conclusion. Intent to destroy To establish Israel’s specific intent to physically destroy Palestinians in Gaza, as such, Amnesty International analysed the overall pattern of Israel’s conduct in Gaza,reviewed dehumanizing and genocidal statements by Israeligovernment and military officials, particularly those at the highest levels, and considered the context of Israel’s systemof apartheid, its inhumane blockade of Gaza and theunlawful 57-year-old military occupation of the Palestinianterritory. Before reaching its conclusion, Amnesty Internationalexamined Israel’s claims that its military lawfully targetedHamas and other armed groups throughout Gaza, and that the resulting unprecedented destruction and denial of aid were the outcome of unlawful conduct by Hamas and otherarmed groups, such as locating fighters among the civilianpopulation or the diversion of aid. The organization concluded these claims are not credible. The presence of Hamas fighters near or within a densely populated areadoes not absolve Israel from its obligations to take allfeasible precautions to spare civilians and avoid indiscriminate or disproportionate attacks. Its research found Israel repeatedly failed to do so, committing multiple crimesunder international law for which there can be nojustification based on Hamas’s actions. Amnesty International also found no evidence that the diversion of aidcould explain Israel’s extreme and deliberate restrictions onlife-saving humanitarian aid. In its analysis, the organization also considered alternative arguments such as ones that Israel was acting recklessly orthat it simply wanted to destroy Hamas and did not care if itneeded to destroy Palestinians in the process, demonstrating a callous disregard for their lives rather than genocidal intent. Our damning findings must serve as a wake-up call to the international community: this isgenocide. It must stop now. Agnès Callamard, Amnesty International However, regardless of whether Israel sees the destruction of Palestinians as instrumental to destroying Hamas or asan acceptable by-product of this goal, this view of Palestinians as disposable and not worthy of consideration is in itself evidence of genocidal intent. Many of the unlawful acts documented by AmnestyInternational were preceded by officials urging theirimplementation. The organization reviewed 102 statements that were issued by Israeli government and military officialsand others between 7 October 2023 and 30 June 2024 anddehumanized Palestinians, called for or justified genocidalacts or other crimes against them. Of these, Amnesty International identified 22 statementsmade by senior officials in charge of managing the offensivethat appeared to call for, or justify, genocidal acts, providing direct evidence of genocidal intent. This language was frequently replicated, including by Israeli soldiers on theground, as evidenced by audiovisual content verified byAmnesty International showing soldiers making calls to “erase” Gaza or to make it uninhabitable, and celebrating the destruction of Palestinian homes, mosques, schools anduniversities. Killing and causing serious bodily ormental harm Amnesty International documented the genocidal acts of killing and causing serious mental and bodily harm toPalestinians in Gaza by reviewing the results ofinvestigations it conducted into 15 air strikes between 7 October 2023 and 20 April 2024 that killed at least 334 civilians, including 141 children, and wounded hundreds ofothers. Amnesty International found no evidence that any ofthese strikes were directed at a military objective. In one illustrative case, on 20 April 2024, an Israeli air strikedestroyed the Abdelal family house in the Al-Jneinahneighbourhood in eastern Rafah, killing three generations of Palestinians, including 16 children, while they were sleeping. While these represent just a fraction of Israel’s aerialattacks, they are indicative of a broader pattern of repeated direct attacks on civilians and civilian objects or deliberately indiscriminate attacks. The attacks were also conducted inways designed to cause a very high number of fatalities andinjuries among the civilian population. Inflicting conditions of life calculatedto bring about physical destruction The report documents how Israel deliberately inflictedconditions of life on Palestinians in Gaza intended to lead,over time, to their destruction. These conditions were imposed through three simultaneous patterns that repeatedly compounded the effect of each other’sdevastating impacts: damage to and destruction of life-sustaining infrastructure and other objects indispensable to the survival of the civilian population; the repeated use of sweeping, arbitrary and confusing mass “evacuation” orders to forcibly displace almost all of Gaza’s population; and thedenial and obstruction of the delivery of essential services,humanitarian assistance and other life-saving supplies into and within Gaza. After 7 October 2023, Israel imposed a total siege on Gazacutting off electricity, water and fuel. In the nine months reviewed for this report, Israel maintained a suffocating, unlawful blockade, tightly controlled access to energysources, failed to facilitate meaningful humanitarian accesswithin Gaza, and obstructed the import and delivery of life- saving goods and humanitarian aid, particularly to areas north of Wadi Gaza. They thereby exacerbated an alreadyexisting humanitarian crisis. This, combined with theextensive damage to Gaza’s homes, hospitals, water and sanitation facilities and agricultural land, and mass forced displacement, caused catastrophic levels of hunger and ledto the spread of diseases at alarming rates. The impact wasespecially harsh on young children and pregnant or breastfeeding women, with anticipated long-term consequences for their health. The international community’s seismic,shameful failure for over a year to pressIsrael to end its atrocities in Gaza, by firstdelaying calls for a ceasefire and then continuing arms transfers, is and will remaina stain on our collective conscience.Agnès Callamard, Amnesty International Time and again, Israel had the chance to improve the humanitarian situation in Gaza, yet for over a year it has repeatedly refused to take steps blatantly within its power todo so, such as opening sufficient access points to Gaza orlifting tight restrictions on what could enter the Strip or their obstruction of aid deliveries within Gaza while the situation has grown progressively worse. Through its repeated “evacuation” orders Israel displacednearly 1.9 million Palestinians – 90% of Gaza’s population – into ever-shrinking, unsafe pockets of land under inhumaneconditions, some of them up to 10 times. These multiplewaves of forced displacement left many jobless and deeply traumatized, especially since some 70% of Gaza’s residents are refugees or descendants of refugees whose towns andvillages were ethnically cleansed by Israel during the 1948Nakba. Despite conditions quickly becoming unfit for human life, Israeli authorities refused to consider measures that wouldhave protected displaced civilians and ensured their basicneeds were met, showing that their actions were deliberate. They refused to allow those displaced to return to theirhomes in northern Gaza or relocate temporarily to otherparts of the Occupied Palestinian Territory or Israel, continuing to deny many Palestinians their right to return under international law to areas they were displacedfrom in 1948. They did so knowing that there was nowhere safe for Palestinians in Gaza to flee to. Accountability for genocide “The international community’s seismic, shameful failure for over a year to press Israel to end its atrocities in Gaza, by first delaying calls for a ceasefire and then continuing armstransfers, is and will remain a stain on our collectiveconscience,” said Agnès Callamard. “Governments must stop pretending they are powerless toend this genocide, which was enabled by decades ofimpunity for Israel’s violations of international law. States need to move beyond mere expressions of regret or dismay and take strong and sustained international action, howeveruncomfortable a finding of genocide may be for some ofIsrael’s allies. “The International Criminal Court’s (ICC) arrest warrants forPrime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and former DefenseMinister Yoav Gallant for war crimes and crimes againsthumanity issued last month offer real hope of long-overdue justice for victims. States must demonstrate their respect forthe court’s decision and for universal international lawprinciples by arresting and handing over those wanted by the ICC. “We are calling on the Office of the Prosecutor of theInternational Criminal Court (ICC) to urgently consideradding genocide to the list of crimes it is investigating and for all states to use every legal avenue to bring perpetrators to justice. No one should be allowed to commit genocideand remain unpunished.” Amnesty International is also calling for all civilian hostages to be released unconditionally and for Hamas and otherPalestinian armed groups responsible for the crimescommitted on 7 October to be held to account. The organization is also calling for the UN Security Council to impose targeted sanctions against Israeli and Hamasofficials most implicated in crimes under international law. Background On 7 October 2023 Hamas and other armed groups indiscriminately fired rockets into southern Israel and carried out deliberate mass killings and hostage-taking there, killing 1,200 people, including over 800 civilians, and abducted 223 civilians and captured 27 soldiers. The crimes perpetrated by Hamas and other armed groups during thisattack will be the focus of a forthcoming AmnestyInternational report. Since October 2023, Amnesty International has conducted in- depth investigations into the multiple violations and crimes under international law committed by Israeli forces, including direct attacks on civilians and civilian objects and deliberatelyindiscriminate attacks killing hundreds of civilians, as well asother unlawful attacks on and collective punishment of the civilian population. The organization has called on the Office of the ICC Prosecutor to expedite its investigation into the situation in theState of Palestine and is campaigning for an immediate ceasefire. For the Hebrew translation of this press release, clickhere. INTERNATIONAL JUSTICE ISRAEL AND THE OCCUPIED PALESTINIANTERRITORY MIDDLE EAST MIDDLE EAST AND NORTH AFRICA NEWS PRESS RELEASE WAR CRIMES AND CRIMES AGAINST HUMANITY Related Content COUNTRY Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territory NEWS New NATO defence commitments must notcome at cost of human rights NEWS Gaza: Starvation or gunfire – this is not ahumanitarian response NEWS DRC: Peace deal with Rwanda fails toaddress serious crimes committed ineastern DRC NEWS Gaza: Evidence points to Israel’s continueduse of starvation to inflict genocide against Palestinians Recently added Cambodia: Scamming crisis survivors must beprotected amid police crackdown Ireland: Amnesty’s head urges Irish government to press ahead with Occupied Territories Bill Angola: Authorities must respect and ensurethe right to freedom of peaceful assembly Russia: Proposed amendments to counter-extremism laws escalate assault on dissent EU-Israel: Refusal to suspend the EU-Israel Association Agreement is a ‘cruel and unlawful betrayal’ DONATE TO PROTECTHUMAN RIGHTS Women's Day protest in Mexico Together we can fight for human rightseverywhere. Your donation can transform the lives of millions. ABOUT US Contact UsHow We’re RunModern Slavery Act Statement Finances RESOURCES Media CentreHuman Rights Education Human Rights CoursesAnnual report archiveGET INVOLVED JoinTake ActionVolunteer LATEST NewsCampaigns ResearchWORK WITH US If you are talented and passionate about human rights then Amnesty International wants to hearfrom you. Privacy Policy AccessibilityCookie StatementPermissions Refunds of Donations © 2025 Amnesty International FOLLOW US ON:Facebook Instagram X TikTok Bluesky YouTube LinkedIn On Sun, Jul 20, 2025 at 10:03 AM MartinWasserman <deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:Aram, If that's the definition of genocide, then Israel isclearly NOT committing genocide in Gaza. IfIsrael were trying to kill as many Gazans aspossible, the death toll would be much, muchhigher than it is. They wouldn't allow any foodor medicine in at all, and they wouldn't issueevacuation warnings before striking Hamastargets. The truth is, Israel goes to great lengths to avoidcivilian casualties, but Hamas makes it verydifficult by deliberately placing their commandcenters in civilian locations such as schools andhospitals. The only group that Israel wants to destroy isHamas, which does have an explicit policy ofgenocide (by your definition) against Jews. Yes, the Gazans are suffering, but Hamas couldend their suffering tomorrow if they wanted to.All they have to do is lay down their arms andrelease the hostages, and the war would be overimmediately. But Hamas has no interest inending the suffering of the Gazans. What they'reactually calling for is an open-ended war ofattrition against Israel, no matter what the cost totheir own people. Martin Wasserman On Jul 18, 2025, at 8:26 PM, AramJames <abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: Genocide defined: the deliberate killing of a large number of people from a particular nation or ethnic group with the aim of destroying that nation or group. "a campaign of genocide" On Fri, Jul 18, 2025 at 4:04 PMMartin Wasserman<deeperlook@aol.com> wrote:It appears that "genocide" can be defined in several different ways. Perhaps we should stop using that term altogether and stick to words that have clear and unambiguous meanings. On Jul 18, 2025, at12:25 PM, AramJames<abjpd1@gmail.com> wrote: I’m a Genocide Scholar. I Know It When I See It”: Prof.Omer Bartov on the Growing Consensus on Gaza My inescapable conclusion has become that Israel is committing genocide against the Palestinian people. Having grown up in a Zionist home, lived the first half of my life in Israel, served in the I.D.F. as a soldier and officer and spent most of my career researching and writing on war crimes and the Holocaust, this was a painful conclusion to reach, and one that I resisted as long as I could. But I have been teaching classes on genocide for a quarter of a century. I can recognize one when I see one A month after the Hamas attack on Israel on Oct. 7, 2023, I believed there was evidence that the Israeli military had committed war crimes and potentially crimes against humanity in its counterattack on Gaza. But contrary to the cries of Israel’s fiercest critics, the evidence did not seem to me to rise to the crime of genocide. By May 2024, the Israel Defense Forces had ordered about one million Palestinians sheltering in Rafah — the southernmost and last remaining relatively undamaged city of the Gaza Strip — to move to the beach area of the Mawasi, where there was little to no shelter. The army then proceeded to destroy much of Rafah, a feat mostly accomplished by August. At that point it appeared no longer possible to deny that the pattern of I.D.F. operations was consistent with the statements denoting genocidal intent made by Israeli leaders in the days after the Hamas attack. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had promised that the enemy would pay a “huge price” for the attack and that the I.D.F. would turn parts of Gaza, where Hamas was operating, “into rubble,” and he called on “the residents of Gaza” to “leave now because we will operate forcefully everywhere.” Mr. Netanyahu had urged his citizens to remember “what Amalek did to you,” a quote many interpreted as a reference to the demand in a biblical passage calling for the Israelites to “kill alike men and women, infants and sucklings” of their ancient enemy. Government and military officials said they were fighting “human animals” and, later, called for “total annihilation.” Nissim Vaturi, the deputy speaker of Parliament, said on Xthat Israel’s task must be “erasing the Gaza Strip from the face of the earth.” Israel’s actions could be understood only as the implementation of the expressed intent to make the Gaza Strip uninhabitable for its Palestinian population. I believe the goal was — and remains today — to force the population to leave the Strip altogether or, considering that it has nowhere to go, to debilitate the enclave through bombings and severe deprivation of food, clean water, sanitation and medical aid to such an extent that it is impossible for Palestinians in Gaza to maintain or reconstitute their existence as a group. ADVERTISEMENT SKIP ADVERTISEMENT My inescapable conclusion has become that Israel is committing genocide against the Palestinian people. Having grown up in a Zionist home, lived the first half of my life in Israel, served in the I.D.F. as a soldier and officer and spent most of my career researching and writing on war crimes and the Holocaust, this was a painful conclusion to reach, and one that I resisted as long as I could. But I have been teaching classes on genocide for a quarter of a century. I can recognize one when I see one. This is not just my conclusion. A growing number of experts in genocide studies and international law have concluded that Israel’s actions in Gaza can only be defined as genocide. So has Francesca Albanese, the U.N. special rapporteur for the West Bank and Gaza, and Amnesty International. South Africa has brought a genocide case against Israel at the International Court of Justice. ImagePeople inspecting a huge pile of rubble. Credit...Jehad Alshrafi/AssociatedPress The continued denial of this designation by states, international organizations and legal and scholarly experts will cause unmitigated damage not just to the people of Gaza and Israel but also to the system of international law established in the wake of the horrors of the Holocaust, designed to prevent such atrocities from happening ever again. It is a threat to the very foundations of the moral order on which we all depend. *** The crime of genocide was defined in 1948 by the United Nations as the “intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group, as such.” In determining what constitutes genocide, therefore, we must both establish intent and show that it is being carried out. In Israel’s case, that intent has been publicly expressed by numerous officials and leaders. But intent can also be derived from a pattern of operations on the ground, and this pattern became clear by May 2024 — and has since become ever clearer — as the I.D.F. has systematically destroyed the Gaza Strip. ADVERTISEMENT SKIPADVERTISEMENT Most genocide scholars are cautious about applying this term to contemporary events, precisely because of the tendency, since it was coined by the Jewish-Polish lawyer Raphael Lemkin in 1944, to attribute it to any case of massacre or inhumanity. Indeed, some argue that the categorization should be entirely discarded, because it often serves more to express outrage than to identify a particular crime. Yet as Mr. Lemkin recognized, and as the United Nations later agreed, it is crucial to be able to distinguish the attempt to destroy a particular group of people from other crimes under international law, such as war crimes and crimes against humanity. This is because, while other crimes entail indiscriminate or deliberate killing of civilians as individuals, genocide denotes the killing of people as members of a group, geared at irreparably destroying the group itself so that it would never be able to reconstitute itself as a political, social or cultural entity. And, as the international community signaled by adopting the convention, it is incumbent upon all signatory states to prevent such an attempt, to do all they can to stop it while it is occurring and to subsequently punish those who were engaged in this crime of crimes — even if it occurred within the borders of a sovereign state. The designation has major political, legal and moral ramifications. Nations, politicians and military personnel suspected of, indicted on a charge of or found guilty of genocide are seen as beyond the pale of humanity and may compromise or lose their right to remain members of the international community. A finding by the International Court of Justice that a particular state is engaged in genocide, especially if enforced by the U.N. Security Council, can lead to severe sanctions. Sign up for the Opinion Today newsletter Get expert analysis of the news and a guide to the big ideas shaping the world every weekday morning. Get it sent to your inbox. Politicians or generals indicted on a charge of or found guilty of genocide or other breaches of international humanitarian law by the International Criminal Court can face arrest outside of their country. And a society that condones and is complicit in genocide, whatever the stand of its individual citizens may be, will carry this mark of Cain long after the fires of hatred and violence are put out.*** From:Ramon Moreno To:Lester Wong Cc:Marguerite Poyatos; Maor Greenberg; Dave Stellman; Patrick Kelly; Bill McLane; Gaines, Chantal; osbaldo@or- builders.com; Manu Kumar; Becchetti, Benjamin; Cathi Lerch; Dave Stellman; City Mgr; Moffatt, Pete; Jacob@onemovemovers.com; david@paloaltoconcrete.com; Steve Wong; nancy@drewmaran.com; Dan McKinley; McDonough, Melissa; Reifschneider, James; Transportation; John Lerch; Binder, Andrew; Jade Jin; Xenia Czisch; City Attorney; Lauing, Ed; Lydia Kou; Veenker, Vicki; Council, City; Burt, Patrick; Stone, Greer; Lythcott-Haims, Julie Subject:Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety Date:Monday, July 21, 2025 12:15:28 PM Attachments:google_04352117-2fb4-4963-bb3e-cc5317269360.pngyelp_e821c57e-caea-4e87-a5dd-5905e7ca4fb1.pngP_aece63f3-754b-4dca-a0a9-e93b94de4930.pngHouzz_7abe75ad-d6ee-48ac-943b-592713e31957.pnginsta_26696304-1b39-4259-9776-9f137454bed9.pngemail-signture_87b8d7a2-c4f4-4cbf-b474-af2f32118dd2.pngF_1bc77f31-68bf-4143-80ea-3f34f539ea07.png CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautiousof opening attachments and clicking on links. i Dear City of Palo Alto, I am writing to express my deep concern regarding the ongoing issues caused by the RVencampments in Palo Alto, which are directly impacting my business and the safety of my students and their families. As the owner of the Ramon Moreno School of Ballet, I am dedicated to maintaining a safe,clean, and welcoming environment for our students and their families. However, recent circumstances are making that increasingly difficult. One of the most pressing issues is illegal dumping. Individuals from the RV encampmentshave been using my business’s garbage disposal for their personal waste, resulting in contamination. Because of this, the city has refused to collect the trash, and I have now beenleft to clean and dispose of everything myself—at my own expense. If I don’t, I’ve been informed that I may face additional charges. This is unacceptable and places an unfairfinancial and operational burden on my business. I understand that I am not alone—many neighboring businesses are facing similar challenges. This message needs your attention This is a personal email address. This is their first email to your company. Mark Safe Report Powered by Mimecast Additionally, the presence of these encampments has created ongoing safety concerns. Severalfamilies have shared their discomfort and hesitation about bringing their children to class, due to the unpredictable and sometimes unsafe conditions surrounding my studio. This is not justan inconvenience; it poses a direct risk to the well-being of the children, their families, my staff, and the reputation of our school. I would like to know what specific actions the city is taking to address these challenges. WhileI understand that this is a complex issue, local businesses should not be expected to shoulder the consequences alone. The safety of our community and the ability for small businesses tooperate without disruption should be a priority. I urge the City of Palo Alto to present a clear and immediate plan of action that includes: Proper and reliable waste management enforcement Increased monitoring and enforcement of local ordinances Measures to ensure public safety for local families and business owners Attached to this email are photos documenting the contamination of my garbage disposal andthe resulting conditions. I hope these images convey the seriousness of the situation and the urgent need for intervention. Thank you for your attention to this matter. I look forward to your response and to seeing meaningful steps taken to support the well-being of our local business community. Sincerely, Ramon Moreno Owner & Director Ramon Moreno School of Ballet Please feel free to text or call:650-304-1909 Thank you, Ramon Moreno www.ramonmorenoballet.comwww.facebook.com/pg/RamonMorenoSchool On Thu, Mar 13, 2025 at 12:43 PM Lester Wong <LWong@wongelectric.com> wrote:Commercial St. was cleared last night. Thank you for your efforts! Lester Wong | Vice President O: 650.813.9999 ext. 22 | C: 650.720.8455 4067 Transport Street | Palo Alto | CA 94303 Celebrating Our 46th Anniversary 1978 – 2024 A Proud Member of the U.S. Green Building Council From: Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com> Sent: Thursday, March 13, 2025 12:37:47 PM To: Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction> Cc: Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org <chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org>; osbaldo@or-builders.com <osbaldo@or-builders.com>; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lester Wong <LWong@wongelectric.com>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr <CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com <Jacob@onemovemovers.com>; david@paloaltoconcrete.com <david@paloaltoconcrete.com>; Steve Wong <SWong@wongelectric.com>; RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com <RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com <nancy@drewmaran.com>; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific-equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough <Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <vicki.veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org> Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety The wooden RV seems to be a severe safety issue. A former coworker spoke to the man living in it a couple years ago and was told there is a wood burning oven/stove inside theRV, which he uses. Seems like that could be a severe safety hazard not only for the man residing in it, as well as for the surrounding RV's/vehicles & businesses if it were ever tocatch fire. We have had to face a number of safety hazards on this street. It is unsafe for pedestrians. We have had attempted break ins at night. We have been harassed by people associated withthese RV's, as well as loose dogs, just to name a couple issues. Luckily, police officers do respond and try to help but there will be a time when they will be too late to prevent injury. The community officers coming through and putting notices on vehicles is nowhere near the solution needed for this area. The notices are thrown away and the vehicles rarely move. Ibelieve this email string started in 2023 and we have had minimal progress with the actual issues at hand. On Thu, Mar 13, 2025 at 12:19 PM Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction> wrote:City of palo alto!! please let me know how this is Legal for driving also come and clean the street as it’s not safe see attached Maor Greenberg CEO maor@greenberg.construction | 650-610-7711 Greenberg.Construction | 650-600-9536x101 | Fax 925-269-2325908 Industrial Ave, Palo Alto 94303 From: Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com> Sent: Wednesday, March 12, 2025 10:56:09 AM To: Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com> Cc: Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>; Marguerite Poyatos <MARGUERITE@paloaltoglass.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org <chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org>; osbaldo@or-builders.com <osbaldo@or-builders.com>; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lester Wong <lwong@wongelectric.com>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr <CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com <Jacob@onemovemovers.com>; david@paloaltoconcrete.com <david@paloaltoconcrete.com>; Steve Wong <swong@wongelectric.com>; RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com <RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com <nancy@drewmaran.com>; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific- equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough <Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <james.reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <vicki.veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <pat.burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott- Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction> Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial Safety What is it going to take for the city of Palo Alto to catch up to the rest of the country? A lawsuit when someone in our neighborhood is injured because of the unsafe conditionsthat exist here? This email chain alone would be enough evidence to show the city’s knowledge of the problem and inaction. With newly enacted laws giving cities the legal right to clean up our public spaces, localcities like Mountain View, Santa Clara and San Jose have already begun the process of relocating and housing these people that need it. Why not Palo Alto? Its not a money issuehere, and even if it was, wouldn’t it be less costly to tow some vehicles and help relocate them to a safer area than to pay the cost of litigation? We are asking the city to stop ignoring this issue before it becomes an even biggerproblem. On Mar 12, 2025, at 9:17 AM, Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com> wrote: Hi Ben, Please take action. The safety of our employees and locals is critical. Anyone walking or driving on Industrial/Transport/Commercial is constantly at risk. Every crosswalk and entry is a major risk for anyone walking the sidewalks or pulling into any of these facilities where illegally parked abandoned vehicles are encamped. The visibility is very poor and the reason there are height and length restrictions for these types of streets; There are There are illegally running generators with unsafe live electrical lines oftentimes in the sidewalk or even running across entryways There are collections of volatile liquids like gasoline and oil (environmental issues aside) that pose additional hazards to anyone in the vicinity Please let us know what you need from us to support your team in enforcing our city regulations in order to make our workplaces safer for our employees. Respectfully, Patrick Kelly | CIO DMD Systems Recovery, LLC. C: 650.492.9003 patrick.kelly@dmdsystems.com | www.dmdsystems.com <Outlook-DMD Logo.png> <Outlook-larpkod1.png>Book time to meet with me From: Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> Sent: Wednesday, February 5, 2025 12:39 PM To: Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com> Cc: Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>; chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org <chantal.gaines@cityofpaloalto.org>; osbaldo@or-builders.com <osbaldo@or- builders.com>; Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>; Benjamin Becchetti <Benjamin.Becchetti@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lester Wong <lwong@wongelectric.com>; Cathi Lerch <cathi@lerchconstruction.com>; Dave Stellman <dave@paloaltoglass.com>; City Mgr <CityMgr@cityofpaloalto.org>; Pete Moffatt <pete@petemoffat.com>; Jacob@onemovemovers.com <Jacob@onemovemovers.com>; david@paloaltoconcrete.com <david@paloaltoconcrete.com>; Steve Wong <swong@wongelectric.com>; RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com <RamonMorenoSchool@gmail.com>; nancy@drewmaran.com <nancy@drewmaran.com>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; Dan McKinley <danmck@scientific- equipment.com>; Melissa McDonough <Melissa.McDonough@cityofpaloalto.org>; James Reifschneider <James.Reifschneider@cityofpaloalto.org>; Transportation <Transportation@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Kelly <Patrick.Kelly@dmdsystems.com>; John Lerch <john@lerchconstruction.com>; Andrew Binder <Andrew.Binder@cityofpaloalto.org>; Jade Jin <JJin@wongelectric.com>; Xenia Czisch <Xenia@qmsshields.com>; City Attorney <city.attorney@cityofpaloalto.org>; Ed Lauing <Ed.Lauing@cityofpaloalto.org>; Lydia Kou <Lydia.Kou@cityofpaloalto.org>; Vicki Veenker <Vicki.Veenker@cityofpaloalto.org>; City Council <city.council@cityofpaloalto.org>; Patrick Burt <Pat.Burt@cityofpaloalto.org>; Greer Stone <Greer.Stone@cityofpaloalto.org>; Julie Lythcott-Haims <Julie.LythcottHaims@cityofpaloalto.org>; Maor <maor@greenberg.construction> Subject: Re: Industrial/Transport/Commercial concerns A citation for double parking and expired tags is what is needed here. I’m positive that’s what the police would do to me if I did the same. That is unlessthere are two separate sets of laws that govern the city of Palo Alto and the state of California. Bill McLane --------------------------------- Palo Alto Glass, Inc. 4085 Transport Street Palo Alto, CA 94303 650-494-7000 Office www.paloaltoglass.com On Wed, Feb 5, 2025 at 10:13 AM Marguerite Poyatos<marguerite@paloaltoglass.com> wrote:Please see the attached image. The pictured RV & associated white truck pulled up over night. Aspictured, they disregarded marked parking spots, which is one of the thingsthat exacerbates our parking issue. A small car or motorcycle may fit there but in a commercial area wheremost vehicles are trucks, this does not help. Can you please send a community officer to leave notices on the RVs? Ihope this doesn't come across as petty, but every spot really does matter onthis block. Employees of some businesses have to park in lots that belong toother businesses, which can create tension amongst neighbors. Thank you. On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 9:19 PM Dave Stellman<davestellman@gmail.com> wrote:The police also responded and were very helpful. Initially the peopleinvolved denied everything, but when I sent the videos to the officer andhe showed it to them they admitted to dumping their RV waste. Theywere cited for misdemeanor illegal waste dumping and will be going tocourt. They were then told to leave the area - and freed up two parkingspaces. Thank you Palo Alto Police and Fire. Apparently reportingviolations of every kind is what is going to have to be done on a regularbasis if we want our streets cleaned up. On Dec 21, 2024, at 3:39 PM, Bill McLane<bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: Thank you, Dave! Bill McLane --------------------------------- Palo Alto Glass, Inc. 4085 Transport Street Palo Alto, CA 94303 650-494-7000 Office www.paloaltoglass.com On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 8:22 AM Dave Stellman<davestellman@gmail.com> wrote: I just called the hotline for Palo Alto for hazardous wastedumping and gave them all of this information including license numbers. These vehicles are still parked there.Theyare sending the fire department out to flush the street and these people better be held accountable. On Dec 21, 2024, at 7:56 AM, Bill McLane<bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: License plate of the accomplice<IMG_0142.jpeg> Bill McLane --------------------------------- Palo Alto Glass, Inc. 4085 Transport Street Palo Alto, CA 94303 650-494-7000 Office www.paloaltoglass.com On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 5:13 AM Bill McLane<bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: Still parked right across from my building. Note, NO rear license plate. I do think that is against the law. I do also have video of them driving up, proof of the vehicle operating on city streets. Do you think they have insurance? <image.png> Bill McLane --------------------------------- Palo Alto Glass, Inc. 4085 Transport Street Palo Alto, CA 94303 650-494-7000 Office www.paloaltoglass.com On Sat, Dec 21, 2024 at 4:54 AM BillMcLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com> wrote: Here, they are emptying their waste in front of my building. Bill McLane ---------------------------------Palo Alto Glass, Inc. 4085 Transport Street Palo Alto, CA 94303 650-494-7000 Office www.paloaltoglass.com On Fri, Dec 20, 2024 at 9:18 PM DaveStellman <davestellman@gmail.com>wrote:Chantal, It looks like somehow most of the citycouncil members, Vice Mayor andMayor must have inadvertently beendeleted from your last email response. I have added them back in to make surethey stay apprised of the situation. I hopeit doesn't take the legal channelsmentioned to start cleaning up ourneighborhood immediately; this hasgotten out of control and kicking theproblem back and forth to differentmembers of your city staff is not goingto make it go away. Dave StellmanTransport St. On Fri, Dec 20, 2024 at 8:16 AM MaorGreenberg<maor@greenberg.construction> wrote: Dear Chantal, Your response, while detailed, fails to address the critical and ongoing violations of law, public safety, and business rights in the area. The City of Palo Alto has both the authority and obligation to take immediate and decisive action to protect its residents, businesses, and public spaces. Allowing illegally parked, unsafe, and hazardous RVs to persist is unacceptable and directly violates state and local regulations. Below are specific legal and factual challenges to the City’s approach, along with demands for corrective action: 1. Illegally Parked and Unsafe RVs California Vehicle Code § 4000(a) (1) and Palo Alto Municipal Code §10.48.010 clearly require all vehicles parked on public streets to display valid registration. Many of the RVs in question lack valid registration, making their presence illegal. Further, under California Vehicle Code § 22651(o) and PAMC § 10.48.120, any vehicle unregistered for six months or more may be towed immediately. Additionally, vehicles with exposed sewage tanks, missing wheels, or other structural hazards are in direct violation of CaliforniaVehicle Code § 24002, which prohibits parking or operating vehicles in unsafe conditions. These RVs also create a public health hazard under California Health andSafety Code § 117490, which prohibits improper disposal of waste and sewage. **2. Clarification RequestedRegarding Unregistered Vehicles In light of your response, please confirmwhether the City of Palo Alto allowsunregistered vehicles to be driven on itsstreets. - I have some fun vehicles I wouldlove to order from Alibaba and drivethem around Palo Alto... • California Vehicle Code § 4000(a)(1) expressly prohibits the operation of unregistered vehicles. If these RVs are being moved every 72 hours as claimed, and they lack proper registration, their operation is illegal under state law. • Allowing unregistered vehicles to remain or operate within city limits undermines traffic safety and compliance standards. This point must be clarified explicitly:Does the City of Palo Alto condone theoperation of unregistered vehicles? 3. Abuse of the 72-Hour Rule The City’s reliance on PAMC §10.36.060 to justify the continued presence of these RVs is flawed. Surveillance footage and eyewitness accounts confirm that many RVs are circumventing the 72-hour rule by wiping off chalk markings rather than physically moving. This is blatant non- compliance and undermines the intent of the ordinance. Furthermore, California Vehicle Code § 22669 explicitly allows for the removal of vehicles that are “wrecked, dismantled, or inoperative,” even if they are moved every 72 hours. The City has the authority to act, and failing to do so jeopardizes public safety and traffic flow. 4. Public Safety and SanitationViolations The exposed sewage tanks, illegal dumping, and general neglect by these RV occupants pose significant health and environmental risks. The City’s failure to enforce sanitation laws, such as California Health and Safety Code § 117490 and PAMC § 16.09.100, endangers residents, workers, and the environment. Additionally, blocking roadways and driveways is a clear violation of California Vehicle Code § 22500, which prohibits parking that obstructs traffic flow or access. 5. Impact on Businesses and TrafficFlow Businesses in the area are suffering due to blocked roadways, limited parking for customers, and safety concerns. Under California Vehicle Code § 21101(c) and PAMC § 10.48.120, the City has the authority to regulate parking to ensure the safety of businesses and residents. The City’s failure to allocate parking for business deliveries, customers, or even emergency services is a gross dereliction of duty. Blocking roadways for long periods creates safety hazards, violates municipal code, and disrupts commerce. Conclusion and Final Demands The City of Palo Alto has the legal authority and responsibility to act under the following regulations: • PAMC § 10.48.120: Authorizes the removal of unregistered vehicles. • California Vehicle Code § 22651(o): Allows towing of unregistered vehicles. • California Vehicle Code § 22669: Mandates removal of inoperative vehicles. • California Health and Safety Code § 117490: Prohibits illegal waste disposal. • California Vehicle Code § 21101(c): Permits parking restrictions to ensure safety. We demand the immediate implementation of the following measures: 1. Impound all unregistered, unsafe, or inoperative RVs within two weeks. 2. Establish designated loading zones and 2-hour parking areas near businesses. 3. Conduct regular sanitation inspections and impose penalties for violations. 4. Provide a clear timeline for resolution and enforcement updates. The continued failure to act exposes the City to liability for neglecting public health and safety under California Government Code § 815.6, which requires municipalities to perform mandatory duties. We expect aformal response with a clear action plan within 14 days. If no satisfactory action is taken, we reserve the right to escalate this matter through legal channels to protect our businesses, employees, and the community. <email- signture_87b8d7a2-c4f4-4cbf-b474- af2f32118dd2.png> Maor Greenberg CEO maor@greenberg.construction |650-610-7711 Greenberg.Construction | 650-600-9536 x101 | Fax 925-269-2325908 Industrial Ave, Palo Alto94303 <F_1bc77f31-68bf-4143-80ea-3f34f539ea07.png> <insta_26696304-1b39- 4259-9776-9f137454bed9.png> <yelp_e821c57e-caea- 4e87-a5dd-5905e7ca4fb1.png> <Houzz_7abe75ad-d6ee- 48ac-943b-592713e31957.png> <P_aece63f3-754b-4dca- a0a9-e93b94de4930.png> <google_04352117-2fb4-4963-bb3e- cc5317269360.png> From: Gaines, Chantal <Chantal.Gaines@CityofPaloAlto.org> Date: Friday, December 20, 2024 at 7:12 AM To: Maor Greenberg <maor@greenberg.construction>, Marguerite Poyatos <marguerite@paloaltoglass.com>, osbaldo@or-builders.com <osbaldo@or-builders.com> Cc: Bill McLane <bill@paloaltoglass.com>, Dave Stellman <davestellman@gmail.com>, Manu Kumar <manu@k9ventures.com>, Becchetti, Benjamin <Benjamin.Becchetti@CityofPaloAlto.org>, Lester Wong <lwong@wongelectric.com>, Cathi Lerch <