HomeMy WebLinkAbout2024-09-09 City Council EmailsFrom:Jennifer Koga
To:Council, City
Subject:Please vote against PA airport expansion
Date:Sunday, September 8, 2024 5:16:00 PM
CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening
attachments and clicking on links.
Hello,
As a concerned citizen, I am reaching out to you to request you vote against the plans to expand the Palo Alto airport runways. This morning
I was on a bird-watching field trip to the duck pond and surrounding wet land that are under consideration for removal to make room for the
runway(s). At this site, I and everyone on the trip, got to see and appreciate so many shore birds that call this place home, and need it
for their habitat. We saw many Northern Shovelers on the pond, along with a black crowned Night Heron, American Coot, and Pie billed grebe on
the pond. In the surrounding wetland, immediately adjacent to the pond, we witnessed many, many birds: Western sandpipers, song sparrows,
Ridgeway Rails, long-billed Curlews, Willets, black necked stilts, marbled godwits, long-billed dowitchers, to just name a few.
This place offers a unique habitat, and gives Palo Alto residents and
fellow Bay Area residents a place to enjoy beauty of the wildlife just at our fingertips. I implore you to rethink this plan. If Palo Alto
truly wishes to honor its place in the Bay Area, it should honor one of the reasons we so lover living here and visiting these sites. Please,
lets not be short sighted about making room for charter planes, and not considering how we may gravely impact the birds and other wildlife that
call that place home. This wet land also provides a natural barrier to sea level rise, decreasing risk to the surrounding homes and businesses.
Lets be an example to other cities across the nation, and not bend to pressures for short term economic gain.
Thank you,
Jennifer Koga
(San Jose resident who visits the Bay Lands and loves it)
--
This email has been checked for viruses by AVG antivirus software.www.avg.com
From:Henry Etzkowitz
To:Palo Post; Gennady Sheyner; Roberta Ahlquist; Lotus Fong; Brian Good; Rebecca Eisenberg; Jeanne Fleming;Charlie Weidanz; Jim Hersh; Bette Kiernan; Avroh Shah; Shikada, Ed; Council, City; mickie winkler; MartyWasserman; Mary Rorty; Ellen Fox
Subject:Public space over offices
Date:Saturday, September 7, 2024 5:27:41 AM
CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking
on links.
Let’s applaud the decision of the architectural review board to reject turning the CineArts theatre, an iconic public
space into private offices. Let’s explore following the successful model of transforming the Guild Theater into a
live music venue while retaining the ability to screen films. We have an office surplus and a shortage of
performance spaces.
Sincerely
Henry Etzkowitz
Candidate for Palo Alto City Council
“Put an Innovation Scholar (and arts advocate) on the City Council” of the hometown of innovation.
Sent from my iPhone
heterocyclic aromatic amines (HCAs) and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons
(PAHs). Studies show HCAs and PAHs cause changes in DNA that may
increase the risk of cancer.
Also, MOST Palo Altans do not grill or have a grill. In addition, grilling is BAD
for the environment
On Thu, Sep 5, 2024 at 9:45 PM City of Palo Alto <news@cityofpaloalto.org> wrote:
P
View as Webpage
What's New
Wellness Month Resources Round-Up
Palo Alto Community Survey Reminders
The Clerk Chronicles: Official Custodian of City Records
Climate Action Series: Fall in Love with Sustainability
Local Energy Building Code Changes Take Effect October 4
Citywide Updates
Wellness Month Resources Round-
Up
Through the month of August, we recognized
National Wellness Month highlighting
resources to reinforce the City Council
Priority: Community Health, Safety,
Wellness, and Belonging and acknowledge
the United States Surgeon General’s advisory
on the Loneliness Epidemic in our country.
Catch up on all of our recent updates
supporting teen wellness, family fun, physical
health, and more. The City shares weekly
wellness resources in the Be Well section of
this newsletter and provides support for the
whole community year-round at www.cityofpaloalto.org/BeWell.
Palo Alto Community Survey Reminders
A few reminders as the 2024 Palo Alto
Community Survey is underway. The survey will
initially be sent via mail to a sample of registered
voters that are a statistically valid population of
Palo Alto and will subsequently be available to all
residents online. The survey is one way among
many through which we gain insights from
residents throughout our community. Please
consider taking the survey if you receive it in the
mail. Learn when the survey will be open
citywide and what to look for to know a survey is
coming from an official source like the City of
Palo Alto.
The Clerk Chronicles: Official Custodian of
City Records
In this second installment in our series, learn about
the essential role of Palo Alto’s Office of the City
Clerk as the official custodian of City records and
gain details on how to get help finding a record you
are looking for. The City Clerk’s team is responsible
for maintaining and safeguarding all official City
records, from meeting minutes to ordinances, and
making sure they are easily accessible to the public.
Read here to learn more about the team behind
the scenes ensuring records are both accurate and
easily accessible by the public.
Climate Action Series: Fall in Love
with Sustainability
Fall is coming and so are sustainability events
in Palo Alto. Get ready for a season filled
with sustainability events, workshops, and
programs that’ll leave you feeling inspired,
informed and ready to take climate action.
From worm composting to SunShares solar
panels, there’s something for everyone from
your garden to your home. Commit to a
greener community together by attending a
Climate Protection Working Group Meeting,
taking a walking tour, and exploring vibrant
gardens. Plus, conserving is cool; gain tips to
save energy during hot weather. Make this next season full of sustainability and fun!
Local Energy Building Code Changes Take
Effect October 4
Palo Alto has required sustainable, climate-friendly
construction for years to protect the local
environment, reduce air pollution, and achieve its
climate goals. On October 4, the City will
implement a new set of low-emissions
construction standards to replace previous all-
electric requirements. Changes allow both all-
electric and mixed fuel construction and require all
new buildings and substantial remodels to be low
emissions. If you are a building professional in Palo
Alto, an information session will be held to answer your questions on Friday, September 20.
Hundreds of Palo Altans building new homes or doing major renovations have already gone
all-electric, and you can too at www.cityofpaloalto.org/GoElectric.
Be Well
Heat & Health: This week’s heat advisory was extended through Friday, September 6. Take
precautions if you’re sensitive to heat and find actions you can take to protect your health
and your family’s during hot weather events from the Center for Disease Control and
Prevention’s HeatRisk site.
Palo Alto Fire CPR Class: Learn how to support community health directly from Palo Alto’s
first responders. On Thursday, September 19, take the hands-only CPR class to learn life-
saving skills. Techniques taught in the class follow the American Heart Association Hands-
Only CPR technique. Register for either the 9 a.m. or 1 p.m. session and have the option to
do an AED training after the class.
Recipe of the Week: Treat yourself to this healthy and delicious grilled peach and
prosciutto salad before summer officially fades. Not only is this a flavorful dish, but it’s also
sustainable, featuring fresh, seasonal ingredients you may find at Downtown Palo Alto’s
Saturday farmer’s market.
Family Resources
Voter Information Workshop: Register for an online workshop to learn how to register to
vote, get an overview of the election process and ballots, and discover opportunities to get
involved from the Santa Clara County Registrar of Voters on Saturday, September 24 at 11
a.m.
Join a Book Club: Connect together through reading! Discuss the latest fiction and
nonfiction while making new friends at the Library’s virtual and in-person book clubs. The
Brown Bag Book Club meets online the 2nd Tuesday of the month at 12 p.m., the Palo Alto
Pageturners meets the 2nd Thursday of the month at 6:30 p.m. at the Rinconada Library,
the Graphic Novel Book Club meets the 2nd Thursday of the month at 7 p.m. at the Mitchell
Park Library, and the YA Reads for Adults meets the 4th Thursday of the month at 6:45 p.m.
at the Rinconada Library.
September is Healthy Aging Month: Join webinars from the National Institute on Aging
including international perspectives on longevity and falls prevention for older adults. Learn
how to Move Your Way with special tips for seniors. Sign up for a Medicare Mysteries
Solved! workshop on Saturday, September 7 at 1 p.m. at the Mitchell Park Library.
STEAM Fun for Kids and Teens: Bring the kids to LEGO Fridays! each week at 4 p.m. at the
College Terrace Library. Watch a robot demo from Paly Robotics on Sunday, September 8 at
4 p.m. at the Mitchell Park Library. And check out other STEAM activities happening at the
library.
Projects for Pets: Bring joy to dogs awaiting adoption and help the environment by
transforming old clothing into dog toys at the Pupcycled: Make a Toy for a Dog in Need
drop-in event on Sunday, September 7 from 3:30 p.m. to 5:30 p.m. at the Mitchell Park
Library.
Calling All Amateur Photographers! Enter your photos in the California Coastal
Commission’s 25th Annual California Ocean and Coastal Amateur Photography Contest.
Submissions are due by 5 p.m. on Sunday, September 30. The contest is free and open to all
amateur photographers.
Calendar & Careers
Join the Conversation & Connect
University Avenue Streetscape Stakeholder
Working Group Meeting
September 10 @ 1:30 p.m.
You’re a Good Man Charlie Brown – The
Musical
September 11 @ 6 p.m.
Climate Protection Working Group Meeting
Find your Next Career with Us!
Administrative Specialist - Animal Control
Building Inspector
City Hall Customer Service Specialist
Custodial Assistant
From:Tran, Joanna
To:Council, City
Cc:Executive Leadership Team; ORG - Clerk"s Office
Subject:Council Consent Questions: 9/9/24
Date:Friday, September 6, 2024 1:13:06 PM
Attachments:image001.pngimage003.pngimage004.pngimage006.pngimage007.pngimage008.pngimage002.png
Dear Mayor and Council Members,
On behalf of City Manager Ed Shikada, please view the following links for the amended agenda and
staff responses to questions submitted by Council Member Tanaka:
September 9 Amended Agenda
Staff responses to Items 3, 5, 7, and 10.
Best,
Joanna
Joanna Tran
Executive Assistant to the City Manager
Office of the City Manager
(650) 329-2105 | joanna.tran@cityofpaloalto.org
www.cityofpaloalto.org
From:David Troup
To:Council, City
Subject:Support for Palo Alto Airport
Date:Friday, September 6, 2024 1:41:36 AM
CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking
on links.
Dear Councilmembers:
There has been community discussion of late about the future of Palo Alto Airport. I’m writing to express my great
appreciation for the airport and its contributions to Palo Alto and other parts of the peninsula.
Many people don’t realize the significant contributions the airport makes. In addition to being a hotbed of economic
activity, including employment and serving as a necessary component in the existence of scores of aviation-related
businesses on and around the airport, the airport plays a vital public safety role, especially following an earthquake
or other natural disaster. There are many examples of disasters befalling communities in which the local airport
became the only lifeline to get vital supplies and personnel in and out. Palo Alto Airport has already played such a
role a number of times in delivering aid to other communities in California in their times of need.
Additionally, the airport is used on a daily basis to transport patients from rural parts of the state to critical medical
appointments at Stanford Hospital and other facilities. “Angel Flights,” operated by volunteer pilots, transport
patients in need of specialty care at no cost to the patients, and there are hundreds of these flights every month,
many of which arrive and depart at Palo Alto Airport.
The airport is also a critical reliever airport which allows smaller planes to avoid the need to use San Francisco
International Airport, which operates pretty much at full capacity most of the time. The utility of the airport is
essential to the distribution of air traffic in the Bay Area.
While some may find the occasional sound of a plane flying overhead to be annoying, the community benefits of the
airport outweigh these small annoyances. And if Palo Alto Airport was not there, the airplanes overhead would not
go away – they would simply move to other nearby airports but would not fly over the city of Palo Alto any less
frequently.
I thank the City of Palo Alto for its excellent stewardship of this critical community asset, and I hope you will
continue to protect and improve it so that it can continue to serve the city and the region for many decades to come.
Sincerely,
David Troup
Message to Our Youth
Invest in LWVPA
LWVPA August Board Meeting Highlights
Advocacy Report
Events In the Community
Reimagining Community
Sibling Cities USA Town Hall
LWVUS Commitment to Protecting Democracy in 2024
Message from our President
I hope you all had a nice summer break and emerge
energized and refreshed!
The general election is quickly approaching. While
many people are focused on the presidential election,
we often hear people say they are overwhelmed and
do not know where to obtain information about local
elections and ballot measures. The League is here to
help! Our Voter Services team has been busy preparing for the five candidate
forums and multiple pros & cons sessions, all scheduled in September and
early October. You can also find Vote with the League–Ballot
Recommendations under the Advocacy Report. Having the knowledge and
confidence to participate is just as important as having the right to vote. A huge
thanks to our dedicated volunteers without whom we cannot carry out this
important work.
We are excited to announce our Fall Kick Off—Making Democracy Work—on
Sunday, October 6, 4-6 pm. We are honored to have Pam Karlan, a leading
expert in voting rights and the nation's political process, as our speaker. This is
a great opportunity for members and friends to reconnect and participate in the
vital discussion of voting and democracy. A group of dedicated volunteers is
working hard to make the Fall Kick Off impactful and memorable. The event is
free; everyone is welcome!
All our work requires funding, and your support strengthens our community and
ensures the League carries out its mission of empowering voters and defending
democracy. If you haven't yet done so, please consider donating to the League
Voting Rights Act, representing overseas voters in a case involving the National
Voter Registration Act, representing Latino voters in vote-dilution lawsuits, and
representing voters challenging Texas’s restriction of no-excuse vote by mail to
voters over the age of 65. Pam has argued ten cases before the Court,
including three voting rights cases.
Pam’s primary scholarship involves constitutional litigation, particularly with
respect to regulation of the political process. She has published dozens of
scholarly articles and is the co-author of three leading casebooks, one of them
on The Law of Democracy.
Pam received her B.A., M.A., and J.D. from Yale. After clerking for U.S. District
Court Judge Abraham Sofaer and Supreme Court Justice Harry Blackmun, she
practiced law at the NAACP Legal Defense and Educational Fund, focusing on
employment discrimination and voting rights. Her public service includes a term
as a commissioner on the California Fair Political Practices Commission, which
implements and enforces the State’s campaign finance, lobbying, and conflict
of interest laws. Most recently, she served as the principal deputy assistant
attorney general in the Civil Rights Division of the U.S. Department of Justice
where she was the reviewer for the Division’s voting rights-related work at both
the trial and appellate levels.
Pam is a member of the American Academy of Arts and Sciences and the
American Law Institute, where she serves on the ALI Council. In 2021, she
received the American Bar Association’s Margaret Brent Award, given to
“women lawyers who have achieved professional excellence and paved the
way for other women in the legal profession.” In 2016, she was named one of
the Politico 50—a group of “thinkers, doers, and visionaries transforming
American politics.” Earlier in her career, the American Lawyer named her to its
Public Sector 45—a group of lawyers “actively using their law degrees to
change lives.”
Register yourself and guests early to help us plan for the catering.
Register Now
Foothill-DeAnza Community College District Board of Trustees
(Area 5) Candidate Forum (Zoom)
Thursday, September 19, 2024
7:00 pm - 8:00 pm
Palo Alto School Board Candidate Forum (Zoom)
Co-Sponsored by PTA Council
Monday, September 23, 2024
6:30 pm - 8:30 pm
Santa Clara County Board of Education (Area 1) Candidate Forum
(Zoom)
Register Now
Ask your Questions
Register Now
Ask your Questions
Register Now
Ask your Questions
Tuesday, October 1, 2024
7:00 pm - 8:00 pm
Congressional District 16 Candidate Forum (Zoom)
Tuesday, October 8, 2024
7:30 pm - 9:00 pm
2024 Pros and Cons
Register Now
Ask your Questions
Register Now
Ask your Questions
On Wednesday, September 25, at 7 pm, join a Zoom webinar presentation
about the Pros and Cons of state ballot propositions and local measures
appearing on the November 5, 2024, ballot. The League of Women Voters
sponsors these Pros and Cons sessions to provide the public with unbiased
information to help inform their election decisions.
For more information, visit our website.
Message to Our Youth
Register Here
local high school students.
Young voters should vote for candidates and issues that align with their
priorities. We are sharing the videos with high school and college educators in
California to lead classroom lessons on Voting and Voter Registration using
these two videos and our 2-page handout "Guide for New California Voters".
You can help us share the videos with family and friends too. Every vote
counts!
Invest in the League of Women Voters of Palo Alto!
The fall is a busy time of the year for the League and we are working hard to
engage and educate our community! Your support right now is more valuable
than ever and we are so grateful for it! If you have already donated, thank you!
Expansion plans for extending the runway to allow for larger, more polluting
aircraft for this general aviation facility in our Baylands. The plans pose a
danger to the Baylands’ critical habitat and recreational use and are
inconsistent with the 2008 Baylands Master Plan generally forbidding any
airport intensified use or significant intrusion into open space. The plans failed
to mention that any extension outside existing airport boundaries would require
a vote by the people of Palo Alto, who dedicated the Baylands as parkland by
initiative in 1965. Because preservation of wetlands as a carbon sink is a key
strategy to fighting global warming and sea level rise, the plans are also
inconsistent with the City and State Climate Action Plans and the city’s 2017
Comprehensive Plan. Read the letter drafted by our Natural Resources
committee HERE.
Gun Violence Prevention: The City proclaimed August 26-30 Be SMART Week,
following a request from our Gun Violence Prevention chair, Stacey Ashlund.
Be SMART week raises public awareness about secure gun storage, a
program developed by Everytown for Gun Safety Support Fund. League
volunteers Jane Moss and Stacey Ashlund took Be SMART information to
PAUSD back-to-school nights.
If you are interested in joining our Natural Resources or Gun Violence
Prevention committees, please email us at office@lwvpaloalto.org and the
committee chair will contact you.
Vote with the League
Ballot Recommendations for November 2024 Election
The League of Women Voters wears “two hats”: Voter Services and Advocacy.
In its Voter Services role, the League works to make sure that every citizen can
vote, every vote is counted, and every voter has fair and unbiased information
to understand the issues on the ballot and the candidates’ opinions.
In its Advocacy role, the League studies public issues and takes stands on
them—so that we may support or oppose ballot measures, proposed laws, and
government actions in order to educate our fellow citizens about significant
policy issues and influence public policy through our education and advocacy.
Ballot recommendations are based on existing League positions. If no League
positions exist relevant to the proposition, LWVC will make no
recommendation. The League will be neutral on a proposition if conflicting
policy considerations seem equal. If a League position is relevant to a ballot
proposition, the League will analyze the proposition and either support or
oppose it, offering its recommendations to the public. This is different from the
League’s Voter Services Pros and Cons forums, where no recommendations
are made.
Summary of LWVC Ballot Recommendations for the Nov. 5, 2024, General
Election
(Read the full League ballot recommendations)
Prop 2—Support—School and Community College Facility Bonds. Prop 2
would supplement local bonds by authorizing $8.5 billion in state bonds for
construction and modernization of K-12 schools and $1.5 billion for community
colleges. Prop 2 is critical to our children’s health, safety, and educational
progress. No new bond money for school facilities has passed since 2016.
There is a massive need for modernization and construction across the state.
Prop 3—Support—Freedom to Marry. Prop 3 would enshrine marriage
equality in the state Constitution. While the U.S. Supreme Court has recognized
same-sex marriages, the current Supreme Court has shown it is willing to
revoke hard-earned rights. Prop. 3 would protect the fundamental right to marry
for same-sex and interracial couples.
Prop 4—Support—Climate Protection Project Bonds. Prop 4 would authorize
$10 billion for projects mitigating the effects of climate change. The bond
money would go toward projects to improve water quality and supply, protect
against wildfires, and enhance the resilience of natural ecosystems. 40% of
funding would go to low-income communities vulnerable to heightened risks of
climate change.
Prop 5—Support—Lower Voting Threshold on Local Housing and
Infrastructure Bonds. Prop 5 would reduce the voting margin to approve local
bonds and taxes for affordable housing, transportation, parks, and other public
infrastructure from 66.7% to 55%. The current vote threshold makes it
extremely difficult to secure local funding for vital projects. Lowering the voting
margin to 55% would allow communities by majority vote to act quickly to
address urgent housing shortages and infrastructure needs, promoting
economic growth, quality of life, and investment in essential public services.
Prop 6—Support—End Slavery in California Act. Prop 6 would delete
language in the state constitution which allows involuntary servitude as
punishment for a crime. Abolishing this exception for modern day slavery
supports the rehabilitation and reintegration of people in jail or prison by
allowing them to choose educational and rehabilitative programs over forced
labor.
Prop 32—Support—Raises Minimum Wage to $18. California’s current
minimum wage is well below the estimated living wage needed to support a
household’s basic needs. Prop 32 would raise the minimum wage for
employers that employ 26 or more people to $18 per hour in 2025 and 2026.
For businesses that employ 25 or fewer, the minimum wage would be $17 per
hour in 2025 and $18 per hour in 2026. Prop 32 pauses inflation adjustments
until 2027. After that, the minimum wage would go up each year based on
inflation.
Prop 33—Neutral—Expands Local Authority to Enact Rent Control on
Residential Property. Prop 33 would expand the types of rental units subject to
local rent control laws. The League supports efforts to help resolve California’s
housing crisis, but because there are benefits and drawbacks to rent control,
the League has chosen to be neutral on Prop 33.
Prop 34—No Position—Restricts Spending by Health Care Providers Meeting
Specified Criteria. When the LWVC has no position relevant to a ballot
measure, we offer no analysis.
Prop 35—Oppose—Permanent Funding for Medi-Cal Health Care Services.
Prop 35 would change the temporary tax that helps fund Medi-Cal to a
permanent tax on Managed Care Organizations and require the tax be used to
support only Medi-Cal and other health programs, making that money
unavailable for other priorities and making it difficult to respond to future
changes to Medi-Cal. The League is generally opposed to “ballot-box
budgeting” which limits the legislature’s ability to adjust priorities based on
emerging and essential needs.
Prop 36—Oppose—Increase Penalties for Theft and Drug Trafficking. Prop 36
would allow harsher sentences for minor offenses like drug possession and
retail theft, taking California back to the days when we had unconstitutionally
overcrowded prisons. Prop 36 would shift money from treatment and
rehabilitation to prisons, detracting from effective and humane criminal justice
policies.
inequality, and the movement of peoples across borders? What are the biggest
threats to democracy within and beyond the United States? How are
democratic norms and culture passed down from one generation to the next?
How can “we the people” strengthen and reimagine democracy together? This
lecture series is a complement to election-related Continuing Studies courses
and other educational activities around voting and civic participation being
offered this fall.
See the Program Schedule and Speakers HERE.
Town Hall
Democracy: Voter Access and Turnout
Sunday, September 29, 2024
1:00 - 3:00 pm
Mitchell Park Community Center
El Palo Alto Room, 3700 Middlefield, Palo Alto
Following the very successful joint town halls with residents of Bloomington,
Indiana, and Palo Alto over the last year, Sibling Cities USA is excited to
Register Now
announce an upcoming conversation deeply relevant to the November Election:
“Voter Access and Turnout.”
Included in the event will be short background presentations from
representatives in both cities and open dialog between the two groups.
Residents are invited to attend in-person meetings in both communities, with
simultaneous video connections between them.
Partners in this vital discussion as we anticipate the upcoming national
elections are the League of Women Voters, Braver Angels, the Indiana
University Office of Political and Civic Engagement (PACE), and Stanford’s
Intercollegiate Civil Disagreement program.
ABOUT SIBLING CITIES USA TOWN HALLS
The Cities of Bloomington, IN, and Palo Alto, CA, are the first Sibling Cities in a
national project that opens meaningful dialog between communities in different
parts of the country. Calls for national unity are increasing in response to
today’s national divides and Americans yearn to move past the polarization
afflicting our country. Knitting this country back together is essential and
Bloomington is part of the solution! Want to join the discussion? Ready to listen
with curiosity and empathy? Want to understand what people in Bloomington,
IN, think about democracy and voter access? Want to share your views and
build friendship, trust, and respect across the miles? You’re invited to
participate!
For more information about this initiative, contact Palo Alto program
director Jyotika RoyC at jyoroyc@gmail.com or Bloomington project coordinator
Alain Barker at abarker@indiana.edu.
Register Now
Sign Up for LWV California & LWVUS News & Alerts
Click here to sign up for LWVC Newsletter and LWVC Action Alerts
Click here to sign up for LWVUS Email News (at bottom) and LWVUS
Action Alerts
How to contact your elected officials
All your elected officials
United States
President Joseph R. Biden (202) 456-1414
Senator Laphonza R. Butler (202) 224-3841
Senator Alex Padilla (202) 224-3553
Rep. Anna Eshoo (650) 323-2984
California
Governor Gavin Newsom (916) 445-2841
Senator Josh Becker (650) 212-3313
Assemblymember Marc Berman (650) 691-2121
Santa Clara County
Supervisor Joe Simitian (650) 965-8737
joe.simitian@bos.sccgov.org
Other Areas in California
Locate your elected officials by using your street address
JOIN A TEAM
PC 2533 adopted a land use plan that shows the location of thetheaters.
Replacing the theaters with offices requires an amendment tothe PC zone district pursuant to PAMC Chapter 18.80.
Thank you for your consideration of these comments.
Herb Borock
From:Star Teachout
To:Architectural Review Board
Cc:Council, City
Subject:Please keep the Palo Alto Square movie theater
Date:Wednesday, September 4, 2024 3:55:14 PM
Some people who received this message don't often get email from teachout@sonic.net. Learn why this isimportant
Dear Architectural Review Board and developer,
As a resident of the Barron Park neighborhood of Palo Alto, and the parent of 3 young men
ages 19-26, we encourage you to reconsider the conversion proposal of a vacant CinéArtstheater use to an office use within Building 6 at Palo Alto Square for the following reasons:
1. Walkable: We are doing our part to ease the housing and climate crisis by allowing our
sons to live with us in a 2 BR house until they are financially ready to move. Providing amovie theater nearby allows us to walk or cycle to the movies without adding more carbon to
the atmosphere.
2. Affordablity: For many people—especially younger people who don’t/can’t regularly affordbars and restaurants—going to the movies is still an affordable treat. With the closure of the
Icon Theater on San Antonio, the timing is especially good for this theater to reopen. Offeringteen discounts would be a fabulous way to show you care about them too.
3. Welcoming to teens/young: What with the loss of connections exacerbating poor mental
health (especially in youth) and loneliness, we need more public gathering spaces not fewer.Not that long ago Palo Alto contained a bowling alley, Fry’s electronics (good for roaming
teens and techies), Antonio’s Nuthouse (family friendly), The Fish Market (family friendly),the Palo Alto Square Y, and more.
4. Arts: Have you been to the converted Guild Theater for music? It is awesome. I can
imagine something similar where the space provides not only music performances, but alsolectures, streamed operas (as they used to do), small conferences, group meetings (current
events, sustainability, etc).
5. Movies: The alternative and foreign films once offered at this theater would be veryappreciated at this time. Furthermore, we could host an animation festival, or other cultural
film festivals. Palo Alto could use a bit more energy to revitalize it in ways seen inneighboring cities. A business office does not move us in that direction.
5. Housing focus area: It seems very short-sighted to convert this space into more offices
considering the current vacancies. In an area which has been over-approved as a “housingfocus area” we should be doing EVERYTHING in our capacities to minimize traffic by
offering recreational activities nearby. We will have so many more people sharing this smallgeographical area, and you would be doing a service to our community by considering this
modest proposal.
6. Hudson Pacific Properties: Please consider that the”world’s most innovative, growtheconomies” are driven by people who benefit from expanding their minds through the arts and
making social connections.
Thank you for considering,Star Teachout
Palo Alto, CA
2. PUBLIC HEARING / QUASI‐JUDICIAL. [23PLN‐00110] 3000 El Camino Real (Palo Alto
Square): Recommendation on Applicant’s Request for Approval of a Major Architectural
Review for facade changes and site improvements associated with conversion of a
vacant theater use to an office use within Building 6. Exempt from the provisions of the
California Environmental Quality Act in accordance with CEQA Guidelines Section 15303
(new construction and conversion of small structures). Zoning: PC‐4648. For more
information contact the project planner Claire.Raybould@Cityofpaloalto.org.
You want to know the date of tenancy, initial length and date of last renewal. Why?
City is interested to know the tenancy information of your unit to understand if you have
longer term tenants, or the tenants with quicker turnover with short term leases. This will help
the City to understand the nature of rental markets in Palo Alto.
Do you want to know about all rent changes as they occur in the future?
Yes, rent increases must be reported within ten days of occurrence.
Will you pay for my costs to provide all the demanded information?
The City recognizes that the initial registration period in this first year of the program will take
some time and is here to provide support services, including small group registration
workshops. Information entered this year will be saved to expedite future registration
processes and bulk information upload features will be available for properties with ten or
more units. The rental registry fee that would typically be associated with this program has
been waived in this first year to encourage participation.
Ed
misses."
Again, I know of many children in lower elementary school at Palo Verde who cross theseintersections to walk to school, unaccompanied by an adult. We must make these
intersections safe!
I'm copying City Council - I believe they should be kept on these emails, not removed, asthe City has been doing.
We are now in week 2 of school, and nothing has been done to fix the unsafe intersections.
Could you please provide an update?
Thank you,
Trish TamraziConcerned Palo Alto Homeowner
On Fri, Aug 16, 2024 at 6:28 PM Star-Lack, Sylvia <Sylvia.Star-Lack@cityofpaloalto.org>
wrote:
Hi Patricia,
Thank you for your email messages. Due to staff being on vacation, I am providing this
partial response to you regarding our Safe Routes to School program. I’ll have more for
you next week when critical staff return to the office. Thanks for your patience with me.
Suggested Routes to School
One of your recent email messages included your understanding that routes on our
Suggested School Route maps are guaranteed to be safe. The Safe Routes to School
movement is nationwide, with many cities producing school route maps. No city can
guarantee safety for road users, but cities can select suggested routes that may have
lower traffic, slower speeds, good sightlines, crossing guards, and other elements that
make them more appropriate than other routes for schoolchildren to walk and bike to
school. Even so, our maps include the following text:
The Palo Alto Safe Routes to School Partnership encourages parents to walk or bike
with students and use this mapping tool to explore options for commuting from
home to school. Parents are responsible for choosing the most appropriate route
based on their knowledge of conditions on the route between home and school and
the experience level of their child.
Sharing Feedback
I wanted to make you aware of several channels we encourage residents to use to share
road safety feedback and get involved in promoting safer commuting.
The City/School Transportation Safety Committee (CSTSC) is comprised of community
members, City of Palo Alto staff, and Palo Alto Unified School District staff who serve in an
advisory capacity to the City Manager and the Superintendent on matters relating to
school traffic safety for students. Members of the public are welcome to attend the
monthly meetings. Meetings are typically held the fourth Thursday of the month. Meeting
information can be found on the Safe Routes to School Main Page. If you are interested in
getting on the City School Traffic Safety Committee meeting agenda, please email us at
saferoutes@cityofpaloalto.org.
You can also reach out to the Palo Verde PTA Transportation Safety Representative (TSR),
who can work with you to educate parents at your school regarding safer driving behavior
and safer walking and biking practices for students (such as how to navigate uncontrolled
intersections). While engineering improvements are an element of our Safe Routes to
School program, there are five other elements that work together to support safer school
commutes: Education, Encouragement, Engagement, Evaluation, and Equity. Working
with your school’s TSR to help encourage more biking and walking to school will reduce
the number of cars in and around the school, reducing risk to everyone using the adjacent
roads.
Additionally, as I mentioned in my prior email, the City is also working on two Council
priority planning documents to improve roadway safety that will benefit vulnerable road
users: the Bicycle and Pedestrian Transportation Plan Update and the Safe Streets for All
Safety Action Plan. Council will have an opportunity to review and approve these
documents and the policies and programs contained therein in the coming months.
Community engagement opportunities and feedback sessions on these planning initiatives
at standing committee meetings (CSTSC, Pedestrian and Bicycle Advisory Committee, and
Planning and Transportation Commission) are also forthcoming, so please watch the
committee and Council agendas and the project websites for events and meetings where
you can provide your input.
I will get back to you regarding the other items you raised next week. Thanks, again, for
1. various safety issues within Utilities (emergency line not properly staffed, linemanuntrained and harrassed while working, maintenance not done, records not in line
with the industry, etc.),
2. water contamination by the City's untrained contractors, with the City refusing to
competently bring the contractor in line,
3. City taking funds from parents for middle school athletics, providing a sub-par
service, saying there is no money to pay coaches such that more children who wantto play can actually play, then sending money to the General Fund,
4. fire houses not properly staffed such that we are a fire engine short in South PaloAlto,
5. illegal (incomplete) responses to Public Records Requests,
6. claims for damages submitted to the City virtually never paid,
7. and - the matter at hand - unsafe intersections.
Thank you again for trying to help. I do appreciate you.
With kind regards,
Trish
Trish Tamrazi
Concerned Palo Alto Homeowner
State Bar No. 279541
Tamrazi.Law@gmail.com
On Thu, Aug 15, 2024 at 11:12 AM Star-Lack, Sylvia <Sylvia.Star-Lack@cityofpaloalto.org> wrote:
Hi Ms. Tamrazi,
I am working on a response to your email messages and will get back to you soon. If
improve safety on Palo Alto's streets, focusing on other unsafe intersections, includingsome which have been flagged for years by residents as unsafe to BIKES along PaloAlto's designated "Bicycle Boulevard" on Ross Rd. (Many report almost getting hit onbikes and - in fact - getting hit! Even years ago! Yet the unsafe intersections remainunchanged.)
(2) The problem: everyone is passing responsibility - so where does the buck stop?
These advocates tell me that they are stuck in a full circle of passing the buck:
City staff (traffic engineer) says only City Council can decide traffic signage.
City Council says only City staff can decide traffic signage.
This is, of course, ABSURD!!
(3) The law: the City has heightened duty of care and is actively breaching thatduty.
Many of us here in Palo Alto trust our City. When the City designates "Safe Routes toSchool" - we expect them to be safe for students. When the City designates a "BicycleBoulevard" - we expect it to be safe for bikers. Yet, these designated routes areglaringly unsafe!
I believe, further, that this heightened expectation is supported by common law. Ibelieve that by designating these routes, the City has legally created a heightened dutyof care. My understanding is that the City has been on notice for years of thesedangerous shortcomings, yet has not responded.
Analogous would be the special duty imposed on landowners to invitees: the City ofPalo Alto has, by designating these routes, made students going to school on its "SafeRoutes to School" and bicyclists on its "Bicycle Boulevard" invitees of the streets onthese routes. An invitee is owed the highest duty of care. Park goers, for example, arepublic invitees. The landowner has a duty to take reasonable care to prevent injuries toany invitee on their premises. This includes a requirement to frequently inspect the landto ensure that it is safe. So - to actively ignore resident concerns and calls to makethese routes actually safe - absolutely breaches the City's duty of care.
I look forward to hearing back on how we can work together to improve safety here inPalo Alto!
With kind regards,
Trish Tamrazi
Concerned Palo Alto Homeowner
State Bar No. 279541
Tamrazi.Law@gmail.com
On Tue, Aug 13, 2024 at 9:55 AM Patricia Judge Tamrazi <tamrazi.law@gmail.com>wrote:
Dear Sylvia,
Thank you for your email. The necessary engineering has already been completed -all that needs to be done is to add stop signs at the uncontrolled intersections, suchthat they are in line with the rest of the intersections. Could that be done, please?
School starts at Palo Verde Thursday. We cannot in good conscience call this a SafeRoute to School as is! This is an easy fix!
Let's please, together, review the 7 intersections on Greer between Loma Verde andLouis, which you reference in your email below. Your characterization of them is notaccurate.
1. Loma Verde: 4-way stop.2. Kenneth 1: 2-way stop (stop signs on Kenneth).3. Thomas 1: 2-way stop (stop signs on Greer).4. Janice 1: UNCONTROLLED INTERSECTION.5. Thomas 2: UNCONTROLLED INTERSECTION.6. Kenneth 2: 3-way stop.7. Janice 2: UNCONTROLLED INTERSECTION.
We do need engineering to do a study - it's already been done, I'm sure - and the
necessary traffic control was simply overlooked, it seems.
Engineering already decided traffic control is needed on Thomas 1, so it is also
needed on Thomas 2.
There is no difference between the Thomas / Greer and Janice / Greer
intersections. Engineering already decided traffic control is needed on Thomas1, so it is also needed on Janice 1 and Janice 2.
Please could you do the following to protect Palo Alto's children using this SafeRoute to school?
1. Add a stop sign at Janice 1.
2. Add a stop sign at Thomas 2.
3. Add a stop sign at Janice 2.
Please let me know your thoughts? I'm hoping to see those stop signs go in thisweek!
Thanks so much!
Trish Tamrazi
Palo Alto Homeowner
On Wed, Aug 7, 2024 at 10:43 PM Star-Lack, Sylvia <Sylvia.Star-Lack@cityofpaloalto.org> wrote:
Hi Ms. Tamrazi,
Thank you for your email. I am so sorry to hear about your son’s recent experience,and I am glad that you reached out to see what can be done. If you would like me tocall you about this issue, please share your phone number and a good time to call.
I live just off of Greer Road, near Colorado, and my children biked down Greerpast Janice to get to JLS Middle School, so I am aware of the cross streets alongGreer. I’m also an avid cyclist who bikes down Greer at least weekly to reachdestinations beyond the Greer/Louis intersection. Finally, I oversee the City’s SafeRoutes to School team, our forthcoming Safe Streets for All Safety Action Plan,and the update of our Bicycle and Pedestrian Transportation Plan, so I am workingto improve our streets for everyone, particularly children and vulnerable road users.
The California DMV manual says the following about intersections:
Intersections
An intersection is any place where one road meets another road.
Controlled intersections have signs or traffic signal lights.
Uncontrolled and blind intersections do not. Before entering an
intersection, look left, right, and ahead to check for vehicles,
bicyclists, and pedestrians. Be prepared to slow down and stop if
necessary. Pedestrians always have the right-of-way. Here are some
right-of-way rules at intersections:
· Without STOP or YIELD signs: The vehicle that arrives to
the intersection first has the right-of-way. However, if a
vehicle, pedestrian, or bicyclist gets to the intersection at the
same time as you, give the right-of-way to the vehicle,
pedestrian, or bicyclist on your right. If you approach a stopsign and there is a stop sign on all four corners, stop first and
proceed as above.
· T intersections without STOP or YIELD signs: Vehicles,
bicyclists, and pedestrians on the through road (continuing to
go straight) have the right-of-way.
Notably, some of the cross streets of Greer south of Loma Verde are Tintersections. Of the 7 intersections on Greer between Loma Verde and Louis, fourof them are T intersections where Greer, as the through road, has the right-of-way.Janice does not have a T intersection with Greer, so drivers and cyclists shouldfollow the procedure in the first bullet above, giving right-of-way to the firstvehicle to arrive at the intersection.
As you know, a 311 ticket has been opened, and one of our transportation engineerswill evaluate the intersection for appropriate signage. Stop signs are placedaccording to a standard analysis conducted by our engineers. It can take some timefor the engineers to gather the data needed for this analysis, and the outcome willbe shared in 311.
Since you care about school route safety, I wanted to let you know about Cityprograms and initiatives where you can engage further to support vulnerable roadusers. I will also share your email with the teams working on these efforts:
Our Safe Routes to School program relies on parents at each school tovolunteer as Transportation Safety Representatives (TSRs). You can contactthe Palo Verde TSR (check with the PTA for this year’s TSR) to see howyou can be on the team to help educate and encourage students and parents atyour school on how to walk, bike, and drive more safely in theneighborhood. TSRs also come to monthly City/School TransportationSafety Committee meetings to work collaboratively with School District andCity staff on road safety items.
The City began development of a Safe Streets for All Safety Action Plan inthe middle of 2023. A draft plan will be available for public review this fallbefore a final draft is adopted by Council in late 2024 or early 2025.
The City is currently updating its existing 2012 Bicycle and PedestrianTransportation Plan (BPTP) to reflect current community needs and desires,consider recent trends in cycling and bicycle technology (such as e-bikes),
I flagged this issue of uncontrolled intersections on Greer Rd. toTransportation@cityofpaloalto.org back on July 19, but never received a
substantive response - I emailed back on July 22 that a ticket was started onPaloAlto311 (ID 15716138). I also flagged this issue on 311 yesterday, again, after
my son would have been hit by the car, had he followed the City's traffic signs.
Many elementary aged children walk along Greer to school - many unaccompaniedby adults. Could you please address this before school begins?
Thank you,
Trish Tamrazi, Palo Alto homeowner
From:Federico Andrade-Garcia
To:Council, City
Subject:Please stop the increase in airport noise pollution, and save the Baylands
Date:Wednesday, September 4, 2024 12:40:18 AM
CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening attachments and clicking
on links.
Hi,
As a resident of East Palo Alto, I live less than a couple of
miles away from the PAO airport North side, in the "Weeks Gateway"
neighborhood. I regularly get startled by the noisy takeoffs from some
of those executive/megarich and hobbyist's airplanes, even when all my
windows and doors are closed.
This expansion project, while it may bring you some minimal
increase in taxes and related, it will destroy areas of the Bayland,
which so many hypocritically in Palo Alto fight to protect when East
Palo Alto wants to expand Eastbound, but have less of a problem when
it's about Palo Alto's expansion plans. I haven't heard as much from
those "protect the Baylands" groups in regards to this project.
Please, stop this expansion project, and even consider it closing
PAO altogether, or restrict it so that those rich hobbyists move to San
Carlos airport, which is not surrounded by houses like PAO.
Regards,
-Federico
From:Ken Joye
To:Council, City
Subject:9 Sept meeting consent calendar item
Date:Tuesday, September 3, 2024 3:35:57 PM
CAUTION: This email originated from outside of the organization. Be cautious of opening
attachments and clicking on links.
For the council meeting of 9 September 2024, item #7 is included under the consent calendar.
I am writing in support of Professional Services Contract Number C25191297 to allow workto begin on the Bicycle and Pedestrian Railroad Crossing Alternatives Analysis in Southern
Palo Alto.
As you have acknowledged, the grade separation work will be highly disruptive. I hope thatwe can get ahead of the curve on that by having a sound plan in place to add
pedestrian/bicycle facilities before work begins at Meadow and Charleston. I hope that youwill find this contract uncontroversial and approve it at your meeting.
thank you for your service,
Ken JoyeVentura neighborhood, Palo Alto
agenda: <https://cityofpaloalto.primegov.com/Portal/Meeting?meetingTemplateId=14393>
office: (650) 736-2363
Academic: https://profiles.stanford.edu/jeffrey-koseff
Research: https://web.stanford.edu/~koseff
Stanford University
Ancestral lands of the Muwekma Ohlone Tribe