HomeMy WebLinkAbout2020-11-02 City Council Agendas (8)
City of Palo Alto (ID # 11708)
City Council Staff Report
Report Type: Consent Calendar Meeting Date: 11/2/2020
City of Palo Alto Page 1
Summary Title: Refer the Development of Permanent Race and Equity Public
Art to the Public Art Commission
Title: Refer the Development of Permanent Public Art on King Plaza at City
Hall to the Public Art Commission
From: City Manager
Lead Department: City Manager
Recommendation
Staff recommends that the City Council refer to the Public Art Commission the development of
a permanent public art installation in King Plaza (City Hall Civic Center) to recognize the City’s
priorities on race and equity.
Background
On June 8, 2020, the City Council unanimously passed a resolution affirming that Black lives
matter and committed the City to addressing systemic racism and bias. This resolution also
honored the lives of George Floyd, Breonna Taylor, Ahmaud Arbery, and many others and can
be found online in CMR #11414.
In addition to the resolution, the City Council also unanimously directed staff to return with a
framework, report on possible improvements to police hiring practices, and a diversity and
inclusion initiative throughout the City. In response to that direction, staff returned to the City
Council on June 15, 2020 with a draft framework to inform Palo Alto’s focus over the short,
medium, and long-term (CMR #11441). The City Council also approved a series of actions
including direction to the Public Art Commission to explore public art honoring diversity and
work with our community to paint “Black lives matter” or a similar message near City Hall, as
soon as possible. The temporary installation was completed in late June.
Discussion
This referral seeks to recognize the City’s priorities on race and equity through the potential
development of permanent public art in King Plaza at City Hall Civic Center. In June, the Public
Art Commission commissioned the installation of a temporary Black lives matter Mural by
launching a call for artists. The Public Art Commission hosted panel interviews and selected
sixteen diverse, local artists to paint the individual letters in the mural using their own
CITY OF
PALO
ALTO
City of Palo Alto Page 2
perspectives on race and equity to guide their work. Since that time, the community has
engaged with the temporary mural. In addition, on September 10, 2020, the Public Art
Commission hosted a panel discussion with several of the mural artists to engage the
community on the topic of race and equity. Watch the virtual Racial Equity Panel
Conversation here.
In August, the City Council discussed interest in developing permanent public art in King Plaza
at City Hall Civic Center. In September, as a priority for the coming year’s workplan, the Public
Art Commission approved exploring public art elements at Palo Alto’s city limits to reinforce the
City’s focus on race, equity and inclusion. The recommended motion in this report would add
the specific discussion about a permanent public art piece in King Plaza to the Public Art
Commission’s workplan. With the garage underneath King Plaza, the weight of art installations
on the plaza is limited. Permanent artwork will need to be designed consistent with these
engineering requirements and traditional sculptural works are likely infeasible at this site.
As the Black lives matter mural was intended to be a temporary installation, the City is currently
focused on decommission efforts for the mural. In conversations with the Public Works
Department, the City plans to decommission the temporary Black lives matter mural in early
November due to the anticipated shift in weather and concerns over public safety and traffic
impacts. This allows the City to schedule the road work needed by an experienced crew in
advance of seasonal rainy weather. Staff also expects an increase in traffic as more business
activities are allowed locally with the relaxing of COVID-19 restrictions set by the State Public
Health Officer and Santa Clara County Public Health Officer. The City anticipated
decommissioning the temporary mural as early as September 2020 or by the end of the
calendar year as the mural faded.
The City Council referral would advance and build upon the temporary mural’s impact by
directing the Public Art Commission to develop permanent artwork focused on race, equity and
inclusion in King Plaza at City Hall Civic Center. This recommendation aligns with the Public Art
Commission’s priorities to focus on race and equity in their workplan this year.
Resource Impact
With the acceptance of this report, a referral will be submitted to the Public Art Commission to
explore a permanent public art installation or a series of installations in King Plaza at City Hall
Civic Center. The Public Art Commission will follow the established approval process related to
the budget and the art chosen.
Stakeholder Engagement
Since the City Council’s adoption of their Race and Equity Framework, a series of community
engagement efforts and community conversations have taken place focused on race and
equity. For more on the City’s focus on race and equity, go to
www.cityofpaloalto.org/raceandequity. For more on the City’s Public Art program, go to
www.cityofpaloalto.org/publicart. For other community engagement completed or underway,
including Public Art programming planned, go to the August 24, 2020 City Council Staff Report
City of Palo Alto Page 3
(CMR #11551 Attachment B).
Environmental Review
This referral is not a project subject to environmental review. Potential environmental impacts
will be considered at the time a proposed permanent artwork is identified.